Forgotten History: the Romani (Gypsy) Migration from India to Europe

[@OddCompass]

Thanks for watching, everyone! Hope you enjoyed the video and learned something new. If you'd like to get your hands on a hoodie, mug, sticker, t-shirt, tote bag, or other item in our store, check out the link here: oddcompass.myshopify.com/?

[@dalitnahipehlehinduhu6569]

Hey buddy ur most unbiased historian I've ever seen...thanks brother for this deep researched video.. please make a video on how cruel the islamic invasions happened in India bcoz many don't know how brutal the raids and incursions were

[@fessali5726]

India didn’t exist when they left so saying they came from India doesn’t really make sense.

[@rebecavillanova7622]

@@fessali5726 Also this video is trying to put the blame on Islam for the emigration of the gypsies,when in fact Islam didn't exited when the first migrated out of Rajasthan, the true homeland of the gypsies.

[@PiadasEyer]

ANCIENT MAP OF INDIA HAS TIBET & BURMA... CUZ IT IS DRIFTING SUB CONTINENT..

[@fessali5726]

@@rebecavillanova7622 the person making this video knows they are completely lying. They have been brainwashed to think Hindus have had power for a long time and Muslims are only barbaric. When in reality islam Brant civilisation to a dysfunctional society where law was not observed excerpt what was dictated by cast system. The same caste system used by Hindus today. They use any excuse to change history. Hindus are very bad to people with different backgrounds. Always have been and always will be. They don’t even accept Dalits as human beings. Who are Hindus. This video should be removed from KZbin. Please report it.

[@Anton-tf9iw]

I live in rural South India and about a year ago several families of North Indian Gypsy blacksmiths stayed in 3-4 villages around for 1 or 2 months. They practiced their skills right in front of you, forging tools from old truck springs. No begging or dancing, just production & trade.

[@theduck0]

I think you might be referring to North Indian nomads, since the term "gypsy" refers to European Romanis/Sintis only. Although the Roma do have distant ancestral connections with them, they are not the same ethnic group.

[@yingyang6080]

Well, this does not happen in Europe... they engage in other types of "activities".

[@advaitaveda5671]

@@yingyang6080 cause u lot are xenophobic towards them right from the beginning. And expect wat ?

[@yingyang6080]

@@advaitaveda5671 you do not know what you are talking about and show an utter prejudice towards Western countries. Just bubbling the usual "progressive" 3rd worldism mantras that wherever adopted left rubbles behind. Easy to blame always the "others" and never put yourself in question. Fastest road to misery and failure.

[@advaitaveda5671]

@@yingyang6080 irony u talk about prejudice while categorizing half the earth's population as 3rd world. U know wat/who actually left rubble and rot behind? Yes the Europeans, and there abhrahmism everywhere they set their foot they made sure it turned into a grave yard, as recently as Afghanistan. And u know watelse is more faster way to misery and failure? Presuming only a group of ppl is superior to others and have a god given will/right over others. Sadly if europeans have looked at themselves first before blaming stuff on to others maybe they wouldn't had romani ppl doing other "activities" as u coined. U know one strong mantra that we from a third world country believe in "karma". Karma baby, u reap wat u sow. U show xenophobia towards a bunch of strange looking ppl u recieve the same from elsewhere along with interest.

[@raluca3915]

I’m of Romanian Romani family. Our dna has mostly Indian, then we have Greek, Balkan of course, Turkish, Aegean, Cyprus. My sister did a test so we could know, we are at 34% Indian! 😂

[@Jambudvipa-ug6yg]

mostly is not 34%. you are mostly european genetically.

[@raluca3915]

@@Jambudvipa-ug6yg our biggest percentage comes from India 😏

[@Shiva-nx1tn]

​@@raluca3915true ,Love from India

[@Honeywell233]

Good response dear, welcome to India once it's your ancestral land

[@raluca3915]

@@Honeywell233 thank you!! 😃 I respect and love your culture and people very very much 💚🤍💛

[@andrewmclaughlin2701]

In the late 1800s Mexico, my grandmother was a little girl that was enchanted by Gypsies that had passed through her area. She followed them out of town. They threw rocks at her to keep her away because they did not want the locals to think she was being stolen.

[@BlngW]

did she told you that?

[@andrewmclaughlin2701]

@@BlngW my momma done told me

[@applesandgrapesfordinner4626]

Sad, but understandable.

[@onewotldgovernmentonlywhen9044]

Many practice a lot of witchcraft and human trafficking

[@BleedFromMyEarsBass]

Your grandma was lucky. In Romania, they are known for stealing everything under the Sun. Sometimes even little kids, to put them in the streets for begging. Growing up I used to see 1-2 year olds sat down for panhandling, because they broke everyone's heart, they would make more money. There were no records back then, so nobody would know if it was one of theirs or a stolen kid. There was no protective services or anything either. Many times, they would bind a stolen child's arm or leg so that it would grow crooked, and then put them out in the street. And that would be a money making machine for these animals, because any person with a heart would give something to help out.

[@believeinpeace]

Thanks!

[@OddCompass]

Thank you!

[@neerajanaghosh4464]

My Indian family came to the United States in the late 1960’s and started living in Scranton, PA. A family acquaintance, a female Indian professor was arrested by the Scranton police because they believed she was Gypsy and had not registered with them. She wore Indian clothes and had no id. It wasn’t until she contacted her college who was able to vouch for her that she was released. My own mother was questioned by the police once.

[@Victor_Grimaldi95]

That's sad. The police were so ignorant! I love Indians.

[@user-vy5uy9fo8p]

So, if the police suspected that someone is a gypsy (no offense meant), they could arrest them for that back then? that's horrible.

[@raclark2730]

@@user-vy5uy9fo8p The racism continues over pick pocketing and begging scams. I don't condone those practices but it is not fair to say all Romani / Sinti do that. You need media approval to have a voice it seems.

[@No14me23]

What college?

[@neerajanaghosh7886]

@@No14me23 Marywood.

[@pthanos]

As a Greek, thank you for explaining the Roma and athingani history. I learned something I was wondering about for quite some time!

[@dove5591]

Greece has big Romani population but Greece hides all its ethnic minorities and denies their basic ethnic human rights. 🥴

[@dove5591]

@@scintillam_dei J2 haplogroup is Turkic

[@eliascommentonly4652]

🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷 19;34 Athens It's obvious Bollywood dances are similar to gypsies And gypsies brown skin are Indian brienne skin I like brown skin women 🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷👋👋👋👋👋

[@dswag8495]

@@scintillam_dei most of Europe isn't blonde the only blondish areas are in England, Ireland, Russia and some German. And even most to half their people aren't blonde. And, some people because of history and mixing can be blonde but not Northern European.

[@deusmachinima1189]

@@eliascommentonly4652 I repeat, indians are not only brown skin. We've got asian looking indians to african looking indians

[@Soul_to_soul_1234]

I met a Romani native in UK and her name was Ramona… She could speak some of the words which we speak in Rajasthan… ♥️

[@kiliang96]

In Spain since we got migrations from India and Pakistan, gitanos (spanish romani) started to refer to them as cousins so I guess they knew something 😂

[@bobwilliams2938]

I'm English rumnychel tree/rook,water/pani,nose/nok

[@ainsyaris2378]

@@kiliang96 yes i have heard of Indian and also Pakistan living in the Basque and Catalan region of spain !

[@randleent7801]

Hi...probably also i met this girl...she was tiny body, long black hair and dark skin...because i'm from Italy and she tell me that was in UK. Her name is Ramona.

[@charananekibalijaun8837]

Ek dui tin ccha panch.... Latcho divas

[@jeffboomhauer2724]

I took a DNA test and found out I’m part Romani Gypsy ancestry…upon further analysis I have genetic markers related to Rajasthani and Punjabi. My family is from Spain Portugal France Greece Italy and Russia ❤️ one day I will visit India 🇮🇳

[@sohis]

look up Flamenco and Kathak dances

[@zakaria497]

@@sohisflamenco is mixed with gypsy,Berber and arab culture. The moors (Berbers) had greater influence on Iberia than Arabs, gypsy was a just a small minority unlike the Berbers who crossed the strait in droves

[@SelvaKumar_1992]

Wow

[@Vk-sk7nm]

You are welcome. Come to Rajasthan.

[@dhruvbharija172]

Please visit kailasa temple once in chhatrapati Sambhaji Nagar in Maharashtra and other caves there

[@dhamalsri]

Indian Gypsies also exist, especially in Central and South India. They are also nomadic and performed ancillary services, they are called BANJARA. There tradition relates them to Rajasthan and North Sindh area

[@sulusukta3935]

Yesss .... Banjaras

[@xXxSkyViperxXx]

in the philippines, at least in Filipino/Tagalog, we have a word known as "banyaga" and this means "foreigner", but other local languages, it means "trade"

[@krpranjal6]

Yes all these descriptions were reminding of Banjaaras

[@preetamyadav7952]

@@xXxSkyViperxXx Maybe bcoz of sanskrit nomadic trading community . B anajara in india were ancient nomadic trading community

[@xXxSkyViperxXx]

@@preetamyadav7952 it's because malay traders brought the word they said before "berniaga". the malay traders themselves got the word either indirectly from portuguese traders saying "veniaga" or directly from sanskrit traders saying वाणिज्यक (vāṇijyaka)

[@rouldennn]

The Indian people have greeted and sheltered Persians once and we owe this to them. I’ve never met Loris in my life but I hope that they finally find the peace they have been seeking for decades. 🇮🇷🇮🇳

[@darrydad8288]

I've been there... Even they have their own province in iran called lorestan. They are nice people btw

[@LuisAldamiz]

@@darrydad8288 - Those are Lurs, who are more or less Kurdish, not the same as the Loris, who are semi-nomads of Balochistan in the opposite end of Iran.

