國外聲樂老師點評 陳奕迅《這樣很好》LIVE《英雄聯盟：雙城之戰》第二季 主題曲 Vocal Coach Reaction to Eason Chan「Isha's Song」Arcane OST

[@s70342000]

看奧術前聽感覺是首溫暖的歌 看完奧術再聽一次直接大破防😢

[@beyondhk4316]

隨著年齡轉變及人生經歷，Eason有著不一樣的風格，欣賞他不停轉變及超越自己。

[@loklok6076]

很喜歡這遊戲的製作，他們會找不同國籍歌手參與。每個遊戲角色也有其故事。很多也會獨立製作音樂MV，全都是頂級水準。每季遊戲比賽主題曲也很好聽。相比起主流喜愛的孤勇者，個人更愛這首讓人沉醉的歌曲與影片。

[@Lucas77787]

陳奕迅唱歌真的有種在說故事的感覺 毫無疑問是現在年代的歌神

[@x26574999]

同樣一句話我在15年前也聽過，代表說故事的神一直是他跨過了幾個年代

[@yehyeh1821]

我不是張學友年代的歌迷 但以現在的審美觀來看 Eason的確比較多元跟廣闊 技巧完全高超到 你覺得他沒用技巧全是感情 但實際上卻是滿滿的設計感 很有品味

[@五音全畢]

陳奕迅的音樂境界真的很高❤

[@Klaasti_tw]

當時完全沒注意到是國語，完全沉浸在音樂跟畫面之中...當察覺到 Isha 動機，腦中一直大喊著：阻止她！拜託不要...QQ 直到後面才聽出來是國語！還是陳奕迅 Eason，整個很感動及驕傲［華語］在這種作品當中出現！所以我不太懂某些人說很出戲或不搭的感覺...

[@KiyaLin-f7v]

老師是不是每次評到Eason都會講到歌手最本質的東西啊...

[@DerrickLo-p7k]

Eason就係無敵，無愧「歌神」之名👍

[@vivian7247]

Still my favourite Hong Kong artist after all these years!

[@tofushow]

E神厲害的地方就是在即使音階容易的歌曲也能唱出澎湃的情感，真開心老師也被擊中了。

[@yaphh6769]

如果你看了這部戲，再聽這首歌。你會哭得很慘😢

[@erickson8329]

這首歌在劇裡一出來配合劇情⋯完全擋不住的哭爛啊(;´༎ຶД༎ຶ`)

[@reikei9783]

我好喜欢老师听到喜欢的歌曲之后的样子，好可爱呀

[@lovejylovej2292]

Eason跟其他香港歌手就不在一個層次 別人還在音準音高技巧上衡量時, 只有他在真正理解歌曲想要傳達的溫度及內容

[@BGeorsky]

天啊 這首我在看的時候馬上搜尋🔍愛到不行，陳奕迅又超越了自己

[@Iasbeyl]

對這首歌的觸動與喜愛，是即使一直暫停下來解析他繼續播放，還是會被每個段落感動且雞皮疙瘩

[@ShellyY.]

我不行了再去哭一場(;´༎ຶД༎ຶ`)

[@HihiC-k1y]

Hongkongese Super Star! ⭐️

[@funingyang]

這首歌我聽第一次就喜歡上了，旋律太美

[@nerost9819]

Eason先係香港頂流

[@mcdullpork8775]

肯把music video 也納入評價範圍內算好事。與其看嚴重修音的所謂live然後花所有時間評論修沒修音，倒不如偶爾看看MV把討論都回歸到歌曲本身，而且也能聽新一點的歌。 Eason的演繹無話可說，天花板級別。不建議其他歌手輕易自我挑戰唱cover，可知唱得到音並不代表就唱得出這個vibe…

[@91PowerCart]

再不能認同的觀點，唱得到那個音，不代表真正唱得到👍🏻

[@Theo-zb2fe]

希望點評eason fear and dreams系列🙏🏻🙏🏻

[@Whatever0123able]

I think Eason is not only a good singer, but a good actor too.

[@mimiwu_]

@@Whatever0123able 他演戏真的可以的，演什么像什么

[@onesmile.penana]

很多奧術的影迷不喜歡這首中文歌突兀的出現在故事中 但我覺得正是這首歌賦予了角色靈魂 當時會哭也是因為這首歌，不僅僅是劇情 所以，我很高興有人對這首歌做出解析 因為太多人在咒罵這首中文歌了 這本身是很糟糕的 歌曲沒有錯，中文也沒有錯，請看過奧術、講中文的華人給自己的語言更多認同感 這首歌非常有格調的

[@llXiNrAll]

@onesmilekado I hate this song because it reminds me of the scene. It fits the story and the emotion behind it so much, especially with Eason's voice. It's a beautiful song.

