TLOU 2 vs RDR 2 - Physics and Details Comparison

In this video I show a full comparison of Physics, Details The Last of Us Part II vs Red Dead Redemption 2 Video completely filmed and edited by me (GameBest) I show which of the game is better
Timings:
0:00 - Snow Deformation
0:45 - Water Physics
1:17 - Riding a Horse
2:00 - Glass Physics
2:58 - Fire Propagation
3:55 - Snow Physics on Tree
4:24 - Archery (Arrow Physics)
5:27 - Swimming
6:25 - Character Reaction to Cold
6:41 - Boating (Boat Details)
7:30 - Petting the Dog
7:58 - Riding on thin Ice
Rdr2 vs Tlou2
The Last of Us 2 vs Red Dead Redemption 2
#thelastofuspart2 #reddeadredemtion2 #rdr2

[@TranquilAura77]

2 of the most graphically advanced games Ive ever played no questions. From the physics to the visuals to the animations, they are both near flawless in every aspect

[@K1tsu84]

@@swan-oq8qk 💀

[@swan-oq8qk]

@K1tsu Yeah, indeed, death to a corrupt gaming company, go woke go broke, simple

[@K1tsu84]

@@swan-oq8qk ... No one go broke because they "are woke", conservatives are a loud minority

[@diamondrush4446]

@@swan-oq8qkwhat was so woke about it, i’ve only played the first

[@drunkenmasterii3250]

@@diamondrush4446 character is gay, I suppose that's what some idiot call woke

[@youtubehodol3989]

RDR2 with horse ball physics 🗿

[@dedsecgenius9316]

Only reason I bought the game

[@Jonin_Kazumi]

@@dedsecgenius9316 ayo??

[@demontan4535]

@@Jonin_Kazumi ain’t wrong

[@brenzilla_1003]

@@Jonin_KazumiTranslate your reply to english and you’ll see random words😂

[@MahmutTersak]

@@brenzilla_1003man KZbin is wildin

[@runnerhigh]

Last of Us II not having the boat sinking detail only makes sense though. If you were to sink them you’d be blocked from progressing any further in the story. A neat detail that only works in an open world game like Red Dead 2

[@officerjohns9554]

Yeah, last of us 2 is a pretty linear game compared to rdr2

[@the-insomniac323]

thats the point@@officerjohns9554 but in terms of beauty both games nail it down, the story for both is compelling and emotional and while i can see an open world TLOU game working really well, the linearity of the two games we already got fits the formula and gameplay well.

[@alvarowab1274]

Nah you should sink, die and restart from last check point, they just didn't think about that

[@gobbysopps4224]

That's just stupid 💀why spend time on something pointless@@alvarowab1274

[@sadettinturgut9180]

​@@alvarowab1274kusuruma bakma İngilizcem o kadar gelişmiş değil o yüzden türkçe yazıyorum Eğer tlou gemi batsaydı düşman yanlışlıkla veya isteyerek direk gemiye sıkardı

[@peachycamie1013]

I think the fact that TLOU2 is a linear, story based game whereas RDR2 is open world definitely plays a factor. For example, you can’t sink Ellie’s boat in The Flooded City chapter because its 100% necessary to get through it and the game knows that, however, in RDR2, boats aren’t really necessary to the functionality of the game unless you’re a big fisherman or something. Same thing with horses, the horse mechanics in RDR2 are going to be 10x better because the game relies on them for transportation throughout the whole narrative, in TLOU2, horses are only present throughout the first 2 hours of the game, they’re not the main mode of transport, walking is. I think I’m trying to say that comparing these two games is very difficult just because they’re two different types of games with insanely different stories, and how the characters/environments behave is going to be dependent on that story. Great video nonetheless, however.

[@guilhermebahia6050]

You can say that about the story too though. TLOU2 is a linear game with focus on the storytelling and even that RDR2 does better even though is an open world game with a lot of other things in it.

[@auroragranger79]

thanks. someone with a brain

[@auroragranger79]

@@guilhermebahia6050 excuse me, how does rdr2 do better?

[@liquid1514]

@@auroragranger79 in story obviously, don't tell me you actually think tlou2's story is better

[@auroragranger79]

@@liquid1514 I still have to finish rdr2 story, last 2 chapters but until now I still prefer tlou. call it a question of heart idk... but this doesn't mean I'm saying tlou is better. I agree on what the main comment said. It's too difficult comparing them, even the story, it's all about personal journey.

[@jacobterpstra7490]

I think overall RDR2 wins. BUT the combat mechanics of TLOU2 is hands down my favorite to date. Brutally fun.

[@IgorBozoki1989]

3 things are good in tlou2 graphics, gameplay and sound/music. Story is mediocre at best.

[@natan7487]

@@IgorBozoki1989Crazy.

[@pirazhar9760]

@@IgorBozoki1989 not graphics

[@Aclipso]

@@pirazhar9760 the graphics aren't good well since, rdr2 has similar enough graphics for a comparison I guess rdr2's graphics aren't good either

[@wackosaco7369]

@@IgorBozoki1989 Absolute clown take.

