Pistol or Revolver? Auto or Wheelgun?

Let's take a look at this age old question!

[@chrissidwell9455]

You know, I heard a guy or two running down this " old guy" who thinks he know something about guns. But I find that that "old guy" , has taught me more truthful things about guns than all those young morons put together. Thanks for all the videos you do, your opinion comes from experience from actual gun smiting, shooting, reloading, hunting, ect. Most other people on the internet today couldn't figure out how to pour piss out of a boot with the instructions written on the heel. Your videos come from actually doing the craft over years n years and it shows. Thanks again, " old guy" , and keep up the good work.

[@russelder9743]

Amen

[@lets-allplay]

I believe I seen that video as well.. a few 1911 "guys".. The only thing I can say about that is how GunBlue490 has graciously shared his knowledge, which is backed up by years of professionalism and experience, all without ever trying to sell me a single item. While I appreciate everyone who is willing to teach and share, I personally know who I would rather throw my hat in with. Just my 2c's

[@SARoberts88]

An “old guy” who speaks with authority on a subject that he has devoted most of his adult life to.

[@boomdawg56]

When I was small, maybe 4, a relative came for a visit, he had a trunk full of surplus 1911s covered in cosmoline and paper. I wanted to get my hands on one of those .45s so badly, the older boys got to shoot a couple rounds, he then pulled out a Bearcat .22, "Here is something you can shoot", then he sat on the ground and taught me to load and shoot that little revolver that actually fit my hand, and I shot a box of 50 .22 shells at cattails and dragon flies. I don't remember hitting anything but it sure was fun and marked me as a revolver guy for life. And it marked him as my favorite relative. I love my autos but nothing feels more natural in my hand than a good revolver.

[@CADMike]

I love it when he says he’s not into train tracks all over his gun. He doesn’t want his gun looking like a train set lol. That’s gold.

[@mgf001]

From here on im gonna call picatinny rails road rails

[@Dcm193]

Take a low light class

[@wildweasel6898]

I watch these videos because my grandfather is gone but the same knowledge he gave me is available here. On top of that gunblue has lead me towards Christ. This is the most valuable channel I've ever seen. God bless you brother. Thank you for your time and knowledge.

[@oldcop18]

My career started in ‘68 when revolvers ruled. My issued .38 saved me more than once in 30 years to include having to reload a Colt DS in the midst of a 1974 protracted gunfight w/armed robbery suspects. We transitioned to the Glock in the ‘80s & I was glad to have it due to its increased ammo capacity. I’m in my mid 70s, walk w/a cane so a J Frame is perfect for my needs. As an aside I agree w/you about putting a bunch of tech stuff on the gun in hopes of becoming a better shot. My guns have none of that, I shoot them the way they come from the factory. The only exception is oversize grips on a revolver to accommodate my XLG hands.

[@amtrakjohn]

OC. Thank you for your Service. Glad u made it safely to your Pension. I also like the small J frames, like the Mod 49.

[@DomoArigatoRobot0]

Thank you, glad you made it here to comment.

[@russelder9743]

Old Cop---thanks for standing on the wall....30 yrs God Bless you...I am also 70 and walk with a cane ( live very rural Mts upstate NY ) and also pocket carry a S&W J frame....hang tough stay safe

[@BirdDogey1]

Almost the same boat. Every now and then I think about selling one of my J frames for the new and shiny. Just can't do it.

[@sean0181]

@@russelder9743 I visit ny every summer to visit my daughter she is a nurse and lives in belleville,ny,We were on lake bonaparte last summer loved it ,of course i had to leave my carry gun back home in Pa.

[@jamesgray2955]

I own and enjoy both, but as I grow older, I grow fonder of my wheel guns.

[@markmcdonald5711]

Get your Old Fudd Club card.

[@bluzharpin20]

Me too...

[@fredgaf]

SW 38 Special +p revolver for me. Add some hollow points, and I have all the safe, simple, reliable, rugged home defense needed. Bad dude catches on of those, and it's lights out. GunBlue: THANK YOU for your informative videos, I'm learning lots from you!

[@jetfu400]

"people take more on emotional significance vs realistic one" this guy is spitting facts!! love him already

[@markrutledge-docmark41]

As a long-time lover of the .41 Magnum revolver, it's a breath of fresh air to listen to this educated, and experienced Gentleman discuss these topics in a reasoned, and informed manner! One problem with the "social media" is that we are stuck with a huge mess of "arm chair experts", who have very little experience, and even less in-depth knowledge! Thank you, GunBlue490, for having "been there, done that", and are kindly sharing your experiences with those of us who value what you have to say, Good Sir! Take care, and God Bless! - Doc PS - Listening to your discussion put me in mind of reading the wise words of Elmer Keith, or Skeeter Skelton, the sages of yesteryear! Please keep it coming!

[@navchaps3449]

Love your clarity. You are a natural teacher. This discussion helped push me over the edge. I've decided to get my first revolver. Happy New Year!

[@Monestary_Warrior]

You won’t regret it!

[@DC632A]

you will love it

[@samadams9557]

Congratulations. Revolvers just have a timeless feel to them. They’re sexy.

[@Zona-dw9rp]

What revolver did you get?

[@navchaps3449]

@@Zona-dw9rp my son-in-law is gifting me a Smith and Wesson, 686. he's a good boy.

