HONEST REACTION to BTS (방탄소년단) 'Black Swan' Official MV

[@hjban2977]

Through out the video, Jimin is portraying emotional struggles of inner lights & darknesses of each member as an artist, an idol as well as a human being! That is why when each member’s solo part of scene, Jimin would dance as their shadow at the back ground to show each member’s emotional changes, expressing their inner struggles & pain through his dance movements as their shadow! This is a beautiful MV & all the BTS members did amazing job!!! They truly are remarkable harmonized group of young artists! It would have been more wonderful if their outfits of dancing scenes were not the suits but something more suitable for dancers outfit to easy their movements & show their beautiful outlines of the dance movements! Because with these spectacular artistic lighting effects they were using, it would have been wonderfully emphasized each member’s beautiful outlines of their dance movements so perfectly!!!

[@ishiko2359]

Ohh.. well explained, im not that fast to understand this mv but im trying you know😅 but since you explain very clearly everything, im so thankful to you😉 but i always notice the shadows of them,.

[@MrShiftlove]

If it helps you Jimin is the dancing shadow, when Yoongi is singing, you didn’t noticed but when Namjoon is singing there’s also a dancing shadow in the roof that’s Jimin too... and he’s the shadow in the end too, if you noticed at the end the Black Swan (aka Jimin) is injured, tired, unhappy and he falls on the ground, that’s JK watching the Black Swan fall (death kinda). If you know about that black and white swans fight you know what I mean...

[@needybea4572]

So in this era Jimin is the shadow

[@MrShiftlove]

Val BH well, I think that we had a lot of references of shadow is this MV, like Yoongi reaching his own shadow, Jinnie with the mirrors is a reference of shadow too so a think that he’s not exactly ‘the shadow’ but in this MV he represented it while being the Black Swan

[@lilprinc3122]

Damn....

[@soul575]

At 4:04 tae singing to the shadow on the floor or something just wondering 🤔

[@evelyndelao9372]

@@soul575 *googles how to be a shadow*

[@emmarobinson2006]

1.Jimin went from white swan to black swan 2.That is Jimin's shadow dancing 3. This is based off the movie black swan 4. In the movie it is being performed on a stage 5.This is based on that movie and Jimin is the main character.

[@jebatahsin4774]

💜💜

[@rdvanbilgic341]

This song and the concept feels especially fit for Jimin

[@tanya24able]

Jimin is the Black Swan his Solo Dancing is out of this world . I loved the MV

[@southernkiss47]

The shadow dancing is Jimin. The shadow off to the right is Suga. The shadow above RM is also of Jimin dancing.

[@DEAN-br9wr]

If there's a mv for louder than bombs, I assume that aaron work for bighit.

[@omelas8375]

Fsr I see the louder than bombs mv giving dna vibes

[@nixieshah04]

Onionhaseyo how though? Dna was a whole happy vid, and ltb is dark and sad asf

[@omelas8375]

@@nixieshah04 Your telling me you listen to louder than bombs but feel sad?

[@NuiAoki]

@@omelas8375 Louder than bombs is definitely sad. Not just by lyrics but also by melody. It's alright if you feel otherwise.

[@omelas8375]

@@NuiAoki thats what i just said

[@lightxmar]

Jimin is the black swan that’s it. It probably makes a lot more sense if you have seen the movie “black swan”

[@namlunb2140]

Like Tae commented on Weverse: "Black Swan = Jimin"..he ain't lying 😂

[@eggnoggie]

When Jin stood in front of the mirrors and he turned around, his reflections didn't move at all

[@hwarangswdbs21]

Aaron missed that

[@hwarangswdbs21]

..and 2nd clip infront the mirrors, no reflection at all..

[@edwinpangilinan3720]

Jimin is the black swan, the shadow. BTS came to terms with their black swan/shadow and so it disappears. What we see now are BTS that both artists and human beings in one.

[@dohasmahii4310]

I think that jimin is the black swan even tae said it on weverse.

[@Lemon-mo9gp]

you serious? why tho

[@Lofieloves]

JIMINSHIIIII 🙈🙈🙈

[@angu15]

Yes! Jimin is the Black Swan

[@misszui13]

Jimin is the black swan, its obvious even before the dance or mv was released..

[@raulgregoriopajuelofernand8347]

Boy with Luv:outside the theather . Black swan: inside the theather .🤔

[@monitakhun6735]

It’s funny how this reminds u of blood sweat and tears and I notice that jimin is the black swan here and in the blood sweat and tears v is the swan. I feel that these two songs are connected. And I believe those two guys being the swan means something. WE NEED A THEORIZER!!!

