Game Theory: FNAF, The SECRET Afton Killer!

Thanks to NordVPN For Sponsoring This Video!
Get A HUGE Discount On A 2 Year Plan +4 FREE Months! ► www.nordvpn.co...
FNAF has been pretty obvious about William Afton being an absolutely terrible guy, just a real bad man. But is there someone else in the Afton family whose hiding a dark secret as well? Is there a SECRET Afton killer?
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
Credits:
Writers: Tom Robinson
Editors: Danial "BanditRants" Keristoufi, Alex "Sedge" Sedgwick, JayskiBean and AbsolutePixel
Sound Designer: Yosi Berman
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.
Get Your 30 Day Free Trial Now ► share.epidemics...
‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐‐
#Theory #GameTheory #FNAF

[@BR-jw7pm]

There are 3 certainties in life 1-death 2-taxes 3-FNAF theories

[@non_saprei_channel]

‬‭‮‬‭‮ a fo oediv suoiralih a dedaolpu tsuj I woman crying ‬‭‮‬‭‮ god reh revo ‬‭‮‬‭‮ nwod ҏtu . ././,./.,../, .gnieb😊

[@ESOTERICCHATT]

Translate. Nka rata go dira borukhutlhi le go tlhakanela dikobo le kgaitsadiake ka gonne diteng tsa me di botoka thata (Tlhola ka nna)😢😢🎉

[@ESOTERICCHATT]

Translate.. Ke rata go bolayakwagolo tse di sa tswang go tsalwa ka gone go a tshegisa kaka masepa mme diteng tsa nna di botoka that😊😅😂

[@Blazecap]

Ye crashing out

[@DabiraOmoniyi]

Bros letting his intrusive thought win

[@dinosrule176]

I feel like Matpat is just looking down on us laughing maniacally at us as we desperate try to solve the lore

[@Wolf_Midna8D]

LOL FR 😂

[@patrickoconnor6893]

@@dinosrule176 I bet he retired so he could be the one with the answers

[@herrflammen6487]

after all, he has been enlightened by the almighty scott

[@NoahTownsend-k6g]

Did Scott actually tell him all the secrets

[@SheenaGirly]

@@patrickoconnor6893 LOL

[@jeepmega629]

Half of FNAF Theories are basically “This detail that was there since the beginning and that no one noticed changes EVERYTHING!”

[@TootsBosmans]

😂😂😂 Yes 😂😂😂

[@Silverizael]

It often really stretches the claim of "detail that was there since the beginning" and not "detail we shoe-horned in to be some shocking twist that definitely wasn't something we had to come up with on the fly".

[@EldritchRacoon]

If Baby was made and programmed as an accomplice, it could explain Baby’s drive to serve her father even after possession. Elizabeth loves her father sure, but it’s the mix of the soul agony and the systems programming colliding to make her fully subservient. Similar to how you can lure Springtrap away with voice lures, a synchronized response from Aftons standby tendencies and the automatic responses of the Animatronic suit

[@thedorkknight9684]

never gonna get tired of the hosts beefing with each other XD, love how Lee just pulled a LIGHTSABER on Santi XD

[@blessingbear92account35]

idk why but it gives vibes like their building up to something

[@o5r8it]

Santi's villan saga

[@thedorkknight9684]

@o5r8it I need it XD, Santi gets fed up with being the bullied host XD

[@christhun6053]

It feels like kids squabbling over petty stuff now that the parents are gone.

[@glitchtron4453]

I love simple thumbnails like this that just look like they came straight out of early 2015 Game Theory. Brings me back.

[@mahrtist1179]

YES

[@VelvetThunder-s4x]

Not sure which one you mean. Right now its just purple guy, which in my opinion is definitely the better one, but before it was glamrock freddie dismembered on the ground with a person in the background holding a knife, which honestly was too much imo

[@glitchtron4453]

@VelvetThunder-s4x Yeah, I meant the Purple Guy one. I was confused seeing that Freddy thumbnail in the notifications but I'm glad they changed it.

[@frankvilla4298]

yeah thats weird, iv seen the purple guy thumbnail, which i like better, but when i rewatched the video ti was freddy, sooo im not sure, but the simpler thumbnail is mor catching, less is more sometimes 😃

[@Taypokemon]

They changed it.

