Fullmetal Edition vs. Original Manga - Fullmetal Alchemist Manga Comparison

[@ToriStory942]

Timestamps to Skip Around: Fullmetal Edition Volume 1 Unboxing: 0:10 Fullmetal Edition Volume 2 Unboxing: 2:12 Comparison between Fullmetal Edition Volume 2 & the original Tankoban Volume 2: 4:30

[@jonnysac77]

I can't help but be a little disappointed, in the JoJo's Bizarre Adventure Jojonium editions there wasn't just a hard cover and new art, it also had extensive character specific interviews that gave genuine insight, this edition is also missing content with the bonus chapters and I think FMA deserved better especially since it's such an important series to the western anime fandom

[@БогданКрименюк]

@Omega Legion *Tequila Guts

[@yayo6216]

I’m gonna get the full metal editions because I just love hard cover and how they all look on a shelf

[@DopenessFORlife]

Extremely informative video on the differences! Thank you for this!

[@yourmom5677]

I love you thank you for this video this is what I wanted to know!! You helped a lot thanks queen

[@andreinacedeno8356]

Thanks for this look through and review, it has helped me to decide to buy them! ❤️

[@floopyfloof2384]

Viz has released a separate volume of the 4 panel comics including some exclusive ones. I theorise that the bonus chapters will be included in the final fullmetal volume or maybe a separate volume like the 4 panel comics

[@SnowWolfAlpha]

You're in good company. I'm gonna hold on to my Singapore English volumes because they have a different translation, slipcovers and are out of print. Wasn't going to get the new Fullmetal Edition, but I can't resist a good hardback, especially for one of my favourite series.

[@nathantallon8742]

I would buy the full metal editions if the 3 in 1s weren't waaaay cheaper. I just can't justify spending 3 times as much for a single volume with my budget.

[@theddbrosgaming8085]

The paper is really thin in the 3 in 1s. Some of mine have torn slightly or started wearing down on the spine. These are significantly higher quality and are actually 1.5 volumes. Don't get me wrong, to each their own, I just felt obligated to express my own experience with the 3 in 1s.

[@tothepanels]

So each of this editions is roughly 1 volume per large book? I noticed edition 12 is set to release on 2/9/2021 so does that mean there’s still 15 more coming?

[@theddbrosgaming8085]

@@tothepanels Each Fullmetal Edition is 1.5 volumes

[@Musicedge88]

Why would you pay for worse paper?

[@vuLKan0320]

It's just a shame that there isn't a full color release of Fullmetal Alchemist

[@cutecharlz2252]

They look amzing but the 3 in 1 deals are so good that its kind ofhard to pick these one over the normal ones

[@theanimelibarian7881]

I love hard cover books

[@gerking195]

Who dosent

[@Bobex649]

Well Didnt expect such a Old video to help me choose if I should I deluxe or not Ty

[@phishndaphrog-1895]

I really want these but they're so expensive

[@hahyhnsw]

on rightstuf they cost 14.99 but in retail they cost 19.99

[@jisnarahmanc4176]

You can read it in ur phone I use manga cat app

[@churchill903]

@@hahyhnsw that's expensive

[@Noah-jo7hy]

@@jisnarahmanc4176 lmao no online manga feels way different and ruins the experience

[@galaxygkm4696]

@@Noah-jo7hy ngl I agree I’d rather pay money for manga than reading online

[@ViewtifulDarnell]

Saw these in Barnes & Noble earlier and I think I'll be picking them up. Never read the manga (watched both anime though and loved/preferred Brotherhood) so I'm looking forward to picking these up. And only 18 volumes over 27 is a lot more appealing.

[@ToriStory942]

Enjoy! You're in for a treat! I've seen/read all three versions and the manga is definitely my favorite!!

[@pannonicawong-birchall5214]

You can also get the 3 in 1 editions, which means collecting 9 instead of 27. They are quite a bargain in money as well :)

[@ViewtifulDarnell]

@@pannonicawong-birchall5214 I don't like the thin paper that Viz uses for the 3-in-1 versions they put out.

[@davidgn40]

@@ViewtifulDarnell agreed. Got 2 FMA 3-in-1's on a whim and kinda regret it, but they are cheap and easy to collect.

[@TheSymbiot3Venom]

Hey great video. can you put both volume spines together and tell me if the spine text line up because idk if i got a messed up misprint but my volume2 is not lined up with volume 1 and its kinda driving me nuts lol.

[@ToriStory942]

Oh wow! I actually didn't look at that too closely. It looks like Volume 1 is just a tad bit higher up than Volume 2... but it's only slightly different so I actually didn't notice until you pointed it out! I put Volume 3 next to it as well, and it's height is actually between Volumes 1 & 2 (Vol 3 is a little lower than Vol 1 but higher than Vol 2). Now I can't unsee that XD

[@TheSymbiot3Venom]

@@ToriStory942 lol sorry about that. well now i know its not just me

[@ToriStory942]

Haha yeah, I am glad you pointed it out! Luckily it's small (no pun intended) enough where it won't bug me too much. It's too bad they weren't fully even though.

