God vs Evolution - Who Created Humans? The Blind Watchmaker - FutureIQ

[@TheFutureIQ]

Books mentioned in the video: The Blind Watchmaker: tapthe.link/BlindWMRichardDawkinsFIQD More videos for you: Diamonds are a scam: kzbin.info/www/bejne/e5utZXqjmMyoobc Opportunity cost: kzbin.info/www/bejne/nJjXmnZsh9CFrck

[@navaneethshettyb9312]

I recently discovered your channel and I really love how you manage to explain things without dumbing it down too much. But only thing I would suggest is that the anchor should not interrupt the speaker so much. I understand your enthusiasm and love the format of conversation but we need a listener and a speaker. If you keep interrupting neither of you can make your point.

[@TheFutureIQ]

Thanks for the suggestion. We'll keep that in mind. -navin

[@Spiritandlogic]

A humble advice for the host ...Do not Overreact Bro 😂

[@kunalroy9735]

Be positive bro

[@vaibhavparakh7548]

Really he is toooooo expressive, and that irritates..

[@mithamurali9945]

Even I felt

[@healthwealth2060]

Haha exactly. His one of the main dialogues is " Channel band karwayega ye" 😅

[@paroxymal7688]

This is cheap version they are trying to recreate zerodha type of videos but with science

[@whaddoiknow6519]

The theory of disuse is even more fascinating. We can make Vitamin D from sunlight, but we can't synthesize Vitamin C from our diet. However, animals like frogs and horses can. When out primate ancestors moved into the trees they started eating much more fruit and veg which supplies Vit. C on its own. The apparatus for making it was not essential for survival anymore, so "bad" mutations that destroyed this ability were not fatal, and there was no penalty for such mutations. Over time the ability to make Vit. C was lost.

[@sayedsayed2635]

Simply, one of the best programme on knowledge of modern topics. No dubious reasoning. No political slant. Thankyou.

[@yashsaxena6416]

Great work guys. Need more science based podcasts in our country. Please keep it up.

[@ॐतत्सत्-च2य]

Hey KZbin, can you mute the host or just reverse the evolutionary process for him Navin's pateince is really giving in 17:07 - 17:17 - 17:30

[@TheFutureIQ]

I admit that sometimes I tend to go overboard with my enthusiasm but here's a secret: Navin actually enjoys the banter. That said, I do wish/hope you could be kinder with your words! :) - Shrikant

[@ॐतत्सत्-च2य]

@@TheFutureIQ I'm sorry for the derogatory words but plz in the future podcast, for the sake of continuity & for Navin knowledge, plz plz be patient and just be a listener🙏

[@vignanashala]

17:58 Your question is wrong because light (consisting of photons) is only in the UV, visible, and IR regions of the spectrum. Light happens because of electron transition in an atom, which 'quantizes' the frequency of the photons, while electromagnetic fields can have a continuous frequency.

[@adityasharma5029]

We can also answer why organism still have vestigial organs by asking the question why going through the evolutionary timeline.

[@zasyed114]

We have vestigial organs because we have not discovered their use yet. Every year the list of vestigial organs is striking and also that of junk genes.

[@ThiyaguJS]

This channel does what our teachers ignore during science classes. They ignore evolution theory and propogate stupid stuff.

[@hrishikeshlohare]

Sir, can we have a discussion about human consciousness please?❤ This video was really good

[@kulwantsembhi1982]

Richard Dawkins is one of the my favourite author.

[@kamrupexpress]

Don't you feel afraid to say you like Richard Dawkins.

[@Parkashdavi-l9q]

​@@kamrupexpress why?

[@kamrupexpress]

@@Parkashdavi-l9q I don't have to tell you that. You know it very well.

[@Parkashdavi-l9q]

@@kamrupexpress no but like afraid from God or the people?

