God Can't Give a Message to Mankind Through a Man

Join this channel to get access to perks:
/ @hamzasden
© 2022 Hamza's Den All Rights Reserved
Please support us by donating. Jazak'Allahu Khairan to you all
Help Build Eman Foundation Masjid: gofund.me/d45959d7
Paypal: www.paypal.com/paypalme/hamza...
Patreon: / hamzasden
Social media
Facebook: / hamzas-den-10066183176...
Twitter: / hamza_den
Instagram: / hamzasden4
TikTok: / hamzasden
Videos Edited & Channel Managed by: Ben Iqra

[@mudassirhotak7131]

Quran: Surah Isra 94-96 And nothing has prevented people from believing when guidance comes to them except their protest: “Has Allah sent a human as a messenger?” Say, ˹O Prophet,˺ “Had there been angels walking the earth, well settled, We would have surely sent down for them an angel from heaven as a messenger.” Say, “Sufficient is Allah as a Witness between me and you. He is certainly All-Knowing, All-Seeing of His servants.”

[@ebrahimkhodadoust8748]

DNA is also controlled and tested by humans 😂😂😂

[@cyberspiral]

This man needs to know what it means to be a prophet

[@asifmaner3576]

I think Hamza has been given a gift of dawah from Allah. May Allah bless you more Hamza! I think you should make more videos like this. The world needs more people like you. Please try to train more people to give dawah like you. May Allah bless you❤️

[@rumelahmed4539]

Hes worse than Piers Morgan. His debating skills are that of a 5 year old at best.

[@GM_ViiR4L]

@@rumelahmed4539 he has the courage to go and debate with actual people face to face, your just sitting there behind your phone commenting on his debating skills while you probably cant debate a guy with tiktok IQ

[@rumelahmed4539]

@GM_ViiR4L courage to do what? Go to speakers corner and debate the greatest jobless minds in the world? Leave it alone son. He usually doesnt have an argument to make, a lot of the things he says are riddled with fallacies and his understanding of anything that resembles reality is non-existent. You dont think I could destroy him? Id send him back to being a non muslim. Hes an embarassment to us muslims, converts are the worst type of muslim, always carrying a chip on their shoulders. Flip flopping from one extreme to another. Converts these days do not compare to us natural muslims.

[@stephensneddon1059]

He's another human with a big mouth trying to prove something that will NEVER EVER be proven....so instead of trying to prove a book wrong, believe in what you believe and get on with life...what is his job anyway, and who pays him?...🤔

[@ghazanvieee]

​ You only hold such opinion because you don't know any better. He has to deal with people according to their mental level... Watch his other videos in different environments and observe the difference... You would know how diverse and vast range of capabilities he has. And that's, of course, if you are free from prejudice.

[@Bilteck]

This man has just discovered the "imperfect conduit" theory. Someone needs to give him a Nobel prize

[@aminurrahman2390]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@oscaroz1721]

Lol my exact thought 😂😂😂

[@JunaidKhan-mj8rp]

Such a beautiful argument between two excellent English speaking men👌🏻👌🏻

[@tetra1974]

and when Mick said "Muhammad saw(- May Allah honor him and grant him peace) "- and said " I respect him" - I hope he keeps searching and find the gift of of truth/believe. InsyaAllah

[@KasaAmiel]

He sticks to the one survival point, as he think, has good, and whatever u say doesn't matter, bcz he want to survive.

[@thebin4]

To sum up this whole video: Bro thought he was onto something 💀

[@relaxisasinaturequran]

Respect for mick, his good guy. May Allah Guide mick

[@aminay.al-mahmeed1820]

Jazakum Allahu Khairan..May Allah Reward you with goodness

[@user-hp9hp3rb2i]

Thanks Hamza❤

[@ALzzanam]

جزاكم الله خيرا

[@ghazanvieee]

Hamza bro... ❤👍 You make us learn Alot!

