'Hamas Still Have My Daughter' | Emotional Mother's Plea To James Whale

"My daughter was kidnapped and she is still held by Hamas."
Merav Lesham Gonan does not understand why some people in the west still support Hamas.
A senior Hamas official said on Sunday that the Islamist group has not withdrawn from ceasefire talks with Israel after this weekend's deadly attacks in Gaza that Israel said had targeted the group's military leader Mohammed Deif.
But Izzat El-Reshiq, a member of the political office of Hamas, accused Israel of trying to derail efforts by Arab mediators and the United States to reach a ceasefire deal by stepping up its attacks in the enclave.
Saturday's strike in the Khan Younis area of Gaza, in which at least 90 Palestinians were killed, according to local health authorities, has put the ceasefire talks in doubt.
Click here for more from Talk talk.tv
If you need any help visit: talk.tv/helplines
#hamas #palestine #israel

[@elainekent3551]

Poor lady I cannot imagine what she is going through 💔

[@walktip]

I don't think she cares about her daughter She is putting her daughter at risk with this interview

[@bwow6800]

She shows no emotion. Almost like she's reading a script

[@user-pv1df2gc1o]

@@bwow6800u show no humanity, like your body missing a brain and a heart. idiot

[@user-pv1df2gc1o]

@@walktip u morron

[@mitch2924]

⁠​⁠@@walktipif you had children, you would know this woman has possibly tried everything to get her child back….nothing is working. She is now at this place because no one is helping her, she doesn’t know what else to do. Her kid is already at risk, despite her doing this interview or not. What a dumb comment to make

[@Thisisaweirdthing2makeusdo]

I can’t even comprehend what this mother is going through.

[@Pyrrhic537]

Typical soundbite.

[@tahmidalam5612]

Ask Palestinian mothers they can tell you

[@Itsdifferent-wv4jo]

We don't care ​@@tahmidalam5612

[@Itsdifferent-wv4jo]

​@@tahmidalam5612 The Jews deserve to live in their ancestral land, and to be safe too ... We've been kicked out of 109 countries, Israel is our home, Palestinians can be safe in 193 countries, Europe is big, they can go there

[@dxcsdg600]

@@Itsdifferent-wv4jo Europe is also big, why don't you go to europe since all europeans love israel?

[@wda_digital]

Love and Strength to Merav Lesham Gonan and her Daughter From South Africa. What an absolute insane story for both of them to have gone through.

[@gillianmay988]

It’s heartbreaking listening to this lady and for her daughter also for all those who have families taken from them

[@franceshanna4430]

😢 blessings on this lady 🙏

[@montythepoodlepup9634]

Would love to see this reunion between Amazing Mum and daughter! Biggest thoughts are with you both ❤take care ❤

[@arlenemohandeson16]

My heart truly truly breaks for this mom. It does not matter what country or culture you’re from all parents can universally feel her pain and anguish.

[@walktip]

I don't think she cares about her daughter She is putting her daughter at risk with this interview

[@Noa-cc9ur]

@@walktip Her daughter is already at risk She was kidnapped by a bunch of lunatics terrorists if the international community won’t put pressure on the terrorists to release her she might not make it So I think this mother is a fighter who cares a lot about her daughter she’s been fighting for her daughter for the past 9 months

[@imnotdoingthisagainboy]

A reminder there are still two children hostage in Gaza. 4 year old Ariel and 1 year old Kfir Bibas, with their mother Shiri and their father Yarden that are also held hostage. Bring them home now! 🎗️

[@ShlomoCohen-xr7zi]

Blane their parents. They voted for a fascist occupating government for decades in the ' only democracy in the Middle East '. Next time they will think twice before voting for the wrong leadership. Especially for the little children that had to suffer from their parents bad choices . Sad and heartbreaking. 😢

[@danieldaniel-uf2hl]

James Whale - I'm so glad to see you! Thanks for spreading the true and expose the evil

[@GlaswegianHunzai]

what evil?

