From Tapas to Hard Yoga: The History of the Āsanas of Haṭha Yoga

[@SudhirSingh-ey9lb]

James Mallinson is now a mahant!!!

[@homa.healing]

This was wonderful, thanks for sharing!

[@monkeylala3858]

Begins at 2:39

[@livingsouljourney312]

Thank you for this lecture/video.

[@danieldenardi]

16´44- fala dos efeitos - postura para meditar, treino de taps, prana e beneficios teraputicos.

[@satishnathupadhyay4785]

Great link good apps and I will have an excellent opportunity to join their team of experts in yoga

[@alexanderrogers6862]

Can I join this team of experts too?

[@petercohen3966]

Have you got a link to the journey's of Puran Puri?

[@sethpowell2934]

Here you go Peter, www.khecari.com/resources/Purn-Puri-1792.pdf

[@Ab_someone]

There is no condemnation of Extreme Asceticism in the Bhagavath Geetha infact " yogi yunjeeta satatamaatmaanam rahasi sthitaha | ekaakee yatachittaatmaa niraasheeraparigraha || 10 ||" Well Bhagavath Geetha doesn't deal extensively with Hatha Yoga alone. It is more of a Philosophical synthesis of prevailant Indic thoughts from Vedanta, Samkhya, Tantra and Yoga. The primary discourse in the Geetha basically explores the Samkhyan principles of Guna, The Vedantic Core of Atman and Brahman the supreme godhead and Gunas. Ultimately exploring Dharma, the duty of each individual driven by their natural disposition which is very much what The principles of Yoga does to flow with the Gunas and non identification of the self with which is Chitta Vritti. Chitta Vritti, Vritti which is basically occupation Chitta is always occupied by Guna influences Chitta flows towards objects and their essence of Gunas. To cut this Vritti of Chitta Hatha Yoga is employed and Krishna basically explores Various ways in which it is attained whose final abode is Brahman. Where Geetha does Krishna abhorr extreme Hatha is unknown.

[@sparijat]

What is the purpose of such studies? What enrichment do they provide? What new knowledge, do they provide?

[@Atomic419]

Consciousness studies for one 😉

[@PeterKoperdan]

Understand history to understand the present.

[@zyavanasharmann853]

"James Mallison =>"YOGA" is usually Identified with Complex and Multitude of Physical Postures " --WHO IS COMPETENT TO IDENTIFY ? COMPLETELY "ABSURD" DEFINITION --WHERE FROM MR.MALLISON GETS THIS DEFINITION ?

[@zyavanasharmann853]

DOES MR.MALLISON KNOWS MORE ABOUT "YOGA" --OR --THE LORD-GOD-OF YOGA => 'YOGA ISWARA KRISHNA KNOWS MORE ABOUT "YOGA" " YOGASTHA KURU KARMAANI SANGAM TYAKTH VAA DHANAMJAYA" "SIDDHYO ASIDDHYO SAMO BHOOTH VAA SAMATHVAM YOGA "UCCHYETHAY " LORD -GOD- SRI.KRISHNA VERY PRECISELY DEFINES "THIS IS CALLED YOGA" WHERE HE TALKS ABOUT PHYSICAL PASTURES ?

[@axelmont]

The amount of angry ignorance and entitlement spat in this comment section is incredible. Great lecture.

[@shivamyadav-zt7zy]

its really some way good for yoga i am indian hindu and did lots of asans and yoga and rituals and please all you uk people plz dont do more research on us once u guys have break our trust in past

[@vikrambmw007]

hinduism is digested by west through these angrezz/lefti/opportunist who talks on hinduism with half knowledge......... inspite west people should contact directly to 4 shankaracharya math, gorakhnath math, other math

[@小龙的梦]

Left lmao

[@lazaru1]

anonacc no she didn’t. He is renowned sanksrit and Hinduism scholar

[@lazaru1]

Idiot. Nath sampradaya is leftist pluralistic panth. Tantric panth, not your Vedic fire worship imported rubbish. Keep your hindutva nonsense to yourself

[@lazaru1]

@bv tv hahahahaha. Moron. Adityanath is nothing more than a political right wing plant. His sect is irrelevant and he is generally regarded as an embarrassment within the sampradaya. As for your other claims, well that’s just your opinion

[@lazaru1]

@bv tv no they’re really not. Are you an initiated Nath yogi by any chance?