[@mtl_yg]

Prophet Muhammad (peace and blessings of Allah be upon him) is infallible in all that he conveyed from Allah, in word and deed and in what he approved of. There is no dispute on this point among the scholars. Allah says (interpretation of the meaning): “By the star when it goes down (or vanishes). Your companion (Muhammad) has neither gone astray nor has erred. Nor does he speak of (his own) desire. It is only a Revelation revealed. He has been taught (this Quran) by one mighty in power [Jibreel (Gabriel)]” [al-Najm 53:1-5]

[@essyaboii]

Whether he was a Christian, brought up around Christian teachings, whatever the case may be, he's realized how flawed Christianity is and therefore he's trying to apply his principles onto Islam to help solidify his own beliefs. May Allah guide him.

[@sub7se7en]

​@@user-cw3ox2nn5tSure, that's true, but Christianity is flawed nonetheless. That may be the reason why it has the largest apostasy rate of any faith. I think it's nearing 100 million per year.

[@sub7se7en]

@@user-cw3ox2nn5t Why would there need to be a biblical basis for it? That's ridiculous. It's statistically proven by groups like PEW research. According to PEW, millions of Christians are leaving Christianity every year, and that's not offset by conversions. There's a net loss there. It's the religion with the highest apostasy rate. I was wrong about 100 million though, I double checked. It's about 13 million per year. I'm not saying that because people leave Christianity it is therefore flawed. I'm saying because Christianity is flawed people leave. Not the same things. While I'm aware what you said is what Christians believe, it unfortunately is not supported by anything Jesus allegedly said in the Bible. According to Jesus in the Bible, salvation is through works and faith, and not faith in his sacrifice. It's far more similar to Islam than it is to Christianity. I can provide references if you like. The notion that Jesus needs to die for anyone's sins is not substantiated by Jesus. Rather, it's according to Paul, who contradicts Jesus.

[@MoorfHiden-wq2ou]

@@sub7se7en Christianity is worlds biggest religion you forgot?

[@sub7se7en]

@@MoorfHiden-wq2ou Currently, but that's not going to last. In a few decades it's going to be Islam. Every single statistical projection shows Islam becoming the world's largest religion very soon. Enjoy it while it lasts because it'll be gone before you know it.

[@dripdna9954]

@@user-cw3ox2nn5t it is inherently flawed. Of course there won’t be a “quantifiable biblical apostasy rate claim” .. because what in the..?!! Its 2023 God has no son. That’s a human level thinking. God is almighty.

[@Fur38kan]

Allah razi olsun ❤

[@TheOzTube]

Last part was so funny.. I laughed so hard :)))))

[@ben10theorist]

Just because "humans can make mistakes" doesn't mean that "humans always make mistakes".

[@HumanbyGod]

We should give him an example of "hadith science ". Assume a group of people heard something and then some time later they meet and everyone gets every single word similar. We know the Qur'an is recited from the life of the prophet, minimum five times a day in salah with the groups of people.

[@MrEric-rs2wg]

That was a pretty beautiful debate tbh

[@giginsr]

I hope Rasullulloh S.A.W sees you in jannah. Allahuakbar

[@freeman7983]

Masha ALLAH

[@a.ld.b.9204]

Belief is the six articles of faith that are in the acceptance of Islam.

[@user-1efty29uns]

Brother Hamza has smashed this guy 😂😂😂☝️🇬🇧

[@Mohamed.Jowhar]

I can't keep watching!! This man is dump. Hamza may Allah reward you for your work and great patience

[@aminurrahman2390]

Imperfect Conduit 🎉

[@darkaria88]

A few questions to the kind sir debating Hamza 1) Why does he insist that whatever information a human being conveys from a divine being will 100% always be wrong. 2) What makes the Angel coming down to earth now cease to be an Angel and now a human(Like what characteristics changed in the process that takes away the attributes of an angel). 3) After the quality check done by Angel Jibrael after the whole Quran was revealed near the end of the prophet's life, why does he still think the information would be wrong? like he talks about the dirty glass but if the water poured from the glass goes through a purity checker which confirms the water is still clean, why is he still claiming it's dirty?

