FIRST TIME HEARING Serú Girán- "Eiti-Leda" & "Cinema Verité" (Reaction)

[@retroreactions....]

They continue to bless me with their beautiful powerful emotional music...Thanks for watching! Continúan bendiciéndome con su hermosa y poderosa música emocional... ¡Gracias por ver! 🥰

[@bigjapi1]

Imagine a child, who at 12 years old... was not only a piano teacher, but also created a hyper beautiful Beethovian composition called "Desarma y Sangra" "Disarm and Bleed." That child is Charly Garcia and that music that he included into Serú's discography, will touch your soul.

[@retroreactions....]

Wow, a master at 12? No wonder his music always touches my soul!

[@bigjapi1]

@@retroreactions.... just listen "Desarma y Sangra" Serú... and "Inconciente Colectivo" from his 1rst. solo album "Pubis Angelical", "Angelic Pubis"" lol

[@gustavozeoli1274]

Que lástima que estos muñecos que reaccionan, no entienden o no les interese la letra. Se pierden la mitad de la genialidad de Charly.

[@retroreactions....]

Hola. Traduje, leí e interpreté las letras lo mejor que pude en el poco tiempo que tuve (no hablo español con fluidez). ¡Es por eso que tengo mis maravillosos espectadores para ayudarme a entender mejor la letra!

[@reneelyons6836]

This is new music for me. It is fun. I like it very much. 💙🎼🎹🎶🎶☮💟

[@retroreactions....]

Awesome... Happy Monday! Another week heavy on the 70s decade!!!

[@alavalle69]

Charly García was a prolific multiinstrumentalist composer. He is a genius, not only because of the melodies, lyrics are pure poetry. He is still alive.

[@ricardoazcuenaga]

Cinema me hace llorar cada vez que la escucho

[@retroreactions....]

Puedo ver por qué... ¡muchas gracias por mirar!

[@pommie5093]

First time hearing these songs-stunning

[@retroreactions....]

Awesome! Glad you love them too 😊

[@sergiosimionato7962]

Great reaction! Seru Giran the best. Both songs are amaizing. In the same level of Beatles or Queen. Charly write and sings both songs.

[@retroreactions....]

Thank you very much. Charly is phenomenal! Can't wait to hear more!

[@michaelbaucom4019]

The teamwork here, the musicians complementing each other, the music and the vocals complementing each other, so sweet. Well-engineered/produced. Our host's rating is correct

[@retroreactions....]

Glad you enjoyed these Michael. Great analysis! Thanks for tuning in...

[@loligarcia5145]

The surrealistic poetry of all its lyrics is as good as its music💓

[@retroreactions....]

Yes! Thanks for watching..

[@retrospectivapublicitaria2467]

Fantástico !!! Next songs by Serú Girán : "Canción de Alicia en el país" and "Autos,jets,aviones,barcos". Please my friend ! Y gracias por tanta buena música !

[@retroreactions....]

Gracias y de nada!!

[@cecim2111]

Me alegro que te guste Seru Giran ...para nosotros los argertinos uno de los mejores grupos del rock nacional argentino...Saludos desde Argentina 🇦🇷

[@drmagic60]

Nice choices today! I’m liking this band more and more, every time you have them on the channel. I’ve listened to other songs of theirs on my own. Curious as to what you’ll have during this week??

[@retroreactions....]

Great to hear! I can say the same. Let's see... well we have a pretty good week I'd say- a long epic, 1 new artist, 3 of my favorite epic bands and a couple of surprises too 🙂 I predict you shall enjoy!!

[@drmagic60]

Nice…… you had me at long epic!! Lol

[@retroreactions....]

Prob not what you're thinkin, but I'm sure you like it!

[@camilomorales4785]

Nice video Sir, you should check out a song call "desarma y sangra" by Charly García.

[@retroreactions....]

