Historical Accuracy of Hunting & Trading in Red Dead Online

[@vondo84]

Man vs history is THE red dead channel

[@ManvsHistory]

May it be so.

[@K._K.]

👌True👌

[@trisfen9840]

Man vs. History those moose antlers are boss

[@cleanixx5343]

@Korbyn Eduardo Oh my god it took like 4 hours but it actually worked omg just stfu and piss off 😂

[@pumpiati9536]

I’m late asf 😪 but I’m binge watching every video and getting into this game

[@eliasazad8724]

Why isn't this guy more well-known? This channel is so amazing as the day I discovered it

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Elias, feel free to share to your heart's content! Appreciate the support, buddy!

[@polarshoe5078]

Bro this man is the type of guy you'd expect to have 1 million subs for great content.

[@dannin1278]

I once pet a black bear while fishing for trout.

[@happyhazza7184]

Don’t wanna be that guy but being friendly to wildlife especially bears and such is a pretty good way to help making that animal end up dead or put in a zoo....

[@theonethingwealladore]

happy hazza he didn’t fucking buy the bear dinner... he touched it. That bear is just fine

[@petecapri4054]

I’ve been fly fishing up in the Sierra Nevada and had black bears get within a few feet of me when I’m in the river. Love to see them

[@ianrocco8453]

@@theonethingwealladore Usually it's considered good manners to buy it dinner before touching it.

[@theonethingwealladore]

Ian Rocco the more you know

[@MadChase1017]

The first article that you showed about the man shooting his friend for thinking he was a turkey, that is my hometown. The jumped out of my bed when I read my town name. I never even knew that had happened or that the town was that old.

[@ManvsHistory]

Ha! Very cool!

[@DixieWhiskey]

That's a very old area, people started settling there as early as the French and Indian war, including your own Colonel William Crawford.

[@jameshudson6414]

Fun fact with the bears! If you’re approached by a grizzly bear in RDR2 and don’t move and stand your ground the bear is more likely to leave you alone

[@catrionasloanei6847]

True but in real life that isn't the greatest tactic either. They suggest a fetal position as a Grizzly is inclined to literally rip your guts out.

[@j.fragoso7451]

@@catrionasloanei6847 Wrong. First of all, if you are around bears you must always carry a firearm so that if you encounter one you can proceed to blow your brains out before the bear (literally) eats you alive.

[@jameshudson6414]

Jesse Nash If it’s hungry you could very well be done for no matter what

[@jameshudson6414]

J.Fragoso well thankfully in rdr2 you carry firearms. As long as the bear isn’t hungry you should be good.

[@catrionasloanei6847]

@@jameshudson6414 not with a S and W .50

[@les8947]

goddamn rockstar. we get underpayed and overcharged.

[@alon4039]

💀

[@traegoins6903]

For real.

[@nicholasmendoza9652]

if Rockstar saw this they’ll take advantage of all the ones you said were overpriced in the game

[@oolooo]

My God , the inhuman luck you have to see such adorable Bears on the daily is amazing .Damn you , Southern Hemisphere , for never having the cooler animals .

[@colonelcolin1641]

Yeah but we have to look out mama bear who will completely destroy you if she sees you with her baby

[@magicman3163]

I hope they add an H.H. HOLMES Role cause you can sell random bodies to colleges and get money.

[@ManvsHistory]

Devil in the White City. Soooo good.

[@wilbysot343]

i just wish they wouldnt inflate the gun and clothing prices and/or let me get a doggy for my camp without spending my life savings in a single trip to the store

[@Teddy_______]

1:25 I don’t think that guy actually mistook his friend for a turkey... I think it was 1st degree murder

[@ManvsHistory]

I found another article where a man climbing a tree and was shot and killed after being mistaken for a raccoon... well... according to his buddy, that's what happened. But now I'm starting to see a pattern here that I can't unsee.... You've opened my eyes, Teddy.

[@Teddy_______]

@Man vs. History Murder was definitely easier back then 😂

[@magicman3163]

Teddy BAD B0Y it’s weird tho cause when a group of people robbed a stagecoach or a train in the middle of nowhere somehow everyone knew who it was.

[@Teddy_______]

@Mr. MagicMan It was you, wasn’t it?