[@abhinshavb1277]

Yes these songs are connected... bcz BE next song is connected with BST Nd BS

[@pjmnglow]

Jimin as the black swan represents the shadow, that's why he's been singled out (and he's the only contemporary dancer anyway) and has the wings, this video is an homage to the movie black swan and jimin literally represents nina, the main character of the movie, you can see the journey of him going from the white swan to the black swan. Also the shadow behind yoongi and jungkook (at the end) is jimin.

[@xunknownx.m.6421]

Jin's shot when he like looked back in the mirror room killed me😭❤

[@rabindersingh9762]

The analogy which you were talking about for j hope's move, it's comparable to Fake Love. I just love the amazing dark vibe to both songs.. ah BTS !!!!!

[@needybea4572]

The shadow of Kookie do the same that Kookie did in fake love when the music stop. Oh i forgot... the shadow that you saw in the part of Yoongi is Jimin's shadow... if you see close it does the same moves

[@lito5605]

3:03 I think that is Jungkook’s shadow dancing. In all their live versions Jungkook is right beside Suga, representing his shadow I believe. As for the shadow on the right it’s definitely Suga’s, you can see it aligns with him.

[@deena-s5e]

Thats exactly what I thoughtt💜💜

[@omarkhaled9709]

@Mousely Darne but she didn't say he wasn't she said jungkook the one who was dancing in the shadow of suga I think we will know from the behind the scenes may be🤔

[@t.a.nn.i.e5475]

Right..thats jungkook

[@Prashantkumar-ht1yn]

There is scene of JIMIN doing the exact STEPS as the shadow in the MV itself...so it's JIMIN...but still nothing wrong with waiting for behind the scenes

[@iamlol1815]

You can tell by the moves, its jimin.

[@seanhand396]

Black Swan signifies an insight about yourself which changes your position from one of victim to victor. Black Swan is a graceful reminder to move from any position where you feel powerless and at the mercy of external forces; it is time to reclaim your personal power.

[@MarianaLambert]

I think it's the first time I see you so happy reacting to a video hahaha I love it!

[@dcarmeto]

It was fake love and not Blood sweat and tears. The part with Hobi and Suga. In fake love, Suga goes down the line as he raps and they are fighting, when he meets the end of the line it is Hobi and pulled away from him even then. And Jimin is the Black Swan. Back when they watched the first version of Black Swan, you heard Suga say, that they need Jimin. What Yoongi wants, Yoongi gets.

[@deena-s5e]

omg truee lol💜😂 Aaron was talking about the place, the room they were in it felt similar to the room in Blood Sweat and Tears when Jimin has the blindfold on.

[@زهراءعامررحمنكريم]

Yes that,s right😂

[@MirJa3G33]

... but suga say shirtless!!...😾

[@dcarmeto]

@@MirJa3G33 Of course you would add that part. 😂

[@dcarmeto]

@@deena-s5e Not that part, the part where Hobi is holding onto Suga's arm.

[@xdhplay]

Your voice is so soothing and calm 💜

[@meryembenelkadi3490]

Taehyung said that jimin=black swan and now after watching the mv I understand why he said that 💜

[@armymoomoo9339]

That part when Jungkook's shadow desapeared its from fake love part

[@Ayleenzithaa]

I really enjoy your videos! please, keep reacting to BTS videos

[@edwinpangilinan3720]

I think the shadow leaving at the end of the mv has something to do with the person & shadow becoming one (represented by JK). So BTS has come to terms with their shadows and what we see are complete persons with all the strengths, weakness, greatness, faults, joy & sadness. BTS members as superstars and as human beings are just the same persons.

[@reelgrc]

I like how you reacted on this MV! You're representing ARMYs who make theories on their mind. 😂 Thank you Aaron! You're one of my favorite reactors! 💜

[@BackToBlueSide218]

The way Hoseok sang “I saw myself” looking at Yoongi... chills man! They filmed this while they where in LA too, they were crazy busy!

[@busansarah]

I loved that too was kinda my favorite part somehow 😅

[@isimyok405]

Jimin angel 😍😍😍😍💜💜💜💜

[@Lola-ui2zf]

This mv is beautiful.Even though i needed a moment to calm down after Tae appeared.OMG

[@shagunchauhan1303]

V is amazing👍👍

[@KimNoxy]

Someone notice that the scene of Jin in the mirrors, when there is a lot of Jins and the real one look back at the camara and his reflects(?)(i dont know how to say it, i dont speak english XD) dont change or move??? Like... I dont know.

