First PTX Reaction With Matt! - New Rules x Are You That Somebody

[@lyca4397]

Sound of Silence is another good one for Matt and the others.

[@annitasmalley160]

Seconded! Sound of Silence has been described as Perfection by other reactors. So I can't wait until you watch it!! Love your work. You're great! Keep going

[@winterwidow1728]

yes you should react to sound of silence

[@nicolelylewis]

Their version of “you’re a mean one Mr. Grinch” is sooo good!

[@olivria1254]

Yeah, Matt has the lead so if you really want to see him shine it's a great choice.

[@helmi9003]

Yes to this!

[@annahasty7191]

Please review Mr. Grinch...its purely for fun and its wonderful.

[@anniereboot2800]

nicolelylewis the ‘behind the scenes’ of making Mr Grinch also a fun watch.

[@dws223]

Matt is the center of your a mean one. If you want to hear his voice as a singer and the level of control he has on his base it's probably the best example

[@Wiley_Coyote]

Nobody else is Avi, or ever will be. But Matt gets pretty low, and he does one thing Avi couldn't... he and Scott can get close enough in tone that they can do the deeper equivalent of what Mitch and Kirstin do. I'm always surprised I never see anyone talking about this. The way Mitch and Kirstin can close harmonize is now duplicated, when needed, on the deep end by the other two. It's a new trick, because while Scott's always been able to go fairly deep, there never really was a strong effort to blend Avi and Scott, vs them having distinct parts. That's changed with Matt.

[@mecfstraveler]

I was trying to comment on that Harmony but I don't think I worded it very well! I think it became really apparent to us as fans when we saw Matt and Scott singing Harmony on A Very Wicked Halloween special. They were singing Harmony for Mitch and Kirstin who were the leads in "What Is This Feeling?" And Sweater Weather! That was gorgeous I hear Scott come in to join that in that close harmony! And then Mitch joined and it was just the three of them sounding very beautiful very close together. We definitely knew that this was something different at that point

[@fosixsix225]

Yeah like on “can you feel the love tonight?” I commented “only pentaholics can tell when It switched from kirstin to Mitch in the beginning” but then I felt really ashamed when someone pointed out to me that it switched from Scott to Matt in the very beginning. When singing they sound so different yet so alike. And on stay I had no idea it was Matt, I admit it sounded a little different with Scott but I thought it was him anyway because I had never heard Matt’s voice in a higher register

[@Wiley_Coyote]

@@fosixsix225 right. So they did gain something with Matt that helped their overall sound. The cost was a few super duper Avi low notes that even Matt can't reach, but he reaches enough that it's not any kind of huge issue.

[@olabergvall3154]

@@Wiley_Coyote And, lest we forget; Avi is making his own music now for us to enjoy. So we didn't lose Avi, we just gained a fantastic solo performer, and a slightly revised Pentatonix. A win-win-win as I see it. And Matt looks happy in this setting. Cheers for Matt ❣

[@mecfstraveler]

@@fosixsix225 they've gotten me a couple times 2! I'm used to having to REALLY listen to tell Mitch from Kirstie when they're singing close! I managed to tell them apart on the line they did sing on " Can You Feel the Love Tonight" because of Kirstie's vibrato.. but now they're doing it to us with Matt and Scott! On "Can You Feel the Love Tonight" was a really good example of the group messing with us on just how well we thought we knew their voices, just like you said! I remember we listened to the audio first and in comments we were all trying to figure out who sang what as a solo. Then we watched the video and we were like "OH! Snap!" They got most of us, so don't feel bad! "Stay" was tricky too! Another thing that Pentatonix changed on us (making it harder to tell who is singing at times) is Scott has not been doing as many riffs and runs. I think it was totally deliberate for him to change that up so we wouldn't know if it was him or Matt! When has Scott ever held back from a good riff or run? And another time I suspected it started with Matt, then switched to Scott was a solo in "Despecito". but I didn't have enough faith in my ear to say that in comments under the audio version of the song. it's the 1st 5 words in Scott's solo. I thought it was Matt. " 'and now I'm feeling like' girl you know I want your love, girl you were handmade for somebody like me"... I honestly thought it was Matt for those 1st 5 words because the notes were lower and then "Sound of Silence" came out... Scott starts that out with some notes that would have been low for him and really surprised us. I mean we knew he sang Bass during Avi's solos.. but.. not like THAT. Scott was doing other things differently in songs then he used to , one of them was him holding back some on his signature riffs and runs. and now we see him on The Sound of Silence hitting some very low notes in the beginning? and of course there's "Come Along", with Scott shocking us with his lower register in the beginning of the number. So I doubted my feeling that it was Matt singing that first part of Scott's solo on "Despacito" because obviously Scott was singing that low now so why would they have one person sing the first five words of somebody else's solo? I convinced myself that it was all Scott with no lead-in by Matt... and I quit trying to figure it out. Then, just recently, I saw somebody's recording of the song in concert, and It WAS Matt! I was so shooketh! I was just sitting here staring at the now paused recording with my jaw hanging open and then started telling the empty room "Matt DOES sing that part! I was right! It IS Matt"... I think they're having fun with surprising us because Pentatonix likes to keep us guessing and it's does keep us on our toes! Those two are so close in their sound, especially when Scott does not do any riffs or runs. It is so awesome having these surprises popping up again

