First Time Reacting to SHINee! | Music Producer and K-pop Fan React to SHINee (Replay)' MV

[@amaninc4944]

Actually the song is from 2008

[@hadilbecha8661]

It's from 2008, thank u for reacting to SHINEE, u need to react to more of them cuz u'll never regret it!!

[@valenandtheo]

Thank you so much. More SHINee to come soon!

[@sofeels_]

The actress is f(x)'s Victoria. The video is originally from 2008 and was remastered in 2022. That's why it's 4k and there's subs.

[@eyla107]

Korea’s princes of kpop 🤧 thank you for reacting to SHINEE

[@valenandtheo]

Our pleasure, more to come for sure!

[@tokki_bunch]

Welcome to SHINee World! Make sure to check out their live performances - they're great.

[@CHOLILLIAN]

This song is a legend for every brand new idol group for K-pop. Whenever and whoever debuts, they really try to cover this song in order to have attention from audiences. This song is not easy to sing because only Shinee can complete this song with their harmony. Of course, they are really handsome. Their nickname is the prince of K-pop! ^^

[@sentilomou8740]

This mv is remastered actually Shinee debut on 2008 Their live performance is awesome. You guys should watch it

[@Ofra8191-]

in 2011 SM opened a new KZbin channel and reuploaded all of their old MVs, that's why it says 2011. That year SHINee had only Japanese releases and those are on a different channel so any SHINee MV that says it's from 2011 is actually older. This one is their debut from 2008. The name SHINee is the word Shine with the suffix ee, the meaning is "the ones who receive the light".

[@davidtan2852]

The girl in the music video was from f(x). Another girl group from SM which debuted 1 year after SHINee.

[@BABYMONSTER_RORA_RAMI_AHYEON]

THE LEGENDS ! THE PRINCES OF K-POP !

[@sofeels_]

Good songs for a deep dive and some variety: 2010: Lucifer 2013: Dream Girl 2013: Everybody 2015: View 2016: Tell Me What To Do 2018: Good Evening 2021: Don't Call Me 2023: Hard

[@sofeels_]

Oh and 2012: Sherlock

[@taedreamshi]

Add: ring ding dong for 2009

[@sjames1955]

Shinee is one of the greatest Kpop groups of all time and they are universally admired and respected. Many newer groups have covered their songs. Shinee Taemin is widely recognized as one of the greatest dancers in the business and is a very popular solo artist as well.

[@ugh.ashi_]

The fact that replay viral again recently is iconic

[@ren.the.rascal]

SHINEE the blueprint of most K-Pop now. Vocals and charisma on point!!!

[@tieAcherry101]

Shinee is a very influential group over K-pop’s history. They started the movement for dance practices to be uploaded on KZbin, and their choreographies/sound are known to be the key change from the transition of first to second generation. They also popularised album merch and k-pop’s heavy marketing schedule along with girls generation at the time.

[@maggot2259]

They also popularized hard and expensive choreo with Infinite (as you said it was a key change from 1st gen to 2nd gen and even 3rd gen). Taemin popularized androgynous concepts(outfit, sound, choreo), he wasnt the 1st of couse but Move made it a big deal. And for groups to stay together and last for several years.

[@eaglet294]

This is widely considered as the BEST DEBUT in kpop history. They won all the rookie awards this year. Even the senior artists wanted to watch their rehearsals because they sing live with intense dancing.

[@JMarts-no8hx]

Please do a deep dive!!!!! I’ve been a shinee fan since 2008, yes I’m old lol, in terms of songs there is a shinee playlist that you can follow but if not it’d be great to see you guys react to some of the newer music and go backwards. Hard-Atlantis-Don’t call me-Countless-Good Evening, etc. I would also do album listens honestly their music is gold some of my favorite songs are kiminoseide (Japanese song), all day all night, Code, Kind, Diamond sky-please watch live or concert versions of these. Also each member has solo work. Onew’s latest was O (Circle) is a beautiful song, Dice and blue, Minho - Heartbreak, I’m Home, Key - killer, bad love, good & great, Taemin - Advice, Guilty, criminal, Idea, and Jonghyun- Deja boo, She is, Shinin. Each solo work demonstrates their different color and character which are all amazing 🤩.

