Hard Talk Robin Gibb part 1

[@violet640]

Old songs are incomparable to today's garbage. Remember, when American DJs wouldn't play BeeGees songs because they considered them crap, well they're dead wrong coz people find them classic - a masterpiece , and will be enjoyed by generations to come.

[@lena-mariaglouis-charles7036]

The Bee Gees - three musical geniuses whose lyrics, harmonies, melodies and unique sound (and talent to adapt and stay current for five decades...) will remain unmatched - indefinitely... because, true Legends never die... 💙💛🌹💜🍎🇺🇸

[@robertaclark3286]

100% right Violet

[@user-fi5ob7gy6r]

Абсолютно верно!!!!!!​@@lena-mariaglouis-charles7036

[@Sophia1000]

It's astonishing the garbage that passes for music these. And have the nerve to reward such crap with Grammy's and accolades galore.. I only listen to 60s and 70s music. Nothing really compares.

[@dashriprock8596]

Nobody taught them anything about music! That voice - those harmonies -- those songs... Unfreakinbelievable!!

[@jeanwalters7576]

Sadly Robin passed away 10 years ago today. Such a talented singer and writer of some of the best songs ever written. Love the BeeGees ❤️

[@melbelle2049]

The Gibb brothers actually possessed genuine, abundant Talent. Masters of Music.

[@SweetThing]

And this interviewer just wants to argue with Robin! Pathetic little man.

[@dakotaarnold6280]

❤❤❤😂😊😊😊

[@grandmanancy4719]

Robin should have walked out on this interview. What a jerk! How dare him. Robin is an icon and should demand respect. The Bee Gees truly did "live and breathe in the recording studio." Nobody handed them their success.

[@fuzzluvver69]

This is very, very different to, for example the Clive Anderson interview. The whole notion of this segment was 'Hard Talk' where it was designed to be asking tough, sensitive questions. There is no ambush going on here, and Robin knew before he went on what the line of questions was likely to be on so he was able to be prepared and with his eyes open. Which he did, and did very well throughout this interview. So no, I'm afraid I don't agree with your comment, and nor should any other objective, aware person.

[@newyorkers7707]

Robin Was the best... there is nothing like this guy

[@felinaumali6538]

Robin is such a good person indeed..

[@susangillikin124]

Robin is sooooo intelligent~ NOT just a beautiful voice!

[@beccawolfe777]

Intelligent .. smart .. handsome. Robin Gibb are these and more. ❤️

[@patriciabarkley735]

I love you Robin. You were so intelligent. You were always so handsome. Your voice could make songs so haunting and beautiful. You will be in my heart forever. Rest In Peace. ❤️🌹❤️

[@traciemarsh1611]

poor robin he looked so unwell love him rip robin

[@aishagswellnessinabottle2807]

He was handsome

[@jayjo77144]

❤❤❤ robin

[@dylanmart6007]

yes the bee gees were child stars, but there was no record label that pushed them on stage. everything they did was done because they loved making music and were good at it. and they grew up and still made popular music, which is something we most likely wont see Justin bieber do.

[@TheLobocantaore]

Not only that ,their music stood on its own with the hype !!!

[@jf3226]

GREATLY MISSED. GOD BLESS ROBIN AND MAURICE GIBB.

[@haljohnston3319]

Thanks for your Bee Gee's contribution to the world. Rest in peace.

[@jacksugden8190]

Robin Gibb 1949 - 2012 RIP.

[@grandmanancy4719]

Robin worked so hard to succeed and that he did masterfully! An angel singing in heaven now.

[@sarahjones-jf4pr]

God how awful to lose these treasures ,I feel the world will never have the quality of the 60s, 70s, I feel so sad that commercial music today cannot ever measure up to the Bee Gees sheer natural harmonies.

[@elizabethhayduk4014]

Real talent, harmony, composition and song writing. Very rare as Robin discussed.

[@brandi7ish]

There will NEVER be another sound comparable to the Bee Gees! There's was uniquely without limits. They could do any genre of music, and do it better than anyone else ever could. Their talent and gift of prolific composition of both music and lyrics cannot be matched. Their stage presence and senses of humor brought light and love to all those who witnessed their GREATNESS! IMO even the Beatles didn't compare to the Bee Gees...not in composition or harmonics! THEY WERE THE GREATEST!!!