[@chiefnoah]

They do sound of silence with Matt. It's incredible

[@ProudAmerican1829]

YEEEEEEEEEESSS! I was never really a fan of this song until I heard their version.

[@amandasamson4513]

THISS!!! YESS PLEASE WATCHE SOUND OF SILENCE

[@devinbaker3823]

You should definitely do "Come Along" or You're a mean one Mr. Grinch! Matt is the main focus in the Grinch!

[@JamesWoodTN]

Go Vols!

[@theresastrausbaugh3407]

Loved Avi but Matt brings a whole new vibe to the group. His energy actually reignited the group. he fits right in. Matt is amazing in his own right.

[@lauriep2018]

You should check out their cover of Attention. Matt’s baselines is insane and there is so much energy. It’s one of my favorites! And OMG, i don’t think I really realized that you hadn’t seen ANY of their new stuff! Now I get why you were so excited! They are so ingenious with there arrangements, with their blend and performing live. They are just so much tighter as a group. Especially since you’ve been watching the sing off

[@DarthRayj]

I absolutely love this one too, actually I'm gonna listen to it now lol. When you do watch it be sure to pay attention (haha) to Kevin because some of the dancing and expressions he makes are iconic!

[@mecfstraveler]

Yes yes yes! That bass line is just fun! And it was fun watching Matt sing because he got a little bit comical and had a lot of fun. This is where you start to see sassy Kirstin coming out and then we get to Havana and the harmonies between Kirstin and Mitch OMG!

[@whoami.24601]

Attention is so goood

[@mecfstraveler]

I'm so excited to see his reaction to the stuff coming up!

[@kristinhowk8231]

PTX was on the Sing-Off was 2011. Avi announced he was leaving the group in May 2017, though he stayed through their summer tour which ended in September. PTX invited Matt to sing/tour with them for the 2017 Holiday season, (trial period) and Matt became an official member of the group in early 2018. This song was on the album they released in Spring 2018. So yes, they have noticeably aged from teenagers/college kids to adults. 🙂 A lot of people were prepared to dislike Matt because he wasn’t Avi, but he’s won most people over. Both talent-wise and personality-wise.

[@supposedly1-2]

one of my favorite things they said about Matt when they were trying out basses was that since he was a pentaholic before he met them in person he already knew all of the songs and ofc his bass part in all of them. they said 'well that was easy' lol Matts personality is amazing as well it would be really hard not to like him!

[@jelinenanashi9466]

I absolutely love Avi but I absolutely love Matt's work with PTX. I don't think one is better than the other. At first I was worried about a new bass but it's true, he won me over. Wasn't hard. I agree his personality is contagious and it's hard not to like him. Makes it easy since he's super talented too!

[@ProudAmerican1829]

Some of my favorites with Matt: Sound of Silence, Attention, Havana, Come Along, Can You Feel the Love Tonight, Waving Through a Window.

[@DarthRayj]

Attention, Havana, Come Along, Can You Feel the Love Tonight are all some of my fave PTX songs at this point, hard agree!

[@dimitribrown614]

All the songs you listened are simply out of this world. Matt's base is killer

[@sister1976]

Mad World is a favourite of mine... mitch and Matt harmonising is amazing! Plus I find it really impressive how Matt manages to sound like a cello sometimes. ❤🌟

[@janniestenskjr1093]

I dont mind that you are pausing it. Love that you hear small details😁😁😁👍🏻

[@markbell4017]

Agree! I would much rather have a few pauses rather than talking over the music. I really hate that

[@pattis2641]

You will ADORE Matt!! He has a different skill, just as you said, and this is the best first video with Matt replacing Avi. And they are all in their late 20's. They were 19 yrs old on Sing Off, the original 3 members. I don't know Matt's age, but he fits perfectly!!

[@barbararowe771]

Pauses were fine. You hear more acutely than some of us, and that insight gives a deeper enjoyment of the performance. Thank you.

[@elaineadams6718]

It;s amazing how PTX found another amazing bass! I am a huge Avi fan, that being said Matt just seems to totally fit. He didn't just have to come in as a newbie and learn new songs he also had to come in and learn all of Avi's parts to the old songs. I think you would really enjoy reacting to their videos Sound of silence, Attention, Can you feel the love tonight and Shallow. It's a whole new ride!!

