Game Theory: FNAF, Bonnie's Haunted Past (Security Breach Ruin)

[@hearts4harin]

Ive watched more fnaf theories from matpat than I've seen my extended family.

[@Anonymous-q8t7p]

Same

[@Sike561dont]

Mat should do a theory on Color or die (Roblox) (SHARE this guys) If you guys are going to be negative, don’t reply pls

[@AverageStuffYT]

Haven’t we all

[@realpoesolo]

Same

[@Spicy.Heron.]

That's probably the most relatable comment that I've ever read

[@eef_YT]

still love that he was burned at the STAKE for saying that cassie's dad is bonnie bro and then steel wool basically CONFIRMED it several times in HW2, now everyone who threw a fit is QUIET

[@stevecorp6537]

I've been looking through here to see if any of those aforementioned naysayers have responded since HW2 and all the apparent confirmations they made to this/these theories. As you said, lots of QUIET..

[@melissazoethout3097]

Hi

[@daetomrossington3623]

Wow.. that’s funny!

[@karrimgyver]

why did they throw a fit tho? because out of every therory on this channel, that one ain't really hard to believe. Or is it because "can't make theorys about darker skinned characters". Which would be pretty dumb

[@edwardwestmoreland-caunter6128]

I love the "rivalry" between MatPat and Markiplier. It adds so much humour to both of their FNAF content

[@jamesdeleon3337]

Many likes and no comments lemme fix it

[@SynthesiaVN]

Many likes and just one comment let me fix 🔧 that

[@shwalkingmeme485]

Many likes and only two comments lemme jump on that

[@Billgaming-ip8wg]

A COMMENT WITH REPLIES THAT ARE OVERUSING JOKES CAN'T FIX STUPIDITY

[@medicc2854]

​@Billgaming-ip8wg you can suck an egg and a stick

[@Cindle_The_candle]

I SAW THE MOVIE LIKE 46 MINUTES AGO. MATPAT THE WHOLE MOVIE THEATRE SCREAMED WHEN THEY SAW YOU-

[@danadossary9369]

I would too

[@ski_skammer]

exactly what i did when i saw it

[@GiadaVillucci-hg1rp]

I screamed and like my mind ruptured 😂😂😂😂😂😂❤❤❤❤❤❤🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯🤯

[@rutgerkoenders6527]

I love how Matpat jumps from ancient Greece to FNaF in not even 15 seconds

[@apersonwhomayormaynotexist9868]

I mean the ancient Greek connection with comedy and tragedy masks is pretty surface level and not a difficult jump to make. Anyone with a basic understanding of theater would make the same connection

[@GalaxyGamer-y2w]

ye

[@Gappys6thTesticle]

​@DontReadMyProfilePicture.57if u say so

[@johnfarr8292]

​@DontReadMyProfilePicture.57no I will

[@Threepeater6447]

​@@apersonwhomayormaynotexist9868matpat is a theater boy soooooo

[@fuhlash]

at this point my kids are going to be growing up watching MatPat still try to solve the FNAF lore edit now we will be watching tom lose his mind over the fnaf lore

[@Cheeseboy1967]

@RomanisRandomso I um accidentally Translated it 😶👍

[@hermansfood]

If you keep watching this guy I can’t confirm your bloodline will continue

[@I-do-what-I-want]

​@Cheeseboy1967 same yo. I am safe, thank goodness lol

[@N38873]

Fr 💀

[@fuhlash]

@@hermansfoodlmaooo💀💀

[@colekiesler6218]

I love how Bonnie has now become the ultimate missing puzzle piece of the FNAF lore this era and for some reason he seems to have now become the new Golden Freddy.

[@galaxykitty9690]

Same, especially since he was the first character that scott created

[@doomari20]

And I Remmeber That "Where Is Bonnie" That He Didn't Appeared Fnaf 3 Game Because He Was Replaced By Springtrap🤔😂🤣

[@hafizulrahman3327]

Cassie dad is the bully with bonnie mask

[@adannator1546]

also interestingly (unless its already been mention) bonnie (blue bonnie) in every fnaf game that bonnie's in (fnaf 1,2,4 *sister locations dosent count since he was just a hand puppet*) bonnie is always the first to start going after the player and usually (from watching other people's playthru) is the most agressive activating on night 1 and during other nights will visit the player the most often

[@riverboygamer2836]

However, That's just a theory, A GAME THEORY.

[@Mx.muffin]

14:43 Matpat, are you suggesting that Afton might have been a theater kid?

[@prophecy-8]

Omg I love that

[@WindypadfootESVeiwer]

Omg, yesss!

[@DISCORDCHANNEL]

Robin vibes

[@harrya9458]

The idea that while Michael was literally chasing ghosts and bringing up the pains of his past, his childhood friend was busy building a family and living an honest life is very funny to me

[@unusualusername8847]

In fairness, Michael was literally purple and smelled awful. Not much he could do with that.

[@justice8718]

Michael is the CC as they both love Freddy, the younger character. Phone guy is the one that loves Foxy. Pairing him up better with the one that loves Bonnie, an older character.

[@AxolotlQueen]

​@@justice8718no he's not lol. Michael is the older brother.

