He Rejected her, So she Killed his Mom as Revenge: Case of Mary Yoder

[@HaileyElizabethh]

Vessis early Black Friday sale is on now! Vessi is giving away a pair of socks of your choice to the first 100 shoes sold using my code SOCKSHAILEY. Get your style and size you want now before they sell out! Check out their Early Black Friday sale at vessi.com/HAILEY. Free shipping to CA, US, AU,JP, TW, KR, SGP. "Online Store"

[@Sxomie]

Hi hailey elizabeth you are cute

[@Sxomie]

And i like your videos

[@vickygruber6030]

You didn’t say spooky scary skeleton’s 😢

[@clairepettie]

Eyebrows look great!

[@Jacob-ol9ji]

@@vickygruber6030 it doesn't happen in every video.

[@paigecarlson8782]

the way katie immediately went to saying “my life is over” while being interrogated i have no doubt she is guilty

[@haewonized]

If she didn’t actually do anything, being blamed for a murder even if it’s not true could make a lot of people hate you and believe that you did do it… accusations still affect people’s image. But tbh, idk if it’s Katie or Adam

[@donquixote8462]

@@DimaShirshkov1 Read the site Mary's sister put up. It was absolutely William.

[@MrChopper1209]

@@haewonized I agree. For an innocent person, being interrogated must be traumatic. Uttering that phrase seems like a normal thought process to me. Also, for two juries to be hung means there is no proof beyond a doubt. It doesn’t seem right. Something is not adding up.

[@lil03kay07]

Yall need to look at the backlash that happens when someone innocent is accused. The internet can truly destroy someone.

[@Samnatural]

I personally think it was both William and katie they both helped each other and Adam just got into the mix

[@umokay5516]

People don’t poison someone then keep the bottle of poison in their car with a receipt next to it. Katie totally did it and tried to frame Adam.

[@tiffanysmith4046]

Absolutely. And the timing of the letter being right after he broke it off again. She seriously irks me.

[@MzRage]

I agree

[@oliviamarie6441]

facts! also the fact that the bottle was found 3 months after the fact (unless I misunderstood that). But why would he leave it there for 3 MONTHS!!

[@sexybrainpls]

yeah and wasn’t he on a trip when his mom got sick (when she would’ve been poisoned)??

[@NikkiOliveira]

How could he possibly kill his mom the one who constantly helps him….. like he obviously wasn’t going to bite the hand that litterally feeds him

[@numacamara]

I believe she did it. The way she was quiet when the police brought up the evidence against her and started saying her life is over is very telling.

[@Makberries]

Right that got me to! She just kept mentioning how bad this is FOR HERSELF didn't seem to care about the fact that a woman who considered you family is dead. She was just worried about herself.

[@Makberries]

Plus that initial silence once it was brought up *PARAPHRASING* : "hey we got a shit ton of evidence against you, you wanna explain that?" She went dead silent. Then began panicking likely bc she realized she got caught.

[@dennisemery3175]

So true

[@donquixote8462]

@@Makberries Nope. Read Janine's site. The evidence against William is *astronomical* he used that same colchicine as fertilizer on his plants. He lied on the stand. He went awol from the hospital for hours while Mary was dying. Read the site. It was not Katie 100%

[@MrChopper1209]

I would think my life is over too in that circumstance.

[@cadyfitzgerald3273]

I cannot even imagine my Mum dying suddenly and unexpectedly and then for the police to investigate it as a murder with the murder weapon being found in my car- like how absolutely wack and terrifying, how on Earth are you meant to explain that and prove your innocence?? Thank you for covering this. Mary sounds like she was a wonderful person, I hope her family have managed to heal and find peace.

[@greciahernandez374]

Samee! Even in movies, when I know somehow everything will clear out by the end, I get super stressed, I can’t imagine how that would translate on real life. I would never trust anything ever again xc

[@veledwin1]

Except for maybe her sister, seems like she's only making it harder for everyone else to grieve...

[@chelscara]

@@veledwin1 sister almost seems in on it. Police have cleared him and she's still like "NAH IT WAS THE HUSBAND" Alright babe, whatever you say. Were you gonna get a windfall too? Maybe just be quiet and actually pay attention.