[@ryannafe9252]

Both designs have their strong points, that’s why they’re both still around. Solid video. 👍

[@normanmallory2055]

In 57 years now I’ve never had any concerns with my revolvers, the function all the time every time ! I use speed loaders and the concept is fine and it works well ! Good information! Autoloaders are a different breed all their own I agree!!

[@tommoyer3302]

I prefer a revolver , don't need to pick up the brass off the ground

[@algoneby]

very good video. The wheel gun won't ever fade away, for those who are in the know. I love my revolvers, and am not really in love with the plastic wonders. i like em both, but with a choice, I'd pick a revolver.

[@intj2948]

I’ll take the revolver for conceal carry. Reliability & simplicity are important.

[@wizardofahhhs759]

It's extremely difficult to find an unreliable auto these days.

[@marsonofjo344]

Civilians don't consider keeping a fully loaded mag for years. It weakens the spring. In contrast, a fully loaded revolver has no such problem.

[@comlbbeau]

Years ago I gave my wife (5' 3") a Rossi 5-shot .38 special. She subsequently enrolled in our local sheriff's department civilian firearms course, which included a couple of night's classroom instruction, a session in the shoot-don't shoot simulator, and an afternoon range session. To my surprise, at the range session the safety officer saw her revolver and discouraged her from using it, providing her his department issued Glock 26 instead. She ultimately decided on a Springfield XD-9 subcompact that fit her hands better. Go figure.

[@SuperAriel35]

I own both . The Glock 26 is a great little semi auto pistol. But I very fond of smith and Wesson model 638-3 5 shot revolver. Iam a wheel gun fan but I also own semi auto too . There something of my wheel gun that I just love plus the comfort

[@PYRO200055412]

What a beautiful home and inner/outer ambiance. Merry Christmas and Happy New Year Sir.

[@timothysuddath3852]

Thank you for using the term "auto loader". They are NOT semi-auto. If your auto loading gun is "semi" auto, it is broken. Fire a round it automatically loads a new round to battery. How it fires is the distinction. Single pull, three shot burst, or rock and roll i.e. Fully auto, squad assault weapon. You're the absolute best on KZbin. God bless you and many more new years to you.

[@mat7883]

Thankyou for taking the time to produce such a high grade production with great content week in week out! The video is of high clarity, sound is sharp, great lighting and great backdrop! Makes it very easy to watch. I have both, but enjoy shooting the revolver a lot more and you don't have to search high and low for spent brass. 😉

[@oliverclosoff4973]

I'll take both.

[@RTRider.MaxCaptain]

YES PLEASE…

[@charlesknight3204]

@@RTRider.MaxCaptain … Ditto!!! Chuck Knight from Buffalo, Texas. 👨‍🌾✝️🙏🐩

[@thebluehoodedman6121]

Before I was even watching the video I was thinking the exact same thing I’ll take both

[@IAM-o7o]

If the shtf pretty much anything that works and is sustainable is better than nothing.

[@66smithra]

Revolvers, especially old ones, are much more interesting to me than autos.

[@seapimpnh.9307]

Not a fan of the tactical Tupperware polymer pistols . I’ll take steel and wood any day . Personally I prefer wheel guns .

[@grahamohea2424]

I'm primarily a Glock guy, but I have recently gotten on a revolver kick. Went to the range earlier today, where I brought my Glock 29, GP-100, and two LCRs in .38 Special and .22 WMR, respectively. I like the challenge of pistol shooting and a revolver is a completely different set of skills to master

[@hansblitz7770]

Revolver shooting will make most shooters better at using an auto.

[@waynehendrix4806]

@@hansblitz7770 I agree. And it always seems that from the same approx barrel length, I get more control and grouping with a revolver. Many revolvers also have an adjustable rear sight to square things up as well.

[@claytonoakley8677]

@@hansblitz7770 I agree as well a revolver makes you take the time energy and patience to hone the skills to hit your marks. You have generally 5 or 6 shots and you want them to count. I actually enjoy single action revolvers. I shoot them and my 1911 .45 and I notice my skills always improve

[@russellkeeling4387]

The revolver has an advantage when reloading ammunition. One nice thing is not having to chase brass.

[@loymedic]

GunBlue, although politicians and evil actors are doing their best to destroy our (God-given) rights, thank GOD that as you say “…this is still America, and you can do what you choose…” Thank-you for your service, and I pray that you, the Mrs, and Benny continue to be blessed by His providence!

[@russf6572]

I like my auto loaders, but my revolver is in my hand more. I only have the one, a 4.2" stainless Ruger GP100 in .357, but it's a beauty! There's just something about the history and simplicity of the wheel gun.

[@barrygehosky8734]

Struggled with being comfortable carrying a striker fired auto for years in multiple configurations. Finally and thankfully bought a S&W 638 and couldn’t be happier! Don’t need any special holsters no mor pain the back or side it carries very comfortably in my front pocket in an old cel pal holster. Left those autos at home on many occasions but the 638 is always with me. I love my 638

[@teamstucker624]

Great video thanks for sharing. I like modern striker fire polymer frame guns for sure. At the end of the day I'm an 1980s kid and revolvers are what I learned to shoot first. I also ran hammer fire automatics and I still love those guns more now then I did as a young boy.

