FULL TESTIMONY: Melani Pawlowski, Lori Vallow's niece, testifies in Chad Daybell trial

#eastidahonews #daybell #truecrime
Melani Pawlowski, Lori Vallow's niece, testifies in Chad Daybell's murder trial. Here is her complete testimony from May 6, 2024.
Watch in the video player above.
► Support East Idaho News: www.eastidahonews.com/donate/
► Subscribe to East Idaho News: kzbin.info...
► Get East Idaho News merch: www.eastidahonews.com/shop/
► Download our free app: marketplace-redirect.doapps.co...
► Like us on Facebook: / eastidahonews
► Follow us on X: / eastidnews
► Follow us on Instagram: / eastidahonews
► Subscribe to our free newsletter: www.eastidahonews.com/newslet...

[@justsamantha1833]

This woman should be in Jail ✅😞

[@Anna-loves-you]

Absolutely, she was part of it all, put the hit out on Brandon. Was fine with her children being dark, the WHOLE goddamn crazy shebang. She tried to get her children when Brandon took them away for their safety, Alex the hitman was with her when she got arrested for that. Ffing scary. She makes me sick.

[@Lifewithpersians]

@@belindabrubaker4167I think his testimony must have saved her. Maybe a deal?

[@anwilcox31]

@@Lifewithpersians I thought that when we got told she was going to testify for Lori’s trial, yes they didn’t use her and they sent her home. But listening to the absolute non important drivel from her I wonder what deal was to be made with her. Her testimony makes her sound like she knows nothing! I mean yeah she still could have had a deal and she didn’t keep up her end of the bargain and we could hear her having charges in the future. But this testimony to me, just sounds like the same stuff we’ve heard from others. We’ve talked about Charles death and Boyce let that testimony in so why didn’t Lindsey hit her with Brandon!? God this is so frustrating!!

[@prettiladi8811]

I agree 1000%!!!!

[@KimberlyAnnBlancaflor]

I agree she should be in jail.101%

[@michaels7258]

This woman is just as much a part of this as Lori and Chad.

[@deena7155]

She wanted Tylees place. It is sick.

[@Terrye5588]

SHE TOO IS NUTZ!!

[@marshapieroni6677]

Almost. No doubt in my mind she would have done away with her kids if any money were involved

[@Anna-loves-you]

What a creep. She needs to be charged.🤮🤮🤮

[@annhenry3135]

The most important thing Melani said was that when they went to Hawaii in the middle of October, 2019, Alex couldn’t go because Chad had something for him to do. That thing was help kill Tammy!!

[@smalltowngirlbigcityheart3724]

👏👏👏

[@4MAGA]

Charles tried very hard to stop this murderous binge and for that he was killed.

[@user_angelmum]

If the police took him seriously when he called them . He ,JJ and Tylee would still be alive . But the fell for Lori's miss innocent act .

[@sandraguthrie276]

Lori and Alex set that up. I wonder if they involved Tylee. I hope not.

[@mightymouse1005]

​@@user_angelmumThe police should be held accountable.

[@donnamoss7480]

The whole point was Lori wanted him whacked She thought the million dollar policy still listed her as beneficiary She had came back to him just to set that up

[@swaneespeedramsey6080]

Charles was lured back for one reason. Lori wanted his insurance money after she had him murdered.

[@user-tx9eh4hb8m]

Who are these lunatics believing they are perfect, going around judging people as dark...and killing them..UN REAL

[@mightymouse1005]

They are the true dark ones (evil) The people they killed appear to be the light (good) people......

[@jonibrooks7731]

I think she’s a liar. IMO she knows waaaay more than she lets on, she was in it up to her neck

[@lorikennedy1127]

Her long turkey neck

[@jackie5522]

I believe this or that. I’m not sure. She’s trying to be like she wasn’t sure about anything. BALONEY

[@marshapieroni6677]

Yes, this little creature had some creepy phone calls with "Dad and mom"

[@jonibrooks7731]

@@marshapieroni6677 where do I find these? I don’t remember hearing any with her parents.

[@lomoliving5528]

@@jonibrooks7731mom and dad is what she started to call Lori and Chad. I think they play those tapes during Ian Polowski testimony

[@L0ve4music4life]

This weirdo belongs in prison.

