Historian Reacts to Assassin's Creed 3

[@apanapandottir205]

She's really cool , but I'd love to see her react to something where she can comment for on the historical context and accuracy on things. This one is mostly fights haha

[@kiaws1695]

@Werner Pfeifenberger why not?

[@kiaws1695]

@Werner Pfeifenberger „her type“??

[@EmptyHand49]

@Werner Pfeifenberger There are people like that but you're just jumping to conclusions about her

[@layerqui]

@Werner Pfeifenberger please change as a person 🙏

[@skinlord2902]

@Werner Pfeifenberger lolol spoken like a true racist while trying to rationalize it. gtfo

[@AssassinEmbers]

Connor is an underrated Assassin. I wish Ubisoft continued connor's story apart from a comic

[@guard-keywolf]

For real

[@Sadra_vi]

@@sparkyphantom92 yeah, pretty much sadly

[@hannibalburgers477]

Lol no.

[@CenoriaWoah]

Haytham solos.

[@brendanjames7551]

He was good but to be honest, wasn't even the most interesting character in the story. I was far more invested in Haytham

[@JPMClientHosting]

According to the lore, Haytham's son Ratonhnhaké:ton is of Mohawk decent, which is part of the Iroquois confederacy. He is later named Connor after joining the Assassins. There is another scene in the game where Connor talks to Benjamin Franklin and Franklin talks about the pursuit of liberty and freedom and Connor replies, "Says the man who owns a slave." Assassin's Creed did not let American history off the hook in this game. Hopefully Gameology makes another video of AC3 for this historian to react to.

[@BRay-nw6lt]

actually it was Samuel Adams but you're right

[@Dragosmom.]

@Orobas yes he did.

[@Dragosmom.]

@Orobas honestly i idolize Franklin to a degree. I don't think he was a bad person but i do think he would be if he suddenly got revived and had to love in today's world. I doubt even he'd be able to adapt to such radical change. (imo) Historical figures shouldn't get a free pass because our morals have changed although we shouldn't judge them as harshly as we would a modern day person doing the same thing. I look at him owning a slave as a similar transgression to being *accidently* and *unwittingly* abusive to a child under their care. This is because the slave was totally reliant on the man to survive and was legally there property just like children are today. It's not an exact analog but close enough to hopefully explain what i mean. Even if he never hurt them physically being treated as someone else's property is mentally damaging. I don't really blame him just like i don't totally blame my uncle for being unable to open up about his feelings. I never said i thought bad of the man anyway. He did amazing things and was a visionary of his time. If i lived back then I'd probably think him wildly progressive and insane at best. Now i seem his as old and outdated. It natural.

[@fluidthought42]

AC3 was odd. It tried to be cortical and balanced but also had to introduce a cartoonishly evil character in Haytham's patsy. Meanwhile it tried to maintain both the more personal features of the US founders while also maintaining their decorum and stiffness. It felt like a weird stage play of American history than actual characters emoting.

[@GrimViridian]

@Orobas and im tired of people claiming stuff like this was "a product of its time" there is and never has been an excuse for racism, they knew what they did was wrong

[@ThePeteriarchy]

She's awesome but the early parts of AC3 aren't the most well-integrated with the time period's history. I hope she'll be reacting to latter parts of the game that are set in more significant events in the Revolution, like Revere's ride or some of the huge battles that Connor gets caught in the middle of, so we get to see her perspective on how the game ties those events with the Assassin vs Templar fiction.

[@Rand0m_Mex1can14]

US historian reacts to Star Wars battlefront two.

[@strangeroos]

Nah man, you gotta ask space force for that

[@ThorKill.Beowulvf]

@@strangeroos now you gotta ask the top secret task force correlation between the CIA and SpaceX

[@yotaruvegeta]

The greatest moment in US history

[@koraegi]

What

[@Rand0m_Mex1can14]

@@koraegi how do you not know what Star Wars is?!

[@fiiv3s]

I love this woman's energy. We need more of her. Have her react to the latter part of the game with Conner.