[@kamrupexpress]

@Parkashdavi-l9q people

[@betterinformed_1]

Thank you for the great discussion! Very insightful... Please do theory of simulation vs reality - would love to know Navin's perspective about this topic. Like Srikanth's reactions - keeps the video conversation flow and interesting! Well done team👍 and BW, keep the content coming

[@josephdevasia3921]

Teachers are always teachers. My parents were and even today they talk like him. No need presentation material, they can convey the message clearly, as long as you pay attention

[@TheFutureIQ]

Thank you! -navin

[@BPranayChaudhari]

Every being , substance, thing, planet are perfect in ther sense. It just our human perception that think only humans are perfect.

[@thevivekpandey]

This is an awesome series guys. I am hooked to this Pls keep going. Can you have "donate" button or patreon, or some other mechanisms that we can contribute a bit and help keep you going? Thanks!

[@TheFutureIQ]

Thank you, @Vivek. For now, just continue liking and sharing it with your friends!

[@satishtangadi2448]

Thanks

[@TheFutureIQ]

Thanks so much for the Super Thanks!! Very kind of you! 💛🖤 - Shrikant, Naveen, and the entire FIQ team!

[@avx4281]

Excellent. I wish students in middle school r taught evolution like this.

[@avijitkundal2109]

The blue shirt guy i love, the guy on the right is very annoying. plz speak less. Let him talk.

[@bansurivala]

A very nice chain of events that explain the evolution of the eye. Is there actual evidence of organisms along the chain of the events as described with the precursors of the eye (light sensitive patches of skin, saucers and cups, for example)? If so, please share.

[@marspalk7611]

Eye is a marvel of natural engineering via evlution thru millions of eyes of evolution. If people can not accept that fact, then envoke god to justify it's complexity.

[@zasyed114]

Engineering ....a word used to define purpose. nature....unconscious force. And you convince yourself nature engineers. Wow

[@muhammeddiloarhussain1701]

​@@zasyed114 There is a disigner who designed every thing.

[@SahilSura-yq4ds]

​@@muhammeddiloarhussain1701 nope its the ever interacting consciousness of particles the resulted in all this material world , humans might be now on the top of pyramid but certainly it will evolve into more higher beings with more higher consciousness

[@moviestomanoranjan]

The scientist is seriously explaining ....but then the anchor is unnesserily laughing loudly in between...reasons best known to him only.

[@rakhuramai]

Interesting insights. However, it may be going a bit far to say everything - not just animals and organisms, but behaviour, nations, societies too - can be explained by evolution. Fields like evolutionary psychology, for example, are considered highly controversial.

[@nileshchauhan1953]

Keep the chemistry bet u two going, love it

[@anjalimewade5211]

I like their match and really interesting and completely mindful. I like the question asking habit of the host ...his expression and wat reminds our confusion...👍👍

[@sudhirkulaye261]

Thanks. You guys have summarized the concept very well. Richard Dawkins’s book The Blind Watchmaker completely changed my perspective. After understanding evolution, I realized that concepts like the soul and moksha have no meaning before the evolution of the complex human brain. The evolution of the human brain is a very recent event when we consider the billions of years of life’s existence on Earth.

[@kamrupexpress]

Very well said.

[@megha_t1d]

🙌🙌🙌🙌🙌

[@AgakAgak]

I like your videos. It's very informative ❤. But the plant in the centre is a distraction. My suggestion is it can be replaced with a picture frame on the wall.

[@TheFutureIQ]

You don't like our dear Plantvati? Why?! She's been our constant companion since episode 1!! :( - Shrikant

[@sjain8111]

@@TheFutureIQ i love plants! i think the point was being a large vibrant green object between the two of you is somewhat distracting 🪴

[@rajasegal1734]

Common sense creates evolution not your argument

[@neerajsingh7188]

really love your channel.. huge respect for both of you, together you make difficult concepts so easy to understand

[@ManiKumar-ht1cf]

Sir’s name

[@grapeshott]

It's in the video description

[@TheFutureIQ]

Navin and Shrikant

[@krishnajam]

Who created that intelligent being?

[@zasyed114]

This leads to infinite regress which is impossible.

[@adhirajchoudhary5940]

​@@zasyed114yes that's why god is not possible

[@zasyed114]

@@adhirajchoudhary5940 God ends the infinite regress. Who created God? None. God is uncerated. The uncaused cause. The first cause. The Prime Mover.

