Friedrich Nietzsche’s Guide to the Bodily Resurrection - Fr. Stephen De Young (Summit 2024)

[@JonathanPageau]

This talk by Fr. Stephen DeYoung is from the Symbolic World Summit that took place in Florida on the weekend of February 29th, 2024. Given it was such a spectacular talk, we decided to make it public. I hope you enjoy it! All other talks and discussions from the event can be accessed through the Symbolic World website if you buy the Summit video package. Other speakers included myself, Jordan Peterson, Dr. Martin Shaw, Richard Rohlin, Neil DeGraide, Fr. Dcn. Nicholas Kotar, Vesper Stamper, and Fr. Silouan Justiniano: www.thesymbolicworld.com/summit-2024

[@Warriorsruach]

Thanks for making this public, Jonathan!

[@DerekBalsley1]

This talk made me tear-up a bit. Anxious to rewatch to remind myself why. 🥲

[@nbinghi]

Thank you for making this public! 🙏

[@Mr_M1dnight]

When will you address the widespread mental illness in your fan base, Jonathan Schizeau?

[@Warriorsruach]

@@Mr_M1dnight When Jesus heard it, He said to them, “Those who are well have no need of a physician, but those who are sick. I did not come to call the righteous, but sinners, to repentance.”

[@MatthiasPendragon]

A note of clarification, especially for the non-orthodox. Father Stephen is engaging in speculation, offering a perspective to consider. It is also a self admitted early speculation, as he is still working out his thinking on it. He is not presenting "The Orthodox View" in a dogmatic sense. He is pondering deep mysteries, which is worthwhile and greatly apppreciated, but deep mysteries they remain. Much love to the Symbolic World folks for sharing this lecture.

[@forthegloryofthelord]

Good we have a thought policeman here 😂 so no stupid sheep's may go astray.

[@MatthiasPendragon]

@forthegloryofthelord it's not thought police. If someone attends an Orthodox service, this is not likely the sort of thing you will hear in the Homily, and folks unfamiliar with Orthodoxy might be confused about what is speculation and what is clear doctrine.

[@olgakarpushina492]

​​​@@forthegloryofthelordyour remark was intentionally hurtful and uncalled for. Matthias is right. This is NOT an Orthodox dogma or even remotely something you will hear in church, except for the "little onion tale". I like Fr. Stephen, but as the one who is tasked with tending the flock, he has to be extra careful. Sorry to say, but this talk reeked of Protestantism. And this is one big problem with the recent tide of new converts to Orthodoxy: they bring their Protestant demons with them.

[@andreeampatrasc]

It's not speculation. It is part of what the Saints / Church Fathers in Orthodoxy explain in their writings in the Filokalia which is a series of books that explain the teachings of the Bible and the way we should all transform towards salvation and be born again spiritually in this life in order to live with and in God. :)

[@MatthiasPendragon]

@andreeampatrasc can you cite where in the Philokalia this is addressed? Not trying to be argumentative, but I would expect Father Stephen to cite a Saint or church father if there was one who clearly held this position.

[@Joefrenomics]

OMG no way! I’ve been dying to hear this talk, but I just couldn’t afford normal tickets. Thank you so much, Jonathan.

[@christianbaxter_yt]

I pulled my bootleg copy of this down after my conscience caught up with me. Symbolic World Summit was such a deeply meaningful experience.

[@christopherherrera1007]

Hang onto the copy

[@dominicpaul1]

Jesus forgives you. Just had an email from him 👍 You're in the clear bro

[@christianbaxter_yt]

@ can you send him back a message and tell him I said thankyou

[@JessieJoseph-y1w]

Gibs

[@ISAYWORDS1]

The more I listen to Fr. Stephen and Fr. Andrew both in the Lord of spirits podcast and elsewhere, the more the Orthodox understanding is illuminated to me, the more I just marvel at how this true meaning of Christianity has been hidden to us for so long. I had these questions, these doubts, and when no one was able to answer I gave up on God and gave up on Christ. The view that I am seeing from the Orthodox is so radically different and yet familiar, it removes a great deal of the stumbling blocks to my faith, I just can't believe this is really Christianity and I never knew it existed.