[@bowiethedog6285]

​@@LuisAldamiz The video creator really should have clarified that Loris are not the same as Lors, far more people have heard of Lors, and they're gonna confuse them now

[@tareshhh]

Yeah the zorostranians came here because they were persecuted amd wiped out by islamic Caliphates. so were the jews. so are the armenians...till this date. so were the hindus and Buddhists of south and central asia. i wonder why a single religion is responsible for people of so many other different religions to either convert to leave their homeland.

[@YashSharma-rx3ff]

Are you really Iranian?

[@krooz79]

Hi I am a Roma person who lives in UK I want to say a huge thank you for this video its nice to see our roots around the world. To be honest I feel very upset tht through centuries we have not been able to find a stable an safe place on earth till this say I have no country i live in London but born in poland which makes me polish roma. Hope fully more people will understand and learn about Roma history. Thank you :)

[@urracabolivar1374]

I am from Panama city, Panama and my mother used to tell me that my great grand father was a gypsy, and that he died in Panama while taking care of his circus bear. I aways thought it was a lie until I did my DNA and I found out I am 20% Gypsy.

[@PolHa-gv4js]

How about go back to india

[@TheAtomoh]

I don't know if it is the case in the UK too, but here in Italy romani people don't behave well. They usually join the occasional mafia-like group together with romanians and albanians, and all they do is begging and home invading. I've been home invaded by them more than once. All of my friends have been robbed by them at some point. They live in camps made of slums and caravans, burning their trash all the times. We already have to deal with the mafia and other criminal organizations, and their presence in my country doesn't help at all. The italian government, being the absolute joke that it is, doesn't do anything to integrate them into italian society or do anything to give them the opportunity to live like normal people.

[@Zzzooooppp]

Poland was safe for Roma that wanted to integrate.

[@jayflo714]

Sounds like personal choices cause you to move around. Blend into the local culture and gain a useful skill or trade

[@SintiSchneck]

Hello I am a Sinto ,from Sinti People in Germany . Thank you 😘❤️ for portraing the Sinti and Roma History, Independently of another, in this video, and the fact that you underlined the ethnic independence of both peoples is also to be credited very highly.The story of the two peoples isn't very easy, but you put a lot of effort into it, it shows and it's summarized pretty well. I also like the many Facts you brought up about each Community and the slavery & Gipsy Hunting as a sport 👍🏽 Thank you for bringing awareness to the world & Indian subcontinent about our story😘. I have absolutely nearly nothing to criticize except the word "Romani" which Ian Hancock invented and which I and many Sinti dont like.

[@eliascommentonly4652]

🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷 19;34 Athens It's obvious Bollywood dances are similar to gypsies And gypsies brown skin are Indian brienne skin I like brown skin women 🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷👋👋👋👋👋

[@sugomaamogus1662]

@@nationalist3227 uttralund is worst state 🤣

[@ranapratapsingh3416]

Good to see you my Indian brother from North West India.

[@sjefkerolleman2094]

I am a Dutch Yenian Traveler Yes, we are all over Europe Don't mind all that politically correct history We know the truth

[@SintiSchneck]

@@sjefkerolleman2094 Yenish People have nothing to do with us

[@Dosaskillz]

It’s so fascinating to imagine a language that’s a linguistic sibling of Gujurati/Rajasthani/Marwari/Bhili that’s predominantly spoken in Eastern Europe. The world is an interesting place. I wish more people appreciated how much painstaking research, writing and planning goes into your videos- as fans of Asian history (and really any type of history), we’re all lucky to have someone who’s so passionate about being thorough and objective about less-covered topics. We need to get you more subscribers- let’s goooo!

[@unknownmaster5078]

Romani is closer to Punjabi, Gujarati, Sindhi, Rajasthani, Marwari and Bhili. When the Romani left India northwest India was still speaking Prakrit.

[@atlasaltera]

You're right that our world abounds with endless geographic ironies. I love coming across language groups in unexpected areas.

[@jestfuldemigod]

@@john.c I was in Romania recently and was stunned to see so many Indian-like faces, made me feel like I was in Northwest India. However We didn't hang out around gipsy areas because they seemed quite dangerous.

[@eliascommentonly4652]

🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷 19;34 Athens It's obvious Bollywood dances are similar to gypsies And gypsies brown skin are Indian brienne skin I like brown skin women 🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷👋👋👋👋👋

[@nsk660]

@@unknownmaster5078 can u tell me more about prakrit ,like it's origin and geographical span and how it got lost

[@kathleenstoin671]

I recently took a DNA analysis and discovered that in addition to my European ancestry, there were ancestors from India (Gujarati and Punjab) in my line. I had read that the Gypsy people had come from India, so apparently, I have some Gypsy DNA from medieval Europe in addition to French, Italian, Spanish and Swedish. An interesting mix. Very interesting video. Thanks!

[@muhammadumariftikhar8003]

That's so awesome. Regards:a punjabi gujjar.

[@kathleenstoin671]

@Muhammad Umar Iftikhar I think so, too! I was very pleased to find out about that part of my ancestry.

[@patricemoutoussamy6305]

My test gave me west african ancestors but also greek, balkans, scandinavian, italian, north west europe, iberic and south asian mixture. Very interesting mix too.

[@kathleenstoin671]

@@patricemoutoussamy6305 I think there is only one race--human!

[@patricemoutoussamy6305]

@@kathleenstoin671 same here.

[@Maidaseu]

I'm an Irish traveller and we are similar to the Romani culturally speaking. My great grandfathers were tinsmiths who were called Tinkers (derogatory term in Ireland). It's insane how until recently we still had intinerant lifestyle. Our honour/shame system always reminded me of Punjabi and islamic societal norms.

[@nibbin_official9877]

grandpa wouldn't be proud of you.

[@patrick-bu3eq]

The Netherlands has tinkers(kampies, woonwagenbewoners, reizigers.) too, they used to do the same jobs back in the day like sharping knives, etc, as Irish travellers did in England, these people however were mostly of Dutch stock though. Gypsies are another story here. Local councils forced them into council camps though so not many of them left these days only a handful of die hards.

[@TheRealMycanthrope]

​@@nibbin_official9877based on what exactly?

[@bighappygomateshwara8794]

I can switch between two spirits, Irish and Scottish, depending on what is on sale. 😅😅😅

[@ferencfarkas2729]

Yes as a Roma that’s very true Irish travellers indeed have very similar way of life’s cultures and etc to us .. respect to the Irish travellers from a Roma ❤☸️💪🏼✌🏽

[@kalinystazvoruna8702]

Back in the late 1960s, I took an anthropology course from Rena C. Groper at Hunter College in NYC. She lived with the Romani in India for 20 years and was the one who figured out that the "Gypsies" and the Romani in India were the same people. She spoke their language fluently, as did her two children. Fascinating course.

[@NoahBodze]

Did she tell you they’re roving bands of parasites or are you going to have to learn that lesson in real time, like when they tell us black people are victimized but they’re the actual killers?

[@kalinystazvoruna8702]

@@NoahBodze Your hatred of anyone that doesn't look/act like you is showing.

[@NoahBodze]

@@kalinystazvoruna8702 YOU believe I am superior, stupid, or else you wouldn’t be here. Don’t you know you’re presence here is a confession of who’s better?

[@valevisa8429]

There are no people called Romani in India.What are you talking about ???

[@kalinystazvoruna8702]

@@valevisa8429 The original tribe was not named "Romani". I don't remember the original name of the tribe. I took this class in *1967* and Rena C. Groper was the professor who lived with them for over 20 years. See: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Romani_people for more information. It does not dispute what I wrote.

[@nrj8241]

There is a Banjara Community still in India who never settles at one place and make their living by travelling all over India & selling their beautiful crafts where ever they go but we never had any problem with them infact they are considered as blessed by gods due to their high skill in Music, Trade, Handcraft, Herbal Medicine & Black Magic.

[@rosalind1635]

"Magic" 😅

[@lykkemarieofficial]

I'm Romani! I'm a mix of indian, italian, turkish, middle eastern and of course - central european DNA! It's so cool!

[@Darkwolf-mv7hj]

This is a big lie. The Pakistanis converted to Islam. The largest country with a plurality of Muslims is Indonesia, and it is not Arab. Arabic is a race and is not a religion. There are Christians and Jews who are Arabs to this day living with each other in Saudi Arabia, Yemen, and Qatar.

[@BornKafir]

​@@Darkwolf-mv7hj everyone is converted. It's a fictional mythology, invented 1400 years ago. Go read how Arabs were converted. Race is a made-up thing by eugenicsts. Yemen has how many jews, are you even aware? All the children of concubines produced mixed kids. If you want to play by the race angle then arab are mutts/mudbloods/mullato

[@farhanpathan2976]

​@@Darkwolf-mv7hjthey converted very slowly and even the after conversion the Islam of Indians was very different from Islam in Persia or Levant.

[@kartuli-Sher.]

You should visit Banjara community widely found Rajasthan in India , from where your ancestry matches and when you will them them that you have same geneline, they are not gonna believe .

[@skillbuilderzone]

I am a rajasthani ( Indian first). We migrated from Rajasthan towards the east after the partition and settled in Orissa. I did my DNA test and it points to Sindh/Rajasthan/Afghanistan (just these three). It is interesting how religious reasons meant converting or get killed. Not sure how my forefathers survived those times and we still practice Hinduism . This video explains perfectly , the forced migrations.

