CONVERSING ISLAM - Season 3 - Episode - 2- Islami Riyasat - Hamza Ali Abbasi - Muhammad Hassan Ilyas

[@theoptimistic6065]

i learned about ghamidi sahab through this series. I watched hamza's alif and while searching about him i came to know about this series. After watching this i can say after a year that there is hardly a video of ghamidi sahab i haven't watched. Blessed to have him in my life.

[@i-raza-ahmad]

یقین کریں، میں ہمیشہ سوچتا تھا غامدی صاحب اسلامی ریاست کے خلاف ہے.... لیکن آج ہر بات واضح ہو گئی ... اللہ آپ کو لمبی عمر عطا کرے ... شکریہ دونوں کا.

[@Ilm-o-Irfan786]

Mashallah

[@noorin1196]

Hamza Bhai you are really great and we need such approach , aqamathi deen , nifazi deen , islami riasat .

[@syedannankamran6266]

Mujhe ap log is liye achay lagtay hain k ap logo ka Andaz BoHt acha hae

[@ungrateful7742]

Loving this season 💞

[@Bilawal-Bhutto]

Very well explained... Hassan Illiyass 👍♥️

[@syedashirazi1752]

ماشاءالله زبردست حسن بھائی سلامت تھیں اپ

[@ZainAli-po6mg]

Mash allah

[@GG-ft1bf]

GG (Great Ghamidi). Teacher of teachers. Hero of heroes. Ocean of knowledge. The best philosopher, theologian, educationist, researcher, critical thinker, Mujaddid-e-Islam. Love you Ustad-e-Mohtaram.

[@saadivlog1306]

Hassan bhai Next level ❤

[@IslamicResearchtv1416]

Mashallah ❤🌷❤👌❤🌹❤🌷👆❤❤❤God bless you sir all

[@faisalsadiq7698]

Hassan bhai Ghamdi sahb k lectures se or unki jo Dr israr sahb k sath "Islami Riasat" k name se jo debate he us se to ye baat samj main aati he k islami hukomat namaz ka nfaaz kerwa sakti he

[@ZainAli-po6mg]

May Allah bless them

[@cooldude3421]

That's why it's important to learn the basics. Rasoolallah SAW was seeking authority to establish the Deen of Allah (to build a State) Quraish rejected it. He saw directed to different tribes of Arab. He saw found Nusrah from Auos wo khajraj. Formed a state of madinah. Ref. Seerah Ibn ishaaq, ibn Hissham, ibn kaseer..

[@AftabKhan-lg8uc]

Question is very pertinent to establish an State based on Quranic Laws and Ethics

[@shanikaimkhani7123]

Assalamualaikum dono ustad ko

[@syedannankamran6266]

Good session

[@syedannankamran6266]

Ghamdi sir is best

[@syedannankamran6266]

Hamza Bhai and Hassan Bhai plz Ali Bhai k stream Mai aye..ghulam Haider Bhai ya Shahid and Bilal BHai ki mai...ap sab log gems hain

[@waqaruddinansari8757]

محترم: "لِيُظْهِرَهُ" اور "غَالِب" دونوں قرآنی کلمات ہیں، الگ الگ مادے اور معنی رکھتے ہیں، "لَا اِكْرَاهَ فِى الدّٖينِ" جب دین میں جبر / زبردستی نہیں، تو "غالب" کرنے کا سوال ہی پیدا نہیں ھو سکتا۔

[@theexposer46]

سوال۔18:30 سر جو حکمران کے انتخاب کےلیے آپس میں مشورے کا کہا گیا ہے۔ آپ کہہ رہے ہیں کے علم والوں سے مشورے کا نہیں کہا گیا تو یہ بات بھی تو عقل کے خلاف ہے کہ آپ علم والوں اور بے علم لوگوں کو برابر کر رہے ہیں۔ جب مشورہ کرنا ہے تو عقل کا تقاضہ ہے کہ علم والوں سے کیا جاۓ۔ اور پھر حضرت عمر ر ض کی سنت سے راہنمایٔ نہیں ملتی جو انہوں نے صحابہ مقرر کیے خلیفہ کے انتخاب کےلیے؟؟

[@enviroexperts1092]

Kia abhi islami riyasat ki zrort nh hy? Main heraan hun k do musalman islami ryasat ki jadojehad k khilaf jidojehad kr rhy hen. And for your kind information, hm kmany k liy bhi ALLAH K huqam ko dekhty hen. Jab bacha paida hota hy tab bhi ALLAH k huqam k mutabiq usy treat krty hen. Dunya ma koi aisi chez nh hy jis k bary ma Islam rehnumai na krta ho.