[@pandamanou]

good questions, i also hade questions like yours, the man was repeating the same thing without explaining, i think he wanted to say that humans could "potentially" make up stuffs and twist reality because of the "human" nature. and for the angel jibrael, i think the man wanted to also get the confirmation of the angel himself or something like that, so i feel like all that talking can be compiled in 1 sentence: "Muhammed peace be upon him, could be saying truth or lying or mad or making up stuffs to get power, why ? because he is human and can fall into one of those propositions" So even if hamza gave hime arguments for each proposition at the end he sounds like a sophist, its impossible for him to believe that truth can be reachable...

[@abdullahawan9412]

That's some extreme rationalization

[@ironman521000]

Alhamdulillah he loves that word conduit he sounds like a broken record lol 😂

[@nghaider]

To insist on his illogical argument, he even shamelessly insults his Grandmother. How dishonourable can one get?

[@scottholder4431]

Can you show how his logical point is wrong?

[@nghaider]

@@scottholder4431 Hamza did that very comprehensibly. Weren't you watching? However, my shock was what he said about his Grandmother! He said it as a joke?

[@scottholder4431]

@@nghaider That's why Im asking......I don't believe Hamza did. So can you show his logical point is wrong?

[@amahmod]

@@scottholder4431 what? he had a logical point? can you please tell me what was his logical point?

[@scottholder4431]

@@amahmod I asked "how his logical point is wrong?"...........and you have failed to show me. Is that because you can't?

[@mohammedyusuf7975]

Hamza 🔥

[@islampeace7647]

I believe this man is an impure conduit. the reason I believe He is so confused and uncertain about anything he heard from Hamza.

[@Rocksworld1]

Only thing which was forgotten to mention is Angel Jibreel took out the dark part out from Phrophet Muhammad pbuh. So he was perfect human being.

[@toshikosugi]

Baba Hamza Ji

[@rumelahmed4539]

If god is all powerful, he can be both a god and man. A God with a big G and a God with a little g.

[@atc6266]

imperfect conduit😂

[@Israel-IS-Socialism]

They love shaming themselves by saying that being irrational means that they are human If they put it in that nihilistic/human sacrificial way -that just proves that their own scripture in their own communities don’t even teach them gratefulness 🤣

[@HamnetsWorld]

quality control: Angel tells man what to say, man says it, angel check if its correct. smh. its not their eyes that are blind, subhanallah

[@HamnetsWorld]

in his analogy, the prophets pbuh are the filters for the dirty pipes which we are.

[@jagadeshchennabatini8947]

God is a common component in all living and non living things,it cannot speak ,but only reason for life and death of anything in this Universe.

[@user-hp9hp3rb2i]

Hamza he's nice guy

[@KhatmulAuliya]

Gabriel on a few occasions transform himself to look like a man. Read the hadith when he sat in front of Rasulullah (s.a.w.) in the presence of companions. Angels are shapeshifter

[@slimbroski5335]

The telephone ☎️ game demonstrates what he’s trying to get at. No matter how perfect the original message is, humans will eventually mess it up. 😁

[@theoneeyedshaman6884]

Worse than a disbeliever is one who disbelieves but acts like he neither believes nor disbelieves. Insanity!

[@user-1efty29uns]

Muhammad pbuh angels came and opened his chest and washed his heart from special 💧 water from heaven yes he is special and only one who's heart was washed by angels ☝️pure in every way ☝️

[@Mohamed--Aden]

9:15 so if you have specific talents tailored for something you are no longer human according to this line of thinking. Human is no longer human once god grants them the wisdom and ability to receive his message…

[@aaraazameen8218]

💐👍

[@user-mb9gp1hn5j]

I hope God guides the agnostics

[@moafro6524]

He is right though Gabriil hs opened Rasuullullah chest pulled his heart and cleanse it.

