國外聲樂老師點評王力宏《Forever Love》 Vocal Coach Reacts to The Evolution of Leehom｜

[@JenOng-x9e]

He sounded English because he is an American He is one of those artistes that brought Mandarin songs in more western singing style to Asia in the late 1990s or early 2000s A singer-songwriter, actor, producer, and film director. Formally trained at Eastman School of Music, Williams College and Berklee College of Music, his music is known for fusing hip-hop and R&B, with traditional Chinese music

[@iantsai2514]

Yes

[@fennlynn7675]

She makes herself sound so dumb in this critique 😂😂

[@lingt9959]

可惡王力宏真的好帥！！

[@GW-oz9sf]

真的帥！王力宏、陶喆、周杰倫、林俊傑，一定是王力宏最帥

[@kevinguo1164]

@@GW-oz9sf 說真的…這四個如果純論顏值… 後三個歌王根本不夠王力宏打… 王力宏即使現在的年紀…也跟他最巔峰時沒差多少！ 陶喆嘛歲月痕跡太明顯加上過氣... . 周嘛…個人覺得單純發福太嚴重，跟阿妹一樣，哈哈 JJ嘛…嗯…說實在的，從來也沒帥過？ 應該說…他的優越條件不在於顏值上面！ 當然，這四個都是我很喜歡的歌手！ 甚至有時候因為歌曲傳唱度太高… 不認識都被歌曲洗到認識！哈哈

[@GW-oz9sf]

@@kevinguo1164 只希望王力宏好好愛惜自己名聲，不要惹太多事情🤣

[@kevinguo1164]

@@GW-oz9sf 真的…你說的四個裡面… 我也最喜歡王力宏，也幾乎每首歌都會唱… 能好好的再出來唱歌出專輯就好了！

[@HYananan]

王力宏太多神級現場了 2006蓋世英雄 心中的日月 花田錯 在梅邊 2008music man 愛錯 花田錯 你不在 forever love 落葉歸根 2014福利秀 心跳 2019福利秀 你不知道的事 唯一 shallow you raise me up 2019中國好聲音 緣分一道橋 2021跨年 火力全開 從早期機能巔峰到後期唱功魔攻大成 很值得深入分析的現場實力派歌手

[@PangNiBear]

突然很想聽老師評價動力火車

[@annew5380]

yes!!!!

[@ariel84tsai]

我也超想看老師評老爺們的現場演唱！！！

[@phuanicky2217]

我想听曹格😂

[@wokwithjosh1473]

我刚也这么想！

[@tiffanyhun472]

好久没听了，再听还是鸡皮疙瘩，想哭，激动。

[@KaiNg-yf1ud]

When I hear he said “ 台北的朋友，我太愛你們啦！‘’. His ABC accent speaking of Chinese is so strong, his first language is English for sure.

[@Vbssss3]

His free show in 2019 “Shallow” performance was amazing

[@princessmongolian9985]

Can’t wait! Really love his talent!👍🥰

[@han-fk9gh]

老師的聽力還有對發音的概念真的超級敏銳 王力宏就是美國人，所以他的確是英文母語的人在唱中文歌XD

[@bravo189226]

可惜畫外人不太想說他是美國人，應該說不太想贊同這個論點，但我覺得都沒有誰錯誰隊

[@ASDFBRANDON]

@@bravo189226 我覺得是他不知道XD

[@__yang9223]

@@ASDFBRANDON 我也覺得是他不知道

[@一叶知秋-v6i]

@@bravo189226 有许多华语歌手是欧美或者东南亚国籍的，小时候也不清楚，都只听歌好不好听，没有去关注这些

[@iantsai2514]

​@bqravo189226 他應該是不知道

[@jasonjosh170]

He was born in Rochester City, New York. He's a New Yorker. English is his native language. Though his parents were immigrants from Taiwan, he only started learning Mandarin Chinese in college (William's college). So Mandarin is more like a second or foreign language to him. Being ethnic Taiwanese (Chinese) doesn't mean that he is or has to be a Native Chinese speaker. He grew up in the States. He was a monolingual person before taking Mandarin Chinese lessons (an additional language) in Williams College (university). Till this very day, he's still practising Mandarin. It's tough for him.