[@datakit9280]

Glory to God for him illuminating your understanding.

[@zeph99]

☦️🙏

[@mysticape9386]

I've just started working through the Lord of Spirits podcasts from the beginning they are great

[@datakit9280]

@@mysticape9386 yeah me too. I’m on episode 7

[@kmotynojodas]

I don't like listening to Fr Andrew, I had to stop listening to the lord of spirits podcast because of him 🙄

[@JorgeAguilera]

Thank you Father Stephen for helping me understand why I must not lose hope.

[@EamonBurke]

This talk was stunning. I was not at all prepared for it, it made me hit a level of contemplation I'm not ready for outside of fasting seasons

[@TS_Apostolos]

Thanks!

[@faturechi]

About time!

[@sean_jackson314]

I have spent many years trying to find answers and rest in the many things of this world, in Peterson and Jung, Nietzsche, etc. But my soul had no rest until i found Christ. If you’re curious about Christ, i encourage you, seek Him with all of your heart. Your life depends on it.

[@BlueEagle-yk6dg]

I am inspired by this

[@DM100]

Second listen. Got alot more out of it this time. 😊Best discussion on the bodily resurrection I have ever heard. These two men together are magical. Holy Spirit is working because this topic and the ramifications of the truth it holds, even if in part, are huge. And, as Father DeYoung pointed out, Western thinking on it can be very detrimental, if not downright evil. This life does matter. All Glory to God for my Orthodox Tradition ! 🙏🏻☦️🙏🏻☦️

[@emmett_shortt]

Love Fr. Stephen De Young!

[@christophersnedeker]

For a second I thought you said "die young" and I was confused. Lol.

[@ThatLauraPerson]

wow crazy date and timing to post this one publicly- this was my fav talk from the event

[@ethan-sq6zv]

😂🎉

[@aep2631]

If even a glimmer of this idea is right, and I do believe it is - all I can say is "Thank you Lord Jesus!"

[@torinmccabe]

Victor Frankl says something similar about rescuing good into the eternal past >> Those things which seem to take meaning away from human life include not only suffering but dying as well. I never tire of saying that the only really transitory aspects of life are the potentialities; but as soon as they are actualized, they are rendered realities at that very moment; they are saved and delivered into the past, wherein they are rescued and preserved from transitoriness. For, in the past, nothing is irretrievably lost but everything irrevocably stored

[@STMukr]

Fr Stephen is the best❤

[@DM100]

💯

[@eldermillennial8330]

“I wear the chain I forged in life, I made it link by link and yard by yard…”, Jacob Marley

[@JessieJoseph-y1w]

Love Fr. Stephen!

[@DerekJFiedler]

This talk and Martin Shaw storytelling were highlights from the stage at the conference.

[@justadog-headedman6727]

Jordan Peterson is the guy who, a couple of sentences after warning about the dangers of post-modern transhumanism, talks excitedly about bringing people from the dead with AI. 🤷‍♂

[@peterbuckley9731]

I can make no sense of Jordan. He’s a moralist and little else… I don’t believe he has any felt sense of Christ. “Here are the rules to life (literally)” …the hubris.

[@Primordialtruth666]

Lol he's got a chance at the spotlight and likes it to much so he just rambles about whatever he thinks. To each is their own! And guy is nothing but a distraction plan from ai. Lol dude probably works for them

[@NightLetterLondon]

@@peterbuckley9731 Starting to agree with that. Jordan has done A LOT of good, in many ways, and has indeed brought many people into and back into the Church.. but he has not moved himself - not moved away from the 'psychological' position..

