Gigguk REACTS to Reddit's Top 100 Anime

[@newbie4789]

Okay. Reddit feels like a community with biases and opinions yet watched a lot of anime. It's a great list. Didn't disrespect any classics while also having interesting and unique picks and clear, human biases. The list ain't pretentious, newbie pleaser or niche genre simp.

[@hokutology1718]

Overall, I have to agree. But some of the placings, though...

[@turjamajumder7053]

Agree.

[@kenhiyoko941]

​@@hokutology1718the placing makes sense if the popularity vote is counted

[@kzsoni]

the list was egregious.

[@binkiebrew]

It definitely disrespects a fuckton of classics. The fact that mushuko tensei was higher than perfect blue!?!?! Unbelievable. The isekais should have been like 60 or even kicked out. God damn it, I'm fighting the redditors!

[@thexenoist3493]

The thing about 86 is that it had a frame perfect ending.

[@SilkSonic-c9z]

Aot anime and monster also have a frame perfect ending

[@popop143]

I think Garnt at the middle forgot it's "favorite" anime and not best anime of Reddit, and was comparing them too much in their merit and not how much people "favorite" the anime

[@jonathanbosman1568]

Joey - Pretentious Taste Connor - Vanilla/ Popular Taste Garnt - Trash, Spicy and Degen Taste That's why Garnt you are the man. Maybe I just need to reaffirm that another guy has the same shitty taste in anime as me

[@ShadowOfMassDestruction]

If y'all got shitty taste then I'm one more to add in the pile.

[@javi4591]

Jeoy: ThePretentiousTasteMan 💀

[@DRAGONOFDESTINYZ]

Pretentious taste is better imo

[@areebsiddiqui758]

Connor just likes JoJo

[@DRAGONOFDESTINYZ]

@@areebsiddiqui758 Connor: gay taste

[@Rarchieo]

Re:Zero is definitely still cooking if you go by the anime alone, but imo its earned its spot in these lists already.

[@Loldx123]

I think it should be higher tbh, from character and story writing to music and voice acting, it's amazing, but people rate it lower because the animation is nothing too spectacular. I find it funny tho that Garnt still doesn't get the hype around the show while praising NGE. The both are pretty much telling the same story of character growth and trying to be a better person.

[@FireDragg]

@@Loldx123 he says ReZero is still cooking, after 50 episodes and 2 movies, but is okay with Made in Abyss that has only 25 episodes and a movie, and is also still unfinished. And while, yes, Made in Abyss does makes us feel emotions with episode 10/13 and others, but DAMN, so does ReZero!! I guess the problem is that he made that video saying "ReZero is entertaining but its not a masterpiece" and ever since, has been overlooking it, unable to admit he was wrong.

[@aissaaissa3080]

I dont get garnt saying "it still cooking" . It 's like 50 episode and every episode is 30 min of really deep and complex story, it had enough content to be classic . It's my favorite anime by the way.

[@aissaaissa3080]

​@@FireDragg mother basment made a great video proofing that gigguk is wrong .

[@Loldx123]

@@FireDragg I think he just doesn't like it as much and can't relate at all, which is totally fine. However as you said, him saying it still needs time after 50 episodes is just wrong. We had 2 seasons and people loved it. The plot is really not the main focus because it is a character driven story. If he doesn't understand why people love it so much, there are so many videos, even from big youtubers, explaining the purpose of the story. Him saying it doesn't deserve it because he didn't like it that much is a dumb take.

[@user-lh5my4ws8j]

Even on IMDb, Mushoku Tensei has only 3 episodes with a rating above 9 across both seasons, while Re:Zero has over 10. Mushoku Tensei has won 11 awards, whereas Re:Zero has won 28. The entire final saga of Mushoku Tensei was inspired by Re:Zero. Hundreds of other series, from novels to even Korean manhwas, have also drawn inspiration from Re:Zero. But Mushoku Tensei is considered a classic while Re:Zero is not? Stop being ridiculous.

[@Muchacho2DMax]

Riiight???

[@kenshin1368]

Every main character is one dimensional and pretty poorly written. Echidna and Margrave are far more interesting than the main characters and even get more fleshed out than them (despite them being pretty common tropes). A main character who never gives up because he loves a lifeless doll of a character with a magical cat isn't that unique of a story. Literally every character is a tired trope: a 'perfect' maid girl who loves the MC unconditionally and is ignored, her tsun sister who bullies the MC, a mysterious royal who supports the MC with unknown motivations and a magical mansion, and an immortal loli who loves books all facing off against the 7 deadly sins. Its literally just torture porn to try to get you to feel like you empathize with Subaru.

[@user-lh5my4ws8j]

@@kenshin1368 Everything you say is wrong, but do i even need to explain when you didn't watched the show? You copy pasted this into other comment and got destroyed in under 1 hours. RafaelSouza-om1mx: @kenshin1368 Damn, you really have not paid attention at all to the show, either that or you just went into it with premade notions and didn't really watch it. Subaru is one dimensional...? Subaru never gives up because he loves a lifeless doll? There is an entire episode with Subaru pouring his heart out and trying to runaway and give up everything. Its 26 minutes of dialogue in which he talks about how he hates himself and that everything that he has been doing os far is nothing but a mask he is wearing, trying to convince himself that he is not that shitty brat that he thinks he is. Did you skip this episode or just turned off your brain? A perfect maid...? I guess you mean Rem? Where is she perfect? She is depicted as a very flawed person, who suffers deeply from self-depracation, low self-esteem and thinks of herself as nothing but a replacement. She suffers from survivors guilt due to her sister having lost her horn while protecting her. And even after Subaru manages to help her overcome that (partially), she then clings to him, instead. Where is she perfect? Just because you projected her as your perfect waifu, doesn't mean she is perfect, you just have zero capability of analyzing a character. Magical Mansion? The Mansion isn't magical at all, is just a normal building, another proof you watched it with both eyes closed. Immortal Loli who loves books...? Beatrice is not immortal, she actually wanted to die and actually DID DIE in an episode (killed by Elsa), so how is she immortal...?!?!?! She just can't kill herself, which makes her fate much more depressing. A lifeless doll with a cat...? Emilia is much more than that, she suffered racism and prejudice for her entire life, she got ostracized in a forest with the other elfs and is often a victim of assassins. Despite all of that, she still tries to look at the bright side of life. She could have become the evil Witch that everyone claims her to be, but she pushes herself and tries to be better because she wants to save her family, te people frozen in the forest. But yeah, I guess she is just a lifeloss doll doing nothing all day. Another shitty take of you just projecting what you believe, instead of actually seeing what the characters are. You are wrong even in the 7 deadly sins, since we've seen 9 (all 7, plus Vanity and Melancholy). And still, the original 7 didn't seem like the antagonists (the witches). Want an adivce, bro? Keep watching Demon Slayer or JJK, that way your lack of braincells won't affect your enjoyment.

