GRINCH BATTLE!! Voiceplay vs PTX (Blurred) | Voice Teacher Reaction

[@creativecrewfam]

I understand people feel that you can't battle two polar opposite groups. This video is more so a comparison and who I personally think did better with the song. Everyone has their own personal style and taste, so everyone's decision on this is an opinion...INCLUDING MINE. Remember that! :) I'm reacting to this from a musical knowledge perspective and not a "who do I like more" perspective. They both are phenomenal renditions! Did I have a favorite out of the two? Yes, but that's a result of the musical knowledge and what I was looking for going into the two videos. Let's just enjoy the beauty of music! :)

[@randiskye4444]

You knew you'd be opening up a can of worms here, right? I'm a VoicePlay fan so I'm going to be biased. That said, I appreciate the quality of PTX's cover, it was nicely executed. I really enjoyed VoicePlay's rendition because of the reason I'm their fan: they breathe new life into these kind of pieces, instead of just singing in multi-part harmony. So, of course, if there were a vote, I'm in Camp VoicePlay.

[@johnlopezii3821]

completely accurate

[@vanessamorris1985]

I agree completely! When PTX version came out I loved it and played it all The way up to Christmas! I have always looked forward to PTX’s Christmas songs. And then when VP came out with their version I absolutely loved it too! I agree with you on the bass because I’m a really huge fan of the original version of this song and that’s what I was missing from PTX’s version. Once again nothing against Matt! I really love his voice, he’s super talented. But I was wanting some thing a little bit more bass-y and I feel like Geoff delivered that better in the song.

[@jessicacole7981]

It seems that the majority of people on this thread that like PTX are very dismissive and at times, downright nasty about VP and some don't even really know anything about VP by their own admission and just talk them down while sitting on their pedestal gushing about PTXs accomplishments like they are their own. On the flip side, I noticed most of the people that enjoyed VP more also commented on how talented PTX was and didn't deride them, just stated that they preferred VP. Why does it have to be this way? Why do people have to tear down others who have worked extremely hard to develop their craft and put a lot of time and effort into everything they do just because it isn't their cup of tea? By all means prefer one group over the other but there is no reason to tear one group apart in order to try and make the other look better or make yourself feel better as a fan.

[@marykuettner752]

It is personal preference, Obviously Pentatonix and Voiceplay aren't in the same stratosphere as far as record sales but no one is wrong as far as who they like.

[@samuelmncedisi1065]

Personally, I prefer Voiceplay's rendition. Pentatonix are awesome, they have amazing arrangements - especially this one with the key changes and transitions, they know who are they are and because they know who they are, they always confine themselves within that box. Voiceplay on the other hand are versatile like octopuses, they have the capacity to weave through various genres - much like jazz fusion - while still being anchored in their own identity, they think outside the box, not to mention they're always showcasing and collaborating with other musicians.

[@billsturm9225]

I will have to give this one to Voiceplay. While I have been a Pentaholic for a very long time, this song is meant to be performed as opposed to sung. VP performed it, PTX sang it.

[@candilunsford2878]

I think that all the "big" a cappella groups--VoicePlay, Pentatonix, Home Free, Voctave--are all insanely talented. For me it comes down to arrangements and I feel Geoff and Layne just have that magic touch. I love how they do their own. Each has it's own distinct sound and song preferences and I usually just put my music on shuffle when I'm at work because they're all good. If you like Geoff's higher register try his solo Blackbird or High and Dry to get all 5 octaves. His belts in Oogie Boogie, Little Mermaid and Queen in 5 Minutes just makes my day. LOL

[@b.buster.]

I also have to add that Voiceplay arrangements by Layne and Geoff are a bit more complicated than PTX since they have to account for so many different people coming in and out of the group whereas PTX has changed one guy, Avi, in their history. Voiceplay mainstays have been Geoff, Eli and Layne from day one.

[@marykuettner752]

@@b.buster. That isn't really true. Accounting for different voices is a tiny part of arranging. Arrangements can be simple or complex depending on many factors. For example Pentatonix does a extremely complex arrangement of the Twelve Days of Christmas because each member's part is different in every verse. So five members all have twelve different parts to sing. Different voices to arrange for is the smallest part of arranging.

[@randiskye4444]

@@b.buster. Just a minor technical point: Eli, though a longtime member, is not an original member. Mykal Kilgore, Scott Porter, Earl Elkins, Jr., Layne Stein, & Geoff Castellucci make up the founding members in 1997, when they were called 4:2:Five. Eli joined years later in 2010. (Their video "Just Sing" has captions that show their history of members and collaborative connections, it's a very good listen!) I agree that the arrangement of a capella is wholly dependent on knowing the abilities of your instruments (the singers). Geoff has stated in his video about how he arranges that you have to remember to arrange for the voices you have, not the ones you wish you had. He went on to say that he tries to bring something new to the piece while still honoring the original artist's work. The artistic choices he and Layne (and Eli on "Eleanor Rigby") make are what we VP fans appreciate. They are both 'out of the box' thinkers, creatively speaking, and all members and special guest singers they've used have been awesome collaborators.