[@ghfdt368]

I think what RDR2 did was give us the peak of that generation of gaming in terms of graphics, attention to even the smallest details and a mastercrafted story. I've played RDR2 for over 300 hours and im still finding things or seeing things i didnt even notice the first few playthroughs on story mode. For example in the town of Annesburg it can actually hail there when it rains and if you change your main characters hat members of your gang comment on it, you can do out of left field things to finish a task in a mission and you get completely different dialog and there literally thousands of easter eggs, tiny injokes and references all over the place you don't notice first time round. RDR2 is truly a masterpiece.

[@Pebieditor]

That's what I'm talking about bro Just what do you mean by out of field tasks in mission for dialogue???

[@ghfdt368]

@@Pebieditor what I mean is that you can approach ways of playing missions differently or you get hidden dialog or cutscenes that you didnt know existed. Great examples are when you have to get mary's brother from the chelonians if you shoot one of them they all jump off the edge and its a level failure, and there is a mission where bounty hunters capture trewlany and there are 2 guys at a campsite to start it off and you can actually shoot one of them and the cut scene and dialog is slightly different. There are lots of things like that you just dont see or realise first 2-3 playthrough's in the story mode.

[@Pebieditor]

@@ghfdt368 exactly I've played the game more than 600 hours and I'm still finding new things in the game For example one of the details that i'vs recently discovered is in the last mission of guarma when Arthur and micah blow up cannons in the cutscene if you blow it up earlier you won't get into cutscene and that's just wonderful I mean there are lots of ways and hidden ways to do the missions almost every mission

[@aidenmcgonigle2498]

​@@ghfdt368 it's pretty obvious as it's a gold requirement but even shooting Sean's rope is a decent example

[@ren12275]

I believe on you but 1000 easter eggs is a big lie developers won’t even give that atention but the atoey and details of the game was phenomenal

[@simonegranato7023]

The thing I've always loved about RDRII is the muscle contracture of horses

[@dabearcub]

Cough * you gey brah * cough

[@user-hp5sr2xs2d]

Yes me too and how the blood vessels are visible depending on how the horses neck moves, it's so satisfying to watch

[@t_rimor]

especially the cremaster muscle

[@ArchangelExile]

​@@t_rimor😏

[@abhijeetverma6795]

To be honest TLOU2 is a good game with amazing graphics and story but the fact that it’s a linear story game and RDR2 is a massive open world masterpiece with stunning graphics, engaging random events and story. RDR2 is a winner

[@TitankroW]

Red dead redemption 2 story is linear too it just takes place in an open world

[@juacomprar_]

@@TitankroW exacto, tiene más mérito ya que todos los detalles pasan en todo el enorme mundo

[@joppekim]

​@@TitankroWTrue, without the missions you can really feel the emptyness of the world in RDR2

[@abhijeetverma6795]

@@TitankroW True, But apart from the story, I prefer exploring the open world and admiring all the amazing details that both Rockstar and Naughty Dog put into their respective games. Overall, Rockstar has more detailing than The Last of Us due to the huge size of the map, and we can't forget the fact that RDR2 was released earlier than TLOU2.

[@ShadowAngel06]

​@@joppekimmaby you payt no attention to the sorroundings. The world of red dead redemption2 is full of live

[@Emerald-X]

Rdr2 wins hands down

[@thesliedrecht]

Like always 🙂

[@markozmunoz4126]

Na es más realista the last of us

[@SpiderCruncher]

I just love this game 😂

[@toofoo8708]

​@@markozmunoz4126Mas realista? Zombies dont exist while Cowboys do 😂 stupid

[@taadeo1995]

@@markozmunoz4126😂😂😂😂😂😂😂 que buen chiste

[@MrKasugano]

Also Archery on 4:25 - In RDR2 the type of arrows are determine penetration force. Standard stays like in TLOU2 while improved are striking thru objects.

[@RetroRift.]

True

[@Skiff780]

in Tlou 2, the arrows just break, and this indicates a great tension force of the bow

[@KnowToChill]

​@@Skiff780The Last of us is also based more on Survival Mechanics...getting infinity Arrows and Bullets would be feel more like ...StarField GamePlay ?😂Im a Astronaut but can wear More Guns in my JetPack then Rambo used in 3 Movies ! 😂😂😂

[@user-uv2rh6pt3v]

Sooo...That is what happens in every Bethesda game (If you've even played one)As well as holding an ungodly amount of things being an RPG staple, you can get ecunmbred, but you've prolly never played starfield@@KnowToChill

[@ncshuriken]

@@Skiff780 "The world is already like Mad Max and all I have are these bargain priced 'made in China' arrows that keep bending & breaking!! It even says 'Pro Quality' on the box..."