[@kenshin1368]

@@user-lh5my4ws8j WOW I feel so destroyed! I'm glad to find out all Re:Zero stans are as stupid as he is. Did you perhaps notice that everything he mentioned shows no depth to any of the characters? They are all tropes upon tropes. Here's your copy pasta response, but I'm sure you're still refreshing the comments do defend your waifus: Wow a MC that hates himself and hides it with a happy, can-do mask while he tries to become more than the nobody he was in his past life? Truly unique! Wow, I hope he doesn't get some magical power that seems pretty useless but ends up becoming very important! Wow a love interest that struggles with self esteem issues and imposter syndrome? Never heard of that! She is literally waifu bait for fans of trash isekai like you lmfao. I guess she's really deep because she feels guilty over her sister getting hurt for her. Its not like that's the majority of siblings in anime. Oh excuse me, I meant totally normal mansion that has been heavily enchanted, has plenty of secret passages and rooms, and literally has a magical dimensional library in it! Definitely not magical. WOW! The 1000 year old loli is actually different because she isn't actually immortal, she just doesn't age and can't kill herself! Oh the cardboard MC girl is actually super unique because she is destined to be a queen, has assassins after her, and faced racism for being a half breed? Never heard that story before! Don't worry, she has an evil doppelganger, that makes her super original! And don't worry the cute flying cat is actually secretly a very powerful mythical beast! Truly groundbreaking! Excuse me, they're all against a shadowy organization which is much more unique! The 7 deadly sins are super important and original because they added two other sins which are literally slight variations of Pride and Sloth! Keep fapping to your Emilia figures as you pretend I'm the braindead shonen fan.

[@kenshin1368]

@@user-lh5my4ws8j WOW! I feel so destroyed! Keep pretending you're just like Subaru: @RafaelSouza-om1mx Wow a MC that hates himself and hides it with a happy, can-do mask while he tries to become more than the nobody he was in his past life? Truly unique! Wow, I hope he doesn't get some magical power that seems pretty useless but ends up becoming very important! Wow a love interest that struggles with self esteem issues and imposter syndrome? Never heard of that! She is literally waifu bait for fans of trash isekai like you lmfao. I guess she's really deep because she feels guilty over her sister getting hurt for her. Its not like that's the majority of siblings in anime. Do you have so few braincells that you thought " 'perfect' maid girl" meant that I thought she was actually a perfect waiful lmfao? Oh excuse me, I meant totally normal mansion that has been heavily enchanted, has plenty of secret passages and rooms, and literally has a magical dimensional library in it! Definitely not magical. WOW! The 1000 year old loli is actually different because she isn't actually immortal, she just doesn't age and can't kill herself! Oh the cardboard MC girl is actually super unique because she is destined to be a queen, has assassins after her, and faced racism for being a half breed? Never heard that story before! Don't worry, she has an evil doppelganger, that makes her super original! And don't worry the cute flying cat is actually secretly a very powerful mythical beast! Truly groundbreaking! Excuse me, they're all against a shadowy organization which is much more unique! The 7 deadly sins are super important and original because they added two other sins which are literally slight variations of Pride and Sloth! Go buy another Emilia figure for the jar as you pretend I'm a casual shonen fan lmfao.

[@halkun7191]

I thought me and Gigguk had an understanding when it came to Re:Zero It being one of if not the best Isekai makes it deserving of top 20. (As long as they don't drop the ball)

[@cluster4583]

Yeah he seriously needs to rewatch season 1 and 2 before season 3 cause every time i hear him talk about re zero it feels like he didn't get anything when watching the anime that makes re zero so good. And he especially really needs to rewatch the anime if what someone said to me that he watched season 1 for the first time in 2× speed is true, idk where the person got that info from but either way that probably played a big part on why he didn't understand re zero at all in season 1 and thought it was nothing special if true. Unfortunately probably unlikely he would rewatch the anime and see everything he missed. Dunno if he has even watched the ovas.

[@elia0162]

overrated af i never saw somethhing more overrated than re:zero

[@jadenzeno7423]

@@elia0162cope

[@kenshin1368]

Its definitely one of the best isekais but that doesn't make it good. Every main character is one dimensional and pretty poorly written. Echidna and Margrave are far more interesting than the main characters and even get more fleshed out than them (despite them being pretty common tropes). Its literally just torture porn to try to get you to feel like you empathize with Subaru.

[@kenshin1368]

@@cluster4583 I think you need to rewatch them and realize a main character who never gives up because he loves a lifeless doll of a character with a magical cat isn't that unique of a story. Literally every character is a tired trope: a 'perfect' maid girl who loves the MC unconditionally and is ignored, her tsun sister who bullies the MC, a mysterious royal who supports the MC with unknown motivations and a magical mansion, and an immortal loli who loves books all facing off against the 7 deadly sins.

[@jaycebradley8404]

joey and garnt together make one whole redditor

[@kyuuby5458]

Trueeee 🤣🤣🤣👍

[@Rando1028]

Missed opportunity, you should have run a short poll on each ranking to see if chat thought it's too high/perfect/low.

[@kenshin1368]

Would have literally taken twice as long lol.

[@twodents]

I was starting to worry that Kaguya-sama somehow didn't make the list and then its placement threw me for a loop

[@Plorant11]

No ashita no joe or hajime no ippo is mine boggling

[@karma3098]

It is a good list but there are some good shows that are missing like; Hajima no ippo, Golden Kamui, Food wars, GTO, Parasyte, Magi, and maybe Heavenly Delusion.

[@perkeletto640]

Frieren that is not even ended yet as NR.1 is regency bias personified. Could it in future be in top 10? Perhaps, even likely. But after 2 seasons nr.1? Hell no

[@sleepylion9788]

No worries, S1 will definitely drop to top 2 by the time S2 comes out

[@Akiraspin]

One Piece being above Cowboy Bepop lmfao... Can always bet on Two Piece Taste.

[@osmorca618]

I mean of course One Piece is above Cowboy Bebop, it's far better and it's not very close lol

[@sitaL-z9x]

gigguk lives in japan and still cant pronunce 'Tatami"

[@mania1021]

A top 100 with Bunny girl Senpai but no Sakurasou...

[@shah_riar407]

Man I can't find another comedy like Grand blue, which is definitely my fav

[@wymanbartlett4648]

No Akira? No GITS? Reddit needs to eat it's anime veggies.

[@thomasffrench3639]

Akira is dessert lol. But yeah a lot of Redditors think Akira is overrated. They are wrong, but it’s how they feel.

[@pougetguillaume4632]

The problem is that these are movies, you notice there's basically no movies going forward. My guess is that people saw "anime" and forgor 💀 that movies also counted. There's like 6 or 7 movies on this list tops so you can smell the anime bias. People didn't vote for movies, simple as.

[@Ash_Wen-li]

Barely anything before the 90's

[@sumitdutta5584]

Garnt you should check out some special episodes of one piece like - 1015,1061,1062,1074,1100,1102,1112,1114.

[@WieldMyWord]

nah, he gave up on the anime due to pacing, etc. he isn't even caught up to Wano in the manga (might have dropped the show and lives now on nostalgia).