Thank you very much! Ah yes, that one is on my list already, so I will add your vote now! 🙂

[@christianmiguel8794]

I love your reactions, the clarity of your words and how you allow yourself to get emotional... I have been a fan of Seru Giran since I was a child, for me it is the best progressive rock band in my country... I would love for you to react to the song "Noche de Perros" from Seru Giran album " La Grasa de las capitales.” a dark but beautiful song with incredible solos... thank you for your work!!!

[@retroreactions....]

Hi Christian! Thank you so much for that wonderful compliment! I'm trying hard here. I just added your vote for Noche De Perros! You're welcome and thanks so much for watching 🙂

[@christianmiguel8794]

@@retroreactions.... big hug !

[@retroreactions....]

🤗

[@manuelseting5674]

Escucha "Autos, yets, aviones ,barcos" de Seru Giran.

[@ami8tomas]

Todos las canciones de esta gtan banda son buenas,y no se van a repetir nunca más porque estuvieron estos músicos geniales y el mejor Charly García,gracias por compartir esta música

[@arielfernandez9555]

"La Grasa de las Capitales" te gustará. Gracias!

[@retroreactions....]

¡De nada! ¡Ay, ya le he reaccionado a Grasa! Aqui esta el link: kzbin.info/www/bejne/jnebloyCgsl_iJI

[@kumarvivas9467]

great reaction!

[@retroreactions....]

Thank you very much! I appreciate you watching...

[@eternaltol]

So glad you do “Cinema Verite”, such a beautiful and unique song, (this song is played by Charly and Pedro only, both with synths and vocals)

[@Vrealita]

Great reaction! So glad you are listening to more and more Charly García! Waiting for some of his early solo work from the 1980s, in a similar vein to Cinema Verité, leading the prog to some kind of prog-pop sound!

[@retroreactions....]

Thank you! His music always does it for me. Great to know... I already have a long to do list for him solo and his bands...Thanks for watching!!

[@Argenbiz]

Delightful pleasure to see you plenty of rejoice... We kinda worship our musicians... When I see your reaction, it completes my experience. I grew up nourished by this music.

[@wushu_jingwu_ar]

What about Pedro's fretless bass solo? The most amazing part of the piece imo.

[@retroreactions....]

Yes, I enjoyed it but just briefly mentioned the bass in song 1. Thanks for giving Pedro his well due credit, and for watching!

[@susybacci]

@@retroreactions.... el solo de metales no existe.. el solo al que te referís es, supongo... al solo de bajo fretless de Pedro Aznar en Eiti Leda!!

[@retroreactions....]

Vaya, eso no me suena mucho a un bajo. También deben haber agregado un efecto externo. Cada día aprendo algo nuevo, ¡gracias!

[@susybacci]

@@retroreactions.... el solo de bajo fretless está desde el min 4:26 al 4:58 escuchalo y me dirás 🙌 también podés verlos tocar en el vídeo de Eiti Leda de Serú Giran...

[@retroreactions....]

Sí, lo escuché de nuevo hace unos 20 minutos. Ahora suena un poco más como un bajo, pero sigo pensando que suena como un trombón jajaja...

[@rocksarioCP]

Se nota q no es la primera vez q la escucha pero me alegro que la disfrute..

[@eternaltol]

Don’t give up on Seru Giran, next for me would be “Peperina”, “canción de Alicia en el pais”.

[@danielvillalba9189]

Thanks

[@retroreactions....]

You're welcome, thanks for watching!

[@josedebayres321]

P.S: An additional note about the ending of Cinema verité: you got that right too, the sound effect is taken from the iconic film "Gilda" (whose story takes place in Buenos Aires) which serves as a transition to the next song and then the one after it in which that the famous slap scene, dubbed into Spanish, introduces a short and funny song in smooth latin-funk mood that ironizes about the sad feelings of sexist possession of a dear friend of Charly ("Salir de la melancolia").

[@retroreactions....]

Haha, I thought that sounded like Rita!

[@josedebayres321]

​@@retroreactions....and you got that right too: Gilda is Rita Hayworth (Charly is also a renowned cinephile)

[@retroreactions....]

