Three GST Rates for Popcorn Spark Confusion and Ridicule | Vantage with Palki Sharma

[@dipendudas8021]

Why are journalists not questioning 18% gst on educational and skill courses. Education is more important than your popcorn.

[@Stallion_1044]

Thanks to her great master, Vishwa guru : Modi-G

[@nareshbandari9806]

Bcoz states want more tax collection as well

[@stratpaul]

Popcorn is more important than education

[@gopsda]

The actual reason could be there were no big players in the Education domain -- it's scattered for Medical, Engineering, Law and other streams, private tutoring institutions, etc. If there is one Adani like figure doing all these, probably they reduce the tax and get donations to increase their assets value to further Rs 8000 crores.

[@vanacharlasaipavankumar6331]

Education is taxed at 0% Coaching is taxed at 18%

[@rohitgautam6693]

One nation one election One popcorn 3 taxes

[@jitendrakumar-ni4ys]

GST on comment comming soon... 😂

[@scamexpose123]

😂😂

[@scamexpose123]

Unbelievable

[@mrs9305]

before 2014 elections cruid oil price around 105 dollars per barrel. and petrol around 72 rupps per litter Now in 2024 cruid oil price around 77 dollars per barrel. Even got cheaper Russian oil and yet petrol around 104 rupps per litter Thanks to BJ party Mudi sarkar ki Jai.....

[@scamexpose123]

@ Well I don’t agree with this rhetoric. In 2014, 1$ was equal to 58₹ and now it is 85₹. As ₹ has been pegged to usd since 1991, this depreciation is going to continue till India becomes a highly productive modern economy. We are no where close to that yet and would not be close to it in the next 25 years. Fact of the matter is that how slowly it depreciates in the controlled manner and let’s leave that to RBI to manage. Plus, the inflation compounded value of the currency also depreciates and in 11 years it is easily 70% of its value in 2014. If we consider the value addition index at 1.6 factor which is the average of last 10 years. Hence, 2014 equivalent of value for a litre petrol is (58/85)*(1/1.7)*1.6*104 =₹66.79.. Hence it’s proven that the cost of petrol today is lesser than it was in 2014..

[@TPG405]

Russia - Cure For Cancer, USA- Working on AI, Singapore - business hub, India- Lets putt taxes on popcorn

[@abhisheksoni303]

4th fail champu se kya expect karoge.

[@lionelmessithegoatLM10]

China ai robots and military

[@user-dv9tz3wu6b]

Palki is mouthpiece of Godi media, who is defending more taxes on non-upper class people

[@ankurgaur3620]

😂😂😂​@@trisongnanaraj9881

[@MrFun4U.]

​@@abhisheksoni303 He don't make gold from potatoes.

[@Su-d2q]

Finance minister must be changed. Nirmala sitaraman is terrible for indian lower and middle class.

[@vensilver]

You have to change the government she is just a month peice

[@nitinchauhan1025]

Why not PM be changed...she is just a puppet of government

[@takeshih3909]

without boss command no dog will bite others so u know what i am saying right? master is a sudhra and nimmi is brahmin so she wont listen in the other case

[@Housenumber68]

She says you wil have to change your class to poor.

[@cuckoonut1208]

Democracy must be removed.

[@nandakara9579]

If arrogance is taxed, Madam Finance Minster will go bankrupt 😜

[@i.m.o.17]

👌🏻

[@Satanreincarnation-zg6sl]

🤔! How much income tax are you paying?

[@dragonmandy2658]

u mean she diesnt hv arrogance?

[@Ghi365]

No, he means you don't pay tax for arrogance! ​Hard to understand??@@dragonmandy2658

[@JONATHANGAMING69]

Don't say her madam😂

[@samikbasak3067]

She is the most worst finance minister we ever have

[@YoutubeRajesh]

For saving the country from Covid ? Or for keeping the economy positive when other countries are failing ?