[@visd.9344]

Can't believe there was not more outrage about yu yu hakusho. Absolutely deserved minimum top 50. I don't think there should have been any shows in the last 5 years inside the top 20. Proven legacy counts. In my opinion anime's labeled as classic will be hard to come by.. times move to fast these days. In 10 years no one will talk about Frieren as a true classic. Number 1 could have been Neon genesis, one piece, dragon ball, cowboy bebop etc. And that would have made the list more credible. Truly criminal shows like any Gundam series wasn't on the list, tokyo ghoul, hellsing etc weren't on the list just crazy.

[@xenode2059]

In 10 years I will still be calling Frieren a classic

[@TLM_Aoi]

if we're talking about OP manga being number 1 there will be little to no problem at all but OP anime being number 1 really? same with TG

[@visd.9344]

@@TLM_Aoi OP has a huge legacy. Been around forever. Look at how many fans there are and how it's impacted the culture in general. Alot of factors go into a number 1 anime to me. Something in the last 5 years hasn't had time to prove its going to stand the test of time. Side note I really dislike OP in general.

[@sleepylion9788]

AoT top 2 best anime of all time, Garnt? What's next? GOT top 2 best fantasy shows of all time?

[@SilkSonic-c9z]

If u are comparing aot with got after seeing multiple shorts u are the biggest joke imo Got is nowhere near the peak of Aot.

[@newbie4789]

19:00 obviously this should be there. It's a fking meme

[@shashwatmishraalumni4918]

Top 10 for me- 1- Aot 2- Steins gate 3- Monster 4- Code geass 5- HxH 6- Vinland 7- Evangelion 8- Fmab 9- Mob psycho 10-Gurren lagan All time top anime characters imo- 1- Guts 2- Johan 3- Eren 4- Makashima 5- Griffith 6- Light 7- Thorfinn 8- Lelouch 9- Aizen 10-Okabe

[@taqueroman91]

I personally think Black Lagoon should been on the list

[@EmirAssassin]

Steins;Gate disrespect is crazy...

[@XxJiiGSAWx]

Including movies in the list but not having Akira is insane fraud activity Reddit.

[@meraketh]

Hi there, thanks for the video! About Toradora however. How is Taiga a tsundere? Isn't a tsundere supposed to be the one, who acts cold and hostile towards the one she likes? Taiga takes about 2/3 of the series to even realize she likes the mc. The only time she acts rude, violent and cold towards mc is while she isn't even considering him. And she never acts cold towards the guy she likes in the beginning, only shyly. And after she realizes she likes the mc she still holds back, since she knows the mc likes her best friend, so she does everything to help them get together. So how is she a tsundere?

[@PSSHUBH]

MAL : 🤡 Reddit: 🗿🗿🗿

[@ishank942]

I would have been happy with Vinland saga or full metal alchemist brotherhood or attack on titan to be no 1 frieren should be in top 20 but not 1st

[@bobbuilder6761]

Toradora > snafu Ok death note is for sure a classic! Nothing like it. But I agree people judge based on the first season

[@iElimiinatezHD]

Seeing 86 that high brings me happiness 😍

[@zurut99]

ive watched s1 of both and mt was incredible from the production,world building, characters everything was amazing

[@munkhgalamarmend8809]

honestly if they take their time with s3 it could be the best season of anime out there

[@Unknown_1096_]

Mt?

[@munkhgalamarmend8809]

@@Unknown_1096_ yep since s3 is gonna cover one of the greatest LN volumes of all time

[@Unknown_1096_]

@@munkhgalamarmend8809 but still top 15 cmon man

[@zurut99]

@@Unknown_1096_ mushoku tensei

[@shadowdwelling222]

Would you have included arcane? I feel like that was same energy as cyberpunk for me.

[@rustygear447]

1:47:08 There are a couple negatives I can say about Frieren lol. I don't think it deserve #1 even though it the best show to come out recently. It does one thing very well, but not great in many others. 1. From the first episode it bugged me to death how none of the hero's party member have anything new to their lives after 50+ years. No one get married, no kids, no new jobs. They just age. It doesn't feel like a real world. 2. All characters emotional state seem to be the same like they are just one person acting as different characters. They all talk in similar tone, pace, and calmness. Even the young mages in the exam arc. They face certain death with unnatural calmness. No one ever freak out, or look desperate about anything. Again, it just doesn't feel real.

[@sufyanbob]

Gintama should be in top 3

[@TheKrigeron]

Ready to seethe at evey Mari Okada joint ranking anything above 999999999 Edit: other than shounen that aired on tv when we were young, Death Note is THE gateway anime, a classic among classics. There is not a shadow of a doubt in that notion. EDITTTTT: SLOP GAYASS ABOVE DEATH NOTE? I'D RATHER EVEN FUCKING SEE NEVERLAND ABOVE IT AND THAT INCLUDES *SEASON 2* !!!1!1!1! I'M GLAD THEY TOOK YOUR API REDDITOR Edit: Ahem. Anyway. Frieren got memed to the top but Steins Gate is hilariously reddit as fuck even though it's good, deserves to be the quintessential redditcore.

[@Elico-du1oi]

Other gateway anime classics to me are D Gray Man and Deadman Wonderland

[@NeroPiroman]

Demon slayer allmost 50 places above yu yu hakusho is fucking sad

[@TLM_Aoi]

i'm really hoping for Frieren to get a season 2 with the same production quality or maybe even better because reading the manga and knowing how the story and world building beyond what the anime covered keeps getting better and better makes me hella excited to see it all animated

[@randomonlinegames3013]

this list convinced me to believe that SAO only popular in japan not even top 100

[@du6ee]

Surprised Tokyo Ghoul didn’t make the list

[@Ash_Wen-li]

Not surprising considering they butchered the story and most fans are fans of the manga

[@Mcng2343]

legends of the galactic hero's is just too hard to get though on my 4th rewatch I made it into the 90ish episodes. There's just too many characters to follow and you get lost so easily. I plan on watching to completion eventually because it is an amazing one-of-a-kind series

[@tommykaung5882]

It is hilarious to see average anime fans like Gigguk would shock in disbelief to see 86 above JJK and Violet Evergarden over One Piece on reddit. Of course, I can't blame them. These shows tackle themes and issues that may not understand to average people but those who served in the military and saw combat would say "pretty relatable". Shows like these are quite rare in anime medium. I see a bunch of reddit post written by US soilders who saw combats about both 86 and Violet Evergarden.

[@sharebear421]

86 ain’t that deep lol it’s not some super in-depth crazy hard to understand series. I liked it but it’s kinda overrated by its fan base. It needs more seasons tbh

[@tommykaung5882]

​​@@sharebear421 I think there is a misunderstanding. The 86 itself is not that hard to understand like Monogatari series level. It has mechs,war, politics and a bit of romance which are themes that you can expect from a mecha anime. For these reasons, most would say it is 7 out of 10 ok show. But there are some aspects which are just too invisible to realize for average viewers unless you are combat veteran or born in a military family which unsurprisingly some of the author's family members served in the JSDF. So for military otakus and actual combat veterans, 86 is a masterpiece.