[@moldybongrips]

also just realizing u knew the person who did it and that u introduced them to her ☹️

[@JJones987]

The entire anonymous note she sent, and the planting of the evidence was sniffed out immediately by the investigators. That was a poorly executed gambit. Amateur hour by Katie.

[@JeannieLorene]

I hate how she tried staying away from pharmaceuticals and then she ended up dying by pharmaceuticals:( So sad. She seemed like a great lady. I believe it was Katie. The only time I question "false confessions" is if they've been questioned over 20 hours.

[@kenyaaragon3944]

Forced confessions are like that one confession with the poor guy who have a bullet to the head and was bleeding out and eventually died when he could've been saved cause the police didn't feel like investigating anyone else. This doesn't feel like that at all how do you go from "I know who did it and have evidence y'all" to "My life is over".

[@JJones987]

@@kenyaaragon3944 Exactly right. Detectives work out from those closest to the victim. Once William and Adam were eliminated as suspects, while establishing motive was initially difficult, Katie was the next closest to Mary with opportunity. Katie's digital activity then left a trail of breadcrumbs right back to her and her electronic devices.

[@iden685]

Okay, Bill had access to Katy’s work laptop. But how about her home computer? Her alarming search history? The fact that she knew about the type of drug that was used to kill Mary? The way she acts during the interrogation? Idk, I feel like this is just the end result of a toxic relationship and Katy did it. I however don’t believe that Katy knew that the dosage would be lethal.

[@gertskook]

But isn’t she a nurse ? You are supposed to know how medication works especially with super high dosage

[@delynn111]

@@gertskook she was the office manager/receptionist

[@mrs.sprayberry9977]

She definitely meant to kill her. She’s an insecure little girl who didn’t get her way when Adam finally opened his eyes to her toxicity and she saw an opportunity to hurt him and send him to jail but it backfired on her and that’s why she broke down in the interrogation because she realized she’s not as smart as she though she was

[@Vgs183]

Why else would she do it if she didn’t plan to kill her?

[@Bettersucksaul]

She researched the drugs and dosages. She knew and even if she didn't she would just keep giving it until it finally killed her

[@lieslwright70]

You didn’t mention that Adam had previously been similarly poisoned by Conely or that Conely’s DNA had been found INSIDE the bottle of Colchicine. She definitely did it. Nobody else could have.

[@mizz2ts86]

This part‼️

[@tiffanysmith4046]

I really dont understand how the search history + the dna would not be enough to convict her. She even admitted to purchasing the prepaid cards to buy the colchine. The timing of the poisoning and the letter arriving too consistent with Adam rejecting her then dumping her, it is like c'mon...what more do you need

[@lieslwright70]

@@tiffanysmith4046 100%!

[@AngelaMastrodonato]

I just came across this case and have seen other people commenting about this, but have yet to come across a video about the case mentioning it. I don’t normally go to the trouble of researching deep enough to seek out the actual documentation from the trials. But if that information about Adam also getting suspiciously ill and Katie giving him pills came out with evidence during trial, then I would feel confident convicting her if I was on the jury. Based on what I’m seeing in the videos, either the husband, Adam or Katie could have done it, and I wouldn’t be able to convict due to reasonable doubt. Anyway, if this came out in the trials, I don’t know how Mary’s sisters could still believe Katie is innocent

[@renn8827]

There are a couple of things she missed that other KZbinrs mentioned like this!!!!

[@lacemsboo]

For me personally, it doesn’t matter if you’re doing make up or not. I’m here for your storytelling talent and soothing, calm voice. Keep up the good work, your channel keeps growing because YOU are exceptional.

[@uci1111]

i think it is a little disrespectful talking about murders and doing make up but that’s just my opinion ❤

[@TheRealCrazyCoconuts69420]

@@uci1111 Same, but I think Hailey doesn't focus too much on her makeup, and she's actually respectful which is good.

[@lacemsboo]

@@uci1111 The way she delivers the story is respectful and she makes it about the victim, not the criminals. For some people the make up is a welcome distraction if the topic becomes too graphic or intense, so it serves a purpose in a tasteful way.

