Things I Would Change in Minecraft

[@Grian]

Those of you suggesting water for building under: it is a method that I did not include in the video, it's not ideal because you can't remain stationary, you drown but most importantly it breaks all grass, torches and redstone beneath you, which there usually is one. Very good point there are other methods - however none of them are a perfect fix, even bonemealing warped roots, they are under the block.

[@crazydragon1846]

Hi

[@masonallen3628]

That is true

[@VVF0x]

Will GRIEN join hermitcraft?

[@LennyTheSniper]

This also doesn't work for if you need to bridge downwards in the nether for example (happened to me a couple of times)

[@ccrum32]

Perhaps a reason that cobbled deepslate isnt in redstone recipes is that maybe there are future plans for deepslate redstone?

[@PetLover334]

I think like Scar said, horses should be able to carry two players on them. Being able to ride horses with your friends would be very fun!

[@goosehonk6715]

Season 8 flashblacks

[@Kevin-wj4ld]

@@goosehonk6715 🤣🤣

[@silentdrei251]

@@goosehonk6715 Mumbo's song instantly played in my head😂🤣😂🤣

[@thegreatbeavers]

I think a Flying Pegasus be awesome as well. Also if you want horses at home, you can always do what Zedaph did with BDubs. Minecart and Boat with 2 Striders while each person riding a Strider while having 2 Parrots on each person. It's silly but fun.

[@NedJeffery]

They should also be faster. And Elytra slower.

[@unchartedchartz]

I think large swarms of bats could actually add to the atmosphere. maybe have them in dripstone caves, and they can fly around in large numbers together.

[@justanothergeek77]

oh this is a great idea! Having the bats swarm would add a lot of character to them I think. Maybe if you hit a bat they swarm around you and block your vision. they don't hurt you, but it's annoying for a bit.

[@roadtoad2714]

Perhaps they should only spawn in bigger caves though, not the small noodle ones

[@masonwilstead6526]

They could be made territorial too, attacking other mobs and/or players that enter their cave (as long as they are a swarm)

[@glupshitto1977]

That’d cause so much lag on servers

[@raphaellebarnes4343]

u played botw 😂

[@ChristopherSmith-Art]

I think the reason the glass is harder to break is to prevent people from accidentally breaking it all the time and losing their glass forever

[@determineattention]

oh no my glass i dont wanna lose it forever!!! ;-; (with a maxed out netherite pickaxe and gear)

[@tanakisoup]

I think glass should break as fast as it does right now, but break faster with a pickaxe. It makes literally no sense why an efficiency V netherite pickaxe can mine dozens of blocks of stone in seconds, but only break one piece of glass in the same amount of time

[@kawaiidere1023]

Sand/glass should be renewable (I love villagers/village-building, but things should be renewable outside of that)

[@machinegunlament]

It's renewable if you make a sand duper with an end portal ​@@kawaiidere1023

[@creeperbait_42]

I wonder how hard it will be to make a check, when you try to break a block like glass, that drops nothing without silk touch, if your tool has silk touch the tool will speed up the mining, otherwise it won't or will speed it up less

[@MadLadTrav]

Something I would like to see would be color variants of leaves. They are all shades of green. Give us cherry blossom trees, or autumn colored leaves with reds and yellow. And stay that shade when you move them to different biomes.

[@slendrrr]

The nether trees are small addition that I was VERY happy about for this exact reason. All trees in the overworld are green. Even a little variety would be good.

[@odayakaanimations7938]

origin realms moment

[@knottleif]

I agree. I loved the new azalea tree because not only did it add those flowery leaves, but it also added a type of leaves that actually don't change color based on the biome it's put in. We need more of this in the future!

[@MadLadTrav]

I get the white trees in the snow. But that's barely anything, and you can't move them they have to stay in the snow biome. The nether trees.... one of them is another shade of green/blue and they aren't even leaves lol. Eh idk imagine standing on a mountain and looking down and all kinds of colored tree leaves. Would bring so much life and scenery.

[@HelpMyCatBarked]

That’s actually something mojang considered, and hear me out, they didn’t scrapped the idea. Maybe in the future we will have that update. Wasn’t confirmed but wasn’t deconfirmed

[@Marzek_]

I think it would be cool if beacons would have certain special-abilities, depending on what is the base made out of. For example: - A full emerald beacon could give villagers a permanent discount. - A full gold beacon could make piglings peaceful, even when not wearing gold armor - A full iron beacon could make iron golems stronger and more durable - A full diamond beacon would give permanent usage-speed of all diamond/netherite tools (additional to haste 2 maybe) - A full netherite beacon would give all of the above as well as the 'Weird flex, but ok'-advancement. Maybe even add more beacon-bases - A full lapis-beacon makes enchantments a little bit more powerful - A full redstone-beacon makes every player in its radius grow a mustache

[@j-j8984]

I love two things about this: "weird flex, but ok" advancement is hilarious. And I love that the redstone one would give you a mustache.

[@MaxWasSurprised]

I don't think there should be any achievement behind the netherite beacon because it's an extreme grind to get one and people who would want to get all the achievements wouldn't want to grind for moths to get one. Tho giving them special effects for what they are made of is a great idea

[@Coli2603]

I like that last one

[@nimifisch.6134]

I hed a similar idea, didn't think about redstone and lapis though, i really think they should do this but if you use more of one material for building it, it should have more of an effect on what the beacon does so you can mix it to your own preference

[@Hu_man_the_3rd]

This sounds like a great addition

[@valoeghese]

as a modder I can confirm making glass break quicker would literally be changing a single number in the code

[@TheRealWaffles1]

Oof

[@news_mans]

that's so hard though how could they have the time???

[@whitebeartigtig]

Yep it literally is. At least in beta. I've never looked at modern source code, so I can't say much about that but I assume it's the same.

[@BABS_SEED]

Thats funny also you are very talented

[@captain_d1]

There's also the issue that glass doesn't have a dedicated tool, so you would probably want to make the pickaxe glass's tool. However, that would also just be a single line changed I'm pretty sure.

[@LuneKidYT]

i think giving villagers the ability to give you quests to complete (ex: fix broken houses, create barrier against mobs) would be a great way to refresh the game, they could be biome specific (ex: snow biomes would require heating, deserts demand water sources, ect) and each quest would serve to elevate the village's level (incorporating a ranking system for the quality of life in villages would be great) but make it so it can be partially automated so it dosen't feel too manual

[@biggiepuffs5368]

Reminds me of a video that Tango made about revitalizing villages.

[@ChristopherColombus-ł]

Just don't want too much "goals" in minecraft

[@carrott36]

@@ChristopherColombus-łI think goals in Minecraft are good! But you should be able to choose which you embark on. You could go kill the ender dragon, OR the wither, or fix up a village, or explore the deep dark, etc. The idea at the core of Minecraft is to have so many goals that there are no goals, if that makes sense :)

[@ChristopherColombus-ł]

@@carrott36 That makes a lot of sense. On the other hand, the thing about minecraft is that it is a game in which you make up your own goals, like create megabase, collect all music disc's, etc. The preset theme doesn't quite fit in with that idea as well.

[@carrott36]

@@ChristopherColombus-ł Fair point. I still think villagers giving you quests could work, but each to their own :D

[@MrMickeyyy89]

I think they deliberately made glass so slow to break because it helps to prevent accidental breakages, especially early game that can be painful when you permanently lose a glass block

[@porygon-z4503]

Early game is exactly when you *wouldn't* have a good pickaxe to give you faster breaking.

[@DiamondPlays901]

I still agree with michael

[@MrMickeyyy89]

Even late game when you have maxed out gear it's easy to use a fortune pick instead of silk touch if you're not paying attention and it's less annoying as you'd likely have the resources but it still not a fun time when you don't silk touch it by mistake

[@DiamondPlays901]

@@MrMickeyyy89 i know.. I think its a great idea honestly

[@MrMickeyyy89]

@@DiamondPlays901 same :) id rather glass have this break time than be instamineable

[@billcipher147]

You know you've been playing Minecraft for a while when horses still feel like a brand new addition.

[@noahsnerdstuff]

reality is an illusion, the universe is a hologram, buy gold, byeeeeeeee

[@87goats.]

Same!!!

[@87goats.]

@@noahsnerdstuff bill cipher

[@oakuvalentine7734]

LMAO

[@TurkeyTray]

I still think that the old boats were recently removed

[@Sbeev]

"There is a lot to be learned from the mods that people keep picking up time and time again." Exactly. A large portion of the most downloaded mods on Curseforge just make inventory management and ease of access better. For example JEI (170m downloads), Mouse & Inventory Tweaks (200m+ downloads combined), Iron Chests & Storage Drawers - item management mods (200m+ downloads combined), & AppleSkin - displays hunger and saturation value of all food items and your current saturation level on your HUD (100m+ downloads). These and many more mods like them just make the vanilla gameplay less frustrating and pointlessly time consuming. EDIT: Bats are extremely useful for locating caves while mining. Especially if you enable subtitles.

[@andrewsprojectsinnovations6352]

Optifine definitely fits that "basically vanilla" category in my book. Sure it's not inventory tweaks, but still probably the #1 mod I hear tossed around It addresses a bunch of the main visual complaints people seem to have across the board, plus a full-screen zoom feature, plus a noticable frame rate boost

[@carrotorr]

A lot of the time, they can’t add certain things because it would be hard to implement on other devices. It sucks because I feel like it’s super limiting to the potential that Java edition has. It’s like we can only have the features of a mobile game, despite playing a pc game.

[@Healion123]

@@carrotorr that would just be unfair for the other platforms tho. There's already so many smaller differences between Java & Bedrock that the mere mention of it could start an argument. If they went even further with the differences, it'd only make things worse

[@neophyte_tpk]

@@Deaddeaddeadiii ew

[@neophyte_tpk]

@@Healion123 I don't understand how quality of life changes would make the debates between java and bedrock any worse. Who cares if people don't like one or the other when you can just play what you want to and leave it at that.

