“Fluttershy’s Music Box” - MLP Grimdark Song [Silent Ponyville 2]

A Melancholy Music Box...
This song is based of SamRose's MLP fanfiction, Silent Ponyville 2
• Silent Ponyville 2 (Re...
----
Vocals and lyrics by Magpiepony
/ magpiepony
Artwork by UrbanQhoul
/ urbanqhoul
/ urbanqhoul
/ stsoulfur
Instrumental by Myuu
• Promise ~Reprise~ (Pia...
/ myuuji
Audio Editing by Magpiepony and PegasusPitchVA
/ shadowpony12
Video Editing: TheLostNarrator
Support me on Patreon and get some awesome rewards!
/ thelostnarrator
Follow me on Twitter!
/ thelostnarrator

[@Magpiepony]

This was so much fun to write and bring to life ^.^ I hope I did the character and story proud!

[@MalakEzzo]

Hi mag

[@parthxus]

You did insanely well! I love this song one my fav piano pieces from Myuu

[@BeesMeliss]

You also made the viewers proud. All of you! ^^

[@kiryugaming9424]

U fucking killed it!!

[@Dog-Girl-Defect]

You did

[@ScribblerProductions101]

Hearing this one on preview genuinely made me go back and relisten to SP2. Hauntingly beautiful singing.

[@MalakEzzo]

Hi scribbler!

[@jayfether167]

Same!!!!

[@LeviAckerman-ni6wh]

Agreed

[@Trish707]

scribbler

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

@@Trish707 This totally sounds like Fluttershy

[@NyxMoonTV]

Just finished listening to "Forever Lost" this is still breathtaking.

[@MalakEzzo]

Hi Evan ze geek va

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

@@MalakEzzo Fluttershy's voice sounds just like her.

[@adenentertainment7365]

THEORY: the radio that we hear at the end of each vid is tuning to a different signal meaning that we will have more songs on the way

[@galaxygamer1269]

What you mean?

[@adenentertainment7365]

@@galaxygamer1269 what I mean is that we will have Moar music video

[@vilmavenla]

it would be interesting that this all connected...

[@zerumsiru5204]

The radio flaring to life with static at the end put me on edge after I had just gotten relaxed due to the music. Somehow something so haunting put my mind at ease, then the static ripped me back into reality. Beautiful song.

[@MaybornePastimes]

This is hauntingly beautiful. The reverb makes her seem so far away, yet so near. The lifted air frequencies also lets it give the song a much more "airy" and haunting feeling. It definitely gave me goosebumps!

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

Mayborne's Yeah and it sounds like Fluttershy too.

[@nocturnalvessel2241]

With fluttershy's voice this song is both soft and sinister, IT PERFECT 👍

[@nocturnalvessel2241]

@@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376 agreed

[@nocturnalvessel2241]

@@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376 yeah

[@nocturnalvessel2241]

@@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376 I haven't watched silent Ponyville yet

[@nocturnalvessel2241]

@@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376 sorry if this sounds rude, but what took you so long to reply?

[@nocturnalvessel2241]

@@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376 It's okay

[@theironpone035]

Wow, talk about a blast from the past. Hearing this music again brings back memories of me clutching my Tails plushie whilst listening to Fluttershy's adventures through Silent Ponyville. Beautiful...

[@MinersLovePonies]

In my restless dreams, I see that town. You promised you would take me there again some day. But you never did.

[@Peaches501]

After finding out about the story and listening too it this song makes so much sense now. So depressing…😢

[@no-ie8eh]

I remember being 8/9 years old and watching MLP Gore and horror stories and strangely loveing it now 8 years later i still love horror but with a but of...sadness especially the sound of distress in The Voice it's just disturbingly beautiful ฅ^•ﻌ•^ฅ...

[@idiot5700]

Same :v

[@chriswedemann8599]

I remember when I was eight or nine, before KZbin was even online. But somehow, still coming back to Silent Hill, even after all these years. Feels like home now.

