FROM Season 3 Theories | Julie's Time Travel | Martin's Secret | The Answers Are at the Beginning!

[@Noshushpls]

If they cancel this show I’ll never get over it not only is it a good show but the community behind it it is is amazing !

[@WolverDean]

I have a theory about when boyd and sarah got dragged in the tent at the end of season 1. I think they weren't actually dragged. I think the landscape changed and they rolled around. I think an entity has the ability to alter the land. Victor even mentioned that the trees move. It would also be an interesting way for the entity to control where the people explore futher manipulating them. It may also explain what happened to the motel.

[@Likilagushka]

Love it!

[@l05555]

Exactly, that was my initial thought. I don't think the spiders theory makes sense for that scene

[@likeluptid]

Victor never once hinted that the trees move like that. 4 inches, man. The trees moved 4 inches. Boyd and Sara were transported several miles. It was quiet where Boyd set up the tent. They were dragged for a few seconds and we're close enough to hear the loud foghorn of the nearby tower. You've gotta move a good few miles for 0 sound, not even a faint distant foghorn blast, to the sound being right there with you. The landscape doesn't change like that. Interestingly, the tent moved several miles fast, and was left amidst newly hatching spiderling. There is definitely a mother spider nearby. And very often, but not always, one of the last things the mother spider does when she lays all those eggs is leave food with the eggs before she dies. Boyd and Sara were supposed to be dinner for the spiderlings as soon as they hatched. Obviously not recognizing the silk, probably because he's from the city and cityfolk never know anything, Boyd walked right in at the same time the eggs were hatching. Even after the spiderlings came out, Boyd didn't even recognize that if you see a bunch of little spiders coming out of silk, there is a much bigger spider nearby. Without wondering anything, he and Sara walked off. There was definitely a giant spider. I am theorizing that it was what dragged them to the nest for dinner.

[@likeluptid]

​@l05555 4 inches. The trees moved 4 inches. Boyd's tent was taken several miles to a nest of spider eggs that just happened to hatch while Boyd and Sara were there. Boyd must be from the city and didn't recognize what he was seeing when he stepped out of the tent. There is no question at all that there is a giant spider nearby. They were standing in the midst of definite proof of that. I believe that that's enough evidence, circumstantial evidence, to conclude that they were taken by a dying mother spider who left the tent in the silk as food for her spiderlings when they hatch. (A lot of mothers die around the time the spiderlings hatch, but not without leaving food there first.)

[@WolverDean]

@likeluptid everyone is obsessed with there assumptions that there are giant spiders. Spider's were referenced and spiders were shown. Also Victor never clarified what he meant about the treats movie. Lack of clarity isn't logic against the idea I stated. But keep waiting on them giant spiders lol I'm not

[@MOK9888]

2 points: In S2E1, Tabitha may not have heard Julie calling “Mom” but we defiantly hear her in that scene, connecting Julie to the scene in the tunnels S3E8. Love the idea of the trees in the road being faraway trees since the faraway trees are portals and the downed trees transport people to Fromville but I want to point out that nobody sees the same down tree, they are all different trees at their point of origin, there isn’t just one downed tree.

[@LarisaBayaMomo]

After they said that the first episode has so many clues I watched it about 5 times through, trying to figure it out.They talked about the lake of tears and Ethan mentioned fairies. Also, they all came into town whilst driving, nobody ever walked in. I think the answers are in all the small details. The interesting thing was also the boy who said to Julie "don't you remember me". Looks like Tabetha and Julie have been in that town before.

[@sceneinvaders]

Amazing comment per usual ❤️

[@shparto1118]

@@LarisaBayaMomo I think it's more likely Julie time travels again and interacts with this guy while doing so

[@ChrisM-yq2pq]

Then the boy who asked Julie if she remembered him is friends with monsters or turned into a monster

[@MoksiLesi91]

@@LarisaBayaMomo the boy in white is Thomas 😋

[@BaDazai]

😮 I feel that man was grown up ethan or thomas and he said 'don't you recognise me', Julie even walks a bit towards him as if she did, like seeing a grown up version of a family member you last saw as a kid - they look both familiar and unfamiliar. Also, the monsters didn't attack, they just stood there. They chose not to attack like they chose not to attack Victor.