[@This_Ayoifeoluwa]

their name "SHINee" is a play on the word "Shine" as you guessed. it's like employ- employee... the ee depicting the "receiver" so SHINee means "receiving light", or more contextually, "the ones who receive light"

[@BABYMONSTER_RORA_RAMI_AHYEON]

9:03 FROM LEFT TO RIGHT : MINHO, KEY, TAEMIN (Maknae), JONGHYUN (REST IN PEACE) and ONEW (Leader).

[@keysburntgucci9016]

The year is 2050, and Replay is still the BEST DEBUT EVER! Thank you for checking the song out on SPOTIFY, felt you took them seriously, and SHINee should be taken seriously. 16 years into the industry and they are still relevant, very hard to do in this competitive industry. THE group to check out if you're looking for Quality, Quantity and Variety! And Yes to the Deep Dive!

[@evaswol]

omg yes !! they were all such babies in this 🥹 taemin (the youngest) was only 14 and onew (oldest and leader) was only 18! hope u guys check out more of their music their discography is INSANE. i would recommend sherlock, view, 1 of 1, lucifer, and atlantis (or honestly just their entire discography cuz tbh theyve never released a bad song imo)

[@valenandtheo]

Woow we had no idea they were so young and we definitely will do more from SHINee

[@dewidelisa9236]

The best debut song ever🥰

[@maryanna5832]

Welcome to SHINee World. SHINee is 4ver 5. Take the SHINee journey. Start from their beginnings. Well you already have. They are known as the "Princes of Kpop". Go thru all their Korean and Japanese (hopefully not complete blocked) discographies and mvs....but you need to watch them live in concert, they are know for the live vocals. If you take the SHINee journey i'll subscribe. 5HINee 4ever💎💎💎💎💎

[@bumkeymyeon]

AAAAAHH I'm so happy you're reacting to SHINee!! I subscribed recently bc of your Exo content and I'm so glad you listened to SHINee too ❤

[@Nicolehub]

SHINee are legends..hope to see more crazy reactions

[@angelaliris]

Please more react to shinee😊

[@Catzfamily269]

Shinee was in Singapore 1st weekend of March 2024, along with Taylor Swift. Lisa from Blackpink attended both concerts. 🇸🇬👍

[@luffyd.aceroger8254]

that's why I loved this song when I first heard it it gave me old school NEYO, usher, Chris brown etc vibe

[@jinkidorobol]

SHINee debuted at 2008 the video was just re-uploaded and remastered. They are Korea's Princes of Kpop. Please react to them more. They are the best most especially their live performances. They are still together and continue making great music. Oh one last thing, they are this generation Idols' Idol, that's how legendary they are. Thanks!

[@zafiro2505]

Thanks for reacting to SHINee 💎💎💎💎💎 SHINee stands for "the ones who receive the light" and the song is from 2008. You should check their live performance, they are insane. Some people call them CDNee because they sound exactly the same singing live that in the recordings

[@mesyadinda3582]

Please react to Shinee's other works for example there's some recomendation like Lucifer, Sherlock, Ring ding dong, Married to the music. But if you want to be Shawols you also need to react on they're guide. Also don't forget to check out the member's solo songs and they're live performance, especially in they're concert

[@lailaexo]

This is the best debut of all time 🎉🎉

[@tara8288]

Please do a SHINee deep dive, I'm running out of shinee reactions to watch lol

[@fefi1501]

Awww qué emocionada me sentí con tan solo leer el título ❤️‍🩹. Lo disfrutaré mucho, agradecida de antemano con la reacción.

[@worldcitizen6542]

Yeeess.. Shinee! One of the legends and the industry gave them the title "The Princes of Kpop" 🙌🏻 Replay is one of the most iconic debut songs that to this day is still being covered by countless of Kpop artists and idol groups

[@lori4021]

SHINee are known as the Princes of K-Pop and the Kings of live performances, especially amazing on their concerts. Their title tracks are great, but imho, their B-sides are even more so. Even in songs that I normally would not have vibe to, they'd changed my mind with the live performances.