[@SkeetWeet4368]

funny long winded way to say to you didn't understand one piece

[@tommykaung5882]

@@SkeetWeet4368 I haven't watch One Piece so I don't have the opinion to criticize or understand. It would be dishonest to say something like it is mid or overrated if I haven't even seen it in the first place.

[@thomasffrench3639]

I haven’t seen 86, but from what I’ve heard, it seems like a pretty standard mecha show. Still great, but I have heard the stuff people talk about, and it seems very similar to Gundam

[@pabu__]

i mean JackUTS made a great video on this, land of the lustrous anime exemplifies and even add new definition to what an adaptation can be. it transformed an already unique manga into a completely different medium that comes with its own innovation that is possible due to the use of 3D animation and all of the other aspects that it presents, kudos to all the production staff behind it, that you wouldn't really experienced if you go straight into the manga. making these 12 episodes the perfect gateway for those who want to get into the manga which is on another level on its own (which also is finally finished thank god). the anime did however, skips a few chapters at the end since the manga introduce one character that is prominent and crucial to the rest of the story from that point on, but i think what they decided at the end is wise since it would've been very weird if they follow through instead. anyway, watch or read houseki no kuni if you haven't

[@WieldMyWord]

1:23:00 you mean in terms of nostalgia when you were like what 15 years olds and had zero critical thinking (might aswell put mirai nikki in top 10)? Go back and watch those stuff again its slow as hell with tons of inconsistency all over the places. If an anime makes you go over to the manga because the pacing is ass means it shouldn't be near top 24 in a top 100 "anime" list. I highly doubt Garnt read one piece and its just nostalgia talking, because there are several instance he has no clue what goes on in the current stuff and he probably knows deep down the manga went to shit during Wano.

[@arcane_1989]

As an isekai trash fan, i'm shocked eminence in shadow made it. Not because I don't think it deserves the list, but because I'm shocked enough people agreed...

[@Cardenal_]

I fuckin choked on water when i saw your name right after

[@KP-hc7ug]

2 Ghibli masterpieces being sandwiched between Symphogear and Railgun is peak reddit

[@DavisBrown-fm3dj]

Railgun is fantastic though. Sure it isn’t as good as those Ghibli films since they are some of the finest in the medium but it’s certainly a great show and one of the best battle shounen (not that the competition is very strong).

[@Lucario6804]

@@DavisBrown-fm3dj This and people have to understand that these votes are heavily based on how big the fanbases are. Something with multiple medias like Railgun will obviously beat out Perfect Blue because that many more people have seen it and are still active in the fandom. I can guarantee that most people that have seen both perfect blue and railgun would go for perfect blue because it's a masterpiece.

[@pougetguillaume4632]

@@Lucario6804 also there seemed to be an anti movie bias, by that i mean people probably didn't register movies as proper anime and didn'tvote for them as a result. You can count on the fingers of 2 hands the number of movies in this top 100

[@KingCasual1986]

Tell me you haven’t actually seen Symphogear without telling me you haven’t actually seen Symphogear.

[@воваомелюх-к8о]

Maybe because this is not "acclaimed as the best", but people personal favourite list?)) And Railgun/Index anime is actually really enjoyable and fun to watch.

[@pougetguillaume4632]

It's no surprise garnt and r/anime seem to align, r/anime specifically is filled with old timers who remember when haruhi was the new hot stuff. There's always that thread once a week of someone saying "hey guys i found this underated anime called claymore" and everyone just kinda look at the guy funny followed by either "fuck i'm old" or "dude claymore was NOT underated you just don't remember it". Rest of reddit is very hit or miss (mostly miss) but if you want genuienly good discussions and recommandations r/anime is a really good place to go. I actually find it better than most other plateforms because the brainrot and long term memory loss isn't as bad as it is on other plateforms like discord, twitter or god forbid youtube comments. Also being better than ign or crunchy is a real low bar to clear

[@thomasffrench3639]

Old timers are Ghost in the Shell, Akira, and Lupin III fans.

[@pougetguillaume4632]

​@@thomasffrench3639lupin the 3rd man that's such a noob filter When a weeb knows it exists you know he's a real one Ghost in the shell, akira or eva at least get recognition from newer anime fans because everyone talks about them but stuff like that or city hunter star is how you know you've got your hands on a geezer

[@Nakul22099]

​@@thomasffrench3639those are fossils, we extracting oil from the corpses😂

[@thomasffrench3639]

@@Nakul22099 that’s Astro Boy. 80s is not that old. Old timers is a good description

[@Audreythescrub]

Additional huge upside to r/anime, it’s not hostile to minority audiences in western otaku fandom, by this I mean stuff like BL, Idol Series, CGDCT, Yuri, fringe comedy, you get the idea. With how the threads work you just get the people who are genuinely interested about those series and fandoms commenting

[@Nessterovv]

HOLY MOLY 2 HOURS OF GARNT'S PEAK

[@ttmintus9932]

Wdym by garnt’s peak

[@ShadowOfMassDestruction]

That's what Sydney said

[@ahyesiamacarnerd1656]

We edging to this one lads

[@benjaminmallari106]

Garnt's peak goes hard on this one

[@воваомелюх-к8о]

This video look like Gigguk totally forgot that this is "favorited" list not "the best", so all this "should be higher/lower" doesn't have sense at this context))

[@WieldMyWord]

True and a lot of it is either recency bias or nostalgia talk, rather than objectively pointing out the overall quality of the show.

[@AnimeBinger370]

I'm about to get the popcorns ready for this absolute banger of a 2 hour ride.

[@Ifeelyou-mr]

Bro your video is so hilarious lmao, I'm subscribing

[@rhn2rhn]

@@Ifeelyou-mr the mrbeast one is stolen btw

[@skappy2000]