[@onesmile.penana]

@@llXiNrAll The storyline is indeed heartbreaking, but everything will pass. Of course, if you’ve watched Attack on Titan (AOT), you might have noticed that many fans recreate scenes where characters who have died are portrayed as “acting” out their death scenes. Using green screens and composited visuals, they humorously have the characters perform their deaths again. So, if you look at it from a different perspective, perhaps you won’t feel as sad.

[@MT-ub7eg]

Story teller ❤

[@leesamuel3194]

Eason really a super signer

[@Hahnck750i]

Now that you have heard the song i strongly urge you to watch arcane. Having watch the last episode of act 2 season 2. Listening to this song always gives me flashbacks and makes me want to cry

[@ColinPoole]

Seconded

[@freestyle11051]

做雖千萬人也要盛開的孤芳 As one among millons, still must blossom into a solitary and splendid flower. 歌詞直譯了 孤獨且絢麗的花朵 但孤芳不只是孤芳，它更深的含意是高潔絕俗的品格、與眾不同的獨特見解帶有人品高潔絕俗或懷才不遇的意思

[@Tesutino]

沒辦法，中文的意境不是三言兩語可以表達的😂

[@freestyle11051]

對的，我只是想告訴橘老師，為什麼她會無法理解那三句，因為中文有很多引申的含義👍

[@Rebuswind]

😭no, still can't listen to it without crying.

[@Mad_Titan_Paresh]

You and 6 million others

[@ch5116]

喜歡抒情歌的我的感覺，這一首更勝孤勇者，是我可以反覆播放一直沉浸其中的歌，看完整部動畫尤其第6集片尾搭配這整首歌曲的片段時，我真的淚崩，建議老師沒時間看整部動畫沒關係，只要看第6集，到最後這一段的時候，搭配這首歌的曲跟詞，那是更加讓人動容的時刻🥲

[@刘撰卿]

15:50 he is also widely known as an actor with gift

[@綠綠仙人掌]

直接讓我想到老師應該超愛這首「言不由衷」❤ 徐佳瑩 艾怡良寫的這首

[@JoeChanTV]

16:30 不是你情商低而是 this part was CGI where he turned from older version of himself to a slightly more refined version of himself, that's part of the cinematography - it‘s a build up for the lyric "在我们还是孩子的模样“

[@unimusx4893]

ARCANE es simplemente arte es la representación de cuando se hace algo con amor

[@MT-ub7eg]

Now she’s appreciating lyrics while listening to the song hahahah

[@Razorwindsg]

You are going to cry once you watch the story for real...

[@christina76454]

终于有人讲到这首歌的大调小调的转换了，这首歌真的很适合isha和jinx的关系

[@toram6210]

u got to finish the anime then listen to this again!

[@-takumaku-5209]

我们这边有句网络热词：男人致死都是少年，Eeson拍过电影应该受到过或者主动学习过演艺，所以mv的戏剧效果演绎得很入戏的。然后第一次副歌前是现在的去寻找初衷的感觉，第二次是追寻到不再迷惘，最后变成少年时初生牛犊不怕虎的感觉。这歌我正想挑战一下，我喜欢ktv但我没受到系统化的音乐教育和锻炼，但又牙痒哈哈哈哈。这支歌就是有这种魔力，听一次就能抓住人心，记得之前疯狂动物城的try everything也是这种感觉。

[@-takumaku-5209]

男人直至死都是少年，打错一个字了，怕误解。哈哈哈。

[@-takumaku-5209]

还有的是最后少年的样子大概是用Eason小时候的照片AI做的。再看看我连偶像的名字都打错了，该死的。

[@Chavi27]

It´s cute, how clueless she is about the scene where it was played. Would love to see her reaction - hope you guys showed it to her after

[@snowice1942]

可以去看這樣很好的製作花絮！有錄音過程⋯而且mv裡面的小孩真的有演員😂

[@leon5120]

视频中采用了Deepfake换脸技术模拟了Eason逐渐变年轻的样子，同时也对应了那句歌词“在我们还是孩子的模样”

[@q0w0p-WywyWayne]

這應該是Isha對Jinx臨別的叮囑吧 Jinx 一路上走得孤獨和黑暗兼瘋狂，而 Isha是jinx是難得獲得的光明 卻短暫的擁有就失去

[@rexyu1546]