[@justice8718]

@@AxolotlQueen Michael has never once shown any love for Foxy and is alluded to being bitten at the B-day parties ("The party was meant for you"). WIlliam is obsessed with Michael in particular that he calls out his name in his OMC dream realm.

[@Los_HermanitosCruz]

Honestly 😂

[@totallynotmisty]

If Scott doesn't release a full 100-page, thorough explanation of this darn timeline - by at least the 15-year mark of this franchise... I say we riot (at least for the sake of Matt's mental health) edit: GUYS WE DID IT HE'S WITH SCOTT!

[@stoid9231]

Agreed

[@Snakepit_Media]

When Scott dies we better get a full 1000 page essay about the lore of FNAF

[@Amongusaurus]

​@@Snakepit_Mediabreaking news: 1000 page explaination of fnaf lore found in the last will of Scott Cawthon

[@TheEpicGalaxy21]

Plot Twist: It's just like, a 5 page essay that basically just summarizes everything we see happen in the game with little to no connecting, deeper discussion...

[@countingstars9781]

to be honest, he'd definitely be capable of something like that

[@starling1226]

An interesting thing is in SB in the endo skeleton tunnels, there’s so much Moon imagery, plushies, ads for the Moondrop candy. It makes it seem that he has played a bigger role in the pizza plex. And there’s a wall of a drawing of a kid in bed not sleeping with a scratch across it. (Moon is the naptime attendant) I think the candy was made for kids to fall asleep not just for naptime but so Moon can carry them off to Vanessa.

[@michikip45]

The theory of Cassie’s dad being one of the bros during the bite is probably my favorite theory to come out of Ruins release, if the new games can tie back to the original 4 in a semi cohesive way I’ll honestly be content

[@sweetpea2604]

FNAF 4 gave us more questions than answers & now these new games are giving us those answers

[@ayaankureshi-6969]

If I did the math assuming he was 13 during the bite 13+17=30 30+35=65 therefore he would be 65 during ruin so therefore I don’t think it’s normal for a 65 year old man almost the age of my grandpa to have a 12 yo child

[@Rarkss]

@@ayaankureshi-6969 i think it still could though

[@1o733]

​@@RarkssI agree with you, like cassie could either been adopted or born through surrogacy

[@Mayonaiese]

He had here when he was 53 🤔

[@TheTrueNicklose]

Honestly, if they never reveal FNAF's overall story, I'm content with what MatPat has come up with.

[@__Soya__]

Except for gregbot lol

[@skelebonethedread3199]

@@__Soya__I like that so Im fine with all of it

[@__Soya__]

@@skelebonethedread3199 Sorry dude but the “everyone is Afton “ theory is kinda gone

[@ManicFiction]

​​@@__Soya__What? What kinda theory is "everyone is Afton"?

[@dhanyarrozie]

​@@ManicFictioni guess its the "everyone is an incarnation of aftons, like gregory being the crying child, glamrock freddy is michael, and vanessa is elizabeth"

[@helenierudich2049]

I absolutely love MatPat and Markipliers banter they should make a channel/podcast where they just discuss games callled “the m&ms”

[@LynkPlaysGames]

yes!

[@Marshmallow_raccoonn]

And they have to add a hidden m&m in each video cause of the name

[@mohamedsayed6844]

that will be awseome @@Marshmallow_raccoonn

[@mohamedsayed6844]

if it happend

[@Nico_Di_Angelo_Official]

𝚈𝚎𝚜𝚜𝚒𝚛

[@OneColdRepublican]

15:36 - 16:12 Well now I want an hour long video of MatPat describing Jester/Clown/Carnival lore.

[@madeleinepotter2786]

Your never gonna believe this.....

[@OneColdRepublican]

@@madeleinepotter2786 IS THERE A VIDEO OF CLOWN LORE?????

[@madeleinepotter2786]

@@OneColdRepublican yep! It's not by matpat, but it's game theory, and whooo boy, it's deep

[@Leosloth2011]

@@madeleinepotter2786whats it called

[@estefan5837]

Honestly, I thought that Cassie's father didn't die or go missing, but changed. Something he experienced made him completely change how he viewed these characters he used to love. Another detail that I am surprised Matpat didn't mention (although almost certainly would have noticed) is in the end credits. Each entry seemed normal enough, except for his favorite lore bots, the staff bots. They had "..." after their entry. Makes me wonder why. The feeling it gives me is the way that a person trailing off is normally written, especially to indicate uncertainty. But that's just a theory.

[@ejlyt9148]

A GAAAME THEORY! Thanks for watching 🙃

[@hospitalizations]

This is your last clue

[@hospitalizations]

Save me from him..