[@coreydoyle8423]

It was easier to get away with murder back then

[@MrJamiez]

I were chasing a black bear, through manzanita post, and out of nowhere, a big ass Grizzly Bear attacks me, and kills me. 🤣

[@traegoins6903]

We used to poke our oars down and feel gators on the angelina river when i was little. Probably not the smartest thing lol but i thought it was neat.

[@xxadrian_mxx7871]

When did Tom Brady get so knowledgeable about hunting. I like it.

[@ManvsHistory]

You aren't the first person to mention this. I get it from my students quite a bit.

[@Marius.T.H]

@@ManvsHistory i want to be your student now😂😅

[@iCXRUX]

One cool thing to note about the grizzlies in Red Dead Online is If one starts to charge at you from a distance, hold completely still. The grizzly will stop a few feet away from you and roar and swat it's paw for a minute, then walk away. Your screen and controller will go crazy lol. Try not to be on your horse when it sees you, as it may attack by the time you get off.

[@ManvsHistory]

I'll have to try this! You're not just setting me up to be eaten are you, Jack?

[@iCXRUX]

@@ManvsHistory haha nope. I found out while my character was standing there. I was on my phone looking at facebook. I heard the roar but didn't realize my controller was under the blanket haha. The bear came at me like a bat outta hell, then just stopped. I was blown away... might take a try or 2 but it does work. Just depends on how quick you stand still once you see the bear

[@ManvsHistory]

@@iCXRUXAlrighty, I'll give it a go!

[@MrVictor1227]

Just found your channel. I like your content and it is very informative. Subscribed

[@ManvsHistory]

Thank you, Victor! Pumped to have you join up!

[@schultz3145]

Dude, I freaking love your channel! Glad to know somebody is making content on KZbin that has the same ideas for Red Dead as I do. Keep it up my guy!

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Schultz, really appreciate the support, my friend!

[@imjulian5393]

I think Rockstar would be quite happy to know they've performed a grave mistake paying us more than we should for most animal pelts.

[@fruitsalad4615]

I'm not gonna lie, the couger pelt price surprised me

[@magicman3163]

You should do Expansion Ideas like jobs,weapons,vehicles,and animals in Alaska,Mexico,or Guarma.

[@IncrediibleHauck]

how about CANADA

[@aidsman762p]

Captain Canuck Yes, I’d legitimately love Canada or Alaska and Canada or something. But you need to realize Mexico is much more probable as the blueprint exists from RDR1

[@IncrediibleHauck]

Aidan Du Plessis agreed, loved playing in Mexico in rdr 1 , could also be a great way too play as Javier aswell , Canada could play as Charles

[@magicman3163]

Captain Canuck nothing was happening in Canada tho I put Alaska cause the gold rush

[@IncrediibleHauck]

Mr. MagicMan just being you don’t know anything about it doesn’t mean nothing happened

[@milannikolic8731]

Im an awesome hunter! I usually go to the open plains of Fridge.. But sometimes I venture out to the great valley of Supermarket where I might have to fight with the other hunters for the best spots

[@ManvsHistory]

You sir sound like a bold adventurer!

[@ManvsHistory]

Hope you folks enjoy this latest video! She's a long one. As most of you know, my channel isn't monetized so if you do enjoy the videos please consider donating on Patreon! www.patreon.com/ManvsHistory?fan_landing=true I've been filming all these vids with just my cell phone, so all initial funds will go towards an actual microphone, then a camera, in order to up the quality of the channel moving forward. Thanks folks!

[@LadyTylerBioRodriguez]

Welcome back! Already worth it to hear about the 1800s version of a Dick Chaney hunting party. Oh man I thought you were a turkey! In all seriousness I'm shocked at how many pelts are actually overpaying compared to historical value. I somehow imagine Rockstar isn't aware of this.

[@yandhi__9970]

Finally, Rockstar updates the game after 7 months! Hope you enjoy the new update Man vs History. (Great video, learned something new today.)

[@ManvsHistory]

Glad you enjoyed it! Looking forward to this update tomorrow!

