(한국어 자막) 비투비(BTOB)의 킬링보이스를 라이! Killing Voice & Wind and Wish | Vocal Analysis + Appreciation!

Help Support this channel! My Patreon is live!
/ koko3op
I love creating for this channel however I do need some help to keep me going! They'll be award show reactions on there just for Patreons as well as some behind the scenes footage at some point because I have a TON of bloopers, I may do some personal reactions for comebacks myself!
Starting from only £1 a month! Thank you!
Hello everyone, welcome to Koko3op, (Yes, we are named after the EXO song as we are EXOL's at heart) a c lub night based in London however we are also content creators that will provide K-Pop lovers with reaction videos and many many more!
We hope you'll enjoy what's to come and will join us for the ride!
#BTOB #Killingvoice #BTOBReaction #비투비(BTOB)의 킬링보이스를 라이

[@Koko3op]

JOIN my Patreon for more exclusive content here INCLUDING KINGDOM and BTOB album reviews : patreon.com/koko3op 용서해주세요. 자막 중 일부는 완벽하지 않을 것입니다, 그래도 최선을 다했습니다. 연습은 완벽을 만듭니다. Apologies for the slight double sound too. I really should've double checked but MERCURY GHETTROADE BABYYYYY.

[@elenakim1210]

Thanks a lot for your effort

[@kimyu57]

해외 멜로디 만나서 너무 반가워요 감사합니다 ❤

[@basaraki]

와....이렇게 신경을 써주시다니 정말 고마워요. 외국인 리액터분들 무슨 말을 하는지 궁금한데, 모르는게 많아서 조금만 보다 스킵하는 것이 많았는데 정말 고맙습니다.ㅠㅠ

[@annafirnen4815]

Let me just say I feel very validated for knowing there is another person as much obsessed with Changsub's voice as I am lmao

[@Koko3op]

He is the TRUTH!!

[@graceanastasia5325]

Count me in!

[@heartfullgiraffe]

this is seriously me, literally one of my top three vocalists in the world. his tone/the feelings in his voice are just top notch

[@jessaanndelacruz7638]

I am toooooo!!!!

[@juliancth0529]

Count me in

[@AAADRONEIDAAA]

as a fellow changsub vocals enthusiast, I was so excited yesterday when this was posted because our boys slayed once again 👏🏻👏🏻

[@rheathecreative5612]

There are very few groups that have the ability to make people feel nostalgic. For me, that group is BTOB. I was there when they were first a seven piece group and crushed when Ilhoon left. I’m proud of them for continuing their journey. My bias since I discovered them has been Minhyuk/HUTA. Vocal wise, my bias is Hyunsik. These men hold a special spot in a lot of Melody’s hearts even now, including mine.

[@ferlynjoy7153]

“we know eunkwang he knows what he’s fckng doing” “if I have a voice like changsub I would be like oxygen to people I would sing from sunrise to sunset” Lmao so relatable at the first minute

[@user-Hongssi]

비투비 멤버들 모두를 진심으로 아끼는 것 같아서 저도 영상 보는 내내 행복했습니다😊 특히 창섭이의 음색을 진짜 좋아하시는 것 같은데, 리액션이 너무 웃기고 귀여웠어요ㅋㅋㅋ 이번 신곡도 많이 홍보부탁드리고, 함께 멜로디 해요💙🍀 영상 리액션뿐만 아니라 멤버들 고유의 창법이나 화음을 짚어주셔서 분석적으로 볼 수 있었어요. 한국어 자막이 있어서 잘 이해할 수 있었어요. 감사합니다😆

[@Koko3op]

You’re welcome!! I’m glad the subs are good and I do care for them all truly.

[@Andaeriel]

Reminded me of a kpop vocal analysis blog who said that Changsub's voice is a beautiful instrument, and Changsub is smart in utilizing his instrument to produce sounds and effects that he wants with his technique. And yes, Changsub has the best voice tone. My fave one in the world.

[@Koko3op]

Absolutely!

[@plutonian_accountant]

Everytime Changsub sings I wanna throw a shoe. He betta sing!

