Hindustan Kay Halaat, Musalman Kia Karain - Part 1 - Javed Ahmed Ghamidi

Hindustan Kay Halaat, Musalman Kia Karain - Part 1 - Javed Ahmad Ghamidi
ہندوستان کے حالات، مسلمان اب کیا کریں ؟
🔴 SUBSCRIBE 🔔: kzbin.info?s...
▶ About Javed Ahmed Ghamidi:
Javed Ahmed Ghamidi is a Pakistani Muslim theologian, a Quran scholar, and an educationist. Mr. Ghamidi is a student of Maulana Amin Ahsan Islahi and Maulana Abul A’la Maududi. Mr. Ghamidi has authored several books, including the bestseller ‘Meezan’, in which he presents a comprehensive treatise on the entire content of Islam. Mr. Ghamidi is a researcher and a critical thinker who has challenged many aspects of the traditional Muslim schools of thought on the basis of evidence from Quran and sunnah.
▶ About Ghamidi Center Of Islamic Learning:
"Ghamidi Center of Islamic Learning", an initiative of Al-Mawrid US, is established with a single purpose, to educate people of all ages about moral, ethical, and humane values as taught in Islam. Our aim is to separate history and culture from Islam and teach it in its purest form as a field of knowledge and not enforce it as a creed. We base our instruction method on argument and logic and encourage healthy criticism. An institute where traditional and historical knowledge can be understood as well as challenged with reason.
▶ DONATIONS: www.ghamidi.org/donate/
▶ CONNECT with us:
◼ WEBSITE: www.ghamidi.org
◼ FACEBOOK: / ghamidicil
◼ KZbin: / ghamidicil
#GCIL #JavedAhmedGhamidi #QnAGhamidi #AlMawridUS

[@kanikachawla1498]

Thanks a ton, Shivani for this brilliant translation. Ghamdi sb's sophisticated urdu could only have its full effect with such an excellent translation. More power to you.

[@shivanimakker7618]

Thank you :)

[@karl_marx3466]

Just shocked to see you here Well

[@arizakram6517]

Nice sister

[@Junaid6646]

@@shivanimakker7618 A humble request to you : Please translate the second part also. Will be grateful to you. 😊

[@jitendrakumar-wv3fh]

Mai Hindu hu , love from India,ghamidi sahab❤️🙏

[@skintalk22]

We need people like him even more..For world peace.excellent intellectual and so clear n honest a man ..Great !💐

[@hearthacker5565]

Omg he is such a logical scholar. He is totally at some different level. Whole Muslim community is proud of him

[@EmonKhan-wx1rj]

Ghamidi is big tribe in Saudi Arabia

[@jehangirshahzada2528]

اللہ تعالٰی آپکو اور جناب جاوید غامدی صاحب کو جزاے خیر عطا فرمائے آمین

[@Suhaylan]

These videos should be in English with voice over for English speaking audiences. All lectures and videos of Ustaz should be with English subtitles & voice over for the international audiences.

[@haafizsaadaatsayyad6935]

AS AN INDIAN MUSLIM I THINK ONLY WAY FOR MUSLIMS TO LEAVE PEACEFULLY IN THIS WORLD IS COME BACK TO BOOK OF ALLAAH SWT “QURAN UL KAREEM” and MESSENGER OF ALLAAH “RASULULLAAH SAW”

[@asad-kc8zf]

64000$ question is how you define “only way”.

[@shaalvinsharma3971]

I thought Ghamadi ji will also address this emotional issue as a muslim Or a pakistani but to hear it with rational approach based on ground realities was refreshing.

[@asad-kc8zf]

I am sure you can find some rational hindus in India too, unlike the emotional followers of certain fundamental hindu party.Peace.

[@ghufranshareef3699]

India was going to be an Asian giant but hindutwa issue is destroying the country. India is hindu majority country and it had to be so.

