Can States Impose Taxes Besides Zakat? کیا ریاست زکوۃ کے علاوہ ٹیکس لگا سکتی ہے؟ | Javed Ghamidi

Can State impose Taxes other than Zakat? کیا ریاست زکوۃ کے علاوہ ٹیکس لگا سکتی ہے؟ | Javed Ghamidi
🔴 SUBSCRIBE 🔔: www.youtube.co...
▶ About Javed Ahmed Ghamidi:
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi is a Pakistani Muslim theologian, a Quran scholar, and an educationist. Mr. Ghamidi is a student of Maulana Amin Ahsan Islahi and Maulana Abul A’la Maududi. Mr. Ghamidi has authored several books, including the bestseller ‘Meezan’, in which he presents a comprehensive treatise on the entire content of Islam. Mr. Ghamidi is a researcher and a critical thinker who has challenged many aspects of the traditional Muslim schools of thought on the basis of evidence from Quran and sunnah.
▶ About Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning:
"Ghamidi Center of Islamic Learning", an initiative of Al-Mawrid US, is established with a single purpose, to educate people of all ages about moral, ethical, and humane values as taught in Islam. Our aim is to separate history and culture from Islam and teach it in its purest form as a field of knowledge and not enforce it as a creed. We base our instruction method on argument and logic and encourage healthy criticism. An institute where traditional and historical knowledge can be understood as well as challenged with reason.
▶ DONATIONS: www.ghamidi.or...
🔵 RELATED TO THIS VIDEO:
◽
🔵 RESPONSE TO 23 QUESTIONS:
◽ Meezan Aur Furqan: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ What is Sunnah: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Itmam e Hujjat: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Qiraat Ka Ikhtelaf: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Excommunication (Takfeer): • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Singing & Music: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Veil (Pardah): • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Beard (Darhi): • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ First Revelation: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Halal & Forbidden: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Splitting of the Moon: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Isra-o-Mairaaj: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Return of Jesus: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Arrival of Mahdi: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Interest / Usury (Sood): • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Human Nature: • Response to 23 Questio...
◽ Jannat Ki Hoor: • Response to 23 Questio...
🔵 OTHER TOPICS:
◽ Introduction to Quran: • QURAN Ka TAARUF - Intr...
◽ Hujjiyat-e-Hadith: • Hujjiyat e Hadith - Ja...
◽ Dawat Ka Tariqah: • DAWAT E DEEN SERIES
◽ Ahl-e-Sunnat Ke Aqaid: • عقائد سیریز | Aqaid Se...
◽ ALI (r.a) aur Muawiya (r.a): • Hazrat Ali (ra) aur Am...
◽ Foj Ka Bayaniah: • Bayania Series | Fouj ...
◽ Mishkat Dars on Ramzan: • Nabi Ki Batain - Yasal...
◽ Dallas Lectures: • Dallas Lectures - Coun...
◽ Conversing Islam: • Conversing Islam with ...
◽ Meezan Lectures: www.youtube.co...
◽ Al-Bayan Lectures: www.youtube.co...

[@sultanhashmi201]

سبحن اللہ و بحمدہ سبحن اللہ العظیم ۔ Ghamidi Sb . should be esteemed as a great research scholar of divine religions n should be followed for orthodox Islamic teachings . He is standing by the origional principles of Islam . U n me also have the right to differ ( in some cases ) with his explanations , interpretations n applications .

[@aroosausmani100]

Allah pak apki zindagi ma barkat aata kary or musalmano ko apky ilm say fayzyaab hony ki toofeq day....aamen

[@kasheikh]

As I understood from previous lectures of Ghamidi Sahab, if one is working in USA/Canada/Europe and paying heavy taxes on income like 30-40% then Zakat is not applicable to that individual -- which is quite rational and insightful inference considering the framework of Zakat.

[@omaranis]

What about tax and zakat on savings of retired person's?

[@kasheikh]

Impressive and logical explanation by Ghamidi Sahab 👍

[@MuhammadFarooq-ur-Rahman]

Sir I have some investment in stock as well in Islamic saving whatever Dividend or profit I get already deduct 15% by govt, please advise may I pay Zakat on it because govt allread deduct tax pls advice

[@qqq2001pk]

In my sense , whatever net income we get regardless wherever we are , it is safest option to ourselves to pay zakat to needy Muslim anywhere in the world 🌍

[@aliakber2k10]

Jo naye taxes government nay lagaye haien, or us ma awam ki himayat shamil nahi hay (agar app ye kahien k ye parliament say manzoor huway haien to ye b such hay k ye parliament awam ki muntakhib karda nahi bal k election ma dhandli k a nateeja hay). To is surat e hal ma agar zakat say zayed paisa hukumat muhj say wasool kr rahi hay to ye najaiz hay. Or kia hum is zaid paisay ko mehfooz karnay k liye tax chori or tax evasion ko halal samjhen. Hassan bhai Bara e meherbani reply karien.

