The New York Giants Are A Solid Team, But Have One BIG Problem | 2024 NFL Team Previews

The Philadelphia Eagles Are Here | 2024 NFL Team Previews:
• The Philadelphia Eagle...
Apple Podcast:
podcasts.apple...
Spotify Podcast:
open.spotify.c...
TWITTER: / fballanalysisyt
DISCORD:
/ discord
TIKTOK: vm.tiktok.com/...
Welcome to the Football Analysis KZbin channel! Subscribe for all NFL related content! Drop a like if you enjoyed the video as all support is very much appreciated! Thanks for watching!
#nfl #nflfootball #football #nfldraft #giants

[@FootballAnalysis1]

How Far Do You Think The Giants Go This Year? 🤔

[@judewhite4401]

I think they could be similar to the 2022 Jets: they win games off the strength of their defense, but their quarterback is terrible, likely putting them in that 6-11, 7-10 range and putting them in position for somebody like Jalen Milroe from Alabama.

[@NAT-turners-Revenge]

​@@judewhite4401milroe is a project QB 😅... 3rd ed at best

[@judewhite4401]

@NAT-turners-Revenge Everybody called Will Levis a project QB, and he’s actually looked pretty damn good for my Titans.

[@NAT-turners-Revenge]

@@judewhite4401 negative... I loved levis coming out... I heard every stupid criticism from his attitude to his age. Strong armed QBs get those labels. Levis didnt play with " super teams" .... these Alabama teams are loaded with 25-40% nfl players every year since saban

[@Matt90541]

Jones will carry the team back to the playoffs like he did in 2022 but they won't make the Super Bowl.

[@TheAceVentura00]

You spit some bars in this one. The Saquon loss is overblown, we weren’t a juggernaut rushing attack with him. With the work we put into the trenches, I think a RBBC can be at least SERVICABLE behind that line (not to mention DJs rushing ability). Im not impressed with the Tight End room either though. Im just praying that our offense is good enough to uphold Brian Daboll’s reputation and job security, as he is crucial to our success going forward. As long as DJ doesn’t turn the ball over a massive amount of times and our defense hits it’s top 10 upside, we can definitely exceed expectations. 7-8 win ceiling.

[@Metalgarn]

I don't think Daboll is really in jeopardy at this point. John Mara has NEVER fired a HC that had his GM's support. Daboll would have to have an epic disaster and roster mutiny (like Mac in 2017) to lose Schoen's support. They aren't precisely a package deal but they are pretty close... and Mara isn't going to fire both of them this early on without being left with no choice whatsoever.

[@ADUSN]

It's not about the rushing attack, saquon was the face of the franchise and put butts in seats. Fans loved him, he was loyal, and yall did him wrong. Rooting for the eagles.

[@rohanshah7559]

Yeah giants getting rid of Saquon would be the equivalent of like, Bucs getting rid of Mike Evans. You lose a good player AND you lose a big aspect of franchise culture. Imagine if the Bucs had cut Mike Evans, and signed Zay Jones?

[@Metalgarn]

@@rohanshah7559 Except Mike Evans has had over 1000 yards every year of his 10 year career and has been generally healthy throughout his career. While Barkley has only had over 1000 yards in 3 of his 6 years and has missed FAR more games to injury in his 6 years than Evans has in his 10. And of course, it's a passing league not a running league.

[@TrollKing2781]

​@@Metalgarn To lose Shames support. If anyone is going. It's Joe Shame, not Daboll. They already have his replacement on standby.

[@williamblake8560]

Right now the biggest weaknesses on the Giants is the quarterback and secondary. The offensive line should be better than last year and they have more weapons and the front seven of the defense should be good. Again, the two biggest weaknesses are quarterback and secondary

[@vinnieandhispizza6299]

Offensive line still might be bad

[@vinnieandhispizza6299]

The offensive line is still shaky to me too

[@quintinb6584]

@@vinnieandhispizza6299it’s not

[@Leo2810-m2q]

@@vinnieandhispizza6299offensive line look a lil better then last year

[@Texmsx]

No it's not they got eluemenor and van roten ​@@vinnieandhispizza6299

[@Catelynmeow]

This is one of the best takes on the Giants that I've seen. Very well-researched!