[@coolnamebro]

They also wrote their own stuff, while the Beatles were a covers band until they were signed and had their songs written for them. Donovan wrote Blackbird and George Martin wrote Eleanor Rigby, for example. The Bee Gees left the Beatles in the dust talent-wise.

[@merciaspain6321]

Agreed ❤

[@alex2934]

I totally agree with you. The Bee Gees are always the BEST.

[@saradavidson3054]

​​@@coolnamebroAmen! They knew nothing about music, only what they felt in their heart and soul really. They wanted to be famous and I tell you this.....They delivered! 👍👏 ❤J

[@izildabaptistadeoliveira2920]

Exatamente isso!!

[@antoinettelamontagna9999]

Beautiful, talented musician! RIP Robin Gibbs! You are missed greatly!

[@Marz5004]

Robin very well handled this arrogant interviewer. I miss you Robin. ~Marz

[@erica_goats1997]

I miss Robin too and miss his twin brother Maurice and younger brother Andy and wish I could have met them 😔😒😪😢😩🤧😭💔💘

[@timothyparsons8327]

I recognized talent when I saw The Bee Gees for the first time on Top Of The Pops in 1967. The song was Massachusetts and immediately I was hooked. I was 12 and played it on our local jukebox till eventually I decided to buy the record with my pocket money. Then, they did “World” and the next day I bought the record in the freezing cold at the end Of 1967. These two songs are still my favourites by them and, amazingly, I managed to hold on to the records!

[@christelgrimmer4478]

I used to listen to Radio Luxemburg at night, secretly, and every time I turned the radio on there was a BeeGees song. Loved the older songs, didn't quite care for the disco era, got quite a few CDs with the older material. They had to do the hard slog to start up like the Beatles, performing in clubs and pubs, really like any of the great bands in the sixties, no synthesizer, electric guitars just tlent. I like how he said we and us, just a gentleman.

[@miguelmunoz9989]

Excellent interview!! The more I know about the Gibb brothers the more I admire them. Absolute geniuses, the four of them.

[@gaymichaelis7581]

Totally agree with you, Miguel Munoz!! Thank you! Gracias!

[@lindifuller9113]

I am from America, I am an old lady and loved the Bee Gees music in the 60's and 70's. Just recently I started listening to them again and now I am obsessed with their music and learning new things about them. I enjoy watching the old videos of them when they were just boys. Robin was my favorite. He really was fun to watch. Always clowning around. Not to mention his voice. Every time I hear him sing I get chills. I Started A Joke is one of my old favorites. I just recently ordered the Ultimate Bee Gees CD on Amazon. It has all my favorites by them. Can't wait to get it so I can listen to them in my vehicle. RIP Robin and Maurice. Your music lives on through your fans.

[@erlindacaguiat9]

Bee Gees are so different and very special. Music is so cool and sweet to everyone's ear. There's no copy cat at all. Genius and the best of all💖🌟

[@beatlesgear]

Carve it in stone! Everything Robin said is the rock solid truth about the junk I hear today! Beautiful and complex harmonies over amazingly clever chord changes, the Gibbs were masters at it, master! In 40 years NO ONE will be listening to J.B. or B.S., no one! However, Barry, Maurice and Robin Gibb's great-grandchildren will still be enjoying a steady stream of royalties! Their music simply defies description...

[@user-ge8it1gd4n]

Sca re_Punk_Kid

[@garygrace8658]

Brilliant 🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧🇬🇧👍

[@charlesEE]

Rest in peace. Thanks for the music!!!!!

[@thestick52]

Thank you, Robin and rest in peace now...

[@azgypsy]

The Bee Gees are, were & will ALWAYS be the best. They are also 3 of the nicest famous people I've met. Thank you guys for giving me some amazing memories.

[@erlindacaguiat9]

Robin the genious👍❤

[@erlindacaguiat9]

Genius"

[@carlosdelarosa6522]

Omg

[@patriciaeddy7629]

He was this brilliant so young.😊

[@valaarts8494]

It was their God -given gift that enabled them to Purdue their dream and sing . This compare us so annoying . He keeps trying to layer the interview with his own criticisms . Great , honest responses from Robyn .

[@bethdalmolin5919]

Robin Gibb è sempre un vero gentiluomo. In ogni occasione e con qualsiasi persona. ❤❤❤

[@user-ks1ii9gb5q]

Robin-best.

