GTA Trilogy Definitive Edition Comparison - PS2 / Xbox / PC / Mobile / Remaster

[@GTASeriesVideos]

0:00 GTA 3 Comparison 3:39 GTA Vice City Comparison 6:58 GTA San Andreas Comparison

[@Afthen]

Good

[@huseyinardc4026]

The characters used to have emotions like anger but now they look like plastic and their voices dont even sync correctly in the cutscenes. Such a disappointment man

[@WangLaker]

Cool

[@C.A._Old]

Legendly Series ReBorn !

[@marcosguzman4461]

Cool and Good !!!!

[@Ofejiro.]

Claude looked angry before, now he just looks sad

[@kivaHBRO_04]

True

[@public.archive]

same goes for Tommy, maybe even worse

[@gabrielfmm]

😒

[@AttakusZakus]

He’s dead inside. His Dommy Mommy shot him.

[@XWXS2]

Whaaaat Claude looks waay better he looks more like the real Claude from the gta 2 intro cutscene

[@Theesvpremekai]

Okay so the draw distance fog that Rockstar originally had in San Andreas is gone. I know it was to hide the draw distance but shit, it makes the map look so much smaller than I already knew it was.

[@rainer_32]

I think this remaster needs an option to adjust the draw distance.

[@castroabuful2468]

@@rainer_32 they should add fog or clouds, something that makes the map look more massive, am ok with the draw distance.

[@rainer_32]

@@castroabuful2468 of course they could also do that

[@semendemon2127]

@@castroabuful2468 maybe they could make it so depending on how high you go up is how far the draw distance is

[@Kacpa2]

@@semendemon2127 No it just should be there and what they should fix is drawdistance for trees and traffic so you never have traffic or trees appear out of nowhere ahead. They obviously didnt donthat for VC, cars still pop in 10m ahead

[@christianloggins]

The lighting in San Andreas looks good, but it’s just that for certain cutscenes, the characters can look very dark to where you can’t see their faces

[@KrishnamKumawat]

👀

[@bluejuly2633]

I agree! In the Big Smoke ordering scene you can barely see anyone besides CJ

[@DuckThePato]

I think it's because of the ambient occlusion, if so, I will definitely turn it off

[@osama_rawwagah]

I think increasing the game brightness will fix that

[@waltsp.6969]

I think the HDR is the culprit

[@maddylmaz4627]

+Look Sonny, we were set up, the trilogy edition was an ambush… -You better be kiddin’ me Tommy! Tell me you still got the licensed soundtrack! +No Sonny, i dont have the soundtrack…. -THAT WAS MY MUSIC TOMMY! MY MUSIC!

[@aryanpawar8409]

Cd or a floppy😂 just kidding

[@talpatv512]

At lest you know what music is missing ? Pr is it that bullshit leak from reddit or something

[@JonnyHorseman]

They even lost a license to a Love Fist song ffs

[@BrosL0L]

@@JonnyHorseman 90% of the OST is there

[@JonnyHorseman]

@@BrosL0L as opoosed to 100%

[@AVGNROCKS1996]

Never understood why they changed the PS2 San Andreas haze effect, it looks so natural and the color pallet is nicer. Looks flat everywhere else.

[@JPX64Channel]

its weird , they had a partnership with sony at the time because they really wanted the ps2 version to shine even when it was the console with the weakest specs, ok at least we can have it now in pc with a little mod.

[@ghosttoast8610]

It’s supposed to cover up the shitty draw distance

[@DexZeth]

The rain looks so fake :s 2021 come f' on!!!

[@budaroddy]

Unique lighting effect, has much more personallity than this grab money edition

[@chrisrichfield8906]

Ya the color pallet thing really confuses me. THe haze effect i kinda just assumed was a special function of the ps2 hardware that is much more expensive with how modern hardware works, or something. But the color pallet looks so much better on PS2, like it has that perfect orange and teal combo that was on basically every single movie poster is 2008, because some study said it was the most attractive color combination, or something like that.

[@re.liable]

The vibrant colors really suit Vice City

[@opiumgxn_]

Yessss looks beautiful

[@kayleyjones1133]

The neon

[@AloneInThePark]

That's the point, it's Miami in the 80s course it's gonna be colourful lol.

[@fctn99]

@@AloneInThePark i think he means the overall vibrancy of all these new versions suits vice city the most because it's 80s & colourful etc etc

[@AloneInThePark]

@@fctn99 Ah okay I get ya now

[@feloniousbutterfly]

Hopefully Silent won't have to singlehandedly save this edition too.

[@H4S5A4N79]

He might have to but I think on Twitter he said he won't.

[@III-------------------Ill]

He won't because take 2 interactive would sue him for everything he got.

[@infernus3660]

Fr, we dont deserve Silent, he is a legend

[@zeapsin186]

Who?

[@thenamelessone6119]

@@zeapsin186 A modder famous for patching the PC versions. He’s a badass, he goes above and beyond for these.

[@MidnightClubStillCancelledSoz]

Carl lookin' a little thin, man. He's gotta be hungry, man.