[@larryblair4765]

Again, a fantastic video. I am a big fan of both. I have many semi auto and many wheel guns. I carry a glock 19 to work and as my edc, but would not feel uncomfortable with my 2" 357 s&w 19. Or one of my 586 or 686s don't carry my pythons, as they are just too beautiful of gun to get punished in a carry routine. Hope u had a great new years and thank u for another great video sir.

[@TheGrenadier97]

Lots of solid and experienced comments in this video. Great content.

[@LionquestFitness]

I like both, own both, and have carried both professionally. Most times as as a citizen defender I conceal carry a snub revolver.

[@selaxlife7621]

Same here....I own both and love both....guns are like women....they come in different shapes and sizes and all deserved to be loved and taken care of....in return they will take care of u.

[@Zkpe02]

My first duty weapon was a S&W Model 10, then I was issued a mod. 65 then I bought a model 586…and having only 6 cartridges in that cylinder made me work harder to become a more proficient shooter; I knew I had to make every shot count….I spent a lot of time at our police shooting range every other week, where we had thousand’s of cartridges of wad cutter ammo with no limit on how much we wanted to shoot…I spent a lot of time reloading as well😂

[@robtans5042]

My first revolver was a s&w mod 13 but I have had many more. I done 👮‍♂️from 1981 to 2017. Speaking of mod 10 Ive got a round but mod 10 Ive had for a long time and an old s&w mod 10 pencil bbl that was a royal hongkong police dept revolver. Ive got several more but I dont carrying them anymore. Nowadays I carry a 9mm its just a change that came through time.

[@Zkpe02]

@@robtans5042 I carry the Glock 17 nowadays, it’s light and with the double stack mag’s it’s still lighter than my beefy L & N frame revolvers. I had never used a hand gun per say to any degree of proficiency, I was a long gun rifle user my whole life which served me well though while in the military during Vietnam….

[@TrustedCustomer]

Continue with the good work! I just happened to look and see whether you had any recent videos and noticed this one. You had a dozen comments within four minutes of your upload! Hats off! and HAPPY NEW YEAR!

[@DomoArigatoRobot0]

Thank you very much GunBlue490, for taking the time to talk about this subject. I did not know about "feeding the autoloader dictates the cartridge". This, among the other wisdom you've conveyed, convinces me to invest in a midsize to large revolver. They are just more aesthetically pleasing, by sight and feel, than the autoloader as well. Happy New Year to you as well, and God bless! 🙏🤲

[@spudboyQ]

Your voice is so pleasant. I could listen to law books if they were read by you.

[@krashdude1]

I had an instructor once tell me his way of practicing a revolver reload. At his range though. Have your reload in your pocket or wherever you carry the speedloader. Shoot your 5 or 6 rounds at about 5 to 7 yards. Then without looking at your revolver { he would close his eyes on his range] empty the spent casings, acquire your reload, load them and then shoot those rounds. He said this was a fairly realistic situation in a defensive shooting because you never want to lose sight of your opponent. Of course I brought up the "peripheral vision" situation, and he thought that was not something you can truly depend on in a real defensive scenario. We had lots of discussions about that.

[@markchoate9021]

Thanks for this video. I really enjoyed it. My wife carries a revolver for all of the reasons that you mentioned. However, while she is a right handed shooter, she had to overcome having a left eye dominance. She has done pretty well with this, but I wondered if you had a video, or could do one, on dealing with "left eye dominance?" Thanks.

[@64samsky]

A Smith & Wesson Police Chief's model 10 is an awesome shooter! I have 357 and 44 Magnums, but I love my model 10!

[@jeffreyelliott622]

I really love my 51/52 frankenstein post war Smith & Wesson Regulation Police .38s&w caliber revolver for it's like I can't miss with that handgun out to 15 yards just deadnuts accurate to say the least I mean I have to make myself miss my target on purpose and I'm wanting to test it at the indoor range at 7 yards to see If I can place my 5 shots in almost one hole shooting single action of course !!! I believe I can do it just aim solid for that bullseye and SQUEEZE the trigger and see myself keyholing that bulleseye !!! CHALLENGES got to love'em !!!

[@ramzimakarem1837]

Thanks for your valuable information.

[@butchyboy69]

Welcome back, yourself, sir. I hope 2023 is good for you and yours.

[@rickyramirez3483]

Man! What a straight forward video, thank you, Sir! I kept saying to myself…’this guy is on the money on every point he brings up’. Very good info, lots of sense on each statement and very open to any caliber and fire arm. AIR ASSAULT, Sir!🇵🇷👍🏻

[@adrianalanbennett]

As for me and my house, we will serve the Lord. Happy New Year! God bless.

[@bobbyscott8024]

Thank you so much for posting this and showing us the ''pros and cons'' of each! I liken it to David when he was going out to face Goliath! He couldn't wear Sauls' battle-gear or use his weapons because they didn't fit and he hadn't tested them! To me it's the same with guns, tools or anything else. It an emergency or spur of the moment we might could manage but they really have to ''fit'' us individually! I grew up in the '60's and you sir are a dying breed! Thank you again and God bless!

[@daveaver]

Happy New Year Like them equally but those wheel guns are works of art.

[@tobylopez445]

I have an SW model 60-14 357 magnum, but I carry 38+p in it and I shoot it very well. Happy New Year to you and your family from a 75yr old Army Veteran 1966/1969. God Bless you and your wife and thank you for our well-needed Police, Sir. God Bless America and all who love her!

