GRILLED CHEESE MAYO VS BUTTER | BLACKSTONE GRIDDLE

[@boballard5637]

I use BOTH. Butter on the outside because it's better at that. Mayo on the inside. My mayo of choice is Japanese Kewpie mayo, and Kerrygold is a great butter, but I am from the midwest and prefer Tillamook Sea Salt butter. Why not both? You decide... time for another video. Thanks for all you do.

[@cookingwithbigcat]

That is genius!!! It may be time for another video!!! Thanks Bob

[@troysweb]

Great ideas here... butter vs mayo comparo, triple decker stack, cheese choice... all that is missing is the cream of tomato soup (made w/ milk)!

[@cookingwithbigcat]

That's for another video lol... I made my own tomato soup one time and it was by far the best I've ever had. Nothing beats homemade... Thanks Troy!!!

[@chiquisbaby81]

Both! I use butter on the outside and mayo on the inside w/ American Cheese. Bomb! 😋🤤🥪

[@bobbicatton]

Great comparison, Mike! Thanks for the kind ShoutOut😊That Kerrygold butter is definitely a favorite of mine👍

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Thanks Bobbi, you deserve it!!!

[@josephstewart324]

I'm glad you agree. I started off this video absolutely knowing that the extra buttery taste of a good butter wins every time versus mayo, and I was afraid that you wouldn't catch it for a second. ;)

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Great minds think alike!!!

[@dougstitely5136]

Awesome comparison Mike, thought of trying mayo at one time but never did. You just made my mind up to stay with butter. May have to try that Irish butter. Thanks buddy and great video!

[@cookingwithbigcat]

The Irish was really good. Thanks Doug!!!

[@TheBeardedItalian]

Hey Mike this was a great comparison video and I’m glad I got to see it. I’ve used both but not those brands. I’ve heard really good things about the Kerrygold and I need to go back to using that again. I think if you like the tang of the mayo, then obviously use that but it is very hard to beat a good quality butter when you’re doing grilled cheese. I absolutely love the idea of the double decker!! Great job and always a pleasure to see you cook.

[@cookingwithbigcat]

WOW after reading your comment I realized I should have done a third one with mayo on one half and butter on the other half... Thanks Oh Bearded one...

[@TheBeardedItalian]

@@cookingwithbigcat 🤣🍻

[@gharv1313]

Wow double stack Mike, trying this for sure! I like Dukes on my grill cheese for sure, Cheers

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Double stack is a game changer, give it a shot!! Thanks B13

[@thebigmann81]

I think a double stacked grilled cheese burger would be so delicious 😋 right now

[@SkinnerFarms]

Hard to beat a good grilled cheese Mike! I’ve been using Dukes for a couple years Fiona try the Irish butter now thanks buddy!

[@cookingwithbigcat]

The irish butter was GOOD!!! Thanks brother!!!

[@Erik-vt9xj]

Bigcat 305 my favorite to watch on the griddle… do a Buffalo chicken sub(kinda like Charleys)

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Never been to Charleys but just Google Mapped it and there is one 10 minutes away. I'll check it out...

[@thebigmann81]

Grilled cheese burger and onion with Texas toast so delicious 😋

[@bmt638]

I've tried both but like the butter. 👍👍

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Thanks BMT, me too!!!

[@thebigmann81]

Sourdough bread is the best breed for grilled cheese, tuna melts or patty melts hands down 😋😋

[@4seasonsbbq]

Great comparison Mike! You can't go wrong with grilled cheese anyway BUT, I tried mayo one time a couple years ago, my daughter liked it my son, wife and I thought it was gross. To each their own right? My daughter also likes jelly on her grilled cheese, I tried it once, not bad. But I will always use butter, no mayo. Have a great weekend brother 👍👍

[@cookingwithbigcat]

I'm a Mayo freak so I honestly thought I would have liked it better but the butter one by a longshot... The jelly sounds good actually. Thanks Ron!!!

[@4seasonsbbq]

@@cookingwithbigcat hey Mike I'm a mayo freak too. Give me a bologna and cheese or a BLT and I pile it on.

[@MileHighGuyBBQ]

I've never made double stacked grilled cheese before. I just may have to start. Looked like an awesome grilled cheese.

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Double stacked is a game changer!! Trust me you will love it!!! Thanks MHGB!!

[@megalisa830bright6]

I have had a peanut butter and grape jelly/jam sandwich with three slices of sandwich bread! ^_^ It was good! :D I hope to try a pan-fried cheese sandwich with three slices of toasted sandwich bread someday! :D

[@michaelterrill6435]

Irish butter is sweet ! That’ll make a difference for sure !

[@cookingwithbigcat]

It was soooooo good!!! Thanks Michael...

[@rickbooher8224]

I find the mayo leave a little tang which I like over butter, however Kerrygold butter is hard to beat it compliments the dairy of the cheese. I prefer the mayo but I will never turn down one with cheese. But never done a side by side taste test. I guess I will have to put the mayo vs butter test for myself. I have also done it with mustard it great with a grilled ham and swiss cheese sandwich it was a great option. I have also mixed mayo and Dijon mustard together then applied it to grilled sandwiches with great results. Also like your double decker grilled cheese combo have to make one of those very soon. America for the gooey and the jack and cheddar for the deeper cheese flavor. I could see trying various cheese combinations as well to test the flavor profiles.