[@junyjunaid360]

“Get killed” 😂😂 dramatic much buddy

[@keralanaturelover196]

😂😂 😂 tribal gypsy

[@StoicSamurai123]

@@keralanaturelover196 I NOTICE U AL IN COMMENTS U ARE FULL ANTI HINDU AND DONT KNOW HINDUISM

[@RadicalAntifa]

​@@keralanaturelover196kerela rice bag

[@yassineidrissi8812]

mostly convert or pay tax for religion, and ofc death happens in war in taking a land or defanding a land

[@leenagoyal2403]

Finally someone made an informative video on the Romani's Indian Origin, it's so good to see people getting to learn more about such forgotten people! Thanks, Odd Compass :)

[@Bolognabeef]

Trust me they're not forgotten. They make they're presence known everywhere they go

[@eliascommentonly4652]

🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷 19;34 Athens It's obvious Bollywood dances are similar to gypsies And gypsies brown skin are Indian brienne skin I like brown skin women 🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷👋👋👋👋👋

[@sublimefermion2205]

@@Bolognabeef How?

[@Bolognabeef]

@@sublimefermion2205 pickpockets and catalytic converter theft

[@poldi2233]

@@sublimefermion2205 Stealing, fraud, littering, settling with their caravans on someone else's land, basically any illegal shit you can think of, they do it

[@yashrao5269]

Its a shame that our education system never talks about topics like these in our history textbooks

[@Mrinalini.m]

Mughals Mughals British British Mughal British !!😡

[@mansakarimi]

@@Mrinalini.m Hindus have no rich history. They only try to manipulate and rewrite history or claim Muslim legacies

[@Mrinalini.m]

@@mansakarimi Hahaha !!! Bhikari Mughal india aake aiyyash !!! Go and See WORLD’s LARGEST ECONOMIES data available on various sites from 1 AD onwards

[@Mrinalini.m]

THE RED FORT WAS BUILT BY TOMAR DYNASTY IN 1050 Ad!!! How DID AKBAR ORGANISE MEENA BAZAAR IN RED FORT !!😂😂😂😂 SO CALLED shahjehan built iT 😂😂😂 GO AND CHECK ELEPHANT STATUES AND HINDU DESIGN MOTIFS ALL OVER THE RED FORT AND ENTRANCE TOO !!! Statues are allergic to Muslim religion 😂😂😂😂

[@Mrinalini.m]

@@mansakarimi kzbin.info/www/bejne/oXfPZYyaq6l4lZo

[@sven_86]

Fun fact, there are gypsy tribes all over India too. i.e they did spread into India from their original areas. I am from the south and there is a well known gypsy tribe that were hired as mercenaries to guard a fort in an area near my own origin (they had originally come from the north) and then became more migratory after its collapse some centuries later after. But they still hold their fort-clan name and the stories regarding it. They have very unique customs not local to the area too. So not all gypsies spread only to the west, they spread in all directions, its just that they stick out a lot more in the West.

[@daksh6388]

I don't know if they are the original gypsy people but they are alot similar, we call them "Banjara".

[@BG-it7hb]

They are not Gipsy, they are nomadic Indian tribes. The term Gipsy refers specifically to the ones that went to Europe

[@faithlesshound5621]

@@BG-it7hb Maybe you should use the term "Traveller," which lacks ethnic connotations. In the British Isles there are many travelling communities, which have overlapping but different customs and also ethnic origins. There are the Romanies or Romanichal, but there are also Irish Travellers and Highland Travellers whose language contains Gaelic elements. There are also New Age Travellers who seem to have developed from the Hippies and attendees at music festivals of the 1960s. Margaret Thatcher sent the police to raid the New Age Travellers and the midsummer solstice celebrants at Stonehenge. Right wing politicians and newspapers continue to persecute the Roma as well as the latter groups. Thatcher and John Major brought back mass unemployment and expanded that to include homelessness and begging on the street for all communities. Now we have tented shanty towns in all major cities and also associated with Amazon warehouses. The right to live by the roadside is constantly being eaten away, and local authorities exert themselves to stop caravans going onto unused land. The law even forbids people to settle on land they own: permission to do so is usually refused, even when there is a legal need to provide spaces for caravan dwellers. The police conduct raids to evict families from caravans on their own land. Just recently, the right to camp in a tent on unused land without permission from a landowner in England has been removed: it's still allowed in Scotland. The people who operate circuses and travelling funfairs are itinerants, who overlap somewhat with the gypsies. I should also mention the almost extinct group of families who operated barges on the canal systems. While all this persecution goes on, people from the majority community with houses of their own are free to roam the UK in caravans and motor homes in their free time, and slum landlords rent out caravans on their own land to those who would otherwise be homeless.

[@YashSharma-rx3ff]

@@daksh6388 Which state you are from?

[@vamshikrishnareddy8988]

@Daksh that's true banjara, lambhadi community and many names for their community and I am from telangana Hyderabad and I have a lot friends from thier community and very nice people but it's very sad what happened with them

[@MFIOREN]

I did my linguistic anthropological Master’s work on the Romani people and this video is EXCELLENT! Thank you for such high quality, respectful work! The dozens of Romani language varieties around the world are a treasure trove of borrowings and preservation from the Indic substrata. Great video. Te aven baxtale!

[@coryparni3620]

Do you find evidance of a military origine ? What did you learn ?

[@QuestionsAnswerz]

@@coryparni3620 I am a roma and I actually want to know that too😂

[@ameliapedrego5615]

is your thesis available to read anywhere?

[@coryparni3620]

@@QuestionsAnswerz sashin mush. Mandi romanichal.

[@RobertRodgers-r5h]

Outstanding Reporting! Thank You!

[@ubik8948]

Roma gypsy here thank you for making this video as there’s little to non documentation on our culture also fun fact hindu and gypsy language has a lot similarities

[@arcy63]

The language is Hindi, the religion is Hindu. Although, not all Hindus speak Hindi.

[@shalewhale]

Woah! This was a great video. I had no idea about the connection between Roma people and India. But when you mentioned Sinti, it started to make sense.

[@YellowJacket530]

As someone of Indian descent, I feel for the suffering that the Roma and Sinti people have been through. I hope they're able to find a place to practice their culture in peace without persecution.

[@a.p1675]

I think India has recognised them and invited them back home?!

[@AudioMixedVideoAMV]

@@a.p1675 would like to see them return to rajasthan, their homeland!

[@dustybawls7085]

@@a.p1675 now Europe is their home . The lived there for hundreds of years they have no problem coming to India or staying there but now they feel Europe as their home you cannot do that. Dosent matter indian is indian you don't have to be in india to be indian

[@a.p1675]

@@dustybawls7085 they have no home. Nomads. They go were the money is.

[@dustybawls7085]

@@a.p1675 then why are you suggesting them to come to India 💀

[@hayktt]

I am Armenian and the video is absolutely fascinating. Do you have more information on the Armenian loan-words in Sindhi language? It was a new discovery for me and I would love to learn more about it.

[@Gypsygeekfreak17]

hello there

[@ale_papa]

I had an Armenian friend / work mate in Northampton, UK back in 2010. I did my part time job in Greencore while studying there. His name was Bairam. In Hindi - Bhairaam (Meaning: Lord Rama's brother). This name was more common in ancient Gujarat(western India) then now. It was a revelation.

[@hayktt]

@@ale_papa I think his name is related to Arabic word Bayram which means "blessed" rather than the Hindi word. In any case it's not a common name here, I don't know any Armenian with that name.

[@ale_papa]

@@hayktt Maybe you are right... he was a Sinti btw

[@ares01397]

This channel deserves millions of subscribers.. beautiful animations with amazing story telling..Thanks for existing,Old compass ❤️

[@SintiSchneck]

Yes He did a very good Job ❤️

[@urosmarjanovic663]

No, it's bullshit.

[@mallikadas]

India and Indians, two things in the world show great tolerance for suffering.

[@phillipholland6795]

praying for all the minorities being oppressed in India right now

[@vv6533]

@@phillipholland6795 f off with your concern trolling

[@jirachi-wishmaker9242]

@@phillipholland6795 Show concern for the one in muslim nation Because in India , muslim population is well over 200M

[@ashokbobade9257]

@@phillipholland6795 muslims ruled India for 800 years, so they aren't oppressed

[@salar1586]

The europeans are not even guilty 1% it was stupid to move to Europe with a different culture back then, we didnt come to you you came to us things like this happened in history

[@marcowen1506]

The treatment of these groups in Europe has varied across the centuries. My grandmother grew up in rural Ireland and she remembers the 'Gypsies' as tinkerers, tinsmiths, menders and traders in small goods. Their reputation as useful was so widespread that, if you broke something, 'better find a Gypsy" was a common response.

[@faithlesshound5621]

Now that everything is made of plastic, repairing metal goods is not so necessary. Maybe an itinerant community of 3-D printers will grow up to meet that gap in the market.

[@oaktonj5438]

Your grandmother was talking about Irish travelers which are an entirely different group of itinerant people & are genetically Irish.

