Germany's lessons learned from the 2015 refugee crisis | DW News

[@RollyBalondo]

the difference is. the old migration was mostly men who left their women. now is mostly women who left their men to fight the injustice.

[@jacekwrobel5099]

Exactly 👍

[@troll_zizipiano2kiev]

No the difference is the hypocrisy behind this. Ukrainian are whites, not Afghans or Syrians or Yemenis... if men leave their wife behind it's because they don't come with trains, airplanes or buses. They come on foot thru mountains and valleys. I wouldn't send my wife and kids to the unknown. I'll go myself first then call my family after... Ukrainian men are sending their wives to Europe not knowing where they are or who they will be with.

[@peggybauer6570]

your not a man or a woman.

[@user-uv7wn1gh4n]

True

[@NickiUn]

True, I love Ukrainians for their courage. They stand in war and Europe is watching fearing a world war when interfering. So that is the least that what can we do.

[@The_Savage_Wombat]

There's a big difference when a neighboring country with similar people is invaded by a madman vs radically different culture fleeing civil war.

[@МиколаРиндя]

Another thing, from Middle East came young and adult healthy males, which can build their own country at home, but they dont want it, they want to stay in Germany and live for germans money. And from Ukraine are fleeing only womens, their childrens and older people because ukrainian males are not permitted to go out the country for war time. Most of them will return in Ukraine. And those who dont have european mindset, and would work for Germany's economy

[@hishamalaker491]

you do realize that a civil war is more deadly than someone invading you.

[@california816]

@@hishamalaker491 ...And?

[@HariKrishna-ix2in]

​@@california816 West started civil war in middle east.

[@california816]

@@HariKrishna-ix2in K

[@f5rwall]

It is not due to Germany's effort. There is a difference between Syria and Ukraine.

[@solidfuel0]

They both got bombed by Russia

[@brushemteeth9159]

Where is the difference?

[@f5rwall]

@@brushemteeth9159 look at Ukraine in the last 20 years and Syria for the same time period. Compare what they have achieved in economy, culture, society etc

[@12tanuha21]

@@melinagoranson Religion, geography, government, history

[@blitzkriegedvanhauten5261]

@@melinagoranson 🤓🤓

[@ericafiore1624]

Ukraine getting out the mothers and children and the whole of Europe taking these war mothers and children is heroic in it's self.

[@Chriscs7]

People from Ukraine are very polite, highly educated professionally and culturally and religion more similar to Germany and rest of the Europe so there is no surprise they are welcomed strongly. Have earned the respect all these years

[@ОльгаБендзар]

I am a Ukrainian who currently lives in Ukraine. On the one hand, I am grateful for all the help you provide my people with. On the other hand, I am very mad at the Germany and Germans because lack of MILITARY HELP. If you and Europe in a whole would not be so dependent on russian oil and gas (and our government very creaming about it since 2014!!!!!!!!!!) russia will not have the finance to support this war. Of course, you welcome Ukrainians as you've said - polite, highly educated professionally and culturally and religion more similar to Germany and white. Everyone wants us BUT on manual jobs!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! Read my post above. We do not need you to accept us, we need you to cut off russia from oil supply, ban Nord Stream 2 , and give us weapon real weapons. do not steek my people as a slave for unattractive jobs!!!!!!!!!! this is what we Ukrainians think Europe is doing. And the pettiness is that Europe wins in any case because you get mostly young people and children to support your economy and substitute with the old generation. You do not make us a benefit/ You use us for your own benefit as well. And conclusion - germans shall get rid of their Stockholm syndrome and show their morale by punishing russia not compromising with her.