[@jumpingfrog740]

@@TheRealCrazyCoconuts69420 but you see, it’s not about what you or any of the other audience members wants, it’s about respecting the victims and their loved ones

[@DIPSAINT]

@@uci1111 do you think she doesn't take it seriously?

[@alyssapappas7518]

I feel she just wanted to make his mom sick so she could be a shoulder to cry on but was so dumb she didn’t realize how lethal the drug was. Also props to you! doing your makeup and relaying all these fine details of this case is challenging and you do it so well

[@ladylark10884]

yep yep i agree, my exact thoughts ^^;

[@samantharainey1777]

It seems like 90% of us listen to you while we work. Lol. Thanks for keeping all of us company during our long days. We listen to you for your great story telling skills. It's not all jumpy and you're very easy to follow along with. It really helps keep the story together especially if you're not watching the screen the whole time.

[@StorieswithT]

Also watch her videos whilst working😊

[@eda.mame_]

Same haha, for some reason it helps me focus

[@JackLapidus]

Same i love listening while I work. Although i do like seeing the starting transition to the finale with a change in appearance. Just a fun way to end a usually sad story.

[@inexena]

I listen to her while I paint, it's very relaxing~

[@trashorphan]

LMAO same!!! currently at work listening to her videos in the background😭😭

[@aanonymousamanda1711]

My dad worked 60 hours a week his whole life to provide for our family. One year before retirement, he was diagnosed with Parkinson's disease and was not able to have the retirement that he and my mom planned for 50 years. There is a certain heartbreak I have for those who work hard but aren't able to enjoy the fruits of their labor.

[@auroradazed]

I think if someone comes into the hospital suddenly extremely ill and the doctors can't figure out what it is, they should immediately do a toxicology test on them. There have been way too many cases of people being poisoned and then it's only discovered after their death from toxicology reports. If they start doing them while the person is still alive, even if the situation seems innocent, it could quite literally save their life. But anyway, this case is so sad and I hope wherever Mary's soul is now that it's somewhere as bright and beautiful as she was. Thank you for sharing her story with us.

[@shanirasor1161]

I work on the computer from home, and I'm all alone in the house 90% of the day. Listening to your videos helps me stay focused, and makes me feel a lot less lonely. Whether or not you do your makeup, or true crime videos, or just sit down and talk about what you've been interested by lately, I appreciate it all!

[@julieboolie4070]

Me too. It's been pretty lonely lately with the holidays so hear you on this.

[@kierarichelle9965]

Same here working from home is soo lonely everyone hypes it up so much

[@valsoto776]

@@kierarichelle9965 going to the office is the trenches. Trust enjoy your freedom. Take up an additional hobby. You’ve been given the invaluable gift of TIME.

[@kierarichelle9965]

@@valsoto776 there is no freedom still a slave to my house working 8 hours a week watching the day go by from the laptop

[@savvy8268]

Can we talk about how extreme her actions were? Even if she was only trying to get his mom sick…He didn’t wanna get back with you and bam! Wow. Just wow.

[@cocothedino_2901]

this girl gets dumped and turns to biological warfare, wild

[@キアラシャイアン]

Sounds like borderline to me

[@aimseysredbeanie]

I live around where this poor lady was killed. I found this video and told my mom about and she said one of her friends was apart of the jury. I asked the lady about it and she said Katie was acting extremely immature throughout the trial and she was laughing. Some sick people out in the world.

[@chelscara]

I don’t understand how anyone could be confused about it. The dad was not going to throw his son under the bus, but Katie would. Katie is a fantastic manipulator 🤷🏻🤷🏻

[@mizz2ts86]

Exactly‼️‼️ Plus the letter…that was all I would have needed as a juror. She knew every detail of that woman’s death. Come on people🤦🏽‍♀️

[@paulmaccaroni]

"If love could have saved you, you would have lived forever." Bone-chilling.

[@kianawhite4386]

Mary sounds like a wonderful person. The way she lived her life is inspiring.

[@mizzapril2009]

I can’t believe Mary’s sister accused her husband. Clearly she never liked the man. That’s really sad to me

[@ItsWaffleTime]

Katie had to have done it or had some part in it. Katie had the incriminating search history and she logged into Adam’s email on her home computer and work computer to order the murder weapon. Just the facts themselves outside of her personality incriminates her as an accomplice at best. On a side note, Janine (or how ever it’s spelt) strikes me as a Karen with a grudge against her sister’s husband.

