Flatout Ultimate Carnage vs Flatout 4 Graphics Evolution Comparison

Check out this video comparison between good old Flatout Ultimate Carnage and Flatout 4 Total Insanity. How much the graphics and other elements improved since the LAST great Flatout game. Levels comparison, stunts, car engine sounds and overall graphics.
Ultimate Carnage is basically a Flatout 2 remake for the Xbox 360 with improved graphics with a more realistic tone compared to Flatout 2.
FT:UC first then Flatout 4.
#FlatoutUltimateCarnage #FlatoutComparison #Flatout4

[@Z3PHYR-]

No bugbear = no flatout No need to argue

[@redotix9999]

agree noone can make flatout as good as bugbear maybe comunity patches will make flatout 4 good but you are better of with some visual mods for carnage to have a next gen good game

[@PCGamingVideos]

It's a shame they sold the IP.

[@redotix9999]

well we cant really do anything about it but since glatout joint was shut down I get bored really fast in the game I wish I cloud still find mods for this game

[@xS4RK1Sx]

CajabaRoller amen.

[@aidansky55]

Hay I am a bear!!! :D

[@vyirafael1417]

Flatout 1: Nostalgic Flatout 2: Iconic Flatout UC: Good 'remaster' Flatout 4: who

[@zabudb]

Flatout 3 : best game

[@koriyagay]

@@zabudb easily one of the best games ever made

[@malenix726]

Flatout 3: worst

[@gin4339]

Około miesiąca temu

[@Hiroh1toXD]

Flatout 3: $#/t

[@TheMichaelVier]

Bugbear Entertainment makes the diference.. Flatout 4 is like a toy cars =|

[@sendhysaputra1464]

But they look like Hot Wheels cars a bit.

[@makobnuy1152]

Sendhy Saputra ya

[@olahangela383]

Nope

[@Jgspeedshop]

The point of flat out is fun

[@blakecooper669]

thats the one that wasn't the one that one was chaos and destruction made by team 6

[@subsandnovideos-uo2jn]

0:17 the sound of my childhood

[@fizzisoda7113]

Is it me, or has video game physics gotten worse over the years? It's like developers focus more on graphics than physics.

[@thattonnatoguywithafez8246]

Ask Ferrari that

[@SemBarner22]

@@thattonnatoguywithafez8246 I hope Ferrari in F1? Coming from 2020 Spa race :D

[@rubenb6433]

Obviamente haran eso, es como el gta v, tiene mejor grafico pero peores fisicas que el gta iv

[@alessio4346]

Not the same developers anymore

[@fizzisoda7113]

@@alessio4346 I'm talking about video games in general.

[@AlexMrShot]

I will never understand the people who voted for FO4

[@talvisota327]

17 years is a kid lol

[@Rxfzwashere]

DoubleBubble28 you are really fucking stupid huh

[@Comuzzy]

DoubleBubble28 no nigga you're stupid like overall.

[@federicoarieldominguez104]

DoubleBubble28 You didn't gave us a solid argument.

[@federicoarieldominguez104]

Пётр Чайкус Yeah, even the physics are better in Flatout 2-UCR.

[@Ajdolo2]

UC made you feel like you were actually there, breaking shit, tearing limbs apart, 😅had that adrenaline feel to it.

[@AlexMrShot]

Al Jean Probably because of the physics

[@beanshady]

"Fuelllllled by Adrenalinnnnnnne!" .. damn I loved that song!

[@blakecooper669]

just for that i might see if any gamestop has it

[@ralcolfwolfcoon8207]

Old comment, old channel, but same person. I have the game now and it's a blast!