[@abigail1994]

This woman is deeply disturbed. Calling chad "dad?!" Yikes x 1000. She would have allowed chad and lori to take her kids out too. She would have done anything they wanted.

[@natewilson111]

Like "father", like "daughter"?? 🤷

[@joannamccaffrey2992]

There's a video bodycam of her and police trying to take kids along with the Alex goon....she's a rough cow and as manipulative as lori

[@marshapieroni6677]

I don't think they would have bothered with her kids if there was no money involved. But she probably would have. Especially if they life insurance. No doubt she wanted her ex dead for money

[@madeathinks7578]

@@marshapieroni6677She believed her 2nd and 3rd children were dark. Thank the Lord she didn’t get her hands on them.

[@marshapieroni6677]

@@madeathinks7578 yes, Brandon was proactive

[@4MAGA]

Cults and stupidity are not an excuse, many of these criminals, including her belong in prison. None of this ever should have happened.

[@January.]

Always in the name of religion.

[@rubytuesday1316]

Absolutely! As Ian's testimony reflects with J.Prior towrds the end. mormonismIS the foundation and not far off of Chads teachings.

[@TheLampini]

​@@January.Manipulate your religion so it's ok to kill the "other folks". Indistinguishable from extreme Islam. 🤷‍♀️

[@natewilson111]

​@@rubytuesday1316 There's a reason all these creepy "branch cults" form from Mormonism. It's a breeding ground for zany "theology"!

[@zombiejerry3105]

Or politics ​@@January.

[@angiedues8813]

Why isn’t this woman in jail?

[@zvsmith2008]

Bc they can’t connect the crime of them discussing it, Like a recording, They need verifiable proof and they don’t .. so she free 👍🏾👍🏾

[@wkjeom]

​@@zvsmith2008 Ian better watch his back.

[@britth5333]

I think she would show up in Jonestown have drank the juice and given it to her kids first too. She shouldn’t be allowed to be around her kids.

[@trina7274]

Agreed. I think her exhusband saved he and his kids lives. Who’s to say that Lori wouldn’t tell her to do something horrible from prison 🤷🏻‍♀️ This woman is a loose cannon…

[@cassandra2685]

💯

[@marshapieroni6677]

Yoy are damned correct.

[@amazinlynn3358]

"I don't remember being part of a group called the 7 gatherers" Lie detector determined..that was a lie 😂

[@nettie3485]

Liars and murders, all of them. Both Melanie's and their creepy spouses need to be identified as co-conspirators in all of these crimes.

[@MtlGirl]

How did she not question all the people dying around them.. Charles.. Tammy.. The disappearances of her two kid cousins all people she knew were labeled dark.. C'mon..its hard to believe she was innocently and blindly following Lori's guidance.

[@ravenrozeb3790]

This woman is just as creepy as Chad and I feel for her naive husband. She should have been charged along with Lori. These people are nuts but more than that, they are extremely dangerous. All the poor victims of these psychopaths!! I hope Lori Vallow is pulling "light and dark" BS in the pokey. Her "cellies" will enlighten her real quick that she is gonna be the dark one on the cell floor!! Chad deserves the DP but so did Lori V. Real justice was not served because Lori got to live after facilitating the murder of her own children!

[@Grammichal]

@@Kathydawn25​​⁠ Yesterday I re-watched the police bodycam of Melaniece trying to pick up their 4 children at Brandon’s home. The officers finally gave her a citation for trespass because she wasn’t supposed to be on his lawn. She whined, she pleaded, she begged, she repeated herself, she waved her irrelevant papers, she tried to power up but the cops even yelled at her! Guess who was her chauffeur. Alex of course!

[@jackie5522]

That was scary

[@caribartlett6188]

This girl’s smugness🙄

[@Spikeswift]

Finally we hear from Lori's niece. I wonder why she was never called for Lori's hearing. Also wonder how much she knew about Brendan's attempted murder.

[@4MAGA]

Hearing most of this and reading before hand I truly believe this woman knew! These freaks are so very dangerous

[@Reborn_Enthusist]

She was probably afraid to so they let it slide 😨

[@merricat3025]

She was but she violated the rule not to talk and listen to any testimony so she couldn't testify.