[@Icameinclutch]

If he truly is Michael's childhood friend, than maybe he knows about some more horrific things that involved mike and the animatronics, like fnaf sister location ending and the death of Elizabeth (mike's sister), maybe he used to collect those things and love the animatronics but stopped after what happened to the crying child, but that's just a theory 🙃

[@Coolboy_hehe]

@@IcameinclutchA GAMEEE THEORY! thanks for reading

[@ChadOnSnoop]

Watching matpat descend into madness from Fnaf and still learning about the lore is my guilty pleasure

[@frederichfazbearingtonthefith]

*This comment makes me wanna*

[@AJiguess_]

@@frederichfazbearingtonthefithbattle for dream island

[@RivkahSong]

Is he still descending at this point? Surely he's hit the bottom of the pit by now and is just perpetually marinating in fretful insanity. lol

[@ireallyneedsleep8661]

@@RivkahSong i think he has hit the bottom at this point but he brought a shovel and is digging the pit deeper

[@Sean-qg3gg]

Is the pun intended?

[@dj_netwrk4901]

Im 8 years into all of this, and you somehow STILL manage to make me gasp out loud

[@GaaraFPS]

Been on this since the release of the first games trailer still getting shocked with how well everything is “connected”

[@Oats101]

The fact that this theory may have just been confirmed right by HW 2 is insane

[@shawnheatherly]

Cassie's father being "Bonnie bro" would be an interesting way to tie in fairly forgotten characters. Michael's friends would almost certainly also feel awful about their part in what happened.

[@MrSquidWhiskers]

Okay, this is a bit of a weird/long shot. But in the second book of the FNAF novel series, The Twisted Ones, Charlie created a set of two simple faced robots that were essentially machine learning programs trying to mimic human conversation. Could that have anything to do with the Eclipse, and the comedy and tragedy masks, and the mimic?

[@Parallelocam]

The teeth aren't even the same man, the mimic and eclipse are not related at all lol

[@Jack_Kennedy1987]

@@Parallelocam the teeth are the same though? name one other animatronic you have seen use that teeth design besides the mimic. ill wait.

[@Parallelocam]

@@Jack_Kennedy1987 The mimic was created in 1982-1984 according to the books. Eclipse was created way before then if you believe what Matt says here. Those two things contradict each other. How could that be? I'll wait.

[@omorifan6011]

​@@Parallelocamthis specific design was made after the mimic. Simple

[@junelaananke7138]

​@@ParallelocamI mean, didn't Matpat basically imply that Eclipse was a prototype of the Mimic, not created after? I don't know if I believe it myself, probably don't, but that would still line up according to your logic.

[@lunarnightterror7599]

I love how Matt and Mark are just slowly but surely having more and more of a rivalry it’s entertaining af. Now MatPat needs to be added to the Darkiplier and Antisepticeye universe.

[@Somedudenamedtito]

Madpat?

[@masteroox]

He actually created Antipat for Film Theory to make him some counterpart to talk about. But Antipat wasn't exacly evil, more like trying its best to be funny and popular, but most of his lines sounded so cliché, for example: "Goodbye Internet."

[@Deflamed_Sphere]

Antipat existed

[@Toxicrown]

Don’t you mean PatMat

[@nouille3928]

Madbad

[@citrusinsummer]

Scott needs to just give us a timeline already with an essay for every event cuz idk if theorists can take much more 💀

[@LeafPepper]

I've been watching these theories for 6 hours straight and I'm going insane.

[@mirelapatrcevic1755]

wow

[@ABCDEFGHIGKLMNOP715]

Aren't we all?

[@VTK13_]

real

[@madilynnseidel7378]

I’m about to do that to 💀 I can’t go to sleep so I decided to watch fnaf theories

[@sophbear4259]

i did exactly that last night lol

[@gloomytomb]

Why haven’t I seen someone point out how weird it is that Helpy’s appearance occasionally changes to look more corrupted when giving the player certain pieces of information? It gives off the impression that those particular instances may imply we’re being manipulated and lied to.

[@ABCDEFGHIGKLMNOP715]

That's because the evil mimic is talking when Helpi looks more corrupted

[@colekiesler6218]

Imagine if one day MatPat’s theories could possibly foreshadow many of the events to happen in FNAF’s future to the point that he gets his own FNAF based game.

[@booboothecool]

considering his pretty poor track record when it comes to actually making theories that work out, i doubt it!

[@ShadowOreo77]

...Five Nights At Freddy's... _Matthew's Wrath_ 😂

[@GetRidOfThisFeature]

​@@booboothecoollike you could do better.. and it's called a theory for a reason

[@TheSecondOfJinxers]

@@booboothecool Do you know what a theory is?

[@CoolScratcher]

@@booboothecool the point of theories isn't being right, it's about having fun and being creative

[@erluq9309]

Help Wanted 2 is out and its crazy how accurate this theory turned out

[@aadityamaharaj4082]

Imagine if the FNAF devs write their story based around MatPats theories

[@thatbisexualsimp4269]

They better lol

[@Brielle3-x2s]

i would

[@seemsfishy23]

It would be a tighter and more coherent story lol

[@wiseonly52]

If that was the case, the games story would be alot easier to solve

[@jaycloudberry8736]

I thought Matpat was ghostwriting for them already...