[@mehroseemehrosee3887]

@@ghufranshareef3699 Asian giant......? You mean economic powerhouse? Well that would have been if religion could have been kept away from political domain. China for instance only started growing after cultural revolution, which was basically a movement to do away with religion. India unfortunately is an incredibly religious country. There are regions in India particularly the south of India which has somehow managed to keep religion out of politics to a large extent hence you can see it’s double digit economic growth compared to north India which has become a basket case to study how religion in politics results in lack of economic prosperity.

[@ms.k7807]

Believe or not he almost spent his life to address pakistani Muslims ..pointed out the faults and misconceptions in religious and politics.

[@theaassiim]

What a gem of a human being he is. I don't see any other Muslim scholar today who is this unbiased, practical, and logical in their approach May Allah bless you Ghamdi Sahab, and give you long life so we can have more of your teachings.

[@saadiiaa]

I totally agree with you … in fact couldn’t said it better : Ghamdi sahib is a Gem no doubt

[@ghanwamaqsood9576]

You should listen to Sahil Adeem ...you will forget Ghamdi Sir

[@NaushadShafkat]

Brilliantly put! His very presence during our times makes it compulsory for us to offer 'Shukr'.

[@falakjahan8412]

100% true

[@shahzilbaloch5210]

@@ghanwamaqsood9576 no doubt he has lot of knowledge

[@Sawleyhuh]

Can't wait for Part 2,3,4,5,6

[@junaidyousuf4943]

7,8,9,10

[@devotedhermit2111]

@@junaidyousuf4943 11,12,13,14,15

[@nazmabegum850]

اللّہ تعالیٰ آپ کو جزائے خیر عطاء فرمائے آمین

[@javedalihuma]

I am proud to born in Ghamidhi sahab"s Era.

[@yasarmoin]

Love from india 🇮🇳 Ghamidi sahab 💖

[@no_comparison1157]

Ghamidi sahab you’re an amazing scholar and person.

[@lafzesani]

This should be taught to the leaders everywhere - not only south Asia. Incredible.

[@OppoF-hv9li]

کیا تجزیہ ھے۔۔۔۔۔اللہ آپ کو لمبی اور صحت مند زندگی عطا فرمائے۔۔۔

[@zainiqbal3875]

A masterpiece to understand current political situation. Another series " bat ye hai" is also very useful to understand all this.

[@sameer-111]

Thank you for this sir

[@YouTuberbypassion]

Bhai, kindly share the link of bat ye hei.

[@YouTuberbypassion]

Share the link, kindly.

[@salmanameen7657]

bilkul

[@AftabKhan-lg8uc]

What is the best on this explanation? He is away from the point of discussion. To my understanding, in today’s world Rule of Law is prime importance for any country.

[@abdullahelannoor5173]

Love and respect from 🇮🇳

[@charuchandradiwan192]

What a great man and great talk.

[@reyshaconsulting5550]

Superb.. Yes its human psychology across all religions which discriminates.

[@JamPacked-]

What an explanation . . . so natural and logical . . .!

[@ShahudRShami]

bohat khoob, kia zabardast explain kia Ghamidi sb ne

[@no_comparison1157]

As an Indian Muslim I completely agree with Ghamidi sahab.

[@naseer5424]

TRUE Ghamidi sahab... what a introductory analysis. Waiting for next Part 2....

[@faisalkhan5332]

Allah pak Ghamidi Shb ko Sehat Izat Arooj wali lambi umer ataaa farmay.

[@hussainhafidh1075]

Thank you Hasan bhai, And Ghamdi sahab for having a discussion/ talk on this topic.

[@Shaily73]

Din bhar khud islam countries declare karke they want Hindu can’t even bring their religion up ….what a joke

[@GG-ft1bf]

GG (Great Ghamidi). Teacher of teachers. Hero of heroes. Ocean of knowledge. The best philosopher, theologian, educationist, researcher, critical thinker, Mujaddid-e-Islam. Love you Ustad-e-Mohtaram.

