CONVERSING ISLAM with Hamza Ali Abbasi - Episode - 9

[@GhamidiCIL]

GET THE APP To Ask Questions and Join Community Discussions! www.ghamidi.org/app

[@usamagill5121]

ماشاللّٰہ حمزہ بھائی پہلی اقساط کو دیکھ کر میرے علم.میں بہت اضافہ ہوا تھا اب پھر سے ہو گا اللّٰہ پاک آپ دونوں کو لمبی عمر عطا کرے آمین

[@salmanameen7657]

حمزہ علی عباسی کو دوبارہ پھر سنٹر میں دیکھ کر بہت خوشی ہوئی۔ یہ سلسلہ جاری رکھیں۔ شکریہ

[@syedrahim694]

Masha Allah ❤️ Allah aap dono ko jazai khair den. Bht hi sabaq amoz guftgo. Bht shukriya ❤️

[@ashkehlan4743]

About Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi, I not only believe that there is no scholar of his stature profundity of religious thought and precision of its understanding and lucidity of his articulation in the Muslim word, but I also believe that I have yet to see anybody more profound just and humane than Professor Javed Ahmed Ghamidi sahib, when it comes to commentary on social issues including human rights. (MAY HIS SEED PROSPER GOD WILLING)

[@gmdssss12341]

MashAllah....Thank you for such a thought-provoking discussion

[@HauteCuisine_88]

Wow What an episode.👏 I had goosebumps while listens to this conversation. Keep it up!

[@seemarm662]

Mashallah.. very informative program

[@nimrahalvi1428]

Thank you hamza for discussing this amazing & informative topic very helpful ❤ MAY ALLAH INCREASE YOUR KNOWLEDGE ABOUT ISLAM MORE AMEEN SUM AMEEN 😍 #HamzaAliAbbasi

[@shahedahashmi5366]

Worth watching...Allah jaza de aapko

[@realizeislam4820]

*_what a life_* MONDAY >> working on HADITH PROJECT...etc TUESDAY >> working on HADITH PROJECT...etc WEDNESDAY >> CONVERSING ISLAM THURDAY >> RESPONSE TO 23 QUESTIONS FRIDAY >> working on HADITH PROJECT...etc SATURDAY >> AL-BAYAN SUNDAY >> MEEZAN / ILM O HIKMAT

[@hashmiwable]

Ma Sha Allah

[@farazfakhar1099]

God Bless Hamza, Hassan Bhai and Ghamidi Sb.. you people are doing nothing less than Jihad.

[@aarifbinhossain]

Assalamu Alaikum. ... very very happy to see this program again. jazak Allah khaer Hamza and hasan iliyas vai.

[@mdjunaid6187]

Besides all the critical discussions and details analysis I just love the way of their discussion its full of funnnn. جزاك الله خير

[@malikadnan7]

Loved it !! JazakAllah

[@sumeetmusfirah7924]

beautiful. inspiring. ❤

[@akramkhan-bunyad]

دین و عقل کا بنیادی فرق ۔۔۔۔ علم و دریافت ہے. دین حدود تعین کرتا ہے جو عقل نہیی کرتی ۔۔۔

[@ilayatshah9079]

What a fruitful discussion Mashaaallah

[@AR-yk1kv]

Thanks Hamza & Ilyas

[@peerzadakhalid9319]

Please continue this program I love this type type of conversation most knowledgeable

[@hussy8137]

Ghamidi shb is zamany k Farahi hain aur Hassan bhai hmary Ameen ahsan hain

[@hashmiwable]

Wonderful analogy. I like it.

[@shahidsiddique6402]

Allah ka shukr hai aap log aaye to

[@muhammadtariqzia6570]

amal say zindagi banti hay jannat bhi jahannam bhi.

