How have PENALTY KICKS Evolved from 1900 to 2021? - THE EVOLUTION OF FOOTBALL

[@skillNshoot]

Appreciate the shoutout Kieran 🙌🏼 Petition to bring back the old MLS penalties 😅

[@KieranBrown]

thanks guys! - Check these guys out for more awesome football content!

[@kevinraidna5633]

4th Like

[@Lucas11profile]

@@KieranBrown hi great video 👍🏻

[@yunga.1541]

@@kevinraidna5633 no 1 asked

[@bbg5823]

@@kevinraidna5633 128th like

[@hiteshkumarsolanki8096]

No one thinks about the hard work what kieran does :- For looking the old videos, shooting all day! Hats Off to you!!!

[@MR.ICE.]

@Dimia x Getting paid doesn’t automatically cause hard work to become irrelevant.

[@overall1937]

It is his job

[@MR.ICE.]

@Honest Manchester United Fan Then why mention that he’s getting paid? We all know he is.

[@jenniferlarke970]

Sure thats his job and what he wants to do. He doent have to do all that if he doesnt want to.

[@ballerinChrist]

TEAM JESUS 💪 🙏 🕊 PRAISE THE LORD SPREAD THE GOSPEL ACCEPT HIM INTO YOUR HEART FOR ETERNITY BEFORE IT IS TOO LATe JESUS LOVES YoU❤ SPREAD THIS MESSAGE TO OTHER(S) OR OTHER(S) VIDEOS. YOU CAN DO THAT BY COPYING THIS AND PASTING IT TO OTHER(S) VIDEO OR OTHER(S)

[@masterwill2078]

This is my kind of history lesson.

[@CozmoGOAT]

I wish school was like this lol 😂

[@yunga.1541]

@@CozmoGOAT same

[@spiritzmisty3328]

@@CozmoGOAT same

[@nikodemstarczewski5122]

I wish school felt our pain with history

[@nikodemstarczewski5122]

Same

[@juwansimmons7612]

If a game that went into penalties in this generation used the coin clip technique guess how intense the game will be

[@kevin-gw6dj]

Imagine the "it's corrupt" scenes...

[@Oll1000]

Imagine the riots if France actually won

[@frederic6998]

No

[@gemma_fitzpatrick27]

Who knew a history lesson could be so entertaining!

[@airlesssquare06airlesssqua17]

True

[@rodrigoodonsalcedocisneros9266]

Pleople who actually pay attention in class? lol

[@mothegamer1398]

Your videos got me more interested/involved in football

[@sheilagilligan6636]

Op

[@seanwickham8905]

Kudos to the MLS for giving it a try. I've always thought the classic warm-up drill where you have a teammate standing at the top of the 18 playing a give-and-go to a teammate who hits it first-time anywhere outside the box would be a great alternative to penalty kicks. The best part about it is that players practice that technique more than penalties in their lifetime.

[@NickolaySheitanov]

I disagree its total crap

[@squalk8599]

@@NickolaySheitanov I mean it requires way more skill and gives the keeper a better chance. It gives the team with better skill the win and would be much more entertaining to watch them people hitting a dead ball from 12 yards out

[@ballerinChrist]

TEAM JESUS 💪 🙏 🕊 PRAISE THE LORD SPREAD THE GOSPEL ACCEPT HIM INTO YOUR HEART FOR ETERNITY BEFORE IT IS TOO LATe JESUS LOVES YoU❤ SPREAD THIS MESSAGE TO OTHER(S) OR OTHER(S) VIDEOS. YOU CAN DO THAT BY COPYING THIS AND PASTING IT TO OTHER(S) VIDEO OR OTHER(S)

[@KieranBrown]

Whats your go to penalty technique?

[@skilful1079]

Just sidefoot it

[@cepzz2861]

Panenka

[@CharlyOmega]

Welly it 50 feet over the bar

[@CharlyOmega]

@ZoZi And get a yellow card

[@Hassan_Din]

@@CharlyOmega panenka.

[@hazza2231]

Come on Kieran. Banging video. Rarely uploads but when he does they're banging videos.

[@NW-sp1fj]

3:08 here we see the mighty Brazilian pele taking on Gary smith from wolves

[@franciscacacho842]

Pele: *tallys goal for record

[@azzamalwahshi7699]

SO underrated Kieran deserves more subscribers, views and support

[@Bob-rj2oy]

Yeh

[@mohammedanaskizhakappat8344]

kzbin.info/www/bejne/m6qsXqqBbddsd8U

[@miamitten1123]

He has over a million. That’s underrated!?