[@mubinurraheman3018]

Great personality laeqe ahtram great schaller of the era ,JAVED AHMAD GHAMIDI,lot of love 💕💕💕💕 from India 👌👌

[@ashokdullu]

Ghandi sahib …Aadab Arz…..Request you to please offer translations as many of my friends cannot understand Urdu.At least this clip.🙏🙏

[@honorhonor3352]

That’s too bad. Among other things, he is saying that partition of India was never a solution. But that’s what happened. Both countries were made under the principle of “Nation State”. Under that principle Neither India was made for Hindus nor Pakistan made for Muslims. It’s the religious movements that has given it a different shape and ideology. Muslim of Pakistan are not like the king of older days when they used to grant right to certain groups (for example of a particular religious group) depending upon their liking. Minorities in both countries are equal citizens of their respective states. He also said that although America is not perfect but still is the best example of a nation state.

[@robbykiller2323]

Hlo... Dullu saab please reply

[@falakfayaz3457]

Thank you for such an excellent translation, Shivani. Your translation makes a world of difference for the non-Urdu speaking audience.

[@shivanimakker7618]

Thank you!

[@chandjikoul6038]

Good massages are given in every religious Scriptures, Some opportunist Preachers interpret in Such a way that only Culminates into dissicions among masses Symptoms emanate in conflicts among religious Communities or between the groups of the Same Community.Javaid Sir has enumerated in a beautiful way but if good people Come farward then what would happen to the Profession of those who brought the world people to the precipice of desaster that Saudi Arabia realised Late and death blow to Indian economy who are bringing huge affluence into India from gulf Countries.Stay Happy,God is with all.

[@imranimran3736]

Ghamdi sahib is a man ahead of his times. Despite being hounded out of his own country by extremists he bears animosity towards none and continues to preach a model of inclusion for all humankind and not just Muslims. May his vision one day be accepted by all of humanity for the betterment of this world.

[@ikhan9666]

Ameen.

[@muhammedawan4414]

Masha Allah a great scholar Kia khoob surat andaz e biyan

[@arshkhan4612]

As an Indian 🇮🇳 I'm shocked to see such a gem of a person ❤️ ...such great intellectuals we need .. There's a famous saying .. A lot of people died ,Not "FOR PAKISTAN" But "BECAUSE OF PAKISTAN" indian+ Bangladeshi+ Pakistani Muslims .. Imagine how bigger say Muslims would have had in WORLD AFFAIRS 🔥

[@SuperMickey1967]

You have to read history in its entirety.

[@ranasattarrajput]

Its you indian Muslims idealogy not our Pakistani peoples ideology . Our forefathers secrifies their lives for Pakistan . And for your kind information your forefathers voted for Pakistan .

[@irfannazir5671]

Ask you government first if it consider you an Indian after CAA? LOL. You don't have a say in your own country. How would you have say in the World Affairs? I can quote many such useless sayings also. doesn't mean these are credible sayings. Only Pakistan raise a strong voice for Muslim affairs whether it is Kashimir, Palestine, Rohengya or any other place. Can you or your leader dare to say a word under RSS India?

[@jani1940]

Tum churia pehn kar zilat uthao hum azadi mian jity hain pichwara cheer k 😡

[@arshkhan4612]

@@SuperMickey1967 I have .... Give me logical reasoning if I'm wrong

[@shakeelsait9577]

What a gem of a man he is who has such an unbiased understanding of the present situation in the world. Very good explanation and very good solution to the crisis of both India and Pakistan and we should learn to live in a democratic way and to behave as human beings.

[@buttaurangzeb5412]

Javed ghamadi is just love it allah aap ko sehat aur tandrusti day all time great for me I don't think any other better prayer than this prayer allah qabool farmaey aameen aurangzeb butt from Switzerland daska sialkot siranwali ❤

[@fayazulkarimmemon7705]

Ghamidi Sahab I love you, your thoughts, ur way of educating Muslims. Allah bless you.