[@franciscoimperial8513]

I like the idea of phantoms in the end city, it makes sense since membranes are used to make elytra and slow fall potions

[@lucasmatthiessen1570]

That would make looting end cities even more annoying

[@ZoDoneRightNow]

⁠@@lucasmatthiessen1570Raiding end cities is ridiculously too easy. Adding a second mob type to them would make the challenge proportional to the end game loot you get. The end should be a challenge because it is supposed to be an end game location.

[@commander8625]

​@ZoDoneRightNow while I agree with the sentiment, adding phantoms to end cities makes end busting more tedious, not more difficult.

[@powdermelonkeg]

My suggestion for the bats: If you want to go for the "they should drop an item" side of things, they could drop bat wings. Then you can craft four of those into a phantom membrane in the same way you can craft four rabbit hides into a piece of leather, and use those bat wings to repair your elytra. Bonus points, a bat wing in a brewing stand could make a potion of feather falling (since phantom membranes make slow falling). If you want to go full interaction mode like Grian suggested, you can use it with the sculk that was just added! Sculk sensors take and give off sounds, so what if making a sound near one (that wasn't in range of a shrieker) sent a signal to any bats in range, and the bat would chirp back and come investigate you? Then if you feed it something-maybe a melon slice for fruit bats, since melons go virtually unused, or glowberries since those are local fruit-they can sit on your shoulder, and squeak at you if something nearby makes a noise. For non-player interactions, bats could hunt down silverfish and endermites in the same way wolves hunt sheep and axolotls hunt down fish, since a lot of bats eat insects. This could be a reason to bring them into Strongholds, even; imagine taming a dozen bats or so, and unleashing the swarm upon the silverfish spawner! Another interaction, maybe they land and stop moving in high light levels, or move very slowly, like how the Striders slow and shiver when out of lava. They're nocturnal, they should act like it! Those are just a few fun things I thought of off the top of my head.

[@cyclopsboxhead5318]

YES!!!!

[@Hibernathan05]

Yes, these are amazing. As someone who has a strong hate for silverfish, i love that particular idea

[@cactusblade5112]

@@Hibernathan05 everyone has a strong hate for silverfish They suck

[@Miksolo]

that's such a good idea and i LOVE bats so GOD i wish i knew how to code i would definitely try to code that in for a mod

[@afeatherinthewind]

love these suggestions!

[@demonicsuagercane]

I know I’m late and this wont get recognized, but it would be cool if the bats were on the ceiling ~90% of the time, spawned in groups, and left the ceiling when the player hit a mob ore placed a torch. This would make the bats actually add to the caves. Also more bats.

[@a-bird-lover]

ooh, maybe more bats near the surface and they get rarer deeper down too?

[@classicdino9077]

I would love to see that. The recent caves update is already amazing, and adding this would be like the cherry on top.

[@aurin_komak]

oh god imagine the noise

[@thedanishcatgirl3205]

Bats do usually live in large colonies and do need access to the open air. Maybe make them fly around during the night and return to caves when it gets close to dawn. After all they don’t live in caves. The problem of more bats making a lot of noise is easily solved. Make them make less noise. Some species have sounds that humans can hear but most of the noises are out of our range. In general their behavior does not really match real life bats at all which is sad because the newer animals do in many ways

[@Beelzebub0407]

another issue to do with inventory is that back in the beginning, all you needed was a sword, pickaxe, torches and food at hand to do most things you need while exploring, and now you need so much more: buckets, bows, elytra/chest plate (depending on what you’re wearing), gold armour for nether, potions, shield, totem, fireworks. and most of those things you could use at any moment, which fills up your hotbar with necessities. i recently read a comment advocating for a second hotbar, that can be swapped at the touch of a button, it would only increase the inventory space by 25%, but allow people to have one hotbar for travelling, and another for combat or building or whatever. it would also easily work alongside a larger inventory if need be.

[@no1caresanymore]

The rotating hotbar in Stardew Valley is one of my favorite quality of life features

[@jkf16m96]

Ohh I guess that's why the modpack better.minecraft implements this

[@FoxTheLord32]

tho maybe you can switch your hotbar with the line in your inventory with Ctrl+1,2,3,or4

[@Multimonata]

Use Quark ! It add rottating hotbars. And many more.

[@enthurian100]

33%

[@HeadHunter697]

With the trading halls point, I actually circumvent this by doing exactly that. I defend my villagers against mobs at night, I rebuilt their houses so they don't have to leave their house to access their jobs. And when I need more villagers I just build another house, place a bed down and let them do the rest, my farmers provide enough food for everyone. I find it's more engaging than just making a bunker and stuffing the villagers in en-masse, it feels like they actually depend on me for their survival.

[@FBI-sr2eg]

Local minecraft player creates socialism for cheap enchanted books and tools

[@shoesbutsockless]

I think you would really enjoy the minecolonies mod. It's like a villager civilisation builder. It gets even more fun when you try and make your city look good too.

[@Astrobotl84]

Minecraft legends is like this, but it's just not Minecraft

[@myujmes]

i also do this! actually most of my game is centered around upgrading and expanding my village, trading for me is mostly just to get mending. I like the appearance and feel of a large, meticulously designed community that is free from hostile mobs. I create a trading hall that they go to "work" in everyday so i always know where they are if i need them. Nobody's perfect, though, I keep my mending librarian locked in a big library and pretends he likes it that way, maybe he's an introvert lol.

[@1lots]

Imagine bats spawn in groups inside the caves and rest on the cave roofs until you come near them and they suddenly start swarming around you. And if you feed them with something, they could lead you to the nearest big cave or cave entrance. Polar bears could go diving to catch the fish. Generally more interactions between different animals would be nice and add to the atmosphere.

[@shaunacall4685]

I think the idea of following bats to large caves!

[@CumberNugget]

I love those ideas!!

[@Tiki_Doll868]

I don't know if this is already in the game, but imagine same swarm of bat's in the deep dark accidentally alerting a warden 😈 the perils

[@Scarybug]

Bats helping you find large caves is a great idea! I'd also like to see them avoid burning to death in lava.

[@prodigiumlibidine8039]

What if you can tame bats with Berries or fruits. Tame bats will squeak really fast when a hostile mob approaches you.

[@historicalanomalies4035]

i had a dream once that they added an armor enchantment called “pockets”. it adds a new inventory slot if you’re wearing armor with it. i like to imagine it went up to level 3 and added one new inventory slot per level, with a maximum of 12 new slots

[@FTLnovaKid]

So you want pockets on your shoes and hat? Lol 😅

[@pittpattlitt3016]

"I like your armour" "Thanks, it has pockets ^-^"

[@Pensasneuvostoliittolainen]

i'm all for hat pockets

[@coolcatcartoons]

Where would the items gσ if you lost your armour?

[@historicalanomalies4035]

@@coolcatcartoons just fall out of your inventory like normal

[@CantaloupesRyan]

I believe that items in Minecraft are stacked to 64 because it is a power of 2, which means that you can continue to split it into equal halves until you reach 1, so it's not unreasonable to change the max stack to 128, 256, etc.

[@leem2155]

yup! because of binary notation, things in powers of 2 are very convenient for computers.

[@theonewithoutidentity]

Yes, 64 is 2 to the power of 6 i believe, and it may be possible to store this number in just 6 bits, although i don't believe this is the case since Java doesn't have 6bit numbers. I think 64 is just a number programmers like more than something like 100 or 50.

[@thenightjackal]

I think having mundane blocks like stone, dirt, netherack etc. be stackable to 1024 would make sense

[@ufiking1940]

yes, now they could incrase it to 128 or 256 but back when its made it wasnt possible cuz computation limitations

[@majapaja_]

@@ufiking1940 "back then" it was only ten years ago not in the 80s

[@randomslavicguy2166]

About the inventory. All the things mentioned (more slots, bigger stacks, organize and quick stack buttons) are things that terraria has already. But what also minecraft could benefit from is accesry slots. Slots that you can use to put items in that give you some benefit. They can also be unlocked as you progress. In your accesory slots you could put: -an elytra so that it doesnt share its slot with the chestplate -a backpack that gives you additional inv slots (similarly to don't starve game) -a compas which wuld create a GUI that points you north/spawn/base -a spyglass to finally make it worth using (you could activate it with a button similar how to optifine works) -a map so you can have a minimap on screen -a totem of undying -a clock -all sorts of craftable or obtainable technical/magical accesories that could show you things like redstone power signals, light levels, slime chunks, coordinates and so much more things that we have to check through external sites or mods or the F3 screen

[@Xandros999]

So I had an idea for bats. What if they behaved like bees, coming out of caves at night and returning to caves at dawn. Then if you have dark spaces they might decide that that's cave-y enough and hang around in your attic or cellar. It'd be an indicator of darkness. Polar bears too could go to caves to sleep or hibernate for however long. Maybe over many days, pretending to sleep through the winter. Coming across sleeping bears would be really cool.

[@meizuo]

i hope they add a ice update soon for the ice biome i forgot what they are called and updates for mobs living in ice biome or a variety update which add more colors and shades of wool and other building blocks and even more colored staircases/slabs or add more breed of dogs and other animals

[@monroerobbins7551]

Plus, maybe they could bring things like scraps of rotten flesh or meat or apples (cause fruit bats). Not allay style per say, but just bringing stuff they like.

[@monroerobbins7551]

@@meizuo or sleds! Those are a thing on Origin Realms, and GOD, I wish they were a thing in Vanilla, that would be so cool!

[@MGSLurmey]

@@monroerobbins7551 Similar to cat rewards?

