Floor Execution Breakdown 5 - Morgan Hurd 2019 | Gymnastics Scoring

[@bagelized]

Bruh the leap deductions are SCARY. They come and go like flies. The 0.3 deductions make my heart drop.

[@FlipFlyTumble]

for sure!! i'm glad nowadays we are seeing less chucking of difficult leaps that are done poorly

[@MademoiselleNuna]

Great video! Slow motion at the end really helps with catching the details

[@FlipFlyTumble]

thank you im glad it helps :)

[@MademoiselleNuna]

@@FlipFlyTumble you put a lot of thought and effort in those videos :) I always get excited when I see a notification

[@hannibaljustincase9985]

the quality of your videos is impeccable!

[@FlipFlyTumble]

thank you so much :)

[@smooflarkin]

I love these videos! And just a side note, Morgan has some of the best choreography in the game. I can't imagine how hard it is to keep up artistry while focusing on super hard tumbling with all these deductions just waiting to happen.

[@rezmy10488]

i hope we get to see another American gymnast as expressive and artistic as Morgan :')

[@agent606]

I love the slow mo!! You really have upgraded the editing. This is my favorite gymnastics channel next to sporteverywhere.

[@gn1275]

Wow another amazing video and editing!! So informative! Will be cool though to see Simone's floor execution breakdown (especially her 2019 TF flawless FX).

[@anikokoren3417]

she is so clean! she must go to Tokyo

[@ragansmithgymnastics7782]

Thank you for this video! I do think that the arm position for aesthetic on the switch full/gogean was a bit picky though.

[@FlipFlyTumble]

thanks for watching :) arms are important in leaps too! while it is a bit subjective, the WTC emphasise not to ignore the arms

[@mrparts]

@@FlipFlyTumble you’re a ruthless judge,,, the way it should be 😅😎. No mercy.

[@FlipFlyTumble]

@@mrparts haha yes gotta be fair 😅

[@hannadewaal5047]

Please do more of these! So helpful

[@armandoleopoldino6015]

Your videos have even improved! Like if that was even possible, because they were already great. Keep doing them, please!

[@FlipFlyTumble]

thank you it means so much! I will be making more ^_^

[@Nadaldrolone]

That was brilliant! Do the coaches get a similar breakdown from the judges, so they know what the problem areas/skills are?

[@FlipFlyTumble]

I dont think they formally get advice/'receipts' from judges at competitions but usually judges from their own country will give advice on routine construction and problematic skills

[@Smielyb2000]

@@FlipFlyTumble So what you saying is John most likely was told about Jo's beam and choose to ignore it?

[@FlipFlyTumble]

@@Smielyb2000 hmm I'm not too sure how that went down. There must have been some miscommunication there or maybe the US judges thought there was no problem. Unfortunately this still continues these days like with Kara Eaker's ring fiasco

[@PhenixJoe]

It’s almost weird to me that there is an expectation that they point their toes on double tucks and double pikes.

[@huberttan007]

😍Yess she has no artistry deductions. I’m glad she took out the Ferrari now. Can you do Qi Qi’s 2020 Chinese nationals AA floor?

[@triplefull7057]

I am sorry where was the complex Choreo again. The 2018 routine had it in the end where was it here

[@FlipFlyTumble]

0:58 and 1:31 imo

[@FlipFlyTumble]

the way i decide is i ask myself 'could i get up and do this now in one try?'

[@triplefull7057]

@@FlipFlyTumbleThat a good way to decide

[@yonaeden6688]

Can someone help me understand the difference between lack of landing precision and lack of balance deductions? To me they seem to mean the same thing, but I assume the code makes a distinction? Thank you! And thanks so much for these videos, I'm learning so much!

[@FlipFlyTumble]

Thanks for watching I'm glad it helps :)) precision is for under or over turned dance elements (leaps, jumps, turns) and lack of balance is basically landing deductions for dance elements like extra steps, hops or wobbles or being off balance on a turn.

[@MossyBallerina]

I love seeing the breakdown of all the little details! I wish the judging wasn't quite so harsh, though. It seems like it's pretty much impossible to get abot the 8.5-8.7 E score range. If no one, even the best gymnasts in the world, can get less than a point in deductions (excluding vault, since that's a bit different), it seems to me like the judging is overly harsh. Also, I'm curious: back in the days of perfect 10s, how was execution judged? Since people were able to ger 10.0 scores, in addition to not having a separate D score, the E score must have been judged less harshly.