[@derrickstephens1565]

YES

[@BrahmaDBA]

As a person who is fascinated with history, Assassins Creed games always tickles my fancy. The Hashashin and Richard the Lionheart in ACI, The Borgias in AC: Brotherhood, Ottomans and Suleiman the Great in AC: Revelation, The Founding Fathers in AC: III, The Rogues Gallery of Pirates in AC: Black Flag, The French Revolution in AC V, Victorian Era London in AC Syndicate, the Peloponnesian Wars in AC Odyssey were all like amazing easter eggs for a history enthusiast like myself and I am sure many others. Can't wait to see AC Mirage as it looks like to be set in the Golden Age of Islam during the Harun Al-Rasyid Caliphate in Baghdad with the fictitious One Thousand and One Nights as its mystical backdrop.

[@Strife49c]

So we're gonna get a pt. 2 right? With Connor's part of the game?

[@matejadjordjevic5317]

They should. There is much more of U.S. history that happens through Connor's part of the game than Haytham's.

[@ryujisama]

While a little light on the historical commentary, I kinda enjoyed this one. I also liked how she alluded to the real Knight's Templar and how they used their influence to help shape things from the shadows, which is less and less to what the Assassin's Creed series began to do after this game, I think; and started leaning HEAVILY into the supernatural/superscience aspect of it.

[@kanewilson8624]

1:16 fun fact: that particular kid would grow up and Assassinate Abe Lincoln

[@bluej511]

Such an underrated game. The new remastered edition is awesome as well. My first play thru i accidentaly killed Washington lo.

[@CaNNoNF0DDa]

Historian reacts: giggles uncontrollably for 10 straight minutes. ;p

[@angelicangel32]

It's such a terrible habit.

[@frostieschocopop]

She's so cool!! Can we have more of her, please?!

[@dylanrogers6100]

Why would they show her the Haytham part? Connor meets the most historical figures and is part of the historical events

[@TheJadedJames]

I feel like they just defaulted to showing her the opening. But it was a complete waste to not show her later segments of the game that depict the revolutionary war. That is what you'd want to see a historian react to

[@phantomgamer9264]

@@PaganMin671 fr they had a episode where weapon experts react to combat in AC games and they barely have the games with *good combat* any focus. They just wanted reactions out them with the RPG games.

[@poppoppy7375]

The historical commentary is light, I think its mostly due to this being mostly haytham clips when Connor saw more historical stuff. but I like her

[@Asiangeez]

Wow, loved her reaction. Would watch so much more with her.

[@LeoCharles]

She's awesome! Bring her back soon! ☺

[@razztastic]

I like how she said "Why'd you have to shoot a musket and miss?". It's like anybody who knows anything about flintlocks knows how terribly inaccurate they can be. Let's also give her a briefing on the game next time, shall we? It pains me to hear her guesstimate the game taking place 100 years before it *actually* does.

[@jtmichaelson]

Dawnyale is hilarious. A lot of fun to watch.

[@GamingMyWay]

Love these videos should do more with her and the next game should be!!! drum roll.........Red Dead or Ryse son of rome

[@lemaygaming6952]

Ryse isn’t set in America, lol.

[@GamingMyWay]

@@lemaygaming6952 Today it is >.> I need it

[@SHADOW-rw5tj]

Damn I am actually playing assasims creed 3 right now

[@o_o1515]

I was playing it like a day ago 😂

[@Neph1944]

You're a legend

[@gyutaro8404]

Playing Valhalla right now😅

[@vaasmontenegro1573]

Same bro love this game ❤️

[@shadowguy20004]

Have her react to later chapters when Connor is in New York, Boston and actual Revolution battles like Concord/ Lexington

[@johnbuffington3813]

She’s the cutest historian I’ve ever seen.

[@kendrinawaskoro3031]

She's very cool and funny in a way of explaining these things but maybe next time show her a more from a cutscene or gameplay that required more historical context other than just fighting would be great

[@trevorgreenough6141]

Of all the ancestral assassins that are playable, my favourites most to least, Ezio Auditore, Shay McCormack, and Hathem Kenway.

[@JSGaming0327]

This is so awesome, I’ve replayed this game like 12 times. 😂😂😂🔥🔥🔥

[@GeZz.]

i love the energy she has!!! i hope she do more vids

[@Sonics1DiscordKitten]

Possibly one of the coolest trailers in the franchise. I felt beyond American watching AC3

[@RDJ134]

Too bad we didnt learned some historical trivia, but instead we can see some one enjoying some footage.