[@Mihael_2010]

I really love your videos,respect+

[@norvinzor]

These are the Only two games that are worth paying 60$. If it was 70$ I wouldn’t even be mad

[@JackWithaCrown]

Yeah

[@dcsuperzam]

Well games have been $70 for 3 years now.

[@nirogalactoid8398]

Only read dead I would consider buying at that kind of price or even more. TLOU isn’t my kind of game.

[@ihabda105]

I got tlou2 for 20 Bucks 😎

[@DotyFuzz]

There are a lot of games as good as these two 🤦

[@Josh-mm7qt]

Both are great games, but RDR2 is a masterpiece in my opinion. Beautifully done game that feels fleshed out in all aspects. Haven't played TLOU2 but I've heard that the game is great too.

[@pursharthbawa6881]

How are you so lucky

[@vegetasticknodes27]

bruh ur that lonely kid HAHAHA

[@pursharthbawa6881]

What? I didn't get ya

[@vegetasticknodes27]

@@pursharthbawa6881 not u im talking about josh

[@pursharthbawa6881]

@@vegetasticknodes27 ok sorry bro

[@HiThereFaceHere]

I really don't think RDR2 can ever be topped. The part where you were shooting the guns in the water near the beginning, really shows just how far ahead it is of every other game

[@YapperClips]

I am not a huge Fortnite fan but from what I’ve played it has the same if not better water physics

[@HiThereFaceHere]

@da bean the physics are awesome, but I'm also meaning things like the lighting and reflecting and the look of the water and rocks underneath and the world around

[@AlbaniaIsTheBestFacts]

Let’s see how gta six turns out

[@ILoveFishinginWi]

@@AlbaniaIsTheBestFacts it looks good aside the fact we have to play as a woman

[@huzairusakoir4853]

@@ILoveFishinginWibeing a woman hater is crazy 😭

[@raffyc66]

The mere fact that RDR2 is two whole years older…and this is still a fair comparison, says it all.

[@Topper_Harley68]

A game is not better because it is newer, and 2 years is nothing unless you are 5 years old.

[@vita7456]

Two years is not long enough for any significant technology developments

[@something_pylo2629]

facts

[@RetroRift.]

Yes but still 2 years isnt a very long time unlike GTA 5 which has been 8 years

[@JohnWick-ti8rk]

you are saying ridiculous things for 2 years it has nothing to do better look at the budget the last of us 250 million and RDR2 600 million

[@mujthabahassan7614]

8:00 Treading on some mighty thin ice there

[@diegomaneiro1507]

Good reference.

[@tlf.1339]

this is the content i subscribed this channel for, pls more of these vids!

[@Glori4n]

RDR2 > The world.

[@ElGitanoPeligro]

RDR2 >>> existence itself

[@zazazu2218]

Your mom>>>>🥰🥰🥰

[@Glori4n]

@@zazazu2218 lol

[@Scarlet_Officer]

@@zazazu2218Aaaand ofc lol

[@obediahhinton1890]

As a Naughty Dog fan I got to say that RDR 2 is just a monster of the games. Hands down this is the best game ever.

[@zuher3180]

You are a g you speaking truth .

[@zaydzahir96]

Facts.

[@dabearcub]

Play more games.

[@3to4characters]

​@@dabearcubtell me what your favourite is

[@darkness1978]

@@3to4charactersSekiro

[@shubham_M7777]

Best ch. For comparison videos. Please make video on gta 4 Vs mafia 2 Vs SD vs WD

[@joppekim]

I wish i had the last of us movement in RDR2. Considering the controls are a bit difficult in RDR2. It would play amazingly!

[@tksavage55]

Rdr2 is a masterpiece

[@KALESSIN3]

No, its boring

[@Fortunateenough1995]

@@KALESSIN3 No one cares fanboy

[@KALESSIN3]

@@Fortunateenough1995 yes, super boring like you queer

[@aslan_grozny3667]

boring

[@hrvatdogroba9588]

@@KALESSIN3 bro got that lesbian on his pfp 🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@luisg2978]

I love both of these games but it’s weird comparing them in my opinion because one, last of us 2 is a linear game that is very focused on the story while the detailing is suppose immerse you in the story while Red dead is an open world game that focuses on the detailing more to show the players that there is more in the world around them than just the story that’s taking place. Props to both naughty dog and rockstar for blessing us players with both of these beautiful games and showing us gamers that they are focus on satisfaction which is rare in the gaming world today.

[@NeptuneSega]

You can compare graphics from any game of a similar style. These two are using a realistic approach so it's valid

[@auroragranger79]

thanks.

[@Ryukb213]

@@NeptuneSegayou can compare but there is context on why both of the graphics are that way. its like u compare the combat mechanics of both tlou 2 and rdr 2. rdr 2 WAS focused on the environment while tlou 2 was focused on the story thats all

[@Smile_Flint]

Red dead is an open world game? try to get around the enemy during a firefight and you will be thrown back🙃

[@Ryukb213]

@@Smile_Flint it is a open world game dear 🤣 it may not allow you to do certain things when ur on a mission, but when your done with them you’re pretty much free

[@monkeydluffy6134]

2 masterpieces in one Video.