[@hankhill3417]

Welcome home

[@menomisespeanut]

So do I!!!! I love my Lady Smith!

[@cbroz7492]

..love hearing those bells in the background...

[@midnightsailor1]

Opened up my eyes to some considerations I hadn't given to revolvers...and also turned me on to the 41magnum ,a revolver I hadn't considered before. l think it will be my next purchase wish list.

[@williamwatson4625]

I tend to prefer a revolver over a semi-auto, for a few reasons I don't have to worry about issues like failure to feed, failure to eject, and stovepiping in a revolver. If a revolver fails to fire a round, I simply pull the trigger again. The added bonus is that round may still be good, it may still fire. I just pull the trigger again until I get back to that round, and maybe it'll fire on a second try. With a semi-auto, however, if a round fails to fire, I have to rack the slide to eject that round and cycle another round into the chamber but once I've ejected that round, that round is already worthless to me. I find it easier to clean a revolver after each range session. All I have to do is open up the cylinder and clean and lube the ejector rod, each chamber in the cylinder, and the barrel. That's basically it. With a semi-auto, however, I have to take out the slide first, and then the recoil spring, the barrel (if the pistol is of a locked breech type), and the magazine. Then I have to clean and lube each of them before I can put them back. Unlike a semi-auto, a revolver doesn't leave brass behind. I got hit in the face by brass more than once while firing a semi-auto. Anyway, my $0.02.

[@wizardofahhhs759]

They make autos with double strike capability now so that's kind of a moot point.

[@herman66mi83]

Another wonderful video. For CCW I believe the saying “The best gun is the one you have on you.” Reliability is paramount and secondly knowing your firearm and choice of ammo.

[@tomarmstrong750]

Regarding cartridge case size between revolvers and autos, the rimmed revolver case is based on black powder cartridges where a larger case was needed for the required powder volume. Magnum cases (.357 and .44) were made a bit longer so that they could not be used in a non-magnum revolver for safety reasons. Modern smokeless powder loadings fill only a fraction of the case volume available. Auto cartridges were designed for smokeless powder from the get-go and thus the case volume could be less and the resulting cartridge more compact.

[@guaporeturns9472]

38 special was introduced with black powder but quickly went smokeless. .357 was developed from the beginning with smokeless powder, at least that’s always been my understanding.

[@tomarmstrong750]

@@guaporeturns9472 I believe you are correct about .357 and smokeless powder. Black powder was obsolete for self contained cartridges when the .357 magnum was introduced. However, the longer case was necessary to prevent higher pressure magnum ammo from being used in potentially weaker non-magnum revolvers. The problem to this day is still the same: the rimmed revolver case has a lot more available volume than the modern powders require and hand loaders must be extra careful not to double-charge a case in the process (this applies to magnum and non-magnum cases). A double charge can result in a catastrophic failure of the gun. A simple internet search will produce example photos.

[@guaporeturns9472]

@@tomarmstrong750 True , I am quite aware of what you say .. 2.3 grains of bullseye here

[@wizardofahhhs759]

I usually just fill the brass up and leave just enough room for the bullet to fully seat. Never had anything catastrophic occur.

[@moniquelegarda1842]

The clarity and no-nonsense approach to discussing the pros and cons is evidence of experience and wisdom. Thank you.

[@Grodd70]

Excellent video. I love both styles of handguns and I agree that both can be an excellent choice depending on a persons needs. I noticed at the end of the video bringing up arthritic conditions, some of my older or I should say "wiser" family members are now having a hard time with slide manipulation. The beauty of a revolver is its old camera simplicity "point and shoot". While I have heard that they make "snake shot" for 9mm or .45 acp (I've never seen it in person) and even then I would question cycling reliability , .357 Mag or .44 mag snake shot is readily available for persons camping. Plus both can be down loaded to .38 spl or .44 spl all the way up to much more powerful loads. Both are great but if I could only own one...make it a revolver.

[@revv45acp71]

You are a national treasure and as comes out in some of your other videos a genuine Christian. I appreciate both. Please consider being less wed to S&W. They are not now who they were when you were in the field. Ruger seems to be the best made revolver these days.

[@GunBlue490]

No, they are not what they used to be. I am a certified factory trained armorer for both S&W and Ruger, and there was never a marriage ceremony with me and S&W. I presume that you are not familiar with my respect for Ruger engineering, and perhaps haven't seen the Redhawk that I often holstered and demonstrated. On the basis of your note, it sounds like you haven't seen my critical review of the new Model 19, nor perhaps saw my most recent video comments regarding their century old design and its 51 weaknesses that I was trained to repair. Constantly and frustratingly, year after year. Let me be clear from an Armorer's point of knowledge, having maintained and repaired many hundreds of S&W revolvers since 1975, and having maintained hundreds of Ruger GP100s that never required repair. 1. Ruger is a stronger, and virtually indestructible. 2. The old, beautiful S&W was a nightmare of weak design that was utterly impossible to keep in top working order. It's a pretty, but dysfunctional work of art that left the factory destined for continual breakdown and loosening. 3. The new S&W with the hated key lock and the despised MIM internals is vastly superior in strength, reliability, and does not require the constant skills of an Armorer to keep in top working order. That's why I own two of them. 4. I testified before my chief and police commissioners in 1985 that our S&W were junk and cost the department many unnecessary hours of constant repair and expensive parts (S&W charged us for parts). I further recommended that we scrap our S&W revolvers and eliminate them from consideration, and purchase the then brand new GP100. We did. In the ensuing years before we transitioned to autos, I never repaired a single Ruger. (To this day, Ruger does not charge me as their Armorer for parts, which are very rarely needed). 5. S&W ignored their weak issues for nearly a hundred years until police departments began switching to the GP100. Overnight, they seemed to have an attitude change and they finally addressed those failings.