[@Koko3op]

THIS!

[@junkyuseum]

28:22 Dingo’s Sound Representative admitted they omitted quite a number of ad libs during post production because their mics are catching each other’s voices creating weird overlapping noises. That’s why some parts didnt sound right. I believe they should have had a bigger studio to avoid this, at least if it’s BTOB singing 😂

[@nickysanthi6772]

Where do you get the information? 😮

[@cheshirecat5155]

That explains the weird sound mixing in some parts. That makes sense though. With how close they are, their mics would be catching all those sounds when they're belting.

[@shapby]

no wonder, i was wondering why the whole video sounded way too overprocessed for a group of btob's caliber. i guess dingo's team needs to learn some pointers from tiny desk or the first take's sound engineering team.

[@azphine2681]

tbf I doubt they've really ever had this problem before btob came in. but would've been nice to have the full btob experience with all their adlibs and stuff.

[@lynnvo1228]

@@nickysanthi6772 Dingo left a comment

[@Happpy.happpy]

창섭이 '난 그냥~' 할 때 저 창법 나도 엄청 사랑하는데 이 분도 그렇네요 😆👍 저 부분 들으면 킹덤 오프닝 무대 생각남 너무 좋아 ㅠㅠㅠ 소름이 쫙 오르고 머리 끝까지 홀리하게 시원해지는 느낌이 드는 그 특유의 부분💙

[@Koko3op]

Same here!

[@lynZy05]

This killing voice is a masterpiece! Love them. Please show this to your friends so we can all appreciate them all over again.

[@TA-mr3pe]

Finally BTOB on Killing Voice :) it took a long time and they should have been on there ages ago! What an amazing group, 2012 boy groups have given us so many beautiful vocalists! I swear anytime Changsub opens his mouth no matter what song it is, it just hits me so hard like its so magical and his voice pierces through to my heart (lol), and of course the rest are equally amazing, Hyunsik's range is crazy, Seungjae's old school ballad voice is beautiful, and Eunkwang is awesome too, of course Paniel and Minhyuk's rap and singing just completed the songs.Its so funny to think that at one point they were going to debut them with like a focus on them being acrobatic group

[@Ankita_94]

Finally a reactor who appreciates BTOB 😍😍😍😍

[@yspekpop]

Changsub and Shinee's Onew has the most interesting and unique voices for me

[@sithlord_dani]

I love when people recognize and appreciate BTOB's talent. They're popular, especially in Korea, but often overlooked internationally-- AND ITS CRIMINAL.

[@김승범-j7j]

I felt you! You had to press the pause and rewind on every single 창섭's part. I really love his voice and his singing too.😊 And I recommend you check out 리무진서비스 이창섭.(just copy and paste) You will love it. Thank you for the reaction vid. I did enjoy the whole 46 mins! 잘 봤어요!🤗

[@Koko3op]

Thank you!!

[@annafirnen4815]

Finished watching now, your reactions were a mood. I myself ascended in few places too. You just cannot go wrong with BTOB's vocals. The cleanse of the soul for us mere sinners. Also I agree that the backtrack was WAY too loud, which is why I think the harmony in I'll Be Your Man didn't click. They probably didn't hear themselves properly since the rappers were also going off at the same time.

[@Yung_Guac1]

yea it was def wayy too loud

[@Koko3op]

Ahhh yes just too much at once.

[@gracerori705]

CHANGSUB bias here 👋 Even tho many Kpop groups are more popular, but for me BTOB is on another level, another class 😊

[@sliracha]

I finally found another changsub's voice enthusiast

[@성현-t4v]

비투비 사랑해 줘서 고마워요 나까지 행복해지는 리액션이에요🩵

[@heartfullgiraffe]

Thank you for reacting! lovely to find more people obsessed with Changsub's voice

[@Koko3op]

It does. So surreal!

