ai.bythebay.io: George Hotz, Self-Driving Lessons from Comma AI

Scale By the Bay 2019 is held on November 13-15 in sunny Oakland, California, on the shores of Lake Merritt: scale.bythebay.io. Join us!
-----

[@0xdr0id29]

George is such a legend!

[@kelvinilla]

- Does bad driving crowdsourced data negatively impact learning? - No. Good drivers are good in the same way; bad drivers are bad in different ways. Learning is predisposed to patterns of good driving. Paraphrased. So awesome.

[@tangomuzi]

Not so awesome. Good drivers get good ny experiencing bad different ways of bad drivers. It is not enogh to be good on a empty road. So, in a well designed ai, bad driving crowdsource should 'positively' impact the learning.

[@sunrisetofu]

This guy is crazy, learns deep learning so damn fast, and such deep understanding of all aspects

[@9oo9x]

Elvin A lmao, this dude was the first person ever to jailbreak an iPhone, at the age of 15. He is a prodigy. Look at his videos of when he’s coding.

[@sinki19841984]

@@xyzxyzuvwuvw7633 name one coder that doesn't google

[@umadbroyo2388]

Elvin A I assume you don’t even know who this is....

[@aquamentum]

@@xyzxyzuvwuvw7633 Lol I assume you've never worked professionally as a developer? Literally everyone does this.

[@kira_io]

@@xyzxyzuvwuvw7633 Thats what all programmers do.....

[@mikemallon9541]

Love this guy. Crazy how much hes been able to accomplish with such a small team!

[@aliticx]

Thank you for uploading. Love listening to this guy!

[@p00pie]

The smartest person to ever wear Yeezys most likely.

[@kpopisthebestful]

771 LMFAO he got the bootcut jeans tho

[@conservativethuglife5150]

Elon Musk

[@UserName-vu9hq]

George Hotz is legend

[@metinyildiz7041]

this might be the longest video I didn't feel lost while listening to George. I guess he is also teaching my brain how to listen to him

[@superkeybi]

Just I have 2 questions, this system working with smart phone cameras, what's append in raining days or cloudy days?

[@MrScorpion749]

I feel dumb listening to a genius like him lol

[@MrCmon113]

You are dumb and that's why you think he's a genius.

[@trace8634]

@@MrCmon113 george hotz is a genius

[@Kloutkulture]

Taxtro He's a genius. The only human ever to hack the iPhone....at 17

[@ryanevancoe5797]

@@MrCmon113 youre a delusional arrogant ass, and thats why you think he's not a genius

[@lx4302]

Just be honest and set realistic expectations of yourself. Clearly you think you are something smart but have too much of an expectation that you end up comparing yourself. We all have to be humble at some point and be inspired by others instead of acting our lives as if we live in a competition.

[@sippy_cups]

This video is amazing!

[@jonasmister]

18:21 i didnt fully understand so i tried captions and it says: "it's a hand engineer creatures pants" I ll make sure to include those in my ai self driving project

[@MasterNeiXD]

When was this recorded?

[@theodopoulos]

Great talk

[@busterdafydd3096]

planning problem, why not make AI plot in the localization space where it should be at what time and what condition the car should be in meaning which what should the car be facing what speed it should travelling at.

[@CardinalHijack]

He says things that he has no idea about with such certainty. This is something I struggle with.

[@XxMrBryanxX]

He wasnt kidding at the end

[@adisharr]

How long before it can handle real life road tests such as construction zones, lane shifts, bad visibility, unpredictable drivers, etc..?

[@MrCmon113]

Only infinite days.

[@sheeiiittt2012]

it's good with bad visibility and construction zones right now

[@chrisrosenkreuz23]

hey this isn't some plan, this is already released for cheap comma.ai/

[@Pablo-oi5rt]

What about mirrors? How will that see behind it?

[@ARV1999]

Pablo cameras most likely. They will be cameras all over the vehicle acting as a sort of sensor

[@jody5661]

I have seem wheels fall off of trucks going 75 on the highway, it happens.