[@damkhan13]

MashaAllah may Allah shower his blessings on you

[@madmax5756]

It's great to see you again. Hamza apki excitement qabil-e-deed ha😁 please keep it up. Love you both ❤

[@salmanyousaf5697]

The way hassan Ilyas bhai is speaking is very similar with ghamidi shb. I am listening audio and it feels like ghamidi shb is speaking, the way he presenting his thoughts

[@umarfarooq4906]

Great discussion indeed 👍

[@Doctor_Xeno]

Follow Quran and life of Prophet and everthing else will keep changing and is only limited to a particular era and people.

[@AR-yk1kv]

Beautiful discussion

[@ChalkyTheASMR]

i'm so happy to see season 2. may Allah bless you

[@ArsalAcademy]

Waiting. Eights episode was on Hadith. We were discussing on hadith. Hopefully after so many month Hamza Ali Abbasi"s urdu will be improved.

[@pashteen8348]

Even more better thN most of us

[@shahabkalim]

Allah bless Ghamidi saab . Salaam from Calcutta.

[@AR-yk1kv]

Great work by Ghamdi sb, Ilyas and you

[@muhammadarif-ng9rp]

Thanks brothers! May Allah elevate your statuses.

[@darkheart8119]

Great Islamic conversation Welcome back here

[@yasalamo5951]

Sab ko Allah bless you

[@muhammadtariqzia6570]

beshak nabi Saw ki zindagi tumharay liyee behtreen namona hay.

[@mazhar008]

Every one listens : jaha ishq hu waha kuch socha samjha nae jata waha bs apne mahboob. Ke itaat ke jati ha ۔ or Muhammad mustfa S.w.a say to zada scha or koi ishq nae hu skta jaha sb aqalo ke b koi haisyat nae

[@nuzhatsher9305]

To jb ap deen ke dawat dete hn kisi non beliver ko to usko to ishq nhn usko ap aqal ke bunyad pe dawat den ge to usko kya kahen ge.islam deen e fitrat he aur aqal ke bunyad pe qaim hota he

[@realizeislam4820]

kuch loog deen ko *apni* aqal kay mutabiq karna chahtay hei...........

[@SyedAZafar-ji9gm]

Well said.

[@dunya7627]

آہااا__انظار کی گھڑیاں ختم ہوئیں __ میں بہت بےصبری سے انتظار کر رہا تھا__

[@amankhan3093]

Amazing

[@skyhawk9429]

Jazak Allah khair 🇵🇰🇵🇰🇵🇰 04 / Dec/ 24 😍❤😍

[@mazhar008]

Yahe to jazabat humri bakshesh zriya bny gay k hum na Allha k sche rasool say bina sochy samjhy ishq kia

[@MasoodKhan-cx5zw]

MashAllah

[@fatimakhalid4094]

allah bless you bai

[@mehersuhail711]

Good discussion but a request for Hamza that plz keep your questions short so that the speaker would have more time to explain and don’t interrupt so that we have better understanding

[@learnlikemuzna4702]

Great to see u both again! With a great topic

[@shcarim124]

Could you please provide the link of ilyas shahab program related to madarsa students. I really want to study them with open mind. JazakAllah!!

[@AbdulWahid-mw3uw]

Mashallah

[@KHM95]

Very good conversation 👍

[@habbaanhabib8651]

Allah ap dono ki mhnat ka phal day.bss ap sy guzarish ha itni important batoon ko thodi simple language aur aasaaan tariqay se paish karain taaki awamunas asaani se smjlain

[@8abid]

We are too far behind,it is a shame that we are not available to listen to this intellectual conversation 🤔. Only 18,000 viewers in 3 months.🙏

[@muhammadumerhanif6572]

Finally seeing u #Hamzaaliabasi

[@shabnamshafique355]

Great

[@hafsamuhammad0590]

Allah Pak K Noor Say Daikhhta Hai Momin,Banda I Momin Ki Aqal o Farasat Dain Hoti Hai Allah Pak Ki, Uss Par Allah Pak Ka Fazal Hota Hai,Uss Ki Aqal Haiwani Jabilaton Ki Taabay Nahin Hoti, Panah Jo Allah Pak Ki Maangta Rehta Hai Woh, Shaitan Our Uss K Lashkar Jinnaat K Shar Say

[@muhammadsajidjavedkhan1252]

Simply amazing

[@callmeerteza2454]

مگر مٹی سے وہ احساسِ صفائی کیسے ممکن ہے ؟؟؟

[@shaikhsohel4376]

Mashallah 👌

[@adbee6247]

Very interesting information thanks for hosting 👍

[@salmanshaikh9059]

Very informative.