[@hellojennifer520]

Mandrian Chinese? Taiwanese Chinese? What?! 😅

[@dishiuan9022]

老師分析真好：）王力宏就是很迎合市場的唱法

[@benboy8098]

5:49 of course = 老娘知道 XDDD我笑死

[@snoopy10570s]

希望有機會可以評一下 2019 FREE SHOW 王力宏翻唱的Shallow

[@小資當沖白話文-實戰]

這個作者偏愛林俊傑+周深，難喔

[@RB-zk2vo]

王力宏這個現場太棒了

[@Dz-yd6zb]

最後一段很棒 People always believe the best period of music is the one they grew up with

[@daygood9292]

库存真充足呀❤

[@kwoo24]

This is not the first time Rozette talks about LeeHom's first language, I wonder why Jkai never explains. I thought everyone knows: LeeHom's first language is English. He's born and raised in New York. He's American. When he debuted in Taiwan, his Mandarin wasn't very fluent, with very strong ABC accent. Eventually his Mandarin got better though.

[@brendachan2629]

@@kwoo24 Agreed, I wondered why the host didn’t explain it to Rozette too. It’s a common known fact that Leehom grew up in the States and his first language has always been English. Should have done better preparation and give more correct information.

[@kwoo24]

@@brendachan2629 Yea. And the thing is, this doesn't even need any preparation or research. As you said, this is a known fact. Everyone who knows LeeHom definitely knows that he's born and raised in the states. Especially those who listened to LeeHom's music throughout the 90s, which I'm sure Jkai did, given his age and those other singers he listened to (from the same period). And strangely... when Jkai is uncertain about something, he would usually just Google it up on the spot and get an answer. But only for this topic about LeeHom's first language that they discussed several times, Jkai just never seemed to care much...

[@brendachan2629]

@@kwoo24Exactly, and without this critical information, Rozette cannot comment accurately, which I think lowered the professionalism of the video. Also, JKai’s comment about Leehom wrote his songs & lyrics in a certain way, so he sounds more Westernized - I have doubts about it. To me, it’s more his ABC accent that makes his sounds Westernized. Give Leehom’s songs to any native-tongue Chinese singers to sing it, I’m sure the word pronunciation won’t sound the way like Leehom does, just as Rozette has pointed out about the words “愛你” (ai nei). She has very professional ears even though she’s a foreigner, just wish she was and will be given the correct information.

[@kwoo24]

@@brendachan2629 Agreed. And also, let's not forget that LeeHom doesn't really write all of his lyrics. Most of his songs were co-written with some other professional lyricists. Because his Chinese proficiency wasn't that good...

[@chongeddiehwajie82]

Exactly

[@雞雞-s8v]

不是阿兄弟，這也等太久了吧~

[@Benbbg]

还是很支持王力宏💪👍

[@zengjun2249]

he is the best,super star

[@tiffanyhun472]

He is an ABC!!! I couldn’t help to say it despite knowing many comments said it. I wish there’s a way Rozette can know 😂

[@hellojennifer520]

Lee hom grew up in the states. So maybe that's why when he sings it sounds like he is singing in English. Btw 😊

[@韓逸洋]

等太久了

[@陳威志-b5x]

應該聽一下王力宏的地獄級那首 愛錯😂

[@CK-gd3lb]

Take care, Rozette. Please review Lee Hom’s and watch the original MV. You are gonna fall in love with him! Then . Note: Lee Hom made his debut album in 1995, while NYSC made theirs in 1997, and Justin Timberlake made his at 2002.

[@spiritualgirl02]

Love his voice

[@Jessica-n9j7n]

每次都好短不夠看，希望EP5趕快出來...

[@henryzk-ve3ks]

真帅啊😂

[@TChin0000]

很喜欢看rozette老师的评语， 但是真的希望身边的人可以做好功课，不需要太多，至少背景,原唱这些必须做好。 每次看到rozette老师的疑问，他们都答不出. 不过overall影片我很喜欢. 加油！

[@A粒에리]

橘子老師一直感覺力宏的發音他更能學會 很合理.. 因為但對於我們來說(中文母語者) 力宏的發音其實就是帶有點ABC腔調的人... 而且力宏就是英文母語者....