[@NightLetterLondon]

@@Primordialtruth666 To be fair to him, he's more than that. And he's brought a lot of people back to 'life', you could say.. Indeed, brought a lot of people back into the church (his original Biblical Series lectures were groundbreaking).. But his continuing to not 'move' from the psychological, begins to be a problem.. I feel.

[@alvareo92]

@@NightLetterLondon even if he doesn't accept Christ until he's in his deathbed, we knew him by his fruits.

[@anselmcs595]

At "the triumph of joy" a potty-mouthed exclamation of wonder, surprise and awe escaped me, and I was only a hair's witdh from tears.

[@TheOrthodoxPunjabi]

i've been waiting for this!

[@BillyKangas]

What a wonderful talk. I wish I could have been there for the whole event. I just gave a talk on this very thing this morning, including the onion tale! I wish I had heard it ahead of time because he did such a great job of explaining so much of the nuance here.

[@mills8102]

This is a very helpful talk. Thank you for sharing. 🙏

[@DM100]

The importance of this topic cannot be overstated because it speaks to who our Savior is. Historically, the shallow teaching on Heaven and Hell, in my view, has harmed the Church and harmed the psyches of so many. As always, thank you Father DeYoung for your wisdom and courage to use the sound mind that God has given you. Many blessings to you!! May the Holy Spirit continue to guide you. Understanding the mysteries is a fearsome thing. 🙏🏻☦️🙏🏻☦️

[@jennablue87]

This might be the best thing I’ve heard

[@jonboatwright7777]

Holy cow. What have I stumbled upon? Well, this is exciting.

[@jonnyschaff7068]

I’ve been eagerly waiting for this

[@janmalaszek1459]

Thankyou, wonderfully clear .

[@MatthiasPendragon]

A thought on this: if the goal of the Faith is to grow ever closer to God, and what preserves in eternity is our identity as found in our relationships, then our Eternity is not a "groundhog day" where we repeat our lives, as another commenter put it, but our lives are joined to the lives of the everyone else as we find our common root in God. All the good of all the lives, the chaff burned away, lived out together.

[@gabeholm857]

We want another symbolic world conference!

[@profeh3346]

❤THANK YOU!

[@babyBmaj]

Thank you

[@testsignupagain7449]

Fascinating! Thanks Fr

[@kmotynojodas]

Pageau Fest was amazing this year!

[@ibelieve3111]

Thanks

[@mohitoautomaciek801]

🤝👍wielkie👍PiĘĆ👍DZiĘKUjĘ👍Wszystkiego DOBREGO dla WAS👍🤝

[@cs2890]

More of this please. I will have to attend the next Symbolic World Summit.

[@aurochs1]

Dr. Peterson should do a podcast with Fr. Stephen

[@shaynajo8217]

So rich, his voice and his words. Can listen many times and still not taste every note. Thank you for sharing, and all the work (daily rituals😉) that went into making the summit happen! 🤍🤍🤍

[@adrbaz]

Peterson has done a huge amount to bring Christianity (and amazing Christian thinkers such as Fr. Stephen, Jonathan) to former atheists like me. I do think people in the comments could be a little more gracious towards him. I found him at his best here, yes he talks too much-but he would confess to that and often does. Nonetheless I enjoyed their interaction at the end, I thought it added value.

[@NightLetterLondon]

Yes.. The fact that Pageau has the platform and popularity he has now has a lot to do with JP. Jonathan deserves the platform, but JP was instrumental in bringing him to the attention of the world..

[@AlexLGagnon]

This rises a question in me. How do you explain all the accounts of resurrection done by Jesus and Elijah, with this framework?

[@david6ravy]

I was there! So good to hear it again.

[@SpencerTwiddy]

Now I want to hear Langan describe the analog of this in the CTMU.

[@sebastienberger1112]

Good stuff. Food for thoughts. Thank you.

[@angelostoulis3670]

All of this is conceptual and as changing as the body itself. The mind is not where anything eternal can be found. So many people will want to make sense out of this talk. In will never be full satisfying. The intellect can never be satisfied. It can only feed on concepts, feel satisfied for a while and then need to feed on concepts again.