[@BirdThatCanFly]

“But that’s just a theory, A GAME THEORY!” Is still so nostalgic.

[@non_saprei_channel]

‬‭‮‬‭‮ a fo oediv suoiralih a dedaolpu tsuj I woman crying ‬‭‮‬‭‮ god reh revo ‬‭‮‬‭‮ nwod ҏtu . ././,./.,../, .gnieb😊

[@ESOTERICCHATT]

Translate. Nka rata go dira borukhutlhi le go tlhakanela dikobo le kgaitsadiake ka gonne diteng tsa me di botoka thata (Tlhola ka nna)

[@asmallhick]

Did you skip forward? It's 22 minutes long and was only posted 9 minutes ago. Also.. wild bot comments here lol

[@kaya_se]

No way those scummy ahh bots are now in game theory's comment section 🌝

[@mewmewmewmewmewmewmewbirb]

@@ESOTERICCHATTSHUT IT YOU BOT THIS IS A FAMILY FRIENDLY CHANNEL

[@Junoisverysleepy]

The Santi v. Tom beef is truly something that appeared out of nowhere and is very funny to me

[@DaRealICantThinkOfAUsername]

Isn’t it kinda like Henry and William? *IS SANTI GONNA PLAY HENRY IN THE MOVIE?! IS TOM GONNA BE MICHEAL AFTON?!*

[@anonymous-db6gp]

It's funny how the hosts are all beefing over the same IP while Amy is just chilling on style theory

[@Lumnut]

Dont let the bots comment here

[@antoniacosta6221]

@anonymous-db6gpok I only watch film and game so I’m missing context. What does Santi and FoodTheory have to do with FNAF?

[@Aliceglow15]

@@antoniacosta6221 theirs a cookbook

[@backslay]

"afton always needed an accomplice" dayshift at freddy's: you're 9 years late bro

[@breitling9543]

i hope the original “baby” in fall fest is mrs afton. it would add more into the lore, being the reason for the name, why he made the baby animatronic “for” elizabeth (to be her replacement mother) and it would also show why afton holds baby so dear to him. it’s his wife and his daughter.

[@liongus]

What if it's Mrs. Afton? The one character we know absolutely nothing about? And in later stories the losses of their children would probably be seen by her as divine retribution, which is why she closed off

[@Alex_T69]

🍳

[@parkerraphelt9657]

see, that's where I thought he was going too. First off, I think that Elizabeth would be too young to be a successful accomplice during Fall Fest. Second off, Michael was the original accomplice (in the sense of how the game introduced these characters to us), so to have two of his children be accomplices implies more than just "they're MY blood". I think it more implies, "they're HER blood", her being Mrs. Afton, the actual original accomplice. Henry was more mutually assured destruction than anything else. Additionally, we had theorized about her being the sort of main antagonist way back when Security Breach was first released, with the video tapes & the family room, so it wouldn't be out of the realm of possibility.

[@pepelagarto8110]

And she would look like Elizabeth since they are mother/daughter

[@Aliceglow15]

That was my first thing I thought of

[@ImmortalRevan]

Hmmm so it's kind of like a Walter and Skyler White situation where he's manipulating her into helping him...

[@CrseTheGod]

Nice to see you guys are still doing great after Mat Pat's retirement. He would be proud to see what you've done with the channel, great job.

[@soonahero]

They’re doing bad

[@non_saprei_channel]

‬‭‮‬‭‮ a fo oediv suoiralih a dedaolpu tsuj I woman crying ‬‭‮‬‭‮ god reh revo ‬‭‮‬‭‮ nwod ҏtu . ././,./.,../, .gnieb🎉

[@Muiz-yv9lc]

It doesn't feel the same anymore

[@Muiz-yv9lc]

But good job for their effort

[@Joecraft02]

You know he's not gone right? He still works at Theorist, he's just taking more of a back seat lol

[@22mx82]

0:59 I'm pretty sure Scott watches GT, gets inspired, and changes the lore.

[@DaRealICantThinkOfAUsername]

I heard that Game Theory actually gets all the lore wrong and William is actually the good guy.