[@lambluemei8635]

08年的musicman演唱会是他声音的巅峰，之后就开始现场走音，但他还是我心目中的王力宏，加油哥！

[@cyclopsjiang1271]

那是因为他改变了唱法，现在唱功更牛了

[@iankobe24]

敲碗動力火車！

[@mingwen523]

讓老師聽一下動力火車 啦

[@pennyblossoms]

Please do more Lee Hom!!

[@hellojennifer520]

I also think his Mandrian also sounds different because his pronunciation in more influenced by Taiwan.

[@ting-a-ling7383]

his first language is English

[@frankbird19790925]

看着老师正常说话说中文时不由自主会拐音，但是开口唱起来时字正腔圆的普通话，这种感觉太奇妙了

[@dwmobusa]

因为唱歌的时候声调这个东西被音高的变化取代了呀

[@Mina-el7lj]

希望可以聽到老師點評鄧麗君 我媽媽最喜歡的歌手

[@JoePan-mq5sw]

王力宏是New Yorker啊.....ABC跟外國人說中文的語感是不一樣的，杰凱應該能夠很好的跟橘解釋裡面的差別

[@LIUSANG1]

I am pretty sure leehom is born and raised in the USA and a native English speaker. He speaks Chinese with huge abc accent.

[@hellojennifer520]

Mandrian not Chinese. Btw

[@陳跡-n9s]

想聽老師評價台語歌手 如江蕙或黃乙玲之類的

[@TFB-t6d]

是不是他發音比較像台灣口音（但他國外長大，是ABC口音）之前Alin老師也說很不像他平常聽中國歌手唱的中文

[@sipayuexue]

一個國外老師評價我覺得都自己了解王力宏老師來真實點

[@banbbc2921]

Leehom born and raise in New York. His first language is English not Chinese, of course he might have a bit of immigrant accent. But I remember in late 90 when I heard his interview, his Chinese was really terrible. Even LeeHom is ethnic Chinese doesn’t mean his first language is Chinese. Not too sure why Jack didn’t correct it, but he is a bit patriotic though :)

[@hellojennifer520]

Chinese is not a language. Mandrian is. Btw He is from Taiwan not China. Lol

[@ashaj7095]

@@hellojennifer520 No such language of mandrian. Taiwan official name is Republic of CHINA except to separatists

[@hellojennifer520]

@@ashaj7095 Mandrian is a language! Have you been living under a rock all these year? Haha...

[@ashaj7095]

@@hellojennifer520 There’s Mandarin, but no Mandrian language exists!

[@hellojennifer520]

@@ashaj7095 You are a hypocrite! Lol

[@JINGWU-p4o]

啥气候re一下王力宏21年的福利秀，刚觉是唱功进化的巅峰

[@Gipppp]

其實老師是不是想說王力宏的ABC腔讓他的歌聲很有個人特色？

[@TSENG666]

簽到影片下方給你們點個讚👍 遇廣告看完看🈵

[@三文鱼鱼-l5d]

叫老师点评一下王力宏的 唯一 ，，，谢谢你

[@kai4748]

平井堅

[@hom3r]

Yes agree

[@ceewayson2266]

I watched a couple of these videos, and i feel that sometimes the hosts should have done some basic background research on the singers that they are comparing so they can effectively answer rozette's answers or comments. It is common knowledge that leehom grew up in the states...

[@teateagogogo]

王力宏的影片都太短啦，聽不夠😊

[@奕廷林-m9o]

更期待shollow 的影片了😂

[@Thomas-freedom]

希望老师可以评一下李安的《逝去的爱》

[@安德魯-y9y]

05.49秒(老娘知道!) very funny~hahahahaha

[@5Yea]

12:30 到 13:14 被消音了QQ

[@lan7510]

那個最high的部分T.T

[@A粒에리]

想許願老師聽 "家家"

[@okwapno]

Shallow

[@xianglilee3686]

希望能评论曹格的歌~~

[@GW-oz9sf]

曹格+1

[@chenille2765]

Is it possible to make a full review of his 2008 music man concert. That one is really amazing from my point of view.

[@CharlesRama-f6n]

React to the Land of the greatest singers Philippines

[@von5699]

Hi CZ Media! I hope you could react to Big Mama Dingo Killing Voice! You will love them! Thanks in advance!