[@ArnavSingh-wk9fs]

Worst for us but best for the govt. As she is collecting a good amount of money from our pockets and in return we are getting the same poor infrastructure facilities.

[@Quantinvestor1]

​@@KZbinRajesh don't compare with falling country We have 140+ crore people Only 3-4 pay direct tax why? Every one should pay tax as little as possible And gst is less on rich people things Increased capital gain taxes I can write 100 mistakes I am not in financial sector Govt should focus on job creation, wealth distribution not increasing taxes

[@soullette]

​@@KZbinRajeshandhbhakt, u pay my taxes instead.

[@sougata890]

We have tax minister not finance minister 😂

[@priyankanand7039]

Sukha panipuri 5% ,panipuri with salted pani 12%, panipuri with chatni 18%😅😅😅

[@User1976valid]

+ Potato then 28%🤣

[@kalpesh655]

😂🤣😂🤣damn funny

[@delmanpronto9374]

see... what a brilliant FM... no more namkeen you see.

[@Stallion_1044]

Thanks to her great master, Vishwa guru : Modi-G

[@sanjaymehra4632]

On plate 35%

[@A_Train]

The worst FM ever! The most unqualified person to hold the finance portfolio.

[@startingpoint1265]

Her husband had warned the nation.

[@Stallion_1044]

Thanks to his master, Vishwa guru : Modi-G

[@rajx7120]

Then you don't know, how it was before GST. Every state had different tax rates, and different slabs. It was hell. Today, we are only discussing popcorn. Not which state's tax on the same item. Be thankful.

[@Titoo1346]

Be thankful 😂 Dumbb 🤡🤡​@@rajx7120

[@trb7813]

​@@rajx7120itna bhi justify nhi karte yrr

[@GurudeepSingh-k9p]

Dosa-5% Masala dosa with potato 10, with potato n ghee 18%😂😂😂😂

[@GauravSharma-hk2vo]

Rich and Poor are least affected. Middle class has to pay too much in comparison to earning to make life comfortable. I.e. tax on Second hand cars.

[@cuckoonut1208]

What's the most important piece of the sandwich? The meat of course.

[@Stallion_1044]

Thanks to her great master, Vishwa guru : Modi-G

[@khottasikka4700]

Jai Shri ram bolna thaa….. kuch aur hi likh rahe ho. Kya ho gya bhai 😂😂

[@Noddytheblackgod]

Now there will be no middle class

[@student1821]

Anyone not paying tax can go to pakistan

[@darkshadow2443]

Tax like Europe services like somalia

[@iZunesha]

All thanks to "Nirmala Sitharaman" 🥹

[@Renotalks]

I think somalia is doing better nowadays

[@Deathsboyg]

Europeans didn't want subsidy food to live like more than half of the Indians

[@Peoplevoice09]

Plain Underwear - 5% tax Colour Underwear - 12% tax Colour+printed Underwear - 18% tax lastly citizens get torn underwear to wear ...which FM is least worried !!!

[@AltLeafDrifting]

Somalia is also doing better than us bro

[@j0saf]

Do we have a Finance Minister or a Tax Minister 😂

[@nightmist7977]

Blame GST council. Your father's also sit there

[@aarti7423]

​@@nightmist7977 GST council just give advice. But it's in the hands of govt to implement it or not.

[@ruarika3112]

Newbie on Economics and Polity​@@nightmist7977

[@iams04]

Sometimes I feel it should be renamed to NST ( NIRMALA SITHARAMAN TAX)

[@dhoniteron1059]

😂

[@EvanE-d4q]

No need to change...its simply "Goods Sitharaman Tax"😅

[@tmanis02]

Why are we need to pay Tax?? Countries developement??? Where is the development???

