Genesis - One for the Vine

[@waveoflight]

Watching this really blows my mind at how such music can be produced at all. It is hard to comprehend.

[@bobbywillis1466]

waveoflight tony said it took him about a year to write it.

[@drj602]

Tony Banks 😊

[@EixtremeDrummer]

One of the most epic Genesis songs after PG leaving. Thanks for the gift.

[@MICHAELSTEPHENROGERS]

That was inbelievable.....This was one of Tonys masterpieces and you completely nailed it !!! I play a keyboard but I will never be able to achieve that level of performance.....A brilliant song superbly performed my friend

[@stokkernk]

Thank you Michael, thank you so much for your words!

[@VasilyMusic]

You will! It really just takes practice. I, too, thought Genesis songs were impossible to play, but after some months of practice I could handle some of their harder tunes. I'm sure you'll be able to play it one day. Believe in yourself!

[@bornon221269]

amazing performance!! BRAVO! a song like this will never NEVER be composed again anymore in the history of music I'm afraid, and I'm surprised this was not covered by more people on piano by the great amount of virtuoso piano players genesis fans

[@stokkernk]

I'm surprised too! thank you!!

[@joer3481]

bornon221269 timeless music

[@jobvink]

it's really stunning. You fully captured Tony Banks, whilst incorporating Phil Collins' vocals on your piano. outstanding performance!

[@stokkernk]

Thank you so much for your comment Job, really appreciated!!!

[@raelscage32]

Superb! A wonderfully executed rendition and an insightful arrangement of one of Tony's best compositions. Congratulations.

[@stokkernk]

thankyou so much!!

[@bobbywillis1466]

I still don’t understand how this was written by a human being. It’s so complex yet so beautiful.

[@oddities-whatnot]

Fantastic. I dont read music but used to play a lot of Genesis on the piano 20 years ago. Probably forgot how now :(

[@stokkernk]

thankyou you Simon! I play by ear too, I don't read music.

[@TheDeadeye42]

This made a hard day much better. Thank you.

[@stokkernk]

I'm very happy for this! thank you so much!

[@mrnelgin]

I was expecting some crappy version of this long and complex song...but wow...did you nail this one, not only the performance but the arrangement. I wish I had just a drop of your talent. Thanks for sharing with us.

[@gordonturke4171]

Think I might of said this because ,I really like this tune from genesis and you are doing amazing. Job on it, this tune reminds me of my holidays in The Gambia, nice

[@Aquatarkus96]

I'm getting a bit of a Debussy kinda vibe in the first part of the song with those repeated block chords. Very pretty interpretation!

[@cheefr0berts]

You're welcome. I am so impressed that I sent a link to my dad who is a school music teacher and piano teacher. Here is what he had to say: "Thank you. I listened to it just now and your mum heard it as well. Takes me back a bit and I was singing along in my head and also imagining the Genesis version at the same time. A very musical piece of music and well arranged and performed. Makes me feel like finding the album again if I can and buying the sheet music"

[@TheLanternOfShame]

Wow... it took me 10 years to find this video. Perfection.

[@michaelreeves3637]

I'm amazed an)t how many times I visit KZbin, mindlessly click on videos like this, then feel like I was treated to a gift just for me. I know I'm not the only person who feels this way, so thank you for sharing this with everyone.

[@stokkernk]

Thank _you_ Michael, for this wonderful thought.

[@marticus61lau]

I guess I'm about 10 years late to comment. Just saw this. What a wonderful job you've done here. I am a Genesis fan from Duke onward (and subsequently went back in time to discover all of their earlier work). I am a musician/vocalist. I am in a Genesis tribute group based in London, Ontario, Canada. This is my favourite Genesis piece if I had to choose just one. You've really capture the feel Tony intended. Just wonderful. Bravo!

[@stokkernk]

Thankyou so much! I play Genesis tunes every day, and I discover every day something I've never notice before. Their music is amazing, a never ending treasure. I'm a composer myself, and this year Steve Hackett recorded a solo on one of my composition for The Samurai of Prog. What a gift! If you want to ear something simply search for Inner Prospekt on Bandcamp. Do you have some video on you tube of your band playing Genesis?

[@marticus61lau]

@@stokkernk yes.... there are a number of them under GL Fountains of Salmacis, Squonk, Firth of Fifth and other earlier works of the group. These are rehearsals, some a first run so best to keep that in mind. Again, keep up the fantastic work.

[@marticus61lau]

A start - kzbin.info/www/bejne/e6jEmpijYtSlg7M

[@stokkernk]

Thank you very much Jurgen. Yes, I love the original indeed, it's one of my favourite Genesis songs. And with this tribute I wanted to thank you Genesis, and Tony Banks for a music that is part of my life. Happy you enjoy it!