[@AugustasKunc]

33:10 "eternally living this life, without sorrow and sighing and pain"

[@sethhat9620]

Peterson's talk of reanimating Neitzche from the dead via LLMs is disturbing. Immediately brings to mind a clip of his speaking on another podcast about this venture, where he talked about training an LLM on the bible and how you could 'capture the spirit of the text' this way. Perhaps it didn't occur to him that what he was describing sounds a lot like deus ex machina (creating god out of the machine). At any rate, trying to pull wisdom out of a black box prone to hallucination, with no way to determine the manner in which it's decisions are made, seems a fools errand. Let the dead rest. This criticism aside, Father Stephen's talk was very interesting.

[@Messianic-Gentile]

I’m glad someone else felt this. I’m afraid Peterson doesn’t know what he’s doing by messing with AI. With these things, even the programmers/creators don’t really know what is going on behind the scenes. It’s much like divination. These machines are self-learning and can easily embody unclean spirits.

[@renrichardson6517]

Exactly. "We're going to create an image of Nietzsche and give it the ability to speak." Peterson understands more about what he is doing and where his teachings come from than he lets on, but that has always been the case since he first came into the limelight.

[@Hitlerbaddaringood]

Pageau is basically Jeff Goldblum in Jurassic Park

[@vincentraddclus9490]

It sounds pretty much like NECROMANCY. And might and should, be a biiiiig fat elephant in the room then.

[@justadog-headedman6727]

He talks about the dangers of post-modern transhumanism at the same time that he striving to make it happen.

[@cw4091]

Good to see Peterson where he should be.

[@GarikaiGumbo]

Very wise and thought-provoking insights

[@animula6908]

I got to inform the good father that Protestants actually sing all the verses of amazing grace. ❤

[@arthurholmes-brown7104]

This is true . I was a protestant for many years and that is the case😂

[@torinmccabe]

What I picture is simulation theory with God becoming at the end and Him holding all past reality (including our physical bodies) in his divine hard drive but now with Him and his divine grace being with us at all the moments of our lives he thus makes everything all right as our savior.

[@antonioperez4091]

Aurelius and Sophia sat quietly, the candle between them flickering in the cool night air. After a while, Aurelius ventured, “Sophia, you speak of resurrection and of life infused with divine purpose. But tell me-what do you believe happens after we die? Is there a journey, a transformation, or simply a return to the Source?” Sophia took a deep breath, as if drawing wisdom from the silence around them. “I believe that death is not the end, but a passage-a threshold we cross into deeper union with God. And yet, I think that what we find beyond death depends on the lives we live here and now. In Jesus, we see that God treasures each soul and seeks to draw us closer. When we die, I believe we are invited further into that love, to be transformed by it.” Aurelius nodded thoughtfully. “So you think our journey continues after death, not just as a merging into the One, but as a kind of ongoing communion with the divine?” “Yes,” Sophia replied. “I see it as a deepening of relationship, a life that grows ever fuller as we draw nearer to the heart of God. For those open to divine love, it is a movement toward fullness and healing. But for those who resist, who cling to shadows, that love might feel like a purifying fire, stripping away all that keeps them from seeing God. It is as if death is a doorway, and we pass through it to meet the truth of ourselves and of God.” Aurelius considered this. “In Neoplatonic thought, we speak of the soul’s ascent, its release from the material world to return to the One. But you’re suggesting that after death, we do not lose our identities, our uniqueness?” Sophia’s eyes were gentle. “I believe that the One holds and cherishes every soul’s uniqueness. The resurrection is a promise that the things that make us who we are-our loves, our sorrows, our longings-are precious to God. After death, we do not vanish into the Source like drops in the ocean; rather, we are drawn closer, becoming more fully ourselves as we grow in divine love.” Aurelius’s face softened as he listened. “So, you imagine that even after death, we continue to grow and deepen? That eternity is not static but alive with movement and love?” “Yes,” said Sophia. “I believe that eternity is a living communion, a place where love and joy deepen forever. Jesus’ resurrection, to me, is a promise that there is always more-more of God to know, more love to experience. I think of eternity not as a place or even a time, but as an ever-unfolding journey into the infinite life of God.” Aurelius looked down, letting the words sink in. “I have always thought of the One as an ultimate unity, a return to simplicity and purity. But you speak of eternity as a kind of unfolding, an infinite exploration of the divine. In your vision, heaven is not a mere return but a further journey.” “Yes,” Sophia said softly. “We enter into the mystery of God and are invited to explore it forever. And perhaps even the smallest acts of love in this life prepare us for that journey. When we die, I believe we are welcomed into a life that no eye has seen, nor ear heard-where we are fully known and fully loved, and where every soul is cherished as a unique part of the divine tapestry.” Aurelius leaned back, his eyes wide. “If what you say is true, then there is no end to the adventure of knowing God, no end to love or life. Death is not the end but a new beginning, a doorway into a journey we cannot yet imagine.” Sophia nodded, her eyes shining with quiet joy. “Exactly, Aurelius. If Jesus is the Logos, then his resurrection shows us that life itself is eternal, always moving further into the heart of God. Even after death, I believe we will find ourselves invited deeper into the mystery, into a love that has no end.” The two sat in silence, gazing up at the stars. In that moment, the heavens seemed to pulse with a hidden life, a promise that the universe itself was filled with the same infinite love they spoke of-a love that would carry them, even beyond the boundary of death, into life unending.