[@avizonpictures9697]

The tree in the road is a metaphor of life’s problems we always look back instead of going through it. Que Sera Que Sera

[@Cecelovesbirdie]

The new cop Acosta- Acosta was originally used to describe people who live near coastal areas or lived in the mountains... The lighthouse from Camden was drawn by water and the mountains . Camden is 1 of a couple places where mountain meets the sea. Im thinking Acosta is a representation of the tower or something like that. Very coincidental in the name

[@2blickbic]

when sara and boyd get to that bottle tree sara also states she hears a woman screaming that “she made a mistake and she shouldnt have come here”, that’s possibly miranda and a hint that saving the kids was a trap.

[@SaraStarlight-sw8lb]

I think the voices of good side are keep out of the town and they are trapped in the forest far away from people who can listen to them, that means the voices Sara was listening to in the season 1 were the evil side of the voices. Sara heard Abby and Miranda while being in the forest is a big clue.

[@Likilagushka]

I think you're 100% right about Sarah hearing Miranda. Not yet sure if saving the children is a trap or the actual solution. It's still makes sense that Miranda feels it's a mistake if she was not the one who was supposed to go in the tree (we are now lead to believe it was Christopher because he was the one asked to do so by the boy in white) so maybe for it was only a mistake for Miranda and caused her death...

[@Cecelovesbirdie]

Maby the children sacrificed themselves to keep the monsters trapped, and freeing the children will let monsters loose

[@georgetackie3558]

I believe that the seizures are a sign of a character either time traveling or going to different dimension. Ethan, Sara, Elgin and Julie have all had seizures. Ethan said in first season after his seizure, he saw the lake of tears and pictures on a wall in crayon (victors room). Idk maybe something

[@Gabriela-zi1wl]

@@georgetackie3558 I think he saw the giant spider too

[@Shaggy_Is_Shwaggy]

I think of this town as an infinity loop. Everything that could possibly happen will happen and already has happen. The same way Boyd only Got out of that hole because of Julie on the future, I’m willing to bet a large portion of events that have already happened were affected by events that were yet to happen, because everything is interconnected. What happens in the end of this show could very well be the reason the beginning ever happens to begin with.

[@erikblanco2763]

Also, you never seem to pass the town on the way to the fallen tree! You only enter Fromville when you turn around from the tree. Now my mind is spinning!! Let's see someone go back to the tree and go past it in the same direction they were initially travelling.

[@HarshMelon]

What really struck me about the first scene with the Matthews family was that Tabitha consoled Ethan by telling him that there was no need to worry if Norman had been killed by monsters, because monsters aren't real.

[@andrewv8905]

Fatima being scared could trigger a fight or flight finalizing the transformation, then she kills Elgin

[@WBJOJOHNSON]

It was the TREE ALL ALONG!!

[@timr3023]

😅

[@miximojo]

When Jim and Tabitha are driving in circles during episode 1, Tabitha has an idea that the road to the highway might be a "switchback" where you would need to do a U-turn to get back on the original road. Looking back this feels like a huge tease at the time travel concept they are introducing.

[@Cecelovesbirdie]

@miximojo and ethan told him to drive through it, but jim didn't listen to anyone

[@mrsw2923]

With the new scar on Randals face he is the spitting image of the man in yellow

[@mithaqali9921]

@@mrsw2923 who is the man in yellow?

[@mrsw2923]

@ one of the drawings.

[@craggyy]

Why did Miranda try to go through the far away tree at night time instead of during the day? Maybe the trick is that you can only save the kids by going through the three at night and the monsters come at night to keep people locked indoors in the town to stop or prevent them from getting to the far away tree.

[@Tee_Babie9]

I believe Toby may be a key to the answers. They never saw the tree but ended up wrecking before ever going through the town. No one knew about the other car until he came asking for help- possibly why Sarah had to kill him

[@Cecelovesbirdie]

And why was the guy driving crazy and caused rv to crash? I can't remember

[@brandonS141]

He did, him and Jade did see the tree. They just never got to the town before they crashed. Both high out of their minds and swirving on the road

[@brandonS141]

​@@Cecelovesbirdiehigh on something

[@LadypassportT]

Using the Faraway Trees , the dates are the attempts to go back to the beginning to stop the sacrifice of the children. The dates in the bottles are the dates that were tried.

[@annebethkuijs9442]

Maybe the Lighthouse is also a place to slip through time. Because when Tabitha walked up the stairs time also seemed to shift.

[@BattleDamageProps]

It just hit me, what if the monsters know every bodies names and situations, have all this info, because the whole story is just one giant self contained 'Julie throwing the rope' loop. Except the monsters always retain the info from previous loops. This could be attempt number 9000 for them.