[@olivria1254]

So glad you like this song! If you were impressed by Kevin's progress over the years in this video, wait till you react to their "Evolution of Ariana Grande" (with Matt). It's insane, they all shine but especially Mitch and Kevin. Also if you're interested in seeing more of Matt, check out "You're a Mean One, Mr Grinch". He has the lead (prepare to be shook by Scott taking over the bass!) and it's an amazing cover. Love you channel, I'm always excited to get a notification! :)

[@MelaniePoparad]

Olivia Genest-Binding yes! The ariana grande one is fantastic. I’m not even a huge fan of hers but they make me like her music!

[@olivria1254]

@@MelaniePoparad Agreed, I've actually never listened to one of her songs (not really into most pop music) but their medley just blew my mind.

[@MelaniePoparad]

Olivia Genest-Binding I am the same with Ariana. I have only ever heard her songs in passing when they are playing on someone else’s radio or PTX covers! But i think that is one of my fav evolutions. I don’t know if i can actually pinpoint a fav but this is up there.

[@olivria1254]

@@MelaniePoparad Yeah, my favourites are probably their Evolutions of Music, MJ, and Ariana Grande.

[@lurker1107]

I really love your reactions! I don't mind the pausing if it's with purpose! The bell tones are not effects, Kristy, Mitch and Scott each take a tone consecutively to make that "effect" happen. A lot of reactors don't pick up on those subtle little things, but it's my favorite part of this arrangement!! Glad you actually did!

[@lindamorris3149]

I love that part too and you're right - a lot of reactors don't pick up on that!

[@briannaweizenecker4719]

It’s also extremely hard to perfect those bell sounds the way they do. I know from experience in my own choir it’s not an easy task so it’s amazing that you picked up on it!

[@lake9980]

The bell tones are actually effects on their vocals. You never hear it when they perform the song live.

[@lurker1107]

@@lake9980 What do you mean they're added effects? I have indeed heard that them do it live. Also, if you listen/watch their Evolution of Ariana Grande, which is a live recording, you'll hear them do those bell tones at exactly minute 3:28 of the video.

[@envyrem]

Matt taking the bass role has been a positive in my eyes. I love Avi dearly, and this has given him his own solo career which I am a very big fan of. Matt fits their style so well, and he's incredibly talented. I'm glad PTX has given him his recognition.

[@nicolelylewis]

Also their cover of “come along” is pretty good too :)

[@brandyanderson3522]

Matt's voice during his solo in "Come Along" 🧈. I really think ge would be a great voice for a Disney prince. 🤴🏿

[@kaseycurtis468]

I LOVE their cover of this song

[@sarahmcgoodwin5911]

I would highly recommend Attention be your next one, made about the same time as this and Matt kills it in that one too- and then after that, Sound of Silence, which is in my opinion maybe the best cover they’ve ever done, and you get to hear Matt’s first solo! Then Mr. Grinch, where you really start to hear Matt shine and come into his own! (And for songs/parts where the bass is singing, whether it be Matt or Avi, Scott does the bass. And no, his range did not used to be that low in the Sing-Off days, but it is now. Love hearing him take the bass part to let another vocalist shine!)

[@calhoun1968]

Yup. this aint no; "We've been together for 5 weeks", stuff going on here! And yes, Kirstie is perfection personified! (Yes, your concerns are gone..., long gone!!!) You should watch "Come along", and, everything else...... Heck, for "Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy" they make themselves sound like an old vinyl record. Peace, Love and Light Kyle!!!

[@amandasamson4513]

OMG YEEESSSS Come Along is one of my favourites. I play it on repeat!

[@kaseycurtis468]

Amanda Samson me too!!! 😁

[@terib470]

You're going to love Mitch and Kirsten, they both change their looks often. They all have worked so hard to get where they are today. Believe it are not they just keep getting better.

[@anniereboot2800]

Live your reaction! Always a great pleasure. The Rihanna medley is great for hearing Matt with the group. And YES they are all beautiful to behold. There is nothing inappropriate about noticing and acknowledging it.

[@anniereboot2800]

Oops! LOVE your reaction...cannot type without my glasses.

[@ginawhitfield6797]

Your Reaction to this NEVER gets old

[@smk828]

Love your reaction. Your attention to everyone’s skills 👏🏾👏🏾👏🏾. It’s like listening for the first time again even though I’ve seen it many times. Don’t worry about the pausing. It’s organic and part of your reaction. Thanks 💕

[@ankhgirl3]

Yes...giving Matt some love now!! I’m here for it😁 I’m so enjoying your reactions, Kyle!!!