[@GlaswegianHunzai]

the fact that you cannot learn from history is your tragedy

[@coopz1969]

Are you really that stupid or do you support terrorists ​@GlaswegianHunzai

[@yevgenymashenberg2369]

⁠@@GlaswegianHunzaiwhat evil ? Are you a human ?

[@GlaswegianHunzai]

@@yevgenymashenberg2369 These touts are just not sane and they are following the Zionist agenda. How dare Ash says Jews who do not support Israel, which backed Hamas in order to create a stable state for themselves.

[@ninavarnava6781]

As a mum my self , god know what that mum is feeling. My thoughts for this mum and all those Israeli families.✝️🙏🏼

[@Prfdt3]

And people criticize isreal.

[@adriennefried5368]

Al Jazeera is a Islamic Muslim communist party propaganda newspaper produced by Qatar

[@TroyEnglish.]

🙏🇮🇱🙏🇮🇱🙏🇮🇱🙏

[@user-fd9oi3uq9t]

talk TV thank you very much 👍🇮🇱

[@bwow6800]

Yes they are passionate about the propaganda they spread. As long as israel keeps writing the checks

[@galsholder2317]

A nightmare is what this is.

[@Ann_Maree68]

😢 omg, I am sure I saw her daughter on video today 😢 I'm on Australia and it was The Sun I could swear it's her daughter. 🙏🙏 for this lady and her daughter

[@Sd01123]

מירב❤ חושבת על רומי ועל כל האחרים כל יום😢 מתפללת שיחזרו כולם🙏

[@stevenkingett2192]

I can't imagine what these poor people are going through

[@jeremymoonlight7638]

אוהבים אותך מירב❤

[@user-fd9oi3uq9t]

כל הכבוד לך מירב את אמיצה ,דיברת יפה ולעניין. בקרוב בעזרת השם ניראה את הבת שלך בבית ‏🇮🇱

[@charshill2978]

​@@user-fd9oi3uq9t You mean with the help of the US, and the UK who gave the land to the zionists? God is not with you.

[@charshill2978]

😂😂😂God 😂😂😂 the British gave the land to you. The US maintain your military Occupation. ​@@user-fd9oi3uq9t

[@clockfacecarpets5746]

Why do our politicians allow these people to demonstrate in our country and seem to support them? ie Corbyn?…

[@ezharlawson]

I am a brit living in Israel and i am very happy to acknowledge what James saying at the end Thank you very much mr whale

[@TheSlimbee]

@@ezharlawson you are not a Brit, us Brits do not support stealing and ethnic cleansing

[@ezharlawson]

@@TheSlimbee no one supports it and you're most welcome here to see the truth with your own eyes

[@TheSlimbee]

@@ezharlawson I have seen the truth with my eyes it is horrific

[@ezharlawson]

@@TheSlimbee you remeber that us brits concerd and ruled many place around the world?

[@TheSlimbee]

@@ezharlawson did I say that our history is good my family was treated like slaves by our governments

[@oriamayanahum482]

So sad

[@user-js9xk1xz8n]

Wonderful thank you

[@user-dz5we7mz3o]

💔

[@smileyzed3843]

🇮🇱❤️🇦🇺🙏🇮🇱❤️🇦🇺

[@sourayaserhan8519]

The clowns are on again

[@Nathan-ky6fn]

🤍🇮🇱🤍🇮🇱🤍

[@stanislavpasternak5856]

מירב יקרה , תחזיקי מעמד !

[@loanpham2681]

😢😢😢🙏🏻

[@Paul-ow8fh]

PAUL🇬🇧 Its a spiritual battle. People need to wake up, watch the film they live, its not meterial , its spiritual.

[@GoodmanRecordingsTokyo]

🙏

[@cathyburkart9395]

What about the Palestinians jailed without trial? That issue has been going on for decades.

