My ranking of MAMD songs

All MAMD songs are perfect, the entire show is flawless, go watch it ten times before doing anything else today.

[@ErinLovegood73]

MAMD is such an underrated show. The score is fabulous and the story (While full of dick jokes) is a sweet tale of your first time. And Corey Dorris is a KIng.

[@lostchimaera6339]

Hearing fetus joe again makes me see his glow up from this to SAF

[@GoodMorningButch]

It's kind of insane how much him and Joey have grown as singers!

[@bi_cycle]

The whole message and vibe of this musical is very strangely wholesome. Okay edit: I just noticed something and tell me if I'm overthinking or just restating what's already been said but- In the beginning Sally's outfit is a complete match with Joey's, even down to That Blue Band Thing. But at the end of the musical, when they actually hook up, she is wearing the completely different outfit. She became her own person, and through that she was able to finally get with Joey. Awwww.

[@GoodMorningButch]

THAT’S SO FUCKING SWEET

[@bi_cycle]

I know right!

[@muir6946]

the commentary just makes it ten times better

[@GoodMorningButch]

I'm so glad people think that, I always kinda feel obnoxious putting in the comments lol

[@MisterAppleEsq]

@@GoodMorningButch No the comments are the best part!

[@hamclamcamp]

Only ten?

[@HaunaMyKiki]

I have _such_ a special place in my heart for MAMD! It's ending message is so sweet and wholesome, far greater than most give it credit for!

[@GoodMorningButch]

I agree! It's such a soft, sincere show!

[@katk.8603]

the dress miss cooter wears. i want it. it's so flowy. that being said: this show is so soft and good, it doesn't get as much appreciation as it should. also baby joey richer

[@katk.8603]

also funf acts coming around & nothing like a dick may possibly be my top 2 songs bc....babies

[@TheBuddsO]

I NEVER REALIZED HIS FLOPSY VOICE IS THE SAME AS JAR JAR AND I CANT HANDLE IT WHAT HAVE YOU DONE I CANT STOP LAUGHING

[@hamclamcamp]

As an asexual, I was expecting to be disappointed, and I was honestly pleasantly surprised, this is a cute damn show (also, the world building is surprisingly good)

[@verletzt546]

Yooo hello fellow ace i also liked this musical ist cool

[@cornybram845]

aro/ace here! And, this is actually one of my fave Starkid shows. It's just got a certain charm to it. I love classic Starkid! 😁

[@aconstantstateofohio7211]

Ok Flopsy/Old Snatch's verse in Ready to Go is the bEST but maybe thats just bc im in love with Brian Holden.

[@bi_cycle]

Tiff and Ness' bit is my favourite, but it might be my inner lesbian making the decision.

[@aconstantstateofohio7211]

@@bi_cycle Lmaooo valid ngl

[@professorrock4698]

@@bi_cycle Joey and Sally's bits are the best because of how relatable and genuine they are. (Also, Sally and Miss Cooter's relationship is one of my favorite things about this show.)

[@christinehelgeton4686]

When "nothing like a dick" was so low i was surprised bc i love that song, the stomping nick does just works so well with the rythm. But when the video kept going i realized the 4 next songs just couldn't have been any lower, which goes to show the MAMD songs are just underrated and there's so many bops

[@GoodMorningButch]

It's SUCH a good soundtrack throughout with a whole matching vibe it's just really great!!!

[@screechingbirbs6406]

Awww Mamd is so underrated I’m so happy you made this uwu

[@GoodMorningButch]

It is! I don't like complaining into the void about people not producing the content I want when I can simply make it myself so I'm just doing it!

[@marinarasauce5701]

yay someone else appreciate pre vocal glow up joey !!

[@crookedfingers945]

woAH alle is a great dancer 🤯

[@ava8779]

you said "even though" RIGHTS!

[@GoodMorningButch]

It's such a cute song!

[@jordanne229]

Your love of this show is amazing and your little analyses of it makes me appreciate it even more! You’re right this show is cute and wholesome and genuinely good

[@GoodMorningButch]

Thank you so much!!! I try to really produce content and edits that come from the heart to convey my love for these stories so I’m so glad this is what’s coming across!

[@thereckoningthot5807]

I'm glad to have finally found someone who enjoys mamd as much as I do

[@alexashley9140]

Yessssss Even Though is my favourite MAMD song too! It's one of my favourite songs and I know all of the lyrics off by heart!

[@zbotello1439]

This show deserves more recognition it one of starkid’s finest

[@marinarasauce5701]

AAAHAHAHAH i didnt realize till this video that he uses the same voice for flopsy and jarjar and that makes me laugh so hard

[@jimmy_the_squid9456]

I love that arguably the most wholesome show in Starkid is about sentient genitalia

[@vividly_valeska5738]

Listen to your heart is my favorite song because AJ’s projection is just... *muah* I also AM LITERALLY IN LOVE WITH HIM

[@marinarasauce5701]

10:38 IT CUT BEFORE "HEA-EA-EA-EA-EA-EA-EART" IM SAD NOW

[@lynchie2073]

the old snatch is my favourite nicholas role shes SO GOOD

[@lattehottay3120]

sjkjsjs i love this show so much and i love joey/sally and ALSO i love "pre-vocal glow up" joey sO MUCH the bit they have at the end in the bed with "i'm so glad you were the one" etc they both sound so good etc and even though and the finale are both SO GOOD and i could listen to them forever

[@literallymoxxie]

MAMD is so so underrated and it makes me so upset its my favourite starkid musical and definitely deserves a cast recording 🙌 also praise even though being at #1

[@BlueGooTea]

7:15 I 100% agree with you on this part, something about Joey's growl (i guess I'll call it that) is really good

[@una_10bananas]

This video sums up why I love this show

[@idontevenknowwhy3655]

Mamd is my comfort musical

[@g.k.2795]

This is amazing, and the top 5 are great!

[@GoodMorningButch]

Thanks! I love those songs so much.

[@lilac_reed]

A lesbian ranking of a musical about a *man* trying to get laid. Now this is the content I'm here for

[@fallon3216]

MAMD is my favourite starkid musical- there I said it- have you seen Jaime?! I can’t help it!

[@Trinitysflicks767]

I love this show so much 💖

[@leilanyx]

love me some pre vocal glow up joey appreciation! he always sounded good imo, he just learned how to be a healthier singer and take better care of his voice! i def need to rewatch mamd bc it's been a hot minute - i remember not being super enthused about this show when i first watched it as a teen (most sexual jokes and stuff made and still do make me uncomfy) and i didn't vibe with a lot of the humour but i def have grown to appreciate it a lot more over the years. it's a cute, fun story with some surprisingly incredible and heartfelt songs that just happens to have genital jokes in it. it still would probably rank fairly low if i ranked my favourite starkid shows unfortunately, but i still love it.

[@opalash3345]

I LOVE THEM - someone named sally

[@GracieSanderson]

I need even though recorded so I can stream it for life in good quality lol

[@MisterAppleEsq]

Lol the top three are the three Darren songs.

[@GoodMorningButch]

He is SUCH a talented songwriter! I did notice that when I checked the composers of each song of the show a while ago, I guess my taste is consistent!

[@MisterAppleEsq]

Unrelated, but 14:28 PERFECTLY encapsulates MAMD, like wow.

[@levitate08]

Finale is probbably thbe most cutie patootie song about sex

[@maskedsinger8337]

MAMD best Starkid musical? 🤔