[@ConnieGordon]

I could live a life just putting this song on a loop. Such beauty, such energy, such....art.

[@Max-jf5vu]

Such an underrated cover of theirs, the mashup was flawless! Absolutely loved this reaction!!! It's sometimes hard to appreciate what a massive jump in quality there is between the old and new stuff when people watch everything completely chronologically so I'm glad you did a bit of a jump!!!

[@bill.godwin-austen]

I think this was one of the first videos they released with Matt, and it was a great introduction for him. He killed it in this! Not only are they all older than in most of the videos you've reacted to so far, but as is their wont, Mitch and Kirstin are always changing up their look. They've always been great at blending for the background harmonies, but with their voices maturing a little, and both gaining so much more self confidence since the early days, they're definitely taking those harmonies to new levels. These mashups have become one of their signature styles, and they just keep getting better with the arrangements and harmonies. My all time favorite of their mashups is Despacito x Shape of You (from the same "Top Pop" album as this one). Unfortunately, there's not a video for it, but I could listen to it on repeat for hours, it's so good! You might want to react to it audio only, or if you could find a good live concert performance of it that would be great.

[@DarthRayj]

That one is really good! I nearly died when Kirstin started singing in Spanish tbh; as far as I know she isn't fluent but being Latina she definitely does a better job with it than the original song did, and her pronunciation/accent is impeccable.

[@davidbeal6925]

Dude I’m not really one for “reaction videos” but you, you had me from the very first one. Your reaction are so real, and your break downs of what’s happening are awesome.

[@blackkymera]

It's so fun to watch a pentaholic being formed from wow to why I didn't before. 💕

[@andreastrandlien440]

As a Pentaholic I just stumbled across one of your reactions and liked it so much I had to go back and watch all the rest. You strike a very good balance between letting us enjoy you watching the music and you pausing to insert thoughts. I appreciate that you never stop for no reason and your thoughts are insightful and offer deep perspective into what you are hearing in the harmonies or performance. I am glad you are enjoying them! Another group to check out would be Voice Play. They have a similar setup with an amazing bass and beat boxer to balance the trio of vocalists. The bass, Geoff blows my mind. Their cover of Warriors would give you a good feel for all their voices. Their Moana medley does the same in a more playful way. And if you want their bass to leave you shook, watch their cover of The Oogey Boogey song. Whatever you watch, I look forward to seeing more of your reactions!

[@madelinedavis217]

Dance of the Sugar Plum Fairy by Pentatonix is incredible!!

[@mamajenkins1981]

“You know how...when something sounds real good...you make, like, an ugly face?” -Shawn Stockman, 2011

[@wayneguess7946]

Stank Face! Proper term! LOL

[@rlhcat7662]

Great reaction! I'm kinda glad you waited, too, because there is so much to compare. In the recent songs, there is a LOT more production going on behind the scenes than when they used to sit on a couch with one or two mics. Also, there is a LOT more Scott leads - very few with the others in a full lead. But they do sound good, and they are coming out with a new album of originals. I'm hoping Kirstie or Mitch have more leads in the new songs - even partial leads. We'll see. One of my favorites with Matt is Havanna. He only does the bass line, but it's really good.

[@abezkhlebetskiy]

You should DEFINITELY check out Mr.Grinch! Matt is the lead in it and you get to really hear not just his bass but his singing voice also!

[@LeskeyC001]

Thanks for another great reaction. I very well remember the anxiety I felt before I listened to Matt’s reaction. Within seconds I was sold. I love what he brings to the table and and I knew there and then that my PTX journey continues. I’m with you as well on the tightness of the arrangements, coordination and everything that makes them who they are. Their genius goes beyond the singing to whoever is doing the behind-the-scenes work on the arrangements, the videos and finding the not-so-obvious links and transitions that make these mashups possible.

[@DreadKyller]

And what's even cooler is that Matt brings a lot of energy to the group, he's a very positive, energetic, upliftinng character that has meshed exceedingly well with the group. I believe this was their first studio recorded song with Matt, prior to that was a few performances on tour and such, so he meshed with the group very fast, and has only gotten better since.

[@irishangel5689]

Matt fits in so perfectly with them. He, along with the rest of PTX are the nicest people I have ever met. I was fortunate enough to meet them on tour in Aug. 2019. They are all so damn nice and sweet.

[@MARISALA-SS]

I personally really love when reactors are so into what they're reacting to that that rewind and watch again. I love how you point out those intricacies in PTXs music, there's SO MUCH to hear in their songs it's easy to miss some cool stuff! Brilliant reaction! Thank you!