[@HEY_Letsplay_withPai]

Did you know in Viktor’s flash back, the empty space above the motel say Star Magic. It’s now empty in current episodes. Not sure if this means anything but worth notating knowing this show lol

[@davidagiel8130]

The falling tree on the road is the first threshold on the journey. It's the barrier between the ordinary world and the special world, the autumn equinox.

[@rcollins4958]

Its a far away tree!!

[@davidagiel8130]

​@@rcollins4958yes, a tree that "falls" on the road, when we enter the season of Fall/autumn.

[@avizonpictures9697]

The tree in the road is a faraway tree. You have to go through it to get back home. Everyone keeps turning back

[@Dreamevil2009]

I like this alot maybe it is just an illusion. No one that I remember has tried to touch it or go on top of it jump over it form what I rmemeber.

[@MumRah441]

Yes, They try but the crows come and scare them away.

[@Dreamevil2009]

@@MumRah441 ah maybe if they push through they w ill be fine then

[@tamaracuttill782]

Ethan walks on it in the first episode before they see the crow's​@@Dreamevil2009

[@Zadian-y4g]

The beginning shows Ethan climbing on the tree. This ain’t it

[@maryharrison6948]

Something’s with the birds. The S.1, Ep. 1 the crow appears when Jim sets Ethan on the tree in the road. Then more crows come. Jim says a storm must’ve knocked the tree over across the road. Tabitha says, yeah, a “selective” storm. Interesting. Julie teases Ethan about more than one crow being a “murder” of crows. Tabitha tells Ethan the birds may be ravens and more than one raven is a “kindness” of ravens. Idk. But interesting with the birds in the theme’s beginning and in Victor’s colorings. Also, Julie playing with Ethan and “ killing” his toys. Once you’re dead you can’t come back. Tabitha telling him there are no monsters…

[@brimfulofyashaonthe4599]

Ends at the beginning, Julie reading a story to give the children hope. Julie is potentially going to other times, maybe she ends up stuck in the past.

[@lisasimpson8895]

the man in yellow reveal wil most definitely be the cliff hanger of this season.

[@sceneinvaders]

I hope so!

[@connormcnab540]

What's this "man in yellow" all about? I feel like I missed something..

[@Dream-Musiiic]

@@connormcnab540 He's from the paintings remember

[@704Nike]

@@lisasimpson8895 People are saying that the man in yellow is Randall. If you look at the picture of him, he has a red scar on the side of his cheek, and Randall has that cut on his face from being attacked by the creatures.

[@2blickbic]

I think that they time travel via astral projection because their bodies never leave the current period, think days of futures past. the seizures are the key. anytime someones seized up their mind has been else where, ethan when he was in the rv, julie/randall/marielle in the dungeon, julie at the dungeon ruins, the only other time I can think of is sara in the diner and at the bottle tree and she seizes up when the voice is speaking to her.

[@fernandaolivares7926]

There are two paradoxes that could be at play here... the Bootstrap paradox and the Grandfather paradox... Answer: What do Tabitha and Miranda's remember their bracelet is made of? BOOTSRAPS! That is a huge revelation to the audience because it could be a clue from future fromvillers to let themselves know they are trapped in a multiverse loop or the bracelet itself could be the object that future fromvillers keep bringing back because it has a role to play. Maybe the stone in the center is the reason why it's important. If it is the bootstrap paradox or the grandfather paradox or both, it means every time someone travels to the past a new universe is created. The multiverse. They never go back to the universe they first came from, just a version of it, hence why there could be several versions of our characters could be traveling in and out their own loops. Our brains will hurt at the end that is for sure.

[@MarshallClicksPhotography]

Thanks!

[@frances.e.s8203]

It’s interesting you mention interstellar. Because in hindsight he was sending signals to his daughter through Morse code in that room, and in the first season the lights flicker when Tabitha is talking about maybe onto something. Especially when she’s talking about the bracelet

[@sceneinvaders]

Yes! It makes sense!

[@WBJOJOHNSON]

THE MAN IN THE YELLOW SUIT feel like I'm watching the flash all over again

[@chaseclarkemusic]

It's Harrison wells he's behind all this!

[@savannahworth2495]

There are no kids in the town besides Ethan. Somehow this is a very important part of the story because something told Sarah to kill him and I think it’s because he could save the town. Victor’s pictures come true and I feel like Ethan has the power to do the same thing, but hasn’t figured it out yet.