[@muhammadikrama9286]

Iss mein sawaal yeh paida hota hai k the Parliament has been chosen by the people so, if the Parliament decides to impose tax then shall it be considered to be imposed by the people's own personal will?

[@walid1985]

Parliament choro democracy b log choose nhi krtay ya on par musalat ki gai hai

[@taimoor722]

militray needs constant funding and budget to do innovation and research to develop technology and to train the military and do practice even in normal days when we don't have wars, Allah said in Quran "And prepare against them whatever you are able of power and of steeds of war by which you may terrify the enemy of Allah and your enemy and others besides them whom you do not know [but] whom Allah knows. And whatever you spend in the cause of Allah will be fully repaid to you, and you will not be wronged." (Qur'an, 8:60) so its important to prepare and to provide funding necessary in peace times not just in case of war only, you prepare the technology before the war and then use that technology when its the time to use -------- so its now right to say that only to give money as tax when there is some event of crises war flood etc infact state needs constant money

[@mhadnanali]

agr taxes allow nahi hain. tou tax chori krna kesa ha?

[@azmatali2235]

If government say that you have selected members from provisional/National Assemblies and they are agree to impose many new taxes as law so you/general public will pay new taxes then what we will do? Election results are not clear & general public don’t agree that selected members of parliament are selected by them, in this condition what a general person can do?

[@noorsaba434]

Ghair Muslim mulk me tax dena b zakat me include ho sakta hai?

[@ahsansqureshi]

غامدی صاحب کیا آپ امریکہ میں زکواۃ کے علاوہ ٹیکس ادا کرتے ھیں یا نہی ؟ ریاست کے جو اخراجات ھیں وہ صرف زکواۃ سے کیسے پورے ھو سکتے ھیں ان اخراجات کو پورا کرنے کے لئے تیکسز تو لگانے پڑھیں گے اگر قومی اسمبلی بجٹ منظور کر لیتی ھے تو اس کا مطلب ھے کہ عوام کی مرضی بھی شامل ھوگئی کیونکہ اسمبلی عوام کی نمائندہ ھوتی ھے

[@abidqazi1306]

What is GST on commodities? It is legal to take government or factories.

[@muhammadshafiq4436]

زکوۃ کی میں قرآن نے تفصیل سے بتا دی گئی ہیں۔ حکومت یا فرد ان مدوں کو تبدیل نہیں کر سکتا۔ آج کے دور میں جمہوریت رضامندی کا اصول ہے۔

[@uqabsgroup5276]

Zakat is luxury tax And government applied tax is Haram

[@مینهاوطبعیت]

کہا يہ جاتا ہے کہ حضرت عمر نے ٹيکسيز لگاۓ تہے

[@abbasiabdulghafoor]

زکوة کے جو آٹھ مصارف بیان کیے گٸے ہیں ان میں کتنا حصہ حکومت خود استعمال کرے گی۔کیا زکوة کا سارا مال استعمال کرسکتی ہے۔اگر ہاں تو دوسرے مصارف زکوة کی ضرورتیں کیسے اور کون پورا کرے گا۔

[@qqq2001pk]

Only Islamic government can take zakat No other form of government allowed to take zakat

[@LiaquatJSamma]

غامدی صاحب نے لفظ کے درست معنی سمجھے ہی نہیں ہیں۔ اسکے معنی مساکین کو مالی مدد دینا ہے ہی نہیں ہیں بلکہ اپنے اچھے کاموں کو اجر میں بڑھوتری دینا ہے جو قرآنی ھدایات کی مسلسل پیروی کو عمل کے لیۓ ہمیشہ تیار رکھنے کے حکم کے بات یہ کہا جاتا ہے۔( اقیموا الصلات و آتوا الزکات کے معنی نماز پڑھو اور مساکین کی مالی مدد کرو، ہو ہی نہیں سکتا ہے کیونکہ لفظ زکات کے معنی مالی مدد کرنے کا نماز سے کوئ منطقی تعلق بنتا ہی نہیں ہے۔یعنی قرآنی ھدایات کی مسلسل پیروی کو ہمیشہ عمل کے لیۓ تیار رکھو اور ان پر اچھے اعمال کرکے انکو اجر میں بڑھوتری دو۔ زکات کوئ ٹیکس نہیں ہوتی ہے۔