[@tracyz9155]

Awww…come on. I like both for different reasons. VoicePlay has the theatrics with an actual Mr. Grinch, plus Geoff’s low bass. And Pentatonix is so jazzy with interesting rhythms, plus Matt’s voice is so smooth. I always refuse to pick. Just like I can’t pick between Tim/Peter and Geoff for Misty Mountains (Cold). Surely I’m not the only one who appreciates all aspects of a Capella.

[@natebaker3672]

Geoff is my favorite singer period, but I actually liked the Peter/Tim MM a bit better. Both are on my playlist, though.

[@elizabethhostetter1946]

Remember that Geoff is at least a decade older than Matt - as Matt matures, so will his voice.

[@creativecrewfam]

Very true!

[@atomknight8361]

Matt is also a low barritone. Hes not a true bass like Geoff, never will be but has an excellent belt because of it. Works better for PTX style of pop and high harmonies

[@grimmnation1511]

geoff is only 14 years older than matt haha

[@katrinakhalatians2776]

I love both PTX and Voiceplay but Voiceplay's Grinch is my favorite

[@Broomrider1492]

VoicePlay hands down. Love the #TheatreKids. Geoff sounds more like Thurl Ravenscroft. Takes me all the way back to when I was a child and saw this for the first time in the 1960s.

[@huldradraco]

Yeh not a big fan of acapella battles. Its nice to look at them from a "what did this group do different from that group"-point of view, but not from a "who did it better"-point of view. Like Tim Foust said in a very recent interview, there isnt a lot of rivalry in the acapella community, acapella is all about working together, cheering each other on and helping each other out. 🙂

[@creativecrewfam]

@Huldra Draco A battle doesn’t always have to mean “who did it better” or “who got beat” lol. I’m simply comparing and choosing off of personal preference and musical elements. Ultimately, it comes down to personal preference because we all have different tastes. I agree with Tim’s comment too! :)

[@alexwalker8440]

I like VoicePlay better. I love the way they get into character! Matt and the rest of PTX did a great job, but it didn't get to me like VoicePlay did! 💖🔥 Please, react to "Zombies vs. Hillbillies - Survivor". It's the taped version VoicePlay and Home Free did together for the Sing-Off show. The live version from the Sing-Off tour is also great, but I think this one is better.

[@rheklas1]

You really should check out Geoff Castellucci's solo work, he does amazing things just layering his own vocals and creating harmonies with himself. Misty Mountains Cold would be my recommendation on a starting point!

[@billparrish4385]

Geoff counts among his bass influences the old Disney bass singer Thurl Ravenscroft, who sang the original _You're a Mean One, Mr. Grinch_ for the cartoon (and who also voice-acted Tony the Tiger -- "They're grrreat!"). Geoff is really able to capture Thurl's rounded tones and colorful phrasing, and has featured that in many of his performances, such as here with Grinch, and for example with his Headless Horseman video (another one sung by Thurl back in the day).

[@charmainehudson7660]

Voiceplay hands down wins this one . Theatre kids rules

[@LisaD-1969]

It’s PTX for me!! I love the jazzy arrangement. Matt was incredible as lead and Scott’s bass throughout was so impressive.

[@creativecrewfam]

Very true!!

[@madenabyss6981]

I would agree with u on that

[@DougRayPhillips]

Matt can go lower than what he showed here. They just didn't happen to arrange it that way. If you liked Layne as a French waiter, wait'll you hear him as a French chef in The Little Mermaid Medley.

[@youtubepup5301]

I personally like notes that go extremely low without it being a growl note. (Cough, Tim Foust) I just personally dont like to count them, because im a female and even i can hit a C#2 on a growl. Which i know that will get deeper over time since i just started trying lower notes like a week ago. And i know Geoffs notes are lower than Matts. Sorry if any of this was offensive, i guess i just really like geoff more.

[@rmoenmjea]

Personally I enjoy the VP version more. PTX is a bit too clean for my taste, maybe rooting in having such a wide audience that they are competing with "non-acapella" artists. For me I listen to acapella BECAUSE its so unique and a welcome difference from the (for lack of a better term) "normal" music. But I can appreciate the talent and artistry that has gone into PTX`s version

[@leamescher3535]

Ouch! Fans to the rescue of their favs. I love both versions. So very different from each other. PTX has more production and polish, VoicePlay has more theater art elements. Their journeys and priorities as a group probably different. It’s what makes them both so loved, along with groups like Home Free and Voctave. They each have honed their strengths and found their sounds and share their own unique group personality and talent. They each seem very true to themselves which fans find refreshing vs. mainstream music that can be fake and talent compromised.

[@maeco7]

A nuanced opinion in these comments? What?? 😂 I think you hit the nail on the head - these groups have different focuses and styles for sure. Everyone has their favourites, and it's not that one group is better than the other - they just tend to appeal to different audiences. Probably can't be ignored that they have different budgets, too... PTX has big $ and a record label, while VP is completely independent. That can change the flavour somewhat too. While VP is my favourite group, I love both versions of this song for different reasons. Glad we get to experience different takes on the same fun song.

