There are some very glaring mistakes + omissions about Focus Points 1) 2023 overall profit dipped vs 2022 because there was a) strong pending demand post covid in 2022 + b) aggressive stores opening in 2023 which took time to breakeven. 2) for F&B , besides having Komugi & yogurt business ( yogurt biz they have seem to be writing off) , Focus Point has a central kitchen supplying Family Mart (80%) , Zus Coffee and Cotti Coffee. The F&B was used to be in money losing position as the utilization was below 70% but has since improved and become profitable esp after SKUs for Family Mart has increased from 13 to 24 3) The receivables were mainly due to their corporate F&B and 75 days are considered normal in the industry and certainly doesn't affect the profit as mentioned unless they were classified as bad debt and being made provision, which under current circumstance is unlikely as their customers are very mostly strong brand.
@ZFounderClub2 күн бұрын
Thanks for sharing more insights into FP. Good stuff 👍
@nstudio69374 күн бұрын
i understand what Jin was saying about trade receivable vs profit. I'd say the more accurate term would be cash/capital turnover rate. Shorter receivable period results in high capital turnover. If the capital turnover rate is high, with profit margin maintained or even lower, a company is still able to make more money :) This is especially crucial in capital intensive industries. One of the reason why low US Fed rate + massive QE in the past did not create serious inflation. Because in an active market there were many market players, many companies maintain lower profit margin but higher capital turnover to remain profitable. When there was really too much QE, inflation finally kicked in, the Fed hiked the rate too late and too quickly. Therefore, in that high interest rate environment, and low capital turnover rate, prices did not drop but hiked instead.❤ and from business point of view, if we have long trade receivable, it is ok😂😂😂 as long you are able to have even LONGER trade payable lo! it is taking free loan from the suppliers lah but it is a BAD BUSINESS ETHIC ya!!! :)
@ZFounderClub4 күн бұрын
Hahaha not exactly. 我还是要承认自己没有到你的思维的 level, your level is too high bro, but yea that makes sense I guess. 我和 Ivan 纯粹要讲的就是, cashflow 永远都可以成为 reinvestment for more profit. It's just basic common sense for entrepreneurs. 但是还是谢谢你的分享!!
@nstudio69374 күн бұрын
@@ZFounderClubno worries, i am a cha bor anyways. Doing business and having tough life thats how i came to this stage of realization. Love your work & Keep it up ❤❤❤❤
@ZFounderClub4 күн бұрын
@@nstudio6937 That strikes a chord! Did you text us once on WhatsApp long long time ago? You kind of reminded me of someone. A lady entrepreneur from Singapore?
@nstudio69374 күн бұрын
@@ZFounderClubEh no. Not me. 😂
@alexsmart98394 күн бұрын
I get your point, as in collect back money to increase sales by reinvesting new project or product so that increase the profits indirectly.
@ZFounderClub4 күн бұрын
in biz, cashflow is always the king
@jac71806 күн бұрын
可以讲一讲骨灰塔生意吗?
@ZFounderClub5 күн бұрын
有机会的话,一定!
@leong9156 күн бұрын
其实trade receiveable怎样影响profit?
@yaphong22006 күн бұрын
我也想问同个问题,难道是要说Provision for doubtful debts对P&L的影响?而不是直接指Trade Receivable换成Cash会增加Profit。
@xxchin26206 күн бұрын
如果已经把15mil的trade receivable做成provision for doubtful debt,收回来后reversal doubtful debt的话确实会影响netprofit.. 如果没有做provision, 一直outstanding然后收回钱 是不会影响的
Trade receivable ard calculated in net profit. Even they can collect all the receivable profit won increase anymore. Just the cash flow statement and balance sheet will look much more better
@ZFounderClub5 күн бұрын
My bro come on la, Ivan is an ex-banker you really think she doesnt know that? Can we all put on the hat of an entrepreneur and think for once, what will happen if our cash flow is no longer flowing? Getting tired of explaining the same thing over and over again.
@jasonhooi85115 күн бұрын
It sounds like you and her really duno... So here's the figure she mentioned 2022 Sales - 248m PBT - 47m 2023 Sales - 260m PBT - 39m We can see here sales increase but PBT drop. She mention audit report explanation was because operating cost higher that's why PBT drop which is correct. Then she dig deeper which is great and found that trade receivable is as high as 15m. She then said that the PBT different is only 4.8m so if you can just collect back most of the 15m debts your profit will increase tremendously. This is wrong. Trade receivable figure recorded (15m) is already part the sales figure (260m). Collect it back will not increase ur PBT in any way! And do u think 15m trade receivable is really high for them? Their sales on 2023 was 260m. This mean only 15m (5.7%) not yet collect back and 245m (94.3%) is cash sales and debts collected. I would think that is still quite reasonable and no need to cause for an alarm. It's an honest mistake bro. Not all bank staff is from acc or business finance background. I have colleague graduated from chemical science and join bank as credit officer. Banker is not a professional job tittle actually there's no need to over glorified it. You can admit it and learn something new. BTW I don't see any comment from you guys explaining what her point of view when she talks bout the trade receivable which is inaccurate. I really did read all the 25 comments.
@ZFounderClub5 күн бұрын
Once again bro, Idk why I have to explain again. Your comment makes sense in terms of accounting, which I already clarify on so many occasions and under other peoples' comment as well. Let me clarify once again, you're absolutely right, 100% IN TERMS OF ACCOUNTING. Now, let's put on an entrepreneur hat. Put yourself in their shoes, if you have 15m now, which is from the receivable. Will you buy a new ferrari with that money or reinvest into the company for additional revenue and sales? If your answer is I will reinvest into the company, then there you have it. Do you think the 15m cannot even generate an additional 1 ringgit profit? I will stop here, because there's no point. Her views are from a businessman POV. You guys are stating your case based on an accounting POV.
@jasonhooi85115 күн бұрын
@@ZFounderClub On Entrepreneur perspective it don't make much sense. I did 260m (100%) in sales on 2023 and have ppl hutang me 15m (5.7%). It means most of my sales 245m (94.3%) is cash term. I would say it's freaking great for me. However now you're saying ppl still owe me 15m I boh song I wan collect back immediately and buy more stock and sell more to maximize profit. It's OK if ure living in a perfect world imagined by your wildest dream. You have to consider is the company overtrading or undertrading which can be tell by calculating ur efficiency ratio from the financial statement. How do u guarantee buying 15m more stock or whack it in marketing and promotion will increase ur PBT?your sure it won end up in higher closing stock that only become slow obsolete? Besides if ur business environment everyone give some credit term but u don't give I think ur cust will just run away to your competitor. You're not selling oxygen in Mars. 😅
@jasonhooi85115 күн бұрын
And bro u really din explain leh. I really go and read every comments and comment on comment. 😅 Maybe if u did pin it la ppl easier to find