[@xS4RK1Sx]

Ultimate Carnage to me was a much more polished game. It was truly a destruction derby racer. Every action had consequences. The AI were also so much better, more distinguished and added a sense of rivalry that Total Insanity failed to execute. For instance, whenever you saw Jack Benton or Sofia Martinez coming behind you in her Canyon, you sometimes actually had to get out of their way. They actually had a unique driving style. Where as Ray Carter was no way near as much as a threat, more of a punching bag. The AI were even distinguishable on the radar; Sally Taylor was pink, Jason Walker black, Katie Jackson red etc. They really hit the nail on the head. Flatout 4 to me isn't a destruction derby racer, it feels very clunky at time, which makes it so much less addictive to play. Sooooo much more potential, but definitely fell short in most areas. I hope they remaster UC one day 👌

[@stellanpage6766]

Is it bad that I still can remember every ai name, car they drove in most classes, the colour and how good they were aha

[@ninjapotatoe9230]

Flexodus omg so true abuout ray carter😂 I always see him getting into a huge wipeout once the race starts lmao

[@AR3Q]

Flexodus It would be hard to remaster a game, that is already remaseration of Flatout 2

[@psychosode]

Arkadiusz Kielar It doesn't even need a remaster. Just make it playable for current gen consoles

[@Hasdy]

So true

[@alex98241]

flat-out uc graphics are insane when you think about how long ago it was made! the game has better graphics then a lot of games now and has so much more detail its crazy

[@prodbyrhimm16]

FlatOut UC = FlatOut2 Remastered

[@cloke3076]

FO2: Daniel FOUC: The cooler Daniel

[@father042]

Except with worse music

[@Nirwanaa]

No shit sherlock, that's literally what it is

[@poirierdoufc4928]

Yeah

[@arvydasjancys9862]

@@father042 with better music in my opinion to each they're own

[@Nachy]

Looks like Flatout 4 has some better technical graphics and advancements such as shading and lighting, but how it's used and portrayed in an artistic direction with Flatout Ultimate Carnage looks and sounds overall better.

[@marcelocardoso7686]

Horrible physic in Flatout 4

[@crimson1718]

Flatout 4 looks like a cartoon, it doesn't have the Flatout charm. UC has these raw and apocalyptic feel that 3 and 4 don't have.

[@Voytash89]

H8 R3D - your comment is really funny if you think about it. Why? If you remember the old times when UC came out, people were bashing it for this low saturated colours in comparison to FlatOut 2. And now, a few years later you make that argument. LOL.

[@blakecooper669]

uh thats flatout 3

[@Spear98CZ]

2007 Flatot Ultimate Carnage 2017 Flatout 4 UC WIN

[@SampleT3xT_]

Borecfo2 CZ yep

[@TriNhanDzaDza]

But flatout 1 is lost

[@skye4252]

The next was Wreckfest but..is not the same :c

[@blackswan74]

Uc better

[@blackswan74]

The winner of all all all racing games is a mobile game called real racing 3

[@henriquetriaca245]

Even though Ultimate Carnage is a decade old, it's hard to make a better game than it, the game is good in every aspect

[@NameName-ju8il]

No Bugbear = No Flatout Flatout 1-UC forever

[@mert3761]

flatout1 the best

[@fck-_-maw_l-l7044]

Flatout 2 xd

[@HujoGaming]

Fck-_-Maw_l-l he is noob

[@blackswan74]

1 is trash

[@ralcolfwolfcoon8207]

Oh please kid

[@Ignas359]

Honestly it looks like there's a lot that they replicated well enough.. except the sense of speed or the feel like you actually crashed into something. Which are unfortunately the two main things. I also feel like the car selection is mostly uninteresting. The majority seem wacky for the sake of being wacky. Kind of like what you'd find in Carmageddon and I'm not sure if it really works here. Earlier titles seemed more grounded in reality with the separate classes of wreckers, rally cars and the street class, all three having their own pros and cons and different styles. In the end it feels just that, a replica that isn't even up to par with the 10 year old game. They'd have been better off just spending the resources on getting Ultimate Carnage on Steam with proper multiplayer.

[@jammygamer8961]

and fix its crash on start up because of it lacking a file

[@xX_Stunttailija_Xx]

@@jammygamer8961 idk but i got it to start properly

[@alexsa122]

I think that a remake of Ultimate Carnage with better graphics and physics will be better than the "new flatout 4"

[@cheesebusiness]

Just a rereleasing on the modern consoles will be better

[@thattonnatoguywithafez8246]

UC is alredy a remake lol

[@vouk9349]

alexsa122 so you want a remake of a remake

[@No-jt5nf]

@@vouk9349 Better: a remake of a remake of a remake of a sequel.