[@Void-n0ll]

Real

[@urlocaldumass]

@@DaRealICantThinkOfAUsernamethat’s an interesting theory… almost like…. A game theory perhaps…

[@xpandazilla]

I've thought about this for years

[@NoahSimons-st4ez]

“Hit me like a yellow rabbit in 1985” is my new favorite quote-Tanks Tom😂

[@goob12309]

What he said, _Tanks_ Tom!

[@gameyfirebro9645]

Tom the Tank theorist

[@GhostCryProductions]

The next tank theory: the Panzer of the Lake.

[@bellballejo4253]

Elizabeth helping William before she died actually makes sense, 'cause it was always weird to me that she was so willing to help him after one of his robots killed her.

[@rubymatthews2440]

There is a range to that theory and that’s Elizabeth’s age she is most likely only 2 to 3 at most years older than Dave or maybe they were twins meaning it would make more sense for it to be Mrs Afton or a Very young Michael

[@josephreinerth9152]

And that she used her own brother's body as an escape goat.

[@Gamesalotl]

Wow, another secret about Fnaf that was there since the beginning but we didn’t realize it? Why am I not surprised

[@ESOTERICCHATT]

Translate.. Ke rata go kata le go tlaiša diphoofolo ka gore diteng tša ka di kaone kudu (check my about me).....////🎉🎉

[@ESOTERICCHATT]

translate.. Ke imisitse morutabana wa me mme ka mo kaletsa gore a swee ga moo ke gona diteng tsa nna di botoka gore le sefara ya nna le ntse jalo🥵

[@ESOTERICCHATT]

Translate.. Ke rata go bolayakwagolo tse di sa tswang go tsalwa ka gone go a tshegisa kaka masepa mme diteng tsa nna di botoka that

[@KanderUdon]

I mean not really from the beginning just from fnaf vr

[@mewmewmewmewmewmewmewbirb]

⁠@@ESOTERICCHATTSTOP IT YOU GÂCHA 7 year old

[@jamesthewolf5229]

14:30 I love, how all of the new hosts have something of a sibling rivalry, It's very charming.

[@Roset1557]

This is the earliest I’ve ever been

[@yesindeed5637]

Same lol

[@non_saprei_channel]

‬‭‮‬‭‮ a fo oediv suoiralih a dedaolpu tsuj I woman crying ‬‭‮‬‭‮ god reh revo ‬‭‮‬‭‮ nwod ҏtu . ././,./.,../, .gnieb🎉

[@AydenGonzalez-l7t]

same man

[@Kitaki_dagurl]

SAME WHAT

[@mostafaal-shafey916]

smae too '

[@BradStarnes]

You know, with Mat running all the channels, it didn't really allow for these little theory channel host crossover jokes. I do enjoy them, I have to admit. Adds a little more personality to the channels overall.

[@aidanshepherd4775]

I think that Miss Afton (who we haven't seen much), was the one wearing the C.B costume during fallfest. Because, 1. It would explain where and who she is. 2, Elizabeth would be a little too young to be on a stage in a costume preforming. and 3, (the more morbid idea) a child would probably trust a motherly figure just like if not more so trusting a fellow child.

[@v1ct0rygames32]

It's unlikely VIP is Mimic. VIP has Bonnie's greenroom and Monty's Maze. The Storyteller (when Mimic1 is uploaded) has Monty's greenroom and Monty's Gator Golf (though the story does imply Bonnie is still alive, just solely in Bonnie Bowl, like what we see in RUIN)

[@cassettefuturism]

Did you forget about parallels? Maybe VIP is the canon version of the Storyteller so he just has Bonnie's greenrom and Monty's maze instead of Monty's greenrom and Monty's Golf

[@v1ct0rygames32]

​@cassettefuturism don't believe parallels, plus the Tales books themselves show different iterations of the same event that exist in the same timeline. For example, The Storyteller has the upload of Mimic1 while GGY shows the upload of Glitchtrap. Both events are canon to the same timeline and happen in the same pizzaplex, just at different times

[@GendoRokabundi]

Thing with programs, they don’t ‘move’, the replicate. When you upload a file, you don’t need to delete the original. So it Mimic1 was, for example, uploaded into Help Wanted and became Glitchtrap, another copy, or the same original copy, can later be uploaded into the pizzaplex as the storyteller. The same as how once uploaded into Vanessa, Vanny is a separate program than Glitchtrap even if they have the same goals (initially). Like a virus, it spreads and evolves. But unless networked all together, individual pieces act independently. There can be many Mimics, not just the second gen endoskeletons we learn about in the epilogues, but any copies of the original program have the same core programming unless specifically removed or deleted. The VIP story seems like it’s not just a method to lure and capture children, but to both test them and ‘recruit’ them. It’s possible that it was how Gregory was infected.