[@monroerobbins7551]

@@MGSLurmey kinda, yeah. Though… I imagine if you have a LOT of bats, it might cause lag if they’re dropping items a lot, but it would encourage people to go spelunking to find bats.

[@megamerp9315]

Things he would change: 1. Make megabases automatically have backs

[@dukefishronandpigronluvr]

😂

[@J_G116]

This comment bout to have a lot of likes

[@VenomFire7810YouTube]

Lol 😂

[@albinogaming8448]

LMAO

[@georgiedavis9338]

I'm here while it only has 20 likes and not 7k

[@bloodwolf2609]

Backpacks are really a perfect solution, you can see as much in most modded packs. All it really is is a right-clickable shulker box and the difference between having a seamless opening of the backpack for a new inventory, compared to having to place, check, and rebreak a shulker box is so extremely noticable.

[@reoxoglephic603]

If we set backpacks, we need slowness 1

[@pessskychaos4874]

I remember the mod that had backpacks and you made them with a truckload of string, which is a good use for them if you dont use redstone often, even then, theyre basically useless

[@100percent_fish]

*RIP bundle*

[@EzratheRift]

@@100percent_fish what happened to it??

[@nickdimitre]

@@EzratheRift They've sidelined the idea for a while.

[@hera5614]

i feel like the "connected glass" thing could be fixed with one of those villager tables, the masonry table? get a block that you can use to mass-dye glass, make new types like ''paneled glass" which has little squares, or chiseled glass, or whatever ye need! vanilla glass could be "bordered glass", and the connected glass could be the new baseline.

[@shoesbutsockless]

this reminds me of the chipped mod, which adds alot more decorative block variants. You can make the textures connect too if I'm not mistaken.

[@monroerobbins7551]

That would be so nice, and so cool for decoration!

[@timbomb374]

Honestly having a whole village system would make me way more invested in a world. I often build my own villages when I'm playing anyway even though it's completely pointless. Just feels nicer living in a village with npcs rather than building my own house and keeping them in a trading dungeon.

[@osher3784]

The only issue I find with it would be all the bugs and issues that come with that update. Like imagine how frustrating it would be if you leave item for the villagers to use and the AI just doesn’t recognize it and your village slowly dies without being able to do anything about it

[@aapjew18]

@@osher3784 But bugs can be fixed? Anything can possibly have bugs, which then get fixed. That's kind of a weird point to make.

[@Jorgin_Legal6]

I think a simple way to achieve that could be giving big nerfs for small spaces and small buffs for nicer, larger spaces. For example: They could have a 2x inflation if there is no bed or a 50% one if it's in a space smaller than 3x3; They could have a 50% inflation if their overall living space is under 6x6 blocks; They could have a 20% discount if they live in the same room as another villager, but a 50% inflation if they live in a crowded place(something like 12+ villagers in a living space smaller than 30x30); They could have a 20% discount if the blocks they live in allow for acceptable living conditions(stuff like quartz, wood or concrete instead of dirt, stone or netherack, although maybe these blocks could be negated if there is something like a carpet on top); They could have a 20% discount if they can see the sky; The list goes on. These are just suggestions, they probably would have it different but i think something like this would be great!

[@osher3784]

@@aapjew18 yes but even the Regular villagers still have bugs something like that would take even longer

[@aapjew18]

@@osher3784 I mean, maybe. That's pretty speculative.

[@Emerald-Fluffie]

When he said “as a more hardcore player” it really made me realise that this guy really went from “only knows about creative mode and building, and is clueless about survival,” all the way to “top performing MCC champion” within the span of a few years

[@stephalloplayz]

here for it! I remember when Grian joined season 6 and didn't know how to use elytra

[@starkid525]

yeah remember in season 6 where he would just nosedive into the floor and die all the time lmao

[@George12729]

god your right. Hes come so far

[@ypob2007]

@@stephalloplayz the elytra trash became the elytra god of the server

[@starkid525]

he really is the elytra god

[@galacticat7144]

One simple addition to this from me: make it a shift-click to get parrots on and off your shoulder. It’s incredibly annoying

[@captain4318]

Definitely would be a HUGE improvement.

[@kaymeez2214]

dude yes

[@28msLIVE]

Yes

[@ItsAsteri_]

and to lock them

[@askbatguy]

i know why u ask but you can actually just jump

[@amay728]

9:40 Automatically knew he would say stardew because it has such a simple yet genius storage and inventory system. I hope they add features like this to Minecraft.

[@Planetyyyy]

I thought he was going to say Terraria

[@thekraeken]

it is very similar

[@eeee-m6l]

@@Planetyyyy same lol

[@Dingusdoofus]

I think that the inventory slots should still be 9 wide, but with two extra rows. Those 2 buttons are great.

[@theoneandi5241]

and then a tool belt where you can scroll instad of using all your hotbar for basic tools

[@fabiankeidies7755]

Also Terraria has the take item button. So you can stack your inventory again as long as you have that 1 item/block left in your inventory :)

[@henryhere]

@@fabiankeidies7755 absoloulty yes. terraria inventory buttons for minecraft PLEASE mojang

[@Rider-og5xb]

i think instead, it could be like hypixel skyblock. With personal bags, it is easy to find items and a lot more realistic.

[@benji-menji]

I think that it should be 10 wide because we have the 0 button that could have been and hotbar slot but it didn't end up being used as far as I know.

[@svenb.9363]

I think it would help if they made swarms of bats instead of just one bat in a random underground cave, maybe let them hang from the ceiling more often and make them less scared of the player.

[@sheepas]

I just imagine entering a cave, placing a torch and having a huge swarm of bats flying towards the player. If Mojang is looking for atmosphere then this should be it

[@arcturuslight_]

I completely forgot bats can even sit on the ceilings, usually they just flap in my face. Also, now nobody can predict what atmospheric things mojang can and cannot add to the game, after they failed with a certain two pixels.

[@kaboomer]

Grian: “lastly we’ll be talking about pvp” Scar: *my time has come*

[@armp1tthenormalguy176]

HAWKEYE!

[@xudaniel2762]

@@armp1tthenormalguy176 hOt GuY

[@wetsprocket625]

Superfast PVP mode.

[@YaboyiNathan]

Your profile pic made me laugh so hard

[@lucasqualls5086]

2:55 I have craved for the longest time the desire for a mechanic that makes raids a constant thing you need to defend against. It would happen only once you begin to grow a villages wealth and population. The increased level of villages gives you better trade deals, and more types of villagers, but corresponds with harder and harder raids. The raids could trigger upon leveling up a village. Once a final level is reached, raids return to just being when you kill the pillager party banner holder. Overall, villages are the key to minecraft feeling lived in. If villager AI could be mastered and constantly engaging, it would combat the emptiness and loneliness of single player minecraft worlds. Give something beyond building for building's sake.

[@brickone_]

I would really like to be able to customise the "Sorting-Button" so my standard inventory layout can put itself back in place how i want it to be.

[@holographix4722]

There exist QOL mods if you want (they are clientside)

[@ClownIsGood]

@@holographix4722 dude thats mods not official

[@unknownleo24]

Like terraria?

[@jasonreed7522]

When he said "lets go to another game for an example" i thought of terraria immediately for its quick deposit and withdraw buttons (and a sort button). Honestly I don't care too much about the auto sort because my standard is a nearly empty inventory and a full hotbar

[@unknownleo24]

@@jasonreed7522 same

[@spectrumjitters4672]

3:44 YES this is exactly what I want. I wanna build super secure villages that are also functional and practical. I want to defend the village and have fun

[@beneboy8695]

When I was younger my favorite thing to do in Minecraft was go in creative and remodel villages making a wall and defenses. Then I'd have zombies invade and go in survival to fend them off. It would be amazing to have this be in survival!!!

[@LLRTgame]

@@beneboy8695 Same it was my Favoriten thing to do!

[@RemTheFisrt]

yes, while i agree a lot, it would be ridiculously hard to code soo if this will happen it would be incredibly difficult

[@Spirit0fBoredom]

@@RemTheFisrt It's not like only a handful of people are working on minecraft, though. If the company can code something like the warden and the new world generation, surely this is a possible change

[@WackMaDino]

Yeah, I think it would be cool if minecraft had more systems which encourage building certain things. I.e villagers actually needing houses like in terraria to encourage you to build cool unique villages. Another less overpowered counterpart to villagers could still be added to fill the role of villager farms because i dont think its a good idea to completely remove them when so many people enjoy them, but mojang themselves have said they want to encourage people to build across the world rather than just having one base with really efficient compact farms in them when talking about amethyst geodes. doesnt hurt to have a bit of both

[@Drotdog]

The ‘organise’ and ‘transfer’ features immediately sent me to terraria, though I do think Stardew valley might have had them first, just don’t have all those memories with it.

[@A_Professional_Idiot_mk.2]

I think terraria had it first

[@endreask]

Terraria was first because it's an older game

[@onex4739]

yep

[@clarehidalgo]

Terraria came out way before Stardew and it had the organize and stack features. My friends and I were playing both at the same time during high school back in like 2012-2014 and that's what we would complain about to each other lol

[@VbLongNeck4110]

I've played a lot of all 3 games and the inventory mechanics were first and better in terraria by far. "Quick stack to all nearby chests"

[@ashmarie130]

Something that i hate is that you can't convert a path block back to dirt without either breaking and replacing it or placing something on top. It's such a small thing but can be really annoying

[@AmartharDrakestone]

The glass breaking actually does seem intentional. It seems that it's to prevent you from losing the blocks. Glass needs silk touch to pick it up again and if you confuse your picks, with the current speed, you at most will lose one block before you notice that you don't have the right one. If it could be insta-mined, you would lose a lot more before noticing. And glass is a PITA to get.

[@LtDansOldLegs]

Except its not a huge pita because (tying into something he also mentioned) even just a basic villager hall will get you plenty of glass

[@Lumpypillowcat]

I agree! I would end up constantly breaking huge swaths of glass because I'm so clumsy with mining.