[@raguks]

Thank you. However some of the things below are controversial and not accurate. Some claims are far fetched. Tapas is "heating power of self denial" "Karma became key tenent of orthodax brahminism." "part of the tradition that later came to be known as Hinduism." These come from a complete misunderstanding and arrogance that Indian tradition can be studied like a lab animal. Yogis do stuff "to capitalize popularity of yoga..." not much different from what the speaker is doing. Also a lack of appreciation for anything being studied is a bit dissapointing. Indian tradition has the element of gaurava/shradda/aastaa. The lack of any mention of people who you learnt things about yoga tradition from - credit etc is also disappointing. Thank you for the lecture.

[@EduardoRiter]

Ragu Kattinakere I have not come here to defend the lecturer, but to inform you that he is a well respected western baba amongst babas. He has been ordened a mahant by fellow babas. But I agree that he should have been introduced, or introduce himself, as to his Lineage, there is a documentary by BBC where they Join him on the MahaKumbh.

[@raguks]

And I informed everyone about some of the things that are not accurate in what he said (to put it mildly). I appreciate the entire effort. However, these things should be reviewed by traditional scholars before being presented as facts. Thank you.

[@EduardoRiter]

OK, I comprehend. He is anexo actual scholar, and by anthropologic standards he is quite in a good line.

[@raguks]

One should not use "anthropologic standards" for religions just as anthropologists do not go about giving lectures on Christianity. When I say traditional scholars, they should be living that tradition. For example, "tapas" is related to Indian darsana (philosophy). As an Indian belonging to the tradition, myself and a lot others will not consider these explanations authentic. There is a rigorous etymology used by Indian traditions to determine correct meaning. Traditional scholars of India are trained in them. Hope this helps. I remain respectful of these efforts to give more information.

[@EduardoRiter]

Ragu Kattinakere OK. But again I tell you he is an initiate, an adept, don't remember If he is Juna Akhara or a Ramanandi. Baba Rampuri also does a very valuable work, in my opinion a much more profound one. Also many western Naths also do a very good effort to document their yogic traditions.

[@shivamyadav-zt7zy]

and mr.newly mahant how could you take reference from upnishad u cant even read or translate that in actual meaning and many of ur information is wrong i am changeling you for this i think you didnt take acctual energy with use of yoga

[@Ab_someone]

Wtf lol

[@lazaru1]

Jealous because he knows more than you ever will. I can’t imagine you’re fluent in Sanskrit

[@satyamsaurabh8060]

@@lazaru1 Har cmnt mein jaake haag kyun raha hai 🤣🤣🤣

[@lazaru1]

@@satyamsaurabh8060 too afraid to type your reply in English eh? Coward

[@satyamsaurabh8060]

@@lazaru1 TmkB

[@dgvirgo]

this is exactly why we must be careful of westerners and concept of Poorva Paksha

Utter bullshit he's talking about. Tapasya is not a bit what he said about or very surface things. "Cat doing Tapasya" do you even know what you are talking about boss? Don't talk bullshit. I know you are influenced by islamic studies and that too in Britain( the land of white civilized ignorant bitches and bastards) so fuk you in advance if you ever open your mouth again about Sanatan Dharma.

[@shivamyadav-zt7zy]

and whoever is after money betraying hus guru he definitely go to hell un your worlds

[@sparijat]

“Proper” Pramhamsas take wows of forceful silence by tiring their mouth up!!??? Where he got that definition from 😂😂🤣🤣 Man! They never learn!! 🤣🤣😂😂 Not capable of real learning!! It is like English jumbled up their nuts and bolts of though and intellectual capability 😂 How is he increasing our knowledge or enriching our lives by such studies??? If not for a wine party for so called “intellectuals”, for some “intellectual” laughs to show their wisdom and enlightenment 😂😂🤣🤣

[@davesmith2675]

What a load of bollocks

[@souravmandal7264]

Islm and yoga what the f***🤣🤣🤣