[@revolutionaryliberation9250]

@@savannahworth2495 But There Were Kids In The First Show. Boyd Walking Through Town Ringing The Bell, Kids Are Walking By, One With A Bike, & Remember The 1st Murder Is The Girl Who Opened Window!! But I've Also Noticed No Other Kids Anymore!🤔

[@robert123re8]

Or maybe Ethan is there to replace the boy in white it would make sense he resembles Ethan to me and like you said he might have the same power as victor or he could even be stronger and how the story line has been going everytime they involve Ethan he actually helps so what if he dies if they can’t break the cycle and he ends up becoming the boy in white to help the next group of people that come into the town

[@evanzi1333]

Have you noticed when Julie was in the kind of vision in the caves down with her mom and Victor, that she heard “anghkooey” a couple of times? Then the “anghkooey” slowly becomes “Julie” when her brother and Kenny call her. It has some kind of similarities in the sounding between anghkooey and Julie.😮

[@md.md16]

Aunt Julie 😅😅😅

[@wesamazori5210]

Whys everyone so surprised by Julie’s basement encounter with Martin. I always saw when residents came to town and would drive over and over in a loop it was the same thing as Julie throwing the rope to Boyd

[@obiwankenoobi4202]

I am one of those people who discovered the show this season. I was honestly shocked i hadn't even heard of it as it's right up my alley. Binged seasons 1 and 2 on my days off. I'm looking forward to at least a few more seasons.

[@sceneinvaders]

Same here! It has to happen

[@danielrus7509]

Since they introduced the time travel aspect, what if the voices inside Sarah's head are the villagers from the future. The voices instructed Sara to do some horrible things, but what if they were necessary in order to put some characters on their path of progression.

[@joerod2019]

Man in yellow has to be Randall bc of time travel, scar on his right cheek, and big ears vs pict painted in Mirandas studio

[@Gbralta]

I think that the symbol is the roots of the tree that is fallen when you enter Fromville. The children are lying down and looking up through a hole. There may be answers at the base of the tree that brings you to Fromville.

[@StacieFlores-l9i]

Oohhhh I love it ❤

[@Cecelovesbirdie]

They did do a closeup on base of tree! Gotta go look at it again

[@eddyquara]

I’m in love with the ‘Aunt Julie’ theory 🤣

[@ChrisM-yq2pq]

If it’s the kids saying that, I came up with that

[@andykopgod]

There was a similiar programme over here in UK called Life On Mars where Sam Tyler is in an accident and goes back in time to 1972, my thoughts are is that they are all dead to start with and they are stuck in pergutuary, the town, building, monsters are all connected to their past.

[@kayellis4096]

In the 1st episode Boyd goes to see Ellis, he says about Fatima 'she doesn't change does she?.The town was sure that she would change, I just wonder in what way.......

[@rubiks15]

After seeing Julie's 'time travel' I'm starting to think that young teenage nightmare creature is a future Ethan! Yes, "Julie, don't you recognize me?" We thought nightmare creatures were using hypnosis, but it was really a sibling recognizing another despite the age jump. Oh and notice the weeding dress tabby found in the tunnels was being worn behind teenage Ethan in the second episode by another nightmare creature. Who's under it?

[@sceneinvaders]

🤯🤯🤯🤯

[@Likilagushka]

Don't take it the wrong way, but I hope you're wrong 😅😅🫶🏼

[@EbonyEyez415]

@@rubiks15 what if it is Ethan!!! Grown up

[@jamesp2708]

I think Certain areas of from are in a Time Bubble. The dungeon is in a short time loop probably about the length of the music box song. So one area of from is in a loop from a certain time period. Why different parts of the map have different dates. Watch the movie called The Endless. For more details

[@RachelLeahCreates]

I love the cromenockle book theory. Even if it ends up being less (or more) of the “answers” of the show, I made my own “Flight of the Cromenockle” into a notebook for my very genius theories.

[@juliemarie612]

I wouldn't say that Elgin is a good guy who's been led astray, same with Sarah. It isn't intentions that determine our morality, it's our actions and their impact on the world. No matter how desperate I am to go home, no way would I EVER be able to kill someone, then let in creatures to torture and kill two people. I would never kidnap someone and hold them against their will while watching their loved ones search for them. It's like Elgin doesn't even see Fatima as a person, he just sees her as a vessel for kimono woman's baby...yuck. One would have to be incredibly naive to think that someone who's asking you to kill, maim, and/or kidnap your peers would be honest about wanting to help. Literally, how dumb would you have to be to believe them?