[@AvocadoLena]

@@ОльгаБендзар Do you even have any basic knowledge? Germany is already cutting of Russian resources since the begging of the war. It’s countries like China and India who are now cooperating with Russia. Also, Germany has absolutely nothing to do with this war, why should we fight with an army that can’t even protect it’s own country? Why especially Germany and not any other country? We pay the Ukraine lots of money already which, if you didn’t know, is also a very big reason why Germany is currently suffering under inflation, we can’t afford anything anymore. And no, we don’t need you as workers. In fact, every Ukrainian has the right to get welfare. Welfare includes a house, enough money to live and school education and payments from the government for special occasions like school trips etc. And you know who pays for that? The working class via higher taxes due to the war. A stable working class that can even run a country that spends money for your war to safe your people. Shame on you, really!

[@skully170]

@@ОльгаБендзар hope you undestand that we are afraid to be military involved, it will instantly start a III word nuclear war..

[@necromorph1109]

Germany wont have issues helping and assimilating Ukrainians they have similar culture and the Ukrainians are not part of a conservative religion.

[@thekaiser4333]

Ukrainians have a very conservative religion, so according to you we should not let them in.

[@bottlerocket2528]

Ukrainians dont have nearly as many radical extremists or people with views incompatible with a free democracy.

[@thekaiser4333]

@@luke2026 But that is what he meant.

[@Daguhl]

"assimilating" 10 seconds of using google and you can read that germany has ukraine teachers too. but keep up trash talking.

[@kukulroukul4698]

yeah , yeah and im ... Harvard graduate eating mash mellows now

[@davidhookway514]

They are European, and many will return home after the war.

[@kukulroukul4698]

oups ! realy ? NO WAY ! ...:)))

[@geoffsimpkins7650]

@@kukulroukul4698 Ukrainians love being Ukraine

[@gsmmasha]

Exactly, something obvious but not looked at properly in this vid

[@brushemteeth9159]

1) So what? 2) How do you know?

[@tatymax7293]

Ukrainians? No way.

[@murko1630]

"This is a conflict next to Europe"? Are you kidding me?

[@prinzeugenius7907]

for this liberal pathetic shill the EU is the equivalent to Europe

[@thewholetruth5473]

This channel heavily deletes comments that contain too much truth.

[@prinzeugenius7907]

thats democracy and freedom of speech in Germany for you

[@celiaowen2444]

Also because Ukrainians are essentially European and should have been allowed to join the EU Years ago. They have been a democracy for 30 years.

[@kukulroukul4698]

that doesnt make you a German !!! keep up with you're studying more fervently

[@jessicaandersson4313]

They need to sort out their high levels of corruption first and do something about their dodgy legal system

[@ASK-ko9qx]

Democracy is fallacy used by many corrupt countries. It does not make you a free country.

[@brushemteeth9159]

So being a white European gives your more rights? That's called white priviledge.

[@strife2746]

@@brushemteeth9159 Europe for Europeans.

[@aliancemd]

Romania and Moldova employed Ukrainian teachers to teach the children. It looks like Germany doesn't plan this to be temporary and made them learn German and integrate into the society.

[@raspberries97]

Russia will not stop the war or some of the territories will be occupied. Most of Ukrainian citizens, fleeing now, will stay in the EU, and it'll be right

[@raempftl]

Reports like this are never able to show every aspect… In Germany they are also hiring Ukrainian teachers. But those welcome classes are already in place so why not use them?

[@Daguhl]

10 seconds of using google and you can read that germany has ukraine teachers too. but keep up trash talking.

[@kukulroukul4698]

@@Daguhl pffff :)))) u worm

[@Daguhl]

@@kukulroukul4698 say that into my face you wannabe :D it was clear that small children like you can't use google

[@manojpoddar7555]

I think all nations of NATO should support Ukraine and stop Russia's aggression and countries with terrorism need to overtaken by better countries in order to make it safe

[@katiestans2824]

Is Iraq and Afghanistan better off now that they are free of dictators. Maybe it should be up to the people that live in those countries who they want as their leaders. They have to live there.