[@sutapasbhattacharya9471]

Going off on a slight tangent here but, in regard to metalwork and India, did you know that in the 1790s English experts declared Indian wootz (the steel from which Damask swords were made) to be the best steel in the world and Sheffield etc. copied its techniques whilst steelmaking (as with all other manufacturing - see below) was was suppressed in India to keep it a Captive Market pauperized by the piratical British who (according to research published by Columbia University Press) in 2018 stole US$45 Trillion from India over 190 years of occupation. Prior to British occupation, Mughal India had the world's largest economy with over 25% of global GDP. In 1616 English ambassador Thomas Roes described Delhi as the Treasury of the World. Indian cottons dominated the world market (revolutionizing European clothing), and it was the silver drain due to India's successful exports that was a major factor behind British conquest with its systematic elimination of Indian textile competition including breaking weavers' fingers and cutting off the thumbs of Dhaka Muslin weavers (Dhaka Muslin which cost many times the price of silk can no longer been made due to this). As mid-19th Century historians, H.H. Wilson and Friedrich List both noted, Britain's cotton-based Industrial Revolution could not have taken off without the systematic destruction of competition from cheaper and superior quality Indian handloom cottons - even with steam power. Similarly, the oldest seaworthy ship in the Royal Navy HMS Trincomalee was built by an Indian company in Bombay in 1817 (of superior Indian Teak) but British shipbuilders made parliament pass laws stopping shipbuilding in India. In 1770, the EIC started shipping Indian opium to China which brought in 1/7 of UK export revenues for 140 years. Furthermore, whereas Ireland suffered one great manmade famine created by the British, India was subjected to around 3 dozen such British famines killing tens of millions in British occupied parts of India. It started with the Great Bengal Famine of 1770 which killed up to 1/3 of Bengal Province (then inc. Bihar and Orissa - some 10 million) which William Thackeray's relative Richard Becher had predicted due to British Rapacity. At the same time Robert Clive returned to Britain with his 'loot' (Hindi for plunder) as the richest non-monarch in Europe and his East India Co. mafia henchmen became the new super rich 'nobs' (from nawabs/'nabobs'). This loot largely financed the Industrial Revolution. The 1770 Famine caused a Credit Crunch in Europe in 1772 when dozens of banks collapsed in days due to lack of stolen Indian wealth financing European projects. Adam Smith had to delay publication of his Wealth of nations. In 1877 Cornelius Walford showed that there were 30 famines in just 120 years in Brit-occupied India compared to ony 17 famines in the whole of India in the previous 2,000 years. This is because native rulers (including Indianised Muslims) acted to prevent and alleviate famine with imports of grain, rationing and prohibition of hoarding/profiteering. The British created famines by hoarding and profiteering during droughts, exporting India's grains for British Food Security and Profit and even preventing charitable aid to famine victims. Disraeli's regime set up Death Camps for victims of the 1877 South Indian Famine which gave less starvation rations than Buchenwald for hard labour to famine victims. 94% of inmates died with 5-7 million in total dying whilst record amounts of Indian foodgrains were exported for British Food Security and profit. Disraeli also organized the biggest feast in human history - the 1877 Delhi Durbar - feasting 60,000 for a week [to mark Vicky being named Empress to match her German cousin's 'Kaiser' title] whilst 100,000 a week starved in Madras Province. Famine survivors were coerced into the new slavery of indentured labour in the Caribbean. Such British Crimes Against Humanity continued into the 20th Century. In 1901 The Lancet calculated conservatively from the Census that 19 million had died of starvation in Western India in the 1890s due to such 'Let the Poor Indians Starve' policies - 25% of the UK's wheat came from Western India at the time - industrial Britain was not self-sufficient in food until after 1945. In 1936 George Orwell wrote in Road to Wigan Pier that 100 million Indians must be forced to the edge of starvation so that the British can live in comfort. In 1942-3 White Supremacist War Criminal Winston Churchill - who had actually spent the 1930s campaigning against Indian Independence (not against Hitler) -warning that the British working classes would starve without occupying India - was responsible for the first 1939-45 war atrocity actually labelled a 'holocaust' - the 1942-3 manmade Bengal Famine which again killed millions (although India as a whole produced surplus foodgrains). None of the wartime rationing of food etc. used for White British was applied to India. After British censorship of the huge death tolls were broken in 1943 after over a year - WC acted to prevent Food Aid from the USA, Canada, Australia and even Japan reaching his victims - diverting the food to Britain to manipulate postwar prices and feed ex-Axis Italians. Even Hitler had allowed in Red Cross Food Aid to famine-struck Greece in 1941.

[@faithlesshound5621]

@@sutapasbhattacharya9471 All worth saying, but this is the wrong place.

[@sutapasbhattacharya9471]

@@faithlesshound5621 There is no Right place to put such knowledge! Having lived in Britain since 1967, I know how these facts are suppressed by the British media and so that it gets heard - esp. as the British were demonizing German Crimes Against Humanity on Jan 27th and have been demonizing Stalin for a much smaller manmade famine, the so-called 'Holodomor' in Ukraine as well as the BBC demonizing Indian PM Narendra Modi whilst hushing up their own Crimes Against Humanity [as with the focus on the 1947 Partition violence ignoring how the British mismanagement, leaving India whilst the exact new borders had still not been declared etc. - and the RAF strafing Indian crowds in 1946 etc.]. I have even included this information [partly as endnotes] in my scholarly books on the scientific and metaphysical understanding of Consciousness which are actually being read by professors all over the world in places such as Oxford and Harvard and many in Germany [they have asked for copies - even though I put in a warning to British people that my work exposes British Crimes Against Humanity which were deflected from by historians such as James Mill (who became 2nd in command of the EIC) claiming that India was a Land of Eternal Poverty and Famine supposedly due to 'Hinduism'!

[@marykirmo]

Your art style is absolutely stunning.

[@bassdmin7436]

You hit this video right on the head. Its very accurate. Thank you!! My mom's side is Roma gypsy. My grandparents and great grandparents where from there. Interesting history my family has. I am proud of it too.

[@suyashneelambugg]

Two famous Romanis are : Ricardo Quaresma (Portuguese footballer) & Nairobi from the Netflix show Money Heist (real name Alba Flores)

[@suyashneelambugg]

You can also watch the documentary “Flamenco India” 😊

[@PK-se2jh]

welcome to the Indian family. :D

[@YashSharma-iv7ok]

You look fully European.

[@Peaceful_horizon-f9m]

You are always welcome your ancient home 🇮🇳stay safe💖🙏

[@eviltinymel]

As a Sinti, thank you for making this video. I have been fighting the educational system here in the Netherlands for some time about how we did not even get mentioned at first and its great to finally see more of a change happening and videos like this that are so well researched~

[@Azokyjuf902]

​@Arosh Lush Sooner or later we gonna invade little irrelevant village countries of East Europe and create Gypsystan for Romanis.

[@yashbhatnagar1478]

@@slashtab yes but what when did indians showed racism to roma people

[@Please_domesticat_pet]

​@Arosh Lush 😊 it's just a game of money 👍 (after a long time and now just one more generation)

[@Cymopolia]

Hi there! I am Dutch myself, graduated not that long ago. it’s crazy to me that we never learned any of this during history.

[@tm-vg8rx]

❤from India

[@rollsroyce4249]

I've been waiting for this for months. What a pleasant surprise!

[@isabelferran1883]

I'm spanish, and I'd like to say that even if in the past gypsies have been chased and abused in my country, they are now a regular part of the population, integrated, but keeping their habits, and deeply admired because of their art, which I'm very surprised no one has mentioned: they are wonderful singers and dancers. Flamenco is spanish gypsy music and dance. Also, their number is much larger than mentioned in the video (200.000? no way), they are more than 1.000.000 in Spain, over 600.000 in Romania, 200.000 in Hungary... just check it. And, there were already gypsies in Columbus third trip to America.

[@spaniardsrmoors6817]

yES, we Spaniards are a mixture of Arab, N. African, Jewish, Romani and PROUD, mi amigo!

[@Laurajd]

Flamenco is from the Spanish, specifically from southern Spain, Andalusia. The gypsies came only 600 years ago, when the culture of Andalusia was more than formed with flamenco among other traditions. Furthermore, there are no gypsies singing and dancing flamenco outside of Spain, so don't tell lies.

[@adriennvarga6869]

Hungarians hate us. But they hate each other as well, they humiliate everyone😂They have the complex of superior race😂I love Spain, greets!

[@taliahass1234]

@@spaniardsrmoors6817Ya’ll kicked out the entire Jewish population in the 15th century but nice try. There’s like a few thousand left that probably immigrated in the last few centuries.

[@greeenjeeens]

​@@spaniardsrmoors6817This is a modern sentiment, gitanos still live in worse conditions and the jews and arabs were long ago evicted.

[@atlasaltera]

Wow, it's been a while! What a great topic to cover! I love the geographic ironies embedded in the etymologies of the exonyms/derogatory terms used by all the cultures that came in contact with the Romani. Degree/distance of migration does that for ya. And competition in trades and artisan crafts in corporatists societies, plus anti-itinerancy suspicions by sedentary cultures will do the rest in dehumanization. Thank you for covering this fascinating history of migration beyond the etymologies and folklore.

[@eliascommentonly4652]

🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷 19;34 Athens It's obvious Bollywood dances are similar to gypsies And gypsies brown skin are Indian brienne skin I like brown skin women 🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷🇪🇺🇬🇷👋👋👋👋👋

[@singhdeepak10]

Gypsy or Banjaara/बंजारा we say in India, Gypsy community are shown in most of the Indian movies on King's and Queen's. We as Indian's never paid any attention to Gypsy shown in movie's, because somehow they are still in our subconscious it's not something odd for us.

[@gisellemason9588]

I am Roma decent. Thank you for explaining our history. ❤

[@dhruvmodi1]

How is it there mate? Where are you from?

[@princepalsingh7304]

U should be come punjab

[@shawnmicheal9638]

Your facial features looks like indian

[@bhadwamodi8294]

Go to Indian Punjab and try to get a role in Punjabi movie.

[@vishaljassal772]

Thank God ur ancestors moved

[@jchow5966]

This channel has great content - and very well made. Top notch history lessons.

[@thisislilraskal]

I hope the channel can eventually cover The Philippines - before the Spanish, and the Sultanates of the southern regions. I don't know much about it, I've just learned bits and pieces from here and there, so I know this channel will do the story justice.