[@gadrycathadson1285]

This is so unfair, that both of this games are developed buy a high experienced team in 7 years and they only get regular full price, while some publishers like ubisoft just release their games yearly with copying and pasting most of assets from previous games, demanding increased full price, intergrading microtransactions in the singleplayer game and making another lame revenge story, while R* make a story in which we care about our character dying and Naughty dog making very controversial story, where the very hated by players character becomes the one, which they like the same as Ellie or even more and we get to see these 3 days in Seattle from different angle. Those are not AAA games, those are AAA+ games or even AAAA. And if any game deserves 100$ price, it's them

[@THE_VISION_OF_RAJA_BHARAT]

Mayn thats wind physics was totally banger in lou 2

[@chciwymecenas]

thats the most interesting comparrison ive ever seen

[@eswayyyy]

rdr2 is the game of the decade

[@carlin2235]

Nop, TLOU2 is

[@dcsuperzam]

@@carlin2235TLOU 2 isn’t even full open world and has worse physics than RDR2. You can also interact with every single npcs In rdr2, you can explore every single building, you can go to bars and get drunk, you can smoke, eat, sleep, the horses poop, there’s an honor system, npcs react to what you wear and if you’re dirty or not, women hit on you based on your appearance, civilization advances over time, building get made, every single npc has a busy life with a schedule, you can hunt, you can puke and food is spoiled, etc. I can write an entire book on how much better and well thought out red dead 2 is compared to TLOU. Not to mention rdr2 took 8 years to make with almost double the employees working overtime. That shows how much effort they put into the game. Every apsect possible puts rdr2 on top.

[@carlin2235]

@@dcsuperzam Yes like every fallout game, TLOU have better gameplay and lore.

[@dcsuperzam]

@@carlin2235 not even close 🤣

[@carlin2235]

@@dcsuperzam you don't know anything

[@jtrillz3953]

Objectively going one by one picking which is better 👍🏽 Snow Deformation: RDR2 Water Physics: RDR2 Riding a Horse: RDR2 Glass Physics: TLOU2 Fire Propagation: RDR2 Snow Physics on Tree: TLOU2 Arrow Physics: Tie Swimming: TLOU2 Character Reaction to Cold: RDR2 Boat Details: RDR2 Petting the Dog: RDR2 Riding on thin ice: TLOU2 RDR2 wins 8-5

[@NoSabesQuienSoy666]

Riding a horse and petting a dog is a tie, and the boat thing too since tlou is not an open world and if that could be done I think it would damage the experience.

[@Vegas7190]

5:54 in real life the splash would be so much bigger

[@Chanshilla]

I feel like splashes are the one thing regarding water physics that video games can't ever do well. The ripples usually tend to look really good but never the splashes.

[@Takkar1707]

The echo at the end of rd2 is fucking awesome!

[@zuher3180]

No games has even come close to beat rdr2 , hands down haters .

[@zuher3180]

@@jayashanrathnayaka2085 bro we both now that rdr2 its best open world game ever made . But the problem is, what do you got💀

[@zuher3180]

@@jayashanrathnayaka2085 i don’t even know why you hate this masterpiece ? Can you develope ?

[@treighknapp5323]

@@zuher3180ghost of Tsushima is better 🥱

[@CinematicUniverse26290]

​@@treighknapp5323 no competition for red dead both are different games But for ghost of tsushima i prefer sekiro it's way more better than tsushima except graphics and cinematics

[@gray01216]

​@@treighknapp5323No it isn't. Check a comparison between RDR2 and GOT open world. If you still think GOT wins, you're either a fanboy or just blind.

[@SlayBotYT]

The combact mechanics of TLOU2 are ny favourite

[@juansnowgaming]

Can you compare final fantasy xv and final fantasy xvi? Love your content

[@waizeshaikh]

RDR2 father of all open world games

[@fereroman]

I get extremely annoyed by people who have only played one of these games, but then compare them, proving that their game is better. Definitely two masterpieces

[@agoodballet]

I’ve only played RDR2 but I have TLOU downloaded. I just can’t stop playing RDR2, I’m on my 8th play through.

[@KoolAidEnjoyer]

​@@agoodballetFR RDR2 IS THE BEST GAME EVER MADE

[@m.n.s.s2825]

The last of us 2 was no masterpiece. The user reactions in many platforms says it all. The story was just MEH

[@fereroman]

@@m.n.s.s2825 🤡

[@panzershrek7942]

@@m.n.s.s2825 last of us 2 had a very cuestionable story.

[@TetDance]

The last part of the video... I've seen that ice breaking too in RDR2 ah....