[@dianadonnell]

Its bad to battle between VP, PTX and Home Free. All super good, but 3 very different groups. As written before me, its like compering appel, pears and oranges. I am a huge VP fan, but like both the others too, they are just not the same.

[@creativecrewfam]

Though comparing “apples and oranges,” a battle can still showcase talent and variation depending on the group style.

[@dianekerr2403]

Voiceplay has it all, so they are my pick. Geoff's timbre was absolutely perfect for this song. Beyond just this song, VP would still be my pick - outstanding arrangements, creativity and with very few exceptions, they allow all the singers to shine. Sadly for me, PTX is too often the Scott and Mitch show.

[@LBreezy24]

not true but ok lol ptx everybody shines even the beatboxer a vocalist

[@kaleighhenderson7354]

Oh VoicePlay wins hands down. Better bass, better arrangement, better story, better costumes. Just 10000% more effort. No contest.

[@ireallyhateyouplsdieinafir107]

Oh they overuse Geoff like stfu

[@nikkibanning176]

How can one choose between two brilliantly done songs? I can't as I love them both for different reasons.

[@creativecrewfam]

Very true!

[@maxiem3679]

Both are good. but i do like the ptx version better. That would be the version i would jam to even during non-christmas times.

[@00Jess_M]

I can appreciate the talent both groups have, but when it comes to personal taste 1: Geoff is my favorite bass, 2: I love the theatrics and 3: VoicePlay likes to showcase every voice as much as possible, so most of the time there isn't one lead, but everyone gets their moment in the song. Especially with this song I enjoy that very much (it's more like a mini movie). You can always see how much fun they have singing and filming together. PTX is always a little to "clean" or "perfect" for me. That's why VP will probably always "win", I can't really get into PTX although I do see and hear how good they are. But how boring would the world be if everyone had the same taste?

[@Bonofox1]

vp relies too much on gimmick and this is why they are STUCK in the same place They arrange the same way they did on The Sing Off, they haven't improved much at all! They were awful on the show I tried to like them all these years but they just disappoint. Just because you bring in the bass at random times he drags the songs down They could be good if they wanted🤷 A lot of reactors have said the same thing and don't react to them anymore

[@00Jess_M]

@@Bonofox1 or you could've just said that they are not for you instead of talking their talent down. Because the way they arrange things is the reason so many of us love them, it just happens to not be what you like.

[@rmoenmjea]

@@Bonofox1 very interesting how you take so much time out of your day to comment negative stuff towards VP under every comment that is not totally blown away by PTX. I get your point, I did not like VP that much on the sing off either but I really enjoy their more recent arrangements. If I were you I would just take a moment to think if your (sometimes pretty mean comments) are really adding anything to the discussion.

[@creativecrewfam]

@Cezy Z I’m going to have to disagree with you on the gimmicks portion. Just off of the videos I’ve seen, their theatrics are another added benefit for entertaining. If you strip that away in some of the recent videos they’ve done, they still are singing their butts off. Take Hoist the Colours or Wicked Medley…pretty amazing to me! But, nonetheless…to each his own.

[@Bonofox1]

@@00Jess_M yeah tell that to the the vp people who say the same (which is ridiculous) about PTX😄

[@erinromary2796]

I vote for VoicePlay! Both are great but there you have it.

[@mck0027]

I agree, Voiceplay was the better version. Voiceplay felt a little more Hollywood while PTX felt like a Broadway rendition.

[@veronicathunander4579]

I love VoicePlay and think their version is outstanding, both in arrangement, visuals and vocals. Actually, Pentatonix often bore me. But I agree, it’s all about personal preference. I realise that both groups are exceptionally talented!

[@Bonofox1]

No contest PTX is KING! numbers SAY IT ALL!! Vp is gimmicky their arrangements are a 3 out of 10 since the Sing Off. They could be better but they don't know how to arrange 🤛🤷

[@tomcharlton5926]

@@Bonofox1 They don't know how to arrange? Please go and watch their newest video (Wicked mashup 'A Chance to Fly') and tell me that is badly arranged 😐 You're entitled to your own opinion, but it's clear to see both groups put in so much effort and passion into their craft. 🥰

[@Bonofox1]

@@tomcharlton5926 thank you U will check it out! I ✌

[@craigcook1350]

@@Bonofox1 your replies throughout this video are hilarious. At first I thought you were being sarcastic, but I actually think you believe the silliness you’re typing.

[@neotheboxer6015]

Personally loved the jazzy take of PTX. I also love the theatrics of VP, it was fun. Very different renditions. Liked them both overall. Several have complained that PTX is too perfect and that makes them boring. I disagree. They worked hard at their blend ad their skill is beautiful to me. To each his own...

[@creativecrewfam]

I agree with everything you said haha! It just goes to show artistic expression is different for everyone! :)

[@pcdoctor48]

I preferred Voiceplay just because their version is more fun.