[@Wardoon]

40:01 "The real goal of Comma ai is to end all jobs"

[@ismaelgrahms]

👌🏾👌🏾

[@billybbob18]

Like all raw forms of intelligence, the machine must be taught. We need human observers (at least for a while) to analyze different failure modes to decide the optimal failure mitigation for that particular situation. The machine would need to learn how to make blind assumptions (Not quite blind) about situations that it deems as "similar to" a learned mitigation (or combination of other techniques if a "combined failure forecast" occurs). The machine would then be able to make decisions in real time based on previous situations with the ability to apply a mitigation rating for each event. Software updates could be done in real time. The rate of auto accidents would drop significantly. Allow a mode to disable the autopilot to allow for manual control. Make a law that requires a "continuous driver seat occupancy requirement" and the transit employees won't get shafted a much. That's my take on the whole thing.

[@ExperienceCN]

The second guy who asks an question was so typical German 😂😂😂

[@ChaseOGLP]

I love George, especially programming videos- 100th comment 😃

[@davidwilkie9551]

Left side of the road driving to right, habitual thinking is difficult to switch until it is practised, and so is switching from solid state physical manifestation in Time to temporal superposition of substantiation. Eg the gyroscopic stability of rotational motion is perceived as a type of inertia, directional momentum holding you upright when riding a push bike, because it's an example of Conduction in an aligned phase of condensation orthogonal-normal to the unity of surrounding solid matter. (Just fun to imagine merging probability wave-package convergences, don't know if it fits with driving programs) You can guess what Gravity is. Reality Hack.

[@MrPacMan36]

Why so few views....?

[@borin2882]

Someone noticed 18:01 last link the https was missing ''s''?

[@xMrRasec]

this guy looks like he is on a 5 streak of black coffe with mdma constantly. but seriously, what a mastermind

[@VinceIsDatBitch]

6:45 Sciencephile AI ayy

[@AWESEM0]

Surprised to hear George use the word impossible...

[@AWESEM0]

Thought Google jumped off this ship

[@orlandorizzo5780]

george has to many Yes guys in his circle.

[@pasiman7717]

haha hes wearing yeezy's what a g

[@gvalb]

How is he so smart omg

[@emmalante9430]

Maybe because he spends his time actually learning instead of laying in the sofa watching TV all day like 90% of all humans?

[@elmehdinaor763]

Simon Chase Lool Einstein is a Genius?? The fuck are you Talking about ?? Nikola Tesla is a Genius or Henry Poincare is a Genius. Einstein was good in stealing ideas.

[@chrisrosenkreuz23]

@Simon Chase yup Einstein stole most of his thesis from Henri Poincare and some ideas from his own wife. And he wasn't actually smart to begin with, if you hold him in high regard you should look into historical context. I don't blame you because it's easy to confuse academic prestige with actual value. Well, to be honest it really isn't, since the former is void of the latter but I digress. If you can name just ONE original invention or discovery that guy has put forth I will eat my hat. Spoiler alert: you couldn't and again I won't blame you, it's his fault. On the other hand, George Hotz has already given the world something pretty valuable if I may say so myself. However, I do believe your point stands: some folks are indeed smarter than others and more work or time spent won't change that

[@TrailTribune]

It is a logical fallacy to draw safety conclusions from autopilot disengagement data. Just because autopilot disengages more frequently than a human crashes does not imply that current self driving systems are less safe. Statistically autopilot 2 is safer than a human WHEN ENGAGED. It's the subset of drive conditions that we currently do not have self driving telemetry for which are less safe by way of comparison. Other than that, groundbreaking presentation.

[@taylormichaels6950]

Another idiot who thinks he is smarter than George... lmao gtfo

[@MrCmon113]

@@taylormichaels6950 George seems to be super popular among people, who have no fucking clue about cars, machine learning and technology in general. In the best case, he has reinvented ACC and lane assist, that's all. He hasn't shown that his scheme solves any problem. Nor does he seem to be aware of the problems in autonomous driving.

[@drumchanneltunnel5191]

@@MrCmon113 Do you still feel this way? Comma has improved.

[@K9JT]

Yeah, science...

[@zhengzhang4275]

It is an open source agent???I thought is's not.

[@Honda-nn3ee]

Make it rain

[@A_Lesser_Man]

the cellphone in most people's pockets (i imagine, anyway) cost around a thousand bucks

[@aakash2939]

This is a billion dollars idea on open source TOTALLY FREE is this guy insane 😳

[@32isaias]

This is the company Elon Musk was worried about lmaoo finally put the pieces together .. I think its the video where Elon is getting interviewed on TED

[@rickross9829]

Yeah Elon Musk tried to hire him to work on driving AI, he formed his company comma.ai

[@jake733]

I don't get it!!