[@BABYMONSTER_RORA_RAMI_AHYEON]

*SHINee guides (WITH LINKS)* : "SHINee's Impact in Music is BIGGER Than You Think. {{Deep Dive}} [15th Anniversary Tribute]" by Jonathan Miller Music Link : kzbin.info/www/bejne/b6XVi2qOe7R_a9k "[ENG/FRA] DEEP DIVE INTO SHINee - Get to Know the Princes of K-Pop // Updated SHINee Guide (2022)" by SHINee Space Link : kzbin.info/www/bejne/gpq8fYmjeNaUsMk "A very SHINee Guide!" by Very Swank Link : kzbin.info/www/bejne/maWsoWmOfKh-bac "WHO IS SHINee? A Member Introduction To The Princes Of KPOP (2021)" by Michelle Hawk Link : kzbin.info/www/bejne/aqCyhWCeqZqnkLs "A Detailed Guide To SHINee (2021)" by shining flowers Link : kzbin.info/www/bejne/mGq6pKqEfsSoic0 "(un)helpful guide to shinee" by c h a w o l Link : kzbin.info/www/bejne/gZWxnYBmlN13iqc SHINee guides by Very Swank Playlist link : kzbin.info/aero/PLbqNxiFkTjvlWCnRk8iBHqfq2FBCMAge0

[@BABYMONSTER_RORA_RAMI_AHYEON]

SHINee MVs (PLAYLIST) : kzbin.info/aero/PLG9J3dru6j3tICbUUcYSncUICWR-xtqQ-

[@byulyo1313]

SM remastered thier old music video from the 1990s to the 2000s (300MV) starting from November 2021

[@Idontneednoanybodyelse]

Actually shinee debut in 2008 and their debut song is replay.. but in 2011 sm ent again re upload their replay song with hd mv and deleted the previous mv which was in 2008

[@zannatunnaim-f8e]

This video is remastered that's why it's quality and everything is change and SHINee debuted in 2008..

[@valenandtheo]

yeah, the quality of the video has definitely been upscaled. It's just a shame they didn't do the same for the music since it deserved better.

[@thaislobo6071]

One of the best kpop debuts

[@TheDeLuLuShow219]

lmao reason why the video probably has ENG subs because they remastered the MV. SM started to do that for a bit.

[@bonzina]

Yes SM used to have many cameos of their artists in other groups' mvs, especially back in 2nd gen! If you watch SNSD's biggest hit Gee, you will see Minho from SHINee as the actor in the mv! I recommend reacting to Don't Call Me next time you check them out. They're hugely popular still, and they're one of the most successful kpop groups of all time in Japan, they just wrapped up their latest tour a week ago with several nights at Tokyo Dome which is one of the largest concert venues in the world. All 5 of the members have established solo careers as well, perhaps you have heard of Taemin?

[@adnwntr2778]

you can watch talk saxy by riize, which reminds people of shinees replay. fyi theyre shinees juniors debuted recently

[@OttersAndOreos]

Sherlock Clue + Note, the concert version. You will love them even more. Shinee, always 5. If you have heard of Taemin, he is the youngest member of Shinee with the bowl cut, in the Wicked T shirt.

[@spectrum4524]

Love the reaction. Assuming there are more reactions to Shinee to come, I would hope to see reactions to their live performances as well as MVs.

[@valenandtheo]

There's definitely more to come soon since it's a really important and accomplished group, and yeah, we'll do live performances too, but probably over on Patreon

[@田田-h7j]

More SHINee pls❤I recommend Don’t call me, Why so serious, Married to the music, Atlantis, View, Everybody, juice, Tell me what to do, our page 😊

[@crochetmittens]

Loved this! Please react to more SHINee

[@enanan83]

I just found your channel and I loved this video! I would love a deep dive! They have sooo many songs but some of my recs would be Love Like Oxygen, Lucifer, Sherlock, Dream Girl, Married to the Music, Don't Call Me, Atlantis, and Hard!

[@K-Director]

2nd gen is truly gem of Kpop

[@FallSouthWinter]

"With that name I thought they were a girl group!" They have been considered an honorary girl group so you're not completely wrong

[@murtadza9]

The girls is victoria from f(x)..sm girly group..Nd shinee debut in 2008

[@onewsfalsetto9439]

yall should read the about first. 2008 debut, 2011 reupload.

[@elliephantastic-qy3hb]

Aside from the LEGEND as a group they are individually famous as solo arrist😍 You must check their solo work too ( Taemin, Key, Onew, Jonghyun and Minho) all are gold!!!!

[@scurinca]

thank u for reacting

[@lilackpop]

Esse mv foi remasterizado, por isso a quantidade boa e as legendas, a música em si foi lançada em 2008!

[@bea_hae_tae9392]

The best debut in K-pop definitely belonged to SHINee. They are still considered role models both vocally and dancing Next Juliette Hello Lucifer Sherlock 1of1 more

[@jatychurch6295]

they debut 2008, the mv was just reuploaded in 2012

[@valenandtheo]

It says 2022 remaster from what I (theo) can see, so they definitely have been through a lot of versions😅 Still, however, I am talking about the actual music mastering, which has definitely been distorted in the "music video process" for some reason.