[@Tryst46]

Got to admit, I love the acting along with the singing. They have some terrific harmonies and the choice of lead singer is great, but the set, costume and make-up shows they really got into the spirit of the song instead of just singing it. Friends on the Other Side shows how they always pick the best person for the lead, J None has the perfect voice for that song.

[@ashcgincog5016]

Voiceplay are my favourites too. Ptx version is great they took a different approach to it but there’s just no comparison when it comes to Geoff he is hands down amazing and I love the playfulness in all of Voiceplays arrangements and videos. If you wanna get a taste of Geoffs higher range (trust me you’ve seen nothing yet) check out his cover of high & dry on his own channel. Also, Voiceplays cover of if I were a rich man / girl will blow you away!

[@Sweeney541]

In my opinion you can't really compare them as they're in different markets, if that makes sense. PTX is at a level where their "competition" is the mainstream/non acapella artists, which means there are certain expectations of them from both the public and their label. This is why we don't see them in costumes all that often (some of the few exceptions would be earlier stuff like Love Again and Papaoutai). That was part of the reason Mitch and Scott created Superfruit in the past - there they didn't have the same limitations. But I agree with what others have said - there isn't the same competition between acapella groups as there are in other parts of the music industry. Which is why there are several crossovers - either one member joins a different group like Avi with Home Free or both groups join forces like PTX and Voctave for Once Upon a December.

[@abenaitwebruce9495]

I really wanted to say this These are two non comparable groups PTX is more mainstream and do their music very differently compared to voiceplay.

[@donnilloyd1355]

IMO, the 2 groups ARE comparable. They both sang the song A Cappella, didn't they? It does not matter HOW they did it, technique style. They did it, which makes them comparable. Throwing in how they do it, is a different issue. (IMO)

[@laundrygoddess4]

I'm with the voiceplay people. It was just more fun and interesting and I think just fits the song better

[@eadanime1741]

Absolutely voice play! They made it there own!

[@Wildecat10]

I’ve never had any doubt about PTX’s ability to sing. Their drawback to me has always been that in their striving for perfection, they tend to ignore the other members of the group. (Or other people they are performing with). It all seems rather cold and sterile. VoicePlay, on the other hand, handle all of their production themselves. So their creativity and love of performing with each other is always up front. By having fun with each other, they allow the viewers to join in on that fun. All without sacrificing the quality of their vocals, which keep getting better all the time. I won’t say which one is “better”, but I know which one I enjoy seeing.

[@Bonofox1]

You will like a group EVEN THOUGH they are 💩 and that is what vp is! That is why a lot of reactors don't like them! 🙈

[@tomcharlton5926]

@@Bonofox1 That's a bit rude don't you think? Truth be told, they were OK in the Sing Off, but since then they've developed in confidence and performance quality. Just watch their newest releases, you'll love their singing. 🥰 One thing is clear, WE'RE ALL HERE TO ENJOY ACAPELLA MUSIC

[@Bonofox1]

@@tomcharlton5926 Thank you I will☺✌

[@TYGER0902]

@@Bonofox1 I keep hearing that reactors don’t like them but I’ve never seen it when I search for VoicePlay Reactions. Can you name some?

[@vanessamorris1985]

@@TYGER0902 I’ve seen a few but it they only do it for attention or views mostly. There was this one guy but he was a huge fan of PTX’s style and just didn’t get VP’s style or theatrics. He did enjoy their voices though. 😉

[@edyta_soko]

Hmm PTX for me✌️. VP is awesome as well but still…

[@lizlilliman3644]

Voiceplay definitely, one thing I always like about their arrangements is that it let's everyone have a highlighted moment , and although Geoff did most of the bass because the others had lines and parts it breaks up the song on the ear. With ptx I found that I was getting a bit bored of just listening to one voice, they had some lovely voices in the background which if they had sung a main line or two it would of broken it up more. (I would ask my daughter to see which she likes but Grinch is banned here as she is sacred of his long fingers, this is my 15yr 9ld that watches horror movies lol)

[@bradnymeyer9064]

PTX without Avi just isn’t as good. Matt is a good vocalist but just doesn’t have the bass like Avi.

[@AllyisHyper]

I'll take both! I love them both for different reasons. I'll be in the mood for voiceplay randomly and in the mood for PTX.

[@Crittergirl81]

Both groups are insanely talented, but personally, Voiceplay has more appeal to me. The songs they choose, the arrangements, the costumes... they're just incredible.

[@Tryst46]

Voiceplay brings the song to life. Instead of just singing a song, they act the parts as well. Along with costume, set and make-up, they just knock any song out of the ball park.

[@marshayoung9387]

@@Tryst46 I agree

[@tomcharlton5926]

Both groups are amazing at what they do, and it's clear to see the passion and dedication they give to their craft. An amazing reaction video 🥰😄

[@natebaker3672]

Great reaction. Can't dispute your findings. Both are definitely on my Christmas music list.