[@henry3417]

LOL, UC always will be the best part in this series. 4'th part is like new ME: Andromeda. No comments.

[@WickedParanoid]

Still not as bad as *ugh* Chaos and Destruction though.

[@aperson6374]

@@WickedParanoid agreed that game was awful

[@antonismathioudakis3791]

Have you ever played Flatout 3?

[@lenneth878]

The only thing is better in Flatout 4 is graphics. But Ultimate Carnage looks (and sounds) so much better overall. P.S. That engine sound in Flatout 4 is annoying as hell.

[@herryrico5741]

Kalivan the graphics are shit for a 2017 game and not much better that ultimate carnage

[@bloodbtf8708]

ikr that tow truck sounds like a fart canon honda civic

[@cheesebusiness]

Look at the water reflections in FO4 (the water doesn’t reflect everything)

[@AlryFireBlade]

Really? to me Flatout 4 looks worse then UC. UC is so much more polished.

[@BigBoss-uv6zb]

@@AlryFireBlade +

[@cheesebusiness]

FlatOut Ultimate Carnage is the best racing game ever

[@Kovalski_15]

And FlatOut 2 too

[@grzywa7401]

@@Kovalski_15 FlatOut 2 id awesome !

[@alessgr9394]

Flatout 2 is harder in terms of damage UC has more realistic driving physics

[@martilances]

Best flatout game is flatout2

[@noice6421]

no, but flatout 2 is.

[@Sir-Prizse]

I am a huge FlatOut Fan, played the 1st, 2cd game and Ultimate Carnage a long time, was a littel bit disappointed that Ultimate Carnage is only a Remastered FlatOut 2 with maybe 5 new cars and nicer graphics, but thats great 3 games from Bugbear.

[@deathmachine7777]

I’ll never forget ultimate carnage’s oof noise 🤣

[@samtunley8325]

still better engine sounds than gran turismo

[@RetroTheMinecrafter]

Gran Turismo Sport improved

[@TomeeDee86]

ah yeah, sounds at all... UC has better sounds as FO4 also!

[@mauronavarro3209]

or dirt 2😁

[@tharindurajakaruna1590]

@Sam Tunley Do you even have a PS?

[@hayatmir1989]

Must be smoking

[@riasgremory6971]

Honestly, I think both games are enjoyable in their own right. Besides, at least they're better than Flatout 3: Chaos & Destruction...

[@riasgremory6971]

+Class Atlas Yeah, that's true. Which is kind of a downside when compared to the amount of cars from Flatout 2 (not including mods) and Ultimate Carnage.

[@thattonnatoguywithafez8246]

well its just like 6 cars lower than flat out 2

[@Hazard1007]

Rias Gremory I know that this is an EXTREMELY unpopular opinion, but Flatout 4 is actually my favourite Flatout game.

[@riasgremory6971]

+Hazard 1007 I can see why. It's a pretty decent game in its own right.

[@unanec]

Rias Gremory it's impossible do another flatout as bad

[@matthew6649]

0:55 = original "oof"

[@The_Mucho]

Flatout 4 dont have physics.....Flatout Ultimate Carnage WIN!!

[@CodyDBuni]

Flatout UC: Better detail, physics, attention to detail and damage model. Despite being a rehash of 2 with some extra content. Flatout 4: Better lighting, new cars to drive despite looking like plastic, soundtrack par with UC but inferior to 1 and 2, more vegetation to some levels despite others look bland even by 2010s standards. Definitely going with Ultimate Carnage anyway.

[@PoisoningShadow671]

Man, gotta love those ragdoll contests, it was fun doing it in the first flatout game.

[@7Andy77]

FO2 is the best. UC is nearly as good as FO2. Microsoft managed to screw it up a little (forcing ppl to create accounts, music a bit worse, but still good and some other minor stuff). FO4 looks bad, if we take into consideration that its 2017 game. No physics. No visual damages. Cars look like toys.