[@Anna-loves-you]

She was, but she watched testimony she wasn't supposed to so they didn't put her on the stand.

[@tiredofitall9213]

She was but she admitted to either watching, listening, or talking to others about Lori's trial. She was on the stand but right after she was asked if she viewed, listened to, or talked to someone about the trial she was dismissed as a witness.

[@Human4Peace]

Why has she not been investigated ? Her phone and digital devices should be checked. Nothing is ever deleted and everything can be recovered.

[@kathysharpe7339]

Can we cast her out?. Im feeling attacked.

[@Grammichal]

Good one! ​​⁠​​⁠ Yesterday I re-watched the police bodycam of Melaniece trying to pick up their 4 children at Brandon’s home. The officers finally gave her a citation for trespass because she wasn’t supposed to be on his lawn. She whined, she pleaded, she begged, she repeated herself, she waved her irrelevant papers, she tried to power up but the cops even yelled at her! Guess who was her chauffeur. Alex of course!

[@justsayin5865]

She wants us to believe she went to Hawaii with her aunt. Knowing her 7yr old autistic cousin who's dog her aunt sold wouldn't contact his mom once. Never saw her aunt on video or phone with him. This was normal. Yeah right Yet Melanie acts like she was dieing to have her kids but her aunt who's autistic child not around doesn't make her question her aunt. PLEASE

[@kimberry9632]

Not In Defense of her, but Lori didn't sell JJ's dog, she gave it back to the foundation who gave JJ the dog. The dog went on to help another child.

[@bamccabe1]

Was made to give the dog back after first trying to sell it.​@@kimberry9632

[@saclohecy]

I believe they took the dog back once they were alerted that she was trying to sell him

[@timothyfreeseha4056]

Melanie is carefully answering. I'm afraid my sympathy is for John Prior in trying to get a complete and honest answer from some of these witnesses, especially the Melanie's . The Prosecution is doing an awesome job!

[@user-li8nn4mo5n]

She knew what was going on

[@flyoverurbangarden4315]

I wonder if she was given immunity, she seems sketchy.

[@user_angelmum]

Both melonies and Zulema were given immunity.

[@kimstout6419]

@flyoverurbangarden4315 I heard at one point that she was given immunity but have never heard it verified. Can anyone help us here'?

[@justsayin5865]

Listening to her old interviews she lied so much. She said she didn't know what her aunts teaching were. Everything was just "Speculation and Rumor." Liar lLiar Pants On Fire.🔥🔥🔥

[@Grammichal]

⁠​​⁠ Yesterday I re-watched the police body cam of Melaniece trying to pick up their 4 children at Brandon’s home. The officers finally gave her a citation for trespass because she wasn’t supposed to be on his lawn. She whined, she pleaded, she begged, she repeated herself, she waved her irrelevant papers, she tried to power up but the cops even yelled at her! Guess who has her chauffeur. Alex of course!

[@asamatteroffact9247]

Something about her aura gives me the creeps! She is alive but looks dead.

[@natewilson111]

Hmm...maybe you've absorbed bits of Lori's zany theology? (I hope you don't start telling people they've become "zombies" 😳)

[@nohalfstep4435]

The "I'm not sure" and "I believe" responses are getting on my nerves.

[@elless4817]

Why was melanie not questioned about the phone call Ian testified about? Mel knows way more than she said and got by playing the dumb ditsy girl again 😡

[@gracecass9402]

In one of the clips, you briefly hear her say that she withdrew $50k cash, so Ian's ex-wife didn't know how much money they REALLY had. She did that because he had a child support hearing approaching & they didn't want the courts, Ian's ex, or his kids to have additional funds. With that being said, that's 10000% illegal to do! If the state questioned her about the recordings, that wouldn't benefit the state because the defense could ask her about it. It then all boils down to whether she's a credible witness for the state because the defense can prove without a doubt that she lies, leaving it open for the jury to question whether or not she lied about anything regarding the cash.