[@azzamalwahshi7699]

@@miamitten1123 1Million is nothing rn

[@gustavofring2748]

He has a million! The man has made it

[@jodellkesterseegobin2039]

Love the video mate. Just want to add that Adrian Alston first tried the Cruyff turn in WC74 against East Germany, and five days later Cruyff did it better. Thanks for your dedication and hard work making this. Keep up the good work!

[@michaelorr9951]

The MLS style penalty shootout described at 6:00 was only used for the shootout at the end of a tied match; penalties given during the match were conducted in the usual manner. That being said, I would love to see an MLS style shootout being used to settle ties in knockout matches; it at least requires the use of a larger set of football skills than kick and dive.

[@afuzzycreature8387]

only problem i would see with the MLS style is fatigue on the keeper would accumulate faster over longer shootouts than say a hockey shootout. Thus letting in more goals and just making the thing go longer. 2 ragged keepers would then let in almost all their shots. Just something to think about.

[@LeoDragon34]

Excellent vid. As an old bloke who still plays football it explains why kids are so much more skilful than I ever was! And they get more skilful with each new generation that comes through!

[@touchline]

Such a great, informative video. Splendid job Kieran (and Ewan)!

[@CMRTUBE]

The best football content on this platform! Thank you Kieran for all of the hard work you put in these vidoes! I strive to make vidoes like yours one day! Thank you Kieran!

[@carlosbaenanavarro]

Great video, it's funny to see the evolution of a game throughout the decades and think to oneself of what would be the changes of the future.

[@danimaster6647]

Good video with one small correction. If you're looking at Juninho he already did the knuckleball technique in the early 2000s. Ronaldo made this technique in with his amazing free kick against Portsmouth but it has already been there before

[@tashaisibor5422]

Imagine learning this in school, Epic 🤣

[@ka_gwima]

Haha! You wish

[@SagittariusSatellitium]

Pele used all of those skills, he even did the croyff quite often.

[@rigbysan]

Indeed! This kid has more holes in his knowlede than swiss cheese!

[@Jtfreestylers]

Kieran, you always make the best football videos bro!!!⚽️🔥😃

[@KieranBrown]

thank you!

[@KnuckleballTwins]

Sick insight man, *a lot of research would’ve gone into this* - Fair play 👏 Skill & Shoot are 🔥 #Knuckleit 👊

[@Hassan_Din]

Kieran Brown I love the content bro keep it up lad and as always have a good day.

[@ChrisBrown-qf5gh]

Field hockey uses an 8 second shoot out system. Brilliant to be part of, as a keeper or field player

[@malthuswasright]

I suspect MLS nicked the idea from ice hockey.

[@davidantao-football]

Amazing video mate... You have inspired me to start making football videos on KZbin... I've been following your amazing content for a few years now... Awesome work mate.. Stay safe and take care🙌❤

[@thomascarroll9556]

Around 3:10 you give the impression that Pele started in the 50s but Garrincha didn’t arrive on the scene until the 60s whereas the facts are that Garrincha was seven years older than Pele and an established idol before Pele, he made his senior club debut in1953 and international debut in 1955 (although he only made a further six international appearances in the next two years.) Pele made his club debut (aged 15) in 1955, and international debut in 1957. both Pele and Garrincha made their Word Cup debuts in the 1958 competition playing against Russia who they beat two nil and far from pele being the more artistic Brazilians and the football world in general regarded Garincha as the more skilful one. But Garrincha was an indisciplined alcoholic womaniser and died aged only 50, Pele was more careful and became the greatest ever player.

[@kekort2]

I like the MLS penalty kick. It's way more exciting that the 12 yard spot.

[@JJ-nu8qi]

I agree

[@joyfulzero853]

Would it have a tendency to increase fouls in the penalty area?

[@JJ-nu8qi]

I'd say only use it for the end of the game.

[@keysersozefede]

hell no.

[@potxtoe]

Time limit needs to be like 10 seconds though or maybe 15.

[@grabham59]

Really glad this popped up in my timeline! Fascinating stuff!

[@krishfreestyle4113]

Kieran is a legend. Bangers all day 👍👍👍

[@MrJoey1971]

The Hungarian Football Team of the 1950's had plenty of skills.

[@dom37262]

So.... What happened in '54?