[@WheelgunsOnWheels]

I always enjoy your vast depth of knowledge. For me it’s always a revolver because I’m a quadriplegic and cannot rack a slide or load a magazine, but I can work a revolver like a champ.

[@marie-noellebaechler1433]

Thank you for this very interesting video. One additional element is that every gun owner has to live "completely safely" with his/her firearms, both for him or herself and for people nearby. And we have to do it for decades. The constraint is even stronger for people keeping a firearm loaded, a firearm with wich it is required to train both in the range and at home (with snapcaps). This is a point where the revolver has a significant advantage, especially for people who cannot train regularly under supervision.

[@cameronizatt3293]

The knowledge and expertise that you pass along is awesome. Thanks for taking the time and your efforts, as you are helping so many people in so many ways. Thanks and God Bless.

[@sjmiller6012]

I saw a similar video you did some yrs ago. You were outside on your porch. Then you commented about manual safeties, DA designs, vs the striker design. Mildly surprised you didn't mention safety concerns. There are many new gun owners. Saw a recent news item where a guy shot himself in the leg in his car. He died quickly after bleeding out. I don't know, but suspect that might have been a safety free, striker fired gun. Also racking a slide for ppl with less strength; it's much easier close to the chest, racking across the chest. Always enjoy your experience based presentations. The lighting and other production values are very good. Thanks. 🤔

[@66smithra]

Any accidental discharge is on the Indian, not the arrow.

[@GunBlue490]

Your point is well taken. The focus of this production was more towards the practical considerations involved with the selection of pistols and revolvers. Your comment prompts me to do a separate one or perhaps individual ones on the safety issues of various types. Thank you and God bless.

[@richardd.9223]

Your concept on men vs women is 100% on point

[@alexkalish8288]

Interesting topic that occupied my thoughts in Vietnam many times. When the shooting started, I was always worried about my 45 having a feed failure. I cleaned my pistol almost everyday but it was always a source of anxiety. I had a single feed failure in 2 tours, it clear with just a rack of the slide so I'm still around. Now I carry the FNX - 45 but on the ranch like my old SSA in 45 colt. I'm also an iron sights guy, even on my AR-15, it gives you a faster response.

[@infogunvault6920]

I've heard people praise the .45 as being very effective (compared to 9mm for example) even when FMJ's are used. Is there any truth to this in your experience?

[@danoman5217]

Had a pal who was a tunnel rat. He used a 38 spl smith. Also had a knife.

[@wizardofahhhs759]

​@@infogunvault6920Of course it's very effective, it wouldn't still be a popular caliber if it weren't.

[@infogunvault6920]

@@wizardofahhhs759 I know more now than when I posted that comment a year ago. The difference in damage between 9mm and .45 FMJ is much less than a lot of people realize.

[@shanecoite3292]

Happy New Year. I have learned so much from your videos. God Bless

[@frankbier1690]

That room is so appealing, beautiful place

[@shooter3083]

May the year bring only the best for you, your bride, and Benny. God Bless.

[@carlhansen8672]

Good vid. I have a 7 shot 357 Mg along with several 9mm and 380ACP Autos. I carry a firearm every day since I have a CCL and live in a Constitutional Carry State. I also train several times a month to maintain my ability. As a formal LEO I thank you for your service. Bottom line, if you are proficient with what ever you carry, that's what really counts.

[@deanschannel1031]

Sir, I have watched most of your videos, and you are a officer I would have loved to serve with. I retired from the PA Department of Corrections. I was a C.E.R.T. Team leader, R.H.U. officer….and worked a lot in our M.H.U. Last position I had was transport officer. Back then we carried a .357 Smith , and a Remington 870. This was ( in my opinion) the perfect balance for the job we needed to do. Many of our transports were to hospitals…court….our special missions. I was very happy with this old school defense. My son is now a patrol officer for a large department in Pennsylvania, and his situation requires a more aggressive stance….I love your common sense in what is needed, and what is not needed.

[@happymotoring4674]

All the best to you and yours. Say hi to Bennie, God Bless.

[@dowdawg]

Nice video, depends on what I’m doing that day as to what I carry. My issue is I like them all…

[@edwardpetty5401]

Happy New Year, and thank you for another informative video.

[@stevensapyak7971]

1.3.23. I personally prefer a double action Wheel Gun™️……..no safety, only two ways to operate. 38 special/357 magnum is my preferred round.

[@randylahey2242]

glock...no safety...only 1 way to operate;) 10mm will do everything a 357 will

[@wwisaacson4807]

I have autos and revolvers. The revolvers are shot more because I hate policing brass and the triggers are better.

[@robertdancho9671]

Was also preferred, until early 2000s, by French special forces; no safety to be concerned about, reliability, could immediately be brought to bear.

[@mtkoslowski]

Revolver is king unless you’re planning to miss a lot or execute a platoon.