[@Grammichal]

@@gracecass9402 Yesterday I re-watched the police bodycam of Melaniece trying to pick up their 4 children at Brandon’s home. The officers finally gave her a citation for trespass because she wasn’t supposed to be on his lawn. She whined, she pleaded, she begged, she repeated herself, she waved her irrelevant papers, she tried to power up but the cops even yelled at her! Guess who was her chauffeur. Alex of course!

[@joyleenpoortier7496]

I can’t stand chads smirk on his face

[@jsbach9848]

Yes! And that sitting with folded hands and watching the witness to intently. Creep!!!

[@kviz1111]

Yeah he is creepy

[@robinlane62]

I know Pryor is doing his job, but there is something about the way he communicates that just gets under my skin.

[@stephendove2850]

I’m jealous she gets to experience this in 3D, I put on my 3D glasses but they don’t seem to be working.

[@katiedid6119]

😂😂😂

[@rubytuesday1316]

"You're killin me Smalls" ! lmao

[@madelineriley-jn9uq]

Lmao!!

[@madelineriley-jn9uq]

Sure not rose collared glasses 🤓

[@Cocoandindy]

😅😅😅

[@kymmyhix4842]

Every testimony I have watched Chad never kooks at the person testifying, this time he is basically staring at melanie

[@SilentThundersnow]

Trying to intimidate her , and succeeding imo.

[@grammy3g808.]

There needs to be accountability of those that knew what Chad was doing, all those that participated in these castings knew those deemed dark lost their lives and they did nothing to stop it.there needs to be something done about it.

[@marshapieroni6677]

All those who knew should be investigated for sure

[@safeenakunni9278]

Wow this one is trying to save her auntie she is full of bs she knows more then she says she was involved with them

[@kimstout6419]

Her auntie has already been convicted of these crimes. This is Chad's trial. Nevertheless, I feel she's speaking partial truths.

[@Grammichal]

@@kimstout6419Maybe she’s still trying to whitewash Lori’s reputation. Yesterday I re-watched the police bodycam of Melaniece trying to pick up their 4 children at Brandon’s home. The officers finally gave her a citation for trespass because she wasn’t supposed to be on his lawn. She whined, she pleaded, she begged, she repeated herself, she waved her irrelevant papers, she tried to power up but the cops even yelled at her! Guess who was her chauffeur. Alex of course!

[@rushoke]

This group was just one step away from saying Chad was the second coming of Christ.

[@saracooper7904]

I thought Elton John entered the court room?

[@lorischellenberg3219]

👍🏼😄

[@cynthiawilson5066]

Melanie is Guilty

[@nsxpetes]

Couple of her kids were dark. She was cool with it. Wished harm on them.

[@laurenecarter246]

Those text messages will hopefully come out in Lori Vallow v. Brandon Boudreaux case in Arizona 🤞

[@user-tx9eh4hb8m]

Exactly!!

[@ValeskaTruax]

She even suggested getting life insurance on Tylee and JJ.

[@user-tx9eh4hb8m]

@@ValeskaTruax I didn't know that..

[@kiaracummings8457]

😢

[@brandybiscoff9685]

I thought the cross examination was way too easy on Melanie. I expected more from it

[@billyje4726]

Thats because Prior knows from Chad, that Melani is still protecting him. She doesnt tell everything she knows and Chad and Prior know this. The way they exchange glances, especially when they wait for cross... He even smiles at her!! 👈👈

[@natewilson111]

She's not on trial......yet

[@georgiajasper3893]

She has great knowledge so Pryor needed to be careful..

[@SilentThundersnow]

Are you aware your cousins and your 2 uncles are dead? Do you even feel bad about it at all??? Why don't you look like you understand that their LIVES WERE STOLEN from them, and you were part of the game!!! Why aren't you barely able to talk because of The remorse you feel??? You're a soulless pod!!! Did you ever fear that YOU were proclaimed dark by Chad? Or were you just too damn special to be murdered??

[@lori3967]

No, no ma'am NONE of this makes sense. Do they hear this silly crap coming out of their mouths!!!

[@kviz1111]

That's what I'm saying kids are missing how about trying some logical things it's baffling

[@hhouse2642]

Show is a liar! My opinion is that justice be served and to me it will not be until ALL OF THE PARTIES INVOLVED ARE IN PRISON! I hate that they the Melanie’s, , Zulema, the husbands were given IMMUNITY!!! They are ALL IN THIS UP TO THEIR EYEBROWS!!!!