[@alexinator-hh5fe]

Real ones know about the hype surrounding Bonnie. I remember when Mark, Matpat and Dawko all had that collab episode where they talked over each other while throwing ideas into the void that ended with Matpat sucking an egg

[@farawayxgalaxy]

And then Fuhnaff, and IDfantasy, and then RyeToast

[@lawrencemidlarsky8240]

Why doesn’t Fusionzgamer get invited to collab with them, he is friends with dawko

[@Draconlykos]

Matpat CAN SUCK AN EGG Matpat: aight

[@generaljashin8067]

@@farawayxgalaxy It was funny when Matpat did it, but then everyone tried to milk it, and not even adding much to it. I can respect Fuhnaff, but even his version was both cut short and you could see him struggle to try to make it funny.

[@finixmoon127]

​@@generaljashin8067 Memes in a nutshell

[@Batmannotbrucewayne]

If you watch this and the very first video back to back you can actually feel mat’s descent to insanity

[@konstantin8246]

Don't forget, Helpi has two versions, one where we can see corruption and one clean version. When Cassie leaves the AR network at the end, we can see both versions talk. First the corrupted one talking to here directly, then the actual Helpi, just giving general information that she is leaving the network.

[@thefrog3685]

That was the mimic wasn’t it?

[@ABCDEFGHIGKLMNOP715]

@@thefrog3685 the one with orange eyes and veins is the corrupted version

[@LucasSouza-ls8hv]

​@@thefrog3685 yes but no,the virus mimic and the endo mimic are 2 separate things

[@Victoriasecret3]

I thought it was helpy?

[@tobysinbad]

Cassie specifically says her dad never told her what happened to Glamrock Bonnie. It’s implied he knew but she didn’t until we discover for ourselves.

[@hospitalizations]

[Clue]

[@Ranger-over]

Hmm, Cassie could have been lying in order to protect her father or they might not know the whole story. Who knows?! Awn7mFktpB4

[@debby15463]

I thought this as soon as he said she knew thank you for bringing it up!

[@williamweyermann9491]

I’m convinced Scott has not idea what to write for these games and just watches all the theory videos and picks which one he likes the best

[@honeyko1929]

fr

[@scrollix1]

npc ahh comment

[@0alyssuhh]

@@scrollix1aint no way dawg said “ahh” 😭😭😭🙏

[@vexinum3837]

@@0alyssuhh goofy ahh reply 🗿🗿

[@theauthor6669]

@@scrollix1 e-boy npc ahh pfp

[@RyanFritsch-m7g]

that whole nobody-showed-up-but-Gregory-and-now-she's-trying-to-save-him bit is really wholesome

[@beccavoto1096]

I love how matt made the final timeline in triumph, having finally solved fnaf…but then Ruin shows up and scrambles everything so he’s back at square one. I look forward to your new complete timeline in 5 years Matt!🎉

[@RivkahSong]

New here, huh? I think Scott's done this to Matpat 4 times, now. 🤣

[@Nightmare-ik2tn]

Matpat throwing out more theories and im here for it

[@Lexi_139]

​@RomanisRandombruh

[@giddy9831]

Same

[@Sike561dont]

Mat should do a theory on Color or die

[@LuninityInfinity]

ATP I don't think he gonna ever stop until FNAF absolutely starts turning into dust

[@tyrellgonsalves5679]

Monty is not the killer Monty was frem Roxy is the real killer

[@TimeBucks]

Great theory as always

[@حكايةحكاية-ح1م]

nice

[@mdmamunislam7997]

Always is tha great

[@quotesenglish8112]

Nice

[@SnorgYippee]

How

[@Choirfr]

A legend has commented

[@ZackaryAsAlways]

Am I the only one who came back to this video after playing or watching FNAF VR 2? I think this video is important to go back to for FNAF VR 2

[@Hallowpool193]

No you're not

[@Hallowpool193]

I'm here too

[@مالكالنايف-ك8ك]

12:35 10000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000000

[@gunshow4524]

The daycare attendant being a mimic type robot also makes a lot of sense given that the mimic was originally created to be a playmate for Edwin’s son. It even makes sense with the AI learning systems that mirror the mimic from the books with the moon personality being the violent evil part that was learned after the tragic death of David and the Sun being the gentle and loving loving part that was learned through its earlier interactions. Possibly making it the, “original” mimic? But that might be a stretch.

[@Los_HermanitosCruz]

That would be awesome thougj

[@LittleToyBonnie]

Yeah, the only problem with that is that it the reason why Sun and Moon are like that was already confirmed, Sun and Moon were made as part of a show and Fazbear Entertainment was to lazy to remove Moon when the show was scrapped.

[@VictorianError]

At this point not even the creators of the fnaf games know how deep this lore is anymore

[@tartra]

They do now lol "Great, MatPat's got his explanation out. Take notes, everybody!"

[@uzuwi9782]

@@tartra thats how i think it is lol

[@JackEtheGuyMan]

They get high before writing the script

[@freddyfzd]

​@@JackEtheGuyManchild

[@TRG_R17]

Reply 5

[@azanimates]

I haven't been so mind blown in a while. Bonnie bro makes a come back.

[@xiea1258]

I really like the idea of Cassie’s dad being the sad friend of Foxy bro that goes on a redemption arc and becomes a technician so no one gets crunched by a fredbear again.

[@knaughta.masso-kist5944]

It's a nice idea, but the supporting evidence is pretty weak imo

[@xiea1258]

@@knaughta.masso-kist5944 I said the idea is is fun, Not necessarily that it is possible.