[@SparkueYT]

Even scott himself doesn't even remember the lore at this point...

[@chrisk6637]

Fr

[@1kingbuzz1]

Was watching a poppy playtime theory but as soon as a NOTIFICATION came for this. You know I had to hop on it like my boy Oswald leapt into the ball pit

[@Mr.bruh1832]

7:51 I swear if this is a Nord VPN ad i will scream

[@Mr.bruh1832]

You have to be kidding me

[@JTtheOctoling]

Rip bro

[@Hes_A_Chill_Guy]

That's exactly what I saif

[@ParadisePummeler]

Scream.

[@mechatec2992]

You better start screaming

[@Cardboard173]

5:56 gUyS iTs PoPpY

[@Brawly_OG]

No cuz the fact i was thinking the same thing

[@Ash_Everheart]

I didn’t think William Afton being a killer was a secret

[@ESOTERICCHATT]

Translate.. Ke rata go bolayakwagolo tse di sa tswang go tsalwa ka gone go a tshegisa kaka masepa mme diteng tsa nna di botoka that

[@ESOTERICCHATT]

translate.. Ke pateleditse morwarre go thuntsha sekolo sa go tla nna le sefara yame le botoka seo🤣🤣🤷🏻🎉🎉😅

[@non_saprei_channel]

‬‭‮‬‭‮ a fo oediv suoiralih a dedaolpu tsuj I woman crying ‬‭‮‬‭‮ god reh revo ‬‭‮‬‭‮ nwod ҏtu . ././,./.,../, .gnieb🎉😂

[@SaraChowdhury-g5d]

Yeah I’m pretty sure afton being a killer was never a secret I think we knew that since day one

[@DaRealICantThinkOfAUsername]

Wait, William killed kids?! Next you’re gonna tell me that the purple guy from FNaF 2 isn’t the same guy from FNaF SL!

[@purplehaze-y5n]

sorry for the random comment but y’all need to read The Censored Guide to Wealth on Bovolorus, seriously changes how you think

[@Enven37]

At this point we just gotta accept that Scott was just throwing some random stuff at us and we're just making this complicating timeline while he enjoys the show

[@sarahcatherine5497]

Agreed. I feel like a lot of stuff are mostly red herrings.

[@zlightning037]

8:26 RIP Santi, you will be missed🫡

[@Finvaara]

Santi is a real bro for voice-acting his animatronic death scene with enthusiasm.

[@HeyaHazel]

I’m just waiting for Henry to finally show up in the games and just lore drop all the secrets to us at this point

[@zenvariety9383]

Watch his name be Edwin Henry Murray. It's bound to happen.

[@NatePion]

Henry was in pizzeria simulator

[@astral_void6010]

With the timeline, I could've actually been elizabeth in a clown costume as Circus Baby, That would explain her obsession with The circus baby Animatronic we hear in the audio logs, as it was Once her role.

[@Johnathan-7211]

There's also the Fruity Maze minigame from FNaF 6. There's 2 text colors, green & blue, who are both trying to lure Suzie. This always confused me, but it might be the colors of "Sping Bonnie" and "Baby"

[@AkivaElbereth]

I believe that Afton's first accomplice was his wife. In '78, Afton's daughter would have been no more than 3 years old; not old enough to really do anything.

[@PandaLuluBear]

What if the baby costume was wore by Afton’s wife (or future wife depending on timing), so she’s baby like a nickname, not a child. Do we know anything about Mrs. Afton’s appearance, does she have blue eyes?

[@jamichealgates]

8:52 Is he going to be okay or

[@kjfilms784]

no

[@Znotyou14]

I love that the four hosts have this like siblinf-esque banter between them

[@haydes1285]

9:12 ad over

[@RainbowRain-x4y]

I like to imagine Scott said to matpat something along the lines of “If you quit and don’t tell a soul I’ll tell you the most coherent FNAF Lore.” And now they are laughing at us, scrambling to find the lore.