[@mannimelen]

Ya he could eat.

[@cloudspeedsoul]

What about some tacos?

[@flaqko5686]

I did this while being fat CJ

[@WelshTurkey]

Starvin Marvin

[@poweroffriendship2.0]

Tacos

[@yellowbat79]

No matter how better the environment and lighting looks... Whenever a cutscene plays it just looks awful, what the hell are these cartoony looks for the side characters?

[@talpatv512]

Ur reaching, it dosent look back

[@deadshot9946]

I don’t know man, it looks good to me. I think you’ve set your expectations too high.

[@limcritiques]

Were you thinking that they'd make the games back from scratch?

[@yellowbat79]

@@limcritiques no, but these models are obviously made from scratch, just with a jarringly different direction and intent that fits nothing. Not the main character model, not the environment, not the lighting, not the story, anything. They look like clay characters

[@BillyPage1337]

that's because it is 3D universe

[@CaptainBoobles]

The orange / teal colours, hazy smog filled sky, heat wave rising off the pavement added so much to the vibe of the original ps2 San Andreas, its such a shame they couldn't find a way to replicate it. Hoping modders can get into the definitive version and have a go at adding them back in

[@D3adSh0t442]

I never liked it, it was annoying

[@krispo7256]

@@D3adSh0t442 I always like it, it was awesome

[@MariusBoss11458]

@@krispo7256 I feel like th effect is maybe too much and should be slightly Reduced. Game is gonna look as Orange as Matto.

[@KevinSheppard]

The definitive editions look like a movie that was presented as it was shot, without the colour correction applied to give it a unique vibe. The textures and models look great, but the visual charm and attitude of the originals isn't there.

[@Brownaut1993]

The missing haze effects don't help either. There's something about the character models making sense in the original graphics but not the new ones. I think it's the animation

[@reveng3r]

definitive looks like machinima or bunch of mods, VC looks awesome at night sometimes, but daily water beyond the good and evil

[@thirdhandlv4231]

@@reveng3r VICE CITY looked stunning.

[@RevanBC]

Good thing on PC there are reshades

[@mookid2223]

This is the exact thing I was thinking, these remasters could genuinely look amazing with the tone and charm of the originals, they just really need the haze and colour pallet of the original San Andreas.

[@jonathanbell8887]

Claude looks sad compared to a total Chad.

[@trevorphilips9065]

He didn't even have eyes back then

[@User71956]

@@trevorphilips9065 That's why he was such a chad

[@Raju-rl1bc]

Man he had to get shot again by his gf. What do u expect😂😂😂

[@JamieRobert_]

Dude looks ugly af in the original

[@aarthikmehta1547]

@@trevorphilips9065 that's why he was woozie's friend.

[@darksouls6014]

don't tell me this is all they did for the past 3 years after releasing rdr2.

[@josephgonzalez7379]

GTA 5 expanded and enhanced as well

[@dhruvthakur6811]

It looks like an intern made this

[@shreyas__]

Rockstar didnt make this. This is done by some other company rockstar paid. No clue what rockstar is working on.

[@nieildilsonsouza4747]

@@shreyas__ another update for online probably.

[@commonchannel3115]

@@nieildilsonsouza4747 gta 6😍 and gta 5 p5 expand and enhance 😗😗 and others don't know 😂

[@RIELSG]

The PS2 colors are still unmatched I see for San Andreas

[@JPX64Channel]

you can replicate it in the OG PC version with ''skygfx'' mod, it looks incredible, like ps2 but at HD widescreen and high framerate.

[@Yeedman]

@@JPX64Channel you shouldn't run it at high framerate though, san andreas (along with 3 and vice city) has physics problems because a bunch of things are tied to the framerate and dont work properly above 30fps

[@arohanpaul5538]

@@Yeedman Framerate Vigilante can fix that, one of the best mods out there imo

[@mookid2223]

I second on Framerate Vigilante, it’s still getting updated and is on its way to make the whole game 100% playable at higher framerates.

[@Yeedman]

@@arohanpaul5538 i never really found a download link for that so i assumed it was still under development and not released

[@BrokenBeats94]

6:58 it’s funny how the lighting is so much more hazier on the PS2 version but I actually really like how blistering hot LS looks - though the lighting is very awkward in this scene across all versions

[@pantheon_6]

The new one looks like someone's unfinished unity game project 😂

[@DDPlay_TABMovie]

In the PS2 it seemed that the Sun was 2 meters from the earth

[@BrokenBeats94]

@@pantheon_6 it actually does 😂

[@bigbosssnakecorn8834]

Specially it fits well hiding C.R.A.S.H. before revealing themselves

[@saimohnishmuralidharan5440]

Forget all other things, but the Jetpack is Simply Incredible.

[@yourlocalchloesimp]

Yeah, I was like "HOOOLY SHIT DUDE!!" I didn't really expect them to go THAT far with the lighting.

[@Booboo-bz5ew]

Crazy part about I’ll still play the originals just got that childhood feel to it

[@User71956]

Well that will be especially true for me, if they ended up cutting the music tracks. It's why I still have my ps3 copy of GTA 4.