[@cheyanndoyle1688]

She hopefully gets to be in court in Arizona for Brandon.

[@poi4ever121]

She's lucky we're enlightened and don't burn people alive for their beliefs anymore.

[@LittleOrla]

Whoa, Melanie's not talking baby talk now. 😮

[@bamccabe1]

Lost her fundy baby voice? Should have gone to Katie Britt for a refresher course.

[@debbiebrog8598]

Why did she not report thr children missing? Apparently she knew the truth. She is totally evil.

[@VivianSoto-nc2qi]

Why the Heck does this murderer get a Lap Top???

[@brichi5407]

I think Melanie was one of the accomplices she was tight knit to chad and Lori she knows absolutely everything that went on she should be in prison herself!

[@sharonkriskovich5911]

You bet she was she knows about all of it she is as guilty as her crazy aunt she was involved in all of it trying to kill her x and all of it she's not in jail because she was given amenity also along with zuela and gibb all this one does is lie she remb. Everything

[@kimjorg]

For someone that quite possibly knows just as much as Chad and Lori she sure does like to play dumb doesn’t she? She should be on trial too and then in prison.

[@michelero4297]

Prior testifies so much I'm expecting him to call himself to the stand any day now.

[@SilentThundersnow]

What a freak. She should be weeping about what she had been involved in, and how close she came to losing her children! She has no idea how crazy she is. She shouldn't be walking around in society if she can be influenced that easily to kill people. She is as dangerous as Lori. I hope she doesn't have access to her children, who Chad claimed were dark. She still acts like she's intimidated by Chad.

[@wap9137]

Melani is lucky she found a man who is able to think critically, something that is foreign to this crazy group.

[@billyje4726]

It all sounds very rehearsed!! She knows so much more!!! And what about Brandon?? And what about those ridiculous glasses? 🙈🙈 Weird vibes! Did anybody notice the glances Chad and Melani exchanged when they waited for cross and Chad sitting up in his chair to catch her attention and smiling at her.. Plus he made this hand movement... 👈👈🤔🤔

[@jillwhite4398]

This whole attempt on Pryors part to pin everything on Melanie Gibb and the "Seven Sisters"(WTF!!!) is patently ridiculous. No matter how unlikable Gibb might be, what motive, what shred of evidence is there to point the finger at her and David???

[@louesparza8003]

Absolutely!

[@MimiPierreBuddy]

This woman is dangerous.

[@nrussell7625]

26:46 very interesting. Listen to the audio of Alex Cs first wife to police re their relationship 😬

[@Grammichal]

I listened to the entire recorded conversation for the second time. It’s even more illuminating a couple of years down the pike.​​⁠ Yesterday I re-watched the police bodycam of Melaniece trying to pick up their 4 children at Brandon’s home. The officers finally gave her a citation for trespass because she wasn’t supposed to be on his lawn. She whined, she pleaded, she begged, she repeated herself, she waved her irrelevant papers, she tried to power up but the cops even yelled at her! Guess who was her chauffeur. Alex of course! She kept alleging to LE that she was trying to keep her children safe because “Brandon was into drugs and even got shot at recently.” Yeah! They shoot him and then try to make it look like he’s a dangerous person. Brandon is a hero!

[@nostoppingit7243]

Well we know Chad didn't have that gift because he clearly didn't see the evil darkness in Lori or when looking in the mirrror.

[@kviz1111]

It's ridiculous but it was his way of manipulation

[@fabshelleyg6214]

Did this girl have a dad? Why is she calling Chad dad?

[@rubytuesday1316]

Its Loris niece from Lori's dead sister Stacy (Hmmm) smh

[@finallylearnthow]

Yes her father raised her. I believe Lorry Shallow and her Dumbbell Husband informed Meliniece that they were her parents in a previous life. I found it creepy when she said what name she called the accused!