[@FootballAnalysis1]

@@Catelynmeow thank you Catelyn!

[@Gillandria]

Good to hear someone unbiased and UNEMOTIONAL talk Giants and even properly evaluating DJ without being overblown about it. We have such a toxic, over emotional fanbase and they just say any damn thing. Good video

[@baxatakbaxatak2014]

Most of these whiners were begging for the rebuild and an outside hire, and completely forget we’ve won a ring a decade for the past 40 years. We’re due. But I guess two rings against Brady will never be enough for some people.

[@FootballAnalysis1]

@@Gillandria thank you so much!!!

[@charlesmoore6186]

Yeah, they are trash. Who tells someone else to watch a different team if the Giants is there team. Manning and Jones had been hit so much it's not surprising he's suffered multiple injuries and Joe Burrow has suffered multiple injuries behind his horrible O Line.

[@gmabailey40]

@@charlesmoore6186 because we are tired of being a laughing stock of the NFL. While our 40 million qb averages 200 yards and a td. Hes ranked in the bottom 5. Its weird that people put him on a pedestal. Tebow won a playoff game as well. Hostetler won a SB and was awful after. The ravens qb that beat the Giants in the SB was terrible as well.

[@boki1693]

I think Barkley was a good Giant. That being said, we never should have taken him in the first place. A running back like him is the finishing piece. Not a building block. Especially since we needed a QB at the time too. This played out pretty much how I saw it with Barkley. By the time we got good, he would be gone. So what was the point of picking him?

[@davydmaxwell2639]

Even though it was definetley a mistake, it could've worked out if gettleman acutally knew how to draft. He's had a total of 3 good draft picks throughout his tenure and picking Barkley is just one of his big misses

[@boki1693]

@@davydmaxwell2639 Heres were we agree though. Or disagree. Barkley wasn't a miss. He was just the wrong choice for the Giants at this point. If we already had Jones as a rookie or first year QB when we picked Barkley, I would have been ok with it. Not saying Jones is great. Just saying we thought we had our QB at that time. As it turned out, it really didn't matter much because in hindsight, all the top QB's were pretty much failures anyway. But all I am really saying is the Giants had to secure a QB BEFORE they picked someone like Barkley at a luxury position. Because by this time I didn't have any faith in Gettleman as a GM anyway.

[@Boosh33]

I think y’all picked right with saquon I just think yall should have moved on from Daniel jones when yall had the chance to and honestly paid saquon. If yall bring in a young qb yall still are a playoff team cause yall success and Daniel jones success ran through saquon just like it would with a young qb. Also paying saquon 13 mil or whatever he was asking at the time gives yall more money to play with and build that offense rather than giving a mediocre quarterback in Daniel jones 40 mil. Just my opinion

[@davydmaxwell2639]

@@Boosh33 The big issue though is that we were coming off of a playoff win so we weren't in a position to draft a new Qb. So we should've franchise tagged Dj and resign saquon which would've been the only other option. However idk if Dj wanted to play on a tag which probably pressured schoen into getting a deal done.

[@carlosflores7064]

Barkley 3 td he sucks

[@tyleraguilar2474]

As a Giants fan I agree with one of your last points. I don’t want to see Dabol being let go because of a shitty situation. Ever since Coughlin we’ve had unqualified coaches but Dabol seems to make smarter decisions and the players seem to play harder when he’s fired up

[@pimpnamedslickback7780]

Unfortunately the giants have become a dumb organization. I expect daboll to be fired and end up in a great situation once he leaves

[@tyleraguilar2474]

@@pimpnamedslickback7780 some of the decisions made over the last few years have been mind boggling.

[@baxatakbaxatak2014]

Daboll took this injury-riddled team to 4-3 down the stretch. He’s safe.

[@mng1628]

Mara is not going to fire daboll, hes going to keep his job until he gets his own qb, he inherited jones

[@20Unknown]

Absolutely

[@carbiv]

Hope so

[@SouthBeachJames]

Trading for Burns is a smart move. Offensive lines will be preoccupied with keeping Burns in check which should free up Thibodeux to make more plays. I can see his sack numbers going up slightly.