[@Alltopicreader]

True

[@sevionus80]

@@User71956 If the current owner of a music property denies anyone else the use of it, then nobody can use it. Plain and simple.

[@johnkittz]

I recently replayed the originals and no I will not be playing them again. My fucking God. You gta fans are absolutely nuts.

[@Alltopicreader]

@@johnkittz it's because u are just an amateur and haven't ever played the original versions like we veterans. The older gta version has a separate vibe that this gta trilogy remaster doesn't have. And u just care about the graphics and not the elements of the game.

[@Awakelettuce77]

tbh Tommy Vercetti in originals is way better looking than in definitive edition, same goes for Claude and CJ actually.

[@carlinytc7431]

100% agree

[@dearestterror5234]

Nah Claude imo looks way better. cj looks ok and Tommy is a little off

[@om1nous312]

THE PERFECT COMMENT !!! Sadly this is the result of being lazy and thinks only for the money. Rockstar ... welcome to the EA, Activision\Blizzard universe ... They literally just port the mobile versions to a "Definitive Edition" and tries to milk us for money. Oh and the best part: if u ask them why is everything so bad compared to other remasters and so on - the answer: "we wanted to save the old feeling of the game !!! ". WTF Bro ... u just wanted to save money, not feelings. And as i see, the excitement comments are so much, that infact we deserve this bullshit :D the community is dumb as f***k

[@OneTwoMark]

They turned him into Tommy Baguetti, moms spaghetti.

[@jamespratt4260]

@@om1nous312 it would be more Rockstar welcome to the Bioware, infinityward/ Blizzard entertainment universe. Because they are just developers. Take 2 is the owners of rockstar

[@13yopredator10]

San Andreas' lack of people and cars makes it look empty + seeing the whole map when flying.

[@DaveG123]

Does anyone else notice the lack of vehicle tail lights at night?

[@mazda9624]

Something I've always wanted since I first played San Andreas was to be able to see the entire map rendered at once and now thay I've actually experienced it with the remaster, I wish I hadn't. It really does make the map feel so much smaller when the whole thing is loaded at once.

[@TSMSnation]

You don't know what you want.

[@vicrattlehead8417]

06:18 is really impressive. Not having played the games since they released on ps2 this will be fun.

[@kennystone1254]

Wow it really is

[@Redwan777]

I don't know why but Diaz looks like he is made of cardboard

[@omnicat4379]

Can’t wait for you to play it, and realize you paid 60 dollars for a minimal remaster of a few PS2 games. Have fun using their outdated controls, and seeing sims characters all over the place. People like you are the reason why rockstar practices the shitty business practices they do

[@DDPlay_TABMovie]

@@omnicat4379 seriously, you never settle for anything

[@omnicat4379]

@@DDPlay_TABMovie I would settle with a decent remaster. Please stop being so sheepish and stand up for yourself. News just came out that the trilogy is a remastered version of the mobile gta ports. It’s literally a disgrace at this point, if you can’t see it, idk what to tell u 😂

[@avengederz]

so strange to see shotting without recoil in the game these day

[@topmei1702]

I feel like this only works for Vice City because it feels more vibrant.

[@waltsp.6969]

Agree The tone and visual styles of VC is more appropriate than the other 2

[@Petekaboo]

PS2 is best at post processing effects, even though a lot of them are to hide the short draw distance, it gave the games their unique personality. PC original is best at overall quality, lost some effects, but everything else looks and plays better. Definitive edition is yet another remaster that's an improvement on paper, mixed bag in practice. Unreal lighting makes character models look worse, black crush everywhere, rain effect looks horrendous, and they screwed the protagonists' face for whatever reason. Gameplay is harder to judge from videos, but I rather have the old auto aim controls than a modern precision shooting controls with no recoil. Let's not talk about 10th anniversary edition.

[@gingerfloofy]

There really is something off about the characters design in the definitive edition.

[@TR58699]

10th anniversary addition was a upgrage for the other 2 but absolute garbage for SA

[@thirsty_yt6481]

Really? I was just thinking that the rain effects for gta 3 were amazing

[@curiousmind_]

That right here is an accurate description

[@estefanyelizrefaellahoward4554]

Did you know that playing video games is bad for your mental health? The most common symptoms are not sleeping well, be it not being able to fall asleep once in bed, having nightmares, waking up in the middle of the night, being groggy in the morning, or all of these. Video games ruin your peace of mind and you just can not sleep. As a result, because your mind and body do not get the rest they need, you’re exhausted the next day. You can’t focus well or make better decisions. That affect your work performance - which may lead to losing your job. If you’re a student, it’s a surefire way to fail your tests as you just can not remember anything anymore and are too distracted and tired. There’s more to this, though. A study shows that this addiction can lead to actual mental health problems. When talking about young people, it interferes with their development too. That’s the effect of video games on you. It’s your job to open your eyes and realise how this "hobby" is preventing you from spending your time in a better way. Once you get a taste of what’s out there, sitting down and playing video games becomes incredibly boring and unnecessary. You’ll be so used to your new life that you see you’ll have no use for it. Then, you end up throwing them away - creating more room for much better hobbies - such as watching beauty pageants and collecting American Girl, LOL Surprise, LOL Surprise OMG, Na Na Na Surprise, Rainbow High, Bratz, Dream Ella and Barbie dolls. So if you find yourself in the universe of video games, I ask you to take a hard look at your life and see if you are using it in an attempt to compensate for some lack. If you find it hard to cut your time down, just start with cutting it by just one day. Reduce it by the next seven days, then the entire month and even one whole year! Then see if you can go five years, ten years or even a lifetime without it at all! It’s worth trying! 😘💚💛💖❤️💜💙