1. Frieren: Beyond Journey's End 2. Steins;Gate 3. Attack on Titan 4. Puella Magi Madoka Magica 5. Hunter x Hunter 6. Kaguya-sama: Love Is War 7. Neon Genesis Evangelion 8. Monogatari Series 9. Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood 10. Vinland Saga 11. Mob Psycho 100 12. Bocchi the Rock! 13. Code Geass: Lelouch of the Rebellion 14. Clannad 15. Mushoku Tensei: Jobless Reincarnation 16. Made in Abyss 17. Re:Zero - Starting Life in Another World 18. Gintama 19. Gurren Lagann 20. Death Note 21. JoJo's Bizarre Adventure 22. Konosuba: God's Blessing on This Wonderful World! 23. Violet Evergarden 24. One Piece 25. A Place Further than the Universe 26. March Comes in Like a Lion 27. Cowboy Bebop 28. 86 29. Jujutsu Kaisen 30. Your Name 31. A Silent Voice 32. K-On! 33. Naruto 34. Haikyuu!! 35. Fate/Zero 36. Odd Taxi 37. Fruits Basket 38. One Punch Man 39. Monster 40. Kill la Kill 41. Chainsaw Man 42. Dragon Ball 43. The Apothecary Diaries 44. Hibike! Euphonium 45. Rascal Does Not Dream of Bunny Girl Senpai 46. Oshi no Ko 47. Demon Slayer: Kimetsu no Yaiba 48. Legend of the Galactic Heroes 49. The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya 50. Your Lie in April 51. Cyberpunk: Edgerunners 52. From the New World 53. Ping Pong: The Animation 54. The Dangers in My Heart 55. Yuru Camp 56. FLCL 57. Toradora! 58. Hyouka 59. Chihayafuru 60. Spy x Family 61. Nichijou 62. Spice and Wolf 63. My Teen Romantic Comedy SNAFU 64. Bleach 65. The Tatami Galaxy 66. Assassination Classroom 67. Girls' Last Tour 68. Mushishi 69. The Disastrous Life of Saiki K 70. Psycho-Pass 71. Fate/stay night: Unlimited Blade Works 72. Land of the Lustrous 73. Aria the Animation 74. Samurai Champloo 75. Lycoris Recoil 76. My Hero Academia 77. The Eminence in Shadow 78. Serial Experiments Lain 79. Summertime Render 80. Baccano! 81. Bloom Into You 82. Angel Beats! 83. Welcome to the NHK 84. Revue Starlight 85. Higurashi When They Cry 86. Non Non Biyori 87. Revolutionary Girl Utena 88. Horimiya 89. Fullmetal Alchemist 90. A Certain Scientific Railgun 91. Princess Mononoke 92. Spirited Away 93. Berserk 94. Showa Genroku Rakugo Shinju 95. That Time I Got Reincarnated as a Slime 96. Symphogear 97. Liz and the Blue Bird 98. Perfect Blue 99. Yu Yu Hakusho 100. Grand Blue

[@3_14thon7]

where did u get magi from?

[@skappy2000]

@@3_14thon7 FIXED

[@JeffDvrx]

Violet Evergarden and Made in Abyss deserved a much, MUCH higher spot that what they got. And that's just me scrolling through the list, something tells me this is gonna give me plenty of _"oh f*ck no"_ moments lol

[@Querez8504]

wrong way around

[@skappy2000]

​@@JeffDvrx Fr, they both deserved to be in top 50

[@Tatersalad666]

March Comes in Like a Lion is one of those shows for me that I can re watch over and over again and get something more out of it each time. It is such an incredible masterpiece of emotional storytelling. It is an anime that builds slowly over time until you find yourself completely swept up in it. I think if you go in with an open mind and not expecting it be a high octane action anime you will enjoy it. The best way I can describe it is as a quietly intense character drama with the ability to both melt your heart from how wholesome it is, and to bring you to tears, sometimes in the same episode. I don't know how far Garnt got into it, but I hope he watches the rest someday because it is every bit the masterpiece that people say it is.

[@lycanerf6885]

this 100%, highly highly recommend it

[@Cardenal_]

How did this man turn 14 minutes into a 122 minutes video???? He really is a yapper.

[@carlosfitzgeraldzolaias4733]

No Hajime no Ippo, no Slam Dunk, no Akira, no Ghost in the Shell... Jeez!

[@bsigns1935]

Yes, this.

[@AtomicZamurai]

Plz no ghost in the shell. It aged like milk and akira is the definition of normie taste

[@Self8Sabotage]

all better than trash frieren

[@corden826]

no Ghost in the Shell SAC actually kinda offended me ngl

[@Ash_Wen-li]

​@@AtomicZamuraiGhost in the Shell Standalone Complex is great though

[@alexielknight]

Oh no, I was so much in agreement with everything Gigguk said and then we got to Eighty-Six. Was Connor sitting next to him, pointing a gun at his head? ;)

[@ryanergo754]

86 sucks balls.

[@mmehedii4906]

Yeh connor didnt even watch the anime he dropped it 2-3 episodes in Gigguk has this habit of agreeing with connor or joey even though their opinions sucks most of the times.

[@thomasffrench3639]

Garnt, this is a favorites list, not best list.

[@Minuey]

Reminds me when Joey made a video about Reddit's top *favorite* anime saying Reddit doesn't know what good anime is. It infuriated me lol

[@xenopixel8877]

There shouldn't be a difference IMO. This distinction causes people to think a piece of media is better because everyone else says it's good. There is no objectivity in this. There's a reason an anime or any piece of media is your favorite; you think it's the best.

[@thomasffrench3639]

@@xenopixel8877 I disagree. I don't have to think that my favorite is the best. For example, my favorite film is The Good, the Bad and the Ugly, but I think the best film ever made is The Godfather. The Godfather is one of my favorite movies, but subjectively I think it is the best movie. It's all subjective, but I don't have to think that my favorite is the best.

[@xenopixel8877]

@thomasffrench3639 yeah I guess I get it. Like my favorite movie is the movie I think is the best but I guess you might have some other reasons why something could be your favorite but quality-wise you think it's not the best. I'm happy you say that both are subjective criteria

[@askebe3]

The metric they are using is a pretty good way to get a best list, though. This list is way better than any other best list on the internet that I've seen.

[@VinlandicSoul]

Frieren, it Hit me like a cheap shot to the gut. I’m someone whos lost all his family prematurely, as well as my crush, good friends, and everything in between. I’m only 35, and The ability to relate to Frieren will forever make it my favourite Anime of all time. I feel you though, it’s by far not the best of all time, but for personal reason, I’m going to have to believe it in my own heart.

[@ryoukaip]

literally sameee, Frieren is so goated

[@sprawlz6466]

If you think it’s the best anime at capturing loss and grief then that’s a valid argument for it to be the best anime of all time. No shame in having that opinion

[@Ash_Wen-li]

43:30 Chihayafuru. This show is a hidden gem. It combines the best of shoujo/josei character dynamics with the intensity of sports shounen

[@KP-hc7ug]

Chihayafuru the GOAT. Praying for season 4 but doubtful it will ever happen

[@edsonolmedomunoz224]

​@@KP-hc7ug I'm praying Mad house so bad

[@rustygear447]

If you like hidden gems, I recommend My Eccentric Family (Uchouten Kazoku)

[@Ash_Wen-li]

​​@@KP-hc7ugIs the manga on hiatus? I can imagine that the only reason we haven't is that they're waiting for the manga to finish first

[@KP-hc7ug]

@@Ash_Wen-li The manga finished over a year ago, I think sadly the show is just not popular enough. I was surprised we even got a season 3 tbh

[@Ash_Wen-li]

1:21:13 March Comes in Like a Lion. Another one of the best drama anime. It's NOT a sports anime so don't go in expecting something like that. Instead expect a brilliantly produced story full of colourful and complex characters with themes that range across the universal experiences for all people

[@воваомелюх-к8о]

I am drop only 2 anime to this moment, and this is one of them. Actually i wached only two episodes and this was enough for me. Are you can tell me (with maximum spoilers) what is so great there for you? Is it all show just this pseudo-depressing kid doing nothing?