[@cryptocrypto8736]

I think we must all be neutral an give them food an medics

[@joexavier8870]

Lol🤣

[@headhunterkonyak4337]

And who are you to decide who is in occupation, who is the oppressor, who are terrorist and who are freedom fighter

[@charlesinglis517]

@Katie Stans So, I’m not here defend the USA’s intervention in the Middle East, but I would like to point out that dictators by their very nature do not let the people choose their leaders.

[@cartoons981]

different groups of people with different beliefs in one country its MULTI VERSE of chaos . eventually .. certain race or population removed or extinct from that land . nothing new

[@Judah132]

They are practically the same people and are historically, culturally and geopolitically within the same sphere of interests as the EU - They come from a democracy, and are polite. Obviously this is strategically a better situation than with Syrians, Nigerians or Afghans, not saying all Nigerians, Afghans or Syrians are unpolite, however judging from statistics immigrants from within Europe are easier to integrate than immigrants outside of Europe. I'm not saying this is good, this is just the geopolitical reason why for instance Poland or Hungary are playing balls this time.

[@florianfelix8295]

hmmm maybe that they are not actively prohibited from integrating by caving them into „ankerzentren“ and even prohibited from working doesn’t help

[@lordaskiamohanmend6335]

where they come from people are being killed for speaking against the government

[@solidfuel0]

Slavic and German tribes are the same people historically and culturally?? How can anyone has access to Internet and be so rtrded

[@brushemteeth9159]

No, the reason is that they are racist and only want white people in their country.

[@Judah132]

@@florianfelix8295 In Eastern Germany that is

[@jimspencer6677]

Mercal made a devastating mess of everything. Look at her she was useless

[@8peterp]

come up with something against housing crisis on EU level caused by money printing and debt speculation ,otherwise far right will come back big time

[@ricardobarahona3939]

Wrong and not enough will done on housing by any of the parties anytime soon.

[@lifesign123]

Are there any Germans left in Germany?

[@strife2746]

Not if this keeps up.

[@MsLarrythegreat]

Herr Gott lass Hirn regnen!

[@shanthiduraiswamy6085]

very sad.

[@Kartoffelsuppe_m_Wursteinlage]

Define Germans.

[@strife2746]

@@Kartoffelsuppe_m_Wursteinlage Caucasians with a western mentality. I can just tell from a mile away what your next comment is gonna be like and that's not gonna happen. Turn the computer off and do something productive.

[@dcooper6329]

I never see cultural interrogation from Germany. Only language intergrations. I personally witness as Asylum seeker..

[@sudeepkumar4757]

Dear DW, Germany gives billions of dollars to Russia for gas and oil

[@Daguhl]

I like it warm

[@ccc771]

well done peace loving people in Germany keep going!

[@AstatiumMr]

The Netherlands free money every month paid by the government and houses. Only thing is get accepted for the assylum quit job after receiving free house.

[@azhershareef4436]

If you don’t see racism in this video, then perhaps you are racist

[@rollingdownfalling]

Great short documentary.

[@Iceyfire12]

It’ll be interesting when you go to Germany you’ll barely see any Germans. It’ll look like the UK soon enough.

[@williampatrickfagan7590]

Wait till 50,000 Indians arrieve in UK.

[@akteno2796]

What?

[@williampatrickfagan7590]

@@akteno2796 The Blond One is over there looking for a trade deal. Everything has a price. The price of this trade deal is 50,000 work visas for Indian citizens to fill vacent jobs.

[@williampatrickfagan7590]

@Tagedieb I'm with you on that.

[@williampatrickfagan7590]

@@Carma123 As a mariner might say, any port in a storm.

[@mygame4451]

The old woman who destroyed

[@akteno2796]

Lessons learned: Fortress EVROPA! We decide who gets in. And others from our naiborhood have a Prerogative.

[@ricardobarahona3939]

Cringe

[@akteno2796]

@@ricardobarahona3939 cope.

[@kylerittenhousecommieslaye4752]

Of course they have a prerogative. They Europeans.