[@JasonFolk07]

Yeah I'm definitely not buying any of them I had a feeling they look alright but honestly for the engine they used hands down could have done better in many areas

[@dankanator2751]

They made this on unreal same I'm not buying this too this looks like a indie project

[@MoistestRock]

Honestly idk what you expected it’s a remaster not a remake. They delivered a hell of a lot more than I ever expected from Rockstar.

[@nytrogyen]

U just kept ur expectations high

[@dankanator2751]

@@nytrogyen no i didn't

[@gameimprovements4347]

@@MoistestRock that's pretty embarrassing to have such low expectations from a company that produces such great games

[@yatins3493]

Dude the jetpack in san andreas looks next lvl high quality look at that thing 😂😂🔥

[@landonbobbett2301]

It would be cool if here was an classic graphics option too.

[@TheMasterQuests]

Like what Halo Combat Evolved Anniversary did?

[@landonbobbett2301]

@@TheMasterQuests yeah

[@unclekaz3153]

Its because this is in a completely different engine

[@RedDeadExpert007]

Why would you waste $60 just for a “classic graphics” option? Dumbass.

[@xkai84]

@@RedDeadExpert007 its an option for a reason.

[@margusmees5720]

Yes that lighting thing really is something.....now i can't even see the characters in cutscenes.....well fucking done Rockstar....."Emmet voice" I am so proud of you boy!

[@jonathanbohm6489]

I like how you can finally switch out of the first person when aiming certain weapons in VC and GTA 3

[@NixDarkLord]

I can't wait to see Vice City's final cutscene with Tommy and Ken and the credits with new graphics

[@jaimeruedagomez]

Amazed by how good the original PC ports look

[@ilikeitupthere5813]

Yeah

[@engineer1941]

Original PC version is worst one. It is missing ton of stuff PS2 had and is bugged to hell with issues. Specialy fps related ones.

[@maxpaw2424]

10th anniversary was the best imo

[@engineer1941]

@@maxpaw2424 nah ps2 has best version. But best thing to do is to get mods for og pc release that fix issues and add ps2 stuff.

[@jaimeruedagomez]

PS2 San Andreas is of course the original idea of the creators, the haze and colors bring the atmosphere the developers wanted for the game. But having in mind the low resolution and texturing it is hard to say it looks better than the PC port

[@HarryB4497]

The graphics are good and the gameplay tries to stay true to the originals, but it would’ve been nice if they didn’t cut so many corners with some of the character models and it would’ve been great if they gave veteran players the options to turn off the casual QOL changes like the guided waypoints and new weapon and radio wheels, having a toggle for the classic weapon and radio wheels would’ve been a nice touch. It would’ve been nice if there was an option to turned off that white outline around people you’re aiming at as well. I don’t understand why that isn’t a toggle for players who have accessibility problems.

[@ianwastakenxx]

The game price suck tho

[@TheEyeFromWithin]

@@ianwastakenxx I mean it’s for the trilogy if they make theme separate I bet the price will go down

[@shanevanholm2684]

Fr? U rather use the old weapon where u had to scroll down to the weapon u need cuz of nostalgia?

[@shanevanholm2684]

@@foolishgoose453 ye but the game also added free aim. Something the old version of the game didnt have

[@public.archive]

i was interested at first , but judging from the footages around, i think they failed to capture the “vibes” of the old games 😕 also not a fan of the inconsistency where the main protagonist has a detailed (albeit different than how it used to be) face but other characters are still low poly. i’ll stick with the OGs for now

[@Kacpa2]

Same....problem is that noone new can buy classic versions anymore....they took them all down replacing it with this shit...

[@redrockbro3679]

@@Kacpa2 hey we can legally pirate the og now lol, well not legally but morally since there's no frickin og in the stores anymore

[@Kacpa2]

@@redrockbro3679 Yeah...Shane they had to ruin so much :/ GTA Underground is the most painful loss :/ And if they just went itno it seriously remade it on GTA IV's rage, no need to take any mods down, unique enough to be worth buying due to new gameplay and classic version could stay... but no :/

[@redrockbro3679]

@@Kacpa2 well Thats rockstar for us..