[@MrSatadal]

For freebies

[@guardiansofgalaxy664]

It's already developed after 2014

[@aaryavaadarsh]

​@@MrSatadal aj tak mai government ka ek paisa ni janta hu. Are mujhe to freebies bhi ni mili aur tax bhi badhate ja rahe hai. Ek personal loan to diya ni jata inse. Itne dhakke khaye. Pm loan program bhi bas kishan aur businessman ko milta hai. Nokri walo ke liye koi program hi ni hai

[@Blitzkers99]

​@@guardiansofgalaxy664You can look at the development. Indian Rupees is like a toilet paper infront of Dollars now . Soon it will become 100 Rupees for a single Dollar. You can buy toilet paper rolls for 1 dollars but you can buy nothing for 1 Rupees, Rather use that crappy currency as toilet paper. Condition for India is so bad that even beggars in US makes atleast 5K a month which is 4-5 lakhs and soon will be like 6-7 lakhs for India, which is way higher than indian average income

[@abhisheksoni303]

We are number 1 in bureaucratic/Judicial corruption, Colonial mentality and Political Prostitution, tax and legal terorism, jhooth-jumla-laffaji.

[@kiranrajendran3323]

Time to leave this country

[@LikeDeep-q6w]

Country leaving tax! 🤣🤣

[@tbraghavendran]

Wait, India will soon make it illegal to move out of the country without permission, just like NK.

[@Satanreincarnation-zg6sl]

@@kiranrajendran3323 , 🤔! Would Saudi Arabia be a great place?

[@kiranrajendran3323]

@Satanreincarnation-zg6sl Thts bad too. But we can survive for a few days atleast unlike the two countries i mentioned

[@indiasane9420]

Lol do you even know how much UK, Europe, US taxes are ? Income tax slabs go up to 45 to 50 percent there. India is much better compared to that

[@nishantahvan]

Wait for Tax on Air and Water... Wait... Ahhhh !!!

[@Titoo1346]

Air purifiers and RO GST 🤡

[@shakthivelsaravanan9263]

Over reaction as if you pay tax

[@316jun]

Some cities like Bangalore they don't provide water properly

[@piyushpsingh81]

Water bill is already taxed at 5% bhai. And packed drinking water at 18% Air bachi hai, vo itni polluted hai ke GST Lena chhahiye humay

[@dominicj7977]

also social media tax and meme tax.

[@ShinichiKudoQatnip]

Isn't food suppossed to have the least tax rates?

[@externalbiconsultant2054]

No it isn't

[@amaledward2147]

No, how dare you eat Caramel Popcorn man. 😂

[@Peoplevoice09]

Plain Underwear - 5% tax Colour Underwear - 12% tax Colour+printed Underwear - 18% tax lastly citizens get torn underwear to wear ...which FM is least worried !!!

[@LinguaSaṃsāram]

India Slowly becoming worst country to live. Sadly🙂

[@bhuwin6186]

Is food a necessity? Dont think so

[@tribeon]

Why don't govt disclose the GST expenditures so that public knows where does all the money goes

[@Anoymous464]

Corruption ko kaise disclose karenge babu bhaiya 😂😂

[@mlg1279]

Infrastructure projects, defence, salaries & pensions

[@Anoymous464]

@@mlg1279 Andhbhakt spotted

[@Anoymous464]

@@mlg1279 BJP IT CELL has joined the chat

[@nightmist7977]

Budget download karke padho. Apne bicharik baap ka video dekhne se nahi hoga

[@sarathiveda361]

Gst collecting is increasing because the rate of goods are increasing. bussiness not growing, its clear in Q2 result of all big companies. Why FM not able to understand this small math. Central is concerned only abt the GST collecting and finding ways to pick more from income tax, public are suffering. Real tragedy for midle class

[@rajx7120]

Centre can't control prices. Prices are going up, because imported items like crude oil and palm oil, which are used everywhere, are becoming expensive. And petrol taxes are applied by both state and Centre m and usually states increase petrol taxes, for freebies. Central excise duty has remained same.