[@markswiftmelodies]

Like how they never lost the Manchester accent

[@Farrah300]

I love it too.

[@conniespiteri7623]

Ohhh Robin Robin I so needed to hear your voice (beautiful) tonight will be a Bee Gees concert 🎶

[@Helen25243]

What a nice guy. Plenty to say, easy to interview. He talked a lot of sense.

[@NixRiverSong]

Robin was great, he outtalked and outsmarted that host because he is so intelligent and puts weight behind his words, he never sais anything without carefully thinking through every word before he says it . And he is very hard to talk over as well because he doesn't let interviewers do it he holds his own with them as this interview and others show. I really enjoy watching it, thanks for posting When was this broadcast? Seems to me like 2010. Am I right?

[@robertaclark3286]

You're absolutely right taly. Robin did hold his own with the interviewers, and he was one of the most intelligent people there was.

[@leggomyeigonosensei]

Robin was by far the most intelligent of the brothers.

[@Lora-qw2rz]

Wow what a put down to Barry and Maurice. Very rude comment. Geez.

[@leggomyeigonosensei]

@@Lora-qw2rz The operative word was 'most'....which if you know how English works, means they are all intelligent. I forgot, everyone gets a trophy in woke world. But thanks, youtube comments archeologist. I think I wrote that comment 2 laptops back.

[@rmoore1686]

The Bee Gees we’re singing when they were very young children.

[@maryralls540]

Oh My God Robin... Are you Busy after the show... I miss you so much. I see the brightest star that shines ever night. And that is you and Andy and Maurice. I Miss you Men so much. Music has never been the same. See you all in Heaven one day... Much LOVE!!!!!!!!

[@susannegimeno1828]

We love so much a talented cutest a handsome in those their days powerful melody are blending together trio beegees, love them Barry, rob!& mo.rip the two miss them !!!

[@EmiliaRavenshill]

So what? He had to say it so often so that this arrogant interviewer and all other fools GET IT. I am not sure they do... He answered the questions exemplarily, he is a gentleman. RIP Robin, you have my total respect!

[@Farrah300]

Arrogant fool is actually putting it rather kindly. This guy is HORRENDOUS!!! To Robin's great credit, he handle this nut like a champion.

[@lazyhomebody1356]

He is supposed to act like an a**hole. It's HARD talk

[@lena-mariaglouis-charles7036]

I couldn't agree with You more! This "host" is behaving like a complete JERK - while Robin Gibb (as always...) remained a true Gentle-man (dash intended...). We lost a musical genius way too soon...💜 💙💛🌹💜🍎🇺🇸

[@andyh8548]

r.i.p. Robin.

[@rosanamelin56]

Dear Robin , so intelligent..

[@christopheranderson1968]

My God! How many times did Robin have to say the same things to this bloke?

[@elainebell1120]

they were the best ever no one can come close to them

[@socoromarquez598]

How can you mend a broken hurt.my heart was so broken when Andy Maurice and Robin dies they left me so broken hurted up to now only thier videos make feel happy.but so empty.i love you brother gibb.

[@allainerni1682]

Same here

[@lindastjohn5007]

Robin was so brilliant, talented and a beautiful loving person! Miss you, Robin! I think of Dwina often and hope she is doing well. Robin and Dwina stuck together through good and sad times.

[@katherinechatham9032]

Creating music for the love of the craft. I agree with everything he said. Auto tune is something I would not use. In my opinion hearing small areas where there is some imperfection is great because you know you are listening to pure music. I remember singing in front of a person that had done some songs. I heard this person say...those mics will make anyone sound good. It actually caused me to join a group of musicians and vocalists who critiqued each other’s work. I wrote most of my own songs...did some collaborations...and it was so uplifting. It did become too much work because the more you had following you, the more you followed and you had to keep up with comments and other artists music. At around 5000 followers...I cut it off. My father was sick and I did not have the time to keep up with comments and following other artists. I plan to do more music at some point, but currently I am caring for my mother. Having said all that I have the upmost respect for the music of The Bee Gees. This is real talent. No smoke and mirrors. This is a group that composed music that cannot he touched by any other artists. I am in awe of their talent.

[@inspirationalbalance5974]

I really want to thumb this down, but i love robin too much. Your beautiful art will live forever, forget bad interviewers!