[@NaushadShafkat]

Brilliant! Just brilliant. In awe of Ghamidi Sb's scholarship. No words to praise this analysis. Speechless.

[@jedahsaudia1746]

ماشاءالله تبارك الله

[@syedzaidi6241]

He is one of The INTELLECTUAL OF ISLAMIC UMMAH OF THIS CENTURY SHARIQ

[@sameer-111]

Speechless ahead his wisdom...

[@omprakashsoni6823]

ALLAH KI MARZI KE BAGER PATTA BHI NAHIN HILTA HAIN. YE SAB ALLAH KI MARZI SE HI HO RAHA HAIN.

[@aneessiddiqui119]

Is tarah k programme badastoor jari rakhen Nawazish hogi.indian hissaas muslim.

[@therahehaqfamily1416]

God bless you

[@Ali-boy444]

Ustaaz imaam🖤

[@majidkhan8767]

Excellent explanation without any bias to any person or country. God bless u, sir.

[@Iqbalpsx]

Great man

[@MirajKhan-jf9vr]

Mai indian se hu.yaha halat to kharab hai per yaha ke muslimo ke sabse bade supporter yaha ke hindu aur judiciary hai.aaj bi yaha judiciary zinda aur hindu bhayo ka support.aur mumbai me rahta hu shayad aapko yakin na yaha shiv sena ki sarkar per yaha sabse jyda safe hai.sirf ek bjp ko chodke sari siyasi partyo ko muslim ko alag nahi samazte hai.

[@dr.mohammadashrafpal6066]

تقسیم ہند سے متعلق آپ کی تفصیلی راے کا منتظر رہوں گا

[@mrcool6905]

A superb lecture. I think, Ghamidi Saheb is first a human being & then whatever & wherever you may keep him. An living legend who is totally unbiased & prejudiced. May he live long.

[@mrcool6905]

Pl. read UNPREJUDICED in place of PREJUDICED.

[@muhammedsultan4017]

نہایت شاندار

[@SyedMaazAnsar]

Jazakallah khair sir, this was a very important topic and much needed

[@mohiuddinahmadsiddiqui8768]

JazakAllah p khairan.

[@ZK-lb5rs]

Shukriya Hindustan ki halaat par

[@junaidbagwan5523]

Thank you for doing this...much needed...

[@abdullahsayed9631]

جناب غامدی صاحب نے اصل سوال کا جواب ہی نہیں دیا ۔ان حالات میں ہندوستانی مسلمان مسلمان کیا کریں؟؟اس کا کوئی جواب ہی نہیں دیا؟،

[@KAMALK320]

Grearest scholar of the era

[@stesmuzammil7917]

amazing analysis

[@AsimSalimMalik]

I would respectfully disagree with Ghamidi Sb's view that the situation in Pakistan and India is same. Well, it's true that the non-muslims are considered minorities in Pakistan however, these minorities are not facing persecution, oppression and elimination from the government or the huge majority of people living in Pakistan. In India, these things are official government policies. Sir you always drage and compare situation in Pakistan and its government /people to the situation/issues in other countries. I request you to stop that and just focus on the issue and suggest future strategies to the muslims in India that they could resolve these issues peacefully.

[@khansherani]

Ghamidi sb did not equate both countries on this line, but he equated that majority in both the countries think, that this country solely belongs to them on basis of religion, and other communities cannot claim equal status

[@DanishAli-rm2ky]

Ghamdi didn't compare conditions of minorities in both countries. He described that the principle which is being followed in both side of border by majority is that this country only belongs to them and they will decide the rule of law, their identity and how they should treat minorities in their country.

[@jaleelkhan9763]

Mr.Ghamidi has brought home clearly the point. It is for the biased minds to not to understand clearly.