[@tirisiclaudiu7672]

I'd rather lose glass than go through the pain of mining glass.

[@james8616]

Plus, they could change it so that it only instamines it if you have a silk touch pick

[@McMinecat]

you could easily fix this with making silktouch pickaxes then be able to break at the same speed :D if the item can drop it can be broken fast, this also makes sure you need to want to break it and since needing to break huge amounts of glass is usually only a problem for players who would already have access to silk touch i feel like it could work

[@chopstick1308]

I completely agree with the backpack idea. However, instead of unlocking slots as you progress, you could be able to craft bigger backpacks with the loot of bosses, and also rare items which can prove your dedication to unlocking new slots. The backpack could, instead, have an inventory to the right of the main inventory and may not have very many spaces at first, however as you craft bigger ones, the space greatly increases.

[@McLegg]

Hey buddy, I think you'd like to look into backpack mods. This is basically every single one of those

[@johnzockt6338]

My idea would be to have a backpack thats upgradeable. So if you kill the ender dragon you get dragons hide with Wich you can add a few slots. Or the whither spine to add a few. Ofc these bosses are repeatable so id think of making it a one time upgrade...

[@begrs8156]

I dont agree, but the only reason is that items are tradeable. So new players can just get a full inventory in no time. Unlocking them with runes that you cannot pick up is more elegant. A new player can ask for help in getting them, so the old player also gets to experience the content again. The new player also experiences the content to unlock them. instead of simply getting the item handed to them.

[@lynnilotta]

i agree, that would be really cool and bring more motivation for players to fight the bosses aswell. on every smp that i am part of a lot of the players never bother killing the dragon or the wither.

[@johntheappleseed6585]

Mojang could 100% add a new "glass frame" item for anyone that wants to keep the og framed glass. There could be glass, iron, copper, or gold frame options which make glass even more customizable. Make connected glass the default option. It's obnoxious to not have glass that you can properly look through. Mojang literally admitted that this glass texture was a problem when they overhauled all the textures.

[@UnknownInstict]

Copper would be best, give it more crafting options

[@sheepas]

Then they'd have to make glass framed version of every different color including glass planes. There should be an option to "scratch" them by right clicking using an axe

[@everyone4352]

@@sheepas It would be better if you just wax them because they look like shiny glass (Axing a block of glass is just very barbaric)

[@sheepas]

@@everyone4352 an axe would make sense though, as when you strip wood you shave the rough sides and this would be the same but just for the edges of the block. Or you could click on them using iron nuggets/bars/chains. Wax would be too consuming to hide the dark edges on large builds like Scars storm. And almost no one needs glass with edges in a very large build

[@Direblade11]

And the breaking thing: imagine if glass, or at least glass panes, could be instantly broken with projectiles. I think it'd be cool

[@armstronggaming8566]

On the item stack count, what would be cool is if you could adjust the maximum stack size of items via editing a game rule

[@TrisMusicalMind]

That would be a nightmare to code in due to the fact that every item has a hard coded stack size

[@armstronggaming8566]

@@TrisMusicalMind yeah, that's why I said it would be cool. Definitely not a must have, but if I had the option to have it, I wouldn't say no

[@mcpecommander5327]

@TrisMusicalMind it wouldn’t be that hard? You could just have a getItemStackSize method which would take the default stack size and scale it by some gamerule factor

[@TrisMusicalMind]

@@mcpecommander5327 my bad lol. I only know very basic modding stuff

[@daniel4dayzzzz]

⁠@@TrisMusicalMindpart of it is the fact that it’s a 64 bit game, so stacks can’t be bigger than that, or it’ll send the game engine into a downward spiral.

[@robingrapentin2238]

A good reference for a lot of features that feel like they belong in Minecraft is the "Quark" mod, Inv sorting, transferring items in bulk, slime in a bucket to find slime chunks....

[@Bryzerse]

Yes I've always wanted that slime in a bucket in Minecraft

[@bobuccman1424]

yes, but if you dont want to use forge just because of how bad it performs theres no quark for fabric

[@codinghub3759]

@@bobuccman1424 I have no issues with running forge. You just need to find the right optimization mods.

[@bobuccman1424]

@@codinghub3759 thanks for the great tips and recommendations, whatever forge mod there is they probably dont top sodium and alike

[@A.Grapefruit]

Right, just give us fucking glass shards

[@fri815]

I've always thought that Terraria's inventory options are the best in any game. Quick stack to nearby chests, sort your inventory, favorite items so you can't drop them by accident, name chests so that you can see their name while hovering over them, etc

[@Octoreality]

Yes … just yes

[@NATHANNN223]

Totally agreed

[@UltraAryan10]

You can name chests in Minecraft but they don't act like hover name tags which is really annoying.

[@bluecorvidart]

Terraria has really kept on top of quality of life changes over the years. (I wouldn't mind seeing Terraria-esque villagers in Minecraft, as well.)

[@smelloodle1070]

Terraria’s upcoming “final” update is literally mostly quality of life changes.

[@notme9801]

I would say more expensive beacons should have a greater range of effect

[@brettmueller6867]

Fair point

[@2wugs]

@KINDLY HELP ME REACH TO 10K SUB BEGONE B O T

[@baisale36]

I’ve always thought that should be the case, also that beacons just increase in range by a certain amount the more layers, which theoretically could be “infinite” (up to max build height.)

[@sqweed653]

YES THIS PLEASE!

[@jakubzamecnik6153]

well.. netherite beacon could also give 2 effects.. cause man getting so many netherite blocks should've been rewarded

[@francis33partier]

I think a tool wheel would be incredible. That way our inventory slots are dedicated to more blocks and things and our tools have their own section. Have the tool wheel completely customizable with maybe 8 spots.

[@buddy1397]

Actually why not have 10 slots 9 for the axe, pickaxe, shovel, hoe, sword, shears, bow, crossbow, and trident then 1 slot for a totem or extra shield

[@captain_noodles]

​@@buddy1397the default hotkey is currently 1 to 9 for the slots. they could designate 0 but that would be too scuffed for mojang now that microsoft owns them.

[@alanbarnett328]

I really want trees to be taller. At least by one block, so you can ride your horse easily through oak forests, but how many forests have you been in where you're scraping the top of your head on tree leaves? Ideally, we could have trees be an average of three blocks taller, going up or down by up to two blocks. Also, I wish there could be skinnier trees. I know there are mods for this, but it seems like a good change to make in game forests more immersive and realistic.

[@clauteletuby]

the taller tree thing is going to be a pain to cut them down early game

[@IzukuMidoriya-bb4ez]

i also want taller trees, and as much as everyone loves memeing on the floating trees, i think we should change the gravity on trees. like in rlcraft, i suppose. but its always annoying how short the trees are

[@VanK782]

For sure

[@Leekodot15]

@darknightoftroy It all depends on the type of forest, honestly. Tall redwood forests (depicted as the mega taiga in Minecraft) are the only forests I've seen, unfortunately, so I can't say all too much, but at the same time, I feel like there should be a more consistent canopy. But, definitely no one tall trees, at least two talls are great. I have one talls.

[@redshift739]

I would really love to have a "quick stack to nearby chests" option like Terraria has

[@cosmicality9688]

This is just my opinion don't attack me but, I feel like all the sorting and such is just a part of MC now. Like it would feel weird without. And other creators spent so much time creating systems for this. Merging the stacking idea with MC just wouldn't sit right with me (at least).

[@jkf16m96]

@@cosmicality9688 in my opinion, sorting systems are extremely ineffective and that's why is not the norm. The most popular one, needs a lot of materials for early game, lots of iron, and only works for one kind of item. That kind of automatic sorting is only a one time thing someone would ever do with lots of items. We want a block or something, that can sort by itself, even if it costs diamonds.

[@redshift739]

@@cosmicality9688 I won't attack you. For me it is fun to a point but it usually gets boring later game when my chests fill up and I have to rebuild or expand more storage constantly. I'm too lazy to build a redstone storage system lol

[@Demonslayer_456.]

As a fellow Terraria player, I agree that quick stack, even if they made it just chest-by-chest, would be a massive help when trying to maintain sorting.

[@johnsmith-fy8jo]

The problem with this is that on servers you could use this to find chests

[@h0ppip]

the blocks you use for the beacon should determine its range, with a iron block beacon having the current range and each more valuable block in the beacon increasing the range

[@kb6358]

Someone should put this on minecraft feedback

[@mikkelburinratzlaff2618]

The only hard thing to get late game is diamonds though

[@Gin-toki]

@@mikkelburinratzlaff2618 Netherrite blocks are arguably more difficult to get than diamond blocks. Otherwise yes, iron, emerald and gold can easily be farmed and as such, should ideally have the same effect when used as a beacon base.

[@Nephelangelo]

I don’t think gold should be renewable. It ceases to hold the value and character of a precious metal if you can produce unlimited quantities. None of the precious metals or minerals should be renewable.

[@mikkelburinratzlaff2618]

@@Gin-toki forgot about netherite😅, I don’t think anyone will grind for a beacon just for more range tho

[@snasvroomsticc473]

Honestly i was skeptical through the most of the video but the phantom bit quite literally had my jaw dropped. Ngl it's a good idea and it honestly makes so much sense that they would be living around the end cities.

[@motherlove8366]

Lore wise it at least addresses the question of how the elytras were made

[@carrott36]

What if phantoms could pick you up and carry you into the void if you got hit by a Shulker? I think that’d be interesting. Could also be neat for them to get angry warden-style when you loot an elytra.

[@epicplayz6132]

I've always thought that Terraria's inventory options are the best in any game. Quick stack to nearby chests, sort your inventory, favorite items so you can't drop them by accident, name chests so that you can see their name while hovering over them, etc 💙💙💙

[@jessefranks2017]

I legit thought he was gonna show the inventory from terraria, when he was talking about inventory space.