[@gazdagpeet954]

@@dom37262 the tournament system was unfair. Hungary won the group stage and played vs Brazil and then Uruguay (50's finalist teams). The hardest route to final. Germany had to beat Yugoslavia and Austria. In group stage Hungary's captain PUSKAS injured. In final Germany's 2nd goal was unfair. (A german player pushed away the hungarian keeper from ball). And at 3:2 Hungary scored a fair goal but the ref ruined it because of offside - it wasnt). I think that world don't want a world cup winner from the eastern block. By the way hungary was way better team in 54. Check all the players and stats about the hungarian golden generation. Hungary 54' Brazil 82' Netherlands 74' 3 best teams, who didnt win the fifa WORLD CUP, but they were legendary I think if you ask your parents / or grandpa, they actually know those names : Kocsis / Puskás / Grosics / Czibor / Hidegkuti

[@neilwadhwa7903]

Mate this would have been so useful a few months ago, I did a project on the evolution of football 😂😂😂

[@nedasworld7435]

Bro I literally can't live on youtube without Kieran Brow amazing

[@markosajn5776]

flip flap, a genius move invented by Rivelinho in 70s

[@flamedflamingo]

Aoa Kieran bro I have been subbed to you for 2 years now Good job man you are one of the best football youtubers out there I see you have grown a lot I'm so happy for you I just re found your channel

[@LucienHughes]

The first line of the video is wrong, pre 1937 the balls were actually slightly lighter - 13-15oz rather than 14-16oz. They certainly were never heavier since standardisation in the 1870s. I think changing tactics are far more to do with the fact that modern balls move through the air completely differently due to their shape and material.

[@LucienHughes]

They also didn't get lighter in the 80s either, ball weight has been pretty much the same for the entire history of the sport

[@georgerubypoppy1063]

@@LucienHughes I was going to mention this myself, but then saw your comment. At 14 t0 16 ounces, It is true the standard football is the same weight today as it was when the rule changed from 13 to 15 ounces in 1937. What has changed are the materials used in the making of the balls, and modern balls resistance to absorbing moisture. Older footballs only gained weight in wet conditions.

[@paulus121212]

Your wrong I have a 1960s ball real leather and it is a lot heavier then one from the 90s

[@malthuswasright]

Might have been lighter at the start of the game, but on a wet day the leather ball would just soak up water and end up weighing a ton.

[@georgerubypoppy1063]

@@paulus121212 Then it isn`t a size 5 regulation football.

[@swavyzt4877]

0:01 those players are massive lmao

[@2_Editz_4]

For real 😂😂

[@jackyarbrough4480]

crazy how much football has changed within such little amounts of time

[@bsloth74]

The MSL penalty shoot out is like in field hockey- sometimes you do penalty flicks and sometimes shuffles that are like the MSL penalties

[@oguiarcanjo]

Quick comment: the Elástico wasn't a signature move created by Ronaldinho. It was created in the 70s by Rivellino, world cup winner in 1970.

[@AdamCoyle08]

You teach me so much about soccer/football. I am a goalkeeper and i love wathching you play and create videos on goalkeeper. Thank you do much.

[@bookemdanno5596]

"In the 1980s with the introduction of more modern lighter footballs" *Shows a 1978 World Cup ball*

[@sandraude1]

the tango was the first light ball

[@shaun.doylee1063]

This is an absolutely quality video Been a fan for years now good stuff Kieran 🙌

[@giles3811]

Damn really like the free kicks and the penalties where shocking back then

[@inigo7776]

The knuckle ball was invented by Didi in the 1950s and the elástico by Rivelino in the 1970s. Maradona rarely went for the top corners too, he almost always aimed low.

[@pksim2073]

Awesome video love form india u are a genius

[@alanbatty3825]

Very interesting video, thank you for posting. A bit surprised you didn't include Puskas and the drag-back, but I have subscribed anyway and look forward to future videos.

[@KieranBrown]

Thank you, glad you enjoyed! - Yeah looking at a few of the comments theres defiantly a few things I missed out!

[@BeautifulEarthhhh]

who needs school when you have this as a history lesson 🤩

[@koen4193]

The 32 meter shootout is still used to this day in field hockey. Not while games then u had penaltys but when it was a draw after a game they would do those shootouts

[@bingola45]

"How have PENALTY KICKS Evolved from 1900 to 2021?" They've gone from a way to redress a foul to a bizarre 'tie-break' in the Final of a major International tournament.