[@nokhchi1079]

💯

[@pandamanou]

oh nice point ! i think it's what he was talking about it... but still not sure if he was talking about natural things that happen to humans like forgeting and so on, or he was talking about the "purposely" lying and making up stuffs because the prophet was human ?

[@moafro6524]

Allah ya'llam

[@user-kq8mj9zo4e]

19:00

[@user-mb9gp1hn5j]

The guy keeps saying conduit with his hand😊 conduit conduit

[@barnwobble]

Mick is %1000 correct,funny how Hamza cries Subjective to Mick while believing what he does

[@bobanncob]

where can i find part 2

[@michaelevans4110]

He forgets, the angel Jibreel (a.s.) has contact with Allah Subhanahu Wa ta'ala, so mistakes by Prophet Muhammad Salalahu alayhi Wa Salam, that were missed by the Angel, would be corrected by Allah Subhanahu Wa ta'ala. Prophet Muhammad Salalahu alayhi Wa Salam also received "Wahi" direct from Allah Subhanahu Wa ta'ala so correction Would be available directly, as was abrogation. Jazak Allahu Khayran BarakAllahu Feek Alhamdullilahi rabbi al'alameen

[@leonidasanaxandridas6163]

The words were not put through an imperfect conduit. Revelation was given to the ‘Perfect Man’ (PBUH) and he gave these to mankind. Simples Mick 😂. We give messages to each other all day. They don’t have to go through our imperfect conduit 😂.

[@yumarromero5144]

Salaam alaikum my brother I don't remember right now at this moment the reference where Jesus there's a verse peace and blessing be upon about Jesus that says Jesus a man amongst you with miracles and sign that you all witnessed a man amongst you with miracles and witness that you guys witness that he did that God did through him

[@hansderoode1721]

Yo mick ! ikra bismillah rahmani rahim ! 😂

[@kenh3344]

Angels are not human. As we are .

[@martmohamed1886]

Humans arent Imperfect conduit all the time.

[@hunterking9687]

So if I used q phone to transmit my words, they become the words of the phone not me?!

[@SearchKnowTruth]

The water pipe/ glass is a creative analogy; however, it is not quite accurate for the purpose of this discussion, because water, unlike words (oral speech) is tangible and a physical entity, whereas spoken words aren't. Words of the Qur'an (as well as translations of meaning in numerous languages) may have been written, but the Qur'an is only the Qur'an when spoken or recited orally in Arabic. So even an analogy of air through the pipe or air in a glass doesn't quite work either for the same reason, because we can physically feel air, and air can carry impurities, germs and various airborne material, etc. One cannot physically feel, touch, taste nor smell the Qur'an. We can only read the words from the book and /or listen to /hear them being spoken or recited orally.

[@ben10theorist]

My man Hamza brought the literally dictionary definion of an english word and that dude was like "no". Bro I woulda just leave him if he don't even know what words mean, let alone denying it when someone says the definition.

[@ma.likkka]

When faced with an illogical man

[@lantorres9852]

recite salawat everytime he says 'imperfect conduit'...

[@smesq]

Tell them about mtDNA, it comes from mother only and it is almost the same for all mankind because of some little mutations, science now says: Mitochondrial DNA (mtDNA) is subject to mutations just like regular DNA. Due to this, and the pattern of human migrations, there are actually quite a few different groups of mtDNA (Human Mitochondrial Haplogroups). However, studies of mtDNA suggest that all the currently existing groups (and hence all living people) are descended from one woman (commonly know as mitochondrial Eve). She most likely lived between 130 000 and 200 000 years ago, probably in East Africa. You can do similar studies of the Y chromosome to identify the male equivalent (Y-chromosomal Adam), who it is estimated lived anywhere between 120 000 and 340 000 years ago.

[@yumarromero5144]

All the prophets of God were men but they were protected and annoyed by God

[@AyubKhan-md4km]

He knows he's consciously denying the truth that brother Hamza is bringing to him.