[@kassandrashaffer210]

They better not cancel this show. it's really good.that look likes Victor dad George in the cellar chained up.they're definitely in a time travel.

[@whizzpop3538]

Sort of wondering if all the characters that have had seizures are able to time travel to an extent? Almost like they're glitching and can't be in two places at once. Ethan recalls a location with a spider after his seizure, and Elgin mentions a lake or The Brundles? Sara seems to interact with characters we can't see or hear. I'm thinking they may have been taken back, but can't physically change things like Julie. They just see glimpses of past timelines... not sure where I'm going with this - just an observation. 😅

[@FakeDriftChris]

17:56 first tree is a faraway tree..the fact its fell over opens the portal and anyone who comes in contact with it is teleporting to fromville. Someone who sees the tree next needs to reset it..we need a logging crew to see it now lol

[@captcardwell3398]

Jade escapes, looks in the mirror and he's the guy on the right...years before the ritual ready to stop it 😂

[@joerod2019]

Interesting point...the writers make it a point to that Tom and Katri know they are dead. Not with Abbi though.

[@tamaracuttill782]

I really believe it's something to do with dreaming kind of like Alice in wonderland. In Lost there were so many references to not being alive throughout the series and in this show there have been references to dreaming. So much doesn't make sense and most of the time dreams don't. Elgin was literally asleep when entering Fromville. I don't know how the characters are linked but I do believe they are dreaming and the talismans are like dream catcher's. 🤷‍♀️

[@zayzo07111]

anybody else wonder how sara survived in the woods after helping boyd escape through the faraway tree

[@SweeetHoneyBread]

Didn’t she say she got transported to the church and never left ?

[@RahYisrael99]

@@SweeetHoneyBread yeah she was in the basement the entire time.

[@belgradewanderer]

I like how back in the day watching Lost I had so many theories that could explain things but in From, no matter what theory I think of, it doesn't give enough explanations. Amazing show, I just hope they don't screw it up.

[@Vaeland]

after the most recent episode I think the children saying Anhkooey are actually saying "aunt julie". I think she is the storyteller that eventually gives the children hope, echoing the very first scene of the show.

[@CasanovaPugilist147]

Yeah show is just copying stuff from Game of Thrones lol

[@StacieFlores-l9i]

I hope That the Tree at the beginning is the key. I bet it is a faraway tree too. And I'm guessing if each faraway tree is located and each one of our main characters walk thru a separate tree at the same time, that might stop the cycle and remove the tree from the beginning. Just a thought.

[@tebjosh13]

GOOOOO BIRDS!!! E A G L E S. love your vids from is a trip.

[@sceneinvaders]

🦅 🦅 🦅 FLY EAGLES FLY!! - and thanks for the support

[@TheGreatOceanDisasterAquariums]

There's loads happening at the sound studio. Very busy every evening so I assume they are filming season 4 already whether renewed or not.

[@cpmow831]

I like the theory about who the screams are.

[@TetsuoIVIX]

Instead of Interstellar, I see it more like how Twin Peaks did it. Both for sure works though (they're basically the same thing) From for sure takes influence from Twin Peaks, mostly The Return.

[@maetaylor5677]

It seems like if Julie can go back in time, she can see the "who" and find out the "why" the children were sacrificed. Go back to the beginning? I think Julie is a big key to unraveling the mystery. Julie will probably confide in Ethan and hopefully, this info gets out so everyone can make some moves in this and work at solving the riddle. Of course Ethans book must in some way forshadow a similar plot "rescuing the children" " a quest" etc I don't think it is likely that the people can escape the town. I think it's the hope that feeds the town and the aftermath of things not working. This town just seems like hell to me. But I want to hope they get out. If others have escaped, hmmm, that would be interesting. These writers are fucking crazy who knows where they will drive this story. I am here for the ride..

[@sceneinvaders]

Same here!!

[@chinguyen8778]

What if it means go to the very start where it all began. What is the significance of the fallen tree? Perhaps chop up that fallen tree into a raft and sail down the lake which is probably a river to freedom?

[@sceneinvaders]

🤯🤯🤯🤯

[@madisonzimmerle7394]

@@chinguyen8778 can they go back to the tree? I thought once they turn around and start driving they go through the town loop and don’t see the tree again.