[@Bocchi4516]

The lazy thing they do here is the menu sound, map blips and style is GTA SA in GTA 3 and VC

[@GW_01]

Especially Vice City because it sounded like a synthesizer which suited the 80s theme

[@s.p.d9227]

Feel sad for the guys that'll be playing this on PS5, most people seems to not be very happy with the color tone of the game. On PC, I'm sure a quick ENB mod will fix the color tone like a snap. Also, first mod for GTA SA is to get the fog back!

[@Diabolical-Tyrant]

Hopefully rockstar will try to improve it with some updates… but that’s being very… very optimistic

[@andrerivera6091]

Yea bro I’m on the p5 right now and I must say I am not impressed one bit. They coulda have done a way better job. More effort

[@supday3877]

That's still sad that u got use a mod to fix the color tones

[@frozenturbo8623]

@@supday3877 on Console you don't have Mods because Console can't do crap.

[@YAH2121]

The only real downsides is that the shadows are a lot darker and ends up hiding more details. Its especially evident in some cutscenes in san andreas

[@Jwatchdizzledrip3003]

@Yah21 I’d take that over the flat textures of the original PS2. Hey it’s realistic now so…

[@maxim196]

Also less songs and less blood

[@BrokenBeats94]

Some of the lighting in really bad in the definitive editions, especially in the cut scenes

[@mastermind7946]

Unpopular opinion but I personally think the Definitive edition looks fantastic

[@TjazzSyn]

Where can i find more comparisons like this? It's so interesting to watch all the versions of the trilogy compared side by side

[@BrokenBeats94]

The original PC release remains the definitive version of these games, especially with the years of community mods and support they have had. Time to pirate the old gta pc releases and mod the heck out of them I think

[@karmaftw3730]

I own all the originals on steam, Had them for years.

[@ionaccel]

Don't remind me of the PC version! It kept freezing my computer within 5 minutes, obviously my hardware fault. But I sooooooo wanted to play that I ended up renting a PS2 just to play. I became a GTA addict so quick, purchased a PS2 just for the game! I really want to PC GTA with all the fun available, but I'll never have a gaming PC cause I can't keep up on the $1000 vid cards required. LOL.

[@Johnnysmithy24]

That’s what I will do when I get a pc

[@BrokenBeats94]

@@Johnnysmithy24 you could run the OG trilogy on pretty much anything

[@BrokenBeats94]

@@ionaccel they definitely have a unique charm to them on the PS2, especially for nostalgia purposes - only thing I struggle going back to is the combat system but mods or this definitive version does fix that

[@kingdashes5031]

Rockstar did an amazing job with the graphics btw I love your videos man keep up the good work ❤️🔥

[@IAMNOTRANA]

10:28 Gaming most iconic cut scene ruin by garbage lighting and freaking glass reflection.

[@Kacpa2]

Whoke DE us fucking awful and classic versilns are now gone from all stores...

[@arjun05234]

10:29 The MOST AWAITED ONE ! ❤✨

[@coolazsmf775]

The lack of atmosphere in GTA SA and GTA 3 is killing the vibe of the game... They did nail GTA VC, they made it much better in comparison... Except for the character's design and animation (this applied to all three games)

[@WhirlingMusic]

I'm glad more people are noticing these new versions are missing the original flairs, colors, and art direction.

[@visionop8]

I've got the original trilogy Xbox versions. After a lot of examination I think I'm going to stick with those. it's not nostalgia because I never finished them. I really prefer the lighting engine and color palate and facial expressions of the originals. It comes off really cinematic like the Brian De Palma/John Singleton films Rockstar was inspired by. I will always be jealous though of the improved controls from GTA V in the Definitive versions because that is a real improvement to the older games in the series and was badly needed. However, my TV clears them up the originals really well and has a "game motion plus" setting that adds a 60fps effect without adding input lag and I'm not missing 40+ songs. I'm all about the feel and emotion and for my tastes, the originals still stand.

[@LNCRFT]

Well said. I still have the originals on both PS2 and Xbox and the Xbox version of GTA III AND VC are already improved versions compared to the PS2 one.

[@LukeMM95]

I still have my PS2 copies and a CRT to play them on. For me, that's the only way to play these games.

[@matiasbenavidesdigitalvisu9511]

The distant Fog, warm ambience and that hot desert blur as a hot day of lost santos, are things that I miss from the old, is incredible little things makes a huge difference

[@javarjv]

definitive seems to have taken a lot of the npcs away, it look like ghost towns in most of the footage of them, I wonder how big a problem that is, Rockstar seems to have half a it again

[@hemantsudarshan2477]

Those In-game sounds gave me massive Nostalgic Chills.

[@IHaveBadWiFiBro]

god the render distance is a gift and a curse, what the...........

[@Kacpa2]

only a cursebit looks godawful like game is unfinished and play sone fucked up alpha test

[@JimmyRadical1986]

the new lighting is good but unfortunately it make some sense to dark.

[@Chantzdc]

Hate that I notice less NPCs walking around, driving etc.. the world looks as empty as the mobile version of the game.. the PS2 ViceCity was jam packed with ppl on the strip.

[@ionaccel]

Hopefully, there are lots of NPCs, that was fun part of game..... just hanging out on a corner and hearing random conversations.