[@lorikennedy1127]

Yes she had a father that was smart enough to block the entire Cox family as she grew up. Sadly once your kids are 18 you can't control who they speak to. She sought out Lori, Alex etc. They lead her down this crazy road of cult religion. She seems like another weak minded religious zeolite. She one of only 4 people who knew where Brandon was living so she told Alex to kill Brandon for insurance money plus she still had his credit cards long after being divorced. No telling how much debt she pit on them. Seeing her in the video getting arrested in front of hercin laws was great. She is so damn dumb.

[@nsxpetes]

Convenient forgets some things

[@nickinurse6433]

It is so obvious that both Melanie's were completely aware of what was going on and that people were being killed based on Chad's designations. This is like the Manson family. Where Manson didn't actually kill anyone but got his followers to do it. However in the Manson case all the little followers went to jail. Somehow in this case probably because the state is exhausted with these two trials the other little co-conspirators are completely getting away with it.

[@persus5756]

She took up with the Wendy Adelson disguise outfit you know just wear something and then they won't recognize you.

[@SundaysChild7]

Being one of their own, there was no love or fire to find out the truth.

[@emmrivera8857]

Chad's trying to intimidate Melanie by writing and typing furiously while she testifies. Like he's issuing directives to his minions to get Melanie after school. It's having an effect on her - I can hear her voice changing.

[@nsxpetes]

So many people could have said something. At multiple points. It wasn’t just the kids. It was Charles. Tammy. Brandon. I hope she was excommunicated.

[@4MAGA]

Charles? He notified LE and was ignored, he also notified family and was thanked by being murdered.

[@ruthdianneschoch5583]

Not enough. Melani deserves prison

[@rubytuesday1316]

lmao - Excommunicated? Too many people are leaving LD$ ! Here in ID/UT I know swingers, dealers, abusers, addicts, & con artists NObody excommunicated until (or even if ) they go to jail. Thousands a year are having their name & LD$ number removed! Even before all this!

[@krabbesign]

She refers Lori and Chad as mom and dad but not Tylee and JJ as brother and sister

[@Mierla406]

Why isn’t she in jail?

[@reneearnett8761]

I’m sorry but I just feel that the niece is on purpose not telling much about Chad… I mean she did call him dad! She only remembers things about lori….. ironic

[@bamccabe1]

And if she had testified at Lori's trial she wouldn't have remembered the things that incriminated Lori.

[@georgiajasper3893]

Why is she calling her aunt Lori now?? What happened to mommy??

[@Grammichal]

I think she’s only admitting as much as she has to. She’s on the prosecution side of trying to put it all on Chad whereas the defense is trying to paint Lori as the mastermind.

[@Gracie-vq2nj]

SHE SHOULD BE LOCKED 🔒 UP

[@simonegarciatsu2854]

Her poor kids. One day they will know that they were called “dark zombies” and were next on the list to be put to death & their own mother was compliant!!!!! I hope Brandon Boudreaux is the main influence in their kids lives. He should get full custody !!!! She does not deserve her children’s love 😡

[@esthermoffitt1430]

She seems so dimwitted I can’t see how she followed so easily

[@bobbicatt]

There is no way Chad and Lori would have went after Brandon without Melanie’s blessing. He had a large life insurance policy and only Melanie would have been able to give his location. I also think there’s a good possibility that Melanie was driving the jeep. Mel P really needs to get charged with something. She was in way deep.

[@constancemcguire5870]

Hey Pryor, you starring creepily at the jury while you are asking witnesses questions; how'd that work out for you?⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️⚖️

[@lori7008]

Is anyone gonna hold her acconntable for possible attempt on Brandon? Maybe Brandon will!

[@jackie5522]

There was no (passed away) they were MURDERED!

[@tharrison0043]

The only way Chad would know about the tracking device put on Melani's car was if he did it himself, and blamed it on her ex-husband.

[@constancemcguire5870]

Pryor is so annoying when he is talking to the witness but turns his body to the jury as if he is asking them a question. Very creepy. I know it is appropriate for the witness to look at the jury when answering a question but Pryor always looks at the jury like he is asking them the question. He barely looks at the witness at all. And sometimes he will stare at the prosecutor's table while speaking with the witness.

[@KSarah369]

As Karma would have it, sooner or later, legal or not, she will be made accountable for her complicity

[@nettie3485]

Prior is funny! He is trying to testify for the witness. 😂 The second coming of Jesus isn't going to need the assistance of the likes of Chad and Lori!