[@theunemployedmind]

I actually played both game back to back this year. RDR2 and right after it TLOU2

[@gameonly1062]

Nahh no other game can match the graphics of RDR2 and its open world too we call it master piece 💙

[@EugenioDaou]

Except gta 6 when it will come out

[@KALESSIN3]

Yes, they already did The Last of Us Part II, Zero Dawn, Death Stranding, Battlefield 1, Resident Evil 2 and 3 remake, The Order 1886, Ghost of Tsushima

[@EugenioDaou]

@@KALESSIN3 and no game match rdr 2 graphics

[@KALESSIN3]

@@EugenioDaou hahahahahaha good joke fanboy!

[@EugenioDaou]

@@KALESSIN3 If it's native 4K it doesn't mean that textures and lighting is better.

[@daydreams3071]

It never seems this peaceful when I'm moving in those games, it's only satisfying when you see others do it😂

[@raquela9821]

So true😂

[@BlobAlt]

I like the echo of rdr2 gun shooting depending on the area

[@A.S.K88]

5:15 also the arrow has shadow

[@togishere]

Rdr2 will always be #1. GTA 5 and Rdr2 are probably the top 2 games of all time. Crazy enough, they're made by the same company

[@CJNG_1]

wait for gta 6 to claim its throne!!!!

[@hubris1845]

GTA 5 top game of all time?)lol okay

[@ezequieII]

😂

[@Batman-hb9dh]

My personal favourite game of all time is the witcher 3, but rdr2 is 2nd for me

[@CJNG_1]

@@hubris1845 yeah gta 5 a decade old still popular game bruh and no game or movie reached its box office !!!

[@maulanaadrian9383]

Both are great

[@haziq5507]

Both great in my opinion. Cant really compare an open world and story based game. Because there have their own advantages.

[@xrayvisin]

Played both games. Love the detail to both games in their own right. But I love the combat in TLOU 2 especially when you have a melee weapon and you’re going ham on enemies as Abby

[@icecolditachi3304]

The fact that rdr2 is less demanding in processor requirements compared to last of us is such a relief🎉❤

[@atom-bomb8383]

Tlou2 is a console exclusive it doesn't need system requirements so it doesn't really matter

[@icecolditachi3304]

@@atom-bomb8383last of us 1 doesn't run well on an average pc

[@krspy1337]

@@icecolditachi3304 well tlou 2 was made for ps4 which has a much weaker cpu than ps5 which got tlou 1 remake

[@krspy1337]

so i bet that tlou 2 will be easier to run than tlou 1 on pc

[@icecolditachi3304]

@@krspy1337 we will see

[@fighter2499]

Two masterpiece games

[@Lil_bottega73]

Rdr glass break testing "Npc - Quit moving that thing around" 😂

[@Xoxobogd4n]

if the same bros and sis will make a new game I can't imagine how detailed, advanced and so on it would will be, they are so talented and hardworking

[@sanitar7423]

The developers of both games are incredible people. I wonder if they communicate with each other, discussing each other's games

[@LukariAnimation]

Rockstar communicating is like a fever dream

[@robmichael8136]

Tlou2 developers are gay. Hated the woke elements and some of the storyline writing. Game could have been much better and more realistic in that regard.

[@clackracks2349]

@@robmichael8136?

[@Spazlites]

@@robmichael8136grow up…it’s time to grow up, nobody cares about this nonsense you’re typing

[@ellieplushies]

@@robmichael8136ur jus mad ellies not straight. people are gay in real life, it happens.

[@ChallengerV8]

Remember that RDR2 is an open world game with gigantic map. Keepeing all the details there is so much more complex.

[@hanselgretel6667]

Rdr2 had a 2000+ dev team with 3000+ outsourcing. Tloup2 had 400 dev team with a little less than 2000 outsourcing. It is a fair comparison.

[@jadduck]

Not all that impressive. RDR2 is full of dead-space. I've played it for over 100 hours and the majority of the map is just wildnerness- same shit copied and pasted over again.

[@Abhaynov1996]

​@@jadduckmost of our lives are empty

[@jadduck]

@@Abhaynov1996 Yours, maybe. Not mine. Peace and love. Hope u find the help ur looking 4

[@jadduck]

@@Abhaynov1996 edgy

[@walidslimani]

i wanna know if you play RDR2 on XBOX one S and xbox ONE X what's the diff ,

[@kenadams101]

I liked the physics and graphics in TLOU2 slightly better, character design in particular, but maybe because I played it first and I love the TLOU series dearly. RDR2 is a great game though, much ahead of its time especially in the open world design and detail.

[@pikaboy101]

Arthur in the snow storm be like: im hungry

[@the_sexfrog]

Horse: how hungry🐴?