[@gertskook]

All cause he was finally done with her and the toxic relationship they had. It’s so sad 😞

[@chelscara]

Janine sounds in on out with how she refuses to even consider anyone besides the husband. Like they couldn't agree who to blame so ones blaming the dad and ones blaming the son

[@ucanfearme1893]

I usually just listen to your content on my headphones. I work in a warehouse, so I can't watch your videos, but I listen to them. So whether or not you do makeup during is no concern for some of us. You do what you like. Keep up the great work! Much love from Addison Illinois

[@royroyalu]

I’m a mail carrier and listening to you while working is so enjoyable! Thank you for the work on these videos ❤️

[@stacyketner]

Thank you for always doing job, rain or shine, and through hot and cold, thank you!!!

[@sheilahskinner5688]

Thank you for ur service

[@royroyalu]

@@stacyketner I appreciate that!

[@royroyalu]

@@sheilahskinner5688 thank you very much 🙏🏾

[@mitchliam974]

Saying "my life is over" in front of an officer is the kind of thing an unstable, obsessive ex with murderous intent would say when they get caught. The fact that she couldn't explicitly admit to it during and after the interrogation, it still is very much leaning in her direction.

[@brianna9448]

I read the title and thought, "Well that escalated QUICKLY!" 🤣

[@cassy420blaze]

That's murder for you!

[@heyybrea3241]

seriously i’m like wait what 😂

[@brianna9448]

@@heyybrea3241 Right?!? I was like, "Wait a minute here!!!!"

[@Haley32Morgan]

How would Katie have known where the bottle was, and why would Adam confess that to her? Especially if the supposed motive was bc of her going to the police and his mother urging her to do so. I doubt he would have felt comfortable enough to confide in Katie after that and resume a relationship, and if he killed his mother over that why not Katie?

[@eleanorellis7776]

oh my god from the title of the video, then the way you describe mary in the beginning i was like Ok this is literally the kindest happiest girlboss when is she gonna suddenly snap and become a murderer or something? then u introduced katie and i was like ....oh

[@Dink_13]

Mary is definitely someone I could find myself getting along with, and finding comfort in. Unfortunately someone took that away.

[@ellendaniels8715]

I could totally see her as a wellness KZbinr influencer. She seemed to have enough knowledge and wisdom to give away to thousands. I hope the actual innocents in this case can find some peace.

[@lavisdizzi3903]

I agree completely this was a tremendous loss , it's so sad.

[@Sigma-p8q]

I love how you recognize and remember the victims by always titling the case about them, and talking about THEIR life, instead of focusing on the killers. Really makes you realize how sick the people who take their lives away are on a deeper level.

[@jaiyden..9088]

Hailey literally makes my anxiety go away so quickly

[@cassy420blaze]

What? You ok?

[@hantheminion]

real. like the makeup videos help me wind down so well after school

[@courtneycormier86]

Same

[@momoriing]

Honey, are you okay?

[@justacutepieceofshit]

Same. I think I found my comfort KZbinr 😊

[@kriskeleigh6956]

i remember when you started your channel.... you were so adorably awkward in those, especially if there was a sponsor. like i remember you pulling out a chair lol. but now theres so much more confidence when you talk and do sponsors. i feel like a proud mom lmao. great work girl!!

[@MrChopper1209]

It feels like doing your makeup with a friend while your telling a true story that should be brought to light. I’ll keep watching or listening either way, but it’s like a friend hanging out when there is makeup.

[@BettyWhite2171]

Her reaction to the detective screams guilty. Innocent people don't act like that and say "My life is over".

[@haileyking2276]

i’m a full time cook and listen to ur podcast while i work. i can’t watch it but no matter what u do i’ll always listen!! i love your content for your calming voice, professional talking, and great layout of the cases u cover. never stop doing you!!