[@car-toonnetwork7723]

Hey hamza I'd like to inform you your channel has dailywire ads

[@frozengamer3030]

He's like a broken record.

[@yumarromero5144]

He will be the one that will tell God to start the day of judgment after we go to all the other prophet like Adam peace and blessing me up on them all the way to Jesus peace and blessing be upon him all the way to the final and the last beautiful prophet Muhammad sallallahu alaihi wasallam and he will want he will be the one that will speak for his UMMAH alhamdulillah on the day of judgment

[@rayhanagrissa2024]

I think his problem is the example he's using of the dirty pipe, cause humans are imperfect.. it should be more like the material of the pipe is not pure perfect metal . And if water went through this pipe and was filtered afterward and was confirmed to be still pure water then it is pure water still🤗

[@bilalmuhammad5845]

Grandpa Shelby

[@MrHamjul]

Basically he wants to believe in God that is not perfect, that himself dictates a criterion for him

[@teemadarif8243]

Don't forget to explain how Prophet Muhammad saaws heart was removed , cleansed then placed back into his chest , by Angels .

[@user-un2xd6tm7n]

This brother in behind eye patch , is he from South Africa ? 🇮🇳

[@ryanmatzinger6698]

Then play it or sue

[@Potato_salad345]

This is an old video from the past.

[@deeeaton1002]

Or ……let’s just love each other and get along and live together in peace and harmony and forget the books ?

[@froggyluv]

According to his logic -if only God is perfect than any other being -which is imperfect as compared to God -cant accurately hear or obey any command as they themselves, even the Angels -are imperfect.

[@Mohamed--Aden]

Imperfect conduit isn’t a problem for us. Since God had cleanses the prophet in childhood and another time in adulthood. Allah mentions it the Quran he had blessed, guided and opened the heart of the prophets and gave them wisdom. And he protects them from being misguided. So imperfect conduit is again pointless to us since we believe God is the one perfecting the mission P.S: Yes, Angel Gabriel did come in a human form at times as well.

[@crozraven]

Prophet Muhammad SAW is sinless & the ideal human so by his own logic, there is no this so called "imperfect conduit" shenanigans. It's simply don't apply to Prophet Muhammad SAW.

[@ace_kriptic3ye649]

I just don’t understand why he says “if he is ridden of his human imperfections he is no longer human” like… says who? A human is a man, woman or child of the species homo sapien, why does him having perfect qualities no longer make him a male homo sapien?

[@obeah81]

So when mohammed believed he was the messenger of god where was the evidence for this? Witnessed by? So where us the difference between this man believing he is the son of god? Arent we all gods children

[@imheretocausetrouble2156]

Is this live?

[@yousefqadeer]

not anymore

[@MohamadRaymie]

Not at the moment

[@hellogoogle1938]

When Life gets hard Manny poepel thinks what is going on the meen is you don't have the nolige from Allah SWT so if someone needs à nolige just pick up the greatest word Allah SWT that's the beautiful Qur'an let's see how good you are may Allah SWT bless everyone ameen

[@user-go5bo4li7m]

تقبلك للإسلام وقراءة القران هو ايمانك بجميع الانبياء ادم ونوح وابراهيم وموسى وعيسى ومحمد عليهم جميعا افضل الصلاه والسلام فهم جميعا من مشكاه واحده .. القران الكريم يعلمك من هو المسيح عليه السلام..الاسلام يأمرنا بالايمان بجميع الانبياء وكذلك الايمان بجميع الكتب السماويه..القران يخبرنا ان لافرق بين الابيض ولا الاسود وكلنا الناس سواء..الاسلام اعطى حقوق الجيران واليتامى ايضا الاسلام يحثنا على احترام الوالدين.. لذلك الإسلام هو المنطق و هو الدين الحق والحقيقه المطلقه لذلك حدثنا الله في القران عن أعجازات علميه لكي يصدقه المشككون..القران يخبرنا ماالهدف من خلقنا ومابعد الموت... ايضا القران يخبرنا كيفيه بدايه تكوين الكون وكيف ستكون نهايته... القران بمثابه كتالوج و فيه اراشادات لجميع البشريه وفيه بلاغ للبشر وقصص للعبره وانباء في المستقبل...الأسلام فيه طمأنينه وسلام داخلي وراحة بال.. .القران الكريم كلام الله عز وجل ولم يتم تحريفه منذ ١٤٠٠ عام وتكفل الله بحفظه...الاسلام ليس محصورا على العرب فقط.... الأسلام دين عالمي لجميع البشر على سطح المعمورة.. حب من اليمن