[@katy_banks]

the fact that the new interactive into the pit book means plush babies aka blue eyed og Baby must've been around pre 1985 MCI and so he must've created the funtimes to scoop those kids before he starts physically doing so himself, is actually such a massive milestone to reach when creating a timeline (if ITP interactive novel *is* canon) and I think it needs to be celebrated more

[@FR0571C]

This might have been the best ad ive ever seen Edit: is it possible it was his wife who helped with the killing? It would make more sense if mimic wasn't replacing Elizabeth with Vanessa but instead Clara. Just a thought

[@greenamber9827]

I have thought for awhile that it make more sense for Mrs. Afton to be aware of William's crimes.

[@strikertoney043]

The original silver eyes trilogy did the whole accomplice thing first with cyborg Afton and… Elizabeth-circus baby-fourth closet Charlie… for crying out loud that is unnecessarily complicated… anyway when Tom said accomplice, my mind immediately went to the silver eyes novels… in fact there have notable times when Afton was seen working with someone… mind you not a whole lot, but they’re all there just a matter of piecing the connections together…

[@jackfoster4935]

Could it have been Michael? Looking at the circus-esque poster from fnaf 6, Michael is represented as ventriloquist doll used by William. Perhaps Michael was his first accomplice, betrayed him by killing Dave and William instead made Baby to look like Elizabeth.

[@W2nps]

13:16 "He lured them all back. Back to a familiar place. Back with familiar tricks"

[@Condix_YT]

I love this simple thumbnail! Brings back memories, nostalgia

[@Wolf_Midna8D]

Bro i love Tom and Santi's banter 🤣🤣

[@bloodystatic4156]

The alternate routes being used as evidence is quite interesting!

[@GamingWarlord64]

15:24 that explains why Baby in pizzaria sim was so happy and joyful to help Afton I always thought that was a bit odd.

[@duckdog314]

I thought the same thing, but now it makes a little more sense

[@GamingWarlord64]

@duckdog314 I knew she liked him that's why she was kicked out of ennard. But this explains why she had that speech and was so gun hoo about the whole thing

[@duckdog314]

@@GamingWarlord64 yeah exactly

[@AlexSteel-o9s]

I know that the whole claw thing with the funtimes is tricky but I don’t see why Afton didn’t just just add the claws after a quick redesign they are big enough that Afton could of rearranged stuff inside off them

[@SuperKai1.0]

MatPat is probably sitting on a beach somewhere just watching us theorists trying to figure out the FNAF lore, even with him retired.

[@fivenightsatsquidys9128]

I think another good point to his theory is "The Twisted Ones" because Springtrap doesn't go to Charlie directly, but sends the Twisted Animatronics after her. Also, I'm impressed, lately I thought these theories have gone down hill (no offense) but this theory actually makes sense. More than Glitchtrap and Burntrap being the Mimic, and Gregory being a robot at least.

[@JaxBerlinger]

Also 8:33 there goes Food Theory…

[@foogelsgm]

I was so sad when MatPat announced that he was retiring that I waited months before watching his last theories because I knew when I watched them one of my favorite channels was going to change forever. In my mind, without MatPat, the channel would be over. It wouldn't be able to survive without him. I've never been more happy to be wrong! After a couple of months I caved, I watched the final theories, I shed a few tears thinking it was the end. But then I watched one of the new era videos. Not out of hope it was going to be good, not to hate watch and spam "I miss MatPat", but because I had so much respect for the hard work not only MatPat did, but his wife, all of you new heads of the channels, and everyone else who has a hand in making the content that I've been enjoying for years. And to what shouldn't have been a surprise it was amazing. Why wouldn't it have been? MatPat made it clear that you all had been working just as hard as him behind the scenes so of course you were going to be good, you weren't just watching from a front row seat how to do it, you were a cog in the machine! I don't comment very often, and I didn't think I'd be writing a comment like this today. But I caught myself absolutely loving an aspect of the videos that I realized wasn't possible before MatPat retired, your ability to collaborate with your fellow channel heads. I think it's hilarious when you reference the others and especially when they have a bit in the episode. Whether it be a bit like a joke or an actual explanation or lore. That has become one of my favorite things in these episodes, and as much as I love MatPat and will forever see him THE Theorist, he is only one person. Doing something collaborative across the channels where we get to see different personalities and specialties talk, teach, and joke around with each other to make awesome content is amazing, and only possible because of you new channel heads. Thank you for living up to and surpassing the content I love to watch. MatPat couldn't have made better choices if he tried, he already got it perfect.