[@lightningboltschannel525]

The lyrics: (if anyones interested):can't escape, from the nightmares laced with demons from my memories How far gone, is my life I left where Ponies cared about me? On and on Each new monster, deferent And some how familiar Why can't I see How it's all connected Why can't I remember? Music box How Can you play After all these years? Seeing her smile It was all I needed to brighten up my morning Hearing her laugh Like a string of bells just happy to be ringing, then she fades Precious Moments wither, swallowed by the darkness Now alone, facing monsters trying to bring back what I suppressed What did I do? What did I do? Mother tell me please What did I do? What can I do? What can I do? Mother tell me please What can I do? Music box Please Will you Play After all these years ? Music box Please Will you Play For Mother and Me

[@gren8te319]

1:25 i love how fluttershy starts sounding like an antagonist after awhile

[@BeesMeliss]

I guess spooky music box tones fit Fluttershy really well.

[@itsjustmenova]

The beautiful eeriness has put me into a mood to go back and listen to more grimdark songs. The singing was absolutely amazing, perfectly soft and full of emotion to match the tone

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

BlueDragon Yeah very beautiful sad song too

[@TheCommenterDragon]

Such a lovely and creepy song i love it, Mag did a topnotch and wonderful job singing this song!!!

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

The Commenter Dragon I agree this is one of my favorites and one of my favorite Silent Ponyville stories.

[@Bluefoxtail]

Listening to this one actually invested me enough to binge-listen to SP2’s narration, and I am just in awe at how wistfully elegant and impactful both the story and the song are. Also listening to the song again after hearing the story is even more soul-stirring than listening to it without context.

[@recorderboi6665]

I genuinely appreciate this series! I hope there is an apple sleep experiment, or rainbow factory one!

[@ashleighstangeland5046]

Incredibly spooky but i except nothing less.... I heard Rainbow and AJ's voice in trailer so I'm excited to find out why but I'm GUESSING for Rainbow it's either a cover of Rainbow Factory OR Pegasus Device, for AJ perhaps MAYBE a song based on An Apple Sleep Experiment maybe... I don't but I'm TOTALLY excited and ready to find out.

[@BellaPinkSavage]

Holy Moly! Magpiepony your fluttersinging is so beautiful! UrbanQhoul your artwork is fricken awesome!!!

[@TakumoKun]

Oh my god the vocals and distressing lyrics not to even mention the soft but brooding piano. Hell yeah!

[@Gacha_Nerd551]

I forgot how amazing of a singer Magpiepony is, especially when doing MLP voices like this.

[@alexanderbaker6756]

A fitting tribute to how I discovered the Lost Narrator

[@hyde5720]

The end made me think that there was gonna be a jumpscare because the sound the music box makes at the end is the sound it makes when a monster is nearby

[@darknessmohag6181]

As someone who just recently finished one run of Silent hill 1 and who loved the Grimdark fanfic Silent Ponyville 2, I can say this song was an real treat and just so great to listen to. I really love the lore of silent hill and the fanfics ''Silent Ponyville'' They are all soo AMAZING!!

[@LunamoonOwO]

Out of all the grimdark songs that were made, this is one is my favorites you guys did an amazing job

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

Lunamoon It's my favorite too Silent Ponyville is awesome especially Silent Ponyville 2.

[@destinytyler3432]

What a great Fluttershy voice to this sad song

[@TheNathand1996]

Yes! I absolutely loved your reading of Silent Ponyville 2! So much emotion, and now we get a small lyrical adaptation of one of the songs. Great work as always, Lost!

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

TheNathand1996 Hey I know you.

[@swordbrethrenmordred1230]

I love the soundtrack, but with the lyrics it's even better.

[@darkblastoise9199]

I was not ready for this 😭 this 😫 was just simply Fantastic, I can't describe how amazing this is XD THANK YOU Lostnarrator now I wanna re listen to GutuiSerenade Silent Ponyville 2 which was astounding as well the wonderful talent that help thank you you all XD i hope he returns to the series in the future 😆

[@SugarsnapCaely]

Oh my gosh, this is so good! I was just looking for a Silent Ponyville 2 song and here you are bringing one to life this year! Seriously, it just makes me all the more excited to introduce my friends to these amazing two stories with yours and Guti's readings. On the song itself, I love how you used Promise Reprise (Myuu's cover specifically. Love his stuff). Mag your voice is super pretty!! The lyrics were brilliant fitting Flutter's confusion and distress through the whole story. Just AHHHHHH! Silent Ponyville 1& 2 mean so much to me and will always be two of my favorite stories period. I didn't pull all-nighters reading those for nothing!