I've actually watched Gilda! She was stunning!

[@TatuCarreta]

The beatles are the Seru Giran of UK, Charly garcia and Spinetta are two of the greatest composers of the world, but people never think in lantinamerican rock, like even dosent exist :c

[@gnr635]

Hello!!...your reactions are excellent!!...please also react to Soda stereo and Indio solari...the most important rock bands from Argentina

[@retroreactions....]

Hi! Thank you so much for that compliment! Do you have a favorite song from those 2 bands?

[@gnr635]

@@retroreactions....hello!!...the truth is I have several from Soda Stereo (fugitivos, genesis, en la ciudad de la furia, etc)...and from Indio Solari (un angel para tu soledad, jijiji, nuestro amo juega al esclavo, etc. )...those are some of the most famous...thanks

[@gnr635]

@@retroreactions.... extra information...for the videos it is in the soda stereo concert it was the "gira me veras volver" tour and that of Indio Solari in the "Estadio unico de la plata"

[@retroreactions....]

Thanks!

[@nawletorre7136]

hermoso

[@retroreactions....]

Gracias por mirar!!

[@pabloarg5]

Good reaction! Like and sub.

[@retroreactions....]

Thank you so much Pablo for your subscription and compliment!! I really appreciate your support 🙂

[@eduardoangel923]

Gracias!

[@retroreactions....]

¡De nada! Gracias por mirar..

[@ami8tomas]

Estaría bueno la traducción de las letras, música y letras lo que dió esta banda

[@fernandosinarle6419]

Excelente

[@retroreactions....]

Gracias por mirar!!

[@gnr635]

extra information...for the videos it is in the soda stereo concert it was the "gira me veras volver" tour and that of Indio Solari in the "Estadio unico de la plata"

[@eduardomastroscello9136]

En Cinema Verite Chsrly Garcia en piano y voz y Pedro Aznar en teclados Oberheim y coros.

[@juansolis4796]

Wonderful voice, I know it´s compressed and everything, but Hey.. I love compression in voices too. New subs, btw.

[@retroreactions....]

Thank you so much for your subscription! I really appreciate you watching and commenting 😊

[@matiasnovoa8794]

You need to listen "desarma y sangra"

[@retroreactions....]

Ok, thanks, added your vote....

[@josedebayres321]

Hi Brandon, once again, great musical and lyrical analysis... About "Cinema verité" (and as you observed) I would describe it as a visit to an earthly paradise traveled by a couple with an un-original sin, in which the narrator plays the role of unobserved observer. About other songs I would insist on "Autos, jets, aviones, barcos" (1978) and then "Perro andaluz" (1979). I think that between the two they can put together a very good combo. Then, sooner or later, you will have to react to "A los jóvenes de ayer" as you have probably already been told. 👍

[@retroreactions....]

Thank you! I added your votes for the 2 songs, but guess what? I have already reacted to Jovenes! Here ya go 🙂: kzbin.info/www/bejne/oHrJkH6JiKuhrac

[@josedebayres321]

@@retroreactions.... ahah, of course you already reacted to it! I remembered it right after I posted it... Bad memory, I should eat more fish.

[@josedebayres321]

And I don't mean Marillion's discography 😉 Anyways, thanks por taking my suggestions

[@retroreactions....]

Haha, blackened or lemon butter salmon, well done!! 😋

[@retroreactions....]

LMAO!

[@darkbluesss]

Excellent reaction, I must assume that you react only to the music, my recommendation is that you translate the lyrics, they are really deep and poetic, keep up the good work. Greetings from Argentina.

[@retroreactions....]

Thank you so much!!