[@tenzackyogi1742]

im sure tech industries sell insurance liability after lvl4.😂 Keep in mind that safety is trillion dollar bussiness.

[@haydenmacfarlane7194]

Damn it I wish Elon hired this guy. He’s the perfect crazy genius type needed to solve such a ludicrous problem

[@crazyweb9605]

He is an alpha in tech he won't work well under Elon. He likes working alone.

[@haydenmacfarlane7194]

3 X I completely agree, it doesn’t mean I don’t want him on the Tesla team though😂😂

[@Wardoon]

Elon tried to hire him but they fell out before they could finalize a contract. They had public spat shortly after that and they part ways.

[@akshayasadventures]

Jessie Pinkman is doing IT stuff now!!

[@AlwinGeorge2008]

Science Bitch !

[@rayseefeldt1966]

Autopilot yes. Stocking cap no

[@_baumi_]

3:33 "the only difference between level 2 and 3-5 is liability" - no that's wrong - the difference in Level 4 "full driving task" and Level 2 "steer and gas" is the tasks with other human drivers - real life has accidents, stucked roads were you have to u-turn and negotiate with other drivers, etc ... that's afaik the "full driving task" that involves vehicle2human communication - and afaik this v2h com. is not solved at all at the moment .... besides that George is a legend :)

[@taylormichaels6950]

Here we go.... Some random idiot thinking he is smarter that George lmao.. stfu bitch

[@Fire0101011]

Taylor Michaels true ... 😂😂😂

[@2CommaClub]

I thought it said level 2 was “steer and gas and deceleration”?

[@chrisrosenkreuz23]

events in the future don't cause events in the past? why not? you know physically that doesn't make sense

[@meenoomeenoo4578]

I'm not the cause of being born 15 years ago. In other words, the event of my being today or in the future didn't cause the event of my being when I was born. Being born 15 years ago was the cause of my being today not the other way around.

[@klscott874]

"Go ahead, do it, I dare you. "

[@kevinspacey6090]

I'm so stupid

[@Budur2006]

Renault allready built a prototype car with level 5

[@elmehdinaor763]

Cosmin Budur loool the french better leave that to germans or jaoanese or koreans. French cars are bad as f...... und not reliable at all

[@andreaskrause]

he is again wearing yeezys :D

[@danieldude15]

I don’t understand something. If he is teaching AI to drive like humans... how will he make it drive better then humans? The problem is in how humans drive.

[@RealFlash100]

The AI learn from both the bad and the good drivers. It learns what to do from the good drivers and what not to do from the bad drivers. This will make it better than the average human driver, which (as he said in the talk) is a win.

[@khanhchung4103]

The machines do not have emotions. We, human, always do something with emotions aside, thats why sometimes it good or bad. For example, if you feel safe then you can drive faster otherwise you drive slower. But the machines are programmed by following the law without second thoughts

[@MrCmon113]

@@RealFlash100 All of this is missing the point. He is not adressing the actual problems in autonomous driving. The problem is recognizing what's on the road, not deciding what's to do when the road is known.

[@crazyweb9605]

@khanh Chung if its AI would it be able to break some rules at some point?

[@abhisht6811]

Damn he must be Elon Musk lost brother

[@keco185]

I wish his ego was smaller but his tech isn’t bad

[@MrPacMan36]

keco185 He's just very excited. And I think his ego matches his success. He also seems humble at times when necessary.

[@ross4]

The problem with his approach is that the car doesn't know what's behind or next to it. It's like driving a car with no mirrors.

[@I2yantheGreat]

dumbass the car has to be advanced enough to already have those cameras built in, how else would the app steer.............

[@rickross9829]

It only works with specific models of cars that already have the sensor they need.

[@chrisrosenkreuz23]

hey guy, it uses the car's own radar system as well as that camera you see

[@bd603]

The problem is him. People don’t like him

[@chrisrosenkreuz23]

that's not what you'd think from the comments

[@spazsi3838]

They need to fired the sound guy I need heard so many feedback

[@rift9891]

But plese dont be next google and steal peoples loacation info!

[@MrCmon113]

He seems to be completely unaware of the actual challenges of autonomous driving.