Forza Motorsport 4 vs Horizon 4 vs Horizon 5 vs PGR 4 - BMW M5 E60 Sound Comparison

Check out Black Friday sale (including Flash Sale) at ENEBA.com ene.ba/MotoGam...
Use code MotoGamesTV to get 3% DISCOUNT for Racing games, DLC! ene.ba/MotoGam... ene.ba/MotoGam...
Forza Motorsport 4 vs Forza Horizon 4 vs Forza Horizon 5 vs Project Gotham Racing 4
/ motogamestv
/ motogamestv
/ motogamestv
speed-zone.pl/
www.thrustmaste...
www.wheelstandp...
MotoGamesTV
#ForzaHorzion5 #ForzaHorizon4 #Forza

[@MotoGamesTV]

And real life for comparison: kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6XIYmufrbaaqbM

[@ROLLINGFANATICS]

Wow seeing PGR4 just brought back so much me memories . Used to spend hours wheeling bikes while doing stunts/seat tricks ! Such a good game . Can’t forget the snow on Nurburgring too

[@ferrr7778]

I'm glad I still have FM 4 and PGR 4, such a good games

[@DarkKnight2845]

Facts

[@Skumtomten1]

Golden era of Xbox racing games.

[@NickWarriorWithin]

Pgr 2 is best, Pgr 4 second

[@justinlzy]

As a guy who frequently travel to Shanghai, I miss PGR4 badly, to this day it is still the best visual reprenstation of the city and do it justice.

[@ROLLINGFANATICS]

It seems like FH5 sounds like it doesn’t rev that high compared to real life . Sounds like it’s limited to 7k rpm .. idk just seems weak

[@Mr.Goldbar]

you're definitely not wrong! I thought the same

[@RS-nq8xk]

Playgroung Games keep down pitching their sounds for no reason.

[@Mr.Goldbar]

@@RS-nq8xk yeah... Every classic muscle car suddenly sounds like it has a 5000rpm redline... Can't make an accurate car sound without perfect pitch

[@mrrakalanov]

Damn! I miss PGR4. The best simcade i played

[@mmt9938]

FM4 was the most accurate

[@mmt9938]

@@wqbb287 then that makes the newer versions sound like racing video game from the early 90s.

[@joaofaria4727]

@@wqbb287 yeah but it needs to rev higher imo

[@DarkKnight2845]

I agree

[@VariantAEC]

LOL! Ok there, maybe have less to drink before watching these videos, eh?

[@cosmiccrazy4557]

@@joaofaria4727 bear in mind upgrades in FH5 change the cars sound, therefore this can easily be fixed by upgrading the camshaft

[@corollavirus4age]

PGR4 seems to be the only one that got the SMG gearbox right

[@sunray2818]

And they are the only game that got RHD UK version of E60 M5 with early iDrive model

[@blunderrated]

Always give a like when I see FM4. Till this day, their best Forza game. Also, their best looking. Aged very well and should’ve continued on that style

[@Tolinx21]

In rear view PGR4 sound is amazing !

[@HG504X]

FM4 sounds the best easily.

[@DarkKnight2845]

Agreed

[@christian_urocar]

In car cockpit sounds fm5 or pg4 is pretty close to reality . From the outside fm4 is just about spot on

[@DarkKnight2845]

Thanks so much again for making this great video, glad that PGR 4 was included too

[@VerypopularSkylineGT-RS]

Fm4 bro pgr sounds like a 1st gen gallardo (but in the chase cam) but pgr kinda goes crazy tho ngl

[@DarkKnight2845]

Nice profile picture, and PGR 4 is a game from 2007, the car was fairly new at the time

[@VerypopularSkylineGT-RS]

@@DarkKnight2845 i can tell and thnx

[@NickWarriorWithin]

@@VerypopularSkylineGT-RS Forza is trash. Pgr 2 and Pgr 4 best racing games EVER

[@StudioArqing]

Great comparison! I like FM4 sounds

[@bugattiincroyable]

Only FM4 is accurate, other's are completly off

[@joaofaria4727]

Not true, horizon 5's e60 sounds alright, it just needs to rev higher than it does

[@DarkKnight2845]

FM4 definitely sounds great, FH5 is also very close

[@kjstancedz]

​@@DarkKnight2845 just no

[@DarkKnight2845]

@@kjstancedz ?

[@ralcolfwolfcoon8207]

Hello??? PGR4

[@hussainkhalid7024]

1- forza Motorsport 4 2- forza horizon 4 3- Pgr 4 4- forza horizon 5

[@SApcGUY]

pgr4 the best!!

[@NickWarriorWithin]

yes, after Pgr 2!