[@evaetterer6000]

I love voice play they are the very best for me ! The 2. band was also good, but voice play are the very very very best ! Greatings from germany ❤ ❤ ❤ ❤

[@ashleysheree7057]

Both are good but VP are more creative with their arrangements and videos

[@Bonofox1]

You know NOTHING of music of you think vp has better arrangements🙈🙈🙈 it's ok because numbers, music industry recognition and respect 19+million subs over 5 billion views Grammys, Multi platinum, multiple awards ect.. Speaks VOLUMES on who has better arrangements😄😃😀

[@janetdw]

@@Bonofox1 They also have a record label to finance all that. You are the worst kind of fan. You only want one kind of a capella and everyone else is garbage in your eyes. Generally I love the theatricality and unusual arrangements of VoicePlay. It appeals to my creative side. But I also love listening to Pentatonix - but I don’t see the same amount of creativity there. I admire Home Free, but not a fan of country so I don’t watch/listen as much as others. It usually depends on my mood. Open your mind, please and don’t knock another group just because you prefer one group.

[@LBreezy24]

@@janetdw there is bunch of creativity need to listen to more ptx

[@vilmariehernandez6726]

Ok course Ptx !!!!

[@chandleraskew6496]

Both of these are so good, but the arrangement of Geoff, his incredible bass and the runs from J none to me gives voiceplay the edge

[@AnaArantes]

I loved reading the comments on this video because I feared that my opinion on PTX was biased by my absolute awe and admiration for VoicePlay work... But I always felt PTX as empty of swag and warmth, it's like they just can't connect with each other when they sing. It's over produced and comercially pasteurized. They feel, to me, like those beautiful shop windows that you look once and thinks it's pretty. You look twice and get bored. With VP, on the other hand, you can feel their affection for each other. Even the new members and the featured artists are so connected with the group during the songs. To me, personally, the craft and thought that Geoff, Layne, and sometimes Eli put on the arrangements are just so creative and talented. They are always surprising me! To me, they are the kind of complete artists that I wanna support, follow and listen on repeat. Also, in this day and age, seems really silly - to me - to base aesthetic apreciation of any artist on number of likes and views counting. We know that labels and media conglomerates have the power to just make or break a band... So, there's that.

[@danamills3981]

Scott carried the bass for ptx while Matt took lead......sooooo good

[@Bonofox1]

YES IT WAS AMAZING!

[@corelli2]

PTX for me. The Voiceplay is a bit too cutesy for me, probably fun for kids. I like the clean moves and harmonies of PTX.

[@venus5019]

Interesting statements. Whether it's sports teams, foods, rappers, rock groups, R&B singers, country music etc. we all have preferences. I kinda put it to some enjoy getting dressed up, I'd rather have a job can wear blue jeans all the time. Same with vehicles (SUVs, Pickup Trucks & sedans) even the colors of vehicles (corvettes can only be red or black). Pentatonix aren't slouches. Pentatonix assembled intentionally for the Sing-Off. Kirstin Maldonado, Mitch Grassi, and Scott Hoying were childhood to high school friends. They had sung as a trio & had gone off to various colleges. One was in another vocal ensemble. He found out from someone about the auditions for The Sing-0ff. He contacted them to get back together. It was strongly recommended to get a bass & beatboxer. They recruited Avi Kaplan & Kevin Olusola. Literally built the sound & arrangements days before the audition. They were selected & went on to win that year's Sing-Off. After that win, they kept together to build a brand/unique sound. Not only were they very focused developing their sound but mastered social media becoming extremely popular as an a capella group. Avi helped to lock in the bass along with the beat boxer Kevin Olusola who's very talented. They have a unique sound apart from VoicePlay & Home Free. The Sing-Off helped these & other a capella groups garner fans & broaden popularity for these a capella groups. In fact, besides the competition, they went on tour together spending months together. They learned from each other a lot of networking, using social media & arranging. I'm not stating no one knew how to do anything, they got exposed to each other & ideas. Geoff has arranged for Home Free & members have worked with each other. Peter Hollens is another collaborator as is Voctave. Avi's featured in another version of Home Free's winning song 'Ring of Fire'. Geoff arranged 'Elvira' for Home Free to do with Oak Ridge Brothers. In my mind, I see no competition between the groups, I see them hustling to get recognition & attention to generate audiences & do what they love, music. Being real, all these groups do versions of songs written & performed by others. Those artists were gracious to allow their songs to be used (royalties & written permission). No one (I know of) has gotten upset over their use & arrangements. So they shouldn't be upset with others doing versions of the song too. How many versions of The Star Spangled Banner is sung? Silent Night? Unlike Pentatonix, these 2 groups weren't overnight sensations & there were times they were ready to walk away but they stuck to it. Both Home Free & VoicePlay started out in high school. Which is over 15-20 years ago. Geoff, Earl, Scott & Layne; Adam & Chris were the remaining founders (then respectively Scott & Chris left). Over the years members had chosen to leave (family, work & changes in career direction etc.). VoicePlay (based out of Orlando FL) toured too & gained experience too. They also had Disney & Universal in their 'hood' gaining theatrical experience/presentation. As mentioned, one of its founding members was Scott Porter. He was the original beat boxer of the group. It's heard in the "Halo" tribute. When Layne & Scott do 'red team/blue team' section, that's him & Layne doing 'sounds'. Fact when Scott left, Layne had to learn to cover his spot beat boxing. Scott trained him. [Scott's main focus now is acting. He was in Friday Night Lights, The Good Wife, Hart of Dixie, Scorpion & Lucifer along with movies, episodic TV (Law & Order among others) & ironically has done voiceovers for multiple video games. He's sung with them on occasion over past few years, that song was a tribute & was one of them.] Home Free based out of Minnesota did singing part-time weekend gigs or so many months away. When they did travel, gained experience/knowledge using their voices. When chose to go fulltime is when Tim Foust & Austin Brown joined up permanently. Let's not get it wrong, there's 'attitudes' & 'drama' between any groups. It's a marriage/partnership. Sure, not every personality gets along with others, happens in all music arenas (backup singers, lead singers, people on Broadway, musicians etc.). People can choose favorites & even like a song version over the original. It doesn't mean it's sacrilege to do another version. Whitney did a version of Dolly Parton's song she recorded & wrote 'I Will Always Love You'. Parton didn't get upset; she was quite overjoyed. She had written that song decades earlier & it now was a cash cow for her (getting writing royalties) for the way Whitney sang it & made that more popular than her version. My dream? Avi, Geoff & Tim do at least couple of songs together, that would be a dream team for me. Interesting to see & hear the results.