[@guaporeturns9472]

@@randylahey2242 no it won’t… wont shoot .38s

[@fisherone9]

BLESSINGS from the West Coast of Canada 🔥 Just finished my design and patenting for my "automatic revolver"😇

[@markr5132]

Awesome video and couldn't agree more. Sooooo jealous of your beauty of a gun S&W 629. Everyone talkes about the Colt Python's but Model 29's and their sister model 57 are the sweeter handling, better value and more robust wheel guns for walking in the woods with bears out there!! Always looked to buy one but that Eastwood character brought the price over list price, and my practical side wouldn't pay the going price, but some day!

[@isaiahmadrid6738]

Wonderful video, thank you for sharing. I'm sure many folks in the concealed carry crowd would consider you a "fudd" for your opinion on capacity in a civilian defensive firearm; I agree with you, however. I have carried firearms with ammunition capacities large and small, and have certainly never felt "undergunned" when carrying a gun with a six round cylinder or a seven round magazine as opposed to a 15 round magazine. I can understand the sentiment of "better to have more rounds, and not need them, than to have too few," however, I think those folks overestimate the number of cartridges fired in a legal self-defense scenario. It's certainly not bad to have more ammunition, but it should not, in my opinion, be the primary or even secondary concern when choosing a carry gun. Better to pick a weapon that is reliable and practical to carry first and foremost. Any extra ammunition capacity should be seen as the "icing on the cake," as it were.

[@markmcdonald5711]

I carry a Ruger LCR in .38spl and a Berretta Nano with two 8 round mags in a sling bag as backup. Best of both worlds. Call me a Tactifudd.

[@m.loughlin1915]

I've always kept it simple for 50 years of shooting, competing, hunting and all other gun stuff, and I do not compromise. My gun policy......... If it's a .22 rimfire pistol or rifle, Semi-auto ONLY. If centerfire....... Handgun: REVOLVER, Smith or Ruger only. 357 Magnum or big-bore NON-Magnum, preferably 45 LC. No autos. Wouldn't lower myself by even touching a Colt. Centerfire rifle: Bolt, Lever or Single shot. Shotgun: Pump or O/U. No Autos. FYI...I can consistently operate a pump faster than most Autos can cycle and still bust clays all day on the Skeet field. While it is true, the SA pistol gets the nod when it comes to capacity, but IMHO that's the limit to the debate. As far as reliability, toughness and longevity, I'll take my 3" GP-100 fixed sight model over a high-maintainence 1911 clunker any day. BTW....Thank you so much, Gun Blue for your videos. Even with my decades of experience, I have learned quite a bit from you. God Bless you!!

[@brianlee6849]

I like both for different reasons but I love the classic revolver. I think capacity is overrated for self defense. I think if someone is in a situation where you need 15 rounds there in trouble. Great discussion thank you 👍

[@toneeclark399]

Very good presentation. On par with Paul Harrel’s discussion with similar bottom line.

[@lopezjp1]

Thanks again for your videos. I have also found that our academy instructors found a way to get good at reloading revolvers. 25 pushups for every round that hit the floor.

[@MarkHansen1990]

Fantastic talk. Love the historical experience and images. Knolage is so valuable. Happy New Year! God Bless!

[@frankbutta9344]

I started out carrying revolvers, moved to 1911 pistols, and now carry both. A S&W 642 in my pocket allows me to have a hand on the gun while pumping gas, or standing in public, and it looks completely inconspicuous. I really like (and own) the new Colt Python.

[@sihall1975]

Serious question from a non-American (and to be clear I'm not anti-gun, I just grew up in England) Do you really feel the need to have one hand on a gun every time you're pumping gas or standing in public? And do many other Americans live with this level of fear of being shot at every day?

[@rob6850]

@@sihall1975 it depends on the neighborhood

[@onedaycloser2death224]

@@sihall1975 absolutely. Always being aware of surroundings, scanning not only for my safety but for those around me. If you don't, then you're as good as dead IF and when things go sideways.

[@connor3284]

@@sihall1975 The average American probably has roughly the same level of fear of violence as the average Englishman. The average person is unlikely to ever be involved in a life threatening violent incident, though it doesn't cost much to prepare for the unlikely.

[@SUBARCTICPSYCHO]

@@sihall1975 Armed carjackings at gas stations have become frighteningly common in recent years in certain types of neighborhoods at certain hours. It's bad enough that this isn't the first time I've heard of someone holding a gun while at the pump.

[@danchenier7686]

"I digress " you often say and when you do you share your wisdom with us. God bless you sir.

[@johnnyguitar6697]

Fantastic video, as usual. Extremely clear, and full of common sense. If I may add a category I don't think you address here, is the home defense gun, the one to keep handy next to one's bed, but that might be seldom used. There, the revolver might be the better choice as one wouldn't have to worry about the spring of an autoloader magazine failing over a long period of time of being compressed. And a decent 38 special +P JHP would do a good job while avoiding overpenetration.

[@liddell157]

I agree with the reliably of a revolver sitting vs auto loader but, it's more challenging to attach a light to a revolver. In the unfortunate event that someone breaks in and its dark I would want to grab a pistol with a light vs trying to flip on light switches or holding a flashlight in one hand and a gun in the other. Just some food for thought

[@johnnyguitar6697]

@@liddell157 It's a fair point, though I can think of a couple of S&W that allow for the mounting of a light. But they're a bit of an acquired taste, and those of us who are into revolvers typically tend to prefer classic lines.