[@abdilyceum7655]

namaze eden aur namiz jumma, hakomt napiz kary gr......... reference plz

[@zainbuttar1]

hasan bhai comment box k ilawa hum apne swal kahan poch sakte hain? koi email wagera?

[@urducontent8485]

Next episode topic should be "Jihaad" Please!

[@abdilyceum7655]

bani Israel our abni ismael ku hkm kub mila tha.. refrence.. yani hokomati ilahi ka hukm kaha dea hy... plz explain... and refrence

[@fidaulmustafa2904]

A Question: I have always wondered why the focus of God's divine attention to guide human beings to the right path has always been focussed in the middle eastern region. Why there exists no sound record of prophets who were sent to the people in American, Australian continents etc. Though we believe that ALLAH's wisdom is endless and there must have passed the prophets who were sent to guide human beings who have been living in the west for ages. But my concern is that when we think holistically, it feels as if this divine effort somehow dilutes when it moves away from the middle eastern region and it is always left on the people of the books (from the middle eastern regions) to spread God's message to other lands. If this is true then why is that? I hope I was able to make my point clear. If Hamza bhai could bring up this question in this series, that would be really great. JazakALLAH

[@thenomadspakistan2304]

Very valid and thoughtful question. They mentioned about Banu-izraeel and Banu-Ismaeel.... My question is similar that please define which are these according to the geography of the present world?

[@muhammadjunaidali4403]

Allah swt mentions in the Holy Quran that for every nation he has sent a warner. Consequently, when the world entered an evolutionary phase, where it was possible for us to observe history, Allah swt bestowed this responsibility upon chosen nations, gave them LAST PROPHET, Divine LAW and guidance, so that, using same means they could spread His word to all. Sending a single man for subject purpose time and again, is a lengthy and laborious process for targeted audience. Whereas sometimes nations end up challenging Allah swt and face dire consequences.... It must be understood that this life is our test and Allah swt only interferes in an evolutionary process to the point where the aim of this TEST is not hampered.

[@InstantPsyche]

Watch this video from 18:42 For this particular question kzbin.info/www/bejne/oZmQnIWQhZuaZ7c

[@syedarshadali8351]

السلام علیکم ۔ مجھے مکتب غامدی سے پوچھنا ھیکہ قران مجید میں جگہ جگہ حکم ھوا کہ اللہ کی تسبیح کرو حمد کے ساتھ ۔ اور اس سے مغفرت طلب کرو ۔۔ کیا اسکو روایٸتی طریقے سے ہی کیا جاتا ھے جیسے مغفرت کے ۔ حمد و ثنا کے کچھ عربی الفاظ بارہا دوہراۓ جاتے ھیں ایک خاص تعداد میں ؟ یا پھر فکر غامدی میں اسکا کچھ اور طریقہ کار بیان کیا جاتا ھے ؟

[@noorjaved1184]

First of all, what is the definition of Islamic state and what are the laws ?

[@NayeemAhmad4783]

کیوں، حلال مال کمانا دین کا حکم نہیں..؟؟

[@sadiqhussain157]

ریاست کا خیال أتے ھی حکمرانی کی لہر اٹھتی ھے جسنے اسلامی تاریخ کا تیہ پانجہ کر دیا۔اللہ جانے انسانی ریاستوں اور حکومتوں کا تصور کبوجود میں أیا جبکہ صاف کہا جاتا ھے ریاست اور حکومت صرف اللہ کی انسان اس انتظام کو چلانے کا ذمہ دار ھے جو اللہ نے انسانوں کی ھدایت کے لیے دنیا میں اتارا۔ لیکن افسوس صد افسوس اس انتظام کےلیے انسان نے مکمل اقتدار کی ھوس چاھی۔کا جاتا ھے مدینہ ایک ریاست تھی اگر ریاست تھیتو اسا حکمران کونتھا ھم نے بنا لیا نبی پاک اسکے حکمران ٹھرے۔انبیإ ھدایت کے لیے أٸے ھمنے انہیں بادشاہ یا حکمرانبنا دیا۔اس تصور نے تنی قباحتوں کو جنم دیا کبھی اے مسلمان اسپر غور کرلے۔ اسلام جس غلبے کی بات کرتا ھے وہ کسی کی ذاتی حکمرانی یا غلبے کیبات نہٕں اللہ کے غلبے کی بات ھے بادشاہ حکمران صرف اللہبندہ اس کے غلبے اور انتظام کو برقرار رکھنے کا منتظم ھے