[@derbdep]

Initially we were culturally fully Austronesians and share culture similar to the Taiwanese Aboriginal groups, Eastern Indonesian, Micronesian and Polynesian peoples. Then from the 6th century, we incorporated loads of Hindu and Buddhist beliefs and became either with a mix of with our indigenous Pag-Aanito (Austronesian animism). We have documents like the Laguna Copperplate Inscription (900AD) , Buddhist and Hindu devata (diwata) statues ad agimat/amulets, a Mahapratisara Dharani (a Mahayana Buddhist mantra that is used like an “orasyon”), and tons of gold artifacts from that golden period, all made by local people around that time (10th century onwards). Islam came in the 14th century and started the process of oppressing the indigenous and Indic hybrid belief system here, but didn’t do away with the culture which was still a rich and silk and gold heavy mix of Austronesian and Indic-Southeast Asian. Most people were literate in kawi script which they used for religious purposes, and Baybayin script for our local languages. Muslims used Jawi (Arabic script) for writing too. The Muslim preachers and jihadists under Brunei were in the process of mass converting the Tagalogs and Kapampangans by the time the Spanish got here in the mid 1500s. The Visayan groups were staunchly against the recently converted Tagalog and Kapampangans, and instead they staunchly remained Hindu or Buddhist mixed with Pag-Diwata. All groups here were in various “bayan” (small cheiftancies and thalassocratic fortified settlements). They all vied with each other, which sharing a lot of similar cultural icons,and religious beliefs. When the Spanish convinced and bribed local rulers (the kadatuan caste of chiefs and rajahs) to become Catholic and join the Spanish empire in exchange for the Mexican silver they held which the local people wanted to gain predominate with trading with Ming Dynasty China (the rich hegemon of the region, who did away with gold as the standard for trade and moved to a silver standard - silver being rare here in the Philippines compared with gold - the rest was history. Anyone who was under the new Spanish colony were convinced within 2-3 generations to convert from the either the hybrid Hindu-Buddhist-Austronesian religion, system, or Islam to Catholicism. They did this by relying on the already high levels of literacy in Baybayin script to publish missionary booklets and prayer booklets like the Doctrina Cristiana. Those that resisted remained outside of Spanish rule and continued the older cultures, albeit without the gold and international trade they benefited from before. They became the Lumad, Bangsamoro, Mangyan, Aeta, and Igorot groups from among the modern Philippine population today. This archipelago was sold away by the kadatuan, who became the “principalía” (a pseudo caste set up by the Spanish) and cabeza de barangays (community heads), who then became the political dynasties we have even today.

[@romano-fy1wp]

Im romani People and Im love big brother and Sister from India 💙❤️💚💚💚💚💚

[@Luckylee331]

❤❤❤❤❤❤

[@rexs2304]

Love you brother

[@RajneeshSingh-hr4mw]

Love from India 🇮🇳

[@tm-vg8rx]

🇮🇳❤️ India loves you too 😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘😘❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️❤️

[@blowingsmoke444]

Love you from a Romani woman in England ❤

[@omnipresentdude2095]

After so long but worth the wait. High quality in-depth research ,superb graphics and sound design , Truely this channel is a top notch ,hope it reaches to more and more people. Keep the good work going ❤️

[@emotionalIntelligence2078]

The romani didnt just use regular iron for swords etc. It was an alloy mix with scrap metals into iron which made tools rust free, lighter and more flexible for longer time. British records identified the extensive use of "Wootz steel" in india, 1790s as an alloy mix while industrial England had just started to look for proper ratio and preparing the mould.

[@AlwaysStayGeeky]

As a Gypsy, who have been in touch with people who are researching us. They told me we came from Egypt through Persia. (Wich Indeed included parts of India.) And than went west. After the Sinti split, and than the Romani came.

[@ProletarianNuklearWarrior]

Great video but "why go west" needs a correction. They immigrated both east and west, while only in the east they were significantly more assimilated. I'm from Bangladesh and in Bangladesh, they are called "Bede/Bedey" or Bedeni as feminine. The word itself is clearly of a foreign origin as many north Indo-Aryan languages are gendered while Bengali and it's recent predecessors are not. A rough translation for Bede would be "river gypsies". In Eastern Indian subcontinent, their preferred mode of transport for their itinerant lifestyle were boats.

[@wakilahmedd33]

Thnx for the info, always wondered about their origin.

[@Ricardo_Vale]

We are not nomads and never have been. That's a euphemism for antigypsyism and enforced nomadism.

[@ProletarianNuklearWarrior]

@@Ricardo_Vale apologies. Itinerant community would make much more sense for the Bede people.

[@pratiksingh1714]

And north and south too

[@truthseeker3404]

What bullshit. They are known for their caravans! The word "car" and "van" originated bcoz of these gypsies bcoz Europeans were fascinated with their lifestyle of "living on wheel" that gave rise to today's Recreation vehicle industry !!

[@Firetail82]

I once met a gypsy in France about 8 years ago, white skinned by appearance, he was a waiter in a café. he showed me something interesting, in his wallet he carried one single Indian currency note, perhaps to remind them of their origins.. It was an interesting meeting which helped me understand how far our people had travelled. It said that most of Russia and former soviet republics were all following or near the culture that is practiced till today in Bharat.. that's a read for another time I guess..

[@trivane626]

This art is amazing the background music is so good. This video had so much information in 15 minutes too it felt like I was watching an hour of content in a way shorter time

[@mrinalyadav4261]

2:21 dude, you nailed it. Most of south Asians were Hindus and Buddhists, but because of taxes and discrimination they started becoming Muslims, this was confirmed by many foreign writers who visited ancient india

[@muslimproudtobe]

Isla spread in punjab and sindh more by pirs and saints these areas were slowly turned muslim even in pre partition punjab and sindh a lot of hindu and sikhs lived there

[@primordialsoup-uu5vo]

@@muslimproudtobe yeah no, it was by the sword

[@muslimproudtobe]

@@primordialsoup-uu5vo No proof of that you can't force people in mass to forcibly convert

[@yugmathakkar4023]

@@muslimproudtobe They turned Muslim because they would be beheaded and their wives and children would be enslaved otherwise.

[@timepasstubee]

​@@muslimproudtobenikal chuslami mulle 😊

[@svamikailasananda]

I admire this effort to make the Romani and Sinti history understandable. Being an Indian, these questions were in my mind for many years and I had come to draw similar conclusions. Thank you. And welcome back to the land of endless quest and eternal wisdom! Om, Prem and Shanti!

[@bapparawal2457]

Thanks for bringing some light on Indian Subcontinents history. Roma and Sinti people were mostly taken as slaves . When no of slaves became huge they were told to go west. Cause if they went east chances are they would have come back to India. Also Many people fled east and South. E.g. Agarwal community spread to entirety of India to escape those brutal and inhuman invasions. Rajputs and others fought a lot but whenever they got defeated ,results were devastating for the people.

[@Dutch_Uncle]

Not mentioned is that some did go east, into Siberia. I took the Trans Siberian Railroad and one of the stranger experiences was to encounter Gypsiss begging at a small train station in Siberia. One had a Latin cross around her neck, and looked unlike anything Slavic, so I pointed at her and asked "Roma?" and she nodded yes. Our Intourist guide said that indeed there were Gypsy groups, and that their lives were separate, with the men not doing military service, and the children not going to school. She said that they begged for food and for money to buy milk for the children.

[@gaurav-hn5zd]

The Muslim butchers have done no good to this world.

[@vedicwarriorOriginal]

One of the best and thoroughly researched videos on the Romani people that I've watched. Bravo! 💪🙏👍

[@scintillam_dei]

See my videos proving Hinduism is wrong if you are a free thinker.

[@vedicwarriorOriginal]

@@scintillam_dei Will do. 👍

[@IshaSharma-qw9zl]

@@scintillam_dei why are you not replying to my comments on your channel

[@riteshvizz9786]

@@scintillam_dei lol.. fall in line kiddo ,you must be 10 millionth person to hv said that and made a video on this . didnt you just see the video and learn anything ??.. no matter what happens sanatan dharma will survive .

[@scintillam_dei]

@@riteshvizz9786 Why are you upset that I said what I did, and proved what I did in my videos on how Hinduism is absurd and satanic? After all, your religion says all that happpens is COMMANDED by Brahman to happen, so you are fighting Brahman by fighting ME. LOL! You boast that ignorance persists. That's all you got?.... Well, there will be an end to Hinduism, and it's called Jesus' return. I already proved the Bible right in my video on the prophecy of Europe conquering the world.

[@vedicwarriorReal]

ODD COMPASS I love your channel ❤️❤️

[@SinghRoadwayS]

I can’t imagine how much hard work you put in to your videos .

[@incasolja1]

One of the greatest produced history videos i have ever seen on youtube bravo! 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

[@SmokeZ420]

I know so many romani gypsies and when you hear some of the basic words they use a few are as close to Hindi as you can imagine practically the same. They even understand the history of being from india

[@siddhantahuja351]

Hindi itself was created around the 18th century so that indicates you're lying

[@scottdoesntmatter4409]

@@siddhantahuja351 Lemme guess, you're Muslim, right?

[@SafavidAfsharid3197]

Hindi language is different from Punjabi,Sindhi, gujurati and rajsthani languages like marwari, Mewari,etc.

[@vladivostok853]

@@siddhantahuja351 and the words used to create hindi arent from the same family of languages? He said they are similar but its his imagination that they are same lol

[@deusmachinima1189]

Hindi is a recent language. You've got no idea. Moreover, there are many ethnic groups in india. No way a kashmiri is related to a rajasthani

[@bobwilliams2938]

I am an English rumnychel (English Roma version) it's true that we didn't know exactly where we were from and it's amazing the work you folks are doing thank u

[@rjmckenzie4706]

This was a awesome video, for years I have been amazed and curios about Roma history and culture. As someone who loves Indian history I liked how you broke it down and gave the reason of why they left. It's really sad to hear that they were constantly persecuted. I also been praying for them love this video man.

[@AVIANAESMERALDASZISTENNO]

I’m Hungarian, Romanian as well as Romani and it’s important to talk about our culture not to blame Europeans and guilting them but just to educate everyone in general to treat our culture better. Screaming at white Europeans doesn’t make them listen. It makes the situation worse.