[@AhmadGalalYT]

1 - Forza Motosport 4 2 - Forza Horizon 5 3 - Forza Horizon 4 4 - PGR4 FH5 definitely sounds great, but it just needs a higher pitch, it doesn't sound like the revs are correct. That's also the case on other cars on FH5 like for example the Jeep Grand Cherokee Trackhawk. Other than that I'm happy that we got amazing sounds back since we had to suffer FH4's horrible sounds for like 3 years lol

[@DarkKnight2845]

FM4 got the S85 V10 right, FH4 doesn't sound correct on the high revs, FH5 sounds very good, just needs a higher pitch, and PGR4 doesn't have the correct engine sound. Though you have to appreciate PGR4 for this, the car was fairly new at the time, along with the game being made 14 years ago.

[@AhmadGalalYT]

@@DarkKnight2845 Definitely agreed bro 🤗, I also love the intake sound more on FM4, FH5 sounds really great as well on the intake, I just hope they look at the pitch on some cars, some cars that are supposed to rev higher sound like they rev lower, like the Trackhawk, GT3 RS 2016, This M5, etc. Also, considering how old PGR4 is, I'm so impressed at how it sounds!

[@RS-nq8xk]

@@AhmadGalalYT They deliberately pitched down FH5 sounds though. They literally added in a rev variable and put it to 0.9 or something. Same for the 'new' sounds in FH3/4 when they started using their own sound engine for specific cars.

[@hussainkhalid7024]

@@AhmadGalalYTit literally sounds like a vacuum cleaner in fh5 and it’s literally hella silent it’s so unrealistic tf bro.

[@AhmadGalalYT]

@@hussainkhalid7024 I heard one in-person not too long ago and you are correct. FH5 sounds too quiet, and low pitched, they did the M5 E60 dirty

[@williamduartecardoso]

Project Gotham Racing 4 is still great today

[@UhhhhhnooOOo00oO]

Still comparing other racing and open world games to PGR4 launched in October of 2007. Over 14 years ago on 2 generations plus of console before today. It shows you how that game was ahead of its time and when Microsoft studios could actually produce a great launch title. Yes, it veers towards arcade or Sim-cade and has an Ai engine but, it excels at graphics at the time and internal and external car design with vibrations and g-forces. Not the most accurate tyre/tire handling model, but really well done at the time. PGR3 had more weight and vibration. It's like driving a car at 260kph in "outer space" on almost a frictionless road, the newer the games got because humans don't like the shaky shaky. You are in a car. They might have well just put flying magical carpets in the game. Take a car up to near or beyond those speeds, then make it a hardwire sports car and try to take even slight turns.....it isn't a smooth as silk experience. They destroyed the experience for the only goal = profit. Humans like pretty and smooth experiences. Nothing close to real world..that might be upsetting. Also, stop comparing "racing" games to open works games. It is embarrassing, that I'd rather play PGR4 to Forza Horizon 5 currently. Even Forza 4 had more realism. Graphics are a different story and world size/graphics/entertainment content.

[@dominicancheif117]

Yeah I agree and sadly the state of games now seems to prioritize graphics above all else. Crazy how games back then we’re made on less superior hardware but offered far better all around experiences that few games can offer now

[@UhhhhhnooOOo00oO]

@@dominicancheif117 I does cost more and even with faster processing and updated development software, games are too large and take too long to complete. Most are launched incomplete for profit. They can just complete it on updates. Not as much when a disk was sold as a completed product. Look to Metroid Prime, Killzone on PS3, Gears of War on Xbox. NFL 2K5 on multiple consoles. PGR2-PGR4. Games way ahead of their time. (Shadow of the Colossus is the best example) The most recent sequel or prequel took so long to develop. PS2, PS3, PS4 and now PS5 has its own iterations of the game updated.

[@DarkKnight2845]

PGR4 was one of the greatest racing games in 2007 I'd personally say

[@UhhhhhnooOOo00oO]

@@DarkKnight2845 In 2007. There were maybe 5 racing games in 2007. Bold statement. ;) I get what you should mean. The DarkKnight has warm milk and goes down for a cat nap. 🐈bat nap. 🦇

[@DarkKnight2845]

@@UhhhhhnooOOo00oO There were more than 5 racing games, and yes thanks for the bat nap.

[@ZombieRofl]

There is a reason that PGR4 is in the video 😉

[@Berstale1028]

FH5 sounds way better than horizon 4 but still weird ( and almost all cars have that racing gearbox whine even if they're stock )

[@Edvardas96]

FH5 cars sound like they are always in a tunnel

[@scunny1835]

I prefer horizon 4’s sound of this car to horizon 5’s. Motorsport 4 is by far the best though!