[@megan1362]

I could listen to them sing for the rest of my life 🙌🏻 Changsub and Sungjae kill me every time with their vocals

[@danyb1168]

Sungjae has a beautiful healing voice

[@moonlight-gt1ej]

Thank you for sharing your reaction! They are indeed very talented. I wish Peniel sang his verse of the new song on Killing Voice too. It sounds so good. As always it's so interesting to hear your analysis. I learned a lot. They do have a mini album. It has 5 songs and all of them are composed by Hyunsik or Minhyuk.

[@Koko3op]

I’m definitely going to react to it! And you are welcome.

[@mochi5519]

Omo, I am not the only one. I love Changsub voice as much as I love BTOB in a whole. His voice really is WOAH.. 💙☘️

[@Jooooy___]

창섭이 파트 나올때마다 방방거리면서 좋아하셔서 나도 같이 방방대고있음 ㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@changmochilee8947]

This has been the longest BTOB reaction video that I have watched but still felt short because of your on point, realistic, relatable, and of course, your non-stop praises to our boys esp. to uri Changseobi. I am one of Changsub's singing voice slave.

[@Koko3op]

Thank you!!

[@chickddye]

Also do you know Changsub has opened his vocal training center? That supports the opinion “Changsub can sing”. So he has the ability to teach others with his skills.

[@isabeljones5868]

them praying before doing i'll be your man had me howling😂 and you bet eunkwang gonna be his dramatic ass all day every day

[@Koko3op]

Hahahshshs dramatic as heck

[@deszdapda8381]

The other title for i’ll be your man is Pray hence the praying gesture😂

[@valentine3a]

They are soooo good it's not even funny I'm always down for Btob appreciation

[@Happpy.happpy]

13:20 성재 저 파트 롤러코스터 타듯이 순식간에 음이 오르락내리락하는데 유연하게 잘 한다고 생각했던거 나만 감탄했던 부분이 아니었구나! 라는데서 공감했어요 😆 비투비 노래들이 듣기엔 엄청 좋고 쉬운데 부르기는 어려운데에 다 이유가 있다니까요 ㅎㅎㅎㅎ ;)

[@averagejoereads7271]

I’d never checked them out before this Killing Voice and I am in love with Hyunsik’s voice!! The low tone you focused on around 18:30 really got me blushing 😂

[@Koko3op]

He sounded sooo good!!

[@averagejoereads7271]

He did! Now I really need a Pentagon Killing Voice one day, as they are BTOB’s little brothers.

[@averagejoereads7271]

@@alletstella5894 it’d be quite hard to choose the songs I think

[@junkyuseum]

I’ve been praying and praying and praying for this day to come where we can watch and hear BTOB do their magic and enchant everyone in the kpop community. 🤧 It’s strange that despite being always showy with their singing, non-fans still had to have a platform like Dingo to finally see what BTOB is actually capable of

[@ZomigagriVanzeur]

I've been waiting for this!! Thank you so much for your reaction! It was an experience indeed!

[@plutonian_accountant]

Melodies are rejoicing around the world!

[@riza5999]

That first pause on Changsub? Me too, me too

[@empressazziah]

Though I am very much inlove in all of their voices, I too first noticed changsubs' vocal tone.

[@asmasam]

I feel like you came in for Changsub , but you left with Changsub AND Hyunsik instead 😂. Can't blame you tho man has range for days!! For the backtrack it was loud for me too, interesting enough only on Btob and Ailee's killing voice video , like why doing that to our vocal kings and the queen I think I need a word with whoever did the mixing

[@챱챱-h1w]

이창섭 목소리는 사랑입니다❤❤❤

[@kiyowojinnie1902]

FINALLY THE BIG BOSS BTOB IS HERE ❤

[@hanniefrei]

I can give my heart and soul for Eunkwangs voice but Changsub voice also kills me. It's so hard to choose which among the two of them I love the voice more. I love Hyunsik can go low and so high too and Sungjaes voice is so MANLY. It's makes me fall in love . ❤

[@holymoly99]

이 형님 창섭이형 되게 좋아하시네ㅋㅋㅋㅋ

[@lie9378]

외국형한테서 익숙한 멜로디 향기가 난다.. 진짜 우리 애들 아끼고 좋아하는게 보여.. 근데 진짜 귀욤뽀짝하시네...