[@dumb0999]

@@knaughta.masso-kist5944 been pretty much confirmed now

[@requiemdragon8620]

Another thing about jesters, they were also meant to kind of make fun of the king after he'd been worshipped all day to make sure he doesn't lose sight of the problems around the kingdom. Jesters got to say things that others would be executed for. Whether this is relevant to anything in terms of lore or not, it is kind of interesting.

[@theparkourgamerplaysgames9312]

This is probably my favorite fnaf theory. I love the idea of shifting our attention to other characters who aren’t apart of the afton family but were affected by the afton’s.

[@shadowychica]

Just finished watching the recent GTlive play through and I gotta say I can’t believe how much all of this lines up! Really amazing you managed to put so much together!! I can only imagine how satisfying it was to see it all come together!! 🎉🎉🎉

[@Salemchevy]

The one thing I like about matpat is how he can always pull a afton and always come back to fnaf. He never fails to connect the pieces together of this decade old decade series

[@NekoEcho13]

Can't wait to see the continued loop of Matt and Mark reacting to each other, where Mark licks a stick; or a sudowoodo. 🤣

[@theonetruekinglord]

Which isn't a stick, but a rock. I thought matpat would of done enough Pokémon theories to know that already 🤣 (Joke, don't take it as hate.)

[@jason4443]

​@@theonetruekinglord Who says a stick needs to be made of wood anyway?

[@ParkerRoussel]

Congrats on the Streamy’s MatPat you did great and you looked great in that suit.

[@planetcheese]

Absolutely

[@testinguser9311]

@RomanisRandom i'll take that

[@EEEEEEEE]

E‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎

[@Vita_Rizz]

Couldn't have said it better myself!

[@vas-poenitentiae-08]

@RomanisRandomI’d rather die than subscribe to you.

[@ItsMe_Victor]

One must imagine MatPat happy.

[@DeAtruche]

I always thought the "It hurts to look at quote" for the AR Monty plush was because its the first AR collectible you can get, and lets be honest glitchy grid patterns are not easy to look at without some eye strain.

[@GamerJoseKun]

I still think that's the reason xD It's the first item we find right after we get the Vanny mask. I think if she was taking about Monty specifically the quote would be like "It's hard to look at HIM/to HIM."

[@DarkShadow-hy6iq]

Nah this seems way too over thought

[@joechristo2]

I think it’s because of her encounter with Monty.

[@apersonwhomayormaynotexist9868]

also Monty was the animatronic that got the closest to killing her

[@dareal_legendario245]

​@@apersonwhomayormaynotexist9868i think it could be possible that she knows because she doesn't have any reaction when she finds bonnie while she does in so many other events

[@unoreversegiorno]

i respect matpat simply because he has the most determination i have ever seen, he has to go through all of these games and find all these clues, then place them all together to find all of that, just for a video for us.

[@EbenezerrYT]

John and Matpat are becoming an iconic duo, and I am all for it‼️

[@FalseInformation-Steve]

Don't translate :,( FNAF သုတေသနကို အနှစ် 500 လောက် မင်းကို ငါကျိန်စာတိုက်တယ်

[@PingasFumberto]

Not as iconic as matpat and Austin

[@pekkatank4386]

It's getting there.

[@callmedimples33]

Just got done with the FNAF movie. Tearing up at the end and still can't get over the cameo ;) and stick around to the very end, spells something out like the mini games in FNAF 2

[@imjustafleabag1760]

did you manage to hear what it said. it makes me so excited for a second film!

[@callmedimples33]

​@@imjustafleabag1760it spells out Come Find Me!

[@Querez8504]

Honestly an interesting connection with the Bonnie mask. Assuming he was 13-17 in 1983, he'd be... anywhere from 40-60 during Ruin? Yeah, that easily adds up. I'd honestly be fully on board with Cassie's dad being "Bonnie bro" if it turns out to be true.

[@RestedAura2]

Yea, the fact of Cassie's dad is Bonnie bro and if we get an age confirmation, I feel it's going to confirm certain timelines

[@WatchPoppy69]

i wont lie. this ties with Jeremy - Bonnie correlation. what if jeremy is cassie's dad?🤣🤣🤣🤣it only makes sense trully speaking.

[@luclee9290]

This is off topic from the comment, but for the gold plushies... There is a Freddy, Baby, Foxy, and "Golden Bonnie" Hmmm... I WONDER WHAT IT COULD BE? (To those who don't get it yet, a gold Freddy, like what the crying child is supposed to possess, a baby, Elizabeth, and a foxy, Micheal. You can tell what the bonnie is. I don't understand the sun and moon though.

[@QuarterCal]

Bonnie bro, I love that! Lol

[@RestedAura2]

@@WatchPoppy69 Jeremy was killed as a child and became Bonnie what?

[@CelestialBellDrop]

Honestly I can’t believe the daycare attendants were any important to the lore, I just thought they were side characters adopted by the community to make a subfandom where they’re in their own separate universe. I’m in said subfandom and I can confirm the fans are gonna be *all* over this ✨

[@Cup1dR0se]

FR!! The fandom be making funni lil animations (me) and fanfics, but now Matpat is telling me that our loveable boys are actually a HUGE part of the lore??