[@lori7008]

Was she wearing sunglasses?

[@Draposo1970]

Why isn’t she being charged

[@Jennifer-ul2vz]

What's with the glasses?

[@karenmegert5872]

Oh Prior is onto the 7 gathers. Chad Lori Alex Zuemma Melanie David Melanie p.....himmmmmmmmm

[@corinnehernandez4549]

After all that has happened is she allowed custody or visitation of the children she had with first husband? It's to bad she had children with her 2nd husband. In my opinion the two Melanie's belong in prison. Being they are not prison they shouldn't be allowed anywhere near children. After all that's happened she doesn't show any emotion for the murders of Tylee and JJ. I think she's the dark zombie

[@Se-leve]

She’s not credible. First of all the interview of Lori and tylee after the fiasco with Charles when he came to Arizona to see JJ, Tylee discussed Tylee getting her GED. And possibly becoming a police officer. This isn’t indicative of a successful person getting into BYU. It was all made up. So for Melanie to believe two months later she was accepted into BYU is ridiculous.

[@mydogky]

omg shows she was involved in this, she knows way more.

[@dustycrum]

Finally !

[@jeanettecoleman-mz7ie]

Innocence taken out by 😈 DEMONS

[@patriciafoster3347]

Lindsey eluded, during interview with Nate, to more charges for more people in the works.

[@flower_goddess1279]

How come she is freely roaming ?

[@nostoppingit7243]

She contradicted herself. She first said Chad personally shared things with her and then said that Lori told her Chad talked about the topics.

[@Jameo-ct2xy]

I believe that she was always jealous of Tylee being Lori's daughter and she knew everything that was going on . I hope to see one soon that her and her mom Lori are reunited in prison . She is the one the stood to profit in the event of Brandon's death .

[@mandystinson4925]

Crazy as a box of frogs the whole lot of em but that craziness had very real tragic outcomes,

[@hyperdog67]

I do not like this woman. How she hasn't been brought up on charges is a mystery to me? And that Ian.. wow! Are men that desperate out there that they'd get with a creature like this woman? How he doesn't see what she is is another mystery to me?

[@marycollingwood2320]

This woman is a despicable and disgusting excuse for a mother. Her children are not safe in her custody. I hope she is held to account for her role in this whole situation.

[@hollybigelow5337]

As a member of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints, it amazes me how many of these extremely unfamiliar topics to me seem to Melani to be from her "LDS" (a term members of the church have been encouraged not to use to because it de-emphasizes the importance of Christ) beliefs. In fact, some of the beliefs she testified are consistent with her beliefs from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints directly contradict the official teachings of the church. It doesn't surprise me at all. I often hear members of the church claim the church teaches things that are actually in direct contradiction to the actual teachings of the church as well as claiming the church teaches a bunch of things that it doesn't even really explain. Yes, some of these things may superficially seem to be similar to actual teachings of the church, but it sounds like someone who instead of reading the scriptures and studying the doctrines themselves have instead been relying on others to tell them what the scriptures say, and the message got mangled like it would in a game of telephone. It reminds me, for example, of that Modern Family episode where Luke is making fun of Manny's mother because she used to dig for coal, and it turned out he really heard his mother say she thought Manny's mother was a gold digger. To those in the know, it is easy to see how the message got mangled. It also technically at least from an auditory perspective extremely close to what was said. However, in all the ways that matter to the ensuing fight, the actual meaning to the person who misunderstood the statement is nowhere near the original meaning.

[@sandraturner3086]

Who is that in your thumbnail? Squeaky or Sadie.

[@lynx6124]

Is it just me or does the defense attorney's voice get under your skin?

[@user-li8nn4mo5n]

Bs Melanie

[@greeneyedgemini2111]

How many people believe this testimony that is being presented here by Melanie .

[@SundaysChild7]

Especially because he's a fellow officer. They had no love or brotherhood for a fellow fallen officer.

[@YourNextDoorNeighborA]

what is his obsession over the 7 whatever it is? Is he one?

[@suzitee8225]

Omg! Enough already JP, with the Melanie Gibb 😱. As much as she might have known all about it, what would have been her motive???