[@TheGooseGroup]

Man vs. History aren’t we all

[@thickboi4304]

The reason they tke this long be less crunch time for dev and there possibly working on a new game ( also the COVID 19 made things worse )

[@trey8005]

Thick boi Gtamen they also don’t have access to their motion capture studio

[@coleforbes6268]

Great video and I think that it's funny that the most dangerous animals have some of the lowest cost while a silver fox was worth so much

[@alisfaah9322]

The amount of work and accuracy you’ve put in this video is some next level shit keep it up you’re doing an amazing work education all of us here i wish I could go and study at your class😂

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Ali, love that compliment, my friend!

[@alexsessock2125]

Whoa, the tree falling death happened minutes away from where I live. I’ve got friends who work at Harvey’s lake!

[@trisfen9840]

Until the new update I hadnt ever seen a moose for over a year and a half of playing this game

[@aaronsanborn4291]

Moose were heavily hunted in Maine by hunters feeding lumber camps in the 1800s...where I live and work in Maine Moose and the signs of Moose are very common today.

[@alextorres4667]

New setup and intro, this is awesome.

[@calithesloth5462]

So has anyone tried the new Naturalist role? The rewards are basically the stuff i've been wanting to have in the game. Temporary camp, tracking, legendary animals and tranqing animals. I just gotta get 65 gold lmao

[@FreeAimDog]

hey we got the same shirt

[@jeffprice4376]

I really hope they give us a bit of a hunting update. I'd love to hunt with a shotgun, especially birds, even if that means using a special birdshot ammo type. Also I hate the headshot design for hunting, heart/lung shots would be a lot more accurate from a hunting standpoint.

[@jimmymarcussen4976]

You just got yourself a subscriber. VERY interesting channel 👍👍

[@Linnnaeus]

Here's hoping that gun in the promo screenshot is the Nitro Express

[@K._K.]

How cool is it to See a Baby bear 2 Meters away from you in my Country bears doesent live in the wild 😆

[@jamesanthony8438]

"Moving on to badgers..." "Badgers?... Badgers?!... We don't _NEED_ no stinking Badgers!" - Trinidad Silva - "UHF" (1989)

[@ManvsHistory]

I used to love that movie as a kid. I'd rent it all the time on VHS.

[@SOUNDsculptures]

Why have I only just now found your channel.... fantastic stuff, thank you. This game has changed my life. Not only am I invested in the history of trapper and frontiersmen, and the history of the horse, I bought a late 1800s Sears & Roebuck catalogue and even took up clawhammer banjo. This is difficult to do, being in the UK. The game has been blowing my mind since the single player, and then morphed into ridiculous amounts of time in online. I will be trawling through this great channel of yours!! Best, Helen.

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks, Helen! Glad you found my channel. You may especially enjoy the 'Moonshiner' video I made, as the banjo makes a couple sneak peeks.

[@piewithmoustachepwm]

Some of my best memories from RDR2-O are from hunting, its just so fun and interesting.

[@Texo_McKevo]

I actually hunt but I live in the city kinda but when a friend of mine or a land owner offers me to go hunt I’ll go see what’s there to hunt and put it in my fridge

[@ScoutTrooperTK]

Hunting is a mighty fine hobby. The annoying part is the modern vegans

[@Texo_McKevo]

Scout Trooper TK 3202 yeah I went to petco and this lady I can’t say she was but she was upset that I was wearing my felt hat and cowboy boots. Then she had the most smart ass question “Um I bet you love to kill Bambi” I laughed and said “I actually would let Bambi live for how young the little fawn is and actually catch her and raise the little fawn and then let the young buck go into the wild.”

[@cheshirecat2641]

@@ScoutTrooperTK I'm not a vegan I'm through and through carnivore but I absolutely disagree with hunting for pleasure or as a hobby or actually hunting at all nowadays. There's abundance of farming industry supplying enough meat there's no need to kill wildlife anymore. Especially when the earth is overpopulated and wildlife is shrinking considerably due to overpopulation and hunting.

