Garlic Harvest - Raised Bed vs Ground Bed vs Grow Bag vs Spring Planting

[@joynicholson_Authentic_AI]

Fantastic video! Thank you. And such tiny elephant garlic, I will stay away from grow bags and garlic. I have subscribed to your channel.

[@shire-garden5155]

Thank you for the garlic info from Kerrie Sydney, Australia

[@littlesuzie6672]

Great video! I love every one you put out, you’re a joy to watch, so, thank you! Regarding garlic, bulb peak maturity corresponds with the number of remaining green leaves during die-back. Softnecks: aim for 6-7 remaining green leaves, Hardneck: aim for 4-6 remaining green leaves. Garlic puts on 12 leaves, with several cultivars starting their bulbing at the 10th leaf & then the lower leaves start dying off. Depending on where you are, each leaf will take 1-1.5 weeks to die off. Sometimes I am not perfect at harvesting according to hardneck or soft neck, (elephant garlic is technically a leek and not a true garlic), so as a general rule, I aim to harvest ALL my garlic at 6 (or at worst, 5) REMAINING green leaves. This gives the adequate amount of layers of skins required for optimal storage properties. I was very interested in this video as I am an avid garlic grower, it is my passion. I knew the grow bag ones would be small even before you showed them. Garlic like space between them (10-15cm) and free range for their roots to roam, lol. Grow bags are almost suffocating for them, and the only way they’ll do well in a grow bag is to plant one clove per bag. Not a good utilisation of space. But your other experiment - the ground ones, were fantastic! They had more distance and space between each other. I’m with you though, raised beds give me my best results. Well done 👏👏

[@RebanKUB]

Thanks for sharing about garlic

[@sharonousmankobo3602]

Thank you for this most educating video on growing garlic. I'm going to have raised beds installed soon so I look forward to it. I've been struggling growing garlic in the ground.

[@johnjude2685]

Suggest you plant Gian sunflower and cut at soil in fall and plant tomatoes in its root ball in spring it will be almost no work and make most tomatoes

[@erikawoods8975]

Excellent comparison, thank you Jill! Do you have a follow up video showing how to properly cure garlic from harvest? I’m in North Texas and harvested my garlic three weeks ago. I didn’t do it right and it almost rotted 😭

[@bronwendemmocks7569]

Great video thanks. My garlic is just starting to poke up out of the ground here in New Zealand.

[@poodledaddles1091]

I love seeing the comparisons!

[@scetchport]

Just subbd, looking forward to going through your vids. Thanks heaps !

[@cindylangford5335]

My grow bag garlic did the same thing! Although I blamed it on the nest of baby bunnies I found in it! 🤪

[@MrsLiz]

Hmm interesting... maybe that grow bag was too small for that many or didn't get as much water?🤔 Fun to watch your expirement though!😎🤙

[@rustee80]

Excellent Video! Thanks! Looking forward to the hardneck harvest. When do you plan to do that? Also, what varieties of softneck and hardneck are you most successful with?

[@lindalyc]

hi, Jill: I really like that light blue cart you put in harvested garlic. can you provide the link where I can order it? thanks

[@marilynbarrett1804]

Hi Jill, nice harvest. Tell me, do you plant onions and potatoes in the fall as well? I think I might try some for the first time this fall.

[@thebeginnersgarden]

Not for overwintering, no. I am doing a fall potato test (I just planted those this week). And our winters are too cold to grow onions through the winter in zone 7b.

[@riskmanagement9106]

What state are you in it looks very nice?

[@tiffanynelson3829]

I have brought some garlic to plant this fall. Granted now that I already committed to it I'm wondering how well garlic does with some below freezing temps and some mountain snow in the winter as I live in east TN. Can they handle the snow cover?

[@quinnlynch1071]

Did you cut back on watering in the last weeks before harvest? I’ve read you were supposed. I saw that you interplanted with peppers and wondered if you adjusted your watering.

[@thebeginnersgarden]

No, we get plenty of rain in the spring usually so often I don’t turn on my irrigation til it’s almost ready to harvest anyway.

[@alan-dr8uo]

What happens to the garlic if it doesn't get harvested

[@Orsucci82]

I love your videos very much but this really wasn't a fair comparison. The ones grown in the grow bags were planted way to close especially when you consider they were elephant garlic. That is one reason they were so small. The ones in the ground seemed quite crowded with the beans/tomatoes. Garlic needs space to fully develop.

[@growingwithpanda6935]

Wait what you planted these in spring... wow impressive I've been a Growing my own food for over 30 years. What date did you plant these garlic

[@Beaguins]

The bulbs harvested in this video were planted in the fall. The spring-planted garlic isn't ready yet.

[@thebeginnersgarden]

All of the ones I harvested were planted in the fall, around November 1st give or take, which is my average first frost date.

[@growingwithpanda6935]

Gotcha coz I was like what wait.. lol.. thanks 4 taking the time to reply. I was curious.

[@robbonvini2295]

When curing your garlic, have you compared results between hanging them bulb-up vs bulb-down? I've seen it done both ways (always bulb-up for me) but wondering if there is a difference. Thank you.

[@thebeginnersgarden]

I have not, but I've wondered the same thing!

[@VertigoBear]

What is your growing medium in the raised beds? You mentioned compost….is it straight compost or mixed with something else? Thank you.😊

[@thebeginnersgarden]

Those particular beds were an experiment in different raised bed soil mixes I did several years ago. Since then, I've topped them with straight compost and shredded leaves. Here's the info on the original raised bed soil test: journeywithjill.net/gardening/2020/03/09/3-raised-bed-soil-mixes-compared/

[@looksirdroids9134]

Elephant garlic isn't garlic.