[@thomasholohan4090]

@@liddell157 True, but the disadvantages of a handgun mounted light are 1) it can show your adversary exactly where to shoot, and 2) if you sweep an area with the light you are covering everything and everyone with your weapon, potentially intruder plus family.

[@Dcm193]

@@thomasholohan4090dont shoot noise . Take a lowlight class

[@samadams9557]

I’m blessed to have more than a few firearms, including pistols and revolvers. My personal two favorites for concealed carry is the full size 1911 and a smith and Wesson 686+ with 2.5” barrel. I have boot grips on it and it’s a bit of a chunk but I just love it. Shoots great, plenty accurate in my hands, heavy enough to take the edge off of the recoil in hotter loads. However, if I had to do it again I’d likely go with the 3” barrel. Not for accuracy or velocity but for the full length extraction rod. I haven’t had a problem extracting shells but overall I think a full length extractor is just good practice.

[@Heywoodthepeckerwood]

Other than the 1911 and the Browning high power, the revolver is the way I roll. I own a few plastic guns but there is zero pride of ownership. Plastic autoloaders are like a 1990’s Honda Civic, they work, but that is all you’ll hear anyone say about them. A fine made revolver, like the old smiths and old colts can not be overstated in their craftsmanship and overall feel of the firearm.

[@DrumandPianoDude]

Your videos are awesome! When I was a police officer, I carried a high-cap 9mm and a snubnose .38spl for my backup. I carried the .38 for my backup due to the fixed barrel that would work better for a CQB situation. Even though I've carried autos for years with my CCL, I'm looking at switching to a S&W Model 64, accompanied by a pair of speedloaders. I love the accuracy. Quick note. When I was a cop, I actually carried a 4" S&W Model 10 bull-barrel as my off-duty gun, so I've appreciated the wheel gun for a long time.

[@Swamp-Fox]

Wishing you and your family (including Benny) a healthy, happy, and prosperous 2023!

[@celticfriar1129]

I appreciate the comparisons, I own all types of handguns, but as an almost octogenarian I really fine myself using a revolver for my edc.

[@user-yj7ew2os1q]

What a great teacher! He has a tremendous dept of knowlege, and good judgment.

[@jacobcelo7040]

I really enjoyed your presentation, GunBlue. I myself have always been a fan of revolvers, and still faithfully carry my SP101 Ruger .357. I'd be very curious to see your thoughts on the Ruger Security Six line, as it compared to the K frame S&W. I would imagine you were around in the days of Rugers emergence onto the double action scene. I have done a lot of research into the history of the guns, but I'm always yearning to hear of first hand accounts. I know you were a S&W armorer and have shown how the newer S&W are superior in terms of strength and design to their older counterparts. From what I understand, Ruger was really ahead of their time with the designs they put forth in the Six lineup. Thanks for your continued effort, Sir.

[@wwalker3738]

The Security Six are great revolvers that stack up very well against the S&W in every regard except the trigger pull. There is nothing that can compete with the triggers that S&W builds even to this day. I love my Rugers and the GP 100 is probably the strongest .357 American built but even though they may be as accurate from the bench off hand in DA the S&W will always be a bit more accurate because of its trigger pull

[@tomarmstrong750]

I have an SP101 and the double action had always been a bit rough. I finally took it apart and found that there were a lot of rough edges and burrs in the action. I smoothed things up with fine jewelers files and stones and the difference is amazing. The single action cocking was also improved. Feels almost like an S&W. Almost. My GP100 did not have the same issues and I was able to improve the action by installing different trigger and hammer springs and a trigger stop screw.

[@jacobcelo7040]

@@wwalker3738 I agree, the triggers do not compare. I've had over a dozen Smiths and 5 examples of Six series guns. One Security Six had a tuned action for competition shooting, which was fairly smooth and light. However it didn't hold a candle to my basic, barebones Model 10-5, the run of the mill service revolver. I was actually quite shocked at what a difference there was the first time I handled a Security Six. I had been shooting Smiths since my teens, and had been very excited to handle a Security Six but was taken back by how stiff and mechanical it felt in comparison to the glass like K frames. It's something I can overlook, as I enjoy the design overall moreso than the Smiths. I have a GP100 as well, and it actually has the best trigger of any Ruger I've encountered. It's a 3" barreled, fixed sight GP100 in blued, circa 1989 which I purchased unfired. I've got several thousand rounds through it and the trigger is actually really nice. Much better than the Security Six with the action job was. My SP101 I carry is nothing to write home about, however I have never liked the comparable J frame triggers either, and actually prefer the SP101 over them.

[@jacobcelo7040]

@@tomarmstrong750 I have never tinkered with my SP101, I will agree the action is not the greatest, it's heavy and mechanical feeling, but not the worst I've felt. I will have to pull it apart and inspect everything sometime. My GP100 actually has the best trigger I've felt on a Ruger and has no modifications. It's an older 3" model from 1989. I bought my wife essentially the identical gun, 3" fixed sight only hers is stainless steel. Newly mfg in 2020. The trigger on that gun is noticeably grittier and more mechanical feeling than mine from 1989.