[@itslolplays]

@@jessefranks2017 honestly, who didn't think that?

[@4ngryant]

I love the terraria inventory!

[@rickvanleeuwen9589]

Relogic is going to raise the stack limit from 999 to 9999 in the upcoming Labor Of Love update

[@Zeldrake]

Also shoutouts to a delete button! Minecraft doesn't have this, you just have to dump them on the ground till they despawn (or you pick them up again by wandering over)

[@JP-dz5oj]

The ability to smelt raw copper/iron/gold blocks into their normal block counterpart would be a great change in my opinion.

[@swordsmancs]

Oh 100%, I’m working on a build in survival (a giant warship, over 11k blocks of iron) and this would save me *so* much time

[@C0deXANA]

Genuinely wish that would be a thing, even if we had to use a new type of furnace OTL

[@swordsmancs]

@@C0deXANA Blast Furnace 2.0, takes 2 coal, smelts a block of metal

[@tagekarlsson4536]

Wouldn't make sense

[@swordsmancs]

@@tagekarlsson4536 care to elaborate?

[@daglemj]

I feel like the cave update is missing a climbing rope. Like reverse scaffolding you could place it on the top of a block and keep clicking to make the rope hang down the side. It would be cool for cave exploration and useful for building. Iron and a bit of slime to create the "hook" and string could be made into rope that would connect to it.

[@aarongrooves]

LOVE this idea!

[@brady1701]

Great idea!

[@abcrasshadow9341]

Scaffolding is affected by gravity so this already exist in a way.

[@geo4876]

@@abcrasshadow9341 Depending on how high up you are, using scaffolding in that way could use up too much scaffolding in order to be beneficial.

[@popcornpope1969]

twisting vines are very simalir but great idea

[@shadowdemonaer]

I'm in the inventory section now, and if it wasn't mentioned,, I would like a separate area just for ammunition just like in Terraria. Also, in regards to backpacks, I have wanted them for so long. I have always hated that we can only get shulkers when we beat the game. One of the most frustrating feelings in the world is thinking about how much it would have made a difference in our lives to be able to have a backpack. And if they are worried about it not being balanced enough, they can make it so you can only use one at a time, and have it replace armor like an elytra does, and it could double the inventory size. Also, I'd like it if the stuff in our shulkers in our inventory could auto pick up things we are getting. Like, if we are strip mining and we have some for shunting off cobble and stuff into other shulkers, that would be awesome. How about an idea for something in our inventory that we can put one item into and it tells the game to throw away that one item whenever you pick it up automatically? Like an inventory trash can. I dunno. I just think about this a lot.

[@propheinx2250]

They should just add a back slot to equipment and add some extra items to fight for the slot. Obviously elytra would still be a top contender for the slot, but a backpack and a quiver could be decent choices depending on circumstances. Backpack is obvious, it turns your personal inventory space to the equivalent of a double chest, instead of just a single chest worth of space. A quiver could both offer a free spot for a stack of arrows, and make you draw a bow a little faster. Another option could be a redstone pack that would cause you to radiate light while in dark places. Or even a parachute for a get of jail free card when you accidentally fell off a cliff not paying attention to your surroundings. Imagine a creeper cloak that would make creepers completely ignore you if you crouch while wearing it. Back equipment should be its own slot, and there's many things that could even challenge the elytra for the slot.

[@buddy1397]

If they do add backpacks make it so that you can put it in your inventory but to access the things inside you have to put it on and if on when you open your inventory it looks similar to when you open a chest also they should allow you to merge the elytra and armor together by crafting a elytra chest plate which would be 2 elytra 1 diamond or nethrtite chest plate and 3 ender crystals

[@jefftheevilpotato]

I don’t know about increasing the stack amount from 64, but the few items that have stacks of 16 should be increased, I don’t see why they aren’t.

[@PetLover334]

I would love to see the stack amount 64 to be increased, but the stacks of 16 be upped to 64.. that way you still have that number in the game

[@joelhoon1707]

They should just add and rework bundles so they can hold 128 items that can be stacked in 64s.

[@2520WasTaken]

Signs

[@CrimsonAkato]

64 stack is too iconic I would literaly feel weird holding like even a 65 stack like yeh no .. I can't but indeed snowballs signs and other items if 16 should definitely at least if not to 64 . just make it half then like 32 .. I doubt u would ever been over 30 signs like hiw many chests are u going to put a label on ..

[@TheAuron32]

while i agree for some items, i feel for Ender Pearls it would be too OP to hold more of those "get out of jail free cards" because they can be so damn powerful if you use them right.

[@moist_box1244]

9:37 I actually think terraria's system is ever so slightly better, because it has both an organize (9:44) and add to chest (9:53) button, but in addition to that it also has a quick stack to nearby chests button witch makes putting away items after a long trip as easy as pushing a button. terraria also has a "restock" button witch allows you to restock your inventory with resources from the chest.

[@simirror_9930]

Terraria just does everything right

[@pavloydus]

Don't forget locking items

[@dandalfthewizard2220]

Love all of these suggestions - inventory is definitely the biggest issue brought up here. You didn't mention chopping trees. At the moment, a haste beacon does not affect the speed of chopping trees - and I personally would love to see haste chopping and insta mining logs.

[@electro-pros2749]

Idea: if you steal anything from villager house (wood, chest, etc) iron golem will hit you. How is it?

[@electro-pros2749]

And make emerald veins 1 - 6 veins, and more % of trades of emeralds

[@slawrie]

Haste on logs works on bedrock, just not on java

[@cloverlovania]

@@electro-pros2749 sounds annoying, to be honest

[@EmalynPugh]

11:14 I just love how Minecraft just was like "here take a bundle"

[@ApexBrachydios]

I use "add to existing stacks" SO often in Stardew, I'm sure I would use it in Minecraft too. Maybe a "Deposit All" button that moves everything but your hotbar to a chest could work too

[@ApexBrachydios]

Or, "quick stack to nearby chests" from Terraria

[@Tomd8002]

The closest thing was a mod called too many items (later versions called not enough items and just enough items) that had buttons to sort and transfer the whole inventory. I do think only transferring items from your inventory that are already in the chest is a much better feature that would really help with organising inventories!

[@CarrierOfChaos617]

JEI mod

[@bloodwolf2609]

Terraria's inventory sorting is just very good in general, being able to favourite items, quick stack to chests, auto-trash stuff you dont need; It's just a very well executed inventory.

[@shadowsquid5499]

@@bloodwolf2609 Autotrashing? I need this. How? But yes agree. Terraria's inv management is amazing (and only going to get better with the 9999 stack limit in 1.4.4)

[@Yeetyn]

The stack size is 100% iconic. When I’m taking a test I’ll think “I’ve answered a stack of questions” or “that’s two stacks of dollars!” It’s become a unit of measurement in my head.

[@TheTiredWorm]

I THOUGHT I WAS THE ONLY ONE

[@brickbot2.038]

Changing the stack size would also mess up almost every redstone contraption that utilize comparators reading block inventories.

[@MohS05]

I guess size of stack based on byte size , 1 byte has 8 bits. 2^6 =32. so bits for item count, 1 bit for storing if item is stackable or not. Last bit I am not sure

[@benjamin_luscombe]

@@TheTiredWorm you are one of Many

[@Nothing-f8z]

@@MohS05 I think in the very early stages of the game stacks sizes was limited to 64 because how java handle numbers, pretty sure they have changed it when changed how the game store item types, because they could only could a fixed amount of unique items at the time

[@flashlightning6742]

I’d be perfectly content with 1.20 being “The Community Update” that just adds a ton of EOL changes we all want. I think connecting glass is a big one here. I don’t think many people would complain about the update being small and insignificant because it is mojang just listening to the community and doing what we want

[@vanKarsie]

Thats literally the exact same name and idea I had while watching the video

[@iamyukkithesnowman9178]

The connected glass should be another type of glass rather than removing said old glass. And revamping content is also important especially with something that looks like the dungeons.... and yeah I would have no problems with an update focusing on QoL changes and Revamp of Content

[@paigesingleton5828]

I build with glass all the time and I severely dislike the individual boxes everywhere.

[@kooldudeno-lastname]

i want the transportation update, but that works too

[@cyborgbob1017]

i mean id argue thats pretty significant tho lol

[@manitshukla568]

I think Terraria deals with villagers preety well. In it, you have to make housings for npcs to move then you can sell or buy items. You have to keep in mind their preferred biomes, their relationship, not making everything cramp etc. So that you have the best deals. You also have to move them into certain biomes to get certain items. Alongside that, certain things can only be unlocked after completing certain goals like killing bosses. So if mojang wants to fix villages, they can make so that the player has to make specific shops and structures around villagers for them to work, make so that you should not keep them cramped and you can't just cure them into Oblivion. Making certain trades biome specific can also be good. The problem with 1.20.2 rework is that no matter how far you are into the game, you can never get max level enchants from the villagers, which is preety annoying. They can do that if you do certain things, like completing certain things like how did we get here, they start to sell max level enchants. This update also doesn't fix any other issue.

[@gamer9smith]

Thissssss, I love terraria and they do NPC’s and your town so well

[@tolanere8469]

Deep Pockets enchantment for Pants with three levels. Each level adds 9 more inventory slots. Make the enchantment you can only find, similar to swift sneak.

[@anicrue]

I'd be on board for that! I'd work for both Java and Bedrock edition mechanics, with the only possible difficulty being UI, though there's already differences, so nothing new there.

[@meowthekitty321]

Swift sneak?