[@ScoutTrooperTK]

@@cheshirecat2641 We have geese where I live that eat all the grass meant for the cows, so we are encouraged to hunt those. There are even hunters keeping the population in wildlife areas under control, so sometimes it's necessary

[@cheshirecat2641]

@@ScoutTrooperTK You know exactly what I'm talking. I have no.issues with killing pests some animals may have become due to.humans killing next in food chain predators of them.and the population grew out of control. (Humans... come to mind now 🤔) . UK has massive problem with foxes which in towns they've become nuisance and are pests like rats or pigeons and.they should be kept under population control. Geese, rabbits etc those are farm animals and fast reproducing too. I'm talking big game, slow reproducing and not pests. Gee I'd love to see mosquitos eradicated from the face of.the earth.

[@InspireDogworks]

Welcome back! The important question here is... How long would that possum have kept rolling?

[@ManvsHistory]

Excellent question, Ashley. Sounds like a great idea for another video.

[@InspireDogworks]

Haha! Oh my gosh please do that! 😂 Also, I nearly choked on my salad from laughing so hard at the end when you chucked that pelt at your horse 🤣🤣

[@ManvsHistory]

@@InspireDogworks Yeah, it was bizarre, right?!? I just stood there after it happened, sort of in disbelief. Hadn't seen that before.

[@imeighteen3749]

Love these vids man keep em coming I’m praying u get monetized (The new update fits ur style perfectly)

[@ManvsHistory]

Appreciate that, man!

[@tylerbessette464]

My favorite way to hunt in rdo is to find an animal (always perfect i dont settle for anything less) follow it at a distance on foot, then at the right moment I shoot for the animals heart. It is so satisfying to shoot the animal then follow the real blood trail to the dying animal.

[@Linnnaeus]

Are- are you okay?

[@tylerbessette464]

@@Linnnaeus what is that supposed to mean

[@ManvsHistory]

@@Linnnaeus Ah man, I'm dying here.

[@ManvsHistory]

@@tylerbessette464 I get you Tyler, just others might not.

[@Linnnaeus]

@@tylerbessette464 I'm just joking:)

[@JARP173]

I had to go back and re-watch all of these. LOVE 'EM! 🤙🏻

[@wayneking9997]

Same I love the historical accuracy videos especially when it comes to clothes

[@347warrior]

It looks like rockstar might have liked one of your ideas good video keep doing what your doing

[@bradleyh.4715]

Trapper role is possibly coming tomorrow; well timed video haha! If you like simulated hunting, maybe you should check out the “theHunter: Call of the Wild”. Best hunting game out there. High quality video as always 👍

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks Bradley! Yeah, I own that game. It's great.

[@Cowboy_Chimp]

At first I thought some of these prices sounded lower than I remembered but then I realised your just selling the skin and not the whole animal like I usually do. Good video mate

[@ManvsHistory]

I had the same thought as I was writing out my script. I'm so used to selling complete carcasses, it was throwing me off. I kept going back and checking my numbers to make sure I was correct.

[@keithcheeseman567]

As always an absolutetly brilliant video, as i have said before, i could easly sit for an hour or more listening to your historical chatter. keep it up please, i want the next one already.

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks for stopping in again, my friend! Appreciate the kind words as always, Keith!

[@ght_1]

A video about historically accurate guns rockstar can add to rdo would be cool, I hope there’s new guns on the new update tomorrow

[@Linnnaeus]

The Nitro Express will probably come tomorrow aka the gun Roland Tembo used in The Lost World

[@theonethingwealladore]

I’m pretty sure they are adding a double hunting rifle today

[@ght_1]

he cannot breathe it’s pretty boring and not that good, I wish they added the burgess folding shotgun or any other historically accurate gun that’s unique and fun

[@thatguydude419]

Great video, man! Excited for the update tomorrow?

[@ManvsHistory]

Better believe it!

[@articusramos808]

Ah... good to see something that will be an update tomorrow. Though I miss rdr1's prices. Better prices in Mexico for bears.

[@magicman3163]

Articus Ramos That makes no sense the Mexican Grizzly Bear didn’t go extinct till 1964

[@articusramos808]

@@magicman3163 no I ment that in red dead redemption 1. Prices for bears in red dead redemption 1 had sell prices that differ on region. Anything from west Elizabeth had a higher sell price in Mexico. You can make hundreds of dollars on bear pelts,meat, claws and hearts. It's a very good way to make money. For red dead redemption 1

[@magicman3163]

Articus Ramos oh that makes sense but it doesn’t in the real world as Mexican bears were easy to hunt.