[@VasilyMusic]

Superb!! As a keyboardist, maybe one day I'll also make a cover version of it. What a song, Jesus. I hope I had just a speck of Tony Banks' talent...

[@hrebolledoc5159]

I always thought this is really a small piano concerto, one of the finest moments of TB, it has several movements and really is a trip for the soul, man..you really captured the soul of this gem, thanks ...thanks, & congrats for your talent to create this rendition ....(much more than a cover)

[@stokkernk]

Thank you so much Rusty Player!!

[@blackfish590]

GOOSEBUMPS!! Great Job.

[@rogerrodrigues3528]

Perfeito...e muito Obrigado, por tão magnífico trabalho...Amei!❤️🎶🎸

[@aldos7985]

You've made me dream and ease myself away from the tiring and tearing down reality! This is a great rendition of a gem that not many people discovered and you've accomplished it perfectly! Bravo! Alex from Greece

[@stokkernk]

Alex, thank you so much for your words, you've made my day. Hope your reality change in better! Thank you again!

[@funklover24]

This version is phantastic and worth to be played on a good acoustic grand piano.

[@stokkernk]

Thank you so much!

[@MrPopsmk]

Being a Genesis fan this made me so happy. Kudos to you. Effortless playing. Tony Banks would have been proud of this

[@stargate1555]

You have the gift of music. Natural talent? or hours of rehearsals? It's all the same. Signed: Fellow keyboardist. Just do what you love to do. I do. Well done sir!

[@stokkernk]

Thank you so much Stargate, I am actually self-taught and there are definitely hours and hours of practice. I know I don't play like a real pianist, but the love for music, and for Genesis, works wonders!

[@lunymoony4062]

One for the upload......

[@Eldanoth]

Non avevo mai sentito questa tua interpretazione... di questo..... capolavoro! Solo uno che l'ama con tutta l'anima la può suonare in questo modo. Ti dico solo questo aggiungendo che non mi commuovevo da molto tempo per una tale bellezza. Se avessi i soldi ti regalerei un V-Piano che sarebbe appena all'altezza della tua magnifica prestazione. Continua :,) P.S. (mad man moon, entangled, ripples...)

[@Eleventhearlofmars]

One of the many great songs genesis crafted, nice bit of playing mate😉

[@niteoul529]

Ahh... Breathtaking... It just takes me to another world. Thank you, so much!

[@АндрейКришнамурти]

Sumptuously! The best piano execution I've ever heard!

[@frankslade33]

Amazing cover. One of the greatest songs I think. The chord at 3.44 is just perfect, Banks was/is a genius.

[@markstanger3274]

What an awesome 👌 rendition of one for the vine. You nailed that,man!!!!simply beautiful. 😊

[@xxYOURBIJOUxx]

WOW! I take a bow for you Sir. Simply awesome.....

[@bobbywillis1466]

Thank you so much! Now I can learn to play one of the best genesis songs ever written.

[@2raben]

So much talent. It's already a hard piece to play just looking at sheet music. To do this on memory and with such precision, accuracy, and nuance...I'm in awe.

[@taraxxxx987]

ur a GENIUS!!!! Im a big fan of genesis since their beginning! Now.. listening to you it seems to be in 1976 at their concert! you are gr8! thx from my heart from ITALY!!! :)

[@BigMike246]

excellent! One of my favorite Genesis tunes.

[@antoniodifiore31]

Really great

[@stokkernk]

Grazie mille Antonio!

[@gustavobren]

Espectacular!! Bravo!!!

[@stepa9721]

Uno dei miei pezzi preferiti dei mitici Genesis...reso in modo favoloso!!!! bravissimo!!!!!

[@usa67able]

Very well done! I'm a big Genesis fan and you've done this justice. I'm always encouraged by people perpetuate good music.

[@stokkernk]

Thank you very much!

[@michito46]

@stokkernk Gracias a vos por dedicarle el tiempo suficiente para escucharlo, aprenderlo y tocarlo. Ademas, ese tema, tiene algo especial y es uno de los que mas me gustan.

[@rhodsieau]

Thank you so very much , I remember the feeling I got when I bought this album ,it had just come out and was unbelievable, upon listening to you I got the same feeling ,you are very talented ,thank you again

[@stokkernk]

Thank you so much Neil.

[@vannelli100]

Fantastic thanks for this emotion

[@stokkernk]

Grazie a te Sergio per il commento!