[@jatychurch6295]

@@valenandtheo yeah i mean im just talking about the song and mv in general not about the mastering or any technicalities there is

[@valenandtheo]

Ah okay sorry my mistake@@jatychurch6295

[@itsmeleenie]

Would love to see you react to more SHINee!!!

[@hanbaebummie3215]

I hope you can react to them live also!! They eat there CD’s

[@a_g8095]

Actually I think this style is coming back with groups as riize.

[@shwl525shine]

It's not without reason why every rookie group always covers this song, they are the standard

[@CsillaBerszanArus]

We want to see a deep dive, pls. 😊

[@NewTada]

Be sure to react to their “sister” group f(x) and find their similarity, or so it says…

[@maheshsurya9796]

BtoB killing voice and BtoB live performance..

[@sofeels_]

The group name is pronounced like 'shiny'.

[@cecilesunga3375]

Reason of your question because this song has been remastered…

[@mapalomukupa6459]

Yay we get both Exo and SHINee 💙

[@jonouchi_27]

Please react to more SHINee, you guys won't regret.

[@tanahmei8076]

That girl is Victoria from FX . SM girl group.

[@manelshawol1342]

the song is from 2008, shinee debut in 2008

[@yunabiminhoo]

I known to k-pop because of SHINee minhoo.

[@HAHAPO1008]

He was 14 years old

[@valenandtheo]

Who?

[@HAHAPO1008]

@@valenandtheo shinee tamin

[@sofeels_]

@@valenandtheo in the Replay MV, SHINee's maknae (youngest member) was only 14 y.o.

[@valenandtheo]

wow that is soo young@@sofeels_

[@shatingstar9644]

More shinee please

[@niyetz228]

Ohhh shinee... It's from2008❤ subbing for more❤

[@FAQIvan91]

As others already said, the girl in the video is Viktoria from f(x), but if I remember well she's the member of f(x) who's the sister of Jessica from Girl's Generation.

[@DayaneFreire2016]

Same group but Krystal is the sister :)

[@FAQIvan91]

@@DayaneFreire2016 Oh you're right, I didn't sleep when I wrote that comment 😂

[@stephanieyminho]

Ok,me suscribo si siguen sus reacciones a SHINee😊,su música es increíble ❤, see you!

[@guanyundu5725]

More SM artists plz!

[@marymoser2413]

correction Shinee debuted in 2008 with the song Replay and not in 2011😊😊😊

[@choi997]

Hope you listen Treasure songs for next time, they hv new song called Let it Burn 🔥 😍😊

[@rikaaasha6112]

please react to SHINee’s Body Rhythm, i beg you guys!!!!

[@winghei8511]

Please react to Collar’s new song “ back in the game”

[@djshinee2706]

2008 it is

[@daphneyanet2010]

More please

[@DayaneFreire2016]

You should see Taemin now he grew up really well :)

[@mandytoreno5961]

Why this video got subtitle bcoz it's remastered. And I hope exo old mv got remastered too😢

[@crochetmittens]

DEEP DIVE PLEASE YOU HAVE TO

[@emanfaraidon9072]

please reaction to twice : i can't stop me more and more set me free one spark

[@maheshsurya9796]

BtoB reactions plss

[@battarabbit8827]

You know, research makes you worth taking seriously. To watch you stumble through facts that should be given respect is painful.

[@valenandtheo]

It's our first reaction to the group, and Valen knew a decent amount about the group. We prefer reading up on the group as we go along so our audience can follow the progress (especially with a guide). Luckily, judging from the great response from their fanbase, nobody else found it painful to watch.

[@mandypinguy]

6:46 i mean when does sm not mess up 😅

[@imeldaimey30]

Please reaction boy group pnation psy song MOVE channel THE NEW SIX ,thank you

[@소용돌이-b3p]

too many talk

[@valenandtheo]

Our content isn't just us making faces. We value the format and the art and provide an actual opinion. However, if you just want to watch strangers making faces, I suggest you turn on Disney Channel😅

[@maggot2259]

Thats the point of these videos 😂😂. Just watch the Mv if that makes u feel better

[@BlueNightShineeWorld25508]

Check out shinee's entire discography and solo work