[@AR3Q]

7Andy77 If it wasn't for the Game for Microsoft Live, it would be my favourite game. Now it's Most Wanted 2005

[@CommanderTato]

Wreckfest is the true Flatout 3

[@Oscar97o]

It's the true FlatOut 2

[@dreamer7960]

FlatOut is the real FlatOut. FlatOut 2 is the real FlatOut 2. FlatOut UC is the real FlatOut 3. Wreckfest is the real FlatOut 4. Chaos and Destruction - no, just no. Total Insanity - Very enjoyable, good but... Wreckfest is better :)

[@crimson1718]

Honestly wreckfest reminds me a lot of flatout 1, if you played it. It's less arcade than flatout 2 and UC.

[@No-jt5nf]

@@dreamer7960 Chaos and Destruction is the Spin-Off nobody likes.

[@PlaceboZypresse]

I hate FlatOut 4's character designs. They're so freaking cheesy. The bad kind of cheesy.

[@Tofu501st]

Also all of them are just the same male and female character but with different colored hair and accessories

[@dalenapham5904]

Awesome video! Love it :D

[@mechabroski9993]

I think flatout ultimate carnage is just so much more of a sensory overload, it sounds and looks so much better.

[@Dejroslaw2448]

NO YOU IDIOT COMPARE IT TO THE FIRST AND SECOND FLATOUT AND YOU WILL SEE WHAT DOWNGRADE THIS IS

[@gustavocruzlima119]

Every time they try to create a better version of Ultimate Carnage they end up messing the game, although the graphics are better, the physics, sound, water and even the character names are worse. Please, don't mess more with it

[@gustavocruzlima119]

***** And on FO UC they look more realistic, it's possible to see the effort on creating characters

[@lumia_dayZ]

flatout 4 was not made by the real flatout devs thats the reason

[@pokenoobmx3445]

i'm the only one that found satisfying the sound of the dirt on flatout 2 and uc when you were at high speed? it was dope af

[@engineerbeta1515]

Forget comparison , this guy is good at the stunts!

[@AlryFireBlade]

1:55 Is that Ditching Sound an out of season april fools joke? xD

[@DanT-dh8lz]

Holy shit that tiny splash sound is so awful it mademe laugh

[@1203fild]

FlatOut 1 is also awesome, i still play it today

[@adupswillbeback3390]

flatout 2 best graphics

[@flexman9225]

Yeeeee

[@MisterryFox]

Flat out ultimate carnage is flat out 2 with better graphics

[@drmullings2425]

Yesd

[@CymenTheLegend138]

Memories are coming back...

[@user-yl8vy1mr8w]

My god... The Flatout Carnage... I remember me playing that game in my PS2... Good times...

[@zephiroth113]

Ultimate Carnage is not on ps2 and neither in the ps3, it's only avaliable on the xbox 360 and pc

[@ralcolfwolfcoon8207]

Uc?!

[@joseelcrack7446]

Good video👍

[@jean-marcrocher1463]

FO4 looks and sounds nice, but honestly doesn't seem like a huge step up from UC, considering UC came out 10 years ago. One new feature I'd want is better cinematic control, such as watching replays from another car's POV (or a separate POV altogether). Does FO4 offer that?

[@xzocker9247]

Bugbear could made a lot of money and continue with the amazing Flatout series insted of making a new title but yeah sadly not so many people know the OLD flatouts 1-uc

[@cuttieelfiemusic6036]

FO UC had such and iconic drivers!

[@marcelocardoso7686]

Flatout Ultimate Carnage >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> flatout 4

[@alperen194]

Im glad that we have Wreckfest now

[@notKix]

You Should do Car collision comparison it was very funny from flatout 2 :D, Bugbear is professional at car collision (and physics) that's why flatout 2 is funny

[@thattonnatoguywithafez8246]

Meh replaying 2 right now its not impressive at all Just looking at GTA IV's damage model makes Flatout 2 look like NES for me

[@trievoluzione8868]

@@thattonnatoguywithafez8246 tell me when does gta have a better damage model than flatout? sure flatout is not on the beamng level but it completely destroys any gta game!