[@vannelli100]

Mad Crayon azz pure Italiano? Orgoglio allora 😝

[@stokkernk]

ahah, grazie :)

[@MrHudson111]

A fantastic rendition of a fantastic Genesis song, you have my utter most respect, as i also love to play the great Genesis music, but you are in a completely different league. to me. Please post more Genesis

[@stefanodemartinis]

Che dire...i complimenti sono poco. Mi hai regalato un'emozione talmente profonda che mi sono messo a studiarlo per poterlo suonare, non di certo al tuo livello. Bravo davvero, sei riuscito a trasmettere il soul dei Genesis in uno dei loro periodi più interessanti. 😉💪💪💪

[@widzco]

since this album, I loved genesis

[@stanleykarwacki1099]

Beautiful!! Fantastic job. One of my all time favorite Genesis songs.

[@stokkernk]

+Stanley Karwacki Thank you Stanley!

[@javierfilgueira]

Maravilloso !!!!!! Your playing is FABULOUS !!! Thank you for this !!!

[@stokkernk]

Jape Music thank you!!!

[@krissyrose14]

Bravo! Excellent work, and great expression on the piano. After listening to this, I want to listen to the studio version. My favorite song on Wind and Wuthering.

[@stokkernk]

Oh, thank you very much guys!!! As soon as I can I'll watch and listen to your work, and I'll give you my feedback with pleasure. Thank you again!

[@badrogue66]

Great job on this . Was a pleasure to listen to. You have the longest fingers Ive ever seen too .

[@donstefanogreco4276]

BE AU TI FUL ! bravissimo, Tony Banks would be very proud of your arrangement! :) THANKS

[@ginises83]

WONDERFUL !!!! you are the best !!!! please another song of Genesis ....for exemple ....Mad man moon .....thank you so much

[@edub1961]

GREAT VERSION, GREAT ARRANGEMENT. CONGRATULATIONS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

[@stokkernk]

Eduardo Bermudez thankyou!!!!

[@ancoralucio]

Resa tutta l'intensità di questo pezzo, non era facile! complimenti vivissimi!

[@stokkernk]

Grazie Mario, molto gentile!

[@stokkernk]

Grazie a te, thanks to you, very very much, for your wonderful words!! And best from Italy!!

[@emmanuellepoulichet5371]

Amazing. My favorite Genesis song, and what you do with it awesome. Thanks.

[@stokkernk]

Thank you so much Emmanuel

[@paviomuniz]

Bravo, congratulations, thank you so much!!!

[@stokkernk]

@MrHudson111 Thank you very very much MrHudson! It's an honour to receive such a wonderful opinion from a british genesis lover like you! I'll post more Genesis, sure, I love their music: I'll play soon (I hope!) In the cage solo, cinema show instrumental, After the ordeal...

[@BassBusMusic]

This sends the shivers through me as much as the original does. First class work.

[@gyppy1715]

beautiful job ---Tony is a genius.

[@romfordtony]

Beautiful playing

[@andywright8803]

Excellent my friend. Am I the only one to notice the Wind and Wuthering CD on the footstool?

[@stokkernk]

ah ah, I don't think! Thank you so much!

[@reneelyons6836]

I have soooooo much LOVE for this. Beautiful!!!!!!!!

[@stokkernk]

Thank you so much Renee!!!

[@reneelyons6836]

@@stokkernk You're Welcome. Just a fantastic masterpiece.

[@tomjobimforever]

Really awsome, beautifull... impressive, this the best version anywhere... congratulations. you made my day. Keep the good work.

[@iallcroft]

Lovely arrangement of one of Banks' finest.... bravo... could listen to it over and over. Many thanks for posting, and I'm not ashamed to say I'll be practicing this one. Quite excellent.

[@keyboarddancers]

Absolutely fascinating! I learned the intro of Firth of Fifth by ear many years ago in my teens (although I started in the key of C major which is all wrong, LoL!). I did study piano classically to a reasonable standard and I managed a few bars of this piece again by ear but I never got anywhere near to this superb rendition. I'm deeply deeply impressed with the amount of work you've put into this piece. Wonderful and bravo!

[@stokkernk]

Oh, I played Firth intro (not so well) in C major for years!!:) When I wanted to study the real thing, it was so hard to "delete" my old automations... I play everything by ear, so memory is essential. Sometimes it's a friend, sometimes an enemy:) Thank you so much for your comment.

[@windwardpro]

Awesome! Brilliant! Super accurate. (All except the middle section transition) I almost guarantee you won't find ANYONE interpreting it more accurately on youtube than this. It would be great to hear this on a real grand piano! Be all the more impressive.

