Feminism: A Path to Apostasy?

Taken from: • Daniel Haqiqatjou and ...
The Modernist Menace To Islam by Daniel Haqiqatjou:
amzn.eu/d/03iM...

[@asrafnauman4327]

An-Nisa 4:34- Asbabun Nuzul. *In a narration it was found that a woman complaind to the Prophet SAW because her husband had slapped her. The Prophef SAW said: "He must be crushed (retaliation)." Then came down Q.S. 4 an-Nisa:34 as a provision in educating a wife who cheats. After hearing the explanation of the verse, she went home and did not take revenge. Narrated by Ibn Abi Hatim from al-Hasan. *In another narration, it was found that an Ansar came to the Prophet SAW with his wife. His wife said: "O Messenger of Allah, he has hit me until there are marks in my face." So the Prophet SAW said: "He has no right to do that." Then came down Q.S. an-Nisa:34 as a provision in educating wives. Narrated by Ibn Marduwaih from 'Ali.

[@komrij1944]

So 4:34 came down in order to legitimize wifebeating. "a provision in educating wives" 😄 Islam is an abomination.

[@publicpm8809]

May Almighty guide us all and keep us all on the straight path, Ameen

[@samy7013]

Islam upon the Noble Qur’an and the authentic Sunnah of Rasool Allah Muhammad ﷺ, practiced, preserved, and propagated with the understanding of the Salaf us-Salih (i.e. our Righteous Predecessors, may Allah be pleased with them), is the gateway to salvation, in this world and the hereafter. ☝️👳🏻‍♂️👍

[@ridasiddique8949]

Islam gives true empowerment to woman.

[@erik.dejong]

That claim gets easily debunked by 4:34.

[@FreePalestine_____]

@@erik.dejong No it doesn't. “It was narrated that: Sulaiman bin Amr bin Ahwas said: “My father told me that he was present at the Farewell Pilgrimage with the Messenger of Allah. He praised and glorified Allah, and reminded and exhorted (the people). Then he said: ‘ *I enjoin good treatment of women, for they are prisoners with you, and you have no right to treat them otherwise, unless they commit clear Indeceny* (Fahisha Mubayyina/”بِفَاحِشَةٍ مُبَيِّنَةٍ”). *If they do that, then forsake them in their beds and hit them, but without causing injury or leaving a mark.* If they obey you, then do not seek means of annoyance against them. You have rights over your women and your women have rights over you. Your rights over your women are that they are not to allow anyone whom you dislike to *tread on your bedding, nor allow anyone whom you dislike to enter your houses. *And their right over you are that you should treat them kindly with regard to their clothing and food.’ ” (Source: Sunan Ibn Majah volume 3, Book 9, Hadith 1851, Jami` at-Tirmidhi 1163) Grade : Sahih

[@youtubeaccount3230]

Origin of Feminism started in the 1800s, in 1848 there was 2 young sisters who woke up and told their parents that they are able to communicate with the dead and the bangs they heard in their house was people from the dead, this gave rise to what we know as spiritualism, fast forward now those girls had grown up in the civil war, many people male and female would go to these 2 sisters who were mediums to the spiritual world, all it took is one women's observation in the whole matter so saw this as authority and they loved it as prior to this your priest and pastor was basically the person in power and they were all male, after witnessing this, these females tasted authority, fast forward more the war had ended and black men were allowed to vote same again some of these women didn't like the idea that a black man was able to vote but a white women could

[@binder946]

it's much older than that. spiritualism new age has been around for much longer. devine feminism existed long time ago as well. infact there used to be female goddess false goddesses. so feminism is not new

[@zahidmuslim4110]

Brother , May ALLAH SWT Reward you with best of Rewards for your relentless efforts in exposing the falsehood... Enlightening the clueless Ummah (content in blind following corrupt groups and so called celebrity scholars without knowledge)

[@hazabazza7425]

Great conversation mashallah

[@homtanks7259]

Great episode, great guest 👌🏻

[@mohammedghander9243]

God bless you Paul

[@naimac2744]

I've never heard of Amina Wadud, I think I'll look her up

[@Moonlight-777]

💙💚 2 amazing brothers😊

[@allykhan8594]

My 4 sisters are apostates, sad but true.

[@Haze_in-bw7ff]

don't jump the gun , trust in whatever good there is in them and consider them muslim.