[@IWantToStayAtYourHouse]

its just your lie in april but without all the spicy drama

[@selstrives]

​@@воваомелюх-к8оthe show is NOT for everyone. It's very slow paced. But it's one of the most realistic shows that portray someone suffering from depression. As the show progresses the MC is gradually overcoming it, opening up, and finally starting to get out of his rut little by little and each episode he slowly finds meaning to want to live again. The show is simply beautiful.

[@воваомелюх-к8о]

@@selstrives I thought about it some more and I think I got it. The main character has too good a life for me to sympathize with him. I just "don't believe" in his depression on an emotional level. His city is not being bombarded by rockets, he has not had his hands cut off, he has no problems with access to drinking water, food or money in general, etc. And the tragedy with his parents happened on the 10th!!! years ago, which is a very long time. And lastly, all his current problems can be solved very easily, he just "doesn't want" it, because it is more convenient for him to "pretend to be a victim" and be constantly "depressed". It's just disgusting to look at.

[@selstrives]

@@воваомелюх-к8о You're warped in the head my guy. He was indirectly responsible for "ruining" the relationship of his adoptive father and his siblings, because they got jealous as he they were not as good at playing shogi as him. His adoptive sister is verbally abusive to him. This has led him to want to live alone as he's filled with guilt causing him to further push people away. Not to mention shogi is the only way he can support himself so he didn't really have time to socialize at school. You're simply apathetic my guy

[@XLinkiboy]

frieren being on #1 overall, but lower on the top 1 rankings makes sense, cuz not many people think it's the best anime, but as it's a new and hyped up anime, many people have seen it and liked it

[@drp7751]

Makes sense, a lot of people keep strong feeling for their most favourite but for 2nd or 3rd they are likely to go with a good show that's fresh in their memory

[@emonte8148]

The table at the end shows there's not a ton of people putting it at #1, but it's consistently getting more #2-100 than a ton of other shows, just look at the numbers compared to everything else by it. I think this is why there's a lot of inoffensive anime at the top of the list (it may not reach the same hype as some shows, but there's not anything bad you can really say about it)

[@XLinkiboy]

@@emonte8148 that's what I was trying to say

[@NeolwA]

Frieren is that one show that everyone will most likely think highly of, while it's not the most top 1 votes, it dominates the top 2-10 list and it wasn't even close For a new show that's honestly impressive, it captured so many people in such short time, even a year from now if reddit is gonna make another poll, frieren is still gonna be atleast in top 3.

[@XLinkiboy]

@@NeolwA I honestly doubt that. I liked frieren, especially the early manga chapters, its a solid to good on every aspect. But it's not outstanding imo

[@agent6bell]

1:29:40 LESSGOO! GINTAMA YES! My favourite anime❤

[@Audreythescrub]

Gigguk has a running joke of not having seen FMAB, but after this video there’s a lot of classics which he hasn’t seen, a lot more than I was expecting for someone with his job. No Gintama, Clannad, March Comes in Like a Spring Lion, Utena etc. But I guess it’s pretty hard to get around to these when your job is also to go through all the seasonal anime that come out

[@DrJones0801]

If he can watch all of MHA he can definitely find the time to watch Clannad and March Comes in like a Lion

[@maibigbutt3746]

@@DrJones0801 he also watched LoGH's remake, so he definitely has time to watch these shows lol

[@Audreythescrub]

@@DrJones0801 the difference is that MHA is currently airing

[@BharathiRai-t6l]

Steins;Gate peak

[@slattboi_edits]

Ngl the horimiya hate from the boys is crazy imo lmao

[@thewildcard600]

I think Monogatari and Re;Zero are so high because people actually read it (pun intended) those are some really good books

[@zairaner1489]

no; light novel readers are an incredible minority.

[@user-lh5my4ws8j]

Re:Zero has episodes 1x15,1x18,2x4,2x8,2x11,2x23,2x24 which can be easily considered Top20 best anime episodes of all time in all animes.

[@dumbledore_loves_anime]

@@zairaner1489 They maybe a minority for Monogatari. But they are very much prevalent for Re:zero tbh. I feel like most of the people who say they love Re:zero have generally read LN/WN or atleast given it a try.

[@lcmbeatdrop]

the novels are goated. but the anime is also goated too. probably the best adaptation i've ever seen (talking about monogatari)

[@user-lh5my4ws8j]

Can someone explain me how Mushoku and Frieren earn it's spot while Re:Zero isn't when Re:Zero is better than these two? I call this Recency Bias and Gigguk's personal Re:Zero hatred coming from 2016.

[@tp9516]

Re:Zero is hot garbage. It was good for 1 season and then the author decided it was a shounen or something and then it dragged and dragged.

[@user-lh5my4ws8j]

@@tp9516 Dragged? Series does not even start until Season 3 which is already planned. Season 1 has foreshadowing to Season 6 but if you say "dragged" it already shows you don't understand shit about this series.

[@tp9516]

@@user-lh5my4ws8j Everyone craps on season 1 for posing all these questions and having no answers at least they didn't stand around and yap all day about their plans in the sanctuary arc who tf cares subaru has infinite lives it gets boring. Show fell off. Season 1 is like a 6.5/10 and season 2 is like a 2/10.

[@DT_Perigee]

As a fan of magical girls, I'm glad to have representation in the top 5. Also, where's Sailor Moon?

[@kyuuby5458]

You don't even need to be a fan to see how GREAT it is. Truly AMAZING 🔥🔥☠ It warms my heart to see people remebering it this day and age ❤❤❤ Ep 3 still haunts the anime community 😭🤣🤣 A true GOAT of 2011 fosssssssurue

[@TheReaIestOne]

1:30:25 Grant's lost his fucking mind.😂

[@newbie4789]

There were no Mamoru Hosoda movie abd that was sad. Wolf children or summer wars... At least one of them deserved a spot.

[@hokutology1718]

I'd actually say Girl Who Leapt Through Time or Mirai over Summer Wars.

[@newbie4789]

@@hokutology1718 I am a huge fan of Summer wars personally . But anyway we all agree that he deserved something

[@shironasama0445]

Ikr, Wolf Children needs to be here. But Reddit seems extremely on the young side. Probably haven’t seen it.

[@Valefor_Bahamut]

WHERE ARE GHOST IN THE SHELL AND SAILOR MOON?!?!?!

[@binkiebrew]

It's reddit, dude. Isekais have saturated the list.

[@alkerias]

@@binkiebrew LOL there were only 5 out of a 100. That's not saturation

[@ishank942]

I think Konosuba will be remembered as a classic comedy anime. Not everything have to hit hard to be in top 20 some should be there just based on their pure entertainment value and konosuba is just pure entertainment

[@innocentfd6364]

🫡

[@kenshin1368]

Pretty sure it will be remembered as a cringey fanservice anime that didn't age well but plenty of people have nostalgia boners for.

[@innocentfd6364]

@@kenshin1368 Parody certainly doesn't appeal everyone. If people feel nostalgic about something, it definitely had something great. It's for me like the EVA for gigguk.