[@anthonyseregichev2917]

Great perfomance and thorough work! Banks is genial composer!

[@Mobilitydnb]

One of my absolute favorite Genesis songs and very well played! With help from your insightful video, I've started practicing this one on piano myself. A real challenge, since I'm not classically trained at all. But persistence pays off, or so I keep telling myself ;)

[@stokkernk]

Absolutely! Keep going! I'm not classically trained and I don't read music, but I love Genesis:) Thank you for the comment!

[@handsfree1000]

Excellent and entertaining performance, thank you

[@stokkernk]

Thank you Peter!

[@CanadaMikeB]

Beautiful... gave me chills in its purity

[@stokkernk]

Thank you so much Mike!

[@cesarnobre6506]

Fantástico!!!!Congrats!!!!

[@stokkernk]

+César Nobre Thank you!!!

[@richardbloemenkamp8532]

I like this video a lot. It's a song that I like and seeing the piano finger positioning it is really nice to follow the fingers and hear in your head the notes of each note pressed.

[@jamiemcneil3092]

Amazing version and love the keyboard and the sound.

[@greggrubin3475]

Just beautiful, and faithful to the entire arrangement. Bravo.

[@stokkernk]

thank you so much Gregg, very kind of you.

[@anne-mariebridoux8456]

Salut ouah...super version d’une très belle chanson de Genesis...l’interprétation et la performance sont incroyables ...l’arrangement...au TOP ! Bravo et merci ! 👍👏👋❣🇧🇪

[@stokkernk]

merci beaucoup Anne-Marie pour ces belles paroles. Je joue souvent cette chanson, même aujourd'hui je l'ai fait, et quand j'ai fini j'ai pensé que c'était vraiment l'une des meilleures chansons jamais écrites.

[@anne-mariebridoux8456]

@@stokkernk Avec plaisir,c’est sincère ! Pour moi,toutes les chansons de Genesis sont belles...mais certaines nous parlent et nous touchent plus que d’autres...notamment One for the Vine! Encore bravo et bonne continuation...🙂😘🌞

[@stokkernk]

@@anne-mariebridoux8456 Grazie infinite! Alessandro

[@poetwayne]

I love this! Sch a sensitive interpretation... I'm sure Tony Banks would be proud! I've written a poem to this music, loosely structured on the Genesis lyrics, but with an entirely different message.

[@MrRavercomp]

Hermosa interpretación de este gran tema de Genesis, felicitaciones por tu buen gusto musical.

[@stokkernk]

Grazie tante!!!!

[@hillshepherd9444]

Unfrickin' Believable !!!!! It's 2019 now , still great after 8 years. Great Job !!!!!!!

[@stokkernk]

All day I have your words in mind! Thank you so much Hill!

[@kennethbobu3989]

Bravo! Bravissimo!! Grazie!!

[@Muziq4tune]

Absolutely Brilliant!!!

[@jurgenfriedrich1146]

Many congratulations to your work. I was able to hear that your hear and love the original in your brain during you play it. All structures was found in your arrangement. Greetings Jürgen, Germany

[@ze_rubenator]

Excellent! I have to learn this now!

[@Nito654]

Está canción no es fácil de ejecutar ya que tiene muchos cambios de acordes y tiempos ... espectacular, sigue así!!😊

[@leleobhz]

Great performance and skill! Thanks for you video!

[@stokkernk]

Thankyou Leonardo!

[@stokkernk]

Thank you very much Mark, you're very kind! I'll listen to your music, you have a very interesting channel!

[@Fallon144]

Man this is simply amazing. Perfect execution. greets frm holland

[@michaelpugh4894]

Beautifully done. I have all of Genesis albums except the most recent.

[@martinpickard6043]

Well done sir. Amazing interpretation, skilfully played.

[@stokkernk]

Thank you very much Martin!

[@Hammill56]

Great job, thank you!

[@Scarpett]

Wonderful!!! You're simply fantastic and almost made me cry! best from Brazil and "grazzie" for your sensibility and talent!

[@fryderyk2462]

Great arrangement!!!!

[@sidewinder040]

Wow! I'm amazed

[@fantasmahomem]

Majestic music, majestic tribute!!! I never seen nothing like this!

[@MarkCeeney]

Amazing performance.

[@ThomasStrasbaugh]

Stunned, enjoyed the heck out of this!

[@cheefr0berts]

Incredible performance. I like how you really stayed true to the original. Well done Sir!

[@claudiogardiasz9792]

Sos un genio , lo tocas perfecto , el mismo feeling de Tony Banks , felicitaciones

[@stokkernk]

Thank you so much Claudio! Ciao da Roma, Italia!