[@MarkusAldawn]

I'm torn on whether it should be available in other forms. I feel like if it were to be added, it would massively incentivise exploration, but more in a "I spent three hours with chunkbase looting every temple within 2000 blocks" way than a "oooh, I found a fun prize!" way. Then again, if it's a tradable, it'll be farmed. Maybe much like Soul Speed, Piglin trading? That way there's an adventure aspect to getting it, since the Nether is still at least a little danergous (not fixing that typo, it makes me laugh) and quite unpredictable, but not a massive hassle to get if you want to get it in bulk. It's still random, but you can increase output. You'll get ten stacks of blackstone, but you will, eventually, get Deep pockets. If you can only find it in chests, it'll end up becoming frustrating to replace. If in a 1000m2 area, there's one book with Deep Pockets on average, imagine running a server with any number of people. Conversely, if it's more common, on single player it will feel almost too common. It gives another valuable purchase for gold, and gold is an underutilised part of the tech tree in Minecraft imo.

[@tolanere8469]

@@MarkusAldawn great points. I am just tossing suggestions. But you have a great point on the multiplayer side of it.

[@Shenorai]

On one hand, that sounds absolutely amazing. On the other hand... what happens when the durability runs out? Do the excess items explode out from the player [which would be abysmal around lava/cacti/the void]? Do they drop in a Bundle [which honestly, could be overhauled too]? Do they automatically place themselves around you when applicable?

[@geminimaxxim]

On the topic of inventory, I think a big step to making inventory management easier would be making more items stackable. Boats, Bowls, Water Buckets, Water Bottles, etc.

[@mistuyy]

yessss

[@mistuyy]

also bowls are, but muskroom bowls* i don’t rly get why they aren’t

[@sneezydwarf3402]

@@mistuyy stews are not stackable, I am thinking that that is what they were implying.

[@manymanyatoms9327]

I see stacked boats and water bottles, but if you stack water buckets, won’t the water come out? But then again Minecraft makes no sense so I would say it’s fine

[@nategwright]

@@manymanyatoms9327I would assume it would work in the reverse way filling stacked buckets works, it just goes to another inventory slot and removes it from the stack or drops it if you’re full.

[@austinb.4230]

It’s actually wild how much time has passed since minecraft came out. I feel old as well

[@DizzyMapping]

Bro 2 bots already 💀💀💀

[@pixilatedttv1vods]

Same

[@FlyingNoodle554]

You know this comment is going to have thousands of likes in a few hours

[@ellanievanway5019]

I know!!!

[@ArrowMaster_]

I even remember the ough Steve damage sound

[@duggggggg]

One thing I want is actually from another game, called grounded, and that is crafting from storage. If you have a chest within a certain range of a crafting table you should be able to use the items from that chest without having those items in your inventory. It's a small change but it helps alot. Also some form of a quick deposit where you press a button and any items in your inventory get deposited where they go, without opening chests.

[@kasperbierringsknudsen2260]

One thing i’d really like to see, is a bigger difference between diamond and netherite tools. Something that would really make it worth it going into the nether and getting netherite. Like maybe you’d be able to insta mine glass with an efficiency V netherite pickaxe and haste 2 beacon.

[@glencahill6942]

And a netherite pick with efficiency 5 and haste 2 should insta mine deepslate imo

[@inkink9524]

Tbh if that happens then the diamond tools will probably get nerfed cuz netherite efficiency is already op add the enchant and haste & u can almost insta break everything

[@generousdrake2427]

glass has no specialised tool, so that wouldnt happen either way

[@glupshitto1977]

@@inkink9524 it’s definitely not OP

[@inkink9524]

@@glupshitto1977 idk man the current netherite pick is already good making it stronger will just be game breaking

[@xTBCGx]

I've always wanted a rope ladder, so I think that would be a good one for building under. Maybe you can make it with string and sticks to keep it simple.

[@thedesertranger8644]

i think you can get rope ladders in the farmers delight mod

[@angelob2383]

I think people forget you can use red nether vines to move from high to low abd bonemeal them. And you can use blue nether vibes to move low to high

[@catgoaaaaaaaaaaa6152]

​@@angelob2383but they aren't rope ladders, they're just vines. Rope ladders would add a new block to building

[@VoiceDeeJay]

Have people forgotten water buckets exist

[@QUEfrang]

What if you place a block underneath a block when you crouch and place it.

[@pmc_]

I think with the Jukebox, you should be able to extract the disc with a hopper, insert it with a dispenser, and read how far through the song it is with a comparator. That way, players can make their own automated jukebox system

[@nerfer1091]

I've wanted this for years

[@nathansong5926]

the comparator already has a function with the jukebox, it can read which disk is inside

[@Trea-p9d]

You can use hoppers to play music automatically along with a hopper minecart to take the music disk out of the jukebox, and put back in the hopper without needing to manually do it, and you can add more hoppers to play a playlist of music.

[@nojonunes]

@@Trea-p9d not on Java, that’s only on bedrock

[@llynxfyre]

Your wish has been sort of granted?

[@SalamiDog]

*Grian:* I want to place blocks under blocks *Crab:* Cries

[@domoslomo1]

18:06 I’ve always wanted rope ladders in Minecraft. They’d function similarly to ropes in Terraria and would basically serve as a ladder block that doesn’t always need a wall behind it. You could place as many rope ladders on the top block as needed for it to reach the bottom (like reverse scaffolding) and would not break so long as the highest rope ladder block is attached to a wall (like vines). The crafting recipe could be something like 6 string on both sides of the crafting grid with sticks filling the middle. There are so many features like this that the community’s been begging for, and I wish Mojang would just cut loose and add some (though it is smart to be cautious).

[@MynameisnotRenold]

Vines do that

[@TheTryvann]

I just did the bonemeal on a weeping vine next to where I was building down in my skyblock world. Then I created a circular staircase going down around it

[@монастырь]

I think that Farmer's Delight mod has really well-made ropes/rope ladders. As far as I know, they are simillar to ropes in terraria (i dont really know english well, sorry if i've made some stupid mistakes)

[@qualified_educational_user2919]

@@MynameisnotRenold you can’t place vines like reverse scaffolding though

[@antoniepaap5772]

Can't you just place water?

[@Goodmorning54352]

It would be seriously cool if the bat increased your visibility while mining if you have them as a pet like a parrot. Not sure how well it'd work though

[@rufuswhitehead4584]

they could also speed up mining also solving the deep slate issue

[@tammyhall2530]

Or even a feature like echolocation where it can spot some nearby ores etc

[@ignisleo4966]

I like the idea of echolocation, maybe like adding a glowing effect to nearby mobs and/or giving a brief layout of the cave system near you

[@matthijswinkelhagen9829]

@@tammyhall2530 echolocation on bats should work like dolphins if you’re around them they glow up ores for a minute and gou could find this bats in mega caves

[@tammyhall2530]

@@matthijswinkelhagen9829 it would combat the darkness of a large cave very well

[@linkal_8097]

I think the reason glass is difficult to break is because Mojang doesn’t want players to accidentally permanently break their glass. Though To kill 2 birds with 1 stone, they could make wooden tools extra effective at breaking glass, since it’s a trope of breaking glass in movies with a wooden bat. This would give a niece reason to have wooden tools after the first 2 minutes of the game.

[@dudebro1249]

iron sounds like a better choice just because of durability. breaking a large amount of glass would be such a pain with wood

[@JS-rv3et]

add a line of code that says STICKS break glass quickly.. sticks dont have durability but gives players a CHOICE to break glass quickly and unless dirt stone or any NATURE material i mean.... how can you abuse it? other then trolling? breaking glass fast gives no advantage other the. saving OUR time.

[@YataYadaYaba]

@@JS-rv3et big brain

[@RocketsNRovers]

+1!

[@RocketsNRovers]

@@JS-rv3et YES +1!!!

[@simonfitzgerald7104]

The glass molding together thing is something I’ve been wanting for the longest time

[@shoesbutsockless]

yeah once you have connected textures for glass like with the continuity mod, you just cant go back. glass looks way better.

[@fallentofate]

I wish they would have a bonding feature with horses similar to RDR2. The more you ride, the faster it becomes, the more it jumps, the higher it can jump in the future, the more you heal and nurture it, the more health it gains. This way any horse could become a max stat horse with enough time. Id even like to see adverse effects if your hose was neglected after extended time as well.

[@LM-pe3kc]

Very fun game. Yeah loved that mechanic. It would be cool to also have horse races. Some horses can jump higher, run faster, etc.

[@RafaelMunizYT]

might sound a bit of a stretch but I believe mojang and all companies have a lot to learn with RDR2 horses. no one can do better horse mechanics than rockstar but it's worth writing down some notes. minecraft horses could have a little more weight, when you ride them it's like you're sliding on ice. they could walk, trot and gallop like in RDR2. instead of wandering away from you they could follow your orders and the higher the bonding the horse is more obedient. you could tie things and mobs to the horseback or just have someone ride with you. riding with friends in RDO is whole lotta fun

[@TryHardCentral]

That would completely make the breeding process of horses useless and finding good horses

[@Boxygirl96]

@@TryHardCentral considering you can’t breed a super horse because all the stats average with each new generation, it’d be nice to not have to try every single wild horse in the hopes of finding one that can both jump and run and won’t die in one hit

[@henry13b57]

I think that smooth glass would be a better option, this would stop connected textures from changing old builds that might use it.

[@JaxxHunter]

I could see this being done with honeycomb or something.

[@starrysock]

This is an amazing idea actually, you could potentially make some very nice textures using both types together I use connected textures, but sometimes when I want the framed pattern, I have to do a checkerboard of white and normal glass, which isn't really ideal

[@dumby6483]

@@JaxxHunter now that would be epic

[@ArrowMaster_]

YES! Just... YES!!