[@GreenVinickey-z9x]

Brian Burns is overrated.

[@GTBreezy]

Burns really isn’t as good as you tryna make him seem he’s starting to get very overrated now especially with that contract he got.

[@TrollKing2781]

Trading for Burns was a dumb move when you're a $h!+ team.

[@JMO4945]

@@TrollKing2781wow! Good insight! So how does the team get better then?

[@TrollKing2781]

​@@JMO4945 Upgrading the QB position. How else.

[@SoyAngellll]

love that you mention the flipping burger part

[@olivierim.24]

bro i had a xavier mcckiney and saquon jersey because those two were the best one on their side of the ball but bro they both left😭😭

[@Metalgarn]

I think its fair to say that Barkley was our most talented offensive weapon (it's really not close in that regard). As for best on his side of the ball... I'd argue that Andrew Thomas is our best offensive player with Barkley in second place. McKinney is a good player, no where close to being our best player on defense which is clearly Dexter and Okereke was a better player than McKinney by far.

[@swayy9440]

McKinney was a cry baby, always getting trucked & man handled lol

[@Metalgarn]

@@swayy9440 That seems extreme. People need to understand that in Wink's defense safeties are not in a great position to put up great numbers (nor are pass rushers).

[@pimpnamedslickback7780]

That’s the only reason we won games down the stretch

[@ethanshurkus7212]

@@MetalgarnMcKinney over Lawrence????

[@GTBreezy]

My boy finally got that jersey in a frame lmao that hanger was wild as hell

[@joeygsly16]

So basically 23 minutes to say the giants are bad not terrible

[@thatguyjose2678]

Better than the all mainstream media saying that they’re god awful, fire everybody because they’re morons.

[@pimpnamedslickback7780]

The giants are going to be a 4-5 win team this yr. Every season people overrate and overhype how good they can be and they underperform or get injured

[@ajkareem5685]

Thanks for the breaking news

[@anthonyriche552]

Nailed it perfectly. I had the Giants at 6-8 wins. I don't think Daboll gets fired this year unless Schoen goes and there's no way Mara does that. He created part of this mess by hiring Gettleman who drafted Saquon and Jones while forgetting that the offensive line is part of the offense. My feeling is that Schoen and Daboll get to draft THEIR quaterback next year and get two years to prove what they can do.

[@VanessaDMusic]

Exactly

[@juanmikel7507]

If they didn’t pay Jones they could’ve had a young quarterback already with plenty of cap space. That was their decision and I think they’ll lose their job because of that

[@JCNY718]

Most realistic take on the 2024 Giants I’ve seen from someone not directly covering the team. Way better than the national media who talk about this team like their pubic hair was on fire.

[@nathanmillones8798]

Good front 4, Malik is him, ok LB room, but the rest is so bad its actually insane. Drew Lock takes over by the end of the season

[@judewhite4401]

That’s what I’ve been saying. The offensive line has shown clear improvement in the preseason, but they probably need another wide receiver, specifically an alpha wide receiver. And they need a cornerback to pair up with Deonte Banks.

[@AtlasAdvice254]

@@judewhite4401 they have an alpha reciever in malik, they need a slot or an X

[@mikegoldberg8939]

Problem is lock hasn't looked good either

[@judewhite4401]

@AtlasAdvice254 What I’m talking about is whatever CeeDee Lamb or Brandon Aiyuk or Tee Higgins is.

[@GreenShark-hn7pk]

I’d rather see Tommy Cutlets

[@pimpnamedslickback7780]

12:26 “I don’t blame Joe schoen for paying Daniel jones” yeah that’s a ridiculous take. The franchise tag exists for a reason

[@baxatakbaxatak2014]

In that case, Okereke would have been playing elsewhere.