[@hjigyicvy]

နာရီအနည်းငယ်ကြာတဲ့အခါ သင့်နှလုံးခုန်ရပ်သွားပါလိမ့်မယ်။ ၎င်းကိုတားဆီးရန် တစ်ခုတည်းသောနည်းလမ်းမှာ ဤချန်နယ်ကို စာရင်းသွင်းရန်ဖြစ်သည်။

[@xoldragon]

OK@DontReadMyProfilePicture.57

[@SalsCorner]

The DCA "fandom" scares me.

[@xHavki]

@DontReadMyProfilePicture.57 i accidentally read it...

[@jazzyboss1430]

how mat patt comes up with any of this Lore and manages to make complete sense is beyond me

[@ChrysanthosC.]

Try coming up with an original comment for once maybe

[@mwtycafe]

​@@ChrysanthosC.he has literally one comment on gametheory

[@maxbennett5412]

@@ChrysanthosC. This is the most random and pointless attack on someone I have ever seen.

[@gudinesangelicau]

fr😅

[@monkeylegend2579]

@@ChrysanthosC.dawg who are you? 💀

[@MomentsOfAlwaysnessss]

Still on a firm stand that Monty didn't attack Bonnie, mostly because he didn't have his claws until after the transition aaaaand they said green paint was left behind (has to be an obvious cover) and his claws (even though he didn't have them yet) are purple, Monty is innocent I tell ya

[@yomfykwis]

Another thing to add at 17:43 is that the M.X.E.S machine looks similar to the W.O.P.R machine from the movie WarGames (1983) which took place during the cold war. The machine was a supercomputer that ran war simulations which basically was the plot of the movie.

[@miraculous_lady_noir2179]

WOPR WOPR WOPR WOPR, junior double triple WOPR

[@phonene.]

nice observation they do look pretty similar

[@Catto-idk]

The “That’s just a theory A GAME THEORY” will never get old

[@dimitrisfournaros1]

@Amazing_Kiki i agree

[@adenb12115]

Frfr

[@playlistsam4596]

Yeah..

[@germany5678]

Happy for matpat that he got to use his history as a theater nerd in this video :)

[@bquick1177_music]

We’ll miss you, MatPat

[@johnyesjustjohn]

15:35 I’m sure we all have our own hill to perish on, but I was not expecting this particular hill to have MatPat standing on its summit.

[@BobLeBuilder]

Mat is slowly descending into insanity as this game gets new installations

[@EEEEEEEE]

E‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎

[@aliawahfallacy]

Slowly?

[@MCTogs]

Nah bro he's gone insane since sister location this is all just the voices talking now

[@hackertiger8527]

He is descending into madness 😮

[@Slurp_Durp]

This has been said so many times

[@nexo.o9972]

Am i the only one to get so happy when I see John in MatPat's videos. I remember watching John's video and how he hoped to talk to MatPat and here he is. In videos and livestreams. I even get emotional and so happy to see how for John is. Honestly so proud of him

[@Katero131]

At 5:13 Matpat basically explains who you play as in HW2.

[@vastttyl8161]

Every theory I see about Ruin or SB I can't tell whether we're giving Steel Wool too much or not enough credit lol

[@kelsakuyama3222]

I really like the “Bonnie kid is Cassie’s dad” part! It’d be awesome to see how other perspectives of the Bite of ‘83 would affect the lore and certainly would be a fresh take on the series. Not sure of how to feel about the Sun/Moon/Eclipse part, though. I agree that their teeth mean some connection with the Mimic, but Afton being the creator still feels a bit off.

[@Duck_with_grapes55]

It makes sense especially since steel wool wants to make a freadbears game and no one whould expect Bonnie bro to be important to the lore

[@SwiftBlades12]

Since Cassie’s dad is so heavily implied to love Bonnie throughout the game, could it not be that the security system is represented by a blue rabbit, similar to his favourite animatronic, because he was heavily (if not more) involved in the creation of the security system to block Bonnie?

[@TrevaughnSmith-bj3lb]

The same system that held back the mimic as well

[@chérie_valery]

What if her dad posses the security system or like William afton is the security system

[@duchuynhvuong1733]

ôk

[@tritamtran7264]

ok

[@ahealthkit2745]

Wouldn't make any sense, the techology is so old that he'd still be a kid-friend to Michael Afton at that point.

[@nathanbrownlee9276]

I think Ruin’s ending is the same as Sister Location. Cassie got “scooped”. She’s been taken over by The Mimic, similar to what Ennard did to Michael. Except instead of getting turned into a weird Remnant skin suit zombie thing, Cassie was taken over through the neural chip that was implanted in her head at the start of the game. So basically what happened to Vanessa and Glitch Trap.

[@PlayerOne.StartGame]

It's really fascinating to see this series never end. This theory videos always looking like the final but only ending up more complicated.

[@EEEEEEEE]

E‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎

[@crazygur1y]

​@k32ev8inYour mom's worried, Kevin.

