Mafia - Original (2002) vs Remake (2020): Restaurant Scene Comparison

[@NiGHTMARE_NiCk]

Its taken 18 years but Pepe learned how to make good food lol

[@thatrussianguy1348]

You know what? I think Pete should be on Master Chef

[@tootygroody6026]

Pepe needs his own spin off game.

[@sethguest781]

Italian chefs are artists, hands down. You should check out Pepe's in free roam to get into the kitchen and see what's cooking on the stoves, looked amazing and very appetizing.

[@magicabulla9687]

yes but he wasn't able to learn Italian 😂

[@imperalofficer3350]

​@@tootygroody6026Official Mafia cooking sim

[@aks19880]

In the remake, you can see how Salieri controls Tommy's life. He literally makes Sarah ensure tommy quits drinking just cus he doesn't want the business to suffer. That's some Walter White level manipulation

[@sketchsketchy867]

also is good that him as a father and husband isnt an alcoholic so

[@jyothishkumar3098]

In the original, they don't even drink iirc

[@mathiasandersen3401]

They do occasionally, like after the "running man" cutscene in the bar, aswell as them celebrating Tommy successfully destroying cars in "Molotov party" and becoming a official member. And throughout the game bottles of liqour are in the meeting room at the bar

[@dosmasdosesigualacuatro5343]

jesse pinkman deserved worse

[@LikaPyramid]

Can't have a drunk or hungover bodyguard 🤣

[@ArmyJames]

Don: “What’s on the menu, Pepe?” Pepe: “My mother...” Don: “Mmm, that sounds good. I’ll have that.”

[@itsaboveyoupleasedontlooku299]

Wait what lol

[@AzaiKang]

In my language, Pepe means vag! na , lol

[@RavenMatthew]

@@AzaiKang in the Philippines, yes?

[@Special_Agent_Frank_Horrigan]

​@@AzaiKang just say vagina

[@JustFun598]

I like the detail in Remake, how Salieri doesnt turn his back towards the entrance, but instead turns his back towards the wall, so he can have a better look at the entrance, so he can immediately react if any danger arises, and so does Tommy, he moves the chair so he too can have a better view. This is exactly what people of crime do, they never turn their backs in restaurants or bars, they always "hug the wall". But it also ties into the story much better, portraying Salieri as a cunning, manipulative and a smart man, willing to step-over anyone for his own gain.

[@handsaw72]

fr (i didn’t read a single word)

[@Serminator30]

​@handsaw72 I will tell you in short sentence. He is impressed that in the Remake Salieri was sitting while facing the entrance, to prepare any possible assault.

[@grim_56]

​@@handsaw72 Why are you bragging about being stupid

[@Duck_Man4]

My father often does that...OH NO

[@Salza02]

Yeah or sit in the middle because some person behind them could shoot them. So they sit at the far back or at least not near windows

[@fushigiman140]

Rip "I could eat a horse"

[@starbuckoof5219]

Rip kitty0706 we are still talking about him

[@pchtommy1268]

also rip "Throw hes present joe maybe that will smoke him out"

[@boeitnie1185]

So their gonna cook you a horse

[@TipppedScales1015]

Rip, more memorable dialogue

[@abemigos9281]

​@@TipppedScales1015More forgettable dialogue*

[@jaycub6130]

Imagine if Mafia 2 had the same attention

[@h0nza_]

Imagine Mafia 2 not being cut in half

[@CheeseBalls20]

I mean, it’s understandable because the definitives were all made in one year, and I guess they couldn’t give more attention to 2 as they would only need visual upgrades while 1 needed a LOT

[@eddiethemexiii]

@@h0nza_ mafia 2 still feels short, but it's an amazing game

[@TheJonkler2024]

I think it will get that treatment eventually. Hopefully with Unreal Engine 5. That'd look fuking amazing

[@patricksantiago842]

Imagine if Mafia 3 was made in this manner without all the excess

[@Coolfaceable]

- What's on the menu today? - My mother

[@ArmyJames]

- Mmm, that sounds good. I’ll have that.