[@Uhhfff]

At first I was like “wait her sisters conspiracy theory about bill is kinda convincing” and was leaning towards bill but then you mentioned Katie breaking house arrest and I was like NAH GUILTY. she just confirmed how manipulative Katie is

[@EK-ij9fg]

That’s so stupid lol. Eating at a restaraunt after her life has been put on hold for at least months just for a jury to not be able to find her guilty knowing she’s going to have to do it all over again is enough to convince you she’s guilty? We also don’t know the nature of her violations. House arrest doesn’t mean you can literally never leave your home. There could have been very petty violations that cops exaggerated

[@sleepygirl8005]

@@EK-ij9fg what's stupid is believing Katie is innocent, it is obvious it was her. She was good at manipulating, ofcourse normal people will never understand the reasoning behind psychopaths, because they aren't psycopaths.

[@lisa.222]

It's the fact that she didn't even react when the interrogators told her they found the evidence and that they know it's her. She looked like a child being caught. She didn't even try to defend herself. She just stared.She just was saying her life was over. Thinking only about her life. Like that itself shows she's guilty

[@bananablisss]

I would like a KZbin where all creators just make the content that brings them joy and they don’t have to adjust their creative style just to appease the algorithm.

[@tiffanysmith4046]

I second this!! They should also "do what makes them happy today" ☺️

[@VonSly]

Katie's anonymous letter might as well have been a confession note

[@nikkiej.5875]

I definitely think that Katie meant to kill Mary and it was premeditated. She was working at the same chiropractic medicine office as Mary and she would know how much of a dose to give in order for an overdose to happen because she would have the same expertise as Mary. I feel like it's not a coincidence that she got sick right after lunch and almost anyone had access to the lunch room. The relationship between Adam and Katie was on and off again and the time when Adam broke it off finally, I think she snapped. I think she killed her ex-boyfriend’s mom as both a way to have Adam come crawling back to her and getting back together but also as a way to get back at Adam for rejecting her knowing how close he was with his mom. It just seems pretty excessive to kill her boyfriend’s mom as revenge though but I still think she was responsible for her death and the right person was caught. Also, you can't forget that she was pretty quiet once she was confronted by the police of the evidence against her. She also cried and said her life was over. At that moment, she knew she was caught and she wasn't going home that night. Katie was one of the closest people to Mary and hung out with her the most, so she's the only one I see murdering her and the person I see having a motive. Towards the end of the video, I also saw Katie having a different motive. Maybe she wasn't doing too well financially as she hoped and she was jealous of Mary so killing her had nothing to do with revenge on her ex-boyfriend but she was killed out of jealousy. It could've gone down that way too.

[@brittneybabeee4031]

I am pregnant and my pregnancy is high risk due to chronic illnesses I have but I’ve also had complications since the beginning. This has put me out of work more frequently because my job takes a lot out of me. Right now, I have the flu & I had to call out of work because we have to make sure it doesn’t get bad enough to cause more complications. So, watching your videos has helped me get through the day and your voice/story telling technique is calming despite the stories being told. I’ve had so much anxiety and I’m constantly worried about losing my baby girl so keeping my stress levels down has been pretty hard. Thank you for keeping me company & helping to keep me relatively calm. ❤

[@amblonyxx]

Is your baby girl earthside now??

[@hyukadolll]

your videos are a blessing to everyone on this planet hailey.

[@justindenney-hall5875]

nu-jiyuh "Everyone on this planet"? I know of several people who haven't even heard of her😆

[@rxndini]

Maybe not the criminals that she exposes but everyone else 😂

[@justindenney-hall5875]

@@rxndini Them and a lot of other people, look I like Hailey, but nu-jiyuh needs to relax with that heavy handed compliment, Hailey is not a literal Goddess.

[@hyukadolll]

@@justindenney-hall5875 why are you so pressed over a personal opinion?? you just want attention lmao. go lay down somewhere justin.

[@hyukadolll]

@@rxndini honestly💀

[@crisisvision5394]

i truly just love listening/watching your videos while i’m at work. it passes the time and your storytelling + voice just makes me love it more. thank you for all of your hard work!