[@목포가변하고있다]

Provide Ukraine with aggressive war weapons quickly, don't just talk.

[@radicalgreek99]

Should have never allowed anyone in

[@ricardobarahona3939]

Nah

[@matjust5970]

This is a common emotion shared by many people (the right wingers)in the NATO countries. The cost of war.

[@necromorph1109]

Look at Sweden ..Paradise spoiled . Liberal Democracies cant help but bring people in that will undo decades of work.

[@53evi]

And when the Greeks fled all over Europe ????

[@matjust5970]

നമ്മളും അവരും. Which means we and them. This is been the nature of human beings as a species from the day we walked on this planet. This can be seen in many micro levels as well.

[@KennyNGA]

the lesson learned is everything with a skin tone darker than italians is not very welcome here

[@dimm7448]

You mean single dudes with criminal records

[@Janoip]

nice

[@Janoip]

Not true Asians and South Americans, some Arab states are also ok. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯

[@brushemteeth9159]

True.

[@strife2746]

Nothing wrong with that.

[@kukulroukul4698]

Geeezz ! :)))) Whats the matter with you guys ! i mean i know what dystopian means but... this is another level

[@dungnguyen-vx2sc]

Why Slobodan Milosevic not be EU give Human Rights

[@thomasboyd755]

Germany help Ukraine politically Thomas. Germany support Art Bezrukavenko Ukraine. Awesome. Excellent channel. Danke.

[@user-qt1eo7dq8v]

QUIZ: ‘What does SLS mean in the German context?’ ‘Eh, Staunch Leader Scholtz?’ ‘Sorry wrong answer; it means Sulky Liver Sausage.’

[@goosegander3747]

This is how we build back better.

[@ciprianiulian6575]

This zombies are distroying Germany

[@Janoip]

@@ciprianiulian6575 nah

[@ciprianiulian6575]

@@Janoip yes. They are

[@Janoip]

@@ciprianiulian6575 how? Wir brauchen doch einige Arbeitskräfte, diese hier haben immerhin zu einem viel höheren Prozentwert Abschlüsse, Ausbildungen etc. Wie im Osten üblich viele Gesundheitsarbeiter (Pfleger, Ärzte etc.) Und sie passen besser zu uns als ein Nigerianer, Marokkaner oder Afghane.

[@ciprianiulian6575]

@@Janoip English, please...

[@acecarroll3382]

Love your programs god bless you

[@harukrentz435]

feels like im watching CNA here

[@yurigansmith]

You mean 'Channel News Asia'? How come?

[@ΑΛΕΞΙΟΥΠΑΝΑΓΙΩΤΗΣ]

γιατι στην ελλαδα δεν βλεπουμε dw και βλεπουμε ερτ1.τι ειναι αυτο ε

[@objectdefiance4027]

Cause Greece Is less Important To the German State Run Media Company. While in Greece Our State Run Media Will Focus on Us.

[@zahid1909]

Germany showed the world how to accomplish the greatest work God has wanted all humans to do; love and extend help to the people who are in distress. Salute Germany! God bless you!

[@strife2746]

Germany made the worst mistake in their life. Wherever you are, stay there. You're not welcome in Europe.

[@claudiu1261]

Nein!

[@headhunterkonyak4337]

Good till shariya take over 😂😂😂

[@randywenrichjr9228]

In 1776 we fought! Ihr seid Feidlinger! Kammf!

[@joexavier8870]

In 2022 whole world understand what is the real meaning of western hypocrisy...

[@kugul1683]

They were unprepared and had no prior experience in the 2015 one 🤦‍♂️

[@TeddyKrimsony]

@@kugul1683 and in 2021?

[@angelmario7085]

@@kugul1683 Why afgans runs to Europe and don't fight against Taliban?! Rhetorical question! 😅

[@Daguhl]

@@angelmario7085 Why don't you fight against the Taliban and continue to talk about such below-average intelligent nonsense? Rhetorical question! :D

[@hypegamer2362]

@@Daguhl BCS it's not my country that's infested by Taliban hence non of my problem.