[@xzc_wkeys895]

Love the content mate keep it up👍

[@Imagequest100]

Incredible, a video about the evolution of football and there is not a single reference to Messi, the best of all time.

[@ricomajestic]

Actually the run-up shootout use to be how tied games were decided in the North American Soccer League back in the 1970s and early 80s! MLS adopted in the 1990s but then went back to traditional penalties. By the way, FIFA is considering bringing back run-up shootouts for the 2026 World Cup which will be played in North America of course! Shootouts are way more exciting and require more skill.

[@manuelmuzi4245]

You should have put totti in the euro 2000 when scored with a panenka against netherlands

[@keenbekillin1134]

Hi Kieran, I love your vids ❤️❤️

[@innercityprepper]

I've never been a big MLS fan but I always thought the shootout format was inventive and potentially good for the game. The 12 yard PK should be re-evaluated and AT LEAST brought out to the 18.

[@TheEvapiiShow]

Why? Why make it harder for the striker? It is a PENALTY.

[@DuffyBlanco]

@@TheEvapiiShow I disagree that the shootout should replace actual penalty kicks, but I do agree that it should be utilized in tie-breakers

[@afuzzycreature8387]

@@TheEvapiiShow no, real penalties were treated as a real penalty... ball at the spot etc. the shootout was used after tied games on the presumption that americans can't handle ties and that was the running version. Most of that came from the college (gridiron) football scene where fans and writers had a hard time dealing with the difference between a team that went 10-0-1 and one that went say 11-0. sure you never lost, but you didn't win them all... etc. Ironically the NFL created a system that made for more ties.

[@kabeerguliani2042]

Great video mate, love the dedication

[@realmerdon1123]

The MLS penalties actually looks like a pretty good method

[@JoshAston23]

An actual element of skill. Imagine the tension when it comes to the 6'4" bruiser centre halves (if they even reach the box in 5 seconds..)

[@sultanabran1]

offside rule had a big influence too. nice video

[@nitinsaxena4906]

AWESOME !!!!!!!!

[@makeouthill7696]

I would love to have old school football as my history lessons

[@miguelvidela1294]

He’s talking about history without mentioning messi 😂😂😂

[@ha7der_edits]

Yeah..The worst player on Earth can never be forgotten😊

[@justinysnewspaper1897]

@@ha7der_edits cry more penaldofan girl😂

[@roccog8866]

@@ha7der_edits I don’t like Messi but he is one of the best to ever play the game let me guess Ronaldo ban wagon lmao I don’t even like ronni but I’ve been a juventus fan all my life

[@daseafrate2025]

@@justinysnewspaper1897 8-2

[@ha7der_edits]

@@daseafrate2025 ✅💪Another match..Real 11-1 Barca😂😂😂😂😂😂🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@stevencooke6451]

I really liked this. Kieran has some skills too.

[@brunoactis1104]

3:25 That is actually a misconception, it was created at least 14 years before Cruyff by a paraguayan called Eulogio Martinez, also playing for FC Barcelona at the time.

[@willasrock1]

I get the impression that he assumes everything football related was invented by europeans before the 2000's. Rivellino was doing the Elástico in the 70's.

[@adrianojoseph1169]

Best football channel ever

[@overpoweredxie]

yeh

[@CrotchetRest]

Being Czech myself, it really hurts when Czech player Antonín Panenka - an invertor of "Panenka" penalty (duh) - is being mentioned only as a footnote to Zidane's penalty with a year 2006 being displayed in the video. When making a video about history, how about actually showing Panenka's original penalty, or at least use a year 1976 in the video as a generally accepted year of invention? ;-)

[@Nannyfrank]

This is quality work, very smooth

[@ivanmondragon9927]

I learned more from this video than from going to school

[@idle3277]

I love your vids

[@henpezhd7375]

Notification gang

[@robertrodes1546]

In England in 1970, we used to talk about the Brazilians and their "banana shots." The way they could curl their shots (nothing like what people do today) was quite amazing to us.

[@mkumardh5612]

How could you not include messi in skills

[@Chollimaa]

or in free kicks

[@Kilbotz]

When talking about free kicks you forgot to mention. First the wall wasn't being used until the 1950's and it was because of Brazilian Didi. Who was scoring a lot of free kicks which at the time were like long range penalties. So teams started putting walls up. Secondly Ronaldinho's free kick technique was unique. He was nearly as good as Beckham scoring one more free kick than him but most of his free kicks were from close range. He did a kind of flick with an ankle twist. No one else has ever tried it and it was great to see the type of free kicks he scored.