[@alinamazi5792]

what a perfect voice! poor fluttershy

[@oneofnone7947]

A tribute to my favorite MLP fanfiction and so exquisitely done by you and your beloved so perfect

[@Gresekjr122]

Wonderful job MagpiePony. I really love this song. This song fits this dark story perfectly. Keep up the good work. Have a wonderful spooky day.

[@BUBBL33SS]

oh my gosh this music is so good and perfect i love it 🙂🙂💖💖

[@tenshineko0159]

This was hauntingly beautiful. Makes me want to listen to Silent Ponyville 2 again. Amazing work Magpie and whoever did the art awesome. The art style reminds me of Tim Burton.

[@katelynthewhitewerewolf6376]

Tenshineko Yeah me too I like The Silent Ponyville Series wish it would continue

[@weirdsimplol]

This is perfect, I love the song so much😭❤️

[@superrloca]

My little pony G5 comic #11

[@firefox-py8dy]

I think this video is amazing even though it’s a little bit creepy great work my sister even likes it because she’s into scary stuff ❤

[@parthxus]

I LOVE PROMISE REPRISE 2 I KNEW I HEARD IT IN THE TRAILER WELL DONE LOSTY. THANK YOU FOR MAKING MY FAV SONG AMAZING

[@galaxystargazer8910]

Silent ponyville 2 was one of my favourite fan story crossover, and this song brings back the fear and sadness I felt for fluttershy. glad I found this song! Makes me wanna watch the story again on your channel!

[@matededdneddy]

Pretty hauntingly beautiful great job Mag.

[@Jordankons123]

Oh my godness that is standing ovation level. U do an out standing fluttershy. Get a hold of a good animater And u guys can make some very good videos. Itssssss freaky good

[@ko9killer]

Hauntingly beautiful I keep forgetting that Maggie has a fantastic voice

[@MidnightTheGothArtist]

The music (and lyrics) are so good!! Was looking forward to the next song since “Forever Lost” Great job once again! ^^

[@Thedragonlover95]

Boy was not expecting this, but hey we got lyrics

[@Darksoulpoetry]

haunting and lovely. Music Box. thank you Magpiepony for singing such a lovely song.

[@renamon5658]

This sends chills down my spine in a good way

[@makyleighblount1721]

This song is so pretty & sad at the same time. Also this song fits with one of my mlp ocs so well

[@hannahlannah8779]

I LOVE YOUR PFP

[@makyleighblount1721]

Same with yours :D

[@hannahlannah8779]

@@makyleighblount1721 Lol thanks

[@makyleighblount1721]

Yw

[@quintonjones2699]

Absolutely fantastic

[@Lunaisity]

Magpie did a fantastic job. Loved the lyrics and the singing top notch 👍 might have to watch SP2. Cant wait for the next Sinister Symphonies 😁

[@crimsonshade5441]

Magpie pony you've officially gained a follower this was amazing nicely done legend

[@moonshadow3324]

This is so amazing! My cat is even enchanted by this haunting song!

[@bigoldinosaur]

Another creepy and well done song by Magpiepony. Well done my dear, keep it up.

[@crystalpayne_entertains9903]

Now i gotta listen to Silent Ponyvil 2 again cuz omg! Its so creepy and haunting and beautiful all mixed in one. Magpiepony is too good!!! Wonderfully written, sung and edited. Amazing job to all!

[@ChildOfTheFence]

Those sounds at the end REALLY got me. Maybe I'm just easy but, damn that made me shake. Great work once again!

[@vinodindukuri6896]

this was fantastic! I especially liked the chorus ❤️ great job losty.

[@CherryPawCreations]

My new favorite! Amazingly done!

[@nicholasnguyen5181]

Dang that’s scary. I love it. Your wife is amazing and scary lost. You two are definitely meant for each other

[@Rockhoppr3]

Great, now whenever here this music during a creepy pasta reading, I'll forever be reminded of this beautifully haunting song. Thanks for that.

[@iloveyou-bx7xu]

You got me hooked on your narrations! This is so beautiful.

[@cameronjsmith7382]

Ooh this Is really good! Great singing guys! You rocked Mag!

[@pindowthegreat]

I absolutely love the new haunting stuff you keep putting out. hang on to that Halloween vibe and keep this amazing train rolling.