[@ccc771]

We all need to get along and we all need to stop living in fear of each-other. Micheal Jackson was right.

[@翁古-r6r]

❤️🌟 In recent years,disasters have occurred frequently and anomalies have appeared one after another,You must confess your sins and repent,I hope that those who have not yet trusted in Jesus and God can trust in Jesus and God as soon as possible,Confess your sins and repent as soon as possible.2000 years ago, light came to the world,Jesus Christ came to the world.The Word became flesh and appeared before people's eyes.He was crucified for the sins of people.He was resurrected on the third day, and then He ascended to heaven and sat at the right hand of God. If you sincerely trust Jesus Christ and accept Him as the Savior of your life, you will receive the Holy Spirit.Then, you must obey the Holy Spirit, rely on the guidance of the Holy Spirit to act and behave, and be a person who pleases God. But the fruit of the Spirit is love, joy, peace, forbearance, kindness, goodness, faithfulness, gentleness and self-control. Against such things there is no law. -Galatians 5 : 22 - 23 Don’t delay, you should immediately trust Jesus Christ and God!

[@drlobomalo]

Get ready for some really astounding disingenuousness and obfuscation.

[@laribeeadams9142]

Iron and clay will never mix. Read the book of Daniel.

[@jules151968]

@@melinagoranson Are you a fool.

[@strife2746]

@@melinagoranson No. He just wants to preserve his culture.

[@martinsudeh1965]

Crisis is a bad thing

[@jabukatshwa]

Double standards

[@yesremember]

Look like USA! It good for Future.

[@dodyputra3432]

Vote afd

[@АнатолийИванов-м2ш]

Зачем путин поддерживает Германию? Почему он не отключает газ немцам?

[@Daguhl]

Weil Russland ohne deutsches Geld einfach arm sind. :D

[@zofiapatulska4824]

Good question💪👍😎

[@АнатолийИванов-м2ш]

@@Daguhl так вы украли наши деньги! И теперь хотите получать ресурсы бесплатно! И без ваших денег мы обойдёмся! У нас нет ваших товаров!

[@anna_anechka]

Может отключает потихоньку. Вентиль тугой.

[@bobcatthekittykat1075]

To cleaning foots.

[@TH-bj1pb]

Lol 🛐

[@КонстантинСорокин-ж9к]

В стране РФ выстроено государство в котором преследуются Честные люди и оно это государство действует из собственной целесообразности отличной от цивилизованного мира.

[@NickolayEl]

Riiight I can see what civilized human beings you have created by the atrocities your army is leaving behind. Good job, hail Putin!

[@thekaiser4333]

Germany thinks it has learned some important lessons since the country was confronted with a large number of new arrivals in 2015: Close the borders! If that is the right lesson, I am not so sure.... In a few weeks, Syria might be much less radioactive than Germany or Ukraine...

[@thekaiser4333]

@@leojohn6702 Scientific observation makes me think that. Was the world radioactive after Hiroshima? Or was Hiroshima radioactive?

[@fagreed3938]

Какие честные люди?

[@thebitcoinknicksreport5673]

Same here

[@vincentotabor5134]

Germany is the problem of the world from the first world war thin na

[@borntosurvey4919]

Grow up, troll.

[@Daguhl]

No people like you are the real problem

[@Janoip]

No

[@thepretorian5292]

Still more relevant than your country existence

[@patbreitkopf2351]

namaste

[@chrisspeksnijder1717]

Always, always check your prenuntiation of the English vocabulary as a non native English speaker. Especially as German speakers. Like it is of the atmost importance to pay attention to pronounce the German vocabulary.

[@unapatton1978]

And check your own spelling?!

[@Makedonac007]

USA 🇺🇸 CANADA 🇨🇦 OVER ONE HUNDRED YEARS STILL HAVE NOT ... CONGRATS² GERMANY MANY 🇩🇪 SMART ONE' AMEN³

[@Iceyfire12]

Why would they???