[@lfl077]

The problem is, Daniel Jones was asking 45 million like a superstar QB,, when he only had a not bad season in 2022,,

[@brentgaming3914]

Would have been left with no room to try to improve elsewhere, no okereke no gamble on waller

[@pimpnamedslickback7780]

@@lfl077then let him walk

[@pimpnamedslickback7780]

@@baxatakbaxatak2014who cares

[@maxguam4830]

Not being a 1k yard rusher for multiple seasons isnt a saquon problem. 100% a NYG problem. Dont slander the man, his tape is still filthy

[@FootballAnalysis1]

It was a slander towards the situation, not Saquon They set him up to fail

[@maxguam4830]

@@FootballAnalysis1 agreed

[@Sabermaster44]

Thank you for putting that jersey in a frame. The hanger was killing me

[@amaddenmind4597]

As a giants fan I appreciate this fair and accurate assessment of my team... your one of my favorite top 3 football KZbinrs that NOT a giants fan ...you always give a fare an accurate assessment of every NFL team

[@JWD1992]

You are very right that McKinney is a big loss. I was shocked at how unconcerned with re-signing him they seemed to be. I also agree the Giants had an awful offense with Saquon last year and probably won't be much worse without him this year. HOWEVER, I do believe that, once he left, so did their chances of getting back to the (solid-but-not-thrilling) offense they had in 2022. He absolutely elevated Jones. Most of the starts Jones did make last year were without Saquon, and it showed. Of course, their two full games together were opposites: the 40-0 blowout loss to the Cowboys, then that big comeback against the Cardinals. In the former, Saquon kind of put that pick-six on Dan's stat sheet; but in the latter, he put the team on his back and got hurt as a result. Hopefully Nabers can now be the guy who can elevate the offense. Plus Daboll has had an offseason to rethink their identity. And I also think highly of Bellinger.

[@ceezy585]

Paying safeties is not it. The free agent pool is always full of 7 solid starters. We let landon collins walk for the same type thing. And we drafted top 2 college safety in the second rd. Running backs are not looked as a big hole to fill either.

[@Marner4Hart]

It’s so refreshing to hear actual good takes about the giants.

[@ishabelv]

thank you for this video. this team is not great by any means. but we are solid and we have potential. u said everything perfectly

[@shaanpatel5836]

THIS!!!!!! Best take on the Giants I've seen. The defense is solid but our offense did them 0 favors during 2023, and no quarterback would have survived with the OL that we had that season. I agree that DJ is by no means a top 10 QB but he's not bottom trash tier like people want to make him out to be. Hopefully with better OL coaching and less injuries we can take some more steps to being a better team and I think we can start really contending for playoff spots with one (maybe two) solid offseasons

[@terranceramirez4816]

He may not be trash tier but his skillset is a mismatch for the kind of offense that Daboll wants to run. He’s the kind of guy that I could see going the Sam Darnold route and going to SF as a backup and reviving his career that way,

[@TrollKing2781]

Only way giants are contending for anything is by throwing DJ in a dumpster & hauling it away forever.

[@FootballAnalysis1]

@@shaanpatel5836 thank you so much!!!

[@gmabailey40]

except he is ranked in the bottom 5 yearly. I dk why its so hard to look at stats.

[@shaanpatel5836]

This take aged like milk. I am completely off on DJ, he needs to go after that garbage Week 1 performance

[@minigamersurvival22]

I dont need to watch the video to know that the giants having the worst QB in the league is the problem.

[@rjharrold2907]

Yep

[@andrewmcgrory1204]

Broncos might have something to say about that

[@torkrench]

The answer to a better than 500 season is easy... Trade Slayton for a Cornerback- the fella in New Orleans would be cool, sign the Buffalo Corner with some of the cap cash and find a way to get Dante Miller the ball to change up Singletary & Gray.... (I think Turbo has more upside than Tracey) a flex guy. List the FB as the third TE with Theo & Bellinger- solid. The WR corps is solid- keep Robinson to replace Slayton, OL is solid and finally servicable, DL/Edge very good, Backers are solid, Safeties are solid. Then keep all in place and add THE QB next year and we'll be in good shape.