[@ashwinatresh4278]

My sincere advise to all hardworking and honest middle class tax payers. If you have the opportunity to leave this country, leave for a country that values and protects hard working middle class. In some of the other countries even if the taxes are high, you know you are being given your tax money's worth in terms of welfare and infrastructure provided by the state. In India, they just keep taking all the time, the taxpayer, who virtually pays tax on everything hardly gets his/her money's worth of taxes paid. e.g This bloodsucker levies GST on railway cancellations, beat that!! In effect you get taxed on the money for which you have already paid taxes (TDS)

[@cyth1054]

@@rajx7120u must be a real psycho😂😂

[@munagekar1992]

Regular Condoms 5% Strawberry non season 12% Pineapple 18% Kesar flavoured 40%...next Gst 😂😂😂😂😂

[@AnshumanPradhan-nf8mc]

Nothing can be done this country is doomed!

[@khottasikka4700]

Jai Shri ram 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Satanreincarnation-zg6sl]

@@tbraghavendran, we complain to show our importance, when we don’t have a enough brain cells to find the solutions.

[@malasardar3147]

It was already doomed since 2014

[@Satanreincarnation-zg6sl]

@@malasardar3147 , 🤠🤠🤠🤠🤠! Another follower of some religious crap.

[@str7413]

You elected clown now enjoy circus. ❤

[@K1999-2]

INR crashing GDP rate falling Taxes increasing Inflation is record high We are in Amritkaal

[@Blitzkers99]

Indian Rupees condition is so bad Infact a Beggar in US can give you donation Beggars can make upto 5k USD per month 😂 Which is currently 4-5 lakhs and soon will become somewhere 6-7 lakhs in INR Anyways it's far higher than average indian income lol

[@Noname123rr]

Not true bro

[@Noname123rr]

​@@Blitzkers99 that is nonsense bro 😂. If beggar can make 5000$ and he is still beggar then that means 5000 dollar mean nothing in usa😂

[@laharipuneeth6632]

Dollar is increasing she is busy with pop corn

[@str7413]

Soros Khangress comment 😂

[@PVivekmca]

first cream bun and now pop corn! always tasty discussion.

[@tbraghavendran]

Are you a foodie🤔

[@devilz5873]

😂😂😂😂

[@Peoplevoice09]

Plain Underwear - 5% tax Colour Underwear - 12% tax Colour+printed Underwear - 18% tax lastly citizens get torn underwear to wear ...which FM is least worried !!!

[@heavenlyxtacy]

Some months back Palki went and gave a great speech at Oxford that Indian govt is the best, now she is confused, to tell people that its still the best or the worst, but she has to somehow praise the lootera govt in every video or she will be out on the streets...

[@cuckoonut1208]

Go where the money is. Success is a hustle. Integrity is for fools, the middle class.

[@sasikumars6401]

definitely

[@sasikumars6401]

money is a human tool for transaction

[@hariprasad181]

She is calling a spade a spade... what's wrong with that?

[@Peoplevoice09]

Plain Underwear - 5% tax Colour Underwear - 12% tax Colour+printed Underwear - 18% tax lastly citizens get torn underwear to wear ...which FM is least worried !!!

[@lajji]

This government has no idea how to keep it simple. Give some rebate to income tax payers from indirect taxes...

[@SanthoshKumar-ye3sh]

She demonstrated great kindness by reducing corporate taxes in India in 2019, lowering the rate for existing companies from 30% to 22% and for new companies from 25% to 15%, primarily to benefit A & A Companies.

[@amajitbhattacharjee314]

Taxes are increasing like popcorn... In every GST meeting or budget additional tax are poping out

[@golupowering]

Next time GST on samosa 5% with tikha chatney 12% With pyaj mirchi 18% With dahi 28%

[@raghavendravishwas5929]

BJP please seriously consider continuing Mrs Nirmala Sitharaman as FM..Give it to someone who has popular mandate

[@UdhayaKumar-p6e]

Do you think Nirmala sitharaman do these things without party concern?