[@bigboss4178]

she's really cool bruh, y'all should show her Red Dead Redemption and RDR2 /// also the Assassins's Creed that features Napoleon (with a British Accent lmao) /// and some Mafia Games and LA Noire (do they even relate to actual US history?) good stuff

[@soumen_pradhan]

Bro, imagine Napolean with an Italian accent. It's-a-mi-Bonar-parte.

[@khemib]

Tchaikovsky's Piano Concerto in the background😍

[@DogWearingABeanie]

Not even 2 minutes in she says "this is trauma for me" while laughing hysterically. Love it xD

[@kari4638]

AC3 is not my favorite out of the Assassin's Creed games but I come back to watch videos of it more often than others because of the story. Also, Haytham is the best even his voice. Love the love story between him and Ziio and the father-son dynamic between him and Connor.

[@pokeczarelf]

I would like to see her react to Assassin's Creed 2/Brotherhood, especially the Leonardo da Vinci scenes with his friendship with Ezio.

[@noxteryn]

That was too short, I wish they showed her more historical events.

It would be cool to see more of the input the expert can give on the thing they're reacting.

[@Echo2-2]

A very fun video. Awesome job!

[@_stxry8705]

yall need this woman back on ur show

[@odameclement2325]

Really happy to see this review on this game, hope to see Assassin's Creed rogue break down next time.

[@yogurtyogurt8774]

She's hilarious, need more of this Assassin's Creed experts react

[@VinnieSpaz]

I like all the experts you guys bring on but this chick is the cream of the crop.. she's awesome 👍

[@bloodycrypt7612]

Would love like back story about the actual characters

[@futurestoryteller]

I felt like this was unfortunately sparse on historical details but her familiarity with Tarantino movies and video games is making me fall for her

[@roxastrife714]

Great video. Next, please do Italian Historian react to AC 2 and Brotherhood

[@cristianmartinez1425]

The 3 assassin is the coolest🫶🏻

[@Vinecars]

We need an Egyptian historian to review assassins creed origins, bonus if you include the mirages that happen in the dessert 😎

[@Mr-Rinn]

I’m British, and this game was the first time I learned anything substantial about the American Revolution.

[@Zuernaxashyr]

Should have shown off more of the actual history parts for her to react too.. Maybe next time? Also I love this game but man that annoying AC3 background music repeat bug I don't miss.

[@69gamer06]

It'd be cool to see her play all the games

[@LegatusLucius1994]

Are they playing the remastered version

[@wonhur885]

Intriguing, i always knew there was more to life and i have also been looking for a way to find not only protection but a way to be influential to the human society.

[@wonhur885]

oh well you can achieve that by being a part of the illuminatus brotherhood, i know it sounds like a mystery but there are ways you can actually get in contact with them

[@wonhur885]

@Rose Allen well it is not and you can't actually expect it to be open to everyone, but if you want to know more you can look up Wilford Robert Taylor online you will find something interesting.

[@nightlyrowentree6047]

I love the 3rd game

[@notautismbrackley926]

You should’ve added the templars she would might likely see that

[@aubreynagel]

“The only condoms are sheep intestine so either stds or children are the next step” lmaoooo caught me OFF GUARD

[@NateTheGreatNDT]

Surprised they didn’t find a 1700’s assassin to react to this…

[@jeco0357]

Hope you guys do Unity next. It has one of the best renders of the - now burnt/damaged - Notre Dame Cathedral

[@antesimic4571]

0:34 It appears as if they are watching movie and she is on screeen.

[@clericneokun]

Poor choice of footage this time. There are several cutscenes later on in the game that referenced actual historical events which she could have given plenty of insight on.

[@EmptyDivergence]

Do more historians reacting to Assassin's Creed games, the older ones though!

[@VANTARTS]

lol the one playing the game didn't notice the music bug

[@PandoraKyss]

I avoided this game in the franchise out of sheer spite after I'd learned that Ubisoft cut my city of Philadelphia from the main city line-up due to being 'too boring' for free running. I was infuriated how once again Philly was given the cold shoulder even during the time when the city actually mattered the most. But then I got over my nonsense and ended up playing and loving the game. Philadelphia does make an appearance - well, the interior of Independence Hall - and I actually have a save file that I quit while Connor's there so that the loading screen shows Philadelphia as the location. I know, it's a sickness of mine. The only other gripe I have is that the women are all wearing caps when in reality American women in major cities, particularly New York and Philadelphia and even Boston, would have followed a similar fashion theme as Europe. Hell, Marie-Antoinette's 'Pandora' dolls made their way here.