[@deoxysoverlord8710]

😂😂😂

[@cristhianramirez6939]

I'll have your mother too

[@thundercrosssplitattack2064]

GTA definitive edition can learn a thing or two from this

[@heisenburger2]

That's what I thought the whole time playing mafia definitive addition. Besides that hellhole of a race mission it still is my favorite game.

[@mrOGbobbyjohnson]

@@heisenburger2try beating that race on classic, you will quit the game at least three times🤣🤣

[@johnnytopgun6414]

​@@mrOGbobbyjohnsoni never had any trouble, i was only 9 as well

[@Knightphall]

​@@heisenburger2I beat the race on the 2nd try. It wasn't that bad...

[@josuepaz9446]

the one I had trouble with was the one where the cops had a tank

[@falliblecrowdstudio4018]

That's how Mafia works.

[@sethguest781]

In the original, Morello's goons just cause minor damage to the restaurant in the remake they nearly wipe it off the block, the Tommy guns virtually blast away the whole facade of Pepe's and then they hurl a grenade into the place, starting a fire that probably burnt the whole establishment down.

[@Phosphorus0]

Minor damage??? Brother they fucking incinerated that place

[@sethguest781]

@@Phosphorus0 It was hard to tell with the old graphics, the new graphics made the damage more visible and apparent. The original was too pixilated and I couldn't make out a thing save for the busted windows.

[@regisegek4675]

Lol it ain't pixelated, there is less change simply​@@sethguest781

[@happy_feed]

​@@sethguest781you are blind then lol

[@sethguest781]

@@happy_feed That's early 2000s graphics, man. I have nothing against the first game but using tech to create riveting action sequences like this was still in its infancy, it was passable for the time but DE is much more authentic, it feels more like the '30s with the gritty atmosphere and dialogue.

[@rory4.63]

they remade a whole game but kept the roots the same, its so impressive they made a great game even better in the remake

[@TipppedScales1015]

Ehhh, some of the dialogue is more generic though

[@h0nza_]

@@TipppedScales1015 for example?

[@TipppedScales1015]

@@h0nza_ The ending monologue for sure

[@h0nza_]

@@TipppedScales1015 the whole chapter was fucked up...

[@TipppedScales1015]

@@h0nza_ Facts

[@Daysbb]

Feel so bad for Pepe

[@benmengala20]

1:45 That laugh

[@jessicaguarin3897]

lol

[@streamspoart2671]

EhEhEH...

[@maxo._.lote05]

“He sounds like Woody fucking Woodpecker”

[@theUnicornOfPower]

I'm surprised that after so many years video games still look like video games

[@mr.apocalypse5143]

I don’t want video games to look like live action movies.

[@TipppedScales1015]

That’s because this engine is ass and outdated, the next mafia will have better graphics.

[@I-was-once-a-krabby-patty]

@@TipppedScales1015so did you see it

[@abadbarista212]

Well the original is more funny but the remake is more natural like a remake should be . So , it's logical you got split by your opinions.

[@suhaiqal]

yeah

[@n00b_ninja]

Hmm

[@simple-commentator-not-rea7345]

I think it's a perfectly fine remake. My biggest problem though is the lack of the original score by Vladimir Simunek. I'd be like making an excellent remake of the original Star Wars without John Williams

[@masochist_karel1087]

The original sounds So crapy (the dabing) cause Its fan made not original the original Czech Is one of the best voice acting ever iam just glad that we Are a small country but have good game like Mafia kingdom come Arma vitcong etc.

[@rueryuuzaki5448]

I was gonna say something similar. Kinda disappointed they didn't go line for line, but both tones are good

[@terrymcginnis4633]

its shows really why i prefer remakes over "remasters"

[@mnickiel09]

_JUST IMAGINE HOW A MASTERPIECE MAFIA II WOULD'VE BEEN IF IT HAD THE SAME 'REMAKE' TREATMENT AS THE FIRST ONE_

[@sulkissulking]

4:22 such a badass shot, holy shit.

[@CopperWasabi]

After 18 years Saliero finally got a sip of that Chianti

[@Ali_Rad]

Even after 18 years, Joe always has his grenades.

[@joelcartagena953]

Sometimes I really wish to turn back time. Especially back in the year 2001.