[@prueba3207]

Escucha (aunque no las reacciones) "San Francisco y el Lobo" la versión de estudio y la versión en vivo del 31/12/92, también te aconsejo "transformación" y "no voy a dejarte" (esta última tiene un mensaje reproduciendola alreves). La gran "Seminare" es hermosa, en versión estudio, "noche de perros" y "viernes 3am", "Jose Mercado" que esta infravalorada, pero a mi me parece que se merece mas reconocimiento. (En realidad a mi me gustan todas las de Seru😅❤)

[@marcelocodina8039]

Pedro Aznar, bajista, dejó Seru para tocar con Pat Metheny en los 80. Seru Giran decidió no seguir sin Pedro y ese fue el final de la magia.

[@elizabethyozia1124]

Hello friend, thank you for listening to the greatest Charly García, I recommend that you listen to the complete album by the band Vox Dei "The Bible"

[@retroreactions....]

Hello! You're welcome. Thanks for the suggestion, will add this band to my list 🙂

[@gusjoagomez]

U must listen "La grasa de las capitales" by Serúu Girán.

[@carlosdanielscala8605]

Molto bene grazie frufru.lkn

[@MaMaHeAvY]

TE CUENTO UN POCO SOBRE LA CARRERA MUSICAL DE CHARLY, NO SIN ANTES DECIRTE QUE ÉL DIRIGE LA BANDA, CANTA, ESCRIBE Y COMPONE TODOS LOS TEMAS. CON RESPECTO A "LA MÁQUINA DE HACER PÁJAROS" PUEDO DECIRTE QUE FUÉ LA ETAPA MENOS EXITOSA DE CHARLY GARCÍA, DESPUÉS QUE DISOLVIERA EL DÚO "SUI GÉNERIS" CON NITO MESTRE.... DESPUÉS EN SU ETAPA DE SOLISTA, COMPUSO Y ESCRIBIÓ TEMAS MUY BUENOS COMO "LA GRASA DE LAS CAPITALES", "PEPERINA", ETC... Y MÁS TARDE FORMÓ EL GRUPO "SERÚ GIRÁN" DONDE TUVO TEMAS BUENÍSIMOS Y CON GRAN ÉXITO COMO "ETI LEDA", "SEMINARE", "LOS DINOSAURIOS", ETC... PARA FINALMENTE VOLVER COMO SOLISTA HASTA LA FECHA... ES PROFESOR DE PIANO Y GUITARRA, RECIBIDO EN EL CONSERVATORIO "THIBAUD PIAZZINI: DE ZONA NORTE, CAP. FEDERAL Y A LOS 8 AÑOS INTERPRETÓ EN DICHO CONSERVATORIO Y DELANTE DE UN CONSIDERABLE PÚBLICO SU PRIMER OBRA, UNA SONATINA EN 3 PARTES, CUYO ORIGINAL SE ENCUENTRA EXPUESTA EN LA SALA PRINCIPAL DEL CONSERVATORIO... COMO VEN, FUÉ MUY PRECÓZ Y A MI HUMILDE CRITERIO EL MEJOR CLMPOSITOR DE ROCK ARGENTINO, YA QUE SUS PARTITURAS SON EXTREMADAMENTE COMPLEJAS Y SE LAS PUEDE COMPARAR CON LAS "FUGAS" DE BACH, LAS CUALES ADEMÁS DE DIFERENTES SON ABSOLUTAMENTE DIFÍCILES DE SACAR EN EL PIANO Y DE INTERPRETAR (CABE DESTACAR QUE YO TAMBIÉN SOY PROF. DE PIANO, RECIBIDA EN EL MISMO CONSERVATORIO) SALUDOS DESDE MAR DEL PLATA (LA PERLA DEL ATLÁNTICO) ARGENTINA 🙂👍😘😘🇦🇷🇦🇷🇦🇷❤️👏👏👏👏👏

[@bigjapi1]

No podia ser otro que Jorgito el primero en comentar LOL

[@retroreactions....]