[@JadonStewart-g1u]

This is beautiful. May I ask what it's from?

[@Messianic-Gentile]

I agree that the One holds and cherishes the soul’s uniqueness after death. However, if eternity itself is full of movement and life, then what is the point of the resurrection and proposed new creation? I have always known intuitively that eternity is stillness. This is why we meditate to return to the Source. Movement/Change/Transformation is dependent on time and comes about through duality and external “things”, which are created and not eternal. I believe the Hebrew word for eternal can also be understood as everlasting or never-changing. If there is no change, then all is still. As for what that means for how eternal life/eternal torment is experienced, I have no idea. However, there seems to be a need for a resurrection both of life and of condemnation. This resurrection of condemnation might be a salvific process, or a merciful destruction. I don’t know.

[@KeirunQuinn]

To some degree we already experience the extraction of the bad in death. When we see news of gang members passing away, people mock those that make reference to their "goodness" & what cynical people they are to believe that even those most entrenched in violence don't have a shred of love in their bones.

[@AndyReichert0]

yes. eternal life includes the present life, but if it's just "be good, and life is good", it's nothing. It only matters if the physical matter of Jesus' flesh and bones were resurrected. If a man's eternal soul is just memories and influence, and he doesn't consciously experience an afterlife, Jesus is bunk, and materialist nihilism is true.

[@Naukaanimacji-kf2hy]

Yes!!! Why dont more people adress this

[@andyfoofoo5759]

He does not know whats next anymore than he knows whats next in a surreal dream he may have tonite. This is it. At least for now.

[@jnj02]

The problem with this perspective is that (despite all that is true about how we 'create' a heaven or hell for ourselves in this life), what is the role of the cross in this? Where is redemption? We certainly can't save ourselves! The life of Jesus and the cross was more than an example for us to follow. It accomplished a redemption for us that we receive by faith.