[@johnpetersen9565]

Best VP.

[@brad8787]

Ooh this video looks awesome.. thinking about it I've never watched/seen a person do a comparison of the two in the same video cool idea🙂

[@arsenelupin4888]

I prefer PTX. Then again you can't compare the 2 arrangements.

[@keithjansen2409]

Voiceplay gives you a great movie preview and outstanding music plesing both sight and sound senses PTX fiills one sense sound so voiceplay wins.

[@caitlinbinedell7706]

I'm going with voiceplay for sure. I love both groups but I definitely lean more towards the theater kids. I haven't heard anything from them that I don't love.

[@roybischoff5656]

The obvious winners are us the fans of a capella music. I think Geoff is the best bass on the planet. Musically, I think ptx won this. Theatrically voice play did very well.

[@creativecrewfam]

Very true!

[@simonmoore7056]

Voice play because they have the better production and put more thought into how they executed the proformance

[@DravenGal]

I agree with your opinion. Equally skilled groups, but VP kept it truer to the Thurl Ravenscroft’s version. (Not surprising as Geoff strongly admires him!)

[@mastermonster195able]

Both great. I give Voiceplay the edge!

[@regardlessyvette]

For next VoicePlay I'd def recommend My Mother Told Me or the Little Mermaid or Moana Medleys

[@jonadabtheunsightly]

Personally, I liked VoicePlay's arrangement better; I felt like they did a better job of trading parts around, keeping things moving, and having more going on at once. Though I admit that the PTX arrangement does have a couple of points in its favor as well, especially in the second half. In any case, you can also do a battle between the same two groups over Attention, which they both covered. It's a little more fair, because Attention is a pop song, rather than a movie song, taking away a significant advantage VP had here with their theatrical background and fantastic make-up artist and such. (Although, they feature Rachel Potter in their version, which is almost like cheating.)

[@brendagrothier967]

Both very different. Voice Play more theatrical.... PTX more of a music video.

[@creativecrewfam]

I agree

[@carriekovach797]

I’m a music lover and it’s all about the listening pleasure for me. Both were great but Pentatonix wins it for me.🏆 The harmonies, arrangement, and overall ear candy is what draws me to PTX almost every time. Again, both phenomenally talented!

[@lisahuff818]

Lol the comments on here are quite childish. Great music and great reaction Chris.

[@creativecrewfam]

God bless you Lisa 😅 If I would’ve known…

[@Wildecat10]

@@creativecrewfam if you choose to do other “battles” I’ll listen, but probably not comment. Don’t need the drama. Just want to listen to good music and enjoy the videos.

[@marshayoung9387]

Voice Play all the way.

[@NicholasAHart]

I love Voiceplay, it was better to me. They are just so fun to watch. Pentatonix is okay, Matt definitely has the classic singing style like the original song which was nice. I fell away from PTX after Avi left, but some of their songs with Matt I do like.

[@mswitch936]

I like PTX better, closer to the original. Not a fan of VP arrangement and while they are fine with visuals maybe, I'm not watching it 99% of the time. Vocally i think PTX are just more consistent

[@creativecrewfam]

I respect your choice! I agree that PTX is more like the classic cover

[@leamescher3535]

Voctave also does a version of Mr. Grinch. I vote another version to see what the best bits were. All vocal groups are so different and amazing in their own ways. And loved for different reasons because the listener is just as unique in what speaks to them. If we all had to be honest and could only select one vocal group to listen to from now on, we would be able to say which one and why. We shouldn’t be forced to constantly monitor ourselves for fear we might upset someone else by having an opinion. I am definitely glad I don’t have to choose just one. I am going to listen and enjoy what they have to offer.