[@BurnedOutWeeb]

For those that don't know Fate/stay Night Remastered visual novel is releasing Aug 7, 2024.

[@SirthOsiris]

I just found this out from this post and it's ON FUCKING STEAM LET'S FUCKING GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[@Heellllooo]

31:31 Land of the Lustrous mention! 🥹❤❤❤

[@1XXL1]

Phosphophyllite my GOAT 🔥🔥🔥

[@rullocompressore1550]

We’ll get season 2 in 10000 years

[@javi4591]

1:29:08 bruh, deathnote at its finest is untouched. No matter how "bad" the 2nd half was (which was not as bad as people think) DeathNote is definitely a classic and it's one of those shows that you can proudly recommend to anime virgin normies

[@osmorca618]

Code Geass does almost everything better than Death Note and its 2nd half is far, far better than Death Note's lol

[@MayukiSukezan-ec4pt]

​@@osmorca618cg is 3/10 the worst mecha anime ever made

[@osmorca618]

@@MayukiSukezan-ec4pt 2nd best mecha anime ever, only behind Evangelion.

[@MayukiSukezan-ec4pt]

@@osmorca618 the worst mecha ever made behind any other mecha anime gurren lagann is 5 milion times better then trash cg which is written like ass

[@osmorca618]

@@MayukiSukezan-ec4pt Introduction: Code Geass Plot: Code Geass Best Arc: Code Geass (Zero Requiem > Gurren Lagann Act 4) Protagonist: Code Geass (Lelouch >> Simon) Deuteragonist: Gurren Lagann (Kamina > Suzaku) Antagonists: Gurren Lagann Side Cast: Code Geass Main Dynamic: Code Geass Overall Dynamics: Code Geass Parallels: Gurren Lagann Worldbuilding: Gurren Lagann Animation: Gurren Lagann Music: Gurren Lagann Dialogue: Code Geass Monologues: Code Geass Themes: Gurren Lagann (Could go either way though) Symbolism: Gurren Lagann Highest Peak: Code Geass (Lelouch's Conclusion >>>) Overall Peaks: Code Geass Consistency: Code Geass Emotion: Both goated Pacing: Code Geass Plot Twists: Code Geass Conclusion: Code Geass Overall: Code Geass high diffs, it's better than Gurren Lagann

[@fantasticfoil92]

Great Teacher Onizuka got no love =( no gundam either

[@Giliver]

Id love to see a list like this but ONLY for finushed anime, i think itd make for a much more interesting list and talking points.

[@楚轩-l6d]

I totally agree with your point of view. It is very wrong to compare many works of all ages before they have finished telling a story. This is because this list is full of many works that are popular at the moment because of a few ideas that may be fashionable at the moment (I am referring to Frieren), but once the novelty of these ideas has worn off, it is like taking off a coat and running naked, revealing the emptiness at its core. Works with such shortcomings should not be on the all-age list before they are completed.

[@aissaaissa3080]

1:30:00 the most classic isekai show up Garnt : nah not a classic

[@notdpanda9525]

There's no Akira, no Ghost in the Shell and plenty of other classics left out of this completely. I would agree with 80% of the list but definitely in a different order.

[@newbie4789]

55:34 yes. Melancholy may not stand out anymore but if you push through it, disappearance makes up for it soo damn well. Im saying as a new anime fan who started during lockdown

[@sirnonsense5033]

I think what drags melancholy down abit is the endless arc…

[@char7743]

The bleach disrespect man.... and the worse thing is agrees with the most mediocre shows being on the list and am not even bleach die hard fan and it irritated tf out of me you and ur friends have one of the worst takes ever

[@WieldMyWord]

I mean it turned in to his favourite list instead of what is objectively better, Its funny how he can say one piece should be higher (on top 24) despite those talking points he brings forward for why it should be so far up is due to nostalgia that happened 800+ episodes/chapters ago.. The fact he admits he dropped the anime to read the manga due to pacing, etc just showcase his hypocrisy it shouldn't be so high since this is an anime list and not a manga list (and even there I would also disagree).

[@Ash_Wen-li]

35:15 Mushishi. Greatest episodic anime of all time. Grandmaster of vibes and contemplation

[@Billybot8]

Natsume book of friends is on par imo

[@SirthOsiris]

I have it as my number 1 because I just don't know if it can be replaced on my own top 10. So eventually I just said "fuck it" and put it there.

[@wolflink9000]

@@SirthOsiris it's #3 for me behind Monogatari and Sonny Boy but it's definitely goated

[@Ash_Wen-li]

​@@Billybot8I like Mushishi slightly more but yeah... SEASON 7 HYPE!

[@ShinNagatsuki]

Its funny he mentioned recency bias with summertime render but somehow mushoku teinsei which didnt air till 2021 deserves its place but re zero which aired 2016 doesnt? Besides that this isnt even a classics list just most liked anime on reddit. Weird take

[@cluster4583]

Fr summer time rendering was such a masterpiece of a hidden gem and he's treating it like it's nothing special now? and then he got all hyped when odd taxi came up when both released around the same time and while odd taxi is really good summer time rendering is just on a different level imo.

[@ryanergo754]

I am just surprised people watched the damn show.

[@HyperKryst]

@@cluster4583 I geniuenly think summertime render is a waste of potential, really liked the beginning only for it to randomly become an action based show with a lot of convoluted additions to the plot. odd taxi on the other hand was slow but was amazing through and through and it felt like it didn't really have any glaring issues (at least on the surface) so I understand why Garnt treated those two shows differently (obviously that's my personal take on it).

[@TheWanderingPlayer]

New anime can also be good. The thing is that new, mediocre anime overtake older ones because of recency bias. Garnt just finds Summertime render and re zero to be less appealing than mushoku tensei and he thinks that people place them this high because of recency bias. It's not hard to understand his logic.

[@Muchacho2DMax]

​@@TheWanderingPlayer that's the thing ReZero ain't recent. There is a bias with mushoku tensai

[@William14363]

Steins;Gate was robbed

[@newbie4789]

1:44:14 lemme guess the top 2 now that we are here. Probably Frieren and Steins;Gate 😂

[@f8nted]

i dont think gigguk finished watching the last 2 episodes of eighty six that got delayed by months to actually understand why its so well loved

[@pabu__]

initially i don't really understand the appeal of flcl beyond just the soundtrack, but the more i let it sit with me the more i adore the story, as confusing as it is at first glance

[@thegrandsc4968]

"Re:Zero is too high....is too early still for it to be this high.......OH YEAH BABY MUSHOKU TOP 15, TOTALLY EARNED" Brother, I can name single Re:Zero episodes that are better that pretty much both seasons of Mushoku combined.

[@lordtouchme77]

Yeah thats why mother basement got better taste over garnt here ngl, re zero got so many memorable eps like eps 15 and 18 of s1, eps 8, 12-13, and especially emilia whole first trial and beako episode all on s2. While the only thing i remember from MT is the last battle of s1, ED and paul episode thats it. Thats not peak yet.