[@Gypsygeekfreak17]

Yea yes I agree

[@venkateshnaidu94]

All your ancestors following Hinduism culture

[@cobicobi6417]

Europeans stereotype, oppress them, and don’t want to give many jobs and opportunities. Nothing ever changes when you give someone a pass on their bad deeds

[@huzarion3814]

Are you honest with yourself ? because fact is that stealing is tradition in gypsy culture .

[@thespatulaa]

​@@huzarion3814 💀💀💀

[@singhs2817]

So I was right till now.. Roma's are to be credited for not just blacksmith but music and dance too.. The greatest contribution to European music is 'Guitar' .. Spanish guitar, flamenco and other dances are also are the product of Roma's (Hindu culture).. When in India they saw classical music instruments like Sitar, Tabla, Sarangi etc and they liked it much but since they traveled so much they needed a portable string instrument and hence comes Guitar.. I'm sure Guitar was perfected by European Roma''s .. Muslim invasions only destroyed Hindus and it culture.. And the sad part it is still going on be it in India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan, etc.. In last 200 yrs even Christianity has destroyed Hindus with rampant conversions with the help of Britain, Portugal, France,US etc and after 1947 all European churches got a free pass to convert with there money.

[@kaloarepo288]

In central Europe the Romani (gypsies} are more associated with violin playing than with the guitar and have inspired many a classical composer like Brahms in his "Hungarian Rhapsody" and Ravel's "Tsigane" They have become a bi word for violin playing especially the Hungarian Romani,A gypsy playing a violin, serenading people in restaurants has become a touristic cliche in central Europe and Austria.

[@spongebobsquarepants3144]

As an Indian living in Europe, it hurts to watch how they were constantly downgraded and discriminated upon. Much respect for not giving up and embarking their culture across borders. What a struggle it would have been!

[@mistersteve6705]

Constantly downgraded because the refused to work, they were the laziest and biggest thieves in Europe. And they still are today

[@ivayloivanov3744]

Discriminated? I from Bulgaria and most gypsies haven't payed any taxes and electricity bills from like 20-25 years. They don't let their children to school and also don't pay any fines regarding don't letting their children schooled. It's a little bit better since 2015, but there is still a lot of work to integrate them.

[@VES.]

@@ivayloivanov3744 you forgot to mention that Bulgarians are paying for the apartments they occupie. their kids use school transport paid by Bulgarians. Privet busses just for them. they dont pai for public transportation. they are basically paid to birth children. the social and medical system works mainly for them. they dont need to work because of this. the judicial system works for them and lows protect their crimes. when doing crimes in the west they give us bad name to the point that when foreigner comes to Bulgaria few people asked " why are white" ? ... integration ? they need to be expeled !

[@alegro4046]

Piles of trash and junk infront of their apartments doesnt make them popular neighbors in my city. Also the fact that they constantly try to shoplift, dont have jobs and are up super late shouting at eachother in the streets infront of where they reside.

[@Scar-jg4bn]

They're the refuse of society.

[@thomasthomasphilp4393]

India is the only country which stood up against becoming Islamic inspite of 800 years of Islamic rule.

[@india9unknown]

That is the power of Sanatan Dharma 💪💪

[@k-force8325]

We're still getting attacked, but we retaliate strongly until our usual opponent cry and play victim😂😂😂

[@chetan_naik]

Spain completely regained their territory from Muslims, India lost vast regions to Muslims in the form of Pakistan, Bangladesh and some part of Afghanistan. Chinese resisted as well.

[@timwinterhalter5233]

the iberians over here like "damn guess let's forget about the reconquista"

[@am-pn6oj]

@@k-force8325you didn’t retaliate bro

[@nostalgicgirrl6053]

This is this first video from your channel that got recommended to me probably because I looked up Roma history on google a couple of months ago. Great job with the content and graphics! Especially the part about how unyielding and gruesome the Islamist colonisers were to Indian subcontinent and our local cultures. They destroyed centuries worth of libraries and knowledge as well along with farmlands, religious institutions etc. It makes complete sense why swaths of Indian population chose to flee from the obsessive cruelty of muslim colonisers.

[@scintillam_dei]

Many Indians converted to Islam to escape the oppressino of Hinduism which blames them for being born poor. "Must have deserved it due to bad karma!"

[@mint8648]

They fled towards muslim lands not indian lands

[@whathell6t]

You’re forgetting Christian brutality against the Romanini.

[@pratyushbanerjee2612]

@@mint8648 becoz they were either sold into it or move with the stronger party and through muslim territory they made their way to further west.Many of them moved towards east but most of them towards west mostly through slavery and chaotic migrations and appointments by muslim rulers ....also they had to protect themselves from jiziya so they agreed to work with the muslim rulers.

[@dwarasamudra8889]

@@mint8648 It wasn't just the Romani and Sinti who migrated. There were also massive migrations of Hindus from the Indo-Gangetic plains into Southern India, North East India and the Himalayan regions to escape the Islamic colonisers.

[@LexProntera]

That word sounded familiar, so I looked it up: "The name Athinganoi, a later variant form of which is Atsinganoi (ἀτσίγγανοι), came to be associated with the Romani people who first appeared in the Byzantine Empire at the time. Atsinganoi is the root word for "cigano", "çingene", "cigány", "zigeuner", "tzigan", "țigan", and "zingaro", words used to describe members of the Romani people in various European languages. Today many of these words are still used in a derogatory sense, albeit others are the most common exonym for them in a given language."

[@susanwestern6434]

Didacoy or Didacoys is a UK dialect for Gypsy or Gypsies.

[@susanwestern6434]

Travellers are for Irish Travellers.

[@Zdamaneta]

It doesn't matter, they already tarnished the names Rom/Roma/Romani/Romany/Romanies already and Romanians also got the bad rep as well due to the name confusion. Source: I'm Romanian.

[@kidzor16]

GUCK FYPSIES. OUT OUT OUT OUT OF EUROPE OUT

[@cpuffins]

This art is sooo nice, the style is really charming and expressive

[@rfjohns4452]

So many of us don't know and will never know our genetic history hidden in time. My Mother French background very fair skin but Dad's family came from the area of Hungary. My Sister's some fair others darker always said Dad was from the Gypsies. I myself fair as a child tan dark and it's funny that I pursue the Hindu style exercises as a senior. Peace for everyone in these troubling times.

[@akkkkk813]

❤️❤️❤️

[@akkkkk813]

U mean yoga

[@melg6834]

@@akkkkk813 Nah. Hindu style is more apt since yOgA has been appropriated & distorted beyond measure. It comes from Holy Hindu scriptures, simple as that.

[@j.d.youtube6557]

Take a dna test and your genetic history is no longer hidden

[@LightLoveLaugh]

Many indians are fair skinned with no tan at all but slight yellowish tinge. In my family we are very fair skinned, many indians look like westerns but that does not mean we are from the west. India is just diverse given that indian climate is different at different places.

[@soumalyapaul9220]

One of the best informed channels on indian history , as indian I liked it very much

[@originaluddite]

There's a French documentary made in the 90s called Latcho Drom (which means 'safe journey' I think) and, without any narration, it simply depicts various Romani groups working and playing (music) from India all the way to Spain. Worth a watch, or even just a listen to the soundtrack. One thing that is fascinating is, if you play the album from start to finish, east to west, the musical style flows, and yet the end sounds Spanish while the start sounds Indian, indicating the key role played by the itinerants in these various musical traditions.

[@sidilicious11]

We rented that film on Netflix long ago. Very fascinating film!

[@iviana1367]

Flamenco, Kathak dance are related.

[@originaluddite]

@@iviana1367 Fascinating.

[@HN-kr1nf]

where can i see it

[@sidilicious11]

@@HN-kr1nf we found it on Netflix

[@Ahmed_Reza_Mehrdad_]

As an Iranian I need to note 2 things: 1_There's also a Zoroastrian Persian community who fled the Arab invasion towards India known as "Parsi people". 🇮🇷❤️🇮🇳🇵🇰 2_ the "Lori" mentioned in this video of Indian descent should not be mistaken with the ethnic Lur people of SouthWest Iran whose language is derived from Middle Persian...

[@supersaiyan460]

Bloch in Pakistan and iran both are indian In past Afghanistan and Xinjiang is a part of Indian history you can change race language with mass killing and rape Like scythian mongol ottoman taimur Arab mughal invasion

[@jithumapper7059]

Yeah this Zoroastrian Community now know as parsis. Now they are richest minority in india

[@timbaktuu9845]

I think jains are still on the top​@@jithumapper7059

[@sunnymitra6372]

Ratan Tata and Cyrus Mistry are Parsis 😊 Parsis are the Richest Indians

[@literalmenteeu7217]

Freddie Mercury was of Parsi origin

[@wasaymoria9061]

Thanks for this video. Even as a Sindhi i never knew about the sinti people

[@barrymoore4470]

I had never heard the term 'Sinti' until watching this upload. According to Wikipedia, it is not universally agreed that 'Sindhi' and 'Sinti' are etymologically related, but many Sinti themselves believe they are, and identify Sindh as their ancestral region.

[@nnes759]

Majority of Sindus were converted to islam by Sultans& Muhals since 11-1200ce onward its the reason both Sinti & Roma tried to escape. May be if they went to SouthIndia where 99% avoided it (only 70-75% of Andra) due to geography & strong Chalukiah, Chola, Pallava etc Forces.

[@shayanraj7840]

Because you people are mostly converted , so Islamic republic of Pakistan doesn't include the history of Sinti people

[@sambarvada]

@@nnes759 even thhose fell after some time.

[@nnes759]

@@sambarvada Thank you for responding to my comment, however, your comment cannot be deciphered/ make any sense, can u rewrite it like "even though the Sinti people or Aryans fell to Muslims" " it was the cause for.." etc in two sentence or so + put noun, verb object etc in proper place plz, so I can understand & respond appropriately.

