Grand RP VS Carnival RP.. Which is the Better Role Play Server?

[@tovartheawesome]

I literally just started playing Grand RP a couple days ago, I thought it was the best GTA RP server EVER, apparently I was VERY wrong and I think I'll be switching to Carnival very soon.

[@Overrated230]

Why you say that I was looking into it today but if you say it’s trash I will look elsewhere

[@Hddizzle4shizzle]

Grand rp sucks, pay to win crap

[@comicallylargespoon3464]

@@Overrated230 its incredibly p2w, most people arent even rp-ing so it just feels like a regular gta online server without fiveM and now most of the people in the servers are speaking foreign languages

[@ComplexGhost]

Played grand rp twice. First time was trash. Second time was trash.

[@Sum2prove77]

Grand rp was good when it launched and now its trash trust me i play that game admins are making the game trash everyday i got perma ban i put 1 year of grind and over 100m in bank although now iam unbanned but the rp is shit

[@Maeousie]

Was a Chief of Police on GrandRP. Had a nearly flawless term and just bailed. Getting *Anything* added or changed was just a MASSIVE headache beyond belief. Staff wouldn't even fix the requests you put in, telling you that you'd have to wait a month. I got stuck with an EMS helicopter for over a week because of incompetence. Stay AWAY from GrandRP.

[@PianoRay]

I was high command of multiple police departments including SAHP LSPD and FIB all of which were very stressful since administration are ruthless when it comes to being in an organization, your held to every single mistake you do, not only that when everything disappeared all the money I spent on cool items was just to waste

[@thynkGaming939]

Grand rp is only cool if it’s ya first time in a server lmao once you explore you quickly realize what a waste of time grp is

[@Maeousie]

@@PianoRay You're not just held accountable for your own mistakes. You're "Urged" to hire any and everyone, with scorn from administration if you don't take clueless people. Who then proceed to go alone or into areas they aren't allowed, causing trouble you have to clean up in the form of strikes. The whole system was toxic all around. A coordinated effort from a few people could end a term in a single day. Some of the standards they set were hilariously toxic.

[@reallynotmuffin]

​@@MaeousieI was High Command in SAHP back in EN1 and it was a shit show. So many newbies kept going alone. It was so bad that there was a hostage situation basically every day

[@Maeousie]

@@reallynotmuffin Oh yeah I did a term as Undersheriff. I feel your pain there. And demanding players do what an AI is literally standing there.... able to do.... bonkers.

[@Incognito040]

Last video I really hate that but today I am agree with you for a honest and top review.

[@casxenn4216]

The problem is, Carnival is full of bugs and it's empty. There's like 20 people in the server and it's very limiting on what you can do with the whole RP side of things. Grand RP might be more messy and have less "cool" things available but it's full of life with over 1000 people on the server. I'm not too educated on the others but that's my opinion on those two anyway.

[@s4my777]

BrokeBoiz on TOP!!

[@INSERT_RIGHTHERE]

I was playing grand rp and it took me... more than 2 to 3 days to grind 100 grand its literally impossible to play the game without buying anything.. and the fact everything is inflated and jobs barely pay shit honestly os annoying i do NOT recommend grand rp for any noobs that haven't played for years because it isnt "new comer" friendly so yeah.. anyways thank you for giving me another option to look into because i honestly refuse to play a game where a license plate costs 50 grand and a bunker that u grind a 100k for only gives u 3 days of use

[@BeastieShorts600]

The bunker you can pay for more days it is 5k per day, and license plate is not 50k

[@DOWNUNDERDEVIL666]

😂😂😂

[@aliawan5490]

Grand always was on the track to downfall with their economy being dogshit and pay to win style and now the coins are gone aswell

[@aarushraj3890]

Please make a guide to start carnival Rp !!!!!🙇

[@clockgamer77]

Bro u started? I am also thinking to start is it worth it to start from today?

[@ykwis7991]

Used to play grand rp nearly 2 years ago, was great then not anymore though. Gonna checkout carnival rp, my only concern is that it’s a low player base that was like the main reason I loved grand because so many was playing at once. Anyone knows gameplay feels like ?

[@RYTG]

both these servers are NOT roleplay servers, just another version of gta online

[@lollmal273mno]

grand rp is not a server made for rp. one of the worst servers for rp is that grand rp has a much better script and it's interesting to drive all those custom cars, but it's useless when rp is crap, the police cars go 500 per hour, on the server you only see who will count down whom for the first 5 seconds and when someone starts shooting someone without being in the ghetto, they say you didn't count, you go to the site and that's the best rp server for you

[@hyperind3415]

Carnival RP is much better..with more things in it..must try it

[@Nix_Au]

Got banned from carnival discord for saying imma play another server til they fix a bug

[@PurgeVision]

The English 3 grand rp server economy isn’t as bad as the English 1 server

[@PineTreeMike]

Yet

[@DCSaiZerAdventure]

not yet..but it's going to happen later soon just like EN1 and EN2

[@Venox_MK8]

The servers that aren't as populated aren't as bad yet. I play on DE 04 and the economy isn't the best but way better than on 01-03

[@MidStarGaming]

i like this RP because it has more features but grand rp is easy to understand GrandRP need to improvment and updates.