[@AB-nv7bz]

I think the wr core is pretty good now. Having that alpha makes everyone else better. Wandale is good in the short game out of the slot. Hyatt can stretch the friend. Slayton is solid. We are weak at corner, but a lot of that could be covered up with exception d line play. It all comes down to DJ. We have a good D that can keep us in games, but we can't have 3 and outs or turnovers.

[@jhonmakesvideos]

it’s not just that they let Saquon walk, it’s that they let him walk AFTER shelling out the big bucks to Danny Nickels. yeah it’s a passing league and letting your star RB walk, even if he’s one of the best in the position, isn’t the end of the world, letting him walk so you can free up cap space to overpay your garbage QB is the kind of decision that’s setting this franchise back

[@kathleenrossi4840]

Saquon walked for the same money the Giants were offering.

[@ryanzz83627]

i want people to realize DeVitos run last year set the Giants back at least 5-8 years now will seal daboll n schoens fate.

[@gmabailey40]

Couldnt agree more. The same guys praising Jones were the ones who wanted to win games last year. We easily could have traded for Howell or Dobbs. Even could have gotten a better qb in the later rounds as a transition QB.

[@athens_1psvr31]

As a Giants fan I truly appreciate the well broken down evaluation and honest thoughts. I’ve been saying the exact same things. Except I believe the run game will improve without Barkley. I’m thinking a 3 Headed Monster combo.👍🏾

[@tarvisbickler3787]

I heard the NYG were making a dak prescott sized hole in their salary cap for 2025

[@WeAreNotSheep2023]

Good fair analysis. Love your channel.

[@bishopdedon7281]

9:12 Evan Neal looked lost last year hopefully our new oline coach can get him on track

[@CINO0816]

Don't forget, a lot of the reason Kayvon wouldn't get home a lot last yr was due to no one on the otherside

[@olivierim.24]

bro don’t say saquon was bad when he had the worst o line itl

[@Metalgarn]

He didn't say he was bad. He said even with Barkley our running game was awful. So losing him is simply not a big deal.

[@ChewsCarefully]

No he didn't. Evan while whiffing on his blocks Evan Neal at least gets his hands _on_ pass-rushers, right? The players in the 1st 23 minutes of kzbin.info/www/bejne/fJrMfGVni998ldE are *actively running away from* their blocks. & if you watch how shocked the QB looks, you can tell this wasn't how things went in practice. I mention this because we're already seeing the fallout from it & are likely to see more. The same channel did a breakdown of that QB's last preseason game. He can't stop bobbing, looking around nervously & running when passes are available. That can happen when your own coaches & teammates betray you repeatedly & NO ONE, not even fans or analysts acknowledge this. That film is from Week One of '23. Imagine your Entire Team doing this to you, the players watching it happen from the bench & no one says anything. It seems to have affected him. But yeah, the Giants' o-line was bad too. Just not that bad.

[@pimpnamedslickback7780]

It’s funny how it works right? They get to make excuses for Daniel jones with the OLine even tho part of the QBs job is to audible and pre snap process which has a pretty big influence over the OL but for saquon it’s “oh he sucks”

[@FrederickGibson-yr2lk]

No one will say it smh.

[@yepdontcarebud]

Dude has recorded like 3 broken tackles in the last 3 years lmao Most overrated player in the league, and the definition of "big for no reason".

[@williehardiman6766]

Giants should've drafted a QB and I'll never move from that fact

[@alexandersoussa8160]

Yeah but a rookie qb does best with weapons around him and a good oline. If we drafted someone else instead of Nabers, we would have none of that. Plus, the way Jones’ contract works we can trade/cut him after the second year and now have to pay him but if we drafted a qb he would take up a huge amount of cap space. I don’t like keeping jones but it is unfortunately the best decision.

[@pimpnamedslickback7780]

@@alexandersoussa8160they have Hyatt, slayton and Robinson. That’s a solid group, jones is just trash and ppl refuse to admit it

[@dbro2907]

Cap. Hyatt and Robinson are unproven. Hyatt can’t beat press and isn’t the best route runner. Slayton should be WR2 or 3.

