Harrison Butker Speech Review

[@josephology3290]

Good thumbnail tittle too as we heard his speech here in Hong Kong.

[@alicegrice8431]

Thank you for all you do.

[@RomeBoys]

Thank you for watching

[@josephology3290]

What’s up with the screen? And a typo in the description box (and, not are). Wish you guys would’ve gotten into his 2 errors: NFP and TLM. Otherwise, great manly speech.

[@RomeBoys]

Thanks for your feedback. Got the typo fixed. First part of the video we had some technical difficulties with the main camera. We get into the TLM in our next episode. Be on the look out for it. Should we do one on NFP?

[@josephology3290]

@@RomeBoys thanks, cool. Should we do one on NFP? Do fish need water? He, and many, are so ignorant about NFP! It is NOT contraception. NFP = good. Contraception = evil. Pope St JPII “NFP is the MOST important pastoral work of the Church today.” A couple can’t “use” NFP with a contraceptive mentality anymore than someone can abstain from Big Mac’s on Fridays with a vomitting mentality. As Dr Scott Hahn’s wife Kimberly said in a podcast, at worse a couple who is selfish and abstains during the fertile time commits a venial sin, not mortal sin. NFP is simply fertility awareness. Truth liberates. God does not want us to ignore our body signs. Can you imagine someone today who is anti-thermometer? No. Well maybe an Amish. We gain knowledge by our temp and then use our FREEDOM to then either go to the doc or not. Pope St Paul VI’s was RIGHT in his Encyclical HV! There is a ginormous difference between NFP and the evil of contraception. To miss this, as Butker seems to, is to miss the boat! Is to miss the field goal! NFP is a very pregnant topic (pun intended) and there’s much ignorance on both sides of it - meaning, ignorance by Rad Trads and Cafeteria Catholics. PS: did you know ALL Christians said contraception was evil / bad / sinful / don’t do it till 1930? Today the Catholic Church is the only game in town still preaching the truth on this. All the other boats threw in the towel on the truth on this. Only the Mother Ship still preaching the truth on this. Truth doesn’t change.

[@josephology3290]

@@RomeBoys absolutely! CCC 2370

[@LifeisPrecious-x2f]

What errors? The speech was excellent, and spot on.

[@josephology3290]

@@LifeisPrecious-x2f 1) his error that NFP is contraception, 2) his error that we should only attend TLM.

[@LifeisPrecious-x2f]

He did say Jesus Christ at least 2 times, and Christ multiple times, the Holy Ghost, and God countless times... perhaps you should pay more attention to the speech instead of nitpicking. "As members of the Church founded by Jesus Christ, it is our duty and ultimately privilege to be authentically and unapologetically Catholic. Don't be mistaken, even within the Church, people in polite Catholic circles will try to persuade you to remain silent." "Congress just passed a bill where stating something as basic as the biblical teaching of who killed Jesus could land you in jail." "Never be afraid to profess the one holy, Catholic, and apostolic Church, for this is the Church that Jesus Christ established, through which we receive sanctifying grace."

[@josephology3290]

To be clear my friend, I truly LOVED Butker's speech. I loved everything about it except the 2 parts he erred on. Are you saying that we should keep silent and not point out these 2 errors that are wrong? That would contradict what Butker said himself: "people in polite Catholic circles will try to persuade you to remain silent." You can't have your cake and eat it too here amigo. Just because he said 98% great things does not alleviate him from the 2% he said in error. Truth matters. It just so happens that Butker was wrong about 2 essentials; namely, 1) Life, and 2) the Mass, which is the Source and Summit of our Faith and where we can receive the Bread of Life. So just because he said key words like Jesus and Holy Ghost and other very wonderful and very true things, it does not trump the fact that he said two erroneous things. This video is titled "Harrison Butker Speech REVIEW". This is what's done in a REVIEW. What went well? What needs improvement? Simple. Try to look at it more objectively with your intellect than with your emotions. That might help. I hope you and I agree that Butker inspired countless souls to SPEAK UP and this is a good thing. Not to remain silent. There is a time to speak up and a time to remain silent. We must speak up if someone says something contrary to our Catholic faith. Butker does not get carte blanche carte just because he said 98 good things and is a famous professional kicker. That would not be fair. He must be held accountable just like he wants all those he called out to be accountable. Thus, we must applaud his 98 good things he said yet hold him accountable for the 2 wrong things he said. But, maybe I'm wrong. You and I have gone back and forth on this quite a bit now. What do OTHERS think about these 2 things please? Was Butker right or wrong to imply NFP was bad and same as contraception? Was Butker right or wrong to say TLM should be a priority such that you should move to a place that has it readily available? I think Butker was WRONG on these 2 counts. TrumpWonJoeCheated thinks Butker was NOT WRONG on these 2 counts. We WELCOME YOUR thoughts. Thanks and God bless.

[@LifeisPrecious-x2f]

All I said was that I did not see any errors in his speech, and that I was fine with you making the same speech defending the NO. The problem I found strange is that the NO crowd I came across are having issues with Trad. Catholics...I meanwhile have no issues with you or others, attending the NO mass, you do your things, I (along with many others) prefer the worship style used by the majority of saints of the church for over a thousand years. Stop insisting otherwise. Look up (deep dive) how Vatican II came about, the motivation and the individuals behind it, if you dare. I did.

[@josephology3290]

@@LifeisPrecious-x2f ah so the truth comes out now… so you’re a V2 denier?!?!

[@LifeisPrecious-x2f]

@@josephology3290 so?