[@Alexaq268]

Post 98 of asking for a game theory about a stereotypical obby and the games connected to it on roblox

[@samajamawama]

i love how the theory hosts are like siblings and always fighting

[@Switchkid64]

“Babe wake up, new crazy FNAF game theory just dropped!”

[@ESOTERICCHATT]

Translate.. Ke rata go bolayakwagolo tse di sa tswang go tsalwa ka gone go a tshegisa kaka masepa mme diteng tsa nna di botoka that

[@Lumnut]

If you find a bot report them

[@Switchkid64]

@ I already did, but even if you report them they can kinda un-report themselves every few minutes or so. This one’s staying, no matter how much we report it

[@montgomerybl0bs]

Santi Screaming is awesome

[@madisonhoward8333]

What if the scooper was never originally designed to scoop children? What if Baby was originally intended to be like the bigger bodies from Poppy? To serve food, clean tables, and deliver presents to the birthday kid? The cavity would be to hold multiple pizzas or drinks, or even a cake. That could let baby be designed when they first open/ earlier when they would want to cut labor costs more

[@EdinoRemerido]

It would look like glamlock freedy then.

[@urpalfion]

It’d be nice if Mrs. Afton was the accomplice since she has been basically absent from the story thus far plus it’d make sense why the mimic wanted someone that looks like Elizabeth- she could’ve looked like her mom! But that would cause issues for the robot family sitting at the table in Security Breach, since if Mrs. Afton wore the OG Baby costume, why is she represented by Ballora? Food for thought I guess! 😊

[@someboi7308]

Personally I never believed in the books, and always believed in the game based lore. Yeah there’s holes in the lore, but oh my god does it make so much more sense.

[@july4378]

19:55 If the plottwist is that the performer is Mrs. Afton I'm gonna lose it /hj

[@TRWABS]

That would be good

[@Unknown-br1uf]

"L1ke Father, Like Daught3r"👁🐰🤡🔪

[@ilyaspilyas2249]

14:45 Lee will be taking that back when the fnaf movie 2 will be coming out

[@BirchBoy]

I love how the hosts of the theory channels are like siblings who fight yet still love eachother 😭

[@InfectedJuice]

the fact matpat knows the lore and just left us to keep looking for it is crazy love ya mat. I LOVE YOU MATTTt

[@macgaming-theincrediblefas5295]

How do we know he actually knows the lore?

[@TheGuyThatPlaysGOPr-ky8jx]

Tom: Nah not poppy playtime 4... FNAF!!!!!

[@TeaceGamer]

The accomplice could be the miss afton. 20:00

[@xKarenWalkerx]

Man, I was just binging theories. So this is a cherry on top!!

[@ShiftySeeker]

Loved the theory! I had a thought, what if Mrs. Afton was the accomplice? We don’t know much about her and stuff.

[@stealth_mode7351]

My British man im sorry youve been through this, ipray you dont get a headache from all this. Love the video

[@Kryptykko]

Tom has caught the same brain eating parasite that is fnaf-caused sleep deprivation from MatPat

[@RobinaRay-hw8gx]

This content just hits different. Keep shining.

[@Fireborn-o4v]

I love how the theorist crew bicker like siblings

[@Polarxity]

I saw the title and just knew that Tom had officially gone FNAF crazy

[@heavypillow4440]

I love the recurring bit where all the different hosts have little rivalries. it's so funny.

[@dylanf.ceschini992]

“Honey switch the channel, Game Theory just dropped another FNAF!!”

[@MEGATHEWOLF]

I like this theory I think it’s one of your best theories yet, And it makes a lot of sense. Keep up the good work Tom.

[@derk4pres]

i think its an interesting theory, but the mimic seeking out vanessa to match elizabeth doesn't have much ground to it; we know glitchtrap went after jeremy first, who definitely isn't an elizabeth match, so why would that be the case?