[@WalrusWinking]

I mean I doubt a colt Navy cost 275 dollars in 1898 so we need that extra money.

[@DNH17]

I saw this video on nexus mods and I could not avoid to comment this: consider that tons of stuff written is also written because of power games - as it happens today it happened 2000 years ago and also 200 years ago, what I mean is that we don't know if the stories are true, some people may be not cool for some others and someone wanted them dead, or simply there were violent people that were just burned in the brain and wanted to kill others for fun, veterans (as once you kill you don't come back from it really at least if u do it in war) and thus how those people died, since there was no CSI methods...simply in many cases could have been cover ups. It takes just to control the writing journal and then nobody will ever know how somebody really lived or died, because if you control the masses you control everything, nobody will try to go against the mass or he\she will be isolated... this is how we are today unfortunately. We use power and tools that should help us ,. in that case inform the community to drive and control and eliminate silently someone. Amazing job at explaining, thanks for all this work. Wow

[@tylerbessette464]

There are a lot of animals in red dead, but i have a huge problem with the lack of prairie dogs around John's ranch.

[@ob1983]

Just found your channel....Fantastic.......this angle on rdr2 is excellent and unique, can't believe I did not find it sooner......thanks so much 👍

[@ManvsHistory]

Welcome aboard!

[@Spirit-Reaction]

Are there currently player run Co-op Fur Trade Companies in RDO? Who wants to start one?

[@hautfenne]

Thx,like your videos.Fox and Vison was xpensif, used for luxurys clothes. Keep going

[@aaronlewis702]

Judge: you stand accused of first degree murder. Accused: I thought he was a turkey! Judge: yeah you're going to jail...

[@minakoishii8760]

I don’t know if Rockstar fixed it or what but at my camp when Cripps is touching the pelt, he isn’t using his bare hands. He is carving the fat off with a knife. Then he walks away.

[@thatzcap9223]

As soon as he said smoked by a grieferI died to a greifer

[@chevychevelle8685]

😯😯Woah!!!!!! a hunter died from being attacked by grizzly bears😟😟 and still managed to kill both of them 😆😆😏😏Yeah that’s pure Awesomeness bro!!!!!!

[@ManvsHistory]

Yeah, I thought the same thing when I read it! Wondered how that story didn't become legendary.

[@tomsawyerpiper9412]

And even with all the value increases, I can spend all day hunting and not be able to afford boots.

[@catherinerobinson6981]

What about the other animals you didn't list in the video? Like Armadillos, Coyotes, The Gray Fox, Iguanas, and some of the other Legendary Animals that aren't relatively in the game as are there models, like the Jaguar-esc Panther or the Black Panther? Or just the Legendary Animals as a whole for RDO.

[@totteryflyer2910]

Think theres a song about an old man who has had enough of living and goes out hunting a massive grizzly and they find his corpse and a the dead bear near him maybe you know the song maybe not I cant find it to know the name but if you can let me know what you think of it and the name of it

[@europeanpatriot8031]

The Coon Hunter probably hunted Racoon

[@Beefmun]

But what about the meat from the animals? How much would money someone get from the meat from a kill?

[@ManvsHistory]

My head is hurting from the thought of trying to dig those numbers up.... But I like it. For the fishing video I was able to find fish prices from 1898, so I suppose anything's possible.

[@christianbustnes9212]

When comparing prices it would be nice seeing the price in the 2020 dollar cause the prices in game is in the 2020 dollar

[@svengonsalves8538]

The price in rdo is 1898 dollar

[@christianbustnes9212]

Sven Gonsalves I know the price isn’t in 1998 dollar cause a pistol didn’t cost 650 dollars

[@svengonsalves8538]

Bomber Harris I said 1898 dollars

[@svengonsalves8538]

Bomber Harris it’s rockstar the game economy is inflated

[@tomockert7779]

Harriet could use her influence for a Warden role I suppose in RDRO

[@Ltngstrike]

Another great video Man! I agree with all your statements on the facts. The only thing I think R* stretched a bit with the Trader role was the whole Cripps routine. Honestly I don't think any of the hide hunters or trappers actually tanned hides in camp except for their own use, even then they mostly traded with the Native tribes for tanned hides. Now, if you put Cripps to work fleshing and drying then pressing the fur/hides into bales for easier handling along with delivering the bales of hides/furs to the buyers and they would have nailed it. All that said I still think they did well with the whole Trader role. Keep on keepin' on Dude!