[@haze_2563]

The Last of Us is no slouch and they put a lot of effort into it, but rdr2 is simply in a league of its own, it was revolutionary, it redefined what a realistic game is, it became the new gold standard, whenever any game comes out, they always try comparing it to rdr2, and there is yet to be one that surpasses it

[@Vertex_vortex]

5:29 beautiful scene

[@ikanhiu8906]

This is how i rate the physics and details. Snow Deformation: Both are great Water Physics: RDR 2 (I really love the details TLOU dev put on the wave, where you can see some water splash when the wave hit ellie's body) Riding a horse: RDR 2 (love all the details they put on the horse in rdr2) Glass Physics: Both are great Fire Propagation: RDR 2 (how the fire spread on grass, house and other) Snow physics on tree: TLOU 2 (i love how the snow breaks) Archery: RDR 2 Swimming: TLOU 2 Character reaction to cold: Both are great Boating: Rdr 2 Petting dog: BOTH CUZ BEING ABLE TO PET THE DOG IS ENOUGH FOR ME :D Riding on thin ice: Both (The ice on rdr 2 looks pretty thick compare to the TLOU) BONUS: Gore: TLOU 2

[@BESTAD_TLOU]

snow: TLOU2 water: TLOU2 horse: RDR2 glass: TLOU2 fire: RDR2 archery: RDR2 swimming: TLOU2 character reaction: RDR2 boating: RDR2 pet dog: N.A. thick ice: TLOU2

[@JsYTA]

Keep in mind that LoU is a guided experience. Where they have a lot more freedom to make things look pretty. The fact RdR2 is even comparable is very impressive.

[@user-lj9zq4dr5t]

factually rdr2 is better in any aspect besides story in wich both games are equal also rdr2 is 2 years older and has many things that are way better.

[@AlirezaAlizadeh-lx5nk]

For a linear game, the details are not very important and should focus more on the combat system, which Tlou has done well, and it is natural to pay more attention to the details of RDR, usually open world games do this to avoid repetition of environments and challenges. They hit

[@JohnWI13]

Untrue, details should be even more polished and focused on a linear environment, because as it is smaller than the open world, there is more time to add details in the environments.

[@AlirezaAlizadeh-lx5nk]

@@JohnWI13 No, the above details are overtime in a linear game, while these above details are very important in RPG games like RDR because the amount of interaction in RDR is more with the gameplay than the story, while in TLOU the amount of interaction is more with the story than the gameplay, if TLOU Instead of using useless details in the environments, it was faithful to it style and gave the player the ability to carry and hide the bodies, which would have helped the player's experience much better than seeing Elie's pupils shrink and enlarge with her flashlight XD. Let's be Details in a linear game in combats is a good feature, like to use the guns, you have to take them out of your backpack, but using them in the environment is useless. I don't care why Molotov in TLOU cuts grass It doesn't burn because the environments have no freedom of action, but it's important to me to be able to hide dead bodies or see limbs being cut off and NPCs begging.

[@JohnWI13]

@AlirezaAlizadeh-lx5nk No, you are wrong. The smaller/more linear game is, the more detail is expected to be present, because detailing that explorable area will take 20, 30 times less than a giant open world like RDR, which is not a RPG, dont know how you came up with that. Also, RDR, TW3, Skyrim, Souls and other games dont follow: "gameplay is more important than story", and even if they did, the story has to be good, like in Red Dead which the story is in my opinion the best ever. So, to put it simply: Smaller environment, more time for details.

[@AlirezaAlizadeh-lx5nk]

@@JohnWI13 Your review was only in terms of the size of the worlds, but the main discussion here is that these details are ineffective in linear games. If you kill an animal in RDR, it starts to decompose over time. Should this be included in TLOU? Of course, no, we don't have much freedom of action in a linear game, and the details should be for things that accompany the player, such as artificial intelligence, gun upgrades, combat systems, and blablabla. and the goal of the player is to enjoy the fighting system and the story of the game and not to play a role, but in games like RDR or Zelda, the player's interaction is more about the environment and exploring their worlds, and the player is constantly passing and surfing While in a linear game, the player surfs for 30 or 40 seconds to find the item and easily passes through the environment and cannot go back. Would you like to discuss details on the combat system in TLOU and RDR?

[@anonymous_dot_com2326]

​​@@AlirezaAlizadeh-lx5nkseeing details insane details is more impressive on an openworld game tgan a linear game. Since the game is linear and the maps or gamespaces aren't as large as open world, it gets more advantage to add more details than an openworld game, so your statement doesnt make sense. This has nothing to do with gameplay, its about how detailed the world and physics are

[@alexandrdanilov3495]

it's like comparing a well designed flat with well designed appartment building

[@mg-us7ug]

In an alternate universe, the cordyceps outbreak happened in 1899 and these two teamed up. Ellie's stealth and Arthur's dead eye would've made for a murderous duo.

[@juno1492]

Both are amazing, the story, the characters, and the graphics. Kudos to both games!

[@hansgiraldo17]

The story of TLoU2 is tremendous shit.

[@Moss_and_Such]

I hadn’t played rdr2 since it launched on ps4. I now have a pretty modest but powerful rig with a 4070 and a 5600x3d and I got rdr2 on sale and my mind was instantly blown playing through the prologue. What a masterpiece.

[@suvamk]

Just play it slow, explore the world especially the swamp areas. Loads of things present in the open world.