[@handofclay5390]

maybe you could add a frame to the glass blocks by adding Iron bars or something? this way you could make use of both glass types

[@tristanschoorens2790]

The building under issue could easily be fixed by just allowing scaffolding to be placed downwards like it is upwards

[@jamescox7886]

Or you could also place a water bucket and swim back up

[@1maxiuns]

@@jamescox7886 no

[@henryash38]

How would placing scaffolding down even work though. Where would you look at the scaffolding from with cursor.

[@Ash74118]

It is a gravity block

[@henryash38]

@@Ash74118 lol true

[@ExplodingDarth]

18:20 "Grian fell off some vines" I did not realize it tracked what block you were last touching, that is a beautiful death message

[@tumblewed538]

I feel like a lot of villager issues could be absolved by making the profession levelup based on interative quests instead of trades completed.

[@calebleach7988]

it would probably make it less grindy too. Because right now it's a huge pain to do

[@mot3600official]

@Savetion Xi 😈 ???

[@thatsleepybirb]

@Savetion Xi 😈 bro what the f*** is wrong with you I would say it but this is a child friendly channel

[@DeadlyAlpha]

@@mot3600official it's a troll, report and move on

[@vanukas8783]

@Savetion Xi 😈 seriously, what the fudge

[@carrotorr]

Minecarts should keep their horizontal momentum while in the air. This would make cool roller coasters way more plausible.

[@joelhoon1707]

I was gonna joke about how that would probably break them and allow you to travel thousands of blocks with just scaffolding, dirt, powered rails and a minecart and by building to build limit, but this would actually be pretty fun to play with

[@JeroMusic]

@@joelhoon1707 true true

[@A-Legitimate-Salvage]

In regards to the villages, I’d like to raise the oft mentioned point that players will always find the optimal way to play the game, so it’s up to the designers and developers to make sure that way is fun.

[@haldalas]

That’s a very good point. Maybe villages could come with a market where they will automatically line up during “business hours” for trades? And you could add new workstations etc for new ones to use when they grew up. That way you at least wouldn’t have to make your own hall, and you’d be incentivized to protect the original village so they could self organize for you.

[@angelch8153]

I would at least like to see an "out of stock" mechanic for some items, where they can't trade you for endless emeralds if you don't give them any, they can't give you arrows if you don't provide them with sticks and the sort, and they can't give you enchanted books if they don't have access to an enchanting table, etc. it would be a lot more challenging to get infinite blocks if you think of it that way. maybe as the villager "levels up", not only they get more trades but also they use the resources you give them way better, making it a long-time investment, where at the beginning you have to provide way more to get less than a regular player could, but at their highest level, they'd be able to give you more items per material they receive. but that could also be made easier by allowing the villagers to trade with eachother and provide materials for eachother

[@-jump6211]

1.13 villagers were a much better system I wish they never changed them, better for the most technical players but much harder at the entry level with no 1 emerald trades

[@aqua3791]

@@-jump6211 Nah levelling up villagers is really easy, you can get a lot of emeralds early game through armorer/weaponsmith/toolsmith (iron), fletcher (sticks), farmer (crops) etc, and armorsmiths have 1-5 emerald trades early on

[@joevdb9232]

@@haldalas again the way to tell how minecraft should be improved is simple: look at how people already choose to improve it one very popular mod adds a 'villager market stand' block, which you can right-click to trade with all nearby villagers an alternative would be a shopkeeper/merchant profession, which would do the same without removing actual interactions with the villagers

[@xrendr]

The thing about terraria and its inventory is great. Not only did they increase its stacks to 10000 , but they also added quick sort to multiple chests around you. EVEN THOUGH THE GAME HAS A LONG LIFE. That proves players will only be happy with these changes, even after they became accostumed to the lower possibilities.

[@jordanertz3034]

I'd love to see more enchantments added to chestplates and leggings. 1.19 is already adding a new enchantment for leggings (swift sneak), and I'd love to see more. In fact, someone else in this comment section also suggested a "pockets" enchant for leggings that increase inventory space. I just think too many new armor enchants get added to the boots and helmet as of now.

[@WhimsicottFanatic]

The funny thing is Swift Sneak was originally for boots, and everyone went "Hey do boots really need _another_ Enchantment? Why not put it on leggings instead, that still makes sense, if not moreso" and thankfully, Mojang listened to that one Really, I kinda get chestplates not having many Enchantments, since for a lot of players those get completely obsolete once the Elytra come into play, but leggings have no replacement so it's weird they kinda get shafted when it comes to Enchantments, especially when some of the boot ones would probably still work on leggings, like maybe Depth Strider

[@namejsklava8276]

I'll go controversial - add pocket enchant to armour. so you have to make a choice - elytra or extra pockets. and swap out based on what you do.

[@palmberry5576]

@@namejsklava8276 how would that work though?

[@eclipse9727]

@@palmberry5576 If I had to imagine, Pockets would give extra slots (to give an example, Pockets / Pocketing 3 would give 5 slots of inventory). So it on all armor would give 20 extra inventory. If you remove the piece and escape the inventory, the extra items would fall onto the floor like inventory overflow. Now as for what was said of "Elytra or Inventory", I think they'd want the enchant to not be appliable to Elytra. So then people would have to make a choice. ...though if I had to choose a mutually exclusive thing for it, I would've gone 'can't put pocketing and mending' on the same piece. That way, people would have to choose longevity or convenience.

[@Im_A_Nerd]

@@WhimsicottFanatic isnt that even more of a reason for chestplate enchantments? right now theres barely any reason to use them over an elytra

[@kungfuzing1018]

When you were talking about extra inventory slots and how to unlock them, you know what immediately came to mind for me? Achievements. There's next to no point in hunting down achievements or progressing in the mini achievement trees that are there. But what if certain achievements unlocked you inventory slots? There are achievements for beating Minecraft's bosses so that point you made still stands, but the possibilities are exciting!

[@evilocto22]

I like how many slots there are right now tbh it feels more like he is complaining about a game mechanic. The point of limited space is so you have to stay organized, people forget that most minecraft players don’t get shulkers on day 3 of playing

[@hifriends9666]

I was thinking about this as well, but I dont think it would be very Minecrafty. I think Minecraft is so unique in its play style and how it feels, I think having things change in-game with Achievements would stray too far from that. Maybe instead there could be enchantments for the legs or chest plate that would increase inventory space, maybe 9 spots for each level? I don’t think it’s perfect but I would prefer it to achievements.

[@bloodwolf2609]

this is a very cool idea, I just think thematically backpacks / Terraria's inventory management system are so much easier to grasp because they are so well executed.

[@GazMate]

Minecraft's achievements have never really affected the gameplay and have always been more of a side thing to grind up unto getting, like with the "how did we get here" which can require hours of work for effectively nothing in return... having achievements become a core part of the game and giving rewards for getting them just doesn't feel very "Minecrafty".

[@Legundo]

Grian- for the gaming vines just use weeping vines from the nether (the red ones) and some bonemeal!

[@Jack101Damascus]

​@carmine pint with water you need to keep swimming upwards while building. with the different vines you can just hold down crouch

[@spudgunner8]

Glow berries as well

[@thelittleewokboss9929]

Yea but the thing is you still need to place the red vines on the bottom

[@jaxwarp8373]

@@thelittleewokboss9929 it grows downwards. If you place it a little higher, it will still grow down before where you need to build. It may just take an extra bone meal

[@tuffpaladin6139]

Good idea, thanks🙂

[@trikolo]

12:28 A Handbag, you can acces it like a new hotbar, you can acces it while not sprinting by pressing a key

[@demonwater3555]

A problem with phantoms only spawning in the end, at end cities is that a lot of people, especially in hardcore, use phantom membranes for slow falling potions to prepare for the dragon fight. Them only spawning in the end would make them pretty useless since I think the dragon fight is the only really important occasion for slow falling. Maybe they could have "nests" of sorts in the overworld and will pursue players who haven't slept for three days IF the player is within render distance of such a nest. These nests could be on tall trees or mountains and depending on size spawn 2 to 5 phantoms. Phantoms could potentially be kept from spawning in the nests by either spawn proofing them or maybe despositing cats or frogs there, as cats sometimes bring you phantom membranes and frogs could eat them. I personally don't have anything against phantoms and how they spawn right now, but I understand why some people might want to change their spawning.

[@veronika7072]

I really like that! Imo there should maybe even be 5-8 phantoms so that it's almost like a mini boss you'd have to fight in order to obtain membranes. And you could chose to go ham with arrows or play it more safe using fun tactics like you said with the cats and frogs. Them having nests seems like a realy fun idea for sure tho :D

[@1umbreon4life]

It's nice to see someone else thought of slow falling potions for the dragon fight lol

[@thesupernile]

I think phantoms are more of a problem on multiplayer servers where it's impossible for everyone to sleep every three days. On single player it seems you rarely encounter them

[@SpeziFischDE]

suggestion for more atmospheric bats: they should spawn in a bigger swarm, especially in cave entrances, and when they hear a player (using same function as sculk) they fly scraming towards the source. you would definitely notice them more with that change

[@CoryTheCoder]

I think it'd be nice if they just dropped at least a little xp since they are difficult to kill

[@shenniekeeley6536]

To much lag on most devices

[@iaxacs3801]

Creepers already give enough jump scares

[@SpeziFischDE]

@@shenniekeeley6536 yeah... That for sure. But 5 or so should be ok. They maybe also can despawn afterwards

[@AllistorRichards]

Glass being a slower to break block is actually a very smart design decision despite it being counter to real world logic. Specifically because Glass is an item that can only really exist in minecraft by the player's own hand, meaning its placement is often very purposeful. If it could break too easily then it would be too easy to accidentally break your own builds, or for people to grief *your* glass builds. But by making it consistently slow to break, they make the act of breaking glass just as purposeful as placing it, giving you time to catch yourself before you screw up with a piece of your build, or catch someone else trying to grief by hand.

[@imperfectimp]

I agree. Especially since glass doesn't drop unless you use Silk Touch. Accidentally breaking glass is so frustrating.