[@Muchacho2DMax]

Yeee

[@sleepylion9788]

Echidna's monologue alone dunk on the writing of the whole MT S2 cour 1

[@jonathanbosman1568]

Please finish March Comes in like a Lion when you have a chance, for me it was such a deep show in imagery and in story. Both seasons were a 10/10 for me

[@SKERD91]

Frieren being number 1? Nah, not a chance, it took me 5 attempts to get past the first 5 episodes because I kept falling asleep. Don't get me wrong, i've now watched it all and I really like it but the show at the beginning is 'bland, boring elf girl with no personality travels a generic fantasy world with another bland, boring daughter character who also has no personality and they do nothing of interest.' Stark and Sein saved that anime as well as the exam arc. Slow burn? It's a nothing burn at the start. I had to force myself get past the first few episodes because I had the promise of 'it gets better'. Any show that you need to say to someone - it get's better - should not be number 1.

[@cordyceps7531]

Agreed as a big Frieren fan

[@jimsaints]

What's with the unnecessary disrespect towards "Oshi no Ko" ? I'm watching anime for more than 20 years and I still think it's already a (modern) masterpiece and deserves to be higher, based on S1 alone.

[@RitinhaGE]

They may be judging it by the incest plot line that will come up in that show

[@not1noob685]

That whole part about it being a "best girl" contest is literally just a fandom construct. The show itself doesn't even focus on it that much. And season 2 has been incredible

[@xstaticelite1640]

His entire criticism seemed to be centered around developments later in the manga which are not pertinent to a top anime list imo

[@maibigbutt3746]

Everytime Oshi no Ko is brought up on Trash Taste, all 3 of them immediately starts to judge it based on manga leaks they saw on Twitter; with no context clues to follow through. And even though Joey said he still loves the latest developments, the boys seem to not take his words literally since Joey always likes things the "general audience" disapproves, so there's always an asterisk to his likes and dislikes. People will go on to praise Usagi Drop anime by completely cutting out the manga, but for Oshi no Ko its "well the manga tho..." (even tho most people never read the OnK manga). Somehow, cute girls doing cute things ranks higher in many people's list than a well written story with good characters.

[@emondadon]

@@not1noob685 season 2 has been popping off so hard. i actually binge read the manga after season 2 episode 4 because i couldnt wait. the best thing the mangaka did was make sure the rivalry with Kana and Akane wasnt just about Aqua. they have literally the best dynamic in the story not even including the romance. But aye when you got two amazingly well written females, best girl contests might not be avoidable for some people

[@Navigatorzoro_]

Garnt if konsuba can be 22then you should not surprised about death note being 20

[@chaos_freak]

These lists are just rage bait! And I fall for em everytime!

[@Ash_Wen-li]

This list actually reveals the massive blind spot Western anime fans have for shows before the 90's No World Masterpiece Theatre, Rose of Versailles, Gundam, Ashita no Joe, Macross, Leiji Matsumoto, Gunbuster ect. ect.

[@popop143]

It's a "favorite" list, not a best list. Makes sense that those anime are not on the list if the people haven't watched it. You say "western" fans, but aside from Gundam (and maybe Ashita no Joe), anyone from Japan also won't rank most of the anime you listed as their favorite.

[@hokutology1718]

That would depend on the age range of the voters. I doubt many people who watched 70s anime the first time round would actually vote.

[@Ash_Wen-li]

​@@popop143This list was made by Redditors though so I would expect them to be knowledgeable about anime in the past. It's not a big deal though, I just always find it interesting to point out

[@Ash_Wen-li]

​​@@DangoWangochuThat's not true. Everything I listed is culturally important. But yeah as people have said, it's a favourites list not a best or most iconic list

[@Ash_Wen-li]

​@@hokutology1718Yeah maybe it's just cause I'm comparing it to film and cinema buffs that actually go back and watch older stuff

[@Ash_Wen-li]

1:10:00 Monster. It's gotten a lot of recognition over the past few years but I still don't think it has the popularity it deserves. Peak thriller and another anime that's reminiscent of live action shows

[@Stringbats]

stop commenting, you have like 10 of your comments in the top 25 comments, just combine them all into one and stop spamming

[@sprawlz6466]

The production quality of Monster is not at the same level as other stuff around that time. The story is awesome but it’s always been the cheap animation and mid dialogue that keeps it just out of my all time favorites

[@novafn509]

@@sprawlz6466what are your all time favourite animes?

[@sprawlz6466]

@@novafn509 Not including movies or mangas, I can say with absolute certainty that I like these more than Monster: Evangelion, Cowboy Bebop, Heavenly Delusion, Fullmetal Alchemist: Brotherhood, Paranoia Agent, Trigun, NANA, Sonny Boy, and Mushishi. Then there's the stuff that's floating right around Monster's level for me like Samurai Champloo, Land of the Lustrous, Cyberpunk Edgerunners, and Rose of Versailles. I mean I still love Monster, don't get me wrong. It's at worst a top 15 TV anime for me, I just wish it gave more attention to the details of the more dialogue-heavy scenes.

[@FireDragg]

the ReZero disrespect IS REAL. 1) Episode 15 (Rem twister in the cave) 2) the Rabbits 3) "who is Rem" 4) "I love Emilia" 5) OOOOOOoeeeeeeeeOOOOOOOO (Witch sound when Return by Death) If THOSE aren't enough cooking already, then what is ??? Erectile Disfunction (Rudy) ??? Come on!!!!!!! Thats DISRESPECT Not to mention, his ReZero video is HIS 4th most watched video ever, with over 16M views, LMAO

[@lordtouchme77]

He is the biggest mushoku tensei meatrider so ofc he gonna disrespect re zero, its nothing new for him.

[@namo2403]

honestly i watched all of rezero already but its just not for me, if i wanted time travel, i would watch steins gate, if i wanted isekai, i would watch konosuba for instance rezero to me feels like eating a steak for breakfast

[@casaruto]

No bro you can like both really easily i dont understand this stupid fandom wars. Both are legendary shows.​@@lordtouchme77

[@maibigbutt3746]

@@namo2403 the show has alot of "classic anime tropes" that lot of ppl just tends to overlook, but there's also quite a few who cant look at those tropes going along with the themes of Rezero

[@FireDragg]

@@namo2403 thats ok, One Piece isn't for me either, but I won't deny how big and important it is. Gigguk saying ReZero still doesn't have enough to warrant a top 20 is just plain wrong. It is still cooking, yes, but it has cooked A LOT already, enough to become one of the biggest franchises out there. It is, for an example, much bigger than Made in Abyss, both in content but also in fandom, but somehow, he is ok with MIA with MIA being even higher than RZ in the ranks

[@Spaxder2]

Garnt is a redditor confirmed.

[@generalv.1891]

Your Name is on the list but not Akira. The world is doomed!

[@Galin_Iliev17]

gigguk has terrible taste

[@aissaaissa3080]

1:27:50 i need top 20 to be just classics . One of the most classic anime ever "death note " show up Garnt: nah