[@BilalAhmed-my2mp]

King is back

[@mnraies3646]

سلام سلام بہت ہی خوب اس پروگرام میں سوال و جواب کا بھی ایک متعین وقت رکھیں

[@peacefullmind122rose6]

Please continue

[@thai58]

اللہ کو پانے کے لئے جتنی بھی عقل عطا ہوئی ہے وہ بے کراں ہے لیکن پھر بھی عقل کی کچھ limitations ہیں۔ ایک اللہ کی وجود گی ہے اور ایک موجودگی ہے۔ اللہ کے وجود کا احاطہ کرنے سے انسانی عقل عاجز ہے اور اللہ کے وجود پر بحث کرنے سے منع کیا گیا ہے۔ البتہ اللہ کی موجودگی پر ہم بحث کر سکتے ہیں اور یہ اللہ کے ہونے کا ایک ناقابل تردید ثبوت ہے۔ ہمارے روزمرہ ذندگی کے مذہب سے جڑے تقریباً سارے کے سارے سوالات اسی سے جڑے ہیں کہ اللہ موجود ہے یا نہیں ہے اور اگر اس سوال کو سب سے پہلے حل کر لیا جائے تو باقی سوالات جو کہ قبر یا محشر سے تعلق رکھتے ہیں سارے حل ہو جاتے ہیں۔ اللہ کی موجودگی پر اس وقت سائنس جتنا بتا سکتی ہے اتنا دنیا کا کوئی اور علم نہیں بتا سکتا صرف یہ کہ سائنس مشاہدہ اور تجربہ پر بنیاد رکھتی اس لئے مذہب سے بعض لوگوں کو لگتا ہے کہ conflict کھاتی ہے۔ ایک سائنسدان اور ایک صوفی اپنے اپنے تجربے میں ایک جیسے وجدان کی کیفیت میں ہوتے ہیں مگر دونوں کی thinking کی اپنی اپنی dimension ہوتی ہے۔ ایک mystical experience چاہے وہ صوفی کا ہو یا سائنسدان کا ایک بہت بڑے ریاضت ہوتی ہے۔ یہی وہ منزل ہوتی ہے جب صوفی کو اپنے باطن میں اللہ کچھ نشانیاُں دکھاتا ہے اور سائنسدان ایک تخلیق کرنے میں کامیاب ہوتا ہے۔ خیال اندرونی ہے یا بیرونی لمبی بحث ہے مگر ایک چیز اولیاء کی کتابوں سے ظاہر ہوتی ہے کہ یہ حواس خمسہ کے beyond ہے ۔ اس کی مثال یک بند کمرے کی ہے کہ جس کے اندر والا باہر والے کو باہر والا اندر والے کو کچھ نہیں بتا سکتا۔ اسی لئے بہت ذیادہ صوفیوں کے spiritual experience میں ambiguity پائ جاتی ہے۔ اور انا الحق اور سبحانی ما اعظم شانی جیسے نعرے نظر آتے ہیں اور اس کو رد کرنے کے لئے جنید بغداد کو کہنا پڑا کہ ہر spiritual experience کو قرآن اور حدیث کے standards سے گزارنے کے بعد ہم اس کا انکار یا اقرار کریں گے۔ غامدی صاحب کا school of thought logical ہے مگر spiritual experience کے بالکل انکاری ہیں جو کہ سمجھ سے بالا تر ہے۔

[@fazalrehman7901]

You guys back ♥️❤️❤️💖

[@amerahmedkhan123]

Excellent informative programme, indeed. But sincere request please avoid using heavy rhetorical urdu words , its difficult to understand for an English medium student like me

[@junaid5551]

keep uploading such videos

[@Sam-j8x2l]

Love from India ❤️

[@97877753]

So many times Hasan is trying to build an argument and Hamza can't help but interrupt. Great program but could be better if Hasan is allowed to complete his point. جزاک اللہ

[@ibrahimahmed136]

Why do they take a break? Isnt this recorded?