[@thomasboyd9861]

England Britain can they do that yes they play part politically in Art Bezrukavenko Ukraine. Danke.

[@sumandey6808]

Everyone else is delivering dialogues on what to do. Only Germany is delivering results! Danke! Liebe aus Indien!

[@caciliawhy5195]

Uh, you forgot Poland.

[@sumandey6808]

@@caciliawhy5195 Oh! Sorry..my bad. Yes! The lovely Polish people. Poland, Romania & other bordering countries! ❤️

[@dodyputra3432]

And srbija too

[@Somali-One]

Germany is the heart ❤️ of the world.

[@marhuny]

How?

[@kukulroukul4698]

more like the funnel

[@luxploded]

Germany didn't take the warnings from Ukrainians and allies seriously and look what we have now. So much to "the heart ❤️ of the world"

[@lordaskiamohanmend6335]

maybe heart of Ukraine , not the world .

[@Janoip]

@@marhuny He is not completely wrong, Germany had the strongest passport with the most visa free countries until 2019 (now top2/3). Has one of the most diplomatic missions. Germany has no direct enemy, theoretically not even Russia. We have at least basic relations with almost every country, no matter if Iran, North Korea, China etc. Every year 20-50 North Korean scientists, health personnel, etc. come to Germany for training/exchange. Germany has a lot of aid organizations, cultural and educational organizations, which are active even in North Korea. The US, unsurprisingly, comes top when looking at total spend. Last year, it gave over $30 billion either as bilateral aid or through international organizations such as the World Bank or UN. Germany is second, with over $20 billion of ODA last year. This constitutes an increase of over $4 billion compared to 2014. The list is dominated by European nations, but the UAE, Canada and Japan also feature. In addition, Germany makes fewer demands for the funds and lets the countries spend them more freely. Germany has almost always advocated diplomatic solutions. We pay even the Palestinian territorial government a few 100 million in aid and advocate the two-state solution. Even though, unfortunately, it came out that the government there also uses the money for pensions of assassins who attacked Israel. Germany has faced many things from its past and does not deny the bad things, like other countries.

[@harukrentz435]

shameless self acknowledgement

[@Flyingmachines350]

German people are so great! The driving engine behind EU.

[@The_Savage_Wombat]

I hope this will continue despite the radical change in demographics.

[@Flyingmachines350]

@@The_Savage_Wombat you’re absolutely right. EU has to make some collective decisions otherwise they are going further to the left and may fall of the cliff eventually.

[@strife2746]

@@The_Savage_Wombat I hope it won't because of the radical change in demographics.

[@ironheart9627]

all nato nations should accept as many as people its because of nato nations refuges and people fleeing war nations. germany involved in all wars almost like america did. so no way to say no.

[@froglifes6829]

No thats a terrible idea. These nations shouldnt be filled with free loaders and people who dont want to stay in their own country..

[@ironheart9627]

@@froglifes6829 why they become like this in first place half of the problem is their country leaders and other half west fault.

[@kugul1683]

@@ironheart9627 Yeah every single problem in the world this day is the West's fault

[@TeddyKrimsony]

Ukrainians should've taken Germany's peace deal with Russia.

[@kylerittenhousecommieslaye4752]

@@ironheart9627 Stop trying to be white.

[@tawandakyle5155]

Racism .

[@kylerittenhousecommieslaye4752]

Stop trying to be white.

[@angelmario7085]

Africa huge continet why they run in Europe? 🤣😛

[@Janoip]

nah

[@objectdefiance4027]

@@angelmario7085 Because We're Wealthy after Extracting their wealth and destroying their Cultures and Nations During the Age of Empire. Let's Just Say We're Returning the Favour.

[@ironandzinc]

@@objectdefiance4027 you can destroy yourself.. just don't include the rest of western society..