[@SahilSura-yq4ds]

​​@@zasyed114ok what is his nature of his existence how does God exists in what form .

[@zasyed114]

@@SahilSura-yq4ds Nature is something we define by what we see touch and feel. God was existing even we didn't exist nor existed the idea of see, touch and feel. So God is beyond nature and beyond form

[@awilum91]

Well I finally didn't understand the confusion of the interlocutor. Is he creationist or an evolutionist?

[@prakashkoovekal8234]

Creation is through the mechanism of evolution, just like adult form through being baby, plant through the seed

[@sayarsaha]

Kindly make video about the pre islamic temples in Saudi Arabia. If you want to, that is.

[@wordsmith1026]

they say whale evlved from hippo like animals...but the population of all whales and hippos over the time cannot be more than 100 M .... its hard to comprehend that speciialized organ like sonar and depth resistance can evolve in such a small number of population

[@draparnaseetharaman9646]

Change the host

[@dreamysap]

Why?

[@akee1618]

Can a society without religion create discipline and justice in long run even in absence of law?

[@sureshpeshawaria347]

Don't mix law with religion...you can surely do without religion, not the law...

[@whaddoiknow6519]

All of this was great until the guy mixed up biological evolution with cultural evolution. The two work very differently -- cultural evolution relies on memory and knowledge passed down from generation to generation, and is simply *not* driven by *random* mutation. Just because you can construct language that seems to describe them both at the same time does not mean there is any commonality of reason.

[@AnilKumar-vo7mr]

For intelligent designer gang here is a question, who created god.

[@muhammadmafaz8530]

Brother asked a very good question rest is history 😅

[@abhishekjoshua2264]

The universe could not have created itself; it could not have come from nothing. Nothing cannot produce something. If nothing existed before the beginning of the universe, there would be no universe today. Though it is hard for us to comprehend fully, an eternal, nonmaterial first cause was necessary. God Himself has always existed, as He is not constrained by the physical dimensions of spacetime, nor is He subject to the physical laws that He Himself created, including cause and effect. Hence, God is the uncaused First Cause.

[@nvspraneeth901]

​@@abhishekjoshua2264 but he listens to your prayers in Latin in this "spacetime"

[@adhirajchoudhary5940]

​@@abhishekjoshua2264nothing here doesnot mean nothing, scientific nothing means quantum fluctuations, dark energy, quantum fields, static fields, virtual particles

[@adhirajchoudhary5940]

​@@abhishekjoshua2264god is just an imagination of humankind, because we don't even know what is outside this universe, we don't even know if this causality actually works outside universe or not, so go read some science books you clearly don't know about "nothingness" in scientific sense. Search what nothingness means in scientific sense on internet

[@sjain8111]

I have no respect for Richard Dawkins but appreciate that you include book references

[@adhirajchoudhary5940]

Why?

[@kshepherd2022]

Hmmmm……the question is how/why does the first mutation occur…!!??😊 Who/ what causes it….There lies the DESIGNER.

[@harishrao2000]

Then who designed the designer?

[@thimbaiah9005]

Ya but there is an inherent assumption that an intelligent creature designed it na, it would probably be better to say "we don't know" Idk for sure Also, there are many random mutations, the ones who get such a mutation which helps them survive, become more in number with time(cuz the ones who don't get it die), again some random mutation which helps these organisms survive might happen, and the cycle goes on

[@TheFutureIQ]

It is randomness -navin

[@zasyed114]

​@@thimbaiah9005 Mutations are spelling mistakes , syntax errors in a perfect code. It does not make the code any better it only creates an error signal and the code doesn't work.