[@barbarabishop9362]

I'm a Pentaholic - and a recent introductee to Voiceplay. Argh. BOTH are extraordinary, but VP is just more ... "interesting" than Pentatonix. PTX doesn't even have an edge with the vocals because VP is equally perfect. Or PTX is equally perfect. Whichever. Sorry - there is no "better."

[@alexrosas1499]

Both are great! I personally prefer VP because I love me some good bass and also love their theatrics! But both versions are in my Christmas playlist anyways so… Anyways, very fun video!

[@Bonofox1]

💥PENTATONIX💥 The PTX version is what I play at Christmas parties MATT Slayed the lead Scott killed at bass throughout! The harmonies and temple changes were AMAZING!!!🌟

[@steelethistleartistry8202]

Everyone has their preferences for sure, but honestly how can you compare the two? That's like asking- is theater better than pop music? How about both? I've always seen PTX as more pop... Voiceplay is more theater, and Home Free is more country. I love all 3. Which version I'd enjoy the most depends on the day and if I'm in the mood to laugh and have an experience or if I'm in the mood to jam... and what to.

[@creativecrewfam]

You can still compare musical decisions in the two whether pop or theatre. That’s what a voice/music teacher does. I do understand your point though…that’s why I put it boils down to personal preference :)

[@stillprocrastinating4308]

excuse me, voctave (mr. grinch)

[@candice9726]

Voiceplay for sure

[@catherineharger8069]

PTX

[@justinperry13]

Loved the VP, but PTX won it for me. Matt embodied the spirit of the song

[@susanhorn4325]

I think if I was just listening to the song (like in the car) I would prefer PTX. It’s a pretty straightforward rendition of the song. If I was watching a video I’d prefer VoicePlay because they performed a complete skit from the story and you would lose so much just listening to it.

[@creativecrewfam]

Very good point!

[@TomLloyd-18]

that's funny b/c THAT's the part that turned me off . . . the children's theater-like 'skit'. 1st time hearing/seeing VP. I've no plans for a 2nd.

[@lrorrer]

You need to react to Small Town Titans version of this song .. you'll be shocked and amazed

[@lachimiste1]

If I’m just listening to the song, PTX wins hands down. The arrangement is jazzy and dynamic and just makes for really good, catchy listening. If I’m watching a performance, then it’s Voiceplay. There’s a lot in the Voiceplay performance that needs the visual to make sense, which makes it difficult to just listen to it and understand what’s going on. They always put on such a great show, and this video is hilarious. One question I have, for anybody who has seen Voiceplay perform live, does Geoff do those subharmonics live on stage? If you watch his bass singing tutorials, it seems like there’s a lot of air that needs to be processed out of them to make them sound as full as they do in studio recordings. I know PTX makes a point of not putting out tracks that they can’t perform live (which might limit Matt’s low end), and I wondered if Voiceplay operates similarly.

[@maeco7]

Yep, Geoff sings them live. There are a few videos floating around KZbin where he uses them.

[@DethWulf]

I liked both versions of these (mostly), but for me, Voiceplay's arrangement felt a little...unfocused? Too all over the place? Like, it felt like it kept killing the momentum of the song to try and insert funny asides, or to switch to a different singer, and as a result it felt a little too try-hard or hokey to me. There are songs and arrangements where that kind of thing works, but I think in this case, it was a bit of a disservice to the song. I know some people seem to complain about Pentatonix and how they arrange, but they always struck me as arranging with a focus on the song as opposed to any one member - yes, Scott sings lead a lot, but he also has a very pop-sounding vocal that's very versatile, so it usually fits. Voiceplay, from what little I've heard of them, seem to arrange so that everyone gets a little time to shine; not that PTX doesn't do the same, but it's more overt with VP. I like some of what they do, but in this case it felt like it was trying to do too many things, and thus didn't dedicate enough time to any of them. I'd have to go with PTX in this case.

[@lkayh]

I missed this-probably because I always resist the idea of this group VS that. Usually I love both for different reasons. I think I agree with you on most points. To me the arrangement is a tossup because they were trying for completely different things. Voiceplay’s felt a little choppy, but then they were intermixing straight vocals with their theater, which I loved. And as another commenter said, Geoff’s been using that gorgeous bass about a decade longer than Matt, so we’ll see where Matt is 10 years hence. (I think one reason a lot of folks love Geoff’s singing is his “chill” vibe-he has plenty of energy, but it never feels tense or nervous.)

[@ellenhulslander2897]

Musically, I prefer the PTX version.

[@mamabear-gu4oo]

They r both very good in their own way but I think voiceplay was a better arrangement

[@davidharman8263]

As much as I enjoy comparisons, as it shows side by side how the same song can be interpreted in different ways, maybe you should include all versions to compare. You missed out Voctave’s version. Just out of fairness.