[@aldotheapache6206]

This is probably the best video I've watched on KZbin about the Roma and Sinti People

[@gunjaneighteen]

1000 years of suffering for the Indian subcontinent.

[@valevisa8429]

Do you know any other people who suffered in this world ?

[@gunjaneighteen]

@@valevisa8429 Jews, natives of the America, the Africans.

[@valevisa8429]

@@gunjaneighteen All humans,no matter whey they lived,suffered in this world.Some more,some less.Indians don't make any exception.

[@gunjaneighteen]

@@valevisa8429 go Gaslight someone else

[@valevisa8429]

@@gunjaneighteen As you wish my lord.

[@ratri6110]

Our Indian history book: 🙊🙈🙉🙉🙊🙈🙉🙉

[@satansjihad6353]

But why?

[@Bigdawgs17]

@satansjihad6353!95 even a single things written about ancient indians and the great warriors of India however they wrote about invaders and they portrayed them good everyone knows how evil they were

[@NationalistBhartiya]

.​​@@satansjihad6353becoz we r still studying Britis education not in Indian education system which Gurukul

[@NationalistBhartiya]

​.​@@satansjihad6353fake historian like romila thapar exploited Indian history in Congress time period... But now Modi changed

[@Darkwolf-mv7hj]

This is a big lie. The Pakistanis converted to Islam. The largest country with a plurality of Muslims is Indonesia, and it is not Arab. Arabic is a race and is not a religion. There are Christians and Jews who are Arabs to this day living with each other in Saudi Arabia, Yemen, and Qatar.

[@Kosovar_Chicken]

Thank you for not white washing Islamic colonialism. I’m in grad school for archaeology and it seems academics are afraid to talk about real history when it reflects negatively on non western or Christian people.

[@mint8648]

He’s literally indian

[@Kosovar_Chicken]

@@mint8648 Ok. I’m just saying the perspective is valuable. I don’t care what race he is.

[@anitathakur9340]

he's american

[@noahtylerpritchett2682]

@@anitathakur9340 he's American of Indian origin.

[@anitathakur9340]

@@noahtylerpritchett2682 well mostly americans of indian origin are usually the ones who look down upon india soo

[@tomico9154]

As a Romani thanks for this video, keep up the good work.

[@akkkkk813]

❤️from india bro

[@SintiSchneck]

You can't be Romani you are either Sinti or Roma , so what are you

[@tomico9154]

@@SintiSchneck I'm a mix of both which is why I used the generalised term.

[@tomico9154]

@@akkkkk813 Hello from England brother.

[@DimljenaRiba]

I think this video should be shown in schools across Europe (and further)! It was very educational for me. I always assumed that Gypsies originate from India but I never could find information on it. India is such a fascinating country with such a rich history that it’s nearly unbelievable. I also wondered where is the distinction between Sinti and Roma. Another point which always sit wrong with me that genocide on the Gypsies was always neglected. In history classes usually teachers explain that Jews and Gypsies both were put in concentration camps. And after that 99% is only about the suffering of the Jewish people. But Gypsies suffered just as the Jewish! Though Gypsies mostly do have a nomadic lifestyle. I know quite a lot of Gypsies from different Balkan countries in Germany. Though most I know personally pursue regular jobs such as mechanics, barbers or cashiers there is great part living on welfare. Also on the balkans you can clearly see the nomadic roots. A lot of those lifestyle choices fester the stereotypes such as begging, drug use and child trafficking. I believe it’s similar to the native Americans which once they were left in the reservations stripped of their original lifestyle became emotionally crippled.

[@india9unknown]

I heard a story that Hitler released Gypsies from camps after knowing their Aryan Indian roots.

[@siddeshnaik2296]

Jews were killed by German christians the hatred existed because they were christians entire Europe was killing jews for silly reasons after Germany lost they put blame on Germans and showed that Nazis killed them and Hitler was the source of hatred. You should read Mein Kempf and understand what were Hitlers motivation

[@toxotorana]

@@india9unknown That would have been after he exterminated the entire Roma population of Bavaria but just before The Russians/Ukranians killed almost as many, we presume.

[@ManamaEd]

If you ask 90% of european where gypsies come from they say Romania lmao

[@DimljenaRiba]

@@ManamaEd I know a lot of Romanians 😂 and they are either Gypsies or complaining that they are mistaken for Gypsies. But to be fair, from my personal experience Romanians are a little darker skinned than most Bulgarians, Hungarians or Serbians (neighboring countries). But I’ve seen blond and blue eyed Romanians too. The balkans have a peculiar mixture. I’d say there are two predominant types. The dinaric type and the Slavic type. Djokovic would be an example for the dinaric type (close looking to Persians) and Jokic is more exemplary for the Slavic type.

[@artvid-1915]

I'm descended from Romani so thank you for this video I'm super excited to learn 💛

[@notallowed6546]

Very educative video, as I am romanian and I get frustrated everytime people think Romania is their place of origin. The term Romani was created in the middle 90`s, and this was an electoral gimmick created in Romania by the ex president Ion Iliescu.

[@Andreea6442]

Finally, the comment I was looking for:))

[@NativeVsColonial]

If you feel like, you can migrate back to India always :) Love from India

[@peterfireflylund]

@@NativeVsColonial “back”? The whole point was that Not Allowed is *Romanian* and therefore NOT a Gypsy.

[@NativeVsColonial]

@@peterfireflylund What?

[@marisadaniela6]

They agreed on the term at the first World Romani congress in 1971, so your statement cannot be entirely true.

[@DevDutta_STANCE]

Amazing history...thanks for the information. Here in my country, India, the equivalent of this community is called "Banjara" and they are largely a nomadic group. They live on the fringe but there's no Banjara-phobia here. I have interacted with some of them selling herbs in Delhi, Mumbai and Jaipur.

[@Anonymous-my5ud]

No they went to West because they were taken as Slaves from India through Hindu Kush mountain (known Hindu Kush because Hindu's were killed there in thousands) not because they didn't want competition and they were thrown more west wards when their population increased as to punish them more by not sending them east to their home. Their stories are really sad and they still are racially identified till this date.

[@Gypsygeekfreak17]

Stop lying

[@Anonymous-my5ud]

@@Gypsygeekfreak17 lying?? Bro you know you can research and tell me about what I am lying about and how I am wrong. Or are you so close minded that you can not take in different world view?

[@Gypsygeekfreak17]

@@Anonymous-my5ud I’m a gypsy this happened They forced us out of India years ago It was all islams fault

[@Gypsygeekfreak17]

@@Anonymous-my5ud who knows there history more when it comes to this Me a gypsy Or You

[@Anonymous-my5ud]

@@Gypsygeekfreak17 When did I said it wasn't their fault? My man I am saying yes they took Gypsy from India and also killed many of them 🙃

[@JordanVanRyn]

My buddy Paul recommended this video to me and it really has opened my eyes on how much the Roma and Sinti people went through. The fact that they have such a rich culture and heritage that traces back to India and yet they’ve been kicked out and reviled for who they are as an ethnicity. In a way, they somehow have shared similarities with the Jewish people, because they too were kicked out of every country and have a rich heritage and culture. But while Jewish people manage to live successfully, Roma people unfortunately still live in poverty and experience racism all the time. Worse than that is that they still deal with this today. To anyone out there who is Romani or Sinti, my heart goes out to you and God bless you. You are not alone. ❤ Thanks for this video. It was very informative and important.

[@abhishekpawar5126]

Europeans lecturing Americans on racism: 😍❤️🌹☀️ Europeans talking about Gypsies: 👹🔥🚀🔫

[@Darkwolf-mv7hj]

This is a big lie. The Pakistanis converted to Islam. The largest country with a plurality of Muslims is Indonesia, and it is not Arab. Arabic is a race and is not a religion. There are Christians and Jews who are Arabs to this day living with each other in Saudi Arabia, Yemen, and Qatar.

[@Relcilisity_Official]

@@Darkwolf-mv7hj um, what?

[@preciousjackson1197]

@@Darkwolf-mv7hj while everything you said is true. What does it have to do with the comment they made?

[@Will-ge7ri]

“They’re like your Mexicans.” -Said by a woman on a plane to my uncle on a flight to France. We’re Mexican but often mistaken for Italian.

[@SFVYachtClub]

If you've met them in any number you'd understand why your ancestors booted them out all those centuries ago.

[@naadanparinda9056]

Ahhh, finally a video on Romani people. It was a much over-due. P.S. I've shared your channel to my friends group, you make amazing videos, being an India I'm ashamed of myself and my Govt that I never got to study this side of our History, not even in higher standards.

[@nostalgicgirrl6053]

the central board of education covers everything from Mohanjodaro to Ashoka and Gupta dynasties to mughal and british colonisation till European renaissance and the Nazi genocide. That’s more vast a coverage of history than majority of other countries. You had the internet growing up, didn’t you? Not everything is the government’s responsibility 🙄.

[@naadanparinda9056]

@@nostalgicgirrl6053 hey hey hey, don't get riled up. We studied about cricket in Class Xth, come on! Internet can come to help only if you atleast introduce some topics, then only those interested could search and read. Not sure how the hell I'm supposed to 'dream' about Koudinya one night and then Google it. Anyway if your argument if that we already are overburdened then why do you want more, then I would say this particular guy has read atleast 5-7 books to summarise those info beautifully in 15-20 mins videos, you just need intent, everything else can be managed.

[@DeccanPS]

@@naadanparinda9056 Exactly! Such an intimate connection of Roma with Indians and people don't expect the government to include these aspects in the syllabus!! It's not for no reason that people curse the Macaulayian education system in India, it has an amazing ability to deracinate Indian's.

[@akza2719]

Higher standards????