Just to comment a few lines to let Ms Rozette and the team understand more about the lyrics/ the theme of this song. Altho this song is named Isha's song, I personally think it is a song sung by Isha towards Jinx. So the msg is actually all told to Jinx, who is the main character of this story. To those who didn't know anything about Arcane, Jinx was in season 1, accidentally ruined and destroyed everything surrounds her. Everything was not done intentionally. But she was just making stuff a mess and eventually, destroys her sister, her dad, her step-dad, her family, her city and even the whole country. Deep in her heart she was actually a really good girl who tries to protect everything and behave well. But accidentally, she just jinx everything in the story and became a "destroyer" in others' point of view, even in her sister's. The only one who understands her is Silco, her step-dad, who at the end was killed by Jinx herself, ofc again not intensionally. But in season 2, things seemed to change. Jinx made her determination to recover and protect everything. At the beginning of the season she is actually self-complaining all the time. Thinking herself as a monster and blames everything to herself. But then Isha comes to her life and changes her. When the story goes on, finally she sees hope that she can recover every mistakes she has made, for her family, for her country and for her "people". She eventually becomes the leader of her country and the deciding factor to reunite her family. And all these was brought by Isha, a little girl that Jinx saves and adopts as her little sister. She first time found warmth and cosiness from this little girla and wants to form a family with her. And when Jinx is struggling to make difficult choices, or feeling inconfident in herself when leading her people, Isha is always the one that supports and pushes her forward. "Isha" is Jinx's new "Hope". And for this song, "Isha's song", was played in the series in a really important scene related to this kind and cute little girl. Not gonna spoil here haha. And that's why I think the msg here is actually delivering to Jinx by Isha, from Isha's point of view. Isha understands what Jinx has been suffering in her past, and is the one and only perosn in the world that understands JInx, after Silco is dead. To her, Jinx is her hero. She saved her and gave her a family. But meanwhile, Isha is Jinx's new hope. A new hope to give herself a new life and second chance. And this song, for my interpretation, is actually Isha telling Jinx that she is actually not as terrible as she thinks herself. And Isha is trying her best to comfort Jinx, bringing her hope to take a leap forward, and to change herself.

[@llXiNrAll]

❤

[@edddddddy6158]

😭在戲裡這首歌出現的時候，哭爆

[@영차-j9v]

It was nice because it was a song in a language I couldn't understand. It was like a story of Isha that I couldn't hear at the end.

[@瓜樂]

老師真的可以看看奧術第一、二季 裡面音樂歌曲都很讚

[@jiajuntu817]

Can’t agree more 🥹🥹🥹

[@AzNightmare]

*Did you guys watch season 2 yet? This song comes on at a very significant moment.*

[@ThingOneTwoThree1]

I am glad you guys like this!

[@Madthund]

可以react一下 陳奕迅跟孫楠多年前對唱那一場嗎？

[@freestyle11051]

孤勇者>>>>朗朗上口(我哥小孩都會) 這樣很好>>>>>氣勢恢弘(需要點人生經歷才唱得好)

[@jasonc9196]

yay eason

[@leestefan2999]

The frustration he portrayed in his expression and singing during the climax of the song summed up very well the feeling I had trying to teach my lil girl her most feared math... 😂

[@-mrt9598]

敲碗 Gabriel Henrique! : I wanna know what love is and Vision of Love!!!

[@kongwilson88]

go watch 《這樣很好》製作花絮 | 陳奕迅 Eason Chan [Making Of]

[@nuoChang]

再為Isha 哭一次

[@MAX-sh6zs]

看完奧術2再回來聽一次，會有不一樣的感覺的

[@Billy-he7hs]

you should review Eason's live concert in 2000..

[@ZtoEnd]

其實他是慢慢變回年輕的摸樣❤

[@烤魷魚-p5h]

對 我多聽幾次也發現他慢慢變年輕 最後變一個小孩

[@YellowBeetle92]

這首歌一定要搭配第六集一起看！😭

[@seanchang217]

Would love to see you guys do blood sweat and tears from arcane 2 sound track. Singer has a deep and gritty voice that I think you guys will enjoy!

[@超冷-h9m]

小時候以為陳奕迅都在唱口水歌 直到跟同學去KTV點了十年 唱成十天

[@Empanada-21_06]

No me hagan llorar de nuevo 😢

[@jacky710812]

這首好聽，希望講評韓國歌手鄭恩地真的厲害，是老師會喜歡的聲音😂😂😂

[@zaylau3025]

this would be my first comment on the entire KZbin -- but what you have discussed the 'difficult' part is not really that hard IMO, Eason just applied the 'Eason's magic' that made the rest of the song 'sounded' less difficult, but those emotional and storytelling parts... try get any other random performer, 99% of them will fail hard for the whole performance, trust me this song got no easy line

[@ryanso6162]

其實這首歌更像Isha對Jinx的最後的鼓勵，而不是Isha本人

[@q0w0p-WywyWayne]

對 這是Isha送給Jinx 的歌才對

[@allanwang9039]