[@rishavsharma6875]

​@@UdhayaKumar-p6eall the bjp parties don't know anything. They only know about tax and nothing else 😂😂

[@scamexpose123]

When will they simplify the taxes?. I simply don’t understand how the regime gets confidence that people will set up businesses in India with such ridiculous tax regimes..

[@OrderoftheSilverCross-ir7ip]

Asking a bureaucrat to cut down on paperwork is like asking a alcholic to stop drinking. Not happening. They're addicted.

[@bowtomepsi6302]

wtf, even popcorn? cant have shit in india

[@ShinichiKudoQatnip]

Don't say that or else they will levy 18% for using the toilet too.

[@amaledward2147]

@@ShinichiKudoQatnipOh God, imagine paying GST for using toilet

[@tapash5868]

😂 😢 true​@@ShinichiKudoQatnip

[@purusvh]

Bro western toilet is at 18% tax😂😂😂😂

[@humanbeing6838]

Don't shit, next that will be taxed😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@raghavendravishwas5929]

What is the tax on pop corn sold by a street vendor? 😂😂

[@JaskaranSingh-rq6cr]

5 percent

[@raghavendravishwas5929]

@JaskaranSingh-rq6cr 😂

[@Peoplevoice09]

Plain Underwear - 5% tax Colour Underwear - 12% tax Colour+printed Underwear - 18% tax lastly citizens get torn underwear to wear ...which FM is least worried !!!

[@toughguy990]

Godi media will be like: this news is anti national😂😂

[@nightmist7977]

How

[@humanbeing6838]

Godi media believes popcorn is antinational😅😅😅😅 so tax it😅

[@anilmohapatra5336]

@@toughguy990 even Godi media is criticising now. Things has gone beyond limit now.

[@ashseth7885]

Common man is suffering,

[@dnbhatia85]

Idea is not working.. as no one is happy to pay GST. It Gabbar Service tax.. even after paying citizen get zero return.

[@rudra20048]

You voted for this. People prioritised a temple over the actual issues, now suffer with extreme taxation. Middle class person can’t even watch a movie without getting heavily taxed. We will just be surviving because after these taxes there’s no money left to enjoy life.

[@sampatkalyan3103]

Congress government would have been worse

[@davidprudhvi]

@@sampatkalyan3103 There needs to be change , the present condition is worsening and pathetic

[@Mannu_Maanu]

@@sampatkalyan3103congress was much better until 2014

[@sampatkalyan3103]

@@Mannu_Maanu LoL you must be living in a different planet

[@prakash525]

​@@sampatkalyan3103bruh.... you must be poor and you don't pay tax and if you are rich you may not have time for writing comments

[@MrJatindeer]

No tax on food but your channel doing insane work and never asking any questions from government

[@sadanand7105]

the biggest problem India is facing today is Appeasement in the name of Poverty and Religion...Politicians cutting across party lines to stay in power are spoiling this lot by giving freebies, subsidies, Reservations etc.,this lot produces in big numbers to further their agenda all at cost of State Exchequer...unfortunately the General Category Middle Class Hindu is having the absorb all this in the form of Taxes etc., this Category is being squeezed to the core...they do not get subsidies, Reservations etc., also, they are afraid to have children...and to boot it they are being victimized as Offenders...unfortunate reality...

[@Golu-e2k]

I used to work in a startup which produces premium quality green energy products at very affordable rates yet find it very difficult to get customer and biggest villain in story was 18% gst.. Some dont want to pay it and some believe its a scam.. Deal ended up most of time due to 18% gst and finally everything ended miserably.

[@prabakaranasokraj174]

When GST officials overstep their defined roles in Tax administration for example thinking like Income Tax officials.....this problem will continue....as long as we have poorly qualified as Mantries...