[@Mapmoop451]

i think Philadelphia may have been in rogue, i don't remember through...

[@theunknownuser9609]

0:27 Master Kenway tends to have that effect on women

[@parkmojo6168]

0:27 who wouldn't? Especially if Haytham was the one doing it 😆😆😆

[@SimonUdd]

She should do ac4 the best one or rogue

[@YuukiRinoReborn]

Next time can you guys have her react to historical elements in games instead of fights

[@elijahtsai6499]

She’s awesome

[@dykuvids6821]

i hope they do a part 2

[@ameemrashaad2038]

Man that audio glitch of the music looping. Just restart the game bruh

[@ltcarlsen2152]

Police officer reacts to the Division 1 Story! Not the second one the first one!

[@gagewesterhouse9558]

This woman didn't add much professional commentary...

[@slyceth]

Best assassin's Creed ever!

[@christiansaii6197]

Predictable she said , ohh what doesn't know is that the he is that bad guy .... i wanted to see it on her face !!!

[@NoNameNemo.01]

I have learned the history of condoms and a little myth story about King Minos and female condoms today because of the comment at 8:47. People been using condoms since the 1500s

[@69gamer06]

Tell her it's the Mohawk tribe

[@unofficialninja]

She seems cool as hell. I want to hang out with her.

[@CasualGamer522]

Did she have 100% synchro i remember trying and trying again the mission to kill Braddock only to destroy the 3 powder barrels :)

[@OmegaRidley90001]

I don't think they gave her enough or the right material. Especially Haytham's part of the game. Wrong way to gain insight on this subject matter.

[@redross7775]

The Kenway’s and their charm LOLOL

[@drewng1636]

"Giggly girlie spoilt, entitled girl giggles her way through AC3 gameplay." Done.

[@SaadNabil]

I love History!!!!

[@gyutaro8404]

Her - "Man I love murdering people in plain view" Me - uhhh... WUT ? 👀

[@barbellman7038]

Is it me or does Haytham kind of sounds like Shere Khan from the original disney's animated version of the jungle book?

[@reescantdance7831]

She's so cool

[@texben123]

Didn’t the Templars get wiped out by the pope and the king? I think I don’t know the kings name. The Templars were wiped out by the pope, and I think the king of England at the time. They mostly did it to get the Templars money and land. Then after that the pope and the king of England, die mysteriously in their sleep, killed by God as punishment for the crusades, the witch burnings, and other horrible sins.

[@animaloftides4739]

She's cool!

[@SantosOnFire]

She's rad, but they showed her a lot of Haytham, who's not the main character haha

[@steveboy7302]

I don't think she's a historian

[@assassinscreedislife7636]

She seems fun, but I think she forgot the assignment

[@thearonalexander6925]

I would like to see a experts react to skyrim

[@Nikolai1939]

6:37 She assumes the wrong date and blames the game lol Tbh this whole video is kinda meh, she mostly reacted to the story and not the cool historical nitpicks

[@CYB3R2K]

Ass creed 3 wasn't a great assassins creed game but I feel it was the last story worth telling in the series, after that everything feels like an afterthought or too fanfic, even with good games like origins, the story just isn't the same

[@spqr49]

she didnt really provide any context on the history... she just laughed at parts and pointed out rather obvious things. to be fair, they didnt really pull from the interesting historical parts that AC3 offers, so kind of a fail on whoever prepared ths video to be shown to her. i also get the sense she doesn't realize iroquois are not a tribe, but a confederation of tribes.

[@TheLuftwaffe-_-]

How does she not know the difference between musket and a flintlock

[@JTGallant]

both appeared in use at that time, the musket was primarily still used by farmers/militiamen while flintlock became the standard for actual armies that could afford the upgrade.

[@catch616]

That thumbnail 💀

[@ronaldojoe3011]

I like her.

[@deveontreadway575]

She’s my type 👀 slow down Gamology

[@RangerHouston]

BA in Russian history reacting to the American Revolution…

[@danielcastaneda4975]

She's cool but you showed too much fights lol . You should invite her again

[@garyballard179]

Did you seriously only show her the prologue?

[@nicolaschristianlindhoff8011]

So when is she gonna talk abt history and not laugh abt him killing ppl