[@officerjohns9554]

the rdr2 can even run on a 1060, which is impressive since this game looks so nice

[@Defeft]

@@officerjohns9554 that'd be 1080p though, and RDR2 looks horrible on 1080p.

[@AxD_A]

​@@Defeftnot really,the game looks great still at 1080p

[@dtrjones]

What on earth, I played on my brothers PC which is 1080p @@Defeft it looked great, that's a daft comment! If you are playing on PC, there are ways you can set the render resolution higher if that is still an issue.

[@dzakidj3328]

Its close. But one is a linear Storyline with semi open world and one is A msssive open world with tons of Story and side quest

[@nirogalactoid8398]

What about the story line in RDR2 best story in gaming history hands down

[@natalia4303]

I'm a big fan of tlou but rdr2 is an absolute masterpiece and none of the productions can beat it

[@syrxs_rod]

Tlou2 graphics win tho

[@natalia4303]

@@syrxs_rod As I didn't know rdr2, I thought that the graphics in the TLOU2 are the best, but now I can confidently say that the graphics of RDR2 win, it's more cinematic😍

[@Szeryy.]

@@syrxs_rod LOOL just turn graphics on ultra this guy doesn't have ultra my game look 50x Better

[@NeptuneSega]

@@Szeryy. He does, stop the cap bro

[@Szeryy.]

@@NeptuneSega bruh my game looks better

[@X_Omen_Z]

As someone who's never played either, I'd say they are pretty evenly matched. Both are very impressive.

[@karipundai4725]

When testing water physics, you can hear the echo of the gunshot in RDR2. Too good!

[@fade2black001]

Where's the 4k option at?

[@hinalocalexchannel3942]

is this comparison both on the same system of PS4

[@mahmut4964]

The best game in the world is undoubtedly rdr2. Love and the best different things!

[@KALESSIN3]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@Mr_Callahan7]

@@KALESSIN3 RDR2 best 🖕

[@KALESSIN3]

@@Mr_Callahan7 🤡

[@Mr_Callahan7]

@@KALESSIN3 😂😂 RDR2 best game of all time little boy

[@KALESSIN3]

@@Mr_Callahan7 hahahahahaha good joke RDR2 🥱

[@Essi.s]

Uma informação sobre a neve de Red Dead 2 que ninguem percebeu, a neve dela diferente de outras neve se você andar pelo rastro que alguem deixou ou andar no seu proprio rastro de por onde passou você passa com mais facilidade o personagem ou o cavalo fica mais rapido e menos pesado

[@mayen67]

This is great

[@strelitzia669]

Two of the most stunning and detailed games even up to this day. The other contestants are not even close

[@mustardsauce5201]

Ok so I think they take different approaches. tlou takes a more movie like approach to art direction while rdr2 just tries to look like real life. Tlou uses a lot of depth of field and the lighting is very carefully placed in scenes for that cinematic look. Rdr2 doesn’t really do that as much unless it’s like cutscenes. Rdr2s light placement isn’t careful or precise, it’s just realistic, regardless of if that lighting looks filmic or whatever. I prefer the tlou approach, but one is not better than the other, they’re just different. Obviously rdr2 is much more detailed due to it being an open world cowboy sim so it benefits from small details like people having routines or crazy water physics much more than tlou does, but I’m just talking straight visuals. Idk why I have so many opinions on this stuff, but whatevs :)

[@Ponchoblatz]

Well, no duh it’s 1899

[@parhamhamedi212]

Rdr2 and tlou 2 : king of game

[@aliramazanl7741]

2:37 I hought he'll call back his axe 😂

[@musicfan07058]

Rockstar and Naughtydog are the 2 top dogs of game design as far as I'm concerned. Excited for whatever is lined up by them...

[@opogtiago3678]

Two masterpieces

[@m.n.s.s2825]

1. Tlou2 is meh

[@Monstert_]

​@@m.n.s.s2825shut up

[@Cashislitttt]

What’s crazy is that the last of us part two is from 2024 and rdr2 is from 2018 💀

[@mam630]

Are you dumb ? Tlou2 is a 2020 game

[@kraventhehunter1083]

2020*

[@Cashislitttt]

@@kraventhehunter1083I was thinking of the remastered version

[@Breakerisaac]

6:29 Had me dying with Ellie XD

[@AT-yg4nk]

Both masterpieces no doubt. But if I were to choose one it’s RDR2 hands down. That game I can just turn on and roam around aimlessly for hours. The game even to this day still has moments that surprise me. I still have fun and enjoy the game every time I play it.

[@agav2345]

I actually think alot of people would like the story and narrative of TLOU2 if it wasnt for joel dying in the beginning but i think that exact thing is what made the whole game so amazing to me it is depressing ashell tho so i understand alot of people simply not wanting to engage in such a story

[@qwertyuseradmin]

Spoiler...

[@agav2345]

@@qwertyuseradmin 3 Year old game also everyone knew this before the game even came out relax bud

[@pickle93]

No that goofball druckmann can stick his golf stick up his mouth. It wasn't a good story but I respect your opinion.