[@bishopdedon7281]

25 QB draft class is better

[@sketchy1018]

If the giants were to draft Eli’s replacement any year, in hindsight it shoulda been 2018 where the saquon pick was made. Issue arises when said qb is either Sam darnold, josh Rosen, josh Allen (who would not have been developed properly), or a massive reach in Lamar. 2020: drafting a qb a year after your rookie posts a promising season is dumb. 2021: nobody would have panned out in the fires of NY 2022: id rather be behind nobody than whatever the dumpster fire this class was (outside of purdy) 2023: you JUST paid Danny, who also looked promising yet again. 2024: giants tried moving up for Maye, failed, would have been stupid to reach for McCarthy or penix or nix at 1.06 when there’s just better talent available.

[@CooperDoesSports]

Here’s a hot take. Tommy DeVito should be the Giants starting quarterback this season!

[@ChequeTwice]

It blew my mind when they didn’t offer Saquon a contract but offered Daniel one….

[@oneboxboi1091]

Giants might have the best front 7 itl but are gonna go 2-15 bc of DJ and the O-line 😂

[@Spookymoulder]

Best football KZbin channel. Thanks for your great work.

[@matthewkelly2105]

my guess is Danny plays until week 5 or 6. Maybe he gets 1 or 2 wins. Then he gets injured or benched. They then play drew lock who gets maybe to 2 wins. Then he gets hurt or benched. Then cutlets comes in and wins a few. So they go 6-11 or 7-10 and miss out on any chance of drafting a good qb.

[@MikeyT1600]

Giants forced 3 turnovers vs Miami the offense let us down that game not the d

[@ScholarlyHiccup]

When you’re hyping up a squad as adequate, that’s how you know they’re bad. Nearly every position group has a ceiling of being mid. DJ is bad, this team is bad.

[@majorsynthqed7374]

The Giants will be in the running for a top 3 draft pick.

[@Metalgarn]

I wouldn't say which DJ we see comes down to a flip of a coin. I'd say, it comes down to the O-line, most specifically Andrew Thomas. 2022 Thomas was healthy all season and DJ with a lesser roster did pretty well. 2023 Thomas went down within minutes of the 1st game, DJ was destroyed (hence your pressure to sack ratio) for weeks and was knocked out for the season before Thomas could come back.

[@TrollKing2781]

So why did the other 2 QB's play better than DJ.

[@Metalgarn]

@@TrollKing2781 Largely because Thomas came back. And also because they were playing against lesser teams.

[@TrollKing2781]

​@@Metalgarn Sounds like the usual DJ excuses. But statistically is factual.

[@Metalgarn]

@@TrollKing2781 You are right the usual DJ excuses are statistically factual. Thanks for playing.

[@henrywallacesghost5883]

Still feel the Giants aren't quite there yet. Once they get a true franchise qb then this team can contend.

[@ADUSN]

Literally a bottom 5 team

[@TrollKing2781]

Unfortunately, that's the hard part.

[@pimpnamedslickback7780]

1:07 “fun stretch” how was it fun? It literally cost us a chance at a transformative qb 😂. Last season was like someone who spends all week dieting and then binge eats it all back on the weekend

[@baxatakbaxatak2014]

Tanking would have gotten Daboll fired, possibly Schoen as well. So, new head coach and GM? No thank you.

[@pimpnamedslickback7780]

@@baxatakbaxatak2014 who the fuck cares? What has joe schoen done that proves he deserves his job past this yr?

[@CarmeloJaimenje]

What's up! Love your info. Thx

[@rmkelectronics6965]

Dabol and shown need to wake up and get rid of jones and move on if they win 6 games I would be suprised tell Mara to fall out of love with jones and move on ho past his ego and move on

[@Unknown17]

Lots of insights here I hadn't thought about. If I were Green Bay, I wouldn't have given up Runyan. Kudos on another great video!

[@dariusjones2593]

Agree a %100 about saquon , been saying it, 2 good years with him, the production can be replaced

[@theguy261]

I think people are overlooking that 2022 season. The playbook was limited that season it was made for jones to not be able to make many mistakes and that plan only lasted half the season.