[@ildaphonse]

Well said

[@sambuwalda1330]

Isa (AS) is also a human being of flesh and blood, nevertheless, he was able to perform miracles because God gave him that power. This did not turn Isa into a God, or ‘more’ than a human being. God can manifest itself through different human beings without the human itself turning into a different entity. Therefor it is totally logical for Prophet Muhammed SAW to be the Messenger of God.

[@jackoply7406]

Most Muslims enjoy a country that was built on Christian prayer and values and yes we are like spoilt children not knowing how lucky we are because God our father "the true God" loves us so much

[@FOOTSHOTS1]

Very strange claim, i heard many stupid claim about our prophet (pbuh) but this one is on a completely different level… just save time and give him a quran. Then say “prove me this book is imperfect”

[@ezz1205]

If God almighty uttered those words, after what an angel uttered same words, after what, the perfect man utters same words, how mentally challenged one needs to be to say the same words are polluted???

[@jthsr]

I get his viewpoint to an extent. I don't put limits on God so Gabriel coming down and verified the Quran then who am I to say its impossible? The whole point of God is he will all powerful. So saying the verification is impossible is saying God can't do everything.

[@meygulet26]

Don't they think, How and why does the Quran exist?

[@muhammadasim328]

Nick: Dirty Pipe, fresh water comes out of that dirty pipe is not fresh water. Hamza: if it goes through a filter, it's clean. Would you agree? Nick: No 😅

[@muslimmade1852]

It becomes do hard when hamza say belief from a dictionary definition, just say the definition of belief from a Islamic perspective..belief is belief of the heart. Speech of the tongue and the action of the limbs

[@randallfe]

Hamas can’t see his own bias

[@dynastylions45]

Which off the prophet had wings. They all were human beings non of the prophet were born prophet they all received it later on in their lives they were teaches preachers before God Appointed them prophet for doing his work if you pass you get your prophethood

[@screwvo83]

He should do hus own investigation obviously he hasn't. The Quran says this book is ONLY for those who believe in the unseen, so it's not ment for him. Well at least for now

[@kenh3344]

God spoke to many individuals . Moses Jeremiah. ISAIAH. Ezekiel david. Come on . God spoke through the prophets. 😊😊 😊

[@nasarkambal4337]

Didn’t the arc angel Gabriel cleanse the prophet’s heart in order to prepare him for God’s revelation to relay to mankind? Based on that it’s tough to claim that he’s an imperfect conduit, because not every person gets that privilege. Right?

[@yumarromero5144]

Salaam alaikum Hamza this message is for the Caucasian Christian The atheist guide do you know when you die the angel of death is going to come for you too then you going to see him once you about to leave your flesh and Bone remember when Jesus said that you cannot enter the paradise with the flesh and bone that we have today but once you come out of your body and you see the angel of death he will come for that soul don't worry you get a chance to see an angel but this is the Angel of death this is a different Angel and you also will see the angel coming from KZbin you will see all this when you die my brother yes the Muslims also has knowledge of what happens when you die and what happens in the grave and what's coming after this life yes we do all praise due to Allah swt alone with no partners

[@user-un2xd6tm7n]

He is trying to cut the believe down 🇮🇳