[@utsavbasu1048]

What wait seriously

[@NoUploads08]

Great job by Rockstar and Grovestreet. All the hate is from people who overhyped this in their head. They improved on the games 100x's imo. If the REMINDER of the PS2 games isnt the REMASTER you had planned in your head... Go replay RDR2...its the best RPG ever made.

[@shrekgaming6593]

That's not the problem The bugs....

[@nabinabat]

Слава Богу, что вышел этот видос, а то бы я реально купил. Это же просто моды, наверное сборка лучших. Платить за это 70$? Are you crazy?

[@molligris]

It's 20 dollars per game and with the definitive edition you avoid download mods like silent patch, maybe an ENB, Widescreen fix, in the original games you can't play at 60 frames because the engine of that olds games doesn't support it, making the game annoying. Don't be exaggerated and think about it.

[@nabinabat]

@@molligris ты когда нибудь играл в оригиналы? Исходя из этого видео лицо Томми - это уже разочарование. Simpsons Hit & Run знаешь что такое?) конечно не поиграв рано осуждать, но по этому видео - продаётся сборка крутых модов. Купишь?

[@nabinabat]

@@molligris существует такая схема, что перед выпуском чего-либо грандиозного показать что-нибудь гораздо хуже, дабы произвести впечатление, занизить ожидания. Искренне верю что это именно оно, потому что Рок Звёзды ещё не били так низко.

[@molligris]

@@nabinabat I obviously play the originals dude, the PS2 version. The nostalgia factor makes you think they're bad. This are Twenty years old games, if you really enjoy them if because the history, and characters personalities, not about their face. The "Simpsons hit and run" comparison has no sense.

[@user-fs8rn4cb6c]

@@molligris What are you talking about?! The faces are major part of the characters. Tommy is constantly angry and sharp-tongued, so his "grin" made perfect sense in the original, now in DE there's a huge dissonance between his "sad puppy face" (especially since he only got one expression throughout the cutscenes, like on original) and the words he speaking. That's just scratching the surface. That dude is absolutely correct about not buying and supporting this half-assed shit, Take2, R* and WDS shoud've done a better job.

[@Elemtree]

Their fingers are finally free from each other… but at the cost of becoming plastic models…

[@K3rhos]

Yeah they added a frickin reflection effect on their skins/hair, that's ruin everything ! In some cutscenes we can clairly see reflection on hair and clothes.

[@andrew_z2856]

PC Original and 10 year anniversary look the best, and the Definitive Edition just looks like a cartoony mobile game.

[@nickb1729]

I found in SA after turning the saturation and brightness down that the characters didn't look so shadowy in cutscenes and so I can actually see foliage detail when it's darker.

[@un-kemp-t]

The lighting in a lot of cutscenes seems to be really dark. The overall quality of the character models have me pretty freaked out on the whole, they could have definitely done with another pass. It's all pretty good and I'm looking forward to properly giving it a go, but it all just leaves me weirdly cold looking at it currently

[@DeepDimpleDemon]

I noticed the cutscenes on PC remastered are brighter than PS5 remastered, not sure what's up with that

[@VlaDuZa]

The cloths, cars, buildings, special effects that maintain the original feel of gameplay (for example - not turning NPCS to ragdolls was a good decision in my opinion, it would have felt out of place) are really awesome. The only problem I have really is the facial expressions. They look like toys, blank and the interactions just seem very off compared to the lively animated and full of emotion expressions of the characters in the original games. If they can work this out, to me, that's enough.

[@naveenkumar-ls9rk]

When the characters is speaking there mouth doesn't even open and the dialogue doesn't sync... Which feels kinda weird and like cheap game with ultra realistic mods.... 😕

[@Raju-rl1bc]

Especially gta iii BTW everything is way better

[@diegoprodriguez]

I remember when I was a kid and plying San Andreas, I’d give some of the Pedestrians models that looked interesting and gave that model a name.

[@BrokenBeats94]

The character eyes look so weird in the 10th anniversary edition of Vice City, it looks really bad!

[@whatshottrending]

Congrats to everyone who is early and found this comment ❤️

[@verycheapyoghurt2566]

My man you have 4 most likely stolen videos with 10k views yet 2m subs

[@Groove4lyf3]

We got nothing yay

[@poweroffriendship2.0]

_"I'll have two number 9s, number 9 large, number 6 with extra dip, number 7, two number 45s, one with cheese, and a large soda."_ *~ Big Smoke in 4K edition*

[@Onaterdem]

Asides from San Andreas being too dark at times, this is literally a perfect graphical update. Everything looks so, so much better, GTA 3 and VC look like GTA 4 while SA looks like GTA 5. I've seen people call the new models "too cartoony", I much prefer the term "stylized" - after all, GTA games are mostly humorous, and the new models fit the world so well. All in all, I've never seen a remaster change so many things for the better while retaining the original feeling. WELL DONE.