[@repetitivemotion]

I just bought an SP101. I can’t believe how bad the trigger is. The hammer and trigger springs are unbearably stiff. I haven’t even shot it yet and don’t plan to until I do a trigger job. On the other hand it is a fine looking piece of machinery.

[@samadams9557]

I absolutely love both.

[@muhabamin8129]

Happy New Year, sir, light weapons expert🇺🇲

[@billelston677]

Years ago I started out with a 38 special J frame and then changed calibers twice with semi autos. After all these years I am now back to a 38 special J frame for concealed carry and couldn’t be happier!

[@Jeff_Seely]

I thought that I had considered all things on which handguns I would purchase. Watching this video has caused me to realize that there are many things I did not consider. But now that I have owned both autos and revolvers, The two main factors for me were: a subcompact auto for personal carry and revolvers for magnum cartridges and sporting uses. This video is about as good as it gets on selecting handguns. And I did not follow the sage advice you gave on picking up my wife's first handgun. That was a grave mistake not bringing her with me, captain. As always, thank you so much for providing excellent content and may God bless you!

[@ShaunPanzer]

I love all of the guns ! But I could only keep one pistol or a revolver I’d keep my 686+ 3 inch . I shoot it well and I like to have the option of 357mag or 38. There are so many great firearms and so many choices

[@hankhill3417]

If it doesn’t have the firing pin on hammer, find one that does they are made so much better

[@johanvandersandt8904]

I live in South Africa and love revolvers but the typical encounter over here in self defense includes multiple attackers. Its rather difficult to license firearms over here as well so many people don't want to make the wrong choice when selecting a firearm and you can only have one for your section 13 license. All of that being said I still want one!

[@nohillforahighstepper]

I have both types. The state where I live doesn't allow hunting with auto cartridges (WY). We are in the process of having them review the ballistics of the 10mm. But for now, my 357 or 44 mag will do the job of harvesting game quite nicely. But I would never carry one of those, or a 10mm for that matter, for personal defense. One area that you didn't cover was shooting through your target and knowing what is beyond. A 44 mag will most definitely remove the threat....but it could also neutralize innocent bystanders as well. The 9mm or 45 auto could do that as well but there is considerably less chance of shooting through your "target". When considering which cartridge to carry, I ask, "what size bullet would you accept being shot with"? The answer is always the same...."NONE". So, with that knowledge, even the lowly 22LR is better than going without. But I still prefer the 45...

[@GunBlue490]

I discussed all those issues in a video a few years ago regarding the selection of handguns. The pass through matter was the driving force behind bullet design changes in the late 1970s.

[@nohillforahighstepper]

@@GunBlue490 I remember. But I thought it may be worth mentioning again. Especially for those who haven't watched your previous video.

[@boblack1774]

Nice presentation!

[@stillhousefilms6165]

Each has it's pro's and con's but i'll throw my two cents in for those who hike or camp in areas where an animal attack could happen. A revolver with a lanyard set up would be the best. Your shooting arm could be in the animals mouth and a semi- auto in your non - favored hand might cause a limp risk and a FTF or FTE. Also if you're in a struggle with an animal the lanyard cord can help you retrieve the weapon if dropped.

[@Dcm193]

If you have such a weak grip that you limo wrist an autoloader you definitely wont control the recoil of a snub nosed revolver.

[@rodeleon2875]

for self defense it comes down to which one you can operate most reliably with muscle memory only and not have to think about the mechanics of it when you have already made the decision to use it. with proper training and practice both could suffice. i myself prefer revolvers but then again i have never been involved in such a situation thankfully.,

[@forthehellofit5544]

Batteries don’t die on iron sites. I had a pistol optic that I loved for competition. Til when I was in the middle of a competition and my zero somehow got messed up. I loctite all the screws. So personally I will never trust a carry optic for an everyday carry pistol again.

[@ram_bam]

Happy new year. Love your stuff.

[@TheLoneRanger745]

I realy appreciate the wisdom and experience of a man that has been there . I only started this hobby a few years ago, I ready like the revolvers, but practice with a slim line Glock 43x w/S15 magazines 15 rds in a full grip for my XL hand . I've been practicing at 30ft over a year now, I push myself hard for improvement getting 4" groups at a quick pace . I also practice with the bigger brother Glock 45 which fits and feels better than the smaller one . I installed Holosuns green dots on both a while back and Glock trigger connector bar what a difference , smoother more accurate package. Not many people carry revolvers anymore at least that l've seen , outside of the home or range . But I realy like them , I have 3 Colt replica's that I realy realy like they usually come out when the Westerns are on the Big screen, 🤠ALOT ! These kids don't know what they're miss'n , I grew up watching westerns , I'm a crippled up old Man now in a world that has changed ! 🤮🤪

[@bhoward9378]

Happy New Year, sir! I really enjoy your videos and perspectives. Full disclosure: I own both. My grandfather's S&W .38 M&P revolver is self-aiming. It was my primary side arm for a long time. Now the Glock-19 is my EDC.

[@davidhandyman7571]

You alluded to the minor issue that I can see with regard to capacity for self-defense usage; a removable magazine not only has greater capacity, but it is also easier to carry multiple magazines than to carry extra speed loaders or loose rounds. As an example, carrying an extra two 15 round magazines is more compact and manageable than carrying 5 speed loaders or 30 loose rounds. Blessings from Australia.