[@jenniferyoung8551]

TBH...of all the reactors I've seen to PTX, you have had the most positive, welcoming approach towards Matt!!! Yes, everyone misses Avi and change can be hard to accept but people don't need to be comparing Matt to Avi. He's the 1 that left the group. PTX took their time searching for the perfect bass to blend, not only with their voices, but with their personalities, and they chose wisely. The thing I love most about Matt is that he is also smiling, even when he sings. So, big Kudos and Thank you!!! Can't wait til you see other vids with Matt...and I know it's not Christmas, but you need to check out You're a mean one, Mr. Grinch, because he leads that song!

[@bmorse68]

Kyle...you are ready for a concert !!!!!! Be prepared to be swept off your feet......They sound so good in concert....

[@jamiemitchell8281]

Mr. Grinch is really all Matt and he is amazing. Also The Sounds of Silence is beautiful and gives all of them a starring role! You also need to see Come Along !!!

[@TheAmocca]

arrrr! I love this one! Matt is not Avi - but he is great and he brings so much energy and happiness

[@CK-jq5gv]

You cannot imagine how happy I am about this :D Really glad you like Matt, because I personally think he's an amazing addition to the group. I also really don't mind you pausing the video. I mean, it is your reaction I'm here for, and I prefer pausing the video over talking through it. Looking forward to your next reaction :)

[@rondileem3111]

Another Mind blown with PTX amazingness!!! I love your reactions because you notice everything. And I'm glad you saw their early stuff first and really got to know them before seeing the newer stuff. That way you really can appreciate their music now. There's still so many old videos that are fantastic that you need to see. Everything is great, old and new. I love everything they've done. Can't wait for your next PTX reaction!

[@MelaniePoparad]

It’s almost like kirstie’s and mitch’s breathing and vibrato are completely synchronized. I think that’s why they sound so tight. And that comes from spending day and night together and constant practice. It’s just their dedication, as well as their magnificent talent.

[@dhchddoctor7666]

I’ve been watching your reactions for a while but haven’t commented. I really enjoy your style and appreciate your insightfulness. I’ve been obsessed with PTX since they released daft punk and over and over you have drawn my attention to things I hadn’t noticed until you drew my attention to them. Thanks and I’m looking forward to sharing more of your reactions

[@Kittyscrazyfurrmusic]

I can't even watch without singing along getting so darn giddy for your reaction! Love how you are so appreciative of so many tiny details, a great guy you are!

[@mateusbelmontedossantos1019]

Black is the color of my true love's hair. Peter hollens and avi Kaplan. Great song

[@mecfstraveler]

It's harder when Matt is covering a song that were used to hearing Avi singing on. Avi has more of a classical training, and I don't know what the range is now compared to when Matt first joined but Avi was able to sing lower than Matt with a richer sound initially. But the Rhythm Bass? I love Matt's Style. There is a difference between the two but remember Avi handpicked Matt and recommended him to replace him and Matt didn't try out he said no I'm not good enough. He was tricked into auditioning by the group, Ben Bram and by his manager. So he is a very humble person and he's very young. He's got a really good energy and he fits in really well with all of them and he's like a big puppy dog with all of that energy and happiness. Everybody's recommending really good songs right now so I will just let them take it away! And yeah you're looking at Mitch with the mustache. We've lost the mustache a long time ago! LOL now I have to go back and find where I missed your last reaction on The Sing-Off ... my feed is just so messed up on KZbin! Love your reaction! Oh what about "Sweater Weather"? Or "Making Christmas"! Sweater Weather shows us a new lovey three part harmony with Matt, Scott then Mitch.. which is something new. Also Scott has worked on strengthening his low and so he takes bass when Matt is singing lead very well now! And Scott has the bass line throughout all of "You're a Mean One Mr. Grinch".. 😁 Kirstin has grown so much as a vocalist it's unbelievable! She did a couple of stints on Broadway in Kinky Boots and it really boosted her skill and confidence level! Scott has always been awesome and he's continued to improve and Mitch has just become more and more in control of every part of his range. Matt said that Mitch can't be human because he sounds the same every single time. Catch you on the next one!

[@DarthRayj]

I think a lot of people overlook or don't notice Kirstin's improvement but IMO she's gone from being the only one I could've pointed at as a weak link to being a much stronger singer and undoubtedly equal in skill to most of the others.

[@mecfstraveler]

@@DarthRayj I agree. She was really insecure though for quite a few years. It was after Avi left, then something happened with her and Jeremy. She moved to New York and did Broadway but the wedding never happened. And then she just really came alive! New York is a place that she thrives! It was so clear that she'd had voice lessons and corrected the problem she was having with the nerve damage from the cleft palate surgery that was making her do the side mouth. We realize now that was why she would j u t her lower jaw forward. She was trying to get more volume and that's the wrong technique. But I'm really glad that she took the bull by the horns and corrected errors plus had those lip implants put in to force her mouth to not go the wrong direction. I noticed that it looks like she's taking them out like she said could be done and her voice is just as strong as it was when she had been in and was working on correcting bad habits. I am so proud of her for getting over her insecurities and becoming such an amazing singer and young woman just like we all knew she was already! She just didn't realize it yet. She used to hate getting solos and I used to hold my breath hoping she didn't go off key and now she's just a warrior! I wish I could give her a great big hug and tell her how proud I am of her!