[@rosilenesilva4853]

Robin Hugh Gibb inteligentissimo gênio!! I love Robin Gibb and Bee Gees ❤️

[@gracemarieherrera2684]

I get where Robin is coming from. No band can outdo nor replicate them and what they have contributed to the music industry. RIP to this great artist and to Mo and Andy!

[@maddylit1643]

And that's the difference between the Bee gees. ..all natural and doing it their way!

[@lecydiasdejesusoliveira9362]

Love you Robin Gibb 🇧🇷🇧🇷

[@ellencasey8503]

Miss You ROBIN You and your brothers still are The champions champions champions

[@gwtwmom2]

Robin is/was brilliant. The interviewer was a bit of a jerk and kept insisting they were pushed on stage as children. Robin was such a gentleman when the reporter kept contradicting him. I'd have told him to shut the hell up and listen!

[@janakinski2762]

Robin💖🙏🏿!

[@jacquelynkeefer4334]

greatly missed gone too soon

[@marjorieholoway6042]

Good interview, love your music and the great talent of songwriting!

[@sunmaw108]

Preach Robin, preach!

[@abbiekokee3576]

My husband and I often talk about How today they Take someone who Looks good but can't sing and Add all kind of Sinthesized Voices. There is no individual voices. All sound alike. So glad I grew up When there was real Talent. Bravo to real talent.

[@lennymadonna5995]

Rip my idol Robin. /! 😢

[@lissaline]

Oh, spot on Robin! Pop musicians these days sell their looks, not any talent they may have. The people who write the songs for them stay in the shadows, no one cares to know their names. (Geeze, I think that _I_ sing better than most of today's pop artists.) Everyone goes on about the Bee Gees' harmonies, which were great, but they could all hold their own alone as well and their lyrics actually meant something. And good job not letting the guy get away with dominating the conversation and putting words in your mouth.

[@theressreed5988]

The brothers Gibb write,compose and produce ALL their music!💞💞💞

[@ooohlaa13]

and furthermore without any formal education or musical training, brilliance and genius gifts from God. @@theressreed5988

[@Farrah300]

Robin doesn't take nonsense off of anybody!!!

[@TheBeatlesGurl101]

I so agree with Robin about artist now a days because now a days most pop singers can't sing live, and they are just not true artist. I mean some pop singer don't even deserve what they have. I mean for sake, all people really care about how they sound it is how they look. I mean singers also don't even work up to what they are now. You can just get discovered od frkien youtube now a days, I mean they just didn't work up to what they have and it just isn't fair.

[@carolclements1275]

This man was acting like an asshole to Robin. Shame on him, robin was so great with his response s

[@debraodonnell4253]

Well said my beautiful Robin star's today are crap

[@JJ-vc6pp]

Is this guy even listening or just trying to validate his own assumptions, I think Robin might be the definitive expert on his own fricken life, If you don't mind big boy.

[@johncarlo7395]

The interviewer sounded like he was trying to catch Robin out, what a prat

[@Jungletraveler00_12]

Bee Gees have so many memorable songs from each album. Today's "artists" have only one hit wonders which are attached to movies or even memes but are musically empty.

[@StrawberrySoul77]

We are far from reality since this wonderful interview with Robin!

[@alecortes12]

Now a days pop is not sang by artists, it's the computer.

[@elsiegamao7781]

He was really a smart and very intelligent guy.

[@kathrynlayfield9599]

Oh, my dear Robin, you and Mo are forever missed! Everything about you was special, the three of you brother's was other worldly. I do understand that it was work and real dedication to your craft! But, the three, Brother's Gibb never gave up, you were dedicated crafter's with a Golden Gift from above! And, the smile you put on the World will go on and on in the decades to come! See you in Heaven.

[@Paulchen7223]

Robin where are you!!!!!!

[@klaralacko9473]

In better place and in our heart for ever.

[@tupelomiss8315]

Thanks for sharing this posting Julian.Robin did good on this interview as the interviewer was a bit straight.love all the Bee Gees and Andy.RIP .maurice.Robin.Andy.Hugh & Barbara Gibb. Xx

[@brandi7ish]

Actually, Violet640, NO! I don't remember there EVER being a time when DJ's wouldn't play the Bee Gees in America. The Bee Gees were ALWAYS considered a stellar group for composition, style, harmonics, and presentation. There's simply NO possible way to avoid hearing/seeing talent when it's as obvious as the Bee Gees!