[@thimbaiah9005]

@@zasyed114 Yes, agreed

[@sjkoroth2018]

Ram and Krishna not made universe? 👻

[@prakashkoovekal8234]

They made the universe through the mechanism of evolution

[@mangosreedhar8277]

Who made Ravanan? 😂

[@prakashkoovekal8234]

@@mangosreedhar8277know advaitha vedantha,and study our upanishads to every question in the existence!!! simply do not waste your time making mockery

[@jessepinkman3912]

​Upanisga and vedas are all aryan bullshit​@@prakashkoovekal8234

[@adhirajchoudhary5940]

Nope, I doubt if they ever existed, I doubt if jesus, ram, Allah ever existed

[@marspalk7611]

How eye developed is well explained british evolutionist richard dawkins. This may be posted on you tube.

[@Phileesha_t-i-t-z]

This was a fantastic explanation for evolution

[@mithamurali9945]

Srikanth is blocking the flow

[@kspace0]

Now I understand why @ngkabra does not believe in thumb rule 😅

[@TheFutureIQ]

Only the Right Hand Thumb Rule. I'm all in favour of the Left Hand Thumb Rule 😂 -navin

[@Spiritandlogic]

Mann it takes alot of More Faith to Believe in Your Theory how eye was made...rather then An intelligent designer made it 😇

[@brahm-ahamasmi]

Until the intelligent designer starts thinking "Where did I come from?". Did I evolve or an Intelligent designer made me? Conundrum captured beautifully in Rig Veda, Nasadiya Sukta. Answer: The Sukta leaves it at that, doesn't answer. That is the perfect answer as per me.

[@brahm-ahamasmi]

Also, they have really sped it up. There is much much more evidence and many more steps, which they have not presented for the sake of brevity. You can always pursue it as a scientist. One of 3 things will happen: 1. Disprove them and find a better theory and get a Nobel 2. Understand it perfectly and be enlightened 3. Find God! All worthy pursuits!

[@brahm-ahamasmi]

Unless you have already ransomed your brain, life and spirit to the darkness! Unless you are seeking, you are in darkness. Videos on your channel point to that.

[@zasyed114]

Asking the question, who designed the designer or who created the creator leads to infinite regress. There has to be an uncaused cause, the prime mover to exist for fir everything else to exist. If we take the cause and effect series infinitely backward then nothing should exist. But something exists eg Universe exists therefore there has to be an uncaused cause commonly known as God.

[@brahm-ahamasmi]

@@zasyed114 If God can be uncaused, so can the universe. Hence the logic that universe needs a cause fails. There may still be a cause. But is that cause Godly (omniscient, omnipotent, benevolent)? If not then it is not the God as told in Abrahamic books. Logically God can only have attributes as discussed in various Vedantic theologies. Specially Advait variants. There God is not benevolent, not omnipotent

[@venkateshkolachalam3766]

Human beings like us are also on other planets but more advanced like Teygatians & pleiadians about 442 light years from our earth. Many inter-stellar entities visit other celestial bodies for source to their needs one of them is Gold & Uranium since long ago the Reptilians are the original inhabitants of earth nd there were Neanderthals as well ape like beings so Anunakis used to visit earth for gold this race r experts in genetic engineering when they found gold mines they wanted help to excavate earth nd get it out for them so they made a deal with Reptilians that they will modify Neanderthals to useful beings nd train them to be productive then Anunakis altered the DNA strands of these ape with Anunakis that mutation resulted in 23 chromosomes which gave birth to a human being. Actually these Apes have 24 chromosomes but the last one human is half ape/half Anunakis. Then these hybrids were taught the skills to mine Gold nd other such minerals to be transported to their planets. Nothing just pops out like that but all this single cell life then other forms were initial experiments of what can be used from earth biological matter to reach a level of maximum synchronicities then have mutations of different higher levels of advanced races to produce different Hybrids. Even now our earth is controlled by the Reptilians who live in underground cities in Antarctica region which is No fly Zone only some US elites r allowed bcoz the deal was when Neanderthals became conscious somewhat the reptilians asked Anunakis to leave earth so they took all the gold nd uranium in their space ship nd left earth the pyramids in Egypt were all covered with Gold as these pyramids were power generators nd gold is super conductor of charge. Necessity is the mother of invention. So please do not search for small things with limited knowledge of earth science bcoz it is already designed by these reptilians as to what knowledge should be handed over to these hybrid human monkeys of earth? The Elites mostly politicians of big govts are puppets to these secret controllers of earth & we elsewhere fight struggle debate talk big about things which we do not know this is 3D that’s how the earth will continue with a false MATRIX which keeps us enslaved bcoz the ideas nd thoughts r beamed into our minds by these dark controllers hidden underneath in large cities in Antarctica 👏🏻

[@ArupGhosh-rj2mi]

This guy should get Nobel peace prize joined by Host.little knowledge very dangerous

[@prathameshshinde9112]

Do not overreact plz..