[@SleepyjoeOG]

2001 was not a good year in America

[@amy-295]

Twin towers 🗣️🔥

[@joelcartagena953]

@@amy-295 yup that too.

[@Alan_The_Jaguar]

In 2002 the audio quality was like a hearing it trought a tin can and the graphics where like cardboard, in the remake the audio it's cinema quality and it looks like you could see every hair on his skin, but the humor and the joke are timeless

[@dustojnikhummer]

Mixing of the English dub was not great. The Czech one is much better for some reason

[@CristianMarchese]

​@@dustojnikhummer cause the game IS czech

[@hunterxsimple3821]

This makes me appreciate the remake's Salieri more

[@EXMachina.]

Lmao Pepe does look like Tony Soprano in the original.

[@JeffWarren-sg7xj]

And Tommy looks like Deniro.

[@samfish5500]

Remake wins in this one

[@cumminscowboy5801]

Sure I guess, Mafia 1: funner and cooler Mafia D.E: graphics and voice improved, nothing else.

[@starbuckoof5219]

But salieri doesn't make fun of Sarah cook it was awesome

[@talpatv512]

@@cumminscowboy5801 good joke

[@SlaveOfChrist2]

@@cumminscowboy5801 if you played the racing mission you'd take back

[@orthodoxcrusader5413]

Yeah a 2020 game is better than a 2002 game . What a surprise

[@generalgeneric9358]

“At last, I could eat a horse.” - Don Salieri, 1935

[@bonganikhumalo9563]

Rockstar take notes please

[@motheuser]

Rockstar is owned by Take Two Interactive. Take Two Interactive also owns 2k games, the guys who made the Mafia games. So it's more like Take Two Interactive take notes from what they bought.

[@jacklupen5337]

A different studio developed GTA DE. Rockstar was just the publisher. If they had to be the one to develop it, it would've completely blew Mafia DE out of the water, no questions asked.

[@motheuser]

@@jacklupen5337 Needs to be said. But I only half agree with you. You know what GTA "Expanded and Enhanced" is like.

[@SeriousDragonify]

​@@jacklupen5337No they wouldnt lol An ignorant assumption. RDR2 and GTA 5 are highly unfinished games and gave worst ports. They downgraded GTA SA on PC and XBOX, GTA 4 worst port on PC and consoles run worse. Only so far that was fully finished was GTA 3, VC and RDR. Even Bully is highly unfinished and SE is worst.

[@jacklupen5337]

@@SeriousDragonify Mafia DE reuses the same assets from Mafia 3 with little to no improvements or anything new to make it distinguishable. It's essentially just MAFIA 3 but with a different coat of paint, with the same recurring bugs from III being present in the DE as well, some of which have been left unresolved. Say what you want, but MAFIA DE would literally stand out as the most half-baked and unfinished among them.

[@su-25frogfoot74]

In the remake they fixed the grenade, they made sure to show it with the spoon detached (The part that holds the striker).

[@luisjesurun7157]

Voice acting, writing, and graphics are pretty good in the 2002 version, but it's outdated and pales in comparison to the remake. The remake feels like it has much more character to it if that's the right way to say it. Plus, character development is key if you want to care about the characters and the remake does that superbly well and better than the 2002 version

[@martinbenko2728]

Exactly! The original was good at it's time, but for todays standards and expectations, the remake is the way to go. I think the game deserves to be called the definitive version.

[@Vekikev1]

The original is ten times better. The remake feels like a cliché.

[@abemigos9281]

@@Vekikev1 Now take your rose-tinted glasses off

[@AarozEzio]

@@Vekikev1 cliche my @$$

[@theguy5776]

The remake fucked up the characters and the story, plus half of the details of the original were removed

[@aramokurdo]

not only this but every ORIGINAL game was masterpiece and better despite lower graphic but they had another atmosphere in another level!

[@temmietim1023]

The Tommy Gun sound design in the remake are so good!

[@Kopreni]

First time I've looked at the thumbnail i thought that the original mafia was some game released around 2018 until I realized what game it actually is.

[@ItsEzraRoan]

My first time playing mafia definitive edition I legit thought it was a movie, graphics were so good

[@JeffWarren-sg7xj]

For real.