[@anunaykumar9736]

1000 forced conversions happened in Pakistan last year and have been happening for long If something like this happened in India there will be huge outcry Persecution of minorities is normalcy in pakistan Pak and India's treatment of minorities can't even be compared

[@AishaKhan-jz7nb]

Very true mashaallah … respected ghamdi sahab 😊

[@faizanrashid8209]

Amazing translation, Shivani. Keep up the good work.

[@shivanimakker7618]

Thank you

[@OdlyAK]

thank you for raising such topics

[@shaiksharjeel0777]

MashaAllah !!! What a great Intellectual Ghamdi Saab is 👍

[@shaguftagul3706]

Great scholar

[@gachi_school]

Amazing perspective....waiting for part 2. Keeping creating such content. Jazakallah

[@sumairarathore6337]

Bahoot Alla MasaAllah

[@ZaminAliQadri]

مجھے زیادہ نہیں فقط اتنا کہنا ہے کہ 1947 میں لوگوں نے الگ ملک بنا کر غلط فیصلہ اور کم فہمی کا ثبوت دیا۔

[@tmkirfan]

In Taza Khudaon Mein Bara Sub Se Watan Hai Jo Pairhan Iss Ka Hai, Woh Mazhab Ka Kafan Hai Country, is the biggest among these new gods! What is its shirt is the shroud of Deen (Religion) 15:33min excellent, thank you

[@NaeemZarrar]

A very LOGICAL sum-up

[@arizakram6517]

Pakistan should stabilize itself politically and economically and then it's leadership should also officially facilitate the immigration of urdu- speaking muslims of India to Pakistan especially from Uttar Pradesh and Bihar.

[@aliaghaus1670]

Ghamidi sahab please speak in easy Urdu. I would really appreciate that. When you quote Iqbal’s poetry please translate it into easy Urdu. Don’t use difficult words.

[@mehran568]

I totally agree with Ghamidi sahib, Division was not the solution. Further divisions are not the solution. All parties should Accept the situation. For us Pakistanis as well, accept that all religions, castes and races in Pakistan are EQUAL.

[@MSS-nt9ko]

Political equality is fine, but if you want other religions to be treated at the same spiritual level as Islam then you are basically denying Islam. Because God Himself says in the Quran that the acceptable religion with God is Islam. Its ok to have sympathy with non Muslims, I have a lot of sympathy and soft corner for non Muslims. I want Muslim majority nations to accord all kinds of political rights to non Muslims, give them first right to the resources of the country as well. But if someone demands other religions be treated on the same level spiritually as Islam, then sorry… InshaAllah that day should never come.

[@MSS-nt9ko]

In a similar fashion I don’t expect non Muslims to see Islam at the same spiritual level as their own religion. To them their way, to me mine. I don’t mind if they see muslims spiritually deficient per their theology.

[@shuaibnaqvi5168]

What a great explanation ,he is a unique scholar,a great human being

[@qaisartufail4341]

Always exceptional, Javaid Ahmed Ghamdi. A clear headed scholar.

[@majidsuhail5147]

Nice interpretation in historical context.

[@roshaanehzafar7336]

God bless Ghamidi sb.

[@changezkhan2721]

Excellent

[@mohdshafi6044]

What a great explanation Hats off sir

[@MahiAparichit]

Aap india ke muslmano ko pak kyo nhi bulate

[@mariasea3869]

things settle down for peace but how to move forward is a question.

[@zamanpeykar3474]

Very nice 👌

[@najamulhusnainkhan2690]

Respect!

[@muhammadshakir5452]

Kiya kehnay Ghamidi sb.

[@kamranhashmi009]

Mind blowing analysis!

[@basicenglishknowledge3815]

Nice bilkul drust....

[@mohdshafi6044]

A good series

[@fahadnasirkamala]

Fantastic analysis ⭐️

[@hasanarshad2]

I believe Dr Javed Ghamidi is the best Islamic scholar of this time, however I disagree with him regarding this specific political view, Pakistan is a blessing for Pakistanis, if we didn't have Pakistan, we'd be dealing with the terror of hindutva

[@idelawebsols]

That is a pure speculation. The formation of Bangladesh proved that Pakistani scheme was not entirely beneficial for the Muslims.