[@isidrogarcia8048]

@@thattonnatoguywithafez8246 as soon as you as you said gta and damage in the same sentence you lost credibility

[@thattonnatoguywithafez8246]

@@isidrogarcia8048 So aperently Flatout 2 has miles better damage, than GTA IV, not any GTA, GTA IV. Made pretty much to show off what they can do with Euphoria, i don't even have to show videos or anything that is true, GTA IV just nails flatout games to the head.

[@isidrogarcia8048]

@@thattonnatoguywithafez8246 yes. Gta 4, fuck it, even gta 5 have significantly worse physical damage appearance than flat out 2. The cars in gta don't break, they don't get dent. They just look like tampered tinfoil.

[@flake1139]

I love flatout 2, its my childhood

[@chrischupp9760]

Looks fantastic

[@kent_lolz6023]

A Ultimate Carnage, and Total Insanity, it was a really good games.

[@AlryFireBlade]

1:20 Were is the little Ramp on the way, where is the water?

[@IKSIEntertainment]

Gosh it's been a year and i still playing FlatOut 2 & Ultimate Carnage, its funny bcs you can remember all of the racers Frank Malcov (Blue) Sofia Martinez (Silver) Kattie Jackson (Red) Sally Taylor (Pink) Jack Benton (Yellow) Jason Walker (Black) Ray Carter (Sky Blue) Lei Bing (Dark Red) Lewis Duran (Brown) Jill Richard (Purple) Curtis Wolves (Dark Black) 🤣😜

[@Hasdy]

1:57 the water 'splashing' sounds like some idiot throwing rocks at water

[@AR3Q]

Things I don't like about new one: -Tracks kinda feel unnatural -Selection of cars is pretty low and boring -Vehicles feel too hard and heavy for me (maybe it was supposed to be realistic game?) -Characters are blank and dull, without real names and good models -I don't know about soundtrack cause I play with my own music, but I bet nothing can pump up your adrenaline and lust for crashing like UC soundtrack. Things I like: -You can feel momentum of the game really well -They recreated arcade mini games really well -Sounds of the cars can compare to other modern racing games -Tuning options in his game feel very advanced compared to older ones "Upgrade Stats up to 3 times of a part" based on the Car class you are

[@franciscoruiz5586]

After bugbear gave the rights to another developer the game lost its identity because the identity of the flatout saga is a driving game with physics that try to be as realistic as possible rewarding the aggressive driving but when the flatout went chaos and destruction with a different theme now more arcade with a lot of game modes that are similar and that do not work because of bad physics combined with bad graphics that made the community angry and now with the release of this new release I can not say it is good but it's not bad either, it's a middle point although the game lacks personality with those gothic characters as if it were twisted metal those vehicles destroyed as if they were abandoned cars and the lack of good physics because they seem like shit just to see how the rider reacts the acrobatics of bouncing in the water and of reaching as high as possible shows how ugly they are without mentioning how boring they are e are the models of the cars and they are all the same, there are no more but they are the same but restored and modified in the different classes

[@felipecosta4666]

0:17 OOF

[@Spanky8402]

I like the first game the best for racing. Every game after feels more like your floating on the ground and you only get car motion and suspension movements on bigger bumps. I still love all the games, but after replaying all the games on steam, the first game is my favorite. I used to really love ultimate carnage, until I replayed the games. I yet to get the 4th game though.

[@FrAndroidd]

Flatout 4: Better shadows Flatout UC: Better

[@feyt8009]

XD that yellow truck in FO4 sounds like a riced fart can Civic!

[@ThallesNinja]

Flatout UC can look pretty modern with the right ENB.

[@official_nadroj7779]

This game was wild on PS2

[@vjollila96]

I hope thq Nordic buys the flatout IP back so bugbear could get their hand on the series again

[@B4RC0D3_YT]

The way I see, Ultimate Carnage shares the similarities of the physics and gameplay with Flatout 2.

[@zephiroth113]

Beacuse its the same game just with 2 new cars (Bonecracker and Grinder), 4 new characters (Curtis Wolfe, Lei Bing, Lewis Duan and Jill Richars), different soundtrack its and made for next gen consoles of that time

[@scare8183]

That nitro effect tho.. xddd if u are playing with oculus, u might think u are on the millenium falcon

[@lagartopunkarra]

I know that FlatOut 4 isn't as good as the ones made by Bugbear, but I think that it's not a bad game, it's fun to play. However, if you want the closest FlatOut experience in a modern system, try Wreckfest, Bugbear did a great job with that game.