[@mrparts]

judging needs to be very harsh, so the the truly virtuous gymnasts get rewarded.

[@MossyBallerina]

@@mrparts If such gymnasts actually existed, then I would agree, but no one has E scores in the 9.0+ range anymore. Looking at the 2023 Worlds, the highest E scores on each event (excluding vault, since that always has higher E scores) were 8.466 for uneven bars, 8.3 for balance beam and 8.4 for floor. When the best gymnasts in the world are getting more than a point andd a half in deductions, it just seems silly to have such harsh judging. What's the point of having the E score judged out of 10 when literally no one achieves anything close to that?

[@mrparts]

@@MossyBallerina the 10 scale is a completely arbitrary number chosen just for simplicity. It could have been 20, or a 100. What matters for the scoring system is the correct ranking of athletes. You could decrease the deductions to 0.01 for each small error to create the illusion that the best gymnasts are now scoring 9.90+ in execution, so close to perfection, , but the routines are exactly the same, nowhere near “perfection”.

[@lucymichel9409]

True question on the Silivas : I would have guessed .3 for chest position, would it be fair or really too harsh ?

[@FlipFlyTumble]

0.3 is for when the head is at the knees/ankles so it would probably be too harsh for this landing

[@GymCentric]

can you do jordan chiles 2019 floor ?

[@calculusfan1]

"Missing movement touching floor" is that the reason that every gymnast rolls around on the floor at some point? I think the only gymnast I can't recall do that is Lilia Podkopeyva, so how did she get exempt? Were the rules different then?

[@bluepanther1013]

The rules were different.

[@asherraymond4430]

Cleaning up the landings and making sure she gets the feet pointed in the tumbling would bring her execution up to only around 1.0 in deductions ALONE, and those are easy fixes! She could totally put up a number on the floor in Tokyo.

[@mrparts]

Flexed feet in acrobatic skills is very very hard to fix this late in the game. At this late stage, most benefit to scoring is avoid landing short ( and preventing injury,)

[@FlipFlyTumble]

@@mrparts yeah it is hard to focus on pointing your toes in hard tumbles. not many can do it.

[@FlipFlyTumble]

i feel like it's almost impossible to get under 1.0 in deductions because landings are so unpredictable and minor deductions add up as well. anything in the 8.5+ area would already be amazing !

[@mustawgym]

Haha sorry but no, a 8.5 execution is already GREAT, her MAX E score is about that range. No way she should have or will have 8.7+ on Execution!!!

[@honeyfromthebee]

Just 0.1 for the step on her front tumbling pass is, I feel, giving her the benefit of the doubt. The camera angle works to her benefit here because she's in the distance and her step is moving away from us on the diagonal, so in reality it might be 0.3...

[@qiancaotang]

I didn't know that for simple jump the deduction can be so big.

[@johnluuee]

They are so picky on every single skill.

[@z.a.4801]

These deductions seems super fair to me but did she really get a 7.3 E-score on that routine? Somehow doubt that. Edit: Nah she got more then a point above that. If judges judged like you did maybe gymnast would go for cleaner and more artistic executions...

[@bluepanther1013]

Flip Fly Tumble didn't give Morgan a 7.3 e score.

[@mustawgym]

I’d take 0.1 on the leap before the final pass and 0.1 in artistry!!!

[@anikokoren3417]

Just curious: what part of the artistry panel is lacking in your opinion? I would say morgan's artistry is perfect

[@mustawgym]

Well, failure to engage audience. I could say also lack complex movements, being pretty strict. Morgan’s artistry is GREAT, really great. BUT is NOT perfect, as u said. Her 2019 routine has no less than 0.1deduction on that category.

[@argoneonoble]

What happened to this girl? She disappeared.

[@FlipFlyTumble]

She was battling elbow problems and was still recovering from surgery during the Classics/Championships period. Unfortunately she didn't make Olympic Trials. We will see her in NCAA and the post-Olympic tour (and hopefully 2021 worlds)