[@deepakkotian3270]

😢💔💔

[@jillyv]

I pray for your daughter and God bless and keep Israel eternally 🙏🙏🙏

[@cobyhizkiya3756]

Unbelievable . Praying for her return alive and safe

[@bossman5359]

does this lady even care about her daughter? she comes on here with politics and talking bad about hamas she better hope they dont see this video 😂

[@Work4Good757]

And if they do? Do you think it matters to them what she says

[@omarballer23]

Interesting how she referred to Israel twice as a “western country” but it makes sense since it’s a western colonial proxy

[@FamilieSievers-v3w]

Western in attitude, in democracy, your word choice is revealing your mindset. I'd recommend you stop the victim mindset. Immigration is everywhere, shouting colonialism is utter BS

[@liatfoxdrach1790]

Israel is the world's best example of Decolonization. Muslims have colonized the entire Levant.

[@MoMedia1]

"This is what the protestors don't undertand, they're going against the Palestinians being free in Gaza" did that actually come out of his mouth? Like before October the Palestinians were free and happy, with no worries. What an absolute joke of a human.

[@jeyhunbunyatov7627]

you can hear the sadness and feel the grief she is having and going through, imagine what Palestinians parents and Palestinians themselves are going through for 75 years...not to offend anyone. so naïve woman talking about the free world...

[@gghstlr]

💯

[@gghstlr]

She was obviously selected to spread the propaganda that we are in an existential fight against Hamas because Israel obviously can’t beat them by themselves and she doesn’t speak for all of the hostages. In fact, there are many of those families that are progressive and have been calling for a cease-fire and an exchange of hostages since October 7.

[@asafzilberberg6648]

Thank you for sharing this. Hamas actions are horrible.

[@AhmedNabil-ev2qz]

What’ about the once kidnapped before 7th October

[@yoav4705]

god bless her and god bless israel . islam cant co exist with normal people

[@Ladypeace12312]

God💔 l can't imagine what this mother is going through 😢😢😢 so heartbreaking. 💔😢 Breaks my heart to pieces that human beings can bes so cruel to other human beings

[@jackiepowell7513]

I ll bless those who bless you and curse those who curse thee. God

[@TreasaVeigas-qq5jm]

Stay strong. Stay blessed. You are God's own chosen people. The good God is with you through it all.

[@nagarmiri]

heart breaking 💔

[@gghstlr]

Her daughter is an active duty soldier. Maybe her daughter is alive if she hasn’t been starved or killed by the IDF. She has more hope than hundreds of thousands of Palestinian mothers. And her daughter is definitely being treated better than tens of thousands of Palestinian hostages being held in Israeli dungeons. It’s really hard to have more sympathy for her than them. She is not well informed if she thinks the “free world” is on her side. The majority of the free world is against what Israel is doing, which is why the ICC and ICJ have declared them an illegal occupation who are plausiblyx committing genocide. Sorry Israel, you’re going to be limited to your fellow genocide supporters on this one.

[@liatfoxdrach1790]

Shows how much you know. Romi is not a soldier, but an innocent civilian. She worked as a waitress in Tel-Aviv. Israeli women serve from 18-20, Romi is 23 years old. No point in even addressing the rest of your lies. You are brainwashed.

[@LoveThegreen]

this world is evil

[@hibalala1521]

Great video just like the last one but you have to make your videos like you did asking and answering your questions it is better

[@Free.gaza786]

Wow I heard them drag my daughters hair I heard 🤔

[@gghstlr]

Exactly! This is after she let it slip that she heard the IDF firing on the car

[@liatfoxdrach1790]

Released hostages were able to share information from those left behind with the families. Your hatred is blinding you.

[@Malloyxng]

Poor lady so should we feel sorry for her even though she dont feel palastinian mothers are going through the same thing

[@galgal4195]

Some Palestinian mothers want their child to die as martyrs. Insanity.

[@kennysmith1336]

Is a different support and Palestinians and supporting Hamas and first of all you really need to learn how to protect yourself stop asking for our help from America

[@user-ir1pw4sf3v]

My Comments are being deleted here

[@edaleman2758]

It's a Z propaganda channel

[@edda682]

@@edaleman2758 Clear off then, go watch Al Jazeera.