[@Naukaanimacji-kf2hy]

The concept of heaven as a specific realm for the soul has deep roots in Christian thought, shaped by both Scripture and longstanding theological traditions. While some argue that heaven is purely a metaphor or a state of mind, the idea of heaven as a true, designated place for the soul aligns with biblical teachings and provides a concrete hope of union with God after death. J 14:2-3, where Jesus says, “In my Father’s house are many rooms... I am going there to prepare a place for you,” suggest that heaven is not merely a state but a real "house" in God's presence. While physical bodies remain on Earth, awaiting resurrection, the soul is understood to immediately enter God’s presence, as indicated in Philippians 1:23, where Paul expresses his desire “to depart and be with Christ.” For Paul, to “depart” meant a distinct movement from this life to another state - a real communion with God in a place beyond this earthly realm.

[@johnsmoth7130]

Interesting perspective on the afterlife. I wonder how that'd play out for the unborn, infants and those who don't develop mentally. Not sure I think it's right, but wouldn't be upset if it were true!

[@bojannikolic4474]

The reality of this man and Jordan Peterson is that this man covers for Jordan Peterson and for all the answers you need to read 12 Rules for Life

[@Fr_Mitch]

18:24 "we're talking about your identity...your relationships..." This seems to run counter to Matt 22:30 when a man specifically asks if relationships endure at the resurrection, Jesus replied, "At the resurrection people will neither marry nor be given in marriage; they will be like the angels in heaven (who don't produce young)" Anyone have thoughts on this?

[@alem8100]

Jesus could be talking about whether people would have married relations as that between husband and wife, which is why he likens it to angels who don't reproduce.

[@ISAYWORDS1]

I don't think it runs counter at all. In that verse, a sadducee who doesn't believe in resurrection is trying to "gotcha" Christ by bringing up a woman who had been married to 8 brothers in her life, and asks who would she be married to? Well Fr. Stephens thinking here lines up well with what Jesus says in that, she won't be 'given in marriage' to the first or to the last or by whatever arbitrary metric you might come up with, but instead with this idea of eternal return, that her resurrected life will be a preservation of all her relationships in the new heavens and earth. That's how I see it anyway 😅

[@SonOfMorning]

This seems like it could be a 💎.

[@notloki3377]

finally, someone who understands that when you leave an article out in greek it means you add an indefinite article. one of the greatest crimes of the middle ages was that little translation error being conveniently left out.

[@eleos_7]

Great

[@johnroccuzzo]

What about the dead? My favourite movie scene to describe eternal life is in The Lion King when Simba speaks to his father in the clouds. Rafiki tells Simba “he lives in you.” Mufasa tells Simba “you have forgotten me.” Simba says “no, how could I!?” Mufasa says “you have forgotten who you are, and so forgotten me.” Our children in scripture are called our “images”, they represent us and all that remains of us when we die. This is not limited to children, but all those we impact, all the ways our time in this world affects the world and goes on to continue after we have gone into the ground. Our vices can continue to the next generation, but when heaven is on earth they will continue only in the sense of the eternal smoke that rises from their corpse. Think of the villains of this world and how their impact continues not as a role model of how to live, but a way of thinking to avoid. That is hell, or Gehenna, the place in Israel where they burnt all the idols that lead to child sacrifice.

[@broin6622]

Matthew 18:18 Assuredly, I say to you, whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.

[@amertlich]

Malachi 4:5-6 "Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and dreadful day of the Lord: And he shall turn the heart of the fathers to the children, and the heart of the children to their fathers, lest I come and smite the earth with a curse."

[@jbell0243]

There is so much good, there was some things that made me nervous. If we are trivializing the promises of God, that we shall live with Him forever and ever, though this is a non-temporal phenomenon then I’m ok.

[@1214gooner]

Well Jordan, what kind of resurrection would an embodied resurrection-resurrection proper to its fullest sense-be if it didn’t resurrect the body? What kind of a redeemer would a redeemer be if he didn’t “put all things in subjection under Him, so that He may be all in all?”