[@maliaann6393]

Hey Haley just wanted to say love your videos but if I could make a suggestion, it would be cool if the photos stayed up on screen for a little bit longer because I also do my makeup while I watch your videos and more often than not I find myself having to rewind the video to get a better look at them. Love your videos love your content keep it up girl you're one of my favorites I tell everyone about you, do something that makes you happy today! 🥰

[@hellsvenus]

i second this

[@MrChopper1209]

Pause? That’s what I do.

[@AmandaNoddings]

Agree! There gone before I get my face up to the screen.

[@Vgs183]

That woman accomplished more in college than I have in my whole life. 😮

[@sunnybearbuds]

Same here.

[@mickistover4118]

Omg I’ve missed this!!! I think what a lot of people miss as well is your silly personality. Being fun with the ads and your funny commentary. You’re so interesting, we love the true crime but we can get that anywhere. We are here for YOU

[@provenguiltypodcast]

after seeing the interrogation there’s no way she isn’t guilty or else she would’ve kept denying it rather than saying her life was over

[@arttheclownkid]

It’s so sad that not just one but THREE of her loved ones were deemed possibly capable of hurting her. Especially when she only loved all 3 of the accused. This makes me so upset that someone so good was potentially surrounded by people who were willing to betray her

[@fatimakhan-wy7tl]

I personally love the makeup I like to watch your videos while doing other things and doing my makeup as well. I also should not admit this but I haven't been able to watch your new videos because it just felt like something was missing without it.

[@Sailor.Catracha]

Poor Mary, it's always the good ones taken away from earth. You got to be careful who surrounds you bc many are jealous of your energy/personality. Also, never ever leaving my lunch in the work fridge

[@sabahqureshi4129]

Yay! I'm so happy to see you're doing makeup this video :D It does make it easier for me to listen to the story!

[@noahhh0444]

mary seemed like such a warm and genuine person. it’s so heartbreaking that her life was cut short over something so trivial.

[@ivypng]

hey queen this look is so gorgeous 😍 you dont have to worry about doing makeup or not during these cases. we love watching your makeup skills a lot but also totally understand if it's more work or you'd just rather not do the makeup for any other reasons. your vibe just helps us chill out and learn, we appreciate it either way 💕

[@_haitian_barbie_]

I second that 🙌🤎🤎🤎

[@jadead]

I like it w/o makeup i feel like its better to just focus on the victims and not something else at the same time

[@sevyn1643]

hailey we love your videos so much , I listen to them as I do my makeup and your voice makes it so easy to follow along and your personality coming out when you tell stories makes them much more interesting . thank you for blessing us with amazing contenttt w

[@val6322]

1 thing i admire so much about your videos is the way u humanize all the victims. it rly reiterates that these were real ppl and not just someone who got murdered. u first and foremost make them known for their life and not their death. great work always

[@AnnaMarie831]

For me it doesn’t matter if you do make up or not. I listen to you through my headphones while working. I love listening to you and all your stories 😊

[@aubrey7753]

This case is insane!!!! Who even thinks of doing something like this? I can’t imagine ever wanting to hurt and ex let alone their mom! And poison is such a pathetic move. She can’t face the person she’s hurting. Then she tried to frame the son! She took the life of an innocent woman who lived a beautiful life and was so kind to Katie!!!! This reminds me of gone girl. Shady, spineless, self centered. This is so horrific!

[@kaylee-mariehickman8677]

She was the only one that had access to her home computer and to actually poison Mary! Plus all the knowledge of the poisoning that only turned up after Adam broke up with her. She is GUILTY!

[@Zafaruss]

The doing makeup during the videos just makes the vibe feel a lot more like a friend telling you a story time instead of a serious video essay. The vibes are just great

[@pipermeh3350]

I really do love watching you do your makeup as you talk about true crime because I'm usually listening to you when I'm doing my own makeup and hair and it's very zen for me. However, I've also enjoyed your videos without the makeup too because I think you're very engaging. So whatever works best for you. Please focus on doing this the way that works best for YOU. 😁🎵

[@NFSMAN50]

I randomly discovered your channel, I've always had an interest in true crime. Im glad to be here Hailey, nice to meet you!!

[@oleanderlove6113]

I’ve watched this video about 3x now and each time I’m always impressed by the life Mary had lived. Hearing her story has inspired me so much. May she rest in peace! ❤ 🙏

[@zephyrurchin4763]

Given what we know about Katy, I can honestly say I think she did it. Also, that outro looked SO COOL!! Who did it?