[@Victor_2000s]

Flatout 4 looks less worse than Flatout 3.

[@lordass9245]

Yeah 4 is a pretty decent game but it's just not a good flatout

[@DreamerDanielsun]

I gotta say, the Derby stages in Flatout 4 looks a lot more interesting. Now if only they had the physics to work with them.

[@justrandom5012]

i mean you just have to hear to the soundeffects so a BIG Difference

[@amaulana090]

The Bugbear Flatouts were rather impressive games technologically

[@energymillion5321]

I feel like physics is more important than looking at the graphics because it was literally supposed to be a racing destructive physics engine that turned into a normal racing game with garbage controls and the same damage models you'd see in Forza. Aka, FO4 is literally Forza, but made by a B grade team.

[@Austriaa]

r.i.p FlatOut series

[@Victor_2000s]

He died after flatout ultimate carnage.

[@Freedomlander_101]

FlatOut 2 is the best one to this day and i still playing it

[@ralcolfwolfcoon8207]

UC plays the same dude. Seriously underated

[@DarkSignal59]

there's a flatout 4? and it's from last year? how the hell did i not hear about it? my first two pc games were the first flatout and nfs underground 2. loved them so much. flatout 2 was great too. so how's 4? is it any good?

[@bendo3]

Flatout Ultimate Carnage is the best looking 2000's game, and you will not change my mind EVER!!

[@straax1184]

Why does the engine sound way distorted in UC than Flatout 1 and 2?

[@estacaotech]

If they at least had used the same characters from last games with their own story and personality maybe it could have been better.

[@TrudnyXd]

Flatout 2, best game ever :D

[@S4FG]

i remember this game

[@CaptPatrick01]

The moment gaming left predefined damage models behind a decade ago, we STILL haven't figured out how to get hoods to deform properly without using soft-body physics...

[@daaalmiro]

it feels like twisted metal from the ps1

[@withemuss8715]

daaalmiro that game gives me nostalgia

[@pedesettrik]

grats

[@hansmitdergans7879]

FlatOut Ultimate Carnage is like a graphics update for FlatOut 2

[@Victor_2000s]

Because its a remaster.

[@AllFather97]

do tf2 all weapons if u can btw love your videos

[@thelizardking3807]

I was hoping flat out 4 was new

[@blakecooper669]

flatout ultimate carnage has the same exact cars from flatout 2 but improved some features

[@dolewkaoleju]

FlatOut Ultimate Carnage

[@Sonkoo]

I Love flatout 2 and UC

[@No-vq1iv]

Might've evolved visually but otherwise it's a step back in literally every way.

[@ralcolfwolfcoon8207]

What is?

[@No-vq1iv]

Flatout 4? 🤦‍♂

[@nathanlester9985]

1:51 "Doik" 🤣

[@FevonTV]

cars in flatout 4 sound like RC boats XDDD

[@kastle3322]

FO4 took tha same approach as another game that goes by the same initials, the "less is more" approach.

[@Rohit.Gaikwad]

Trail Out : Hey All 👋

[@megajuanph11]

Flatout have good shadows, tesselation and texturing. (And I like most the engine sounds) but I really dislike the Grabcad stock character images

[@coccoborg]

Flatout UC kinda looks warmer/better

[@jaffarjames4520]

Flat out Carnage is crazy men

[@HeavyWeapon44]

👍

[@gulin9640]

Nothing can beat FlatOut 2

[@dvdbox360]

this game and black have really good graphic

[@d.pr0digy532]

It's like turning Black Ops 2 into Black Ops 4. That is, through the ass

[@Non_Stop_1]

Flatot Ultimate Carnage - VICTORY 100% !!!

[@the_true_moe6715]

come on, these people tried and it is really good. im pretty sure if the cars had more damage people wouldn't complain. Hay at least it wasn't as bad as the sonic series?

[@lucianolst-ux2kb]

Flatout ultimate carnage win *!!!