[@thehutch1674]

Maschelle Mashburn wait Avi recommended Matt? Where did you get that story? I’m not doubting you I’ve just never heard it and I wanna know more!

[@michaels9595]

Kirstin contributes so much to Pentatonix sound. To me she's been the glue (and rightly so) that you don't notice but understand is always there. Everyone is vital, but if Kirstin were not there it'd be noticeable and I expect soul crushing as a pentaholic.

[@kaygirly19]

I just love how positive you are when you talk about them. Especially Kirstie because she's just amazing to me since day one but you're right...she definitely improved and this video proves it so much. Sound of silence especially. God she killed it.

[@sharonhodder8972]

I love this reaction, it's so good to see you jump from the older to the newer releases. Don't worry about pausing and rewatching, you are pointing out some great things, I'd not noticed the low slide Matt did before. It's good watching these again and hearing your amazement. I think it's time for me to head over to patreon!

[@tamarasmith9060]

I felt the same way when I heard it shortly after its release. They took 2 songs I already liked from different singers & made it into a fantastic mashup performed so flawlessly.

[@jeffc8965]

Hey Kyle! Thanks for the Reaction! I hadn't heard this one yet. Some of the other PTX songs with Matt that I'd recommend are 'Come Along', 'Havana' and of course their cover of 'Sound of Silence'. How about another Home Free reaction? I was supposed to see them in concert this week, but with all that's happening now that will have to wait. I'd like to see what you think of their 'Butts Remix' a fun song that spans multiple genres.

[@heyitsriles13]

I'd recommend You're a Mean One Mr. Grinch, Sound of Silence, Attention, Can You Feel the Love Tonight, and Waving Through A Window... Those are some of my favorites along with Hallelujah and Bohemian Rhapsody

[@louellamoyer5578]

Woot Woot! You have a lot of new PTX to listen to that is so awesome! Their new originals are FANTASTIC! Be My Eyes, Happy Now, Coffee in Bed, not to mention a couple of new Christmas albums, And Kirstin in Seasons Of Love, Mitch in Anchor! This rabbit hole got a lot deeper Kyle! Glad to see you back! Missed you!

[@helene5957]

2:47 ... stares into the camera, rubs head..."Let me just take a minute..." - PRICELESS!!! Always love getting the notification from your channel. Great reaction video. Thank you. PS: I listen more closely to all music videos now because of what your teaching pauses have, well, taught me. Thanks, again :)

[@connix69]

I can't wait to see your reaction to a lot of their original songs plus their newer covers and arrangements.

[@supposedly1-2]

I've been waiting on this one! its just starting now ... edit: another great reaction! I think they couldn't have done this kind of music with Avi as well as they do with Matt just because its not his style at all. Matt has opened up a whole new world of things they can do and i am enjoying it. I loved avi and still do but i also love Matt and i think he even does a great job on the older stuff but he puts his own spin on it when they sing those older songs in concerts etc. i think they have all grown a lot since avi left which was 2017 btw and this perf i believe was in 2018 and the sing off was 2011! many things have changed but overall its only gotten better in my opinion!

[@msmichellewinchester]

Oh my God, this was such a great reaction. I laughed so hard when I realized that you've been doing their Sing Off performances lately and then to pretty much jump straight into this... :D You absolutely need to hear The Sound of Silence. It's the Hallelujah of Matt era and it really enhances a few things they do now more than they used to. And it also gives you a fuller picture of what Matt sounds like. Saying that Kirstie is georgeous is stating a fact, so it's absolutely alright. Mitch has a different look every ten minutes, so you're also gonna see another interesting hairstyle that he kept until very recently :). Also, I fell in love with met when I saw Havana. He's a ray of sunshine and it shows in that video, so I also recommend that one. But really, you can't go wrong with their newer stuff, just like you can't go wrong with their old stuff :).

[@elizawright9510]

PLEASE PLEASE PLEASE listen “You’re a Mean One Mr. Grinch”. It features Matt as a soloist basically the whole song and it is AMAZING. You can really hear him and his tone.

[@debbiegarmonsway1272]

just saw this and was blown away [OFFICIAL VIDEO] God Only Knows - Pentatonix

[@andreac-iheartcrossstitch]

So glad this was your first Matt song!!! Looking forward to watching more reactions to the new and older stuff.

[@misslollaleelou]

It’s always ok to acknowledge the beauty of our Queen 👑😍. This whole album went straight to my playlist.