[@Shin-s5c]

10:44 你說一下 你感動的眼睛 喔SHIT WHAT 笑爛

[@raylee9642]

怎么我找不到EP3 就有EP4了？

[@ssteven8316]

7月15 ep3

[@Chiillo]

我也搜尋不到

[@libbywang6344]

老师很厉害～ 因为力宏是abc他的发音肯定会👐英文的影响

[@louisian988]

Hi, i hope you can review another singer called Ronald Cheng (鄭中基）. He is dubbed as Jacky Cheung no.2.

[@powei413]

印象中看過有次王力宏上綜藝節目，好像是張菲的節目 他的字卡裡面全是拼音，沒半個中文字 當時好像才剛出道的樣子

[@mingyuwang-kd1xc]

周身的解密现场版也挺棒的，希望能看到橘子老师解读一下。

[@user-fh395hn3s4]

You can hear from his speaking Mandarin. His pronunciation shows strong influence from English. I dare to say his native language is English not Chinses

[@小楼一夜听春雨12]

点评一下杨宗纬吧！！！！❤

[@aprilann6421]

His mother tongue is English.

[@jtwotoefl43]

敲碗動力火車🚞～～～

[@michaelyip6904]

Lee hom’s Chinese still has an English accent

[@levis501tw]

他的歌對大多數男生來說，也是很難唱的，因為音域蠻高的 而且他唱得有厚度跟力道又平穩，並且有很多唱出氛圍的細微處理，少了這些細微的處理及口音，是無法唱出他唱的那種浪漫的氛圍的。他是少數偶像與實力兼具的歌星。

[@ariel84tsai]

敲碗動力火車！火車！火車！power station

[@victorlin6310]

Hi, able to review some Aska Yang Songs ?

[@StephLai-z8r]

please let rozette review justin lo 側田 please please please

[@kohkhongshien8787]

I thought because he is a banana to start with? Am i wrong?

[@許溢凱]

等待周杰倫第三集中

[@charlessit7816]

an simple example explained why you think his mandarin is easier for you to learn. its just like an English speaker try to learn mandarin, most likely that will use like "she" to pronounce "是" but then Jkai he pronounce the word just using the mandarin way, i mean bpmf way.

[@yiojinxian]

It’s because he’s American born Chinese.

[@alexsiu1280]

怎麼還沒有曹格的？！

[@GW-oz9sf]

好想聽曹格+1

[@lan7510]

感覺會考慮到中文用字的部分是因為……他自己中文不好啊…… 但反正他有很多歌，淺顯易懂但好聽啊～

[@limcc4520]

想看老师点评 羽泉 live 表演的 离歌

[@Dennisterry]

學音樂的孩子不會變壞

[@mormorteh]

但会骗女孩

[@theodoresiu266]

@@mormorteh自願白給而已 🙄🙄

[@mormorteh]

@@theodoresiu266 我说学音乐的孩子，我没说王力宏。

[@Wilson_Chin]

Try listen Shila Amzah do this song :D

[@Dk_Bat]

5:46 because he is an American...

[@nancechao4980]

His first language is actually English not Chinese

[@hjzzzhou]

Re歌手巔峰會

[@yasianglo9162]

I don,t understand. Leehom he is an American, why Jay not tell she.😡

[@raylee9642]

其实Jkai不解释的最主要原因是因为他说过就是要让老师在什么都不知道的情况下做reaction才最真实吧，就老师过后才发现原来她猜错误了也很好玩不是吗。

[@chriztation]

敲碗動力火車

[@小甄-y2u]

怎麼都沒給老師聽聽楊宗緯呢～想看老師評價楊宗緯的歌聲

[@suen54]

可以做一些方言的歌曲嗎？ 想看看老師對不同語言的感覺

[@snoope.snoope]

有做過廣東話

[@reikei9783]

其实每次老师都是挺好几首歌的但是播出来只有一部分，然后中间又换几期别人，我们跟不上老师的感受了。前后时间顺序不对，所以在评论时会出现一些误会。

[@willischeng]

期待有機會評力宏的shallow live，簡直是教科書級數

[@hsunli7635]

3呢😮

[@ssteven8316]

7/15

[@khooelton3625]

等着黄妈的我的美丽点评

[@遇上方知有]

什么时候当初

[@jiongshen]

太短了

[@rogerrabbit5110]

It would have been beneficial if it was explained to coach that Leehom speaks English as his first language. I wonder why this was glossed over? This is a common known fact about Leehom, or at least it is something that can be found very easily through basic research.