[@XTEX]

The blood is for the baby when Elgin was taking his blood there was a milk Bottle on the table

[@FunTimeWithSouls]

What I don't understand is why Henry and Victor don't talk about Eloise like at all.

[@sceneinvaders]

Yea same here!

[@ChrisM-yq2pq]

I’ve said this before. I don’t think the sister really exist. Victor is not a trusty narrator. Like he actually believe that a wooden puppet talk. This is way beyond normal. I mean who thinks this way and then he remembered I was boy in white. Like how does an inanimate object become a ghost boy. It’s so screwed up that him not having a sister isn’t even out of the realm

[@FunTimeWithSouls]

@ see I would agree if Henry didn't mention her when he was talking to Tabitha at his house.

[@dashl1109]

They didn't talk about Miranda too. I think they're just assuming they both dead, so there's not much to say.

[@Imbadatleague]

Either Xander really likes talking From or He’s on that Colony House Reefer🍃😂

[@sceneinvaders]

Maybe both!!

[@Imbadatleague]

@ Touché

[@goolch]

Wild theory but here I go… I think Christopher was the one that told SARAH to kill the boy (not Ethan) but the boy in white. When Julie time travel, she was having a seizure. What if every character that had a seizure before was actually time traveling to the future/past? (Ethan, Elgin, SARAH, etc…) Once you time travel, the memory doesn’t come back with you fully. I think Miranda traveled to the past when she was on acid and saw what happened to the children. She wasn’t able to remember it all which explains the paintings, dreams and visions. The original bottle tree is where it all happened and the artist of the tree is going to be the man in yellow. He’s also going to be the owner of the moving company. Secretly pulling some strings. He going to be someone that lived in Fromville for a long time and somehow escaped, some kinda of big reveal (Ethan? Randal? Ethan’s son? (Ethan and boy in white do look a-lot alike ) ). Jim will die and Julie will wear his bracelet to remember him. She will go crazy from time traveling trying to save him. Seeing the past and future events. Eventually, Julie will escape somehow. But she’ll end up in 1960ish with no memory of who she is and a messed up mind with faint memories of Fromville past and future. She will become Miranda, explaining why there’s two bracelets. Why they have the same song and why she has the dreams/visions. Memento from her past subconsciously. All triggered by acid and the original far away tree. Now if we saw Julie time travel… I think the boy in white is Ethan’s son who was told all these stories by Ethan. He is visiting the past trying to fix things. That’s why he knows stuff and that’s why the voice Jim hears on the phone /radio knew everything. Maybe Ethan even names his son Thomas…

[@TheRidg11]

@goolch well thats the best explanation I've heard, I'm sold on the Julie/Miranda part, the bracelet part has been annoying me since it showed up in the car, we already saw Mirandas on her wrist so unless Victors Dad is lying and he's been there before there is no way he could have it. I think it would make more sense if the boy in white was the real Thomas though, something to do with Tabitha or the Matthews connection to the place

[@masteraso]

I like your theory,there is one thing that will not stand and that's Richards'father who came into town and saw Julie as a young woman . He would definitely remember her as the young Miranda right?

[@goolch]

@ I don’t think he has seen her yet…

[@masteraso]

@@goolch hmm interesting 🤔

[@johnrainey2774]

Also remember not just Tabitha and Miranda saw fromville in a dream. Abby also said to Ellis that she remembered a dream she had when she was a kid

[@FunTimeWithSouls]

Ankhooey was translated from a Native American tribes word for Remember.

[@ChrisM-yq2pq]

It’s aunt Julie

[@chinguyen8778]

Fromtown really feels like a sadistic bar bet between entities. On one side it’s all: A leopard doesn’t change its spots, as in all things are predestined to occur regardless of time/circumstance like drunks addicts murderers etc for example. The other side is like there’s no fate but what we make type of deal as in stereotypical behaviour can be broken. Both using similar repetitive stereotypes in fromvile to see who is correct.

[@owenbunny]

@@chinguyen8778 this reminds me of Lost and the bet between Jacob and the man in black.

[@chinguyen8778]

Yeah ur right. It’s intriguing the way formvile really explores the human condition. Takes the finger ppl point at others right back upon themselves. Elis blaming his father for his mother’s death only to be faced with the same predicament with his own newlywed wife for instance. Also what with Jim always brushing off his kids? Julie barely walked in the door and Jimbo right away says look after ur lil bro. She then drags him into a dangerous situation at the ruins. I mean she was out in stolen vans smoking weed with grown men sleeping over everybody’s pl while daddy was out grabbing some handful of side salad with random chick deep in the fromwoods.