[@ManvsHistory]

You know your stuff, Ltngstrike! If you look closely at the Fur Trade Review page, on some of the skins they differentiate between 'white man tanned' and 'indian tanned'. The latter being worth much more. Cripps should just be fleshing, drying, and putting skins/ hides into bales/packs. You can tell R* was just kinda winging it, racking a hide here, putting a barrel over there. Heavens knows what's in that wagon tank to make it so fragile... nitro glycerine?

[@Ltngstrike]

@@ManvsHistory Thank you for the kind words my friend. Two of the greatest interests in my life have been reading and history, at age 62 I've had a bit of time to absorb various stuff. Outdoor activities and some cowboy living (small scale ranching and rodeo) have had some additional influence along with having been a licensed trapper and Mt. Man Rendezvous participant adding to the mix. Danged if I can figger out why I enjoy this game so much... LOL You've been doing a fabulous job here, keep it up!

[@ManvsHistory]

@@Ltngstrike Very cool! You sound like somebody that needs a book written about them!

[@Ltngstrike]

@@ManvsHistory I'm not sure Comic Wagnerian Opera's are in much demand now. =/

[@ZeusMaryosepManhwaPicks]

the update is out you might wanna check it.

[@ManvsHistory]

You better believe it, Zeus! Hopping on shortly.

[@yeenosaur2620]

I personally would love it if Rockstar would just lessen the amounts of animals and make them harder to find but much, much more valuable. I'd also love it if they were easier to spook or aggravate.

[@ManvsHistory]

I love seeing these comments keep popping up from you, Yeenosaur, as you make your way through all my videos. Pretty fun actually. As for your comment, I agree 100%. Of course I'd like it to be more of a hunting simulator (plus trapping), but that's just me.

[@yeenosaur2620]

@@ManvsHistory I've watched your videos for awhile but I missed one here or there and today I just decided I'd start commenting so here I am. Your videos are fantastic.

[@ManvsHistory]

@@yeenosaur2620 Well I appreciate you watching, so thank you, my friend!

[@skylyndmeraz6633]

Could you make a video on the historical accuracy of Law Enforcement in the Red Dead series? It seems there's an inconsistency in regards to the jurisdiction of the U.S. Marshals Service in some instances in both main game titles.

[@LucidoMafia]

Seriously why haven't Rockstar given this guy a job. I watch his vids while playing RDO. Great vid mate

[@ManvsHistory]

Much obliged, Lucido!

[@vbswife25]

I know I'm pretty late but yeah I'm a Boy scout and it's bs. We tried to go paintballing for fun and our committee shut it down

[@ManvsHistory]

That's a shame. It was an amazing organization- hate seeing it morph into something else.

[@bluwolf9357]

Really enjoyed this video!!!! Those moose antlers behind your head are a bit distracting... 😆😆😆😆

[@ManvsHistory]

In hindsight I agree.

[@JamesWBarr]

I appreciate what you're doing here but please don't give Rockstar anymore reasons to raw dog my wallet and pay me less for something.

[@ManvsHistory]

Ha! Fair enough!

[@4evergypsy]

thaxXx for your Service You ARE Apprecitaed \m/ @@ \m/ Do Crows Shoot Back, I will Be " Yeaaaa All Right, All Right, All Right \m/ @@ \m/

[@mattwar1015]

Hey Man. Vs History, did you see the new clothes they added with the new update? They added pelts you can wear now and legendary animals as well as a trapper to sell to

[@snansundernail8229]

Telling my kids this was Chris Pratt

[@ManvsHistory]

Love that guy.

[@jambr055]

The real question is: Why were rabbits so cheap??

[@ManvsHistory]

I’ve always thought rabbit fur was a bit under appreciated. I suppose the sheer abundance kept prices low.

[@jambr055]

@@ManvsHistory abundance makes sense. I have some nice pelts from a reserve in Quebec that I wished I payed 1890s prices for lol!