[@hajranoorkhan64]

Nice

[@raufpathan7623]

Bhai sahab aap Hasan bhai ko pury baat kahenedo aap sawal kare takrir nakar

[@hep2022]

We miss u hamza We want u at your own Chanel and want to listen your own thoughts about anything related to religion

[@callmeerteza2454]

36:25 وضو کا مقصد پاکیزہ احساس ہے لیکن مٹی سے یہ احساس کیسے ممکن ؟

[@polkhol6563]

Alternative form ko apnate hue wazu ke ehsas ko zinda rakhne keliye tayammum he

[@a.k..m5841]

Hamza bhai joo app abu yahya saa discussion karta tha woo dubara start karaa.

[@Workbynajeeb]

Agar bhai koi example bhi de dete sath k fla kam deen ka smjh nai ata lekin osy deen ka hukam man k bina aqal use kiye hum accept krte hain to behtar hota ,,, qk aise jab aqal questions uthati hai to wo most of the timr intellectual hote hain na k kesi chez ki khilaf warzi krne wale ,,,

[@callmeerteza2454]

Almost got it.... But it is not in history book....it is in Sahih Ravayatt

[@polkhol6563]

Hadees is the historical record of our prophet.

[@politicaleconomy9653]

Best students of Ghamidi sahib.. Hamza please don't waste your time with Haris sultan. Because he is just using your fame to promote his channel.. He is a money lover

[@aqeelanjum5418]

وَعَلَيْكُم السَّلَام وَرَحْمَةُ اَللهِ وَبَرَكاتُهُ‎

[@callmeerteza2454]

Qoule Ali smjh nhi paaya.. Is it right

[@callmeerteza2454]

Means I think ...that quol is not authentic.... But it is in Sahih Hadees... Ravayat

[@rafiuddin8649]

hat ha yar, maza aageay!

[@callmeerteza2454]

Kindly help anyone.. The Quol oF Ali AS was illogical according to this Debate ???

[@callmeerteza2454]

32:55

[@callmeerteza2454]

اوکے سمجھ گیا .... تیمم والی بات سے...... حمزہ....... کہ یہ قول ان کا نہی .... کیونکہ صفائی تو پیش نظر ہی نہی

[@tarmac5482]

31:31 touch of Ghamidi sb. He talks like that.

[@callmeerteza2454]

34:22

[@realizeislam4820]

AQAL insaan kay tajarbaat aur mushahidat say results nikalti hai........ jab insaan kay tajarbaat aur mushahidat hi limited hai to aqal koi absolute source of knowledge nahi hosakti......... Aur insaan ko aisi zaat kay supurd krna majboori banjata hai jis ka tajarba aur mushahida ki koi limit na ho aur wo ALLAH ki zaat hai ...........

[@yasminjan8979]

Shatan is your nfais or something out side

[@winistan]

flip fops ... seriously dude ?!?!?!?!?!?!

[@ayeshaali864]

So Why is ghamidi Sahib not using his Aqal about the word "Daraba" that it can have other meanings? As a woman, my Aqal refuse to accept that you have to beat a woman into submission. Nor did he elaborate on how to define "nashuz" in his segment. Most of the scholars have failed to explain this. You are reading the Quran and interpreting it from a man's point of view only.

[@islamicmessage2419]

What is your question??

[@mukhtarhussain5282]

and that's why shia believe intellect in relgion but sunni don't

[@oliveoliver4990]

Humza bhai bht achi baat ap ne Allah ki taraf ruju kiya or tauba ki par ap logon ko Alime deen ki trah neem hakim khatre jaan Islaam na padhayein . Islaam ko samjhane ke liye bht ache alime deen hain duniya me. So plz its not your job .