[@ikame28]

Well said

[@BelleWhittington]

Robin

[@elisagodinez6113]

I miss the beegess so much,Sir Robin I'm glad to see you ❤💓💕

[@raewynturei5382]

Awesome interview Robin. You handled it like a Boss. Very intelligent & can speak volume & make sense ..beautiful response to the dumb questions asked.🍂

[@jcortese3300]

2:57 -- OMG that's hilarious and sad at the same time. "It was harder, because you had to be able to sing." Ain't that the damn truth. You had to actually be a MUSICIAN.

[@RiverDanube]

He's a straight shooter with strong opinions and very proud of his achievements. He's so right about today's karaoke singers. The 70s and 80s musicians in general were so creative, writing their own music, creating their own style. I remember listening to the radio back then and there was always something new and so exciting every week.

[@TheZeevik]

good tv show

[@Stigi00]

Lovely man with a wonderful voice. Does anyone hear what he says at 3:27 while the interviewer is talking?

[@julietadizo3501]

Have Fun In Heaven.... 3 Gibb brothers Andy, maurice, and Robin.. Rest in peace....

[@alecortes12]

Can someone please tell me how the hell are you going to compare shit like Justin Bieber or Britney Spears to the Bee Gees!!!!

[@ellencasey8503]

RIP ROBIN Your Music will live on so your infinity Love and miss you prayers Forever my friend.

[@ellencasey8503]

Zero comparison

[@TheLobocantaore]

Bee Gees performances were actually concerts not just a show !!

[@Nixter1974007]

He was completely bang on. Today's music is mostly dreadful.

[@origen64]

Thanks Julian,great video,!

[@bondiblokeoz]

"what does it take to be a pop idol?" Huh? Sounds like the notorious Clive Anderson interview all over again. It starts badly and gets worse. Bee Gees made hugely touching songs, impossibly wonderful harmonies. In Europe they're total heroes, but the UK media never understood em. The brothers weren't their own best publicists: It's all in the Songs, not the singers.

[@Farrah300]

Yeah, and in that interview, the Bee Gees walk out after being insulted. I don't blame them a bit.

[@carmelafiscella3301]

Anche se non capisco l'inglese per me è un piacere vederlo e sentire la sua voce ❤

[@john-fl2qu]

superb harmonies, and songwriters

[@alisoneales]

@TheShade888 I watched it when it was broadcast - I think it was early January 2011.

[@tanyatodd7143]

Great interview!!

[@gentlejoker]

No they don't get it. That's why most mainstream music today sounds like shit. Mainly because they are not composers and they are not musicians

[@payaosuansomchit9568]

I am 75 in Dec. 2019 and i love Robin and his brothers always.

[@Flickit100]

Karaoke..is a good description of today's music

[@glasshalffull8471]

The good old days were just better, there is no comparison today to Beatles, Stones, ABBA, Bee Gees, Motown, no one will be listening to Ed Sheeran or Taylor Swift in 2074.

[@Ayla.00]

♥️

[@andyh8548]

omg Robin answers the first 10 question bye saying, well we were composers, from an early age, ok Robin we get it

[@Farrah300]

We get it, but I'm not sure the interviewer was getting it.

[@robertaclark3286]

Well Andy the interviewer didn't get it. He kept repeating his question.

[@aishagswellnessinabottle2807]

@@robertaclark3286 true, he only listen to himself, shame on him talking like that to an icon!

[@JulianGlass]

To those of you that think Robin was treated unfairly and disrespectfully this is the raison detre of the programme HARDtalk provides "in-depth interviews with hard-hitting questions and sensitive topics being covered as famous personalities from all walks of life talk about the highs and lows in their lives."[

[@gloriamaryhaywood2217]

@@beeharbour Have you ever watched Hardtalk before? That is exactly the format.

[@robertaclark3286]

Julian is right and Gloria, but I think Robin did a great job of answering the questions graciously and intelligently.

[@Evolutionator944]

I Get Robin cause like The Bee Gees my band the gudgetts is a band that are finding it’s footing by areselfs And not go for all that X factor Crap so good one Robin gibb very open on his Beliefs

[@errol-ih4jy]

Barry Gordy was working with class artists , today they are 4th division artists compared to then, waterman came along and then music died, with minogue and jason donavan, and just when you think it cant get worse, cowell comes along with his cronies, and does a hughie green type of bent show, that only promotes his acts, who he says is good, its corruption of the highest standard