[@boldcut5163]

You can’t real understand what father talk only if you’re orthodox. You can understand like Jordan, mentally but not in the deep sense. You have to live and experience that in the Church. What is the Church? The Body of Christ! And the Holy Spirit guide you…

[@luisblanco4371]

Okay. You have to drink the kool-aid and be in the cult, and then you will get it. Once you are in the group and getting out is too hard, you will accent to everything that is false because you have no other option. This is utter heresy. Christ himself said that hell is a place of eternal sufferings and John the apostle reaffirms it in apocalypse because the devil and all the evil people are thrown into the lake of fire.

[@cbasallie]

I’m Orthodox and literally nothing that he talks about makes any sense to me

[@NightLetterLondon]

Catholicism is not so different, in my opinion. But I do believe, outside of these two Traditions one would be lost..

[@prettycatlick4373]

Great event...still talk to some of the boys I met there :)

[@AFringedGentianToEnnien]

I remember this, it was the Symbolic World Summit; and it was a mountaintop for me as well. I had a vision as I watched Dr. Peterson and saw what was written on the back of his jacket that he is a modern day St. Christopher, carrying the Christ child and with Him, the world, on his shoulders across the river. And now I know he does believe in the resurrection.

[@mik569]

He wears Icons of the Orthodox Christian Church..... Not sure how I feel about it.

[@NightLetterLondon]

@@mik569 Also Catholicism. Either way, he's 'speaking' for these Traditions. Certainly not Protestantism..

[@piotr2190]

No. There must be more to it then symbolic interpretation on eternity in our lifetime. there must be something literal in future ressurection of our body. Of what disciples saw after 3 days. I cannot agree with this talk. It sounds like heresy to me. Doesn't bring hope at all. Christian hope is that we will perceive something AFTER we die. And we will with Christ. I dont understand technically of it but this is not it. Thoughts of Father De Young makes me sad and not hopeful.

[@AmyMaris]

I’m a skeptic too.

[@Cyrus_II]

I think the point is that eternal life starts now and not after death. It will continue after. “The kingdom of Heaven does not come to observation. The kingdom of heaven is within you”

[@Naukaanimacji-kf2hy]

@@Cyrus_IIbut as i try to understand him he sounds like he denies perceiving in our counciousness our ability to live forever and see after moment of dying because as he says soul cannot exist without body and eternity in literal sense would make our life now obsolete beacuse it will be small fraction of time. It is very similiar to what jonathan says in videos called Christian dont die and go to heaven. I dont quite understand his massage even dough i read a lot philosophy and teology. But in the end literal imagining being with god end conciously experiencing new life give me mooore way more than this ideas presented here and by jonathan in other videos

[@Cyrus_II]

@@Naukaanimacji-kf2hy There are other kinds of bodies

[@piotr2190]

@@Cyrus_II ok, but jesus came from the dead in flesh, in renewed flesh that had wounds, he could eat in this flesh, so the premise is we also get to get new bodies with flesh

[@setsappa1540]

Thank you. Kinda scary the bits I think I understand..

[@TBT.Stories]

Make an extended version of the intro music ❤😂

[@iankaiser2401]

“Tho he, himself will be saved, yet only so as through fire” 1 Corinthians 3:15 The Flame of the Holy Spirit is the hellfire that saves, Glory Be!

[@canadacookie7796]

to love and be loved. Is there anything else?

[@tm27field]

I appreciate the talk and I don’t mean any disrespect but I think the fact that so many religious people especially priests are physically unhealthy is an elephant in the room and it would be interesting to me to see JP discuss this phenomenon.

[@brandabrothers2127]

C.S. Lewis covers this topic beautifully in The Great Divorce.

[@Bartisim0]

This makes me think of Dante

[@Theophan.pilgrim]

I think of a Christmas carol.

[@MihajloB]

If i ever go to USA it will be because fr Stephen de Young to hear his lecture 😂

[@ChristIsKingPhilosophy]

Peterson shouldn't have stepped up and railroaded the talk, and he should've been deferent.

[@shivabreathes]

I agree

[@NightLetterLondon]

Maybe. But he was there because Jonathan invited him. And he is trying to learn.. He was deferent, and wanted answers, asked questions.. He was also out of his depth and you could tell that..