[@Z7Z77Z]

Hyunsik's vocal range and power are amazing 👍

[@tnahpele0321]

The editing of the video sound made their high notes and chords hard to hear.

[@주치즈-n7e]

비투비 좋아해줘서 고마워요!!

[@lai421]

That's me when I hear Changsub's voice.🤣 it's very soothing.💙

[@Yung_Guac1]

Other killing verse videos, it's too perfect to be true. BtoB is definitely first take 🤣💙 The backtrack was so loud I couldn't hear Hyunsik and Changsubs ad-libs. It probably also messed up the members since it's hard for them to hear themselves. The harmonization in I'll Be Your Man was a little off cuz I think Hyunsik was singing lower and the others was a little higher. I also noticed in It's Okay Eunkwang was a little off cuz he was prolly trying to do that thing he did in their recent concert (kzbin.info/www/bejne/mInKfn6ibLWGnac&ab_channel=meludy_id) which I thought was pretty funny XD.

[@Koko3op]

Ahh this makes sense! Loool thanks for clarifying.

[@sondrarothermel1421]

Thanks for the vocal analysis and your excitement and your re-winds!

[@Koko3op]

You’re welcome! This was a dream come true honestly.

[@yeahz1108]

이분 창섭이에게 과하게 빠지셨네욬ㅋㅋㅋㅋ 좋은 리액션 감사합니다

[@행복한일은매일일어나]

임현식❤❤❤❤ 진짜 작곡천재 노래가 다~너~~무 좋아 !!!

[@thatkpopsis]

We finally got BTOB on Killing Voice! I’ve been wishing for this since MAMAMOO was on. Changsub and Hyunsik voices are my favorite!

[@jayadeepikaarigela632]

Thanks for loving BTOB 💙 And yes Magical Changsub Oppa's voice 💙🫶 It's good to see someone really appreciating BTOB 💙🫶❤️

[@jolie0921]

Great reaction, thanks for the video!

[@Lilo-cr7kf]

Yes finally! I didn't know this would drop yet BTOB has always been one of my fav groups. They're so underrated but i don't get why they have so much talent, great vocals and charismatic personalities. This killing voice just proves my point💁🏻‍♀️🩷👌🏼 After the EXO killing voice i can die happily and peacefully but it better be at least 30 min long😂

[@Koko3op]

Agreed hahaha

[@meral_k]

you better start preparing for your funeral then 😂 the exo killing voive is coming 😍

[@natty7639]

Hyunsik has really such a wide range and my fav voice for sure , plus he is the one writing most songs

[@melody4u_riz467]

The only reaction video with a lot of pausing and rewinding that I'll accept. It make sense coz its BTOB and its Killing Voice. The best! 💙

[@lykapelayo7531]

LOOOVVEEE ITTT!! Def a dream come true for us fans

[@sixteenskies]

4:07 whoooa good catch! can confirm this! he mentioned in an interview that he purposely raps in a sort of nasal way so that he can enunciate clearly!

[@Koko3op]

Omgg no way!! I’m getting good at this! Ha

[@btobyejiapsa4414]

The day has come indeed!

[@yourgingerbread]

I understand you so much! Can't stop pausing and replaying, again and again 🤣

[@Koko3op]

I had to SAVOUR EVERY MOMENT LOOL

[@benggdejusto414]

yesss! we've been waiting for this 😭💙💙

[@louie6730]

Great analysis! I think BTOB also adjusts their technique depending on the song lyrics. They always want to convey the right emotions when singing. It might be good to check the lyrics as well!

[@ariaant0910]

Thank you for reacting to BTOB killing voice, everyone in the group has their own unique voice and they singing together is like heaven Changsub's voice is my favorite, the way he deliver the song just so perfect for me, recently whenever i hear him singing i can't help but crying lmao, especially his appearance on Leemujin service, pls check it out of you have not 😊

[@Koko3op]

I did on Patreon!

[@ariaant0910]

​@@Koko3op oh nice!