[@edaleman2758]

​@@edda682I do watch Al Jazeera. And Al Arabia

[@nowgrownup]

​@@edaleman2758did you have to go to university to learn how to write such nonsense 😂

[@edaleman2758]

@@nowgrownup not at all. I studied engineering, not media

[@yvette7306]

💛👍🏼

[@user-mp6ou3ms6g]

In my time here. Its cold

[@sitihawakamis6735]

These guys are RUBBISH

[@santoshkhadka9251]

Dumb and dumber acting skill is in next level😂😂😂

[@ballerinatop5483]

Well you obviously know what it means to be dumb

[@azmi7454]

James what about palestinian children kidnapped by idf.

[@rajr2120]

Funny host

[@laylaahmed1997]

As a mother i do feel her pain but to say the idf is protecting the people in gaza is just not true.. soldier have actually said they been given the green light to shoot at anyone. We seen the videos of those men on the beach and many other videos.. but as for hostages ithink its gone way to long now and children from both sides that have been taken shud return to their families.. children are the innocent ones here..

[@almoglya2z]

et me correct you please... "IDF has green light to shoot at anyone" FALSE ! theres is no such green light to anyone just because you feel like, there must be a reason for any soldier who open fire. 2nd: "children's from both side has been taken" israel do not kidnap innocent children's and hold them as hostages, that's another lie you believe in ... however there are Palestinians prisoners held in israel for the crimes they commited, young or old !!

[@You.are.boring.me.now2024]

Just wrong on every level.

[@leila.b5014]

Wake up

[@adamhammond3739]

The 2 Bafoons show 😆

[@1234singer]

The only bafoon here is adam hammond

[@Donotmesswithpikachu]

Ropt npidh o shkerdhat islamike

[@ReemiesRecipes]

🤔

[@user-pw4rj7df7j]

Blame Netanyahu for refusing negotiations terms,also he needs to stop lying about the whole situation

[@JonathanMiles-mt7hg]

you can't be that stupid

[@You.are.boring.me.now2024]

@@JonathanMiles-mt7hg Yes they can and they are, awful ideology.

[@jasonburns7897]

Finally, someone who isn't brainwashed by the mass media.

[@bwow6800]

So her daughter is held by Hamas and here she is talking about them in this manner? That's not how I would talk if I wanted to get my child back alive. She's emotionless

[@edaleman2758]

James Whale thinks history started on 7 October

[@edda682]

This land has always been Israel's perhaps you should do a bit of thinking.

[@nowgrownup]

The land has always been Israel check history....These people don't check facts and just spout out nonsense 😂

[@sharonstonts]

Right. Hamas was established in 1987, not on October 7th.

[@SR-yz2uq]

Think you should read and fact check!

[@almoglya2z]

the oldest book says israel belong to the jews ... so you are absolutely right, history did not start at the 7th, but 6,400 years ago!

[@Moustapha97]

Is she care her daughter as she talking when their government msscred Gaza instead of criticizing her government she insultng others.

[@JamaBama-hz1kb]

😂😂😂😂😂😂

[@Moustapha97]

Are you realy care your daughter ?

[@You.are.boring.me.now2024]

Vile!

[@Donotmesswithpikachu]

Learn how to write, poor excuse for a human being.

[@ballerinatop5483]

Do you care about yours?stupid question...

[@KathyPrendergast-cu5ci]

Why do you ask, are you one of the people who has her?

[@galgal4195]

Yes. Unlike Paledtinian mothers who are happy when their children die as martyrs. You are so evil, that it's well know to the entire world. The west can't stand you. You are a joke.

[@Moustapha97]

You don’t care your daughter as you talkng!!

[@galgal4195]

Evil Muslim. You are so evil!!!!

[@asmamalik4173]

I really feel sorry for this woman. She hasn't got any clue about her precious IOF!

[@RivyGenX]

💔

[@ShlomoCohen-xr7zi]

😂😂😂😂😂

[@Yara-Li]

💔