[@cabnbeeschurgr]

4:21 goes hard asf

[@Kortosis_Storm_Shadow]

1:03 Bro said Gyatti 💀

[@cruisertechgt]

Not sure how it's even legal to recreate a full game, everyone need to take lessons to this masterpiece

[@officialtoddhoward69]

This is why I want remakes instead of remasterers. Remastered games, at most, clean up some textures, improve lighting, and fix some bugs but rarely touch up the old models, so it looks jarring. Remakes, on the otherhand, are built from the ground up. Simply put, more work, more effort, and usually more passion. Of course there's always exceptions but generally remakes are more exciting than remasters

[@willmorgan5692]

The original MOBSTERS was fantastic I played it so much on the X-BOX and PS2 now the remake is true to the original and a work of art plus a more defined ending both have subtle difference's and wonderful to play

[@TommyVercetti-g1y]

Tony sopranos 0:50

[@drksimi3]

I really enjoy mafia (2002) back then game was really good I was only 15.

[@corytheginger5102]

God damn......like, wow I wouldn't want them to change up the cutscenes in the old gta games( well give better animation and cinematography) but damn if rockstar took a pi age from 2k, just imagine if the gta trilogy DE was this nice......ahh welp back to dream land

[@Flaggyt]

That game still holds it's own upto this day. Played it recently on the ps5 and it just incredibly well put together. Like it better then gta5 without a doubt.

[@Monterrey5]

Nice video

[@GameIntrosFinales]

Thanks!

[@Lazidiz]

2002 Mafia actually looks really good for its time

[@TheRealCiandria]

The remasters gave this game a major overhaul. My gosh even the audio is better!

[@doupt]

perfect lighting

[@TheLastArbiter]

They learned that the spoon comes off of the grenade when it is thrown

[@simple-commentator-not-rea7345]

Look, I LOVE the remake, it is hands down one of the best remakes I've ever seen, but the original still had the AMAZING score by Vladimir Simunek, and this remake just has the constant piano music; the entire soundtrack sounds the same. Had the remake kept the original score, I'd call it a masterpiece remake. As is, it's almost perfect

[@talpatv512]

Amm, the original had a very repetitive soundtrack lol

[@simple-commentator-not-rea7345]

@@talpatv512 Hmm, what's better then? Soundtrack with several scores all of which repeat at least twice over the whole game, or a soundtrack composed almost entirely of dramatic piano music? And since it IS often hard to tell in comment sections, that was sarcasm

[@talpatv512]

@@simple-commentator-not-rea7345 bruh there are only 2 soundtracks for fighting in the original, repeat only 2 times in your dreams. And yes the piano is much better. It's called orchestra ffs

[@cumminscowboy5801]

@@talpatv512 Mafia Original: MUCH funner, and good storyline Mafia D.E: AMAZING graphics, but it still doesn't beat the original:/

[@simple-commentator-not-rea7345]

@@talpatv512 Okay look, I don't want to go too far in this discussion, so let's just agree to disagree; it's a matter of preference. You preffer orchestral music that's loud and grand, fine, your choice. I preffer a soundtrack that's limited sure, but still more expressive, don't call me out on it

[@bdleo300]

Voice 'acting' from the original is absolute comedy 😀😀

[@stellalunasilverbat]

the og actually has some pretty remarkable character models for the early 00s imo, especially their faces

[@deaconturk7752]

This and the getaway were ahead of it’s time, just unlucky they both released the same year as vice city.

[@ユニコーニア]

the art style in the 2002 mafia just looks crazily realistic

[@ユニコーニア]

it's because the textures of buildings were actually made with real photos I think

[@morse2511]

For being release on 2002, it looks amazing graphically. But just like everyone elses already pointed out, the remake make the mafia act more like mafia. Man I wish they remake 2 or make Mafia 4 based on current modern times

[@Vukso99]

Remake scene is like from some movie..it was so cool play it 4 the 1st time.

[@anthonymckenzie5182]

3:20 Drunkards get slappy 4:28 Bastard could have at least let me finish my wine The boss can drink but his workers can't.I don't like hypocrites.