[@ChristIsKingPhilosophy]

@@NightLetterLondon sorry, no. deferent is not jumping on stage while another person is giving a talk. deference is not merely an inward disposition, it's an objective behavior in terms of objective standards. he should've waited to ask a question after Fr Stephen had ended the conversation, and talked in private instead of addressing the audience.

[@adidelapatru1466]

Hello Jonathan Pageau,I was curious if you saw the latest A24 film Heretic and will you be doing an analysis on the symbols used and how faith in God has been depicted?

[@kikadin]

What is the music used in the introduction?

[@jokerguycz]

please pray for me, if this is true then I am going forever to hell.

[@shivabreathes]

I was mostly following Fr Stephen’s talk until Jordan Peterson started his rapid fire questioneering

[@johnsalamito6212]

At 1:00:30 is the great comment about the body. Gnostics and mystics take the alternate view, which denies ordinary reality.

[@ronalddombroski4235]

What about the 'good thief' who asks Jesus to remember him when he comes into His kingdom? Miserable life saved by his act of compassion at the end of his life?

[@davidramsey2566]

Indeed. There is a lot that I don’t think this understanding can adequately address.

[@ChrishBlake]

I wanna just mention the desert fathers. Perhaps sacrifice and experiencing hell, that is your faults, voluntarily and as much as possible is what the proximal, or the profane, or matter, or earth, is made of when you’re in that rare space around you that is clear and peaceful. At that moment you look around as the spirit of the fathers inhabits you and you notice all the things around you are there because you sacrificed.

[@kittentacticalwarfare1140]

Hell is so real, it's geometry is why we have the depressed monkey experiment. It's arrogant to think that those things our modern science still can't grasp, is not real despite all the ancients knowing better.

[@karlhetzke691]

Fr. De Young's idea that identity is rooted in relationship feels deeply correct to me... But I'm curious to hear his thoughts on Jesus's answer to the Sadducees' question about the many-times-married widow. When Jesus speaks of human relationships after the resurrection, he seems to say that earthly bonds are no longer relevant.

[@Theophan.pilgrim]

A Christmas carol 2 the onion of truth.

[@adrbaz]

Really amazing. Thanks Jonathan, Father Stephen, Jordan :)

[@dermotgilmartin1818]

Hello 👋🇮🇪

[@Naukaanimacji-kf2hy]

1 Corinthians 15:19 19 If only for this life we have hope in Christ, we are of all people most to be pitied

[@simritnam612]

@44:00, JBP starts

[@AndrewMitchell-xv5uq]

Many good points in this talk. But sometimes we make the mistake of over psychologizing the revelation of Jesus. It was God’s intention for us to understand these truths through the scope of the Church he founded; not psychology.

[@basedbuddha777]

Big If True.

[@amertlich]

47:49 The Latter-day Saint tradition has a temple liturgy that has some resonances with this. Particularly regarding salvation for the dead and the vital role of bodily, though vicarious, participation in entering into a covenant relationship with God. Fr. Stephen said "A person can't repent for themselves but the community can intercede for them"- Jordan responded that this is a concept reflected in the way we "carry forward the spirit of great individuals from the past". This idea is central to the LDS Church’s genealogical work and temple ordinances, where the living act on behalf of the deceased to help them progress spiritually.

[@MiyamotoMusashi9]

Joe and Jill went up the hill to get a pail of water, Joe fell down and lost his crown,and Jill fell right after

[@corygoodrich1970]

The degree to which we to claim the chaff as life is the degree to which the flaming sword is hell. The degree to which we accept the gift of Joy as life is the degree to which the flaming sword does not touch us…………………”MY ONION”

[@nathan1720-p9m]

Doesn't this sound like Elitism. So those who do most of the work are the ones with eternal life???

[@corygoodrich1970]

@@nathan1720-p9mI don’t think work has anything to do with it.