[@joejojoe3338]

I've been waiting for you to reacts to this!!!! We have the same exact reaction exclude on the voice analysis part. HAHA Been struggling to find my next Kpop obsession after After School was disbanded 8 years ago, and as I'm getting older (Damn, that's hurt)😂, I'm looking for some ballad music and i found BTOB. Since then, Ive been listening to them all day especially on the rainy day.

[@Koko3op]

Haha I’m gonna check out after school too.

[@kimiya1509]

one of my wish is to be able to hear them live 😭💙

[@iamvoldy4583]

yes tbh i am elated btob finally is here but yeah the music was too loud!

[@hanniefrei]

I love this. THANK YOU SO MUCH. I'm a MELODY AND ENGENE so I love seeing you reacting to both ❤

[@Koko3op]

You have taste!! And thank you.

[@distant_melody]

The Sound Producer aplogised for the mix in the harmonies. There was too much cross over between the mics so he had to cut the sound from some.

[@daniellemonbebe]

I’ve been refraining from KZbin until the semester ended and finals were done- THIS was first on my list to catch up on and your reaction was second!! Idk why but I was so emotional the whole performance. I just love them so much. And CHANGSUB SUPREMACY!!! that’s my bias 😭😭😭 the whole freakin world should know about this man and his voice 💕💕💕

[@Koko3op]

Welcome back!! And thanks for watching

[@mohamedsallehmdnooh35]

Love the way you analyse the boys. Really on point. But I do find Huta's singing voice really awesome especially in 'Kingdom'.. but the combination of them all.... goosebumps....

[@Koko3op]

Yes it’s a shame he didn’t get to sing more here! I liked him in waiting 4 u.

[@fluffynowee7731]

that was me at 5:28 whenever i listen to btob

[@fatimaalyafai9248]

hyunsiks part gets me too😂

[@melodyyook2199]

as a changsub bias, i dare you to react to his amazarashi cover!!!

[@bigkor]

I was waiting to see your reaction. I'm glad you really enjoyed and appreciated it.

[@ASMR-kv1ns]

Sungjae is maknae, we were both born the same year

[@Koko3op]

He’s a Taurus like me too!

[@angie199324]

I'm so glad you checked out BTOB's Killing Voice! They are such a gem to have in the k-pop industry. I would like to recommend Highlight's Killing Voice. Formerly known as BEAST (B2ST), they were originally a six-member group that debuted in 2009 under CUBE. However, two members left the group and four members re-debuted under the name Highlight in 2017. Have a great day!!

[@Koko3op]

I tried reacting to it months ago but I didn’t like it at all and stopped halfway lol

[@b_bk_k8971]

Thanks for reaction of btob

[@Naamy19X9]

Eunkwang is the leader (a gentle leader); Hyunsik is responsible for most of their discography and thus has a lot of influence in the group; and yes, Sungjae is the maknae.

[@twistan4976]

I love that you're obviously a fan and love their voices but you aren't afraid to critique when you hear something a bit off. I love watching and learning from these reactions thank you!

[@Koko3op]

Thank you so much!! Yeahh it's more fun that way

[@thddufdma]

한국어 자막 고마워요 즐겁게봤습니다😊

[@Koko3op]

You’re welcome!

[@vanhanguyen1808]

I'm just gonna drop the song list order here, in case anyone needs it. It all sounds so goooooooood, even the beside songs ٩(◕‿◕｡)۶ 1. Missing You - title track from album 'Brother Act.' 2. Remember That - title track from EP 'Remember That' 3. Second Confession - single 4. Only One For Me - title track from EP 'This Is Us' 5. Beautiful Pain - title track from EP 'Hour Moment' 6. Someday - beside from EP 'Feel'eM' 7. It's Okay - title track from album 'Complete' 8. Pray (I'll Be Your Man) - title track from EP 'New Man' 9. Higher - beside from album 'Be Together' 10. Blue Moon - beside from EP 'This Is Us' (the cinema ver. is in show 'Kingdom: Legendary War') 11. The Song - title track from album 'Be Together' 12. Be Together - beside from album 'Be Together' 13. Wind And Wish - title track from EP 'Wind And Wish' 14. Finale: Our Concert - beside from album 'Brother Act.'