[@Alexander_l322]

I found a few little bugs in my first play on vice city and SA. Graphical glitches on Tommy when I changed into the golfing outfit on four iron mission and in sa I saw sweet doesn’t hold his gun right in the cut scene when the ballas drove by and blew up smokes car at the cemetery. Also Demolition man trophy glitched. It’s the one where you kill all of them with the helicopter blades. Maybe I missed one or something but I did check.

[@Alexander_l322]

@Dead Account it applied its self before I even played.That happened before it launched because i preloaded it on PS5z

[@Kaname85]

The best comparison video so far because there would be moments in trailers when I couldn't decide if it looked good or not? Like I wanna say environments look good, but sometimes it doesn't it's really weird

[@MaidofRage420]

Honestly I like how they still kept that cartoony feel to the models instead of making them hyperrealistic tbh. I am gonna miss that they removed the haze effect from San Andreas. Made that map feel nice

[@thejumpboy1185]

@Rezatera EilolsiânAll you guys do is complain don't you

[@thirdhandlv4231]

@Rezatera Eilolsiân The games look completely different, shut up.

[@tamer9298]

Porque a versão definitiva do San Andreas ficou tão escura em certas cutcenes 🤔

[@choyi-hyun8977]

Like gta 4

[@18andAboveV]

removing that render fog without a replacement was not the right move, everything being always 100% sharp and colorful makes it look like an android game at best

[@GunsNGames1]

PlayStation 2 and Original Xbox versions are still the best and ultimate way to play the classic GTA trilogy.

[@mr.haunted760]

I don't know why they removed the gore from GTA 3 the game feels different without it

[@Zero-bd9ud]

Yeah why they? Are it toooooo gore?

[@mr.haunted760]

@@Zero-bd9ud ?

[@Zero-bd9ud]

@@mr.haunted760 so you don't get it eh?

[@mr.haunted760]

@@Zero-bd9ud i don't know TF you're talking about dude what the heck you meant to say?

[@Zero-bd9ud]

@@mr.haunted760 WHY THE FUCK YOU STILL DON'T GET IT

[@mkdfan]

Not played the other 2 yet but the rain in GTA3 is appalling. You can’t see anything and feels like you’re looking at a magic eye book. 😵‍💫 Also I had to turn the brightness all the way up and contrast all the way down as it was way too dark. Enjoying it nonetheless.

[@UraniumBullets]

I just love how the definitive edition cars don't have working taillights at night

[@Im_Anson_14]

Idk why i feel like ps2 has one of the best graphic but good video keep up the good work

[@j.j.9511]

Waiting for a deep sale.

[@jadejarajveersinh8604]

Best Comparison Ever....👏👍 Keep It Up...❤️

[@TheGamingNorwegian]

The people here who claims this "only" looks like an ENB mod are crazy... Think you need to check your eyes.

[@jessenthebenezer]

Too many blind post gta v kids who never played the originals here

[@BurninPhoenix]

At this point , the kids are running out of reasons and simply crying " cashgrab". Its like they are finding silly excuses to complain about the game. Seriously, these people always wanted massive draw distance and when they got it, they want the fog back now . The reason they are saying : map looks smaller. Fog or no fog its the exact same map size. And then they talk about some trash mods and glorify these modders when it was just a blank improvement of someone else's game with the details someone else made.

[@jessenthebenezer]

@@BurninPhoenix exactly

[@ThePassionOfTheMarc]

I have a Xbox Series X but have been dying to play GTA III and Vice City (already have the San Andreas remaster for Xbox One), I didn't even know this was coming out until last week. I heard rumors forever though. Can't wait!

[@ItsAstie]

PS2 & PC Original still remains my favorite.

[@KrishnamKumawat]

Great comparison! Nice video

[@yami2957]

GTA III looks the best out of all of them. It feels dark and I really love the atmosphere, but during the day, it doesn't look as good. Vice City is good, but some models (like Candy Suxx) are... unimpressive. San Andreas looks the worst, with the shoulders and face models being instantly noticeable as being bad right from the first cutscene with the taxi and CRASH.

[@KellanGDM]

I hadn't noticed the shoulder issue but omg it looks so awful, specially when cj puts his hands behind his head 😬

[@bravesonly]

Seems like they couldn't match deadline with VC and especially San Andreas, so they had to hurry. That would also explain some problems like brand new looking furniture and perfectly clean and new walls in gangstars or junkie's houses in SA. They have probably took the models from some 3d models online marketplaces to go quicker. Also some palms are growing out of the concrete or planted just randomly. That all looks like Groove Street Studios were REALLY in a hurry

[@yami2957]

@@bravesonly The one thing that I DESPISE about San Andreas Definitive is the lack of fog. I know that it existed because of limitations in the original, but without it, the map looks so tiny! I mean, I guess it is tiny, but it didn't feel like it when I was playing the original. You could stand on the tallest building in Los Santos and actually see Las Venturas and San Fierro along with the abandoned airfield and Shady Creeks. That's like standing on top of the Bank of America building in LA and being able to see Vegas and San Fransico.

[@AlphaYellow]

Man, I don't like how the lighting makes everything so much darker and contrasty, characters become really dimmed too, not to mention the huge halos around characters due to the cheap ambient occlusion used.