满意，我还挺喜欢他们理解歌词的

[@jeffy6738]

呢啲先係頂流㗎嘛

[@Tesutino]

在陳奕迅身上展現的無非就「純粹」二字

[@chuwild2830]

希望可以憑一下（黑夜問白天）林俊傑跟胡彥斌的版本，謝謝❤

[@Caoderrick]

跟着老师读过整个歌词，才发现这是Isha送给Jinx的一首歌，如果她可以歌唱的话。

[@williammy12]

你們看了第二季第六集之後會有不一樣的感受

[@yosepyo.z9905]

Who in their right mind enjoys music by pausing every 3 seconds

[@nathanielfoo96]

Could you review the female cover by 真栗Makuri

[@arianekeithvlog]

Hello ! I'm from philippines..please do react to KZ Tandingan Rolling in the deep in china. Thank you

[@chiang730530]

來一集英雄聯盟S1-S12主題曲巡迴吧 尤其英文選曲很猛的

[@hohoho._.]

Can you guys react to dingo music MeloMance live one , the man who sing look so easy and would love to hear what you guys think 🥸

[@sukiodj]

可以點評「望月」1995年Eason比賽時 vs 2023年 FND演唱會安可版嗎？ kzbin.info/www/bejne/sKvRhpmjrLeXjZYsi=MxaydGdaz41fujwl

[@ETHANCHAN53]

可以點平 全世界失眠 這首歌嗎，最近有live表演，唱法很相似

[@athomenotavailable]

If you're reacting to MVs too, then 永夜by 谭维维or the song composer is unmissable! Once of the most memorable and difficult songs to sing live, because it's impossible to find any live covers anywhere. m.kzbin.info/www/bejne/j3qxaaGOmNqtfKs&pp=ygUG5rC45aSc And also 人世间， if JKai doesn't cry from listening to this, I'll eat my hat.

[@chitai9317]

为什么我加入会员好几个月了，但是有些会员影片还是不能看？

[@robbielee4984]

幾時review Eason 與我常在 live? kzbin.info/www/bejne/h6Smo5h6jsSXibssi=kk4IQ1FayrpATOfk

[@FunGwoSiuMai]

Love this version ❤

[@KiyaLin-f7v]

不止這首，我覺得DUO的整場每首歌都很適合評論，那場演唱會Eason喉嚨啞了，但整個都處在一種很神的狀態，我覺得Eason自己都複製不了當時的狀態~

[@jacfung962]

@@robbielee4984 敲碗

[@chunsingko4160]

希望點評一下側田 悲中帶喜

[@bjacksd1055]

i can't take it when she pause the music every 3 sec

[@Amy3419]

求老師點評 艾薇Ivy Lee

[@Antler69]

可以請也老師評論Eason的人啊人嗎？個人覺得這首是Eason近年最巔峰的演繹 kzbin.info/www/bejne/hYSmfaB8fKmrqqcsi=AgbR2Zypo7lAnBiY

[@yuetah6210]

@@Antler69應同，係演唱會現埸聽，好特別的一首歌，好似靈魂出竅，好正

[@Antler69]

@yuetah6210 知音🤝

[@lucks0204]

@@Antler69 這首live強的誇張，有種鬼魅感

[@Antler69]

@@lucks0204 把這個就要頂上去希望可以被老師注意到。這個版本真的太強…

[@adrianbeslada6474]

Do hear that marcelito pomoy Title song (THE PRAYER)

[@lancelin9634]

Zhou Shen: Rubia

[@ayrtonsenna6399]

Pqp num calaboca hahahaha

[@leeantoni2184]

最後橘老師唱歌好像忘了放聲音，呵呵

[@strawberrycrackertaiwan]

最後老師的示範沒有聲音的?

[@gobieric]

but this isn't live performance!

[@AngeloSu]

橘老師應該看一下「這樣很好」這首歌的實際錄製現場 kzbin.info/www/bejne/nGnQhHyDnM6WoMUsi=iYin5Txb_y8bR-T9

[@李柏葳-t7c]

個人對於中文歌曲會這麼抓耳的感想是中文的抑揚頓挫，不管是在古人的詩中、民謠歌曲、甚至是講故事，中文都很強調抑揚頓挫。不過這也算是文化的一種就是了

[@mountain_33]

請問最後老師唱歌沒有聲音是我的問題還是真的沒有聲音...?0.0

[@uu-vm8xe]

個人覺得這樣很好比孤勇者更有技巧一點，旋律也更打動我，可能是孤勇者真的是被唱到爛大街讓我沒什麼fu吧😂

[@arecus_owk]

23:18 好听到中版权也是一种认可 xD

[@honylike4740]

想看評價 庾澄慶 （🙏）