[@callmeerteza2454]

مٹی سے صفائی تو نہی ہوتی right

[@irshanaseer4176]

Why shahaba not imams

[@Grr_rrrr]

حمزہ عباسی صاحب ایک طرف آپ عمران کا ڈھیلا ڈھالا سا انٹرویو کر رہے ہیں دوسری طرف یہ۔۔!! یہ دونوں چیزیں آپس میں میل نہیں کھاتیں بقول اقبال۔۔۔۔ عشق قاتل سے بھی، مقتول سے ہمدردی بھی یہ بتا کس سے محبت کی جزا مانگے گا؟ سجدہ خالق کو بھی، ابلیس سے یارانہ بھی حشر میں کس سے عقیدت کا صلہ مانگے گا؟

[@akhtarshad3903]

Islam kya hea? Es pe Guftagu karne k Leye Quran ku samjh kar parhna 1 ur Arabi Zuban ka feham 2 ur Qalb-e Saleem. Understand!!! My friend???

[@mohammadnematullah9140]

You cannot get out of your religion by any means, you will rationalize it every time you find any irrational thing. You are born in that religion, you will die in it, such is the power of religion you are born and raised. You will believe or rationalize even after knowing it talks about flat earth, the sun moves around the Sun and mountains are erected as pegs to balance the flat earth and on and on.... It has inculcated such a great fear of being burnt forever in hell if you don't believe in it, that is why you rationalize all its irrational claims.

[@saadiiaa]

Why we listen to these guys when Alhamd o lillah we’ve Mohtaram Ghamidi Sahab... especially Hamza Ali Abbasi whose reason of fame is his acting & not just simple acting but acting in films Like JPNA , those who saw the movie knows what i mean... He is a fine example of Pakistani Elites who brought up in western culture environment & when get exposure to islam starts preaching islam to everyone as if it something new ss it’s for them ... Alhamd o Lillah majority of Pakistanis know islam... So please if Mr. Hamza ‘Sau Choohay Kha Ky Haj Ko Chaly Hay Tau Zaroor Jaey ‘ but please do it without coming on the media ... My point is if Showbiz people genuine about their faith then why they can’t let go fame .... that’s the test in which most showbiz people fail because they want to cash whatever they do - .... it is my opinion, no body has to agree with me🙂

[@SyedAZafar-ji9gm]

That is what my feelings are about theses two pseudo scholars. I bet sooner or later these two immature and cheap publicity seekers will cause big time damage to Ghamidi saheb's mission. Hassan lyas's starting remarks: "yeh sawaal aapko kissy bay-aqal aadmee say poochna chaahiay, aap nay saheb-e-aqal say pooch lia" In other words he said "I am a man of wisdom and others are not" Wow, what a scholarly claim and false pride from a young and immature man who has just started learning under the umbrella of a world renowned scholar. Although on some issues and kind of liberal thoughts of Ghamidi saheb, I differ from him, but I have great respect for him as one of the great moderate religious scholar of today. I have been listening his lectures and religious discussions for the last many years, but I have never heard such self praising words from him what Hassan Ilyas (Ghamdi saheb's son in law) has just said in his own praise. I urge Ghamdi saheb not to indulge in nepotism in his great scholarly mission. He has some good and mature scholarly fellows around him which should be enough to continue his mission, and please stay away from appeasers and marketeers. Although Ghamdi saheb is a great scholar and researcher, but he is always down to earth, and says: "I am a student, and I am learning". After hearing Ilyas's arrogant remarks I was not able to listen to the whole discussion. I wonder why Ghamdi saheb will allow such ignorant and arrogant fellows to use his platform for their cheap publicity. I bet if Ghamdi saheb did not stop Ilyas and such actor cum pseudo scholars like Hamza Abbasi, he will not only lose his credibility soon, but also people will start boycotting him. [e-mail]

[@zeropro0]

bro you why do you guys belive Isa (as) is still alive in hevan and will come back? there is no logic behind it . Quran is clear he is dead