[@hussainkhalid7024]

@Berstale1028 hell no the bmw m5 E60 sounds awful as hell bruh literally it’s still silent when I’m at 8000rpm and second of all it sounds unrealistic so no debate that in fh4 the bmw m5 E60 sounds better

[@BigEStan]

​@@Edvardas96nah

[@Maxou_996]

FH5 has a little reverb, it feels like the car is always in a tunnel

[@BigEStan]

nah bro the sound like shit

[@CORVETTEZO6-C6]

pgr4 is good, not in terms of audio, in terms of fun

[@Mr.Goldbar]

that's one of these rare cases when Horizon 4 sounds the best. Motorsport 4 sounds too crunchy and compressed, Horizon 5 while being close sounds a bit too deep and low, PGR4 sounds like a Gallardo

[@DarkKnight2845]

After 3-4 years you still criticize FM4, compression doesn't fully change realism. FM4 has the correct 5.0 V10 sound just as it does in real life, FH5 also did a great job, FH4 on high revs doesn't sound correct, and PGR4 doesn't sound realistic, although it's 14 years old. I'm not hating, but I'm just saying that is a console with 2005 hardware along with only 512 MB of ram, you can't ask for anything more than how good it is now, it was pushed to the limits essentially.

[@Mr.Goldbar]

@@DarkKnight2845 yeah I know, both FM4 and PGR4 pushed the 360's limits, but that doesn't mean we should hold them on a pedestal. As for the compression thing, it certainly does change realism. No car and I mean absolutely no car ever sounds that compressed IRL, every car ever sounds louder when revving up and quieter when returning back to idle, and if not then the tone also changes between the two scenarios. that's physics for you. The tone of FM4 is mostly spot on and in this case as well, but the compression ruins it all, I attribute it to less than stellar recording equipment/technique/technology, which totally makes sense because that's probably one of the first times it's been done in a racing game if not the very first

[@DarkKnight2845]

@@Mr.Goldbar There is a reason behind the compression, they wouldn't go mic recording 600 cars and reduce the quality for fun

[@Mr.Goldbar]

@@DarkKnight2845 still doesn't make it sound good :D

[@DarkKnight2845]

@@Mr.Goldbar That's the best they probably could get to, keep in mind this is 10 years old. The 360 also had only 512 mb of ram with 2005 hardware, it was pushed to the limits

[@RiC3R69]

Forza MotorSport 4

[@marcelorodrigues5884]

What mode did you use in PGR4?

[@yusufffff]

is it just me or the hands in FH5 look very plastic-y?

[@Fansjamal64]

Pgr4 bmw m5 e60 sound but Lamborghini Gallardo swap engine

[@gramatonklerik1284]

FM4 by far the best ever !!!!

[@naidedossantos500]

3:04

[@adamrobledo684]

Pgr4 sounds like a stock exhaust m5

[@apexgt4]

What is going on with the tunnel in fh5? Weird

[@supra2361]

IMO fh4 had the best sound but FH5 is alright….

[@bugattiincroyable]

FM4 sound real, FH4 is a bit lower, FH5 is completly off

[@wqbb287]

Fh4 sucks in high rev range

[@DarkKnight2845]

FH4 doesn't sound correct in the high RPMs, but FH5 and FM4 did a great job imo

[@hussainkhalid7024]

FH4 is way better than fh5 and more realistic fh5 sounds like a vacuum cleaner and I never heard the car sounding like this

[@hussainkhalid7024]

FH5 easily has the worst m5 E60 sound FM4 have the best m5 E60 sound

[@charonunderground8596]

PGR4 the best

[@ericvermeulen9853]

FM4 the best

[@mikhail8429]

1- Forza horizon 5 2- Forza motorsport 4 3- Forza horizon 4 4- PGR 4

[@samix9000]

BMWs always sound weak in Forza games. FH5 sounds okay, but not perfect.

[@DarkKnight2845]

It sounded very good in FM4 imo

[@LeoFitness]

FH5 🔥

[@hussainkhalid7024]

That car sounds trash, it literally sounds like a vacuum cleaner

[@michaszymczak2099]

.

[@NickWarriorWithin]

Pgr 2 and Pgr 4 best racing games EVER

[@mikecustoms]

fm4 just uses the r8 v10 sample which is not bad at all but I'd say FH5 is the best and most accurate, although pgr4 interior sounds are still god tier

[@ralcolfwolfcoon8207]

You wish

[@NickWarriorWithin]

Pgr 4 easy win, forza all trash

[@andreasmoller9798]

Fm4 wipes the floor with pgr 4