[@sophiepainter2543]

When your so early the comments don’t even show

[@Kieran2502]

Brilliant vid, however I will say that it’s a pretty common misconception that roberto Carlos used the outside of his foot for his FK. I believe He used his lace but just with ridiculous swerve

[@ffr7779]

Imagine if that 🅼🅻🆂 penalty still exist today. Goalkeeper can save it easier

[@unidentifiedmadman4080]

Yeah but the reason they are hard to save is because of a foul stopped a goal then it should favour the striker

[@nobodyknows1106]

That's Hockey's penalty bois..

[@henfc456]

Top effort in this video a lot of research put into thinks Kieran.

[@NerdPicnic]

We love your vídeos, please keep it up the amazing work!!!

[@abinashrabha1809]

Most dedicated KZbinr ❤️❤️

[@chrismaynard6016]

Still one of the best free kicks was Ernie Hunt (Coventry) in 1970 where Carr flicked the ball up with both feet and Hunt struck it hard on the volley. Brilliant. It was immediately banned however !!! It's on YT.

[@JohnSmith-oe5kx]

Excellent video! While Ronaldinho is definitely better known, it is a shame not to mention Jay-Jay Okocha, who was his briefly mentor at PSG, and had been doing flashy tricks in professional football when Ronaldinho was still a kid!

[@rmkw4291]

The MLS shootout style is basically what they do in ice hockey to separate draws. Start about halfway from the goal, five seconds to score but you have to be in control at all times.

[@aetd106]

Just to expand on that, with ice hockey there's no set time limit but the player must always move towards the goal which is a natural time limit. Football could do the same where the player must move towards the goal - the GK can advance which pressures the player to move forward quickly so that they can't just run around constantly. Could even make a rule where they can't veer further than 6 yards outside the line of each goal post to keep it more direct. That said, with goal line technology and the use of Hawk-Eye I'd like to see certain penalties replaced by an automatic goal like rugby's penalty try: such as a handball on the line. If it's clear that the goal would have scored if not for a foul, just give it. Obviously this would be fairly limited but saves teams being able to essentially cheat to stop an otherwise certain goal.

[@Bart_Allen_YT]

That Ronaldo goal vs Portsmouth was unstoppable

[@AadishMathew]

I appreciate you have better chance to become a club player in national leagues

[@sport-manstan4919]

Once again a great vid

[@stefanlygdopoulos4668]

Great video only criticism I would have is Pele played the majority of his career in the 60s not the 50s

[@KieranBrown]

thanks mate, appreciate that!

[@stefanlygdopoulos4668]

@@KieranBrown keep up the good work

[@Fin_George]

Yeh the content is super I never get bored

[@siddeshrohri5565]

Like always banger of a video

[@bubskyzone531]

I just love you and your channel very well and i even suscribed

[@collector6815]

The goalkeeper really knows what he's doing

[@DjDolHaus86]

I wonder where the game will be in another 20yrs? What kind of skill/tactical progression will have taken place by then? I can't even think of anyone who is changing the current game, skills and flair are now commonplace in every position but there isn't really anyone doing anything unique or outstanding. Quaresma is the only one in recent memory (not particularly recent admittedly) who had a particularly unique skill with his outside of the boot shots but it wasn't like the whole world saw them and decided they needed to add it to their own skill sets.

[@terryoconnor5262]

You had me actual lol at the toe poke!! I ain’t seen that in a while 🤣👍

[@bataitez6983]

Love your videos Kieran

[@danielmclachlan4795]

I play field hockey and the original football shootout is what we use now if a game is drawn at full time!

[@cerdanmaximo399]

Amazing content than you for this history lesson 🥳

[@sirkakoly208]

Its so cool to have a youtuber live in the same town as you

[@danieleyre8913]

I forgot about how the American MLS experimented with penalties. I remember at the time thinking that it sounded like a pretty cool idea. Does anyone know why it was dropped? Did it fail and why?

[@pratiksr2914]

This is the kind of history lessons i want

[@HimalayanEyewear]

Very interesting, Kieran!

[@arberkaltani5655]

I LOVE YOUR VIDEOS KEEP UP

[@elber-fb1yx]

Your channel is so dope my guy