Si Jorgito, espero que te hayas quedado un poco boquiabierto cuando viste que también hice ambas obras maestras juntas!! 😁 🥇

[@bigjapi1]

@@retroreactions.... también me quedo con la boca abierta con tu perfecto español jajaja. ok, here we go... The unfortunately short period of life of this superband (1978-1982), coincided with the period that Argentina was undergoing a military process, and anyone who opposed that process was kidnapped from their home and normally never appeared again, in several songs, such as the case of "Eiti Leda", the lyrics have a double meaning. Below I explain some... I want to see you naked... ""the day of the bodies parade, who have been saved" (the people who returned home after being kidnapped by the military) On some highway... "having infinite banners saying nothing" (NN graves of people who never came back home after being kidnapped by the military) I want to stay, don't say anything... "just hope the shadows are gone baby" (the shadows refer to the soldiers or police, entering the homes at night) Can't you see how white I am... refers to "I am "clean", don't kidnap me from my home"

[@bigjapi1]

@@retroreactions.... "Cinema Verite" is a great short film of a millionaire Adam and a high-level Eve, having a "hot" encounter hehehe, on a lonely beach in the 20th century, and Charly Garcia... in his brilliant compositional madness, casually and innocently, saw that whole moment with... "the looking machine". That's why he sings... Y yo estoy con la máquina de mirar Justo en el paraíso, para filmar... And I'm with the looking machine Right in paradise, to film...

[@retroreactions....]

Since I'm 7/8 of Mexican descent I better say it right haha! Sadly I'm not 100% fluent. Didn't know if I was saying Eiti correctly. Is that a made up word? Wow so Eiti is much darker than I thought in that context. Thanks for the explanation.

[@retroreactions....]

Still don't quite get it haha....does it mean he is just watching that movie on his TV?

[@reverts3031]

Pretty please could you play Jean Luc Ponty's "Cosmic Messenger"???? It's an instrumental with a touch of tingle for Spooky Season? Would appreciate. Love your channel!!

[@retroreactions....]

It's on my list.... I will add your vote thanks!

[@reverts3031]

@@retroreactions.... Thank you for that. I'm tempted to write up a list of specific suggestions for JLP, but I think that playing Cosmic Messenger was a good starting point. Back in 2017, he did a world concert tour specifically dedicated to his recordings with Atlantic. If anyone mentions "the older stuff" - this is probably what they're referring to - and Cosmic Messenger was one of the songs he played. However his music goes back to the 1960s when he worked with an acoustic violin. I was surprised to see so many people that responded knowing who he is. Every album has different music except for concert albums and collections.

[@terratremit1]

Please don't listen to the musician Spinetta...his sound is addictive.

[@bernardobuffa2391]

man, first of all, thanks for all these videos, and specially this one. I must tell you, you are missing a lot of the musical meaning listening only to the music. If you want the premium Serú Giran experience, you must dive into the lyrics as well. Cheers!

[@retroreactions....]

You're welcome, it's been a pleasure discovering this band so far. I did give my interpretation of the lyrics at the end a bit in case you missed that part 🙂 Thanks so much for watching!

[@bernardobuffa2391]

​ @retroreactions.... you are right, another really interesting bit, is that the narrator's point of view as an spectator of the scene, he is in the 'máquina de mirar', and when the song had already mentioned Adan and Eve in the paradise... at the end he says that him (the narrator) is in the paradise. El paraíso (paradise) is how we know the highest level in a theater, where you can watch the scene from top. es.wikipedia.org/wiki/Para%C3%ADso_(teatro).

[@retroreactions....]

Cool, thanks for the info!

[@darkbluesss]

Hello, I saw your channel, I see that you listen to a little bit of everything, I challenge you again with something from Argentina, the band is called Rata Blanca and the song (la leyenda del hada y el mago) The Legend of the Fairy and the Magician, again the lyrics are important but the music It's going to blow your mind, see you.

[@sergiovallerga3078]

You have chosen very nice songs. Only from Charly there are tons of music missing and from Argentine Music uffff you should make a new channel, the quantity is overwhelming with excellent quality

[@marianito_keluc8770]

Charly es Dios musicalmente superior a lennon