[@Father_Daniel]

This was a really great video guys! When I first saw the priest I thought he looked like Martin to but on IMDb they're played by two different actors. (Still never know cuz it could be same character at dif ages) But I'm still suspect of that priest , exspecially bringing up Thomas. Also IF we get to see this man in yellow I think my head may explode 🤯 lmfao

[@49poper]

Julie is victors brother in another timeline just like Ethan is victor in another timeline. I believe she got out of town or is still there. If she is still there that means other people are alive just not living in the town. Not sure why she didn’t visit her dad if she got out of town though.

[@Likilagushka]

Theory : Martin is either the boy in white OR he's the one who told the children the story which gave them hope, or maybe both are true! Martin's condition suggests he's also being punished for something.. Looks like he's immortal, but in a different way the monsters are. So maybe his punishment is being eternally trapped in the heart of the time/consciousness loop, but somehow he's still able to "project" himself to appear before people. He appears as a the boy in white because he was that child when the original sacrifice happened and somehow he got away, subsequently punished. Or he appears to people as a boy so to seem unreliable.. Because why trust a little boy...? Does anyone think this could be true?

[@BattleDamageProps]

I've said it before, the story of from is a loop that goes back to viking Explorer days (1100's) and will tie to the original inhabitants of the land. In Native American culture yellow can represent divinity. The man in yellow will probably be a false god responsible for the entire situation .

[@j-curvementality4639]

A yall!! What if Ahnkooey is really them saying Aunt Julie...whoa!!!!!!!

[@aharvey102]

@sceneinvaders I have a theory that the "Michael Myers" horror movies can contribute some meaningful inference to from. In the Michael Myers movies the past of Michael Myers is tied to ancient clan who sacrifices kids for the clan prosperity. Also the sacrifice is made to a Celtic deity, whose symbol is literally similar or same to the ones shown on the talisman in from. You can do a lil dive and let me know what you think about it.

[@chantikawinfrey7707]

When they was trying to put that Tower up the town had hoped that they would be saved but then that cloud and storm came and it took the Hope away and made them miserable

[@beefyronin]

So Julie throws rope down, thats how Boyd gets up and gets infected with the worms and how the music box monster get released. The music box monster is what gets Julie, Randle and Mari......so we now have a true paradox because neither of these things can happen without the other one. Its like a cosmic loop that the hope from the town gets the evil from the town to become vulnerable to someone going through the Faraway Tree to save the children but its not the lighthouse its the underground world they will have to be traversed to save the creepy kids. This show rules, but man, there are so many ways they can mess it up.

[@connormcnab540]

I hope we get some answers by the end of the season about who/what the monsters are. I also hope they dont go past 5 seasons.. they have a 5 season plan.. nothing worse than a show that goes for 3 too many seasons

[@BoomerCosmo]

Silly theory, the man in yellow is the baby. 😅 I see people saying it the new smiley but what if it's a bigger bad to end this groups cycle.

[@DappsTheProducer]

Waiting for victor to remember what really happened in the massacre

[@Gamingwithgleez]

Go Birds!

[@sceneinvaders]

🦅 🦅 🦅 Fly Eagles Fly!

[@md.md16]

Just had a crazy thought. What if the monsters end up turning Boyd into one them? 🤔 They've always wanted to brake him, so that would be the last drop. Or.... They turn his son..

[@i_aexis]

It got me thinking. The answer is the beginning. No one ever get to check the tree that falls down the road. Nobody ever tried to walk beyond the fallen tree. If it's in the beginning it might be the tree that they all have seen is the answer to go home.

[@i_aexis]

Maybe they just have to remove it?

[@Gainoffuntion]

They get a new shipment everytime people die right? Totally plausible it's the same people in a different life. The ankh idea is an interesting one. Will definitely look into that

[@ChannieBoo3]

Ouuuu the priest theory 😮 I like it

[@raulortiz547]

Im definitely starting to think the visions they are having are actually memories displaced in time from the last season of From. Like, is Tabitha herself the one aproaching the girl ftom tha POV behind the rock? Also, I always though the command to Sarah to "kill the boy" was in reference to the boy in white and not Ethan. TBIW seems to have escaped what happened to the other children.