[@daddydevito4405]

4th

[@ottovonbismarck8460]

Take a shot every time he sais raw untanned

[@Toastrackman]

Really interesting , i look forward to watching your video on bison when it's completed. Also looking forward to playing the new Trapper roll on RD online. 🤠👍

[@Toastrackman]

I meant Naturalist roll lol

[@ManvsHistory]

@@Toastrackman I gotcha!

[@Conspiracymediashorts]

Already knew I had to click

[@hogmaster1854]

I think moose are the rarest. I’ve only seen one in Roanoke Ridge.

[@alextorres4667]

I've been playing for 11 months and only saw one twice

[@Devin_Stromgren]

I've seen a couple by lake Ojiwa as well, but only in story mode. I've yet to see a moose online.

[@cg69005]

I've seen easily 50 moose but only 2 Panthers

[@asprywrites]

So sad 1:35 that a so-called best-known "pioneer" of Omaha can't even show up well in a Google search. I'd be interested to know why his peers seemed to regard him so well.

[@pwndead2024]

there is a mission where you get tanning oil for cripps its rare and a pain but its there

[@opossumlord]

moose are probably so rare to some people because they're never in the areas you actually find them. I see plenty of moose in RDO

[@tylerbessette464]

I wouldn't mind getting paid only 25 cents for a deer skin if if it didnt cost me $200 for a decent hat

[@ManvsHistory]

I feel the same, Tyler.

[@searose1015]

Alligators have a tiny brain about the size of a quarter and its really hard to hit with a bullet. Thats my guess about the hatchets.

[@TheHeavyshadow]

Yikes, the more I learn about hunting and tanning, the happier I'd be to be the gatherer/farmer-part of the equation. Also you missed one very important inaccuracy of the tanning-setup: the price. I know the Gold Rush did some really wonky stuff to the gold price, but I imagine that any trade in human history where someone bought a table, two tanning-racks, a couple of troughs and barrels, and a tool-set for 15 goldbars is a trade where the seller made a VERY good deal.

[@wranglerjeans4life303]

Something I’d love to see added to the game is the Winchester model 94 in 30-30, I think it would do about the same amount of damage as the kraig rifle and hold 7 rounds

[@sethtfp2373]

8:36 Don’t hold your breath bro 💀

[@ProSkye59]

I guess sometimes the butcher scams us and sometimes we scam the butcher

[@GabbyPlaysGames02]

I can't even tell you how much I love these videos. I love history, but never really had a good source for it. If you were my history teacher in high school, I might have actually learned something lol. Thank you so much for all the effort and passion you put into this series! Any chance you'd do videos on how historically accurate other games were? I'd love to know just how close Assassin's Creed 3 was to the actual revolutionary war lol

[@ManvsHistory]

Thanks, Gabby! I may do others. We'll see where things lead.

[@iamverycool2488]

Damn ima Introduce chamberlain hills families to hunting

[@jj8998]

I’m very bad at math. But how exactly do you calculate the differences between the real prices and the inaccurate prices?

[@wyattcheramie004]

I hope you'll be able to monetize your channel.

[@littlealchemist6872]

I wouldn’t use online to compare prices because most of them are not only not based on what they would’ve been based on at the time and since it’s online they make it very hard to get a lot of money from so that they can encourage micro transactions

[@ALouisae]

I don’t know if you still read comments on this video, but did you ever plan on making that Beaver Trade video? I don’t know what that is but it sounds really interesting and I’d love to learn about it and how it compares to Red Dead.

[@ManvsHistory]

I still might!

[@ManvsHistory]

Still thinking of this, btw.

[@ALouisae]

@@ManvsHistory That’s super cool! Though since I made that comment i’ve lost interest in Red Dead, I still regularly watch your videos because I truly enjoy the content you make and the history lessons. Feels nice to know you’re still thinking about a comment I made 6 months ago. Keep up the amazing work, man.

[@ManvsHistory]

@@ALouisae Thanks, buddy. Yeah, I'm working on a new video around hunting in RDO (still a couple weeks out), but I had to come back to watch my own video in order to recall what I covered in this one. Anyway, still appreciate that you watch the vids, even if you don't play the games!