[@xSnappa]

PC Original looks the best to me.

[@sdb4life448]

Smh

[@yoskolo3976]

Stop

[@PAVELROZEVIC]

Nice work man! Thanks for the video!

[@lunchbox997]

The fog and draw distance is really a big issue for me, some models in Vice city like Ken Rosenberg look weird and washed out with no skin tone.

[@pubgfun2934]

5:00 that's how a painting changes with time 😂😂

[@Mattipillar]

the mods are going to be glorious for these games

[@frymastermeat]

10:28 to 10:44 This is why you don't go near third party remakes. There is no attention to detail whatsoever because they just don't give a fuck.

[@Filipcreate]

PlayStation 2 version is always the best in terms of the atmosphere, especially in GTA III and GTA: San Andreas.

[@tonynasaofficial]

Cap maybe on San Andreas but not GTA 3 it's so much better in the definitive edition and vice city is a mix the characters look off and I agree with San Andreas but GTA 3 in the definitive edition is so good

[@WGSXFrank]

It seems clear that 3 got the most attention and love when it came to the up-scaling, remodeling, and details. VC looks like that care was drop about 2/3rds in, and SA looks as if it was 80% machine algorithms doing the upscaling, and people kinda touching up select areas.

[@user-fs8rn4cb6c]

1:15 Hold on, so they didn't even used superior Xbox car models as basis? You can see the differences in Kuruma (With tailights silver frame on Xbox model, looks better than PS2/PC model, not as eerie), where they (WDS) previously used Xbox models in mobile ports of III and VC, but I guess for some reason forgot to use them in DE.

[@Kacpa2]

They were just lazy and didnt even show Xbox version in official comparisons in the trailer :/

[@dreska256]

Yeah at 3:31 you can see under the police car hood that they still used flat texture for the engine rather than the fully modelled one for Xbox. Like they don't even need to recreate each car, they already have the models

[@VarietyGamerChannel]

Because this is just the mobile anniversary port run through unreal engine post processed filters.

[@khoado2060]

@@VarietyGamerChannel What? No! What video are you even watching?

[@bravesonly]

In GTA 3 it seems like Anniversary Edition has more HD cars than Definitive Edition

[@ThreadBomb]

The latest graphics definitely impress, and I appreciate they mostly duplicated the original character animations, but there are some questionable design choices. The faces look simultaneously grotesque and bland; the older versions had more expression in their features. Also, some clothes have been changed and look less good. 4:01 - The old outfit looks realistic, the new version looks cartoonish. I think the character design undoes the hard work that went into the rest of the remaster, to some extent.

[@jasonr.]

Do you recommend the new remasters? I've been watching some streamings of San Andreas and in the streaming, the game crashed 3 times in a row on the Doberman mission when trying to enter Ammunation. After the guy fixed it (I don't know how), a few minutes later, guess what? CJ was bugged, his texture was not working, and looks pretty weird. So, knowing the studio in charge for the remasters was the same in charge for the awful and full of bugs mobile version, I'm pretty concerned about buying these games...

[@tin7143]

totally not worth $60 and hopefully they’ll update the bugs and glitches after release

[@zeebruh3333]

To be fair the game doesn't officially release until tomorrow, they could slip in some patch notes.

[@benoh3417]

@@tin7143 why isnt it worth 60 ? 3 classic great games for 20 each with enhanced controls and graphics

[@King29Lewis]

@@benoh3417 The remasters aren’t even worth the 60 because there’s so many issues. Driving across an invisible bridge, GTAIII’s controls are bugged, characters look piss poor, games way too dark. On top of all this, the devs that made this are notorious of not fixing anything.

[@zeapsin186]

@@tin7143it's $20 for a game...just say $20. Each game is pretty great for $20

[@senorlechuga8832]

They kinda need to adjust the character models a bit, make the render distance adjustable and ffs do something with the rain, you can notice the same pattern repeating at the same time and it's bothering me so so so much

[@pspdv]

yes! Very bad rain effect

[@lilyblueharsh]

I can admit when I'm wrong, this doesn't look nearly as bad as I thought it did from the pre-release screenshots.

[@walkerkemp4540]

Is anyone else really impressed with what they did with 3 and vice city however can’t help but feel something’s off with SA? I really can’t put my finger on it

[@LILBOO200]

The Shading In Cutscenes Of SA Is To Dark

[@coltonwilkie241]

You can't even see Smoke during the order scene. Is that just the brightness being too low or did they really just darken everything up to make it look "HD"? That genuinely looked atrocious.

[@BrokenBeats94]

The lighting is terrible in the definitive editions - it might because it’s dynamic lighting depending on the weather and time of day in the scene maybe? But it looks terrible

[@DeadpoolX20]

The lighting in that scene sucks

[@TheMasterQuests]

Anyone know if you have a custom music list on these versions?

[@OrphenKryScion]

If there is I got the vinesauce playlists ready to go lol

[@TheMasterQuests]

How can we confirm if this feature is in the collection or not?