[@Ghst_-qn5if]

Amazing

[@elisasatge748]

J'ai adoré Silent Ponyville et Silent Ponyville 2!! Cette chanson me donne envi de retourner réécouter l!! Merci pour cette fantastique chanson!!

[@darkblade8205]

Now after listening to this amazing song my mind couldn't help but picture Fluttershy singing this song as she goes through silent ponyville.

[@jazzykingjack2846]

Demonic pony: I can just imagine what monsters, terrible memories, NIGHTMARES and so much more this poor unfortunate soul must be facing right now. In MY darkness. *evil laughter echoes while the music box plays*

[@Themagicrainbow12345]

This song was absolutely amazing I loved every bit of it and I love silent hill ever since I watched your gameplay it was amazing and I love fluttershy as being then mane character it’s amazing and your version of the silent ponyville is my absolute favorite keep up the amazing work I hope you have a wonderful day/night!^^

[@Agent0FluffyBoxOfVoicesCom]

This brings back nostalgia! I really enjoy your reading of Silent Ponyville 2 Lost! It’s amazing! Magpie’s vocals are amazing!

[@nicolaaudyova9362]

Thank you Mag and Lost. You both do so wanderful these songs and storys. You make my life a lot of better. Once again thank you so much.

[@Hisvchanel]

Since nobody has said it yet, the instrumental to this song was used in Roblox Flicker for the Main lobby theme, I'm not sure if anybody cares, But I wanted to point this out, because I can. Xd

[@Crystalheart-lq1pr]

This is a sad, yet beautiful mlp song ever😭😢

[@starbat3738]

Oooh. I'll have to check out this story again. You are so creative to make this song. ^_^

[@mrmlpvideogerman]

After reading Silent Ponyville 2 myself for the first time (yes Lost you were right when you said it's the best fanfic) I can say that this song fits perfectly.

[@XenotHedgehog]

Talk about a blast from the past. It's a shame he burnt out before he could finish the series.

[@Lifehasker]

Sounds wonderful 🎵

[@kira101]

I absolutely LOVE this!!!

[@jeanfoxgamer]

i'm out of words of how amazed i am, i can't even speak irl, it just made my words fade away, the radio static at the end was the cherry on the top, you and mag made an amazing job here

[@nathanielkirkpatrick4395]

I love how it's the original notes in the background for silent Hill

[@PastaPrincess25]

This is hauntingly beautiful! Guess I'll check out this series and see what the hubbub's been about. Better late than never.

[@SuperSpike47]

Truly awesome song 😺

[@fluterdashwill1308]

The melody of the voice is just amazing vcv

[@Redjay_Lee]

Ooo nice, really liked that story

[@skyquestriamystories]

Thanks

[@ethenaheart5873]

Such a pretty song especially at just finishing the series last week

[@thatclassclown7587]

This has become one of my all time favorite songs.

[@TyriusTheVA]

Awesome!

[@AuraKnight-kn1ux]

Who sang as Flutter shy really did a beautiful job 🥹🥹. Kind Regards AuraKnight

[@AuraKnight-kn1ux]

Thank you Curesword 😉👍

[@Galaxy_Artzy]

This song. This song is amazing!- It can make me go to sleep, but yet give me nightmares- XD

[@Juju_Invokation]

This was AMAZING! I would LOVE to see an animated version of this! 💞💞💞💞

[@samuelkirkwood6702]

Beautiful.

[@TheTMNTFandom-sf9iz]

Any one listening to this amazing piece of art here in 2024? 😁

[@LeandroBrony]

Wow, That Song Was Quiet and So Creepy as Usual. I Like It, Lost. So Much.

[@ChristopherKapoun711]

Mag's singing here...chills literal chills!

[@OblivionTheDragon]

Out of all the other songs this is the best one and I’m so glad I found this

[@Kat-the-Snynx]

Nawwww I need a hour long audio of the music box “buzzing”

[@TheDarkAuthor666]

Great song lost I also mentioned your narration of the truth about mlp story on my narration of the story. Your work is amazing and you taught me music and environment makes a story come to life so thanks

[@AyenCaunin]

Fluttershy's voice is beautiful😍

[@cookiegacha2701]

It's spooky and beautiful

[@vantodd2857]

IM LOVING THIS!!!! MY DAY JUST GOT BETTER!!! THANK YOOOOOOUUUUU!!!!!!!