[@allykhan8594]

@@Haze_in-bw7ff lol. Why you inventing in religion. So them calling themselves christians and wearing cross and marry kufr, still makes them muslims??

[@zuhasbekillin3461]

​@@Haze_in-bw7ffhe literly said they are kuffar

[@FreePalestine_____]

Allah has replaced them with better people.

[@allykhan8594]

@@FreePalestine_____ Alhamdulillah, Indeed!

[@adosayid6368]

i pray you get shahid bolsen on blogging theology.

[@hassanahmed9136]

Feminism are in the comments burning inside 😂

[@abdula16]

One was ‘bbbut talk about the RedPill’ 😂

[@zuhasbekillin3461]

​@@abdula16fr what's worse a praxology which says do what you want with basic facts like hypergamy or a goverment body that literly destroys every nation it touches😂

[@sameenshahid7457]

No most of us feminists watch these videos for laughs. No one takes you cavemen seriously 😂.

[@A.--.]

Brother Daniel has many great points but the MAJOR resson i differ with his approach is that he only speaks from PROBLEM END of an issue and not SOLUTION END....i need Solutioners not Problemers leaders!

[@irpanfauzi1160]

i think he is more to prevention rather than to cure it, like there is a Scholar that make Music,Drawing Not Haram but its Has Many Slipery Slope that make other Scholar Make it Haram as Prevention rather than to Cure

[@A.--.]

@@irpanfauzi1160 prevention advise is also SOLUTION END so i will take it but his videos are more about highlighting PROBLEMS which we all know. His Solutions have a Deobandi color and we know Deobandis have 0 solutions....in fact they are part of the Problem.

[@A.--.]

@allbboss Feminism is a PROBLEM......we all agree and know that by now.....we want SOLUTIONS now not to keep mentioning examples of the Problem. Leaders give SOLUTIONS not just keep mentioning examples of the PROBLEMS!

[@md.shahadathossain8880]

There is solution in his speeches but you're reluctant to see that as you are already labeling him with what you dislike

[@A.--.]

@@md.shahadathossain8880 what solution, give me an example from his video

[@naimac2744]

Why do these speakers engage with feminism rather than what Islam says about women?

[@Arkus123]

Because many Muslim women are becoming manipulated by western secular thought.

[@naimac2744]

If the men haven't been preventing women from gaining knowledge about the deen, why then are there so few Muslim female scholars?

[@Lonzetta_3laama]

From my experience Daniel’s ideology (ie the wahabi ideology) is a larger path to apostasy , countless people have left the dean bc they were taught THIS was Islam and of course people will reject it.

[@f1aziz]

What's a wahabi ideology?

[@Arkus123]

True "Wahhabism" is not a separate sect lol it's just pure "sunni" Islam without innovation

[@samytouabi4087]

You are right. It’s why I personally left Islam. The problem is Daniel has outrageous texts to back up his outrageous ideology…

[@Arkus123]

@@samytouabi4087 how is it outrageous???

[@samytouabi4087]

@@Arkus123 Child marriage, slavery, wife beating, prohibited adoption, jihad al-talab, dhimmism, penalty for apostasy, just to name a few things you can find in legitimate islamic texts Daniel believes and promotes

[@naimac2744]

I wouldn’t be surprised she said we should be able to say no to God because so many Muslim men give their view point as God's word.

[@tafis007]

Saying no to Quran is the definition of apostasy in Islam. That's the topic of this video and you are an example of how feminism leads to apostasy.

[@naimac2744]

@tafis007 as a practising Muslim woman I'm not advocating to say no to the Quran as that's Allaah's word. If you read my comment carefully then you would see that as I was giving an explanation as to why someone would say that. Why would you ignore that there are men out there that think their opinion or interpretation should be obeyed like it is Allaah's word when it isn't? There should be no compulsion in the deen and that goes for women also. It is the attitude of these men, and men who ignore this problem that lead women to apostasy. And the fact that you ignore this problem appears to put you in that category.

[@tafis007]

@@naimac2744 Men have been fighting over opinions for thousands of years with other men. Such men who wants their words to be treated like God's have always been there. Now we also have such women in the form of "Sheikhas". What these feminist "Muslimas" do, they challenge clearly stated verses of the Quran and undisputed Hadiths and invents twisted interpretation just to cater to their desires. I never seen any feminist "Sheikhas" to present clear evidence for their interpretation or winning a debate against a renowned scholar. All they do is emotional yapping.