[@umairalikhan47]

plz ask about the tax or zakat ruling on nonmslims in an Islamic state

[@tqm790]

Sir I hv one query, most of nation created boc of political movement like Pakistan, it's not exactly a religious movement. If we assume that Pakistan was created to implement Islamic state in Indian subcontinent then there might be always conflict and situation of challange till pakistan fully adopt Islamic state guidance. If we tell people that nation is for Islam then Pakistan have to abolish western form of government and setup. Will this not create a situation where people start fighting/revolting with government till it fully comply to Islamic governance.

[@K_Shahzad]

Pakistan was created as a nation state for Muslims of subcontinent. There are people who have interpreted it as implementation of full Islamic governance, but according to Islam, they can not revolt against the government as long as the foundation of constitution is based on Islam. They have been trying to promote their understanding of Islamic law and I don't see anything wrong if it is attained within democratic process. People picking up arms for it are definitely a menace for state and have created a lot of issues even though they themselves are going against Islam.

[@abdilyceum7655]

religion was used only as of the card... all the participants in the movement were elite...only to sustain their hegemony the elite want to establish a state,. and with help of the masses, they can do it so they use religion as a tool.

[@fidaulmustafa2904]

Another Question: If we accept it that going against the نظم of an already established govt (Islamic or Not) is itself UnIslamic then how can we justify the Pakistan and the revolution that brought Pakistan into existence. Not just that how would we be able to justify the creation of many Islamic countries or states in history? Because every country’s creation was at some point a revolution that went against the already established state and in every revolution there has to be blood. But if we look the other way we often realize later in future that the revolution itself was a right decision and we see that a small initial idea with some people was able to convince large populace that led to bigger events in history. Doesn’t it get too confusing and difficult to distinguish whether going against an already established system is unislamic or Islamic?

[@K_Shahzad]

I think its not allowed only against Islamic governments, even then, if it is established that rulers of an Islamic state have gone completely astray, you can rebel.

[@khansher5411]

The status of revolution is a confusing phenomemon.. a politcial scientist said every faild revolution is a mutiny and wrong and every successful revulution is rightful... i forget the exacy words and name but meaning wasike this... you cannot allow revolution and just completely ban it... there must be a middle path between them... bcz if you legally allow then anyone can stand and claim themselves as rightful for revolution against the existing order but you completely ban then how can to justify a revolution and change of an existing order??? So there should be a middle way. The revultion, its environment, existing order itself proves, it is right or wrong. Its a long debate

[@khansher5411]

It should be on human conscience to decide

[@talhadar4672]

How Will the Gov, tax a non muslim then?

[@shakirzaheer3007]

یہ حمزہ صاحب سے کہیں کہ بات پوری ہونے دیا کریں ۔ درمیان سے بات کاٹا نہ کریں ۔

[@pureislampurehuman4186]

bani ismaeel koi ziker nahi quran me bani adam or bani israel h

[@ZahidHussain-lu8ed]

Sorry to say,while “Political Islam”is not part of respected Ghamdi’s theme, then why you both are trying to mislead innocents?

[@AftabKhan-lg8uc]

Where is Allah hukumat?

[@ZahidHussain-lu8ed]

Sorry to say,while “Political Islam” is not the part of respected Ghamd’s theme,then your conversation on “Islami Riyast” is waist of time and energy.

[@waqaruddinansari8757]

محترم: رسول کریم کا ایمان اور اسلام فقط کتاب اللہ تک محدود تھا۔ 2.136 اور 3.84 اور 3.85 بغور پڑھیں۔ جو کتاب اللہ میں نہیں وہ اسلام نہیں "شرک" ھے۔ بھوکے کو کھانا کھلانے کا حکم قرآن میں کئی جگہ ھے بچہ بھوکا ھے، اسکو کھانا کھلانا اسلام ھے، الیاس صاحب زیادہ ہوشیار نہ بنیں۔

[@AbdulRehman-ge2yc]

I don't think there is any Islami State in Islam. There could be a Muslim State. Where majority will be muslims State will reflect the majority out look.

[@qurantafseerbymrsadnan2837]

Mashallah