[@onion_bro2424]

Joel's death isn't the only reason, it's the story itself that doesn't make sense and the way they did the narrative that went wrong. If they actually let us play abby first, then go back and show the death of Joel, then let us play Ellie, it's probably gonna be much better. Also remove all those necessary political correctness, like, who tf would like to watch a woman who looks like a guy and a man fuck in the middle of the story especially when it doesn't make sense at all? There's a reason why people call that scene national geographic lol. Moreover, just let Ellie kill abby, forcing Ellie to let go of her hatred doesn't work in the current story, like, there's already a shit ton of people who died in Ellie's hands, and she suddenly feel sad just because she killed a pregnant woman? And I don't get how seeing your father figure's death in your mind makes you forgive the murderer, shouldn't you hit harder when that happens? Especially with all those rage? Or just at least give us the choice to decide whether we kill abby or not. The story is destined to be shit when they decided to rewrite the story from vengeance for Jesse to vengeance for Joel, and add all those political stuff into it.

[@Note-DS]

Story us trash and edgy

[@aramokurdo]

Two great game two great studios 🔥

[@sameersk5241]

Insane detail at last in rdr gun shot sound eco

[@tzogaming]

bro how did you get arthur in blackwater

[@BopWalk]

2 games are fantastic and have insane physics but RDR2 is a true open world game unlike TLOU2 which is semi open world.

[@user-vo4dv2of1t]

РДР 2 отстойная игра , я купил полную ее версию и пожалел , что это сделал .... Более отстойного проекта я не видел , разве что ГТА 5 .....

[@vhureyeweqw8808]

@@user-vo4dv2of1t brain damage is not a joke

[@sadpow2894]

@@user-vo4dv2of1twow your opinion so edgy bro you’re so cool

[@majesticscope6782]

​@@user-vo4dv2of1t Go play Fortnite then

[@camiloantoniovaldessanchez5429]

Rdr2 winner!

[@zuher3180]

@@jayashanrathnayaka2085 rdr2 masterpiece, thx rockstar

[@KALESSIN3]

@@zuher3180 "masterpiece" 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@itachiuzumaki6942]

For those saying water physics is the last of us: You can make whirlpools in rdr2 and sink ships with explosions, the water is so much more graphical too

[@shanthikk7240]

2022 vs 2018 wow still tied or loses man ilove that game so much

[@AS.Se7en]

The fact that RDR2 is an open world game with that much details is mind blowing

[@The_MaDa]

Rdr2 It is just above tlou2, if they had come out in the same year, rdr2 would be clearly superior

[@KALESSIN3]

🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

[@The_MaDa]

@@KALESSIN3 👍

[@prska]

​@@KALESSIN3cope

[@rezamohammadkhani5893]

​@@KALESSIN3don't cry man. He's right

[@Furk1ylol]

Dude, RDR2 is a game released in 2018 Perfect physique for that date😨😨

[@AT-cd2pp]

It's a crime that they won't give us an RDR2 PS5 performance patch.

[@zm7417]

RDR2 very² amazing😊

[@Blindrusher69]

all know Rd2 is better

[@ILoveFishinginWi]

​@@jayashanrathnayaka2085 bro stop commenting on every post that thinks rdr2 is better. It it's alot better that last of us.

[@_numbb]

@@jayashanrathnayaka2085 ayo ngga

[@zuher3180]

@@ILoveFishinginWi well said my friend

[@ILoveFishinginWi]

@@zuher3180 thank you

[@Blindrusher69]

@@ILoveFishinginWi breh

[@gabrielcarrasco5072]

I have played both, I honestly don't know which one is better, both have the best details and current graphics, without a doubt the best games I have played👌

[@user-2137]

Snow: equal Water: RDR2 Horse: RDR2 Glass: TLOU2 Fire: RDR2 Snow physics on tree: TLOU2 Archery: equal (arrow wobbling looks fancy, but TLOU2 has picking up animations) Swimming: TLOU2 Cold: equal Boating: RDR2 Petting dog: RDR2 (i love the tail wag) Thin ice: TLOU2 Winner: RDR2 (by just 1 point, according to my opinion)

[@user-2137]

Both games are full of details and are masterpieces, but they're different from each other Main difference is that RDR2 is an open world game, which gives a completely different experience than TLOU2 It's like comparing the best sweet food you've ever eaten to the best spicy food you've ever eaten - sure, both are amazing, but does comparing them make any sense? Their taste might be equally amazing, but they're very different from one another

[@Reckless004]

Swimming Ellie: 😃 Arthur: 😕 John: 💀

[@3mk_miles]

Joel:🏌

[@mathiue6968]

both are incredible good games, but it`s hard to compare because, one is an open world an the other isn`t

[@nirogalactoid8398]

You can compare the stories too. Even the story gameplay of RDR2 is far more vast you can do so many things better gameplay and characters and overall better story.