[@aldenaroza3247]

Time to change the government

[@nabinbanik9610]

Such a shame. It’s always about Masjid versus Mandir, yet uninformed people continue to vote for the BJP. Now, die-hard BJP supporters will probably show up and start lashing out, defending the questionable actions she has taken for the country. Responsible citizens don’t engage with absurd Gmail IDs; most of them are likely part of the BJP IT cell. In fact, I won’t bother responding to useless comments. If you want to comment, do so using your real ID.

[@dhanajishinde9722]

If the people who were voted also brought under the Tax bracket, then the pain can be felt.

[@User1976valid]

dont blame finance minister. its her bosses bringing all tax patterns.

[@ismailntp1785]

One nation One election one popcorn 3 taxes 😅

[@franciswj6220]

Tax Terrorism ???

[@UncannySoul-ff4co]

Minister is a face, bureaucrats are the head, working behind the curtain.

[@kesavamoorthivenugopal7624]

Same thing is raised by Annapoorna hotel owner bun with cream and without cream

[@TheMaverick_SR]

Oxygen tax for inhaling and Co2 tax for exhaling..

[@anilv3724]

Taxon air purifiers says hi (18%)

[@TheMaverick_SR]

@anilv3724 I mean that's a luxury external factor. She may tax on lungs for inhaling and exhaling

[@arichinna]

It is good to see Palki criticising the Government in an objective fashion - Old objective Palki is back I guess!

[@BookWormsOriginal]

Everything is an optimization problem in our country. And we have optimized the hell out of Popcorn. I pity it, sadly no hope in the near term

[@rohitjasrotia4303]

Where is our prime minister ??Why he don’t come out any respond to people questions ????

[@naruto_itachi433]

Leave the country if you are rich,you can live a comfortable life in countries like dubai, even it is desert you have good infrastructure and clean air 😂, if you are poor you live in the country where your finance minister thinks Middle class should not have future and options

[@dnbhatia85]

India TAX System is most worse system...british rule was simple.. Teen Guna Lagan .. But GST is 10 Guna Tax ..

[@anilv3724]

Ironic how everyone seems to have a problem with our Finance minister but not with the PM who recommended her as Rajya Sabha MP to Hon'ble President

[@pesking9975]

I thought India will beat china 😂😂😂

[@Titoo1346]

Only in population 🤡 Proud to be an indian saar

[@ZeebleBub616]

Ind. Citizens : You are without doubt the worst FM I've ever heard of. Captain Nirmala : Ah...but you have heard of me...

[@VinodYadav-nn2lj]

I have bigger problem of income tax, which regime to select? Its been few years now but confusion still exists 😮

[@EvanE-d4q]

Select old one

[@shivendrasingh4631]

To be HONEST Freebies, Caste Politics, Reservation, High Taxes probably not going away. Like it or not, talented folks leaving India is plain economics. You need to give someone a very good reason to stay-- earn way less and get taxed more for little benefits.

[@samanwaysanket12345]

So you are showcasing your hopeless and helpless attitude. You accept that now you are neither able to change the societal conditions nor the government so leave the country. Tell me honestly for exactly what percentage of our population is it a viable or feasible option??? One doesn't have money to leave his hometown and your advise is to leave the country??

[@YoutubeRajesh]

Will everyone accept if GST is 14% for every damn thing ?

[@purusvh]

Wow u wanna defend this😅😅😅wow 😂😂😂 being fan is good buddy not until it burns our hands

[@angryhusky2467]

Ideas..... Food cooked on Low flame: 5% Food cooked on High flame: 28%

[@bijinkumar6415]

Nirmala Thullamma from Bhakt Jhandu Party back at it with her LOGICALLY ILLOGICAL statements 😅😂😊❤🎉

[@timelyferry]

Palki if you could do extra reports on tax incliding mentioning state taxes it wud be great

[@HeavenOnEarth-uq5ci]

Public are so naive that they believe she is the one who imposes and raises taxes. They also overlook the fact that she reduced corporate taxes in India in 2019, lowering the rate for existing companies from 30% to 22% and for new companies from 25% to 15%, primarily to benefit A & A. Furthermore, they fail to recognize that she operates under the influence of an organized syndicate at the center.