[@breadstick8502]

This is one of my favorite chapters

[@SO-Negative]

Is the Pepe's surname Silvia because I got boxes full of Pepe here.

[@PoorlyWrttenReviews]

I thought the bit where the don Told Sarah to stop Tommy drinking was weird, we haven't seen Tommy with an alcohol problem at any point, but we have with Pauly... Just my little observation

[@skadess2107]

It's told in Intermezzo II that he had some problems.

[@DB-bq6zc]

The mafia life can do that to a character like Tommy. He gets less safe as the story progresses & Sal has his reasons. A sloppy person effects the quality of business & Tommy's sharp mind Is an admirable asset.

[@exequielpomilio8558]

Both original and remake the drink problem was told in intermezzo but never explicitely show

[@PoorlyWrttenReviews]

@@exequielpomilio8558 what is intermezzo

[@giyutomioka6885]

I just played mafia 1 for the first time and i played the new version and it was a amazing/sad story i havent played such a good story game in a while 10/10

[@LtLXIX]

The Tommy guns sound so damn good.

[@DushaSmile748]

I think the OST in the original game is better than in remake

[@00_real1]

why?

[@GlorfindelofGondolin]

They made it so much more cinematic in the remake.

[@dailydoseofsunshine2319]

The biggest change is Pepe dies in the remake whereas he survives in the original

[@minneeagle]

I think I saw him run out so he lived.

[@kelvinbrinkhuis3491]

Pepe didn't die. Look good.

[@Soldierb0y42]

They really did a great job with the updated version, unlike GTA this is awesome

[@AkshitSharma2109]

Rockstar should learn from HANGAR 13 that how to make impressive remakes

[@daveson1014]

Mafia definitive edition has better graphics than Mafia 2 definitive edition

[@AbhishekVaid]

Voice acting in 1 was way better. Character models too (not in fidelity but looks). Paul looks like a buffon in remake, but was hothead in original.

[@joshuawillis602]

You’re full of crap

[@spatzunderreviews4882]

Hello Game-Intros & Finales I couldn't find any mail of yours, so I'll write you this way in the hopes you'll see this. I'm writing a review for Space Hulk Deathwing and I'm looking for footage of the older games to use during a short look into the brands past. I wanted to ask you, if I could use your footage of those games. I would only use very short snippets and of course I'd also link your channel (not that my small audience would change anything for you ;) ). I'd really appreciate it but wish you all the best in any case. Best regards Spätzünder

[@GameIntrosFinales]

Hello Spätzünder, I'm sorry: In principle, I do not want any video material, that I have recorded and edited, to be used by other channels. I buy the original games (for example on GOG.com), run them via DosBox and spend many hours with recording and editing. Maybe you find websites that have online or emulated versions of these old games. Or you find another channel which is willing to give you his/her material. I hope you understand my point of view and will be able to reach your goals without my material. Thanks and farewell!

[@spatzunderreviews4882]

@@GameIntrosFinales That's a real shame, but I totally understand your point. I used to have the 2 first Space Hulk games but sadly lost them many years ago. Guess I'll have a look into online versions and emulations then. :) Thanks for the very fast answer, really appreciate it. I wish you a great day and just the best for your future projects.

[@onlygaming8106]

I gotta play this game even 2002 version looks interesting

[@Ben-xr6eh]

It’s crazy to think that people hate the remake and I never understand how or why

[@Adilmian-e3x]

I was only five when I played the OG in 2010 and it’s was the game for me

[@Beef1188]

It looks definitely better, but it feels a bit off... like certain objects have better graphics than others... and there is practically no particle effects!

[@jordannaumceski2269]

The original Mafia was and still is a masterpiece... I am not saying that remake is bad but cannot stand a chance with original

[@spastyyykmusic615]

Uh oh 2002 fanboy here

[@051idan2]

@@spastyyykmusic615 what wrong with that?