[@SPEARHEADGLOBAL]

Stop being ashamed for no reason

[@jimmylee1776]

Thanks you for this wonderful video. This week I watched another video about a young Roma lady who went back to northern India to search for her roots. She looked Indian, with long black hair & dark skin. I also watched another video about Cobra Indians (Gypsies) it’s very interesting. Please continue your good work.

[@maltababe2678]

My dna traces back to India 🇮🇳 I’m a gypsy

[@eroguroknight]

What's your religion?

[@YOUTUBE_AMERICA]

​@@eroguroknightaffcorce Christianity

[@Atheist-hy6xq]

You are brown?

[@Fiaw1]

Gross

[@bhavyavlogs11]

Do you follow Hinduism 🕉️?

[@guy.quad_]

Great video as per usual 👌🏽 One of my good friends is Lor from Iran. Interesting to learn a bit about their history

[@_elian_8875]

Lors are not gypsies. The video creator made a massive mistake by saying that. Lors are an ancient population inhabiting western iran (Lorestan province) and are descended from ancient Medians and Elamites

[@bowiethedog6285]

@@_elian_8875 There is a small gypsy group in eastern Iran called "Loris". But the video creator made a huge mistake in not clarifying that they're not the same as Lors who are a much larger and well known group in Iran. Everyone is now confusing the two groups in the comments because of him.

[@13gan]

Although it was covered a bit in the video, the commercial environment in Europe in the medieval age is practically conducted via guilds which have near total monopoly on every facet of business specific to the niche of the guild. Guilds basically operate as a kind of cartel and they have the power to give you license to operate, transfer of skills and can set the price of goods and services that its members provide. Thus you have goldsmith's guild, blacksmith's guild, merchant's guild, shipbuilder's guild, tailor's guild etc. The reason for their existence is somewhat similar to the modern day co-operative business and workers union, in that it not only provide a place for funding for investment but also protect its members against competitive forces from rival guilds both local and outside. The presence of Romani would obviously goes against the interest of the local guilds of the city/region as they would break the monopoly they had on pricing and supply of work. It would be similar to union busting in the modern world. So from the perspective, it make sense to kick them out, in the same way that Jimmy Hoffa did for the Teamsters.

[@13gan]

@Ahmed Parlance Guilds are not quite the same as Chamber of Commerce although the origin of Chamber of Commerce does come from the mercantile guilds. Guilds provide certifications and licence to operate, with the modern day City and Guild of London Institute certificate being descend from that original role. As have been mention earlier, the merchants guilds ate just one of many guilds that exist so saying that they are capitalist is a bit of an oversimplification of their role in medieval society as technically anyone can join a guild as long as they satisfy the requirement and completed the certification process that the guild have. The main reason why the Romani didn't join guilds are more because of their nomadic lifestyle when when compared to the more sedentary Jews make often the target of economic exclusion. I mean, if its due to race, the fact that goldsmith and jewelers guilds are usually mostly Jews would be sufficient proof that its not due to their race despite their similar insular habits in medieval society. Also, where does I equate labour strike (or defending it) with genocide? Also, I think "idiosyncratic" doesn't mean what you think it meant. One cannot infer a pattern when there is only one sample.

[@13gan]

@Ahmed Parlance I think the sentence you're refering is "So from that perspective, it make sense to kick them out. . .". To this, I would like to ask whether your point "But I agree the reason for anti-Gypsie pogroms in Europe is mainly political economy.." is not in any way similar? Just because we pointed out a motive for the action doesn't mean we defend it. I only talk about guilds, so at most I'm only explaining the reasoning of the guilds in promoting the persecution of the Romani. Explaining the reason why some tribes practice cannibalism is certainly very different than promoting cannibalism or even defending its practice in modern society.

[@DukeOfTheYard]

No, the reason is cultural, not economical because the only skill that the respective people had that could present some kind of competition with the local europeans was metallurgy (blacksmithing & jewelry). And these occupations were always in short supply and high demand. In all other occupations the "Romani" people were no threat to anyone. But their way of life was very disruptive for the locals, that is why they were disliked.

[@13gan]

@@DukeOfTheYard I'm not denying that cultural reasons as being part of it, since just like the Jews, they don't assimilate into the local populations. My comment only explain the guild system for those who are not familiar of it aside than what they see in novels and games.

[@Simplyveej]

@@13gan but it does sound like you are defending it’s practice in medieval society.

[@deanstuart8871]

Dude, I am so happy I stumbled on your channel! For the first time ever I have some kind of framework for the origin of the Roma people! Gonna watch all your video from the first to the last. :)

[@bridgetking4553]

My dad is Romanichal and looks Indian. But since my moms polish and only a little Romani, I look whiter than most. Horrifying history, but it shows strength on our part. Jay Hind

[@youtubersdub4339]

Are you still a hindu??

[@bridgetking4553]

@@youtubersdub4339 I am, my dad still thinks the dharma is really cool and agrees with it

[@youtubersdub4339]

@@bridgetking4553 wow❤❤ I will request you to please read bhagwat geeta also.. Jai Shree Krishna🚩🙏

[@bridgetking4553]

@@youtubersdub4339 I have read half of it so far, am really excited to read Vedas also.

[@youtubersdub4339]

@@bridgetking4553 huge respect to you & your family🙏🙏🙏🙏 and please also encourage other romani brothers & sisters to read 🙏🚩🚩

[@christianefleurant7089]

Thank you. I knew that the long journey of the Romani started in India. I learned it from the movie Latcho Drom (1993 Tony Gatlif) a very poetic film showing the of the evolution of the Gypsies from India to Spain with music and dance without words! Today with your video I discover how much religion and politics were very important factors of this evolution. From a movie without words to the contents of your video that I will have to listen again.💃

[@Gronolo_31g]

You did a great job on this video. It is hard to come by history videos of this type of quality that don't pander to people who know nothing about history. I enjoy that you don't simplify too much.

[@takenbythewindNdrivenbythesea]

My God 😮 Today I really learned something. Never knew that all this while they came from India. Superb video and great job 👌🙏

[@Badger69-96]

Thanks for sharing our history. My ancestors lived on the Black Patch campsite, Birmingham they were Romany Gypsy and i always wondered about their journey 😢✌️💯

[@anmeshpadvi527]

Indians suffered from very even in India Many foreigners, culture, religions came to Indian subcontinent they spreads grown Well , Indians Accept change they don't Afraid to Others beliefs culture or lifestyle Majority of people of India is Hindus.

[@RitzyCupcake]

I honestly don’t know much about Gypsies but when I watched a couple of shows with them I noticed so many similarities between them and Indians that I came to the conclusion they must have originated from India. Thank you for such an amazing video!

[@mayankdewli1010]

Not really. I'm an Indian and I have met many gypsies in Germany. They didn't look like me. They couldn't understand me and even I did not know that they were indians. They look like Turks or Balkans. Tbh I can't really differentiate between Arabs , Turks , Balkans , Greeks, Romanians or gypsies

[@useryt125]

Gypsy DNA was India... if u check... And it was not in Pakistan no ... In fact it was originally India... Just do DNA test... Rajasthan or many other parts of India... U can say it Indian subcontinent... Pakistan is part of India... First check what all world government and India government and other DNA report then you will know nothing related to Pakistan It can be called they are from India and India subcontinent. Actually gypsy who not migrated Europe still living in India... But they are far lower than any Indian.. In my area i bet if any gypsy come they will find out their people still living... Even here in eastern area of India.. believe they make their home on India government land here is 100 acre useless land of government they come every year stay and go somewhere else after some time.

[@gipsymelody1268]

Not really… there is 2 main group of gypsies Gitano/lovari Sinti The gitano group traveled in south europe and the sinto in north europe The sinti have pretty white skin and even blonde and red hair while gitano is a bit darker (like lighter skinned arabians) and have brown and black hair! Gypsies not really indins but indo-iranian and aryan people! Also we have major greco-italic dna! Probably because of yavana kingdom Also in our language have ton of greek words so probbaly my yavana kindom theory is true whoch mean gypsies oroginally from greece and italy and the yavana kingdom was a greek kingdom in north-west india in 200bc to 30ad! And just for case we have good and bad peoples too! Not everyone is bad nor good… We had many discrimination and genocides like holocaust where around 1.5 million gypsies brutally died! (Our populations’ 40%!)

[@rohanxdavis]

Finally, more great content on the origins of the Romani 👌🏽

[@oso_nomada]

SUBSCRIBED. Well done!! Incredibly educational and entertaining the entire episode. Thank You!!!

[@prithvi3892]

Very informative video bro.👍👍👍. Keep it up ☺️.

[@capkanada]

I'm Romani, and I appreciate this video.

[@vypa-bk1iy]

What kind of job do you do?

[@puraLusa]

@@vypa-bk1iy do u go around asking people's qualifications? Cause it's hilarious 😂

[@vypa-bk1iy]

@@puraLusa nah I was just wondering because the Romani have a certain reputation in Europe

[@puraLusa]

@@vypa-bk1iy reputation comes from 1 of the several groups who compose the romani, the group is big. They have the clan base familly tipe, meaning that a lot of their decisions are made by the clan leader, not an individual decision. Its different from clan to clan and its even so different that 2 clans might go to war against each other. Then u have the clans who don't follow the approach of living asside from society and those take advantage of the rights, by acquiring a profession. Some are even famous, but people tend to remember the bad. Problem with some clans (again, things have changed and are changing) is being adament of keeping traditions who are illegal, that's where a lot of groups end up with said reputation. And it is very hard to leave your clan, ur gonna be shun and alone which is terrifying when u grew up in a clan base sistem. But, the rights are there: health, education, housing, etc. Governments can't go to a community and tell them how to live within the sistem, nor can the police excuse a serious crime. It's an individual and clan choice. There are success stories, people just tend to forget them.

[@-rate6326]

@@BadRomaMan1 well great. Genetics is more than that.

[@gowri1991]

Man your videos are incredible and give so much insight into Indian history!!