[@MrSatadal]

They had time to discuss salted popcorn and caramelized popcorn but no time to discuss GST on insurance.

[@GurudeepSingh-k9p]

Mother in law of middle class people of India😂😂😂😂.

[@comichero853]

Modi before GST : Let's have equal tax in entire country. No tax differences. Now : Popcorn too will have different GST What a shame.. this government couldn't even control their decisions. Failing at everything. All false promises and lies.

[@dranandphd]

😢😢😢😢😢😢😢😢 Sri Nirmala Sitharaman's tax policies are getting saltier by the day...literally! First, horrible , now the popcorn tax, now I'm waiting for the day she'll tax the air we breathe. 'Inhale at 5%, exhale at 12%, and if you cough, that's 18% GST. 😭😭😭😭😭😭. People are suffering. We elected selected and we need to suffer 😞😞😞. God's wrath will be horrible. Wait watch 😭😭😭😭😢 Money money money, they need to compensate one rich family loss 😢😢😢

[@mohankumar-wj9xx]

They introduced GST to remove multiple tax rates in bill, if a person order for family different kind of popcorn then 3 different gst will be printed in bill

[@SmileHappyly]

Complicated tax on simple Popcorn. Kudos GST council for such great work 😂

[@ramjivjith]

Now its 0%....soon it will be at different GST rate normal, dotted, thin ,flavored 😂😂😂

[@RichardSaladin]

Don't fool yourself more by blaming FM, she is just following orders.

[@chubaakum2726]

Please charge extra tax to lower and middle class BJP supporters and BJP workers who voted for this government.

[@aarti7423]

Plz resign Nirmala. You are not eligible for this job. Plz put GST @1000...% on your smile. It feels like you are making fun of middle class. Increase the tax rate on MP/MLAs income. You politicians are looting the country for your own benefit. These stupid politicians want that young generation shouldn't leave India and remain here unemployed. On the other hand their children roaming around the world. These politicians even needs security for the marriage of their children. IAS/IPS etc who are more educated than these politicians have to give security to these stupid politicians who just filling their pockets with taxpayers money. MP’s / MLA’s get free telephone, air tickets, house, servants, free electricity, subsidised canteen food in government offices / state rooms, no tolls and so much more. Its more like a lottery for them. The worst part is that each and every party, whether in power or in opposition (including the socialists and communists or the Aam Aadmi Party) support such legislation for increase in emoluments every time a proposal is placed, even if they are boycotting more important matters!! #ResignNirmala

[@mrinalbandhu16]

Palki : today we are going to discuss about why gst on popcorn and educations are good for india . 😂

[@dvk4746]

Any sane FM would say packaged one rate and branded another rate. Only in india there i diff rates for salt vs sweet popcorn

[@SanthoshKumar-ye3sh]

She demonstrated great kindness by reducing corporate taxes in India in 2019, lowering the rate for existing companies from 30% to 22% and for new companies from 25% to 15%, primarily to benefit A & A Companies.

[@Samsungbrowsr]

Last week palki herself said, one international FMCG company profit was 50000crore but total employees in india just 20000, then reduced company tax also. See the kindness!!!because rulers getting commission from it!! Who will save our country from this monsters??????

[@davidprudhvi]

though the taxes on companies r decreased and the profits r increased , the wages r still low and the companies and the top executive r making advantage of it , so whats the benefit by decreasing corporate taxes , pathetic

[@samanwaysanket12345]

​@@davidprudhvi looks like you just discovered capitalism.

[@Vishal_Kaushik17]

India nowadays (if you're rich) "Oh sir there you have everything on the go. You just have to pay more." (If you're poor)"Oh, don’t worry we have free schemes for you." (If you're middleclass) "Excuse me, who the ____(beep yes you guessed it right) are you?"