[@anonymanonym5154]

@@051idan2 i prefer both of them. Original will be always a masterpiece

[@anonymanonym5154]

Think one day if a ps10 will be😂 mafia 1 like a film then lol

[@blackfrieza1912]

Jordan Naumceski, bruh the original is trash like wtf are you talking about 😂 the voice acting is not natural band pales in comparison to the remake lol a masterpiece

[@Shagyamum]

Love this game

[@TommyLikeTom]

"You wouldn't say that if you knew what I had for dinner" they changed the line and now it doesn't make any sense, making Salieri look bad. "They didn't let me finish my wine" also changed it and made it worse

[@joshuawillis602]

That’s literally false. Stop making up lies to make the original seem better. The remake is superior and Salieri is much more fleshed out and better in the remake

[@jajoitus317]

The remake is really good if you can get it on sale, it's very much worth it.

[@exequielpomilio8558]

I dont know i love more the original Tommy gun sound instead of the remake one

[@R2green3]

Probably the best remake ive seen

[@paydn202]

i never got to play the original i was a child lol but i loved the remaster it was a great game

[@TheSoapsBeenDropped]

Can’t wait for mafia the old country

[@Oboar]

I feel like in the first game the don was more don like and in the new one he is more like a manager

[@shewbtoob]

i'll never understand how a frag grenade starts a fire, why didn't they just change it to a molotov

[@goldenman5204]

This is the only game where I can say the remake was done really well

[@modest_ozone645]

Pepe sounds like a nice guy In the remake

[@mateuszstrzaek632]

For me like somebody who's scared

[@modest_ozone645]

@@mateuszstrzaek632tbh ur right

[@bruselperro458]

Mafia DE was a pretty good remake in terms of adding to the cinematography

[@Altopelirrojo]

Mafia Original so so bad lol ... Mafia 3 & Mafia DE with sds editing - the Best

[@Eliseu05]

0:09 It's very strange to see a character with few polygons but with a realistic face 😅

[@Corpse_God666]

Lol, until now I have not heard english dabing in the original game, I always played in Czech version, as I am Czech person. It feels like English dabing is without emotions in comparison with ours.

[@vaclav_fejt]

I've only played the original game with the Czech dubbing, but I don't get why Salieri calls Pepe "Pepi". Surely, he's a first-generation immigrant, he should speak good Italian, and his English should have a pronounced Italian accent. Maybe not as strong as Pepe himself, but still audible. I'm glad they fixed that in the remake.

[@MrStronglime]

Fyi the "Italian" accent here portrayed is atrocious. Pepe also says "molto grazie" which would be "Molte grazie" in proper Italian. But whatever, looks like they are doing it right in terms of accents in the new Mafia game set in Sicily.

[@brahmabull9984]

We need a Mafia Game in New York, or a Pate Remake

[@Darthvader---sithlord__]

This game didnot have side missions or openworld there is entire diffrent section for open word where you cannot access mission that is one complaint But still better that rockstar defenetive editions

[@ionutgalatanu9491]

In 2020 din Salieri îs the seam actor that play gomez în adam.s family.

[@qwoi76]

definitive didnt even get to eat

[@dpere565]

Mafia D.E looks epic

[@f-red5449]

Rockstar triology´s can learn a thing or two with this masterpiece (no hate, fan of both franchises)

[@O_INSANOO21]

I wanna know which movie is based these scene?

[@midnightangles407]

What stopped from remastering gta triology like this

[@Vukso99]

this is remake

[@colindubord4239]

The models remind me of Medal Of Honor Frontline

[@Ultradude604]

Call me crazy. For me, I prefer the 2002 one. From the graphics to the voice over. Feels more fun. The DE feels too much like I'm watching television.

[@Melphas]

That might of been the point.

[@jimmynucklehead3070]

Yeah it is a tv show and a really fun one

[@blackfrieza1912]

Ultradude, dude the graphics is trash and the voice acting doesn't feel natural like wtf are you talking about 😂 the remake is a Billion times better

[@jimmynucklehead3070]

@@blackfrieza1912 I mean I never played 2002 version of mafia but it’s a great game the remake and I’ll prefer both

[@meanmeng1950]

@@blackfrieza1912 L you dumb graphics still good L

[@Subarik948]

В Ремейке эта самая лучшая кат-сцена получилась😮

[@Robert-cd2ox]

In the remake, pepe appears much more submissive and fearful. In my opinion, this is also much more realistic when dealing with a mafia boss.