[@willrhodes112]

Teams would game plan around saquon because they knew he was the only offense the giants had. Now that teams are going to play more pass defense heavy, the saquon loss isn’t overblown imo

[@rjrjr1]

You're totally off on this imo. Giants biggest concern this year as far as winning games is concerned is the defense, most specifically the secondary. Assuming the starting o-line can stay healthy that is.

[@baxatakbaxatak2014]

It’s an incredibly young team. Lotta baptism by fire gonna be happening. Schoen and Daboll are going to get another year or two. That might mean getting their own QB from scratch.

[@SamK-vj7if]

So hard to watch. Been a fan since 1981 and dj era reminds me of the David brown era

[@gmabailey40]

I liked Dave Brown he showed flashes as well. Sadly I was wrong. Than it got really bad with Kent.

[@SamK-vj7if]

@gmabailey40 forgot about kent. Unfortunately dj will not be a starter next year In the nfl. 5 or 6 years is more than enough time to know where one stands in the nfl. I feel bad for every player on the gmen who know this to be true and know season is over already

[@thatguyjose2678]

The giants’ motto is “I don’t think it can get worse”

[@Deadboy90]

"Their not gonna go 0 for 30 in passing attempts." Daniel Jones: "Bet"

[@ajkareem5685]

Ahahahahahaah no

[@josuesamaniego182]

Tyrod Taylor has a SB ring which is still odd to think about

[@athens_1psvr31]

Barkley didn’t have a stiff arm, mainly carried in the right arm mostly, fumble and catching issues, no truck move, and doesn’t punish defenders because he rather go around and OB against the last defender.

[@JUDALATION]

LOL Barkley is going to have a Mccafry type season, he was a great pass blocker and catcher of the ball. You are clowning yourself with these takes... And the Panthers were not winning with Mccafry either. Jones is trash and that Oline on the Giants is very good... The Giants have the best LT in the league when healthy and essentially have no real weakness on Ol ANYMORE because they have depth now...

[@jibbjabb43]

He's not saying Barkley can't be good. He's saying the Giants had no business paying him to stay after last year.

[@rohanshah7559]

I also feel bad for Singletary honestly. He’s a solid runner, but he’s gonna average like 3 ypc behind this O-line and with run blitzes every turn since nobody respects DJ’s throwing. Bro doesn’t deserve this

[@leerubin4303]

Their CB position is weak. Dan Jones sucks. 7 wins

[@vikeirishman]

Kool-aid drinking is hilarious looking back.

[@ayyubjackson]

The RB room isn't a concern. Honestly. It'll be around top 20 in EPA or better

[@brysonbailey6613]

If by solid you mean really bad, then you're absolutely correct

[@GodLikeMikeLive]

Daboll is such a great coach but will definitely be scapegoated if they don't make the playoffs this year. Has been given one of the worst rosters year after year and gets thrown to the wolves. Honestly, I don't see any other coach taking that 2022 giants team to the playoffs and winning like Daboll did.

[@TrollKing2781]

Really no evidence to suggest Daboll is a great coach.

[@GodLikeMikeLive]

@@TrollKing2781 K

[@TrollKing2781]

@@GodLikeMikeLive I personally think he's a good coach & Joe Shame is the bigger problem. Aside from the QB position being the biggest issue of them all.

[@gmabailey40]

Devito is able to win behind the line. But they blame the line for Jones. Im so tired of the double standards and people who walk on egg shells for Jones. He is a 200 yard 1 td average QB with well below average football IQ.

[@duanebailey6253]

The reason why the team improved last year is because Jones wasn't playing. Calling tyrod a backup than claiming the team will be better is hilarious.

[@Thecyborgman]

Man was struggling to give the giants good feedback

[@N4divers]

One big problem is that Daniel Jones is their starting QB and the organization has a dumbfounding belief that he’s better than he actually is.

[@rayallen6206]

This is the first time I’ve ever heard Daniel Jones called DJ

[@HotdogJuice]

This analysis falls short in the premise that Jones' poor performance has nothing to do with SB's performance or running opportunity. Implying SB was a poor player is crazy. The defense they play against was eating cake knowing the limitations of Jones

[@ENJ3245]

I think the giants offensive line ceiling is top 12… raiders oline was graded out as 10th best last year and every player starting for the giants oline except one is either the same as the raiders starter or better

[@Socrates21stCentury]

Avoid the Xmas rush ... Fire Dabol now ...