[@JellyMellow_]

Thank you for reacting ❤ I'm so proud of BTOB 💙💙☺️

[@raybows]

Hi, thank you so much for reacting to BTOB! And since you mentioned that the song sounded loud at times, dingo has apologized for the mixing in this video. Apparently, their mics were picking on each other's voices and they had to try and fix the issue during the mixing. Which is why you can barely hear their high notes sometimes, i don't think the song was loud but they had to lower their voices haha once again, thank you so much!

[@droptopcherry8615]

I became a fan of btob and their vocals aft watching this reaction HAHA

[@Koko3op]

Omg no way haha love this

[@breexzyy_]

I watched everything without skipping cause I love your reaction 😭😭😭 (I really wanted them to have sung their debut song 'insane' TTvTT)

[@Koko3op]

Awww thank you!

[@Yuenchungcindy]

Love your reactions!!!!! I don’t find it’s annoying that you stopped frequently, you always stop at the most amazing parts! Thank you for your sharing!!!

[@Koko3op]

Yaaaay thank you!!

[@zikfarah]

I looooove your analyses!!! it's just unfortunate that dingo staffs did poor editing that so many harmonization and adlibs from them couldn't clearly be heard

[@Jojodruis]

I HEAR IT!!!! Changsub is in my top 3 as well, such a good vocalist!

[@bryama2129]

If it possible would you react to btob wind and wish dance practice? It's so entertaining..not just dance they sing too

[@user-yj7mz7mt6z]

👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻👍🏻

[@blackstar683]

the video was badly edited during “It’s Okay” :// you can see Hyunsik belting but there was no audio

[@blackstar683]

also in Finale, when Hyunsik and Eunkwang was belting. geez they didn’t need so much editing tho

[@qwerty.uiop10]

I totally agree when you said "We know Eunkwang, he knows what he's f*ckin' doing"

[@MicheleDoenges]

Changsub is my Ultimate Bias. 10/10 agree, he has one of the top male voices in Kpop. I also really like Jongho, Yonghoon, Max Changmin and, weirdly enough, Bobby from iKON. He's got a jazzy twist to his singing that I'm weak for.

[@flafri]

when i tell you i Screamed every time you had to stop the video multiple times to fanboy over changsub's voice!!!! love to see a man of immaculate taste appreciating his voice

[@Koko3op]

He’s just SOMETHING ELSE!!

[@iljaeftw]

I love you and your love for BtoB's talent 👏🏻

[@Koko3op]

They’re tooo talented!

[@unknown21837]

초반엔 팬들이 비투비 개그돌이라고 영업했는데 알고보면 노래에 진심인 그룹...ㅋㅋㅋ xia killing voice도 리뷰해줬음 좋겠음 목소리가 거의 지문수준으로 특이해서 어떤지 보고싶음

[@bloomingflower5977]

Missing you.. The only btob song that's familiar to me, and I only knew Seungjae bcs of his dramas. Bcs of this reaction.. and THE Killing voice, I am obsessed with Btob and now Changsub is my bias. Thank you Micah..

[@Koko3op]

Aww thanks for checking it out and giving it a chance!

[@sadmochineko]

fellow changsub obsessed here, have you watched Changing Majors hehe

[@Koko3op]

Nooo what’s that? Yes he’s the best!

[@sadmochineko]

@@Koko3op its a youtube series by ootb where Changsubie goes to different universities to try out their courses! i fell in love with him over there all over again...

[@Koko3op]

@@sadmochineko ooo might be something i can indulge in off camera! I think i saw him do ballet?

[@sadmochineko]

@@Koko3op i totally binged it! not sure about ballet, that might be an episode with Key on I Live Alone instead?

[@WitchlightNW]

i don't have time to watch this yet (i will later) i already know you're going to be levitating from beautiful vocals + harmonies!

[@초록발랄]

Please review Changsub’s cover song. "What I thought about dying" "僕ぼくが死しのうと思おもったのは"