[@OscarLangleySoryu]

Hailey is such a dreamy "girl next door". I love "chatting" with you and you're so pretty and entertaining. Thank you so much. You're one of the few channels I can enjoy without getting stressed out (ironically based on the subject matter LOL)

[@Mlmylji]

Personally I typically prefer without makeup version of these videos bc I find it weird to talk about an entire family getting murdered while the youtuber is doing her eyeshadow or something. It wont matter for me anyway since I mostly listen to the audio only so do what you feel most comfortable in!

[@nsujey6936]

I agree with doing makeup alongside true crime. Its different, original and educational in more than one way. Besides, she's beautiful, its cool watching her do art in her face while listening to these interesting topics + i don't know if its just me but her voice is so satisfying and whenever I want to do some cooking or cleaning or art I put up one of these videos and its the perfect combination

[@asmronthego2146]

When she said “I’m going to my old days with makeup” I checked to see if there was an extra like button for that one😂

[@offgray]

Honestly, the way you talk about things, make-up or not, keeps me engaged. But that's just me. Always excited when I see a new video from you

[@whatdaeisit7592]

took me WAY too long to realise that was a mic and not a censor bar...

[@hygz11]

HLEP

[@cocoapuff8302]

There’s something about ur aura and storytelling that just pulls me in 😭😭💕

[@hantheminion]

IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS ONE I LOVE THE MAKEUP VIDS

[@quinnzel316]

Mary is so inspiring, she is basically exactly the type of person I want to be when Im older

[@hanyearner5000]

she definitely did it, her reaction when interrogated says it all to me

[@Sdchamberlain58]

Honestly idc about your makeup you look good either way 🚫🧢

[@GwahsOnGwahs]

Perfect right in time for me to do my late morning routine lol thank you 😊 back to the roots with makeup. I think respectfully to the story and people in the story its better and more respectful without the makeup.

[@harborbenassa8756]

I love your video style and your respectful delivery. I enjoy the makeup, because it makes these videos feel like girl time bonding while we share stories of people who were wronged, not only keeping their memory alive, but also serving as ongoing evidence that violence against women is disproportionately real. True crime has existed for decades upon decades, and only when it became popular with women did the community come under major fire. There are legitimate critiques, but whether or not makeup is "disrespectful" is entirely determined by the speaker's tone and the video script. Your delivery is always on point, and that's the most important aspect of making true crime content.

[@lovesabbaths]

I love your work Hailey, but I think the makeup visuals are better for conspiracy type videos. Some find that the “makeup true crime” scene is insensitive, because it seems like discussing these crimes are more so for entertainment downplaying what these things has done to others. It’s almost like it glamorizes the crimes to be seen as something that can be easily discussed over such a menial task. Although I love the way you talk about the cases :)

[@mae_222]

I agree, I made a similar comment♥

[@swty.x_]

i agree

[@mae_222]

Hi, sorry for commenting again. Please everyone reading this, help this person’s comment get Hailey’s attention! Please LIKE and COMMENT under this comment! Let’s get this to Hailey’s attention LOVINGLY and RESPECTFULLY. I don’t want hate to go to her, I just want her to become aware of this!💕✨

[@divinenb4133]

EXACTLY

[@alicialovesace7459]

Agree. I love just listening to her

[@deannadanielle]

I like to write while listening to your vids and glancing up to see your progress in the makeup every few minutes😭

[@indowilson945]

I do love the makeup murder content most but will always watch anything you do because I like the content you pick :)

[@nunyabidness6045]

Personally, I enjoy the makeup application. I get bored sometimes with just someone talking. My brain needs more stimulation sometimes to keep it from running away. Plus it's relaxing watching people apply makeup. It reminds me of watching my mom apply makeup when I was a child. 🥰

[@lidianapenner]

IM SO HAPPY WHEN YOU UPLOAD

[@cindyamador1752]

tbh i just love getting ready at the same time you do, while you tell me a story. by the time you're done - usually 40-60min i should be ready too !