[@BuilderB08]

And if it’s quickly broken and you misplace a block, you could accidentally break other blocks and mess up more.

[@asd_]

Make it so that with silk touch it breaks faster

[@cooldad4]

Great video, now I would like to see angled blocks where you have a slope rather than a stair case type of block and maybe gravity would like to be changed so you haven't got half cut trees floating in the air and how about adding building blocks like lintels to hold up windows and doors and walls. You also made a video addressing the silly things in Minecraft which make no sense like standing on a stonecutter and not getting cut etc. We have bedrock addition which there's no chance of mods which needs addressing as regarding gravity as I mentioned before maybe a helium block which can float enabling the player to place blocks on top; basically I would like to see Minecraft to be a little bit more natural creating a real life experience. Personally regarding gold your correct it's vale has been diminished. Keep up the good work Grian!

[@Psyan]

Pro tip for building underneath: Use bonemeal on crimson vines! (The red nether vines that hang from the ceiling.) It acts pretty much exactly like you suggested as a way of scaffolding underneath a build!

[@rainasuryu5899]

I just use a water bucket

[@LukasLLM]

@@rainasuryu5899 Water can mess with things that might be underneath you. While usually a good solution, sometimes it can't be used

[@Etri-Dee]

@@LukasLLMyeh and you cant stay stationary in the water stream so kinda annoying when building when you keep descending and also can fall out of the water stream loll

[@modageddon2742]

Only problem being you need to be at the edge of the vine to actually build and unless your building 1 block ahead of you its quite annoying

[@flo0778]

it's a bit hard to place a block while you are in it without falling though

[@39brogade]

Regarding the jukebox, it would be absolutely amazing if we had an ‘empty disc’ and there were a way to record noteblock songs onto them. Perhaps some kind of block could hold the empty disc and be connected to the noteblock contraption, and once the song stoped it would be copied onto the empty disc. I would be so fun to see music stores on smp servers!

[@gabrielleavila9968]

yes

[@starskomodo8350]

That's a really good idea and something I've wanted too. Perhaps it could be crafted/found with echo shards or ancient cities, due to their connection with sound and vibrations? Although that may be a little expensive.

[@everyone4352]

@@starskomodo8350 Worth it because it doesn't make sense for an item that special to be cheap

[@collicou]

Such a cool idea! I'd love to see what Etho would do with that

[@39brogade]

@@starskomodo8350 love that idea

[@grrytgryyt7975]

Fun fact: The phantom were originally going to be put in The End. I don't remember the reason as to why they decided not to put it there.

[@toothbrush1745]

Its bc phantom membrane can repair elytra

[@toothbrush1745]

That is why i like phantoms

[@kamikazesenpai21]

Its because you cant sleep in the end so they would swarm you eventually making a limit on how far you can go

[@OctoNap]

Probably because it requires a ton of bridging above a pit that kills you basically instantly

[@Ch1ssl]

@@kamikazesenpai21 I don't think they had the night spawning concept at that point in development

[@slightlydistressedslug6627]

When he said pvp was painful and takes too long, all I could hear is Technoblade saying “Have you tried getting good?”

[@idefinitelyusethis6964]

I like the idea of Phantoms being in End Cities, even if they personally don’t bother me that much but I don’t think it should be a finite number, In my opinion there should either be a spawner for them, or they just spawn naturally in end cities, like wither skeletons in fortresses

[@vadernation1233]

I like the idea but I don’t think their current appearance matches it. Don’t want the appearance to change either because it looks really cool.

[@neil7250]

@@vadernation1233 You could have an End variant of Phantoms, a bit like how there are multiple variants of cats.

[@neil7250]

And yeah, I also love the idea of spawners that have to be broken first in order to access the ship safely.

[@JNrwlz]

They should spawn in rings around an end ship to help determine their position

[@friesontheside_]

you need phantom membranes for potions of slow falling, though, which are handiest when fighting the ender dragon (and navigating end cities). so I think it would be too late in the game to have phantoms only in end cities.

[@TheGlowingFairy]

The whole inventory thing I'm so on board with, especially with the unlockable inventory slots! The deep dark update was really odd to me because I think "why would I ever wanna go there". But this would make me eager to explore! Except for you suggesting we change the 64 item stacks, how dare you.

[@Direblade11]

Nah, item stacks should be increased, or at least dank:nulled by using things like the pouches. It's a bit ridiculous to have so much clutter when doing anything. A 4×4×4 block of stone is a stack.

[@musabtekagac7905]

Absolutely agreed

[@Hardhat_137]

@@Direblade11 I was thinking they should keep the 64 but show it as 64 with a tiny number at the top right corner of the 64 stack to show how many stacks u have of that one item

[@Direblade11]

@@Hardhat_137 now I'm curious what 64⁶⁴ is Edit: I now realize I am bad at math, and this would then mean that it is 64×64, rather than to the power of. For the record, 64×64=4096 which I'd be happy with

[@TheGlowingFairy]

@@Hardhat_137 Yoooo now that's an idea !! And if one of the stacks is not full, then that number is the one that appears. so like 15^2 would mean 64+64+15

[@Zevox90]

I think villagers should have a "happiness" stat, that can be beneficial to the player if its higher For the pvp thing we could have new weapons that have special effects, like how war hammers in medieval times was used against heavily armored opponents in order to break through the armor, in minecraft this could be an armor piercing effect where some of its damage ignores armor

[@RocketsNRovers]

+1 good point 👍

[@goncalobalanca4299]

Minecraft players would probably find a way to "farm" that happiness stat by faking houses or something ☠️

[@Zevox90]

@@goncalobalanca4299 probably but its the thought that counts

[@MCtime5thebeat]

They sort of do. Their deals get worse if you harm them.

[@Xandros999]

@@MCtime5thebeat Imagine they didn't restock if they couldn't roam.

[@bottled_leviathan9376]

The inventory issues seem very similar to traffic in the sense that "just adding more slots" will just make the problem bigger, add a few more slots just for them to fill up too and your left with the exact same problem but with more of it to deal with. I think an easy way to help with the inventory (on PC at least) would be to add a multi-select then add different filters between what is being selected.

[@super-cloudy]

Okay. The glass thing. They could always add ”framed glass” for Those times you’d want frames on your glass. Otherwise i agree completely with everything said in this video

[@viktoranderas9541]

Like melting glass one extra time to give it the old texture.

[@Aurioksavenger]

Recipe could be like stone block into stone bricks conversion, natural glass would be seamless, framed glass requiring additional crafting, good idea.

[@beanbagburrito]

It could just be a video setting tbh

[@theonebman7581]

YES

[@liuqmno3421]

@@Aurioksavenger Definitely this! Glass bricks exist in rl too after all

[@MojoBeast]

18:50 You know what we need? Rope ladders. They'd be amazing for building and exploring caves. Also, if you could disconnect them at the top by shooting them with a bow it would be a super fun and useful mechanic. Imagine the mini games!

[@whatusernameis5295]

on the flip side you would have to place them at the top of the thing you wanted to climb

[@henrazz1150]

@@whatusernameis5295 You could have them have a connected to wall gimic like a ladder if you place them on walls

[@benathan6239]

Similar to what Terraria does. You could even use chain for the same effect but without the 'shoot it down' mechanic. On a similar vein, what if you could shoot the rope with your bow as a way to bridge across gaps

[@violetopal6264]

Make rope from vines and craft it with sticks. The length could be determined by how many pieces you have. Being able to shoot it down with an arrow sounds really cool

[@whatusernameis5295]

@@violetopal6264 that's a good idea and making it out of string would be a good enough debuff to counteract the ability to recover it (which is kinda the reason I said it should only be from the top of a cliff, honestly a better idea for only being able to place it certain spots would be having a hook block which you have to put in first and the rope ladder has to go on it although the hook can go anywhere on a wall not just the top)

[@Metricate]

I want to sincerely thank you for making this video. I've said a lot of these things for a very long time and even the most recent editions of instant mining Deepslate in the early 1.17 snapshots. I wish to see these things change. I know your pinned comment already touches on this, but water to build under isn't that bad. I think an easy fix for this would be to change scaffolding and have the ability to build downwards. For me, scaffolding is completely pointless. Well, I say completely... it's got a useful feature of being able to break down easily - I just don't like that you have to have it connected to the ground every 4 blocks, when dirt can be used to save that from being an issue. I use dirt over scaffolding still and probably always will until they change this. I just don't see much point the scaffolding being in its current state. It's unpractical in that regard when building bigger structures. To get up somewhere easily, it can be useful in its current state now but it really limits the possibilities for scaffolding as a tool. But yeah as of now using water to build under is the best way to do it currently; agreed that we need an alternative where we can remain stationary.

[@carrotorr]

Yeah. I feel like Minecraft just needs to have 1.20 be a quality of life/community suggestions update. New features are great but I would prefer them to update old features like the furnace minecart or the fishing mechanic.

[@nyahnyahson523]

@@carrotorr Idk, at this rate I feel like they'd promise "Yeah we'll overhaul the game, tweak stuff, and try to get suggestions in game," show off a bunch of different ideas that they're going to implement, then only come out with a new fishing rod enchantment and gaslight everyone that they never promised those ideas.

[@bean9]

Fancy seeing you here!

[@nathanromine6032]

Now thats a comment and a half. Can't say I'm not guilty of that myself.

[@m00ncl0udzzzzz]

Unfortunately water doesn’t work in the nether, so among the other problems Grian mentioned it’s not super ideal

[@missycat7598]

A year later, I've come back to this video. I think the villager concept is very good, and it reminds me of a mod I used to watch another youtuber play with when I was younger. I think it was called tales of kingdoms? And it was more medieval themed and focused around kingdoms, more so than villages. But the general concept around building a kingdom is very similar to the improved villages concept in this video!