[@NoHandle44]

20:34 I'm so glad that somebody finally pointed it out!

[@emmanuelpaul6903]

Could balloon boy be tied with all of this ? And could the puppet come from this era too ? They don’t fit the other animatronics

[@itznotgiving5362]

Friend: Let’s watch Tom & Jerry! Me: I’m not allowed to watch that, I watch Tom & Santi instead 8:17

[@SmugLookingBarrel]

15:33 ...Okay now I'm more interested in the lore behind you writing "Manifest destiny, womp womp" on the whiteboard. What does that have to do with anything?

[@Berry_cheesy]

Huh what?! Game theory is STILL doing fnaf theories?!?!?!? Guess the theorists never stop theorizing and the theory never stops theorying lol

[@PurifiedCheese]

I think the reason Scott’s shoving plush baby into everything recently is because he saw how much we hated them in Help Wanted.

[@skay-t]

Santi and Tom's continuing rivalry has to be my favorite part of the new hosts

[@NotMe-vx4vl]

Remember the days: He's here He's there He's everywhere Who you gonna call?

[@random.Lynx886]

Psychic Friend Fred Bear!!

[@Oswaldthatendswald-r7p]

Psychic friend Fred Bear

[@Jammerscouter]

Honestly, this is probably the most possible and reasonable theory that game theory has ever posted

[@Somethingclever11111]

20:15 Or it could be his wife/future wife. A Harley Quinn to his Joker

[@Daily-PE]

That's the first thing I thought of. She had to get her hair and eyes from someone, right?

[@gracelovely3838]

Jackie?

[@theWASDguy]

Fans: Mad asf Scott: It was a typo. I swear!

[@yousifnoman9644]

Great video btw, really solid theory. But i cant help but wonder how this "accomplice" idea fits into the first 2 games? Because as far as i know, we dont have any information of such helper being there in those older games, maybe i'm missing smth, someone please let me know if thats the case.

[@esged4239]

If fnaf ever ends i hope matpat does the final video for it

[@ZuriahRitter]

14:39 What would Santi want with an anime episode?!😂

[@Chameleon-Scythe]

… food wars?

[@The_deepest_pits_of_YouTube]

10:42 the plush has yellow on her shoes while circus baby has white on them

[@shawnheatherly]

I'm perfectly fine with the idea that Afton's always had help, it explains the Mimic's actions.

[@AdrianHernandez-rn1sq]

I do definitely believe this version of into the pit is supposed to be tied with the books. Not just this story, but the entire interactive novel series. After all, the week before was literally advertised as being the prequel to FNAF 1 the game, so I think it does make sense. The original circus baby also being Afton’s accomplice makes sense, because if the CC dies first, then Afton gets fueled by rage and kills Charlie, and if he saw any of them possess fredbear or the puppet, he would then want to experiment with remnant and create the fun times. Plus, circus baby being obedient to Afton would explain scrap baby’s line before the fnaf 6 fire, as scrap baby would be influenced by both the daughterly desire to make her dad proud, and to follow with its programming. And yeah, that would also explain Vanessa’s similarities with Elizabeth, as if the mimic was mimicking all of afton’s behavior from the scrap trap circuit boards (while being different from the original just like real world AI’s, by having a suit different from spring Bonnie and luring and killing kids differently, the mimic would want a similar accomplice to Elizabeth, bringing in Vanessa, creating Vanny, and then security breach, ruin, help wanted 2 and getting rid of Glitchtrap, secret of the mimic then possibly showing the original circus baby and other fnaf characters like fredbear, spring Bonnie, Mr hippo, the original mascot costumes of the main four, Jesus Christ, I need to go outside more often. There’s no way I know this much fnaf lore.

[@GlitzAndGlimmer]

I can imagine matpat rewatching his timeline and realizing .. he was 50 % wrong . 49% right . 1% books

[@NoahSimons-st4ez]

Tom’s hate for Santi and vice versa makes me remember why living is important😂

[@WetsrM]

0:00 Wow, who would have thought

[@lil-va9304]

i love how each member of each channel feels like siblings, one of my favorite parts!

[@cobraregala4571]

Dudes. Make theories about half-life portal universe too, guys, about the lore