[@D1V5]

How can we apply for a media partnership in Carnival RP?

[@ykwis7991]

You should make some gameplay videos on carnival, would like to see some robberies or working as police.

[@moneyman5148]

where can i find carnival rp i typed it in on fivem and i couldnt find it

[@davem981]

Carnival has like 18 people playing lol

[@richardr2716]

Where is carnival it’s not even on server list anymore

[@A2XGB]

Another one to add would be Phoenix RP its Brand new and there's a lot to get up to

[@Hddizzle4shizzle]

Unless you pay real money in grand rp your pretty much broke, it’s like playing gta online, not even fun.

[@victheplayer]

i typed carnival in fiveM but nothing is showing up. is this rp server still working?

[@BigDevXL]

great video

[@ReeceMchugh-e6x]

i joined the discord but it said invite link expired

[@kingdrip3044]

Hey, can you make a video of installing graphics mods in FiveM please?

[@maxmadgaming9062]

Don't know why but I can't join the server it always days connection faild from fivem

[@TimeWaster-plays]

what rp are you useing is it grand rp or 5m

[@MauritoUchiha]

Carnival looks like the coolest gta server

[@richardr2716]

Anyone know how to find carnival it’s not in the server list anymore

[@itzvscoh7722]

Carnival RP is where its at tbh

[@DagiTubeE]

i tried carnival when u first introduced it and it was laggy .. i shoudl try it now i think

[@asdeyyy]

I am not allowed to go to other servers because i am an admin in grand rp, otherwise i would check some five m servers out ig

[@Xycloe]

how would they know?

[@asdeyyy]

@@Xycloe people playing on that server reporting me

[@thynkGaming939]

Grp is crap so leave who cares lmao why you scared of them?

[@reallynotmuffin]

​@@asdeyyyjust have a different name or smt.. ez

[@1134marcos]

when i m at gov building and try to apply for job , server will kick me a out

[@YT_Rezy]

ow do i join your family in grand rp server 1

[@elyurirense]

Does Shark Card money work on these servers?

[@arafahmed7015]

Are you vee venetia?

[@t10yt29]

how do i join?

[@Venox_MK8]

Is there only an English server for Carnival RP or do they have servers for other languages as well? And if not, do they plan on adding them?

[@RYTG]

the best roleplay server is ECRP

[@MrVoid10]

how to join ??

[@Nurzr]

Grand RP is my only option because I do not wanna pay for FiveM

[@TheRelaxingMusicSince2017]

Say about fps

[@BudgetLows]

can you make more carnival rp videos pls ???

[@gloverrumph5192]

How do I get accepted in the discord for carnival rp? When I go to fivem to join I get an error.

[@drippyisBored]

me to idk what to do?

[@armon.b]

I made 200,000 in my trucking company

[@ludislavke2976]

i made allready more the a half a mil

[@_Brando_69]

GrandRp is so pay to win. 350 bucks for a battlepass is insane

[@GardenTipss]

Carnival is 10x better

[@scar7078]

bro the problem with Carnival rp is you have to be 18+ and I am 16 lol

[@johnlamsdan]

yeah but as long as your voice sounds deep enough no ones really going to know its not like they're gonna ask for your proof of IRL identity and if they do I'd never trust a gta server with that kind of information anyway

[@TheGamingCitrusOfficial]

What is the size of the server? (including mods, graphics, etc.)

[@BestEverHehe]

Carnival is the worst server, whoever is reading this comment do not play, admins are power hungry, someone got banned for saying nice pfp on their discord server, and they said that he was a creep for saying nice pfp to a dog pfp.

[@s4my777]

Im og grand player but i stopped playing along with my friends , Grand is cringe now

[@DeputyDusty]

The economy is broken in grand rp

[@TheMaglor]

Grand Rp is dead ! no more fun nothing to do in server. economy sucks and other things that goes by

[@ashester2276]

carnival sucks staff dont help you out on how to play

[@baljeetgaming8231]

both are terrible servers

[@johnlamsdan]

do you have any suggestions for good servers?

[@ggaming5297]

grand rp on top

[@soulsDemonwarriorOfficial]

Kid crying as shit 🤣🤣, play for some times then u won't say it again

[@Not_Zulu]

Not really