[@PunjabSingh_India]

Modi ji ko 303 se 240 per laane me Nirmala ji ne bahut mehnat ki hai Nirmala ji ko sammanit krna chahiye Modi ji dwara

[@neelkanani7230]

Out of all the things going on , Popcorn was very much important topic to think upon.

[@pramilasekhar8]

May be the idea would be to cut unhealthy food consumption...

[@Boo2019-zf3gs]

If unscrupulous individuals were empowered to collect taxes, they might indeed achieve record-breaking revenue figures. However, the primary concern should not be maximizing revenue at any cost. Instead, the paramount focus must be on ensuring the simplicity, sustainability and ethical integrity of the tax collection process.

[@SipTimes]

The fact that Palki is defending GST and arguing for its superiority is not making anyone lose their minds.

[@munagekar1992]

I am ok if they wish to charge taxes via Gst, but there has to be a cut down on income tax. Absolutely no tax on our income , instead govt sectors and government authorities should be made accountable for every penny spent and every road with pot hole in it.

[@mlg1279]

Potholes are the responsibility of municipalities and corporation - not the central government

[@MrBradMishra]

When GST was about to be introduced in India, PM Modi Ji sent a delegation of Finance Ministers of all states and territories to Australia to learn how they implemented it and know more about the new tax system. I was there at Sydney at the time and interacted with some of the ministers too. Australia's GST implementation is the best in the world for 2 reasons. 1) nothing is excluded from GST and, 2) there is only one flat rate of 10% on all goods and services. Alas, we learnt nothing...

[@hariprasad181]

😅😅 give more freebies and tax the citizens 😢😢 Karnataka already bankrupt with congress and now BJP is trying to give freebies and tax common man? Stop this please

[@athakhinawn9162]

If arogance and greediness is tax, madamji will go beyond bankrupt.

[@emperorheartbk]

Congress first sign after becoming Prime minister should be 5% gst for all goods all across India. Announce this, and congress will come to power without campaign..

[@mlg1279]

First, CONgress is not coming to power. Second, CONgress is the one that introduced VAT, and GST. Also, with corruption, CONgress would probably increase taxes more than BJP

[@BraddysReagent]

@@mlg1279 teri kyo jali ?

[@rajeevjayaram4981]

Looks tax in india is becoming the most foolish system in the whole universe. Tax is killing common man

[@sakshambhadoria9998]

GST was meant to simplify tax regime. Ironically, it led to confusion and bureaucratic complexity. Its haphazard and hasty implementation was met with resistance and backlash from small and medium businesses. Moreover, it snatched power from the state governments to raise their own revenue through taxes and left them at the mercy of central government for funds frequently subjecting them to political blackmail and harrasment. Federalism is also a casualty apart from economic shock and compliance burden.

[@abubakersiddique7597]

Thanks Nirmala madam.Every indians happy about your Gst plan😂😂😂

[@p-k98]

Yes, popcorn is a very important issue, so much so to be broadcasted the news about.

[@rizam781]

I like this lady She a very kind to big companies cos now its far easier to manipulate tax reports.

[@vivekgamedev]

It's a sad reality that when we have more pressing issues, our governments' primary focus is on taxing popcorn. Bloody popcorn is the least of our concerns at the moment. My heart aches to see this.🤬🤬

[@ninjahattori7576]

Finance minister? ❌❌ TAX MANTRI ✅✅✅

[@Bala-zw1lk]

Incompetent government which sucks money from people in the name of taxation.

[@prashanthj807]

Want modi to comment on this like an opposition leader he would have killed it😂😂😂

[@Handlebar360]

It's not because we have a federal structure that requires a different slabs.. the central govt wants to make as much money as possible on natively consumed items like coconut example for kerala, paratha and chapati in north..

[@coolvinder]

How many crores more will the GST on popcorn get for the government?