[@TheSymbiot3Venom]

@@ToriStory942 yeah it was driving my OCD crazy but im fine with it now that i know its not just me i'll wait for a second printing and see if it gets fixed. I hope me asking wont know drive you crazy lol

[@thehavocmiranda]

How they translate " XERXES " in Fullmetal Edition? In Brazil they translated in the new edition " Cselkcess "

[@ToriStory942]

In the original 27 volume release in the US (and I believe the 3 in 1's as well) they also used the translation "Cselkcess" but in the Fullmetal Edition it was updated to Xerxes! Also noticed that the original translation use "Lin" and "Foo" and the Fullmetal Edition updated them to Ling and Fu.

[@thehavocmiranda]

​@@ToriStory942 It is funny they used "Cselkcess" when there scenes in the manga where Edward and Al were reading books with "xerxes" in cover. Hahahha One last question: How many chapters there are in each edition? Thanks for answear me and thanks the video

[@ToriStory942]

@@thehavocmiranda Haha that is ironic XD The Fullmetal Edition has 6 chapters each volume, so there will be a total of 18 Volumes (compared to the original release which had 4 chapters per book and had a total of 27 Volumes).

[@thecumcrusader1990]

@@ToriStory942 In Brazil, they were Lin, Ranfun and Who, that's strange...

[@nesotheshitposter1475]

My fullmetal editions metallic letters on the cover started to ware off after a week of owning it

[@sabersquid2523]

Yeah same and I’m not sure why... idk how to stop it

[@datderpderping501]

Strange. Had mine for a 1-2 years, y’all not taking care of the stuff?

[@sabersquid2523]

@@datderpderping501 I’m literally so careful with it with my second volume lol. The first volume I’m careful too so I’m legitimately so confused what happened with it. The second volume is in great condition though

[@nesotheshitposter1475]

@@sabersquid2523 same with me, I’m super scared the same thing that happened with my vol 1 will happen 😂

[@sunread2679]

I love this edition, but i think the french version is more beautiful for the book cover :/ (i'm french and i apologize for my bad english ^^')

[@freed6038]

My country has this premium edition too, but the one I own (and it's really not represent all of them, since I only have one lol, volume 14 with Winry!) Doesn't have those gorgeous colored pages :(( it only has one, at the very first character art. After that, when it has colorspread or colored first page of the chapter like this one, it's just the good ol' black and white :(( also we don't have hardcover lol. The paper is a great improvement tho, because at original tankobon we had this really cheap gray recycled paper (in my place we use this paper for newspaper), but in the upgraded version of premium we have the paper that used for novels. I think why we have same concept as Viz's with little, uh, adjustments(?) Is because there are not many people who actually can afford it :( it would be super expensive. This adjusted premium version already cost 3 times over tankobon ones, so I doubt if the publisher made the exact copy they will be sold at all lol I Really attempted to buy those amazing babies, even if the cost (I checked its around 20usd?) Is almost 4 times of my premium version 😂 it's super expensive, and it doesn't include the shipping yet😔 why the currencies must be this high and why am I so broke😭 Anyways thank you for explaining in detail about these amazing mangas, it really really helps me to know Fullmetal Edition better!❤️❤️

[@bepsi9939]

Do they have more than one volume in the hardcovers?

[@thomasryan6240]

I would like to know as well

[@Da-Butchar]

The whole story is in hardcovers. But prepare for 200-400 dollars for the whole set

[@marcelanieto3243]

Mild knitpick, the Fullmetal editions didn't improve the cover art of the original volumes but rather just put changed the covers into a single character

[@tothepanels]

So each of this editions is roughly 1 volume per large book? I noticed edition 12 is set to release on 2/9/2021 so does that mean there’s still 15 more coming?

[@sabersquid2523]

It’s roughly 1.5 volumes each

[@Picfifa11]

Are all of the Volumes out on this special edition?

[@marcelanieto3243]

No, only 11. (12 coming out this month)

[@davidpunk7863]

They are 18 in total and Viz is going to release 12th yet

[@keielric6822]

Cual es la que cuenta la historia de Fullmetal Alchemist Brotherhood

[@leonelgrabuiski949]

Brotherhood es fiel al manga, cualquier versión te sirve

[@JagjitSingh-zg3cq]

Excuse me, but it's actually "ISHVARA" not ISHVALA in pronunciation... Hence the original edition was right...

[@joe-oz5ti]

Can you combine alchemy circle

[@bytheway1031]

🎂Arakawa Hiromu 05-08-2022

[@ayatmomyhi3725]

Prefer ishbal

[@soulhunter9118]

Why the front is opposite to how it should be

[@jojoestar9427]

Because the Japanese read from right to left

[@starstudiosRPG]

OooooHhh