[@menofvalourdrin187shai2]

That’s dumb

[@Socrates21stCentury]

@@menofvalourdrin187shai2 So is Dabol ...

[@menofvalourdrin187shai2]

@@Socrates21stCentury so is what you’re calling for if you’re a Giants fan

[@ceezy585]

My take is after watching the jets game last season with zero pass attempts, we go on to win 3 straight and screw our draft pick like usual. Eagles would have secured the top 2 pick by any means. We should be building with jayden daniels right now smh.

[@newjerseyjustin]

i don’t think daboll will get let go i would love to see them get “their” guy in qb

[@Rekthun]

Us vikings thought the same thing when we lost dalvin cook. How bad could it be with Mattison? A lot worse apparently

[@ayyubjackson]

Cellar dweller is a hilarious phrase

[@blueknight5754]

Thanks for this!

[@GTBreezy]

Carson Beck or Drew Allar future giants QB.

[@MPAndoru]

A giants fan has his family at gun point

[@mikeymike2524]

I find it funny that you said tyrod can’t win a Super Bowl… I think he could win one with the jets if Rodgers goes down. He balled out for us and almost won that game against the bills. Might seem like saying a lot but when you look at how good the jets can be with a quarterback that’s not Zach Wilson it gets more real

[@tayewatson6754]

They can have a top 10 wr core with good QB play and top 10 defense with a QB that can give them rest

[@TrollKing2781]

Unfortunately, they have a trashcan at QB.

[@carlosflores7064]

Thank you- Barkley is a beast

[@klabkebash]

Jalen Hyatt is good. DJ just couldn't do anything and for whatever reason Daboll took him out of the offense last year.

[@RJJSmith3]

biggest issue the giants got right now is cornerback and its not even close

[@Luke-ji8to]

people calling the giants the worst team in the league are crazy. We’re going 7-10 easy

[@nathanmillones8798]

No.

[@zackhurwitz9441]

From an overall roster/coaching situation, no. But their division is top heavy, and they have the least promising QB in the division as well. They might not be the worst team, but if certain things go wrong, I could see them with the worst record, and picking in the top 5.

[@yaahlabanyamyan144]

​@@zackhurwitz9441 that's fair. I have them finishing 7 - 10 HEALTHY. With injuries I give them 5 - 12

[@jerichotonumaipea7429]

Is… is this satire?

[@BlendedCreeper]

That’s a loser’s mentality. 7-10 = 0-10.

[@bark2650]

Great video man

[@thellytell262]

As a Giants fan I feel like this is one of the most boring teams in the league. Playing for nothing, not being shockingly bad or any good. Hope for some Nabers moments and a good draft pick.

[@choppy4201]

They should not pay people iff of potential it is back firing really hard right now

[@yaahlabanyamyan144]

I believe they will actually post a top 10 defense. The offense will be bottom of the pack however. 7 - 10 and I'm a Giants fan

[@judewhite4401]

Similar to the 2022 Broncos and 2022 Jets.

[@MattyIceSports]

I respect that

[@TrollKing2781]

Top 10 D, Na. Definitely not gonna happen.

[@MattyIceSports]

@@TrollKing2781 eagles fan spotted

[@TrollKing2781]

​@@MattyIceSports No way in hell giants are gonna have a top 10 D with that secondary. Just being realistic. Something a lot of giants fans struggle with.

[@glennyates2194]

Good takes.

[@mydogvlad]

Great content

[@94dfk1]

Gee, I wonder what one BIG problem is...

[@Smackcity00]

Give Drew lock Solid games to get comfortable and get rolling

[@akinmike5884]

I think they should have kept tyrod honestly our best football came from him and tommy

[@SpunkyStreams]

Love you too man ☺️

[@mrjohn71398]

How many chances can a qb get in the NFL, usually you get 2 seasons then you’re done. Should’ve never resigned him