[@creativecrewfam]

I’m doing there’s soon :)

[@Matriarch456]

i love both renditions. i like to watch the voiceplay one more it's very funny but i have the pxt version on my playlist... and as for bass notes ..i am a sucker for low bass lines as long as it serves the music.. same goes for high notes it has to serve the music and not the other way around.

[@charleigh1681]

Also listen to same song covered by Small Town Titans

[@justrenee6154]

First time ever hearing VP, and video was cute, but I wouldn't add to my Christmas playlist to listen to and PXT version is already on it... so I'd go with PTX.

Creavity With Chris VoicePlay Sang You're A Mean One Mr. Grinch Better Creavitivy With Chris Beacase They Have Aridanna Arellano Creavity With Chris BOOTS CASTELLUCCLI

[@vantreknerd]

I wouldn't put the VP version of this song on a playlist as I don't think it works well without the video...too many vocal flip flops that I found distracting. For my own personal preference, I don't actually like listening to super low base vocal solos. I prefer the arrangement and simplicity of the PTX version for an easy listening Christmas song.

[@dorisartman]

Hands down for me, Voiceplay won, but I have to be honest, I am biased.

[@DougRayPhillips]

So you had to blur out the PTX version? Sorry. Some PTX reactors have problems getting blocked if they don't pause often enough. Others seem to be just fine. Don't know what the key is.

[@creativecrewfam]

I’m not sure either, but this is twice now so I got to try different things next time…just mess around I guess. But yes, had to blur the PTX portion some

[@michelle32855]

I recommend the Small Town Titans version...it'll give 'em a run for the money :)

[@jennifersmith8923]

PTX sounded great and it was a good and different arrangement. Their talent is undeniable....but they just can't hold a candle to VoicePlay on this one. VP is just more fun and I like their voices better.

[@Katie-mb8zj]

I will agree that VoicePlay wins this one, but will also acknowledge that PTX’s version is amazing as a feature for Matt. I would be interested in hearing a re-recording of PTX’s arrangement in a few years to see if Matt can get closer to sounding like the original singer since their arrangement was already pretty close.

[@mariamoumtzi1727]

Definitely PTX!

[@natebaker3672]

I prefer VP in general, but it is somewhat comparing apples and oranges. VP definitely took more liberties which i enjoy as I have heard quite a few Acapella renditions of this song. VPs is definitely more fun and unique.

[@creativecrewfam]

I agree! That’s why it’s personal preference :) Though comparing “apples and oranges,” a battle can still showcase talent and variation depending on the group style.

[@jamesbaio9327]

With Matt, they didn't showcase his bass range very much...but did you hear Scott singing bass though....Scott.

[@ashleyholmes9876]

Voiceplay for me

[@GigiC4]

PTX did the song in a more classic style and Voice Play did it more fun, both are great.

[@allisoncameron-dicker2737]

Voiceplay for sure even my dog was tilting his head at Geoff's low notes. 🤣

[@Aurora-cv5to]

I've puzzled over the appeal of PTX for a long time, getting nowhere. Today it hit me that there is a crucial difference that may explain the passion on both sides. PTX perfectly embodies the rules. Their sound is traditional at the highest possible level. From my perspective, that makes them boring - but I'm guessing that from the opposite perspective, it makes them reassuring and exactly "perfect." On the other side, VP is - to me - pure ear candy. They break the rules constantly, and that makes them (to me) lively and engaging. Because those choices ALSO happen to sound really good while being surprising - I'm infatuated. Not much fond of tradition. It bores me. So of course I love VP.... never bored. Ever.

[@creativecrewfam]

This is suchhhh a good comment because of the way you explained it, YES! I love both groups and nothing wrong with either. PTX is more of the classic modern acapella sound whereas VP is more fun and playful, but BOTH very talented in their respective approaches. :)

[@Crittergirl81]

Thank you for putting that so beautifully, that's exactly how I feel about these groups, but haven't been able to think of how to explain it.

[@Aurora-cv5to]

@@creativecrewfam EXACTLY. And when artists have different goals, they need to be held to different standards. If VP solidified into its own predictable, "always follows these patterns" routine, they'd have stepped off the art track, and it would be a loss. I don't see them doing that any time soon. They have tropes (they frequently use words instead of ahhhh, or ohhhh; that is one of their standards) but even there, they mix it up. In Geoff's latest drop, "God Rest Ye Merry Gentlemen" I don't believe he sings the chorus the same even twice. Instead, his Geoff-tet does something different that has me on alert, waiting for it to happen again - but next time it's mutated into something else equally gorgeous. No relaxing allowed. Edge of seat w/ delight all of the way. For those who want to relax into a known space and be soothed by something beautiful they've heard many times before, perhaps that's irritating. What's important is to recognize that neither is better or worse. They are top flight musicians with very different goals. No surprise that the art crowd loves VP. And also no surprise that PTX has the numbers.

[@marlahudgins7038]

They are both so different, I'm not picking