[@lizkindall9080]

Really love your reactions!

[@cassie8906]

I couldn't click fast enough! I am an Avi fan and was bummed (but understood why) he had to go on his own. Matt has really done a great job on Bass. Because what you said about Kirsti & Mitch ( 4:41 ) how they sound like 1 person harmonizing with themselves...you need to check out the video of Avi overtone singing. There are a few of them out there but you won't be disappointed. I suggest this live performance: just search "Scott Introduces Avi, The Lion Sleeps Tonight, Singapore, Mastercard Theatre" Thanks for the great reactions!! Love 'em

[@mecfstraveler]

That 3-note sound you were hearing (and said you aren't sure how he was making that sound) is a Bell Chord. It's actually Kirstin, Mitch, then Scott. you quite obviously understand the idea of a chord and harmony but instead of singing it in unison, they sang the notes in the chord in Rapid succession. Kirstin started with the highest note and each sang their note one after the other and held it out until the last person has sung their note. Since they held their individual note out we hear the full chord when the last note is added. That's why it's a bell chord. it's like hitting three Bells in Rapid succession. Bells have a resonance that holds in the air after being struck. The person playing the Bells can stop the resonance by touching Bell or they can allow it to continue and add more notes on top of it to make a really beautiful chord with pauses in between each note. That's what Kirstie Mitch and Scott did and it is gorgeous! We were really impressed with how much they'd improved as well especially on those harmonies! It had been a hot minute since they released an entire album with Matt since Avi left and it was unbelievable how much Kirstin and Mitch had improved upon but we had already thought was perfection. And it was really cool to hear them doing a song that had some hip-hop beats to it!

[@Blue-rl5dp]

You've only seen them when the three younger ones were still just kids. They're all grown up now, experienced and self-confident in their skill and fame. Mitch was a little shy in the beginning and the others kind of sheltered him just a bit, but he's a sassy gown man now and knows what he wants. He loves his fashion fits and flights and sometimes puts on things we think are off the wall, but hey, that's him and we love him. Tight and on-spot is what made them what they are. It's a talent they're not testing anymore, they're professionals.

[@vllygrl63z44]

Hi Kyle! Just wanted to say that I enjoy your reaction videos and I’m always happy to see when a new one gets posted. I am a huge PTX fan, but listening to your takes on the music, makes me see (hear) what I’ve missed. Thank you so much! Keep up the awesome job

[@sarahsavagebassett7134]

Loving your reaction videos! It's really fun to watch someone fall in love with Pentatonix for the first time! It's been a minute since your last video - hope all is well with you

[@MelaniePoparad]

It’s not inappropriate to compliment a person! And your face in the beginning was hilarious!

[@sonnyg4792]

You should definitely do The Sound of Silence and Come Along, both with Matt

[@Meegaan]

I love that you acknowledged that Mitch and Kirstin sound so similar, like it's one person harmonizing with themselves. There's been the odd song where I had only heard the recording and hadn't yet watched the video, and I had a hard time telling which of them is singing which part because of how similar they sound, it's crazy! I also love that you waited to jump into the new stuff! I feel like it makes you appreciate it so much more knowing where they came from.

[@kattia1973]

Just woke up to your new reaction. ❤❤❤❤ I sat here laughing at your reaction because I knew you would be blown away! Awsome song, awsome reaction video. Keep them coming!!!

[@exist_without_saving]

If you're gonna keep delving into their newer stuff now, I'd suggest their cover of "Can You Feel The Love Tonight." The harmonies are mind-blowing and everyone's range is tested. Some other newer songs I would suggest that feature Matt more prominently would be "Attention" and "The Sound of Silence," too.

[@kristingraham7957]

"i'm nervous, I love Avi so much. I'm really gonna miss him". ALL OF US when Avi left. But Matt does a great job.

[@Amaroq85]

Love that you're reacting so much to PTX! I like that you branched out from the type of music you normally listen to and found that you really like it. If you want to go even further to types of music you might not have heard may I suggest a Kazakh singer called Dimash Kudaibergen? He does sing in English but he does many other languages too and he injects such emotion into his songs that, to me, it doesn't really matter that I don't know the words. Some suggestions (should you decide to listen): SOS (Singer 2017 version), Sinful Passion, Opera 2, Autumn Strong, Daybreak... Anyway, keep on reacting! I like how genuine you are.

[@denisebetegh7659]

Matt is so great. Definitely stands on his own. I highly recommend You’re A Mean One Mr Grinch next. I known it’s not Christmas yet but it really shows his chops. I love Matt though, he had big shoes to fill and I think he’s killin it.

[@steel5791]

How could it EVER be 'inappropriate' to recognize the beauty that Kristy brings to these performances, particularly when coupled with that absolutely perfect voice? Call me 'foolish' about the unmatched perfection of the entire group!