[@RockRPSN]

Im so glad to see Jon getting recognized and referenced in theories now, both MatPat and Jon are awesome ❤

[@SkydiaStrike]

Doesn’t he also work in the theorist team? I thought it was mentioned before but idk

[@RockRPSN]

@@SkydiaStrike not that I know of, but they do collaborate on theories.

[@toainsully]

Who?

[@jjj6854]

The Markiplier and MatPat dynamic in this video is gold 😂

[@AlfaFrostYT]

Can't wait to see Mark lick a stick in his future episode 😂

[@trdestruction6678]

@@AlfaFrostYTYES

[@Naya_rulez]

Hey I just watched the fnaf movie and I noticed what you guys did. Nice acting!

[@TMRae_Rae__]

Love the theory. Wondering if the past tense isn't referencing death but possibly a spurned or disturbed employee/friend of the family. Imagine loving something with your best friend and then you see his whole family falling apart, surrounded by the franchise you bonded over. Or finally working for the place you've been isnpired by for years, only to learn its shifty as hecc. I'd get rid of my memorabilia too.

[@StormBlackwell]

Eclipse, Baby, Ballora, Puppet, and Balloon Boy have all always seemed weird alongside the others. Now there's enough of them that they feel like a "set" of sorts.

[@ABCDEFGHIGKLMNOP715]

All of them do appear to be humanoid, so that might be something

[@ryismazin]

Yes. Humanoid. Performative. Entertainment based.

[@ABCDEFGHIGKLMNOP715]

@@ryismazin all were also designed to not scare the really easily scared children, at least, that's what I think

[@Ian_Ignacio]

They're also oddly enough similar in design like circus or something..... Or some sort of royal card theme......

[@Lemonade.Peanutbutter]

Matpat be jumping from conclusion to conclusion with no hesitation

[@daboi4983]

Bro saw that there teeth were alike and went for it💀💀

[@go-go-rilla4405]

its a theory

[@Average_Grilledcheese_fan]

​@@go-go-rilla4405 a game theory ayeeeee

[@KatmodoDragon]

He's gonna need a trampoline for the conclusions he's jumping too.

[@chaoticgay7257]

Mat doesn’t make fnaf theories anymore They’re more like assumptions that have no bases

[@alex_does_art129]

watching this after seeing into the pit, mats theory about the masks really makes sense

[@lily-qe9hj]

Congratulations matpat! This is your 71th FNAF theory yet! I wonder how much more...

[@rainingmissiles4652]

71th huh?

[@Maniac_l23]

​@@rainingmissiles4652they meant 71rd

[@hmkrjax]

@@Maniac_l23you mean 71st

[@crownanx2700]

@@hmkrjax71thousandth*

[@goober112]

I like 71nd

[@carlizzlesizzle5086]

I love Mat and Mark's friendship, it's so silly and you can just tell that they adore each other and poking fun is how their friendship works

[@kory_misun]

I love how the Mimic, one of the best abilities in FNAF World, is popping up later in the series as something super important. They might just be the same in name and not in function, but I still find it fun. I have to bring up that in Sister Location, Edgy Teen Narrator brings up that they found someone in the vents, no longer living. It's not a funny story, Hand Unit says, but it is a story.

[@Yuusfw]

A GAME STORY

[@Yuusfw]

A GAME STORY

[@MM_Bee]

No words that I can say to express what emotional impact that was just an emoji. 😭

[@SamanthaLaurier]

My question is if the old FNAF pizzeria was built on top of Circus Baby's, and was then in turn built over by the Pizzaplex.. how did nobody notice? These were all well-known, prominent, popular places that cater to similar demographics. You'd think someone would have noticed that these three places all shared the same general location.

[@earleschulz3031]

Yeah it's a little goofy, since for Henry to have built Pizza Sim directly above Baby's, it would have had to sink under. And then after that PS sunk and they built the pizzaplex above that. Surprisingly one of the most believable things for me in FNAF

[@SamanthaLaurier]

@@earleschulz3031 For me the most believable thing is a massive American corporation being run by an insane man who enjoys killing children.

[@multitaskman4227]

​​@@earleschulz3031inb4 that sinkhole has the Fnaf 1-3 locations somewhere inbetween PS and Circus Baby's. No wonder nobody shut down the Pizzaplex. Fazbear Entertainment's been building bigger and bigger projects over the same plot of land for the past 50 years just because they can buy & cover up plots of land near the expanding sinkhole at unimaginably cheap prices.

[@astercipher594]

@@earleschulz3031 maybe it's because the location of SBPW was only the underground section, the actual pizzeria was demolished, then Henry made a FFPizzaPlace, and _then_ after the sinkhole, we had the pizzaplex? sure it's still goofy but hey it kind of works..?

[@wetzel4806]

@DontReadMyProfilePicture.57 gotcha. Thanks for looking out mate, coulda clicked on cringe.

[@lawden210]

Thank you Matpat for acknowledging the conversation between Helpy and the Mimic😭

[@Cyro_Snow]

Matpat never fails to shove his nice amazing theory’s down our throats

[@Imthatfriendthatmakesyoulaugh]

Ayooo

[@Mikuzao]

💀💀

[@user-ow2cs7fb5l]

🤨📸

[@CoolEdo]

🤖

[@EEEEEEEE]

‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎E

[@pokewoman6354]

The Bonnie mask parallel to the bite of ‘83 is insane, considering that security breach constantly reiterates that foxy is no longer ‘here’ and Michael used to wear the foxy mask.