[@muhammeddiloarhussain1701]

How does nature know to create beautiful butterflies, flowers,hill, mountain, trees, animals etc?

[@shanunelson7161]

Find out your self... Why some creatures are beautiful..

[@adhirajchoudhary5940]

You and I think it is beautiful but it evolved

[@adhirajchoudhary5940]

They look beautiful because of evolutionary reasons

[@cb9461]

Just 2.5K views for this content vs lahks for gibberish focusing of bakwas of so called celebrities who's life is nothing to deliberate about

[@TheFutureIQ]

Thank you for your kind sentiment. We keep working and the views will increase. Karmanyevaadhikaraaste. -navin

[@nvspraneeth901]

​@@TheFutureIQ you are questioning kisan then using his words karmanyevadhikaraste, will you think he will help you 😂.. btw he is jus a myth

[@ylio60]

Science ka bc basic ki raita kar diya aap dono ne

[@richardhenderson4309]

We are not of this world. When was man made on earth, what about the mass extension. Man must have gone with the dinosaur. We are not of this world, our first father and mother were from another world. If we see some of the old historical buildings, today we are unable to build them today.

[@lakshmikrishna5660]

Please read embryology before reaction you can see similarly between embryos of reptile , chick

[@mithamurali9945]

❤

[@LordDajjal432]

Evolution एक फ्रॉड है। में समझ चुका हूं इसमे कितना दम है। 😂😂

[@adhirajchoudhary5940]

😂brother I feel pity for you in 21st century, there is literally no proof of creation, but tones of proofs for evolution

[@zasyed114]

@@adhirajchoudhary5940 Can you name one ?

[@sanchaygupta3466]

For what I learn and understand: 1) chemical composition found on some asteroids presents as proof. 2) Muller's experiment also showed the same. 3) Archeological evidence shows the sequence as fossils of many linking species are found. There are also many but I forgot. Read your own.

[@RashadMunawar-q8u]

I wonder how every male has a female also? God knows!

[@manuhernz2745]

These are a lot of unproveable suppositions & situations that have to randomly occur over billions of years to be true. It oddly Sounds like "Faith".

[@nirbija]

Yes, "evolution is bull shit" ... in so MANY MANY ways! lol However, even as big a bull shit is the fictitious character, 'god'! lol Yes, ignorant people can be wrong, in whichever direction they turn in their 'life is a maze' living. lol

[@rajasegal1734]

Why eye can not evolve...if an organism can evolve then eye can evolve

[@Deveshi.A.]

It depends on laws of physics and nature , even if gets evolved it might take millions of years those humans still can pose same question with evolved eye , looks like it is continuous research and development, remember it is not only eye , brain and nervous also should evolve to detect new readings

[@rupeshkumar-df1zu]

Change the Host..... So annoying & over excited

[@maulikchaudhary9665]

👍

[@waniishtiyaq4993]

Grt

[@ToerohInnah-th6hn]

Evolve doesn't mean humans came from animals

[@grapeshott]

what?

[@kamrupexpress]

I hope that you are not in any trouble for speaking on evolution. Charles Darwin is such a hated name.

[@swordofdurga]

Very childish arguement. There's no God.

[@sureshpeshawaria347]

When we don't have answers, God becomes one - automatically, without any proof, reason or logic..and all the dumb heads blindly believe in it...😮😮😮 There is not one, single acceptable proof of god's existence...now a fool will shout, "then who created this universe"... That's still a question, not an answer, idiot... It doesn't make a slightest difference in your REAL life whether you believe or not in god... it's completely irrelevant...all you need to do is be a good human being... would like to add - most crimes are committed in the name of God or religion...