[@chereewales1680]

I so enjoy watching your reactions and discovering PTX! Thank you for the ride! Keep it up!

[@slkenn9]

Loooooved this reaction! So excited that you got to see some of the newer stuff. Can't wait to hear you do Run to You (not as new, but amazing) and Sound of Silence (newer)

[@Midway_Midway]

Long time follower (though I just realized that I hadn't followed you yet)! Anyway, I'm really really loving your PTX reactions and I'm even more excited to see you react to their new stuff! Keep 'em coming! Also, I think you have still so many old songs to listen (covers, originals, even live performances): don't miss out on those!

[@katiemenne8258]

Sound of silence will blow your mind! Ptx version of it still gives me goosebumps and I’ve heard it way too many times to admit a number lol

[@amyware563]

Those are called 'bell tones' and the trio each takes one tone. Avi even commented on it when the video came out. Amazing!!

[@jameslaing3733]

ANOTHER LEVEL ! (I LOVE watching Kyle's eyes while he watches and listens. It says EVERYTHING.) Brother Kyle, you FEELING IT??!!!

[@stebbiejammin4869]

Sound of Silence is a really great one too. Matt has a killer solo in it.

[@brutalfashion]

Loved your reaction!!! Please react to (another newer one) “Havana”! It’s with Matt, as well, and it is GREAT.

[@tessslastanova7314]

I love Making Christmas with Matt! Also Sound of Silence

[@jelinenanashi9466]

I caught the description that it was your first reaction with Matt and didn't see what song it was (I'm subscribed and only saw the alert on my phone). I squeed (yes, that's a word according to me 😅) when I saw it was New Rules x Are You That Somebody, one of my faves! Loved how blown away you were and I'm super stoked for you to check out others like La La Latch, Sing, Havana, Shallow... So many good ones! Please check out the old ones still. I really enjoy your PTX reactions! Okay, Sing is with Avi but it's one of my favorite originals! Come Along is another good one with Matt to check out!

[@Lupin788]

I believe they made this video around the time Kirstin was starring in Kinky Boots (in early 2018) on Broadway. That's why they're in a condo with an amazing view of Manhattan (NYC).

[@juliegates3036]

Anxiously awaiting you to get to Singoff Episode 12 when they do 'Dog days are over'. Everyone goes nuts. Also love Havana, although there is so much to love with all of their remixes. They have matured and advanced in their musicality over the years until they are unbelievable.

[@yvettemaldonado3725]

One of my favorite Pentatonix covers 😍😍😍😍😍

[@jennamcalister9101]

I also agree, Havana or Come Along next! I've really grown to appreciate Matt and what he brings to the group but a part of my heart will always belong to Avi!

[@lindamorris3149]

They have really honed their craft over the years!

[@tyeshab.3459]

I love your reactions! And as many times as I've watched this video, I didn't notice that note Matt hit during the transition until you brought it up!

[@gustavsson5277]

Yeah, they sound amazing together! If you want an even more recent one with Matt I recommend "You're a mean one, Mr Grinch". Matt has the lead and Scott does the bass! "Sound of silence" is another incredible cover where Scott gets to show off his bass too.

[@tylergirl1970]

There is SO much more. I can't wait.

[@PtxXtp]

That part you were worried was effects was bell tones. One note sang separately in succession from each member of the the trio done in a very fast triplet. They do it a little slower the first time in the chorus and the second time its such a fast rhythm that it’s hard to tell what they’re doing. They’re so good at their rhythms that one person can come in and sing one note and another takes the next note and so on. It’s very noticeable in the Daft punk medley toward the end. Can’t remember if you’ve reacted to that. Another one with good bell tones between Kirstie and Kevin is Can’t Help Falling In Love. There’s so many good songs left to do.

[@victoriakizito308]

@Kyle Kholin the third voice at 4:24 is Scott

[@samanthamorlock1740]

So happy that you are enjoying ptx. I like to mix them up from old and new. Here are some recommendations: from the old: sing, run to you plus the other Christmas songs. From the new despacito x shape of you, come along, Havana. There are too many to write. Can’t wait to see more reactions and don’t worry about pausing, that’s why it’s called a reaction. I’d rather you pause then talk over it. Also if I didn’t want you to pause, I would go to the ptx channel and watch their videos. Take care

[@Nmiller4486]

Love this mashup from them. If you watch the grinch you will also see Matt shine in that song

[@whoami.24601]

Mitch and Kirstie have gotten really good at matching each other’s tone. To the point where in one of the latest ones (I think it was Can you feel the love tonight) I didn’t even notice they’d switched solos it for a few seconds. Can’t wait for you to get into the newer stuff!