[@muhammadalifaruqi1928]

Exactly how??

[@MSCH1954]

I think you should read some history and learn some mathematics. Muslims were biggest single community in united India. On the other hand Hindus were never a nation, nor they were united. An upper caste Hindu hated lower class Hindu more than he would hate a person of other religion. Pakistan was created for those Nawabs and Landlords who were scared that democracy and future land reforms promised by Congress would destroy their power in united India. Pakistan is a blessing for those Nawabs, Khans, Landlords and off course for those who looted and occupied properties and wealth left by rich Hindus and Sikhs. Pakistan is also a blessing for those incompetent illiterate and backward people who have ruled this unfortunate nation since it's creation. For ordinary people nothing has changed and it's going worst with each passing day.

[@Tabishislive]

You guys are just Afraid of your death..... You Guys has forget the Book of Allah... Allah gave you the mission to spread the truth to non Muslim community.... But you guys choose Exit Gate to leave your responsibilities.... So According to you prophet and their companions were wrong and didn't want to go anywhere to spread the Word of God.... They should have choose Life instead of Their Responsibilities?... In short you guys choose your 50-60 years of your life instead of Your Responsibilities?wow incredible.... Turuuu moozlim bro👌

[@hasanarshad2]

@@idelawebsols Bangladesh is a vassal state of india- while Pakistan isn’t

[@shariqueadeebansari7484]

Impressive

[@uzainsaeedqadri9911]

I am in India but main dara hua hu.

[@tajammalhussain31]

وہ جہاد کریں اپنے لیے اور دین کے لیے

[@dryasir786]

💕

[@adeebfeeroz3434]

Neither extremist muslim of Pakistan nor extremist hindu of Indian want to live peaceful. And they excite they just shake whole nation from its root. And by and large human accept what is beneficial for him.

[@faheem0547]

Thanks, as an Indian muslim I am absolutely agree with professor Ghamdi Sahab. Hasan sahab agr division na hota to firkaparast takato ko iqtidaar na milta. We don't have enough numbers.

[@mohdabduljaleel01]

ab hogaya division ab kya krna hae bs us pr fiqr karna hae

[@revolutionary5577]

U R still living in fool's paradise , everything is crystal clear now in india since 2014 .. majority population made calls openly for minority genoside

[@faheem0547]

@@mohdabduljaleel01 yes dear the damage has been done, I was just clarifying the invalidity of division as Hasan sahab said the division was very much reliable n valid. Yeah now we r working on progression n we have to do.

[@saadsalman6641]

First interior minister Sardar Patel was firqa parast. Congress had many leaders who were firqa parast at their core. Agar division na hota, to pseudo secularism ziada jaldi reveal hojata

[@techihandle]

@@faheem0547 work on progress, how Jews can dominate US politics, muslim also can do the same.

[@shoaib_teli09]

❤❤❤

[@yousafkhalid4870]

Very good knowledge thanks Love for Ghamidi sahib and Hassan Ilyas sahib......

[@IsrarAHMAD-iz9xj]

Very wise.

[@leninmaududi3134]

Indian me ab bhi democracy hai. Indian par hamesha ilzam lagta hai ki ham pakistan parst hai aur aap ka Indian muslim par banaya gya video isi disha me jaayega. Dusri baat Indian muslim aur khastaur se ham jaise converted musalman khud ko videshi nahi mante. India me muslim haquq k liye hamare hindu bhai zyada lad rhe hain

[@deltafirexmaster5290]

Javed saheb brilliant analysis

[@reyazahmed856]

I appreciate your knowlege sir. The way you have explained, is commendable. We all must understand the core value of your your views. Will our leaders accept it with open heart. I think no, because their style to rule will come in between.

[@rixgamer5748]

I am from India