[@jordanclark6972]

Maybe it wasn't time travel per say but like astral projection since she was outside of her body. Maybe that's something we'll hopefully see more of the next two episodes

[@JasonBlum-ke7vn]

Eloise and young tabitha are completely different actors, as are Martin and the priest

[@codycox2465]

Remember Ethan walking on top of the tree?

[@sceneinvaders]

Yup he did that I remember

[@sourajit_43]

If it’s all a time paradox, then I feel Martin is probably someone we already know, because the past is connected to the present, Julie is literally interacting and affecting the past. Also, Martin seems to know Julie and Boyd already. And I don’t know if it’s just me but Martin looks a little bit like Henry :(

[@levilama]

Martin does not look like the priest at all 😂 but the priest was definitely suspicious

[@ascitiesburn41]

Gets going to be like supernatural it was originally set for five seasons and with the steam this show has depending on how the fifth season ends they might keep going

[@sceneinvaders]

I'd be okay with that!

[@FunTimeWithSouls]

Just started, hopefully my theory is in this video!

[@FunTimeWithSouls]

And it's not :(. Damn it was pinned on another video and then asked which one on another video :*(

[@sceneinvaders]

I couldn't find it!!!!! Tell me the title of the video it's pinned in and I PROMISE we do it next week. I'm gonna write it down right now

[@FunTimeWithSouls]

@@sceneinvaders this one kzbin.info/www/bejne/ppuooZSgiqibnrMsi=P2tS1QOD1QySzGT7

[@FunTimeWithSouls]

@@sceneinvaders The video was FROM Season 3 Theories | Tabitha's "Dream" or Memory? | Victor's Sacrifice | Jade's Plan

[@sceneinvaders]

Boom. Locked in will read it next theory video!

[@madamesherice]

Starting to think if the theories that the boy in white is one of the intended children that survived, the voices Sara heard were the original people -“the boy” is the boy in white to complete the ritual. Was the ritual completed if the town is the story the kids put together with their hope. No that can’t be right. This show has had me in a fog for years now. I’ve rewatched so many times. When we get answers, I’m sure I’ll be like -of course! Hah 👀 🖤🌙

[@madamesherice]

I will say the time travel thing revealing how that one monster knew Julie (the grandma too) from season one. When this show first came out, I thought the monsters were appearing as people they knew. That isn’t the case. It’s time travel. Which makes me think Julie ends up back there as an adult, but in the past. Hoowwwww what is life even.

[@orunoawhie5695]

In the image in the cave where the monsters live there is a drawing of the towns history It seems the first people where traveling through water before they saw the tree And it seems dey are leaving in some sort of dream realm And in the drawing two people where watching dem when dey where making the sacrifice I think Tabatha Is a recan of one if dem and the boy in white is one of the children that escaped And also some is coming that could cause everyone to die like In Victor's days

[@connormcnab540]

You cant go back in time and change the past. If something happened in the past and you go back and manipulate something, you have already lived it. Like in Interstellar, he couldnt have recienved the message saying stay if he didnt go to be able to send it in the forst place. I definitely think that in order to leave the town, you have to sacrifice the children who then curse the town as punishment for the people who sacrificed them. And the cycle repeats. Never ending. They will escape. But the cycle will never end. Im thinking we will know who the children are but i dont know who yet

[@maryharrison6948]

The boy in white looks like he’s from a different period of time than the other children in white. He looks like he is in “clubhouse” clothes or tennis wear, or from the 50’s or 60’s but the other children look to be in ghostly like attire from maybe past centuries.

[@Gamingwithgleez]

Yeah I also thought Julie was in a tesseract like in Interstellar.

[@sceneinvaders]

It does make sense

[@gmlnjenner7709]

I noticed that two of the paintings in the basement that Victors mom painted prior to leaving her home showed both a figure with long bushy hair holding a baby and also one that looks like the same woman eating something out of a bushel basket (like the rotten food). Crazy how much details they put into the Fatima storyline IMO.

[@amandahurst6952]

I'm not sure if someone has mentioned this but all the kids are dressed in white. What if the boy in white was supposed to be sacrificed as well but he got away and has been trying to help the others since it happened? Maybe he was the one that told them a story that he would save them thus giving them hope.

[@TishaA_29_O]

Anyone think maybe Boyd is actually “bad”? First scene of the show-Boyd ringing the bell

[@sceneinvaders]

That would be crazy

[@ChrisM-yq2pq]

In lost, my favorite character became the big bad. I wouldn’t put it past them

[@Cecelovesbirdie]

Rings the bell to wake up monsters 😮