[@Luthien_0]

I'm like 90% sure it was Katie. I definitely don't think it was Adam, at least. If it were, he would have had to go to Katie's work computer and purchase the meds from his email so that it looked like Katie did it but was trying to frame him. I don't think the typical day-to-day murderer would come up with such an elaborate plan. Framing your girlfriend by deceiving people into believing that she's framing you? I don't think so. It could be William I guess, but I'd need more information.

[@heIIopenny]

this case made me cry for mary. i will always remember her, a legend and a role model ♡

[@hantheminion]

ive missed these videos sm i’ve been wondering where they went😭

[@lydiamecham8936]

personally i like your videos better with the makeup visuals. it helps me focus on the story better. but i understand why some people would consider it disrespectful and i would watch your videos either way

[@Mkayyy]

This title caught me off guard 😭 people are ill

[@hygz11]

same 💀

[@Megan-rh3hu]

thank you for bringing back the makeup!!! youre right it makes it more engaging!

[@wingsloverr]

literally was waiting for your videoooo 😭

[@infamouzy]

I loved your makeup and true crime months ago Im so glad you did it again

[@clairepettie]

I always want to give the "woman scorned" the benefit of the doubt, because it's a misogynistic stereotype based completely on men's interpretation of women's behavior, (and supposedly 'out of control' emotional states,) but I just can't understand Katie's actions if she wasn't the killer. If it wasn't Katie, neither her behavior - nor Adam's - make any sense. Aside from her creepy 'poisoning' research, and specifically using _his_ email at _her_ house, why would Adam keep the bottle in his car after Mary was murdered? Is her defense claiming that Adam or Will went over to Katie's to use her computer for this one order before pretending to be out of town? If it were Will who killed his wife, why would he order the poison under his son's name from Katie's house? Why would Will plant the bottle in his own son's car?

[@riahbruh7372]

I absolutely love that you’re back doing makeup. It’s really not about the makeup at all, it was your humour, it was your facial expressions, it was everything. I love your podcast, but THIS is where I found you and this is what I’ll always come back to! 😭🫶🏼

[@suchlanguageface]

Well done, Hailey. I haven't seen your true crime/makeup videos before - but the format totally works for me. You always cover cases respectfully, intelligently and in an engaging way. The makeup visual really does help me focus on the information, which is a fun surprise for me. Nice one ✨❤️👍

[@blc28x]

I MISSED these videos!!! Thank you 😊

[@Prxncessvaleria]

Btw I love every single one of your videos, weather or not your doing make up. I really enjoy your fun personality or just hearing about your day, even if you think that’s boring, it’s not boring to me. You’re very creative and you have very nice relaxing vibes. I watch your videos to start my day or when I’m feeling alone. Whatever content you make, I promise you, you make great content. I truly don’t like many KZbinrs, but you’re one of my favorites, I appreciate how real and authentic you are with us and you should do whatever you want in your videos regardless if there’s a mistake and you feel embarrassed or something, I truly don’t mind. I like just seeing you do your thing and be a creative person. ❤

[@carriekitchen5796]

On another note I need to know what she’s using for her eyeliner. It’s flawless

[@amthompson]

i know there’s some controversy about doing makeup while talking about cases but personally, i adore it. whenever i drag myself out of bed at 7am to do makeup and get ready for work, i like doing my makeup with you

[@BELLA5678-B]

❄️ I hope the rest of your 2022 goes well. And happy holidays Hailey! ✨

[@aishabutler7248]

Yay love these types of videos, thank you for bringing it back

[@captainjetpack]

Hailey is the best at this. Not to name names, but others are disrespectful by making faces and inappropriate comments. Hailey is a beautiful girl, inside and out, and presents these topics professionally. The make-up is really interesting too! As a painter it helps me develop my craft by watching her techniques.

[@emilynotley6627]

I can think of one huge true crime KZbinr who just makes so many inappropriate dark humour jokes but godforbid ya say anything 🙄highly doubt the families of victims appreciate the “dark humour”

[@Maya-Hayden]

You dont watch alot of true crime then. Hailey is great though, maybe your personal favourite.

[@captainjetpack]

@@Maya-Hayden, You don't know me, don't pretend you do.

[@paradisdiaz4693]

@@captainjetpackthis is so funny 💀