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Thanks Rick!! I definitely recommend the side by side taste test, it was eye opening. Also, I have mixed Dijon with Mayo before and always said they should sell this (which I think they do now), it's awesome. And, the double decker was insanely good. Give it a shot!!!

[@pointnozzleaway]

Butter. Big Cat is from our Planet ! 👍

[@ToddB1]

I've tried both ways a few times. I agree the butter is better.

[@cookingwithbigcat]

I'm with you bro, butter all the way!!!

[@teerexx52]

What board did you put on your grill at the end to place the sandwiches?

[@itsmarshall4323]

Great Video!

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Thanks Marshall, appreciate you!!!

[@markplacker5651]

I need to try sam the cooking guys recomended japanese mayo lol. The guy lives on that stuff. That or maybe a speacialty flavored mayo. Bacon ect. Would kick ass

[@josephmelendez5050]

With a glass of chocolate milk 🤤👌🏽

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Gangsta!!! Thanks Joseph!!! 😎

[@thebigmann81]

I prefer regular whole milk with grilled cheese and I prefer chocolate milk with something sweet like a donut or pastry. But each to there own.

[@jamesmoore1743]

I must say the grilled cheeses look amazing and you did a great job in your preparation but from the beginning when you talked about using that Irish cream butter I already knew it was going to win. That butter I believe wasn't designed for the use of grilled cheese because of the price but if you can afford it that's fine I wish you would have used a regular butter that everybody goes to like Land O'Lakes butter salted on salted but I enjoyed this video very much

[@roynelson7613]

Big Cat U"R The Mac""Daddy On The Flat Iron & The Real Deal Out In The Rain💪🏾💪🏾U Rock Brother💯🤟🏽🤟🏽❤️👍🏽👍🏽🌍😎👊🏽💨💨💥🤙🏽🤙🏽

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Love it, thanks brother!!!

[@roynelson7613]

@@cookingwithbigcat big welcome brother, ♥️👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

[@Maplecook]

Big cat time!

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Oh yeah!! Thanks Maplecook!!!

[@Maplecook]

@@cookingwithbigcat man hug!

[@roynelson7613]

Hay Big Cat I wonder you know there is a lot of people out here in this world that loves the ranch dressing I wonder what a good grilled cheese just like the way you made it with ranch would turn out the flavor maybe you can try that one day bro I have never seen it anywhere else I love your channel man I was going to pass your video up a little bit ago and I changed my mind and I'm glad I did you're one cool dude bro that gives us the real deal here you go I love that about you man it don't have to be perfect which a lot of your stuff is hope you have a kick-ass fourth of July weekend my brother I know you will be cooking some good stuff 💯💪🏾💪🏾❤️👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽🌍🤟🏽🤟🏽🤟🏽😎👊🏽💨💥🤙🏽

[@cookingwithbigcat]

I will definitely try the ranch, I usually make my own with Hidden Valley ranch dressing powder. It's a game changer!!!

[@roynelson7613]

@@cookingwithbigcat oh hell yeah I'm going to have to try that myself brother I'm going to try the ranch pretty soon just to see what we've been missing out on man ♥️👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽👍🏽

[@thebigmann81]

Irish butter or Amish butter is the only butter for me so delicious 😋

[@chefbrooklyn5140]

What's up Big Cat butter no mayo on my grill cheese Sandwich. I like Gouda"Cheese, Munster Cheese and Age New York Sharp Cheeder Cheesw,I combine those 3 cheeses to make my grill cheese sandwich. I prefer to go to someone where like whole foods Trader Joe's or Wegmans to buy my Cheese better Quality Cheese than going to a regular supermarket also I use nonsalt butter.

[@cookingwithbigcat]

You the man Chef, always give great advise!!! Thanks bro!!!

[@smokindave3889]

Butter is and always will be the winner here. Duke's is great, and all but it didn't stand a chance here.

[@cookingwithbigcat]

LOL I agree 100%... Thanks brother!!!

[@bradluhnow9129]

What about a butter mayo combo

[@davidmatke248]

That Kerrygold butter is awesome. It's the best I've tried. Mayo is definitely easier to spread, but I didn't care for the taste at all.

[@cookingwithbigcat]

We are on the same page, thanks David!!!

[@larryroyovitz7829]

Next, sprinkle a bit of MSG on the buttered side. Trust me.

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Thanks Larry, I'll have to try that...

[@larryroyovitz7829]

@@cookingwithbigcat Don't go overboard with it though! lol

[@whammerjammer9185]

Havarti cheese is the best for grilled cheese

[@cookingwithbigcat]

LOL I had my hand on the Havarti cheese and I thought to myself this is not about the cheese. I love Havarti!!! Thanks WJ!!!

[@NormanMcGregor]

Its better with Butter!! LOL!!

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Funny!!! Thanks Norman!!

[@brianmorgan4977]

I tried mayo. I perfer butter

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Me too, thanks Brian!!

[@michealellenburg2701]

Kerrygold beats everything lol

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Yeah Kerrygold is GOOD!!

[@grampsradio]

Artery clogging massive heart attack cuisine.

[@skatarest77]

🤦‍♂️

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Thanks bro!!!

[@TheRookieChefYoungReno]

my bro cooking with big cat.. hope you visited my channel where i highlighted your video my bro.. hope all is well.. Keep up the good work.. Much Love!! 💗

[@cookingwithbigcat]

Thanks Reno!!! I just saw the highlight, it was awesome!!! Very good way to network, mad respect!!!