[@mohammedsalahuddin5559]

So from Bacteria to Monkeys to a Human that hunts Monkeys 😂😂😂 (( Evolution theory is Merde )) la shi 😂😂😂

[@karanveersingh9026]

Host is very irritating

[@raveeshkemmai7608]

Please change the host. He is irritating with his awkward sounds😡

[@Donatellohamilto1063]

😂😂😂😂 waste of time for your theory

[@AnilKumar-vo7mr]

Time is greatest intelligent designer. Still our eye has a flaw. Interconnect that takes the signal from eye to brain for interpretation actually covers the light sensitive area thus reducing its light responsivity. An intelligent designer would not make such mistake. This flaw is indicative of engineering by time. And yes if you find a functioning watch on desert either some human showed up or you will not find. This evolution doesn’t.t have design leap anywhere time engineering is always gradual.

[@abhishekjoshua2264]

The idea that the eye evolved from a simple light-sensitive patch raises some important questions, especially when considering the second law of thermodynamics, which states that entropy, or disorder, in a system tends to increase over time. Evolution suggests a gradual increase in complexity, but this seems counterintuitive to entropy. The eye, with its intricate structure and precise functionality, appears to defy this natural tendency toward disorder. While some argue that energy from the sun can drive the increase in complexity, energy alone isn't enough. There must be highly specific processes and mechanisms to direct this energy into creating such a complex and efficient organ

[@abhishekjoshua2264]

The development of the eye begins in the embryo, directed by a precise sequence of genetic instructions. Specific genes, such as Pax6, play crucial roles in initiating the formation of the eye. The coordinated expression of these genes results in the differentiation of various eye components, such as the lens, retina, cornea, and optic nerve. Each part must develop correctly and in the right sequence for the eye to function. The eye does not function in isolation; it must work in perfect harmony with the brain. Visual information captured by the retina is transmitted through the optic nerve to the visual cortex in the brain, where it is processed into images. This requires a complex neural network and precise biochemical signaling pathways, all of which are encoded in DNA. The eye exhibits what is known as irreducible complexity. It means that the removal or alteration of any one part renders the entire system nonfunctional. For example, without a properly formed lens, the retina cannot focus light correctly, making vision impossible. This interdependence of parts makes the gradual evolution of the eye through random mutations highly improbable, as each part would need to evolve simultaneously to maintain functionality.5. Information Origin: The origin of the vast and specific information encoded in DNA poses another significant challenge to evolutionary theory. The likelihood of random mutations producing the highly organized and functional genetic code needed for the development of complex organs like the eye is astronomically low. Natural selection, which acts on existing variations, cannot create new information or increase complexity by itself.

[@zasyed114]

@@abhishekjoshua2264 I like your comment Abhishek. Can we connect up.

[@eurofoot1519]

Host is too talkative

[@shankararanyadas8189]

So much to prove that there is no God! Sometimes we use the intelligence given by God to prove that He is not the creator

[@rupeshkumaryadavv]

Your intelligence is not given , it' s by blind process is called natural selection, which is not sudden it' s gradual process.

[@adhirajchoudhary5940]

Yes no proof for existence of god

[@theamazingquran6812]

Holy Quran [7.179] And We have certainly created for Hell many of the jinn and mankind. They have hearts with which they do not understand, they have eyes with which they do not see, and they have ears with which they do not hear. Those are like livestock; rather, they are more astray. It is they who are the heedless.

[@Owl86]

We are always watching out for you 🔺

[@rajasegal1734]

How do you know it is not your brother and a predator

[@Farooqueakhan]

Dumbness Doubled ... 😊😊

[@Simply_told]

Do you have a not dumb argument?

[@rajasegal1734]

Why do you not become a predator

[@rajasegal1734]

You are full of it

[@Abhishekabby-t3d]

9:45 or you don't have a thumb 😉

[@siddhartharulmozhi9866]

💀