[@someoneintheinternet8144]

Sometimes, I just wonder if matt is sane after all these fnaf videos

[@Digooz956]

Me too

[@giddy9831]

Fr

[@nmm_01]

Definitely not

[@sarahlethbridge7786]

Same and I worry for him

[@EEEEEEEE]

E‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎‎

[@Mik1_00]

I feel like Mat usually overestimates how intricate Fnaf’s story is going to be

[@mutantpanda278]

I loved the mental gymnastics that MatPat does at 9:00 trying to not directly say, "ah yes these characters.. are related.." *states skin color similarity last*

[@UilsdelgerMunkh-erdene]

Security guy at security breach:uhhh there is a guy named games theory? I don’t know he keep breaking in to find clues it is getting out of hand

[@StanleyG23]

15:40 Matt: "The new game that everyone's teasing is carnival themed... Jesters aren't the same as clowns. Carnivals are not circuses and circuses are not jesters." FNaF: Baby's design is based off of a court jester and yet she's officially called Circus Baby.

[@neadedios3106]

Matpat's "Jester vs Circus vs Carnival" rant reminds me why I love this channel so much

[@chrisbickel9023]

Matpat: THE NEXT FNAF GAME WON'T BE A CARNIVAL!!!!!!

[@retrogamerfoxxie]

I just remembered a quote that I think fits with Ruin: "Deep underground where memories sleep, anger is restless and secrets don't keep."

[@MarinaColdwater]

So I have an idea, Charlie inadvertently gave life to William when he was dying in fnaf 3 mini game. She is seen as this person who gave life to the kids and she, not realizing that William was the one dying, gave him the chance to live on in the suit like the kids she saved

[@TrueDxablo]

How about The Daycare Attendant being a creation of Henry instead of William? We saw Henry (or better said "Edwin Murray") being associated with the creation of the mimic. Due to The Daycare Attendant's design parallels to the Mimic, one could assume they were built by the same person. Also, creating an Animatronic that would serve the purpose of taking care of children is also something we know Henry did before (Marionette / Puppet). Why would William, who is known for.. well..- mudering children- build an Animatronic that, when working like intended (Eclipse) helps taking care of children and even protects them?

[@oomuhn8720]

@TrueDxablo I can back you up on this one. The revelation that the mimic is likely burntrap means that the security breach trailer, where burntrap says “when I first found you, you were nothing” can take on a totally different meaning. I think it is the mimic repeating things afton told it in the sister location Bunker. He says he found the mimic, not built. Therefore the suggestion that it is Henry’s creation is likely

[@777SilverPhoenix777]

@@oomuhn8720 I would hazard a guess that trailer has been retconned out of existence. Steel Wool obviously changed the entire story of SB before launch as shown by the lack of Vanny showing up. I would throw out all trailers as evidence. If is not in the final game it's not meant to be used as evidence.

[@beastgamer582]

I thought Mat Pat was gonna have a seizure figuring out the lore and still, he somehow made a game theory without dying.

[@ScarlettKatty]

Also the idea of Sun and Moon being the first ever characters and being theatre performers brings me such joy and pure happiness and also fits with their backstory a lil from The Bobbiedots story

[@puppetmaster1168]

The way my jaw dropped when he said “only for them to quickly get sayori’d out of the picture.”

[@erikwoodruff5643]

One thing I'm kind of surprised about is how quickly the Stitchwraith was dropped. Don't remember if it was solved then tossed aside but it's been a while since it was brought up.

[@alogarfen9]

At this point it seems like the sitchwraith was used to establish some rules in the fnaf lore: That multiple souls can inhabit the same animatronic, that remnant and agony are two different things and that baby is a manipulator and the big bad. However other than that it was just used to tie the fazbear frights stories together and have a big ending.

[@erikwoodruff5643]

@@alogarfen9 ah, thanks. I've watched all the lore videos but it's easy to forget stuff

[@metallistener340]

the story of the stitchwraith was resolved within the books

[@hodgrey]

8:42 WAIT! Not only do they have similar color design and skin tone, BUT the fact that Cassie puts the Vanny *mask* which is also a Bunny, is mind-blowing hahaha

[@__Soya__]

You F*ckin genius

[@chrisbickel9023]

@@__Soya__ Why is this comment so funny?

[@chrisbickel9023]

(Soya's comment)

[@RobbYarber]

I can just imagine Scott Cawthon watching these theory videos and laughing to himself over how wrong Matpat is. 😂

[@kevinponsrodz]

Well guess what he’s clearly wrong over everything

[@WigglyStuf]

Scott doesn’t work on fnaf anymore 😭

[@stryarflakpanzer6594]

​@@WigglyStufI'm pretty sure he still gets insider info about the game which is what they're referring to

[@jimena6194]

@@WigglyStufi think he does he’s just no longer the main creator, he just took a step back

[@chaoticoofhead9543]

@@jimena6194well im pretty sure after the movie all he will work on is the lore and books