[@tafis007]

@@naimac2744 "there is no compulsion in religion" - is one of the most misused verse used by the feminists. Allah made the hell and warned about it for compulsion. A man is given authority of his wife and daughter and even given the rights of compulsion.

[@md.shahadathossain8880]

No practicing muslim abuse the ayah,"there is no compulsion in religion " like you do....cut the crap....​@@naimac2744

[@TheSyrianAleppo]

Questioning the ahadith has no bearing on being a muslim. Questioning the Quran does. Do not equate the two.

[@abdula16]

There’s no difference 😂.

[@tafis007]

One leads to another.

[@zuhasbekillin3461]

No diffrence

[@toolate6971]

You couldn't be more wrong!

[@Arkus123]

Not true, you are not a Muslim if you don't believe in the Sunnah.

[@naimac2744]

Could it be that the feminists are right in this regard? If it were the reality, then surely you would come to this conclusion without a feminist mind set

[@janrudnik6870]

What should happen to apostates ?

[@Nemo.24]

They should repent

[@janrudnik6870]

@@Nemo.24 and if they don't repent ?

[@abdula16]

@@janrudnik6870they better keep it private or else 😂.

[@md.shahadathossain8880]

What should happen to a russian spy living in America?

[@janrudnik6870]

@@ghassanm6640 Scottish singer.

[@n.a.1397]

Men do not become authority over their mother's in Islam. Patriarchy is a bad word to use for the Islamic tradition.

[@yogurt13393]

If you're going to talk about the problems with feminism, you should also talk about the problems with the red pill movement.

[@BasmTahsin]

@yogurt13393 The red pill movement is a joke. In contrast to Feminisim, no one funds those movements.

[@abdula16]

Hey feminist!

[@موسى_7]

I'm not sure Paul knows much about the Red Pill movement. He seems to be a book-reading old British man, not an internet-savvy young American. Red pill is popular in the USA.

[@tafis007]

Every dawah bros have spoken against it. It is not as pervasive in the Muslim community as feminism is.

[@md.shahadathossain8880]

Red pill movement is not that widespread and promoted and shove down our throat by media and system....and though it has some deviations but the main essence of this movement is not new and was promoted by all traditional lifestyles.... It's like reincarnation of the traditional lifestyle with some modern modifications

[@naimac2744]

It is true, if Imam Ghazali didn't address the oppression towards women, why not? Why does Madina University, a most prestigious university amongst Muslims not take in female students? Why are there far more barriers to learning about the deen for women? Why are men protected amongst Muslims with their individual authority over women but women are not protected by a justice system when those men who are supposed to protect her do not? Why don't these you tubers address these real problematic issues that are tantamount to oppression?

[@ahmedalighouri9673]

Instead of crying a completely illogical and nonsensical why why why why about everything why don't you simply leave Islam and accept who/which can answer you why why why...

[@l3ll5l]

May be you should ask why I dont know Islam and why my comprehension of reality is distorted and lacking.

[@ahmedalighouri9673]

@@l3ll5l Knowledge is free nowadays. If still someone says that he/she cannot understand religion and religion couldn't satisfy my "whys", he/she is not happy with religion. He/she wants only those answers that his/her Nafs wants.

[@l3ll5l]

@@ahmedalighouri9673 I understand your point. Nonetheless we are living in end of times where good becomes bad in the eyes of people and bad become good. Everywhere is callers towards corruption even in the name of islam leading to the fire of hell. Knowledge and understanding is lifted and ignorance is spread. In these times a sincere heart and intellect not manipulated by indoctrination of the west is the most precious investment a human can have because sincerity is a prerequisite for guidance. And real scholars are the lights which God sent to guide the sincere. May God let our feet be steady in his path with a heart he is pleased with.

[@naimac2744]

@@ahmedalighouri9673 and this is the reason why women leave Islam because of ignorant people like you, inviting them to do so

[@alpal681]

Women do not lose faith in the deen but in the men that have corrupted it for their own gain.

[@first9_yt]

Are you a Muslim?

[@alpal681]

I hear countless stories of shady imaams who ask women to stay with abusive men even rapists. No Muslim women questions Gazzali but the men who do not give them their basic rights today.

[@ryojs4286]

Basically slander and hearsey But nothing about kaffir r4pists