[@bas_dak]

they are focusing on jimin because he is the only one who can dance in this style, I think they are telling story about the 7 of them being black swan, because we saw in the past that V was the closest one to be the black swan, so all of them representing the black swan✌️

[@herbsgotmessyhair8497]

Fake love, 6:20-6:29 something similar to that mirror thing 😅

[@moonchild.6498]

Shadow in begining of the mv behind suga is jungkook

[@IAR97]

Aaron did you realize when camera shoot each member, only jk didnt look at the camera, he look above (in my opinion) towards jimin Also Jk n jm only who wears corset I'm -

[@KdramaShip]

Same i was thinking the same that only jk didnot directly looking at that camera during that stair shoot

[@tluangarenthlei9234]

👍👍👍

[@KdramaShip]

@@busansarah yes same

[@t.a.nn.i.e5475]

why everyone just want to find who that? who thats?like only one make the best dance.. can y'all just look at the story. I think no need to find out who the best. Because all of them black swan & white swan for ARMY... and not the only one,they all make the best in the mv. No need to argue..

[@arulselvan4067]

In Blood Sweat and Tears, it was only the statue but no wings. In Black Swan, the statue is not there, but the wings are present.

[@pervypathrose]

2:56 dude actually the shadow in the bottom right corner is that of Suga's and the larger one is possibly of Jimin's from a different angle.

[@claudispan]

I will never get over Tae Taes curly hair I hope he keeps it forever ❤

[@FlowerLotusThe]

Focus on Jimin means only one thing: he is the only one of them who can dance contemporary!

[@nai3437]

legend 4 life mhmm

[@jnyafk]

Imagine Jimin reading this and feel bad about other members

[@nai3437]

Taehyungie ikr like i don’t think we should say stuff like that. all of them can do anything they put their minds to.

[@zquadsunshineflow9512]

You can say he has the best technique but other members give their best for a dance which they arent familiar with

[@nai3437]

ZquadAtiny ArmyZenNeverland 👏🏽👏🏽👏🏽

[@minguyen6743]

aaron the HUGE SHADOW behind suga is the shadow of jungkook dancing... and your face at 8:33 is really funny... thank you for the reaction i was waiting for it i love it as always

[@armymoomoo9339]

Jimin is the Black swan

[@xinzl.5666]

O​h oof​ oof​ oof​*pause*World​ Wide Handsome

[@violetwings3925]

Ok ok guys there is a hundred of comments saying that jimin is the Black swan ,ok guys WE GOT IT

[@bunniemuffin7801]

1st. Behind yoongi (the big/taller shadow) is jimin. Jimin is being yoongis shadow 2. above rm is hobis shadow 3. correct me if im wrong but i think this mv was dedicated to jimins modern dancing skills.

[@deena-s5e]

If you have watched Black Swan the movie you'll see how there are things similar to that of the music video like for example, the stage, its really similar to the one in the movie and the mirror reference; a mirror reveals the hidden identities, in the movie when the girl(Nina) looks at herself in the mirror, it reflected the illusion of an evil, it presented to her the darkness within herself that metaphorically depicted the evolution into the black swan. It speculates the power of the mirror as our source of definition or its reflection that reveals a true identity from our subconscious that we often conceal. Nina is an innocent, fragile girl and she dances the white swan really well, but she always gets stuck at the black swan as its character is of lust, guile and sensuality. The wings on the girls arms meant she and the black swan were one, contending for perfection, it was attained through anger, seduction and aggression. Although her plight contributed to insanity by the hardships of competition and pressure, she lost herself to "perfection" on the stage as the Black Swan, not by practice and technique but by passion derived from the reserved darkness within. The girl contended with the attempt to dance both roles(white swan and black swan) of opposite ability, style and personality which forced her to insanity to see illusions of her double or Lily(a girl she personified as the black swan, she was a reflection of Nina's concealed wickedness), hwr insanity derived from the impossibility of darkness and light to coincide at her will to dance both roles. Darkness was a cost from the plight of perfection that concluded with a suicidal death. Nina, the whire swan was eventually set free. In the BS&T japanese version in the beginning there is a scene that shows jungkook getting up from a mattress, turning and lookimg down at the blood stain of the wings on the mattress, in the movie it showed that Nina often lost control and scratched herself on her back where the wings come out and she usually did it in her sleep and would wake up to see blood.. This is getting very long so I'll just cut it short.. In my opinion in the mv, Jimin dancing shows how he is trying to be perfect in his role of the black swan, and the part where his wings come out shows how the black swan is in control of him now, Yoongi's part where there is a shadow behind him dancing, I feel that its Jungkook's shadow, I've talked about the mirror part already, the last part with Jungkook tho I guess it represents how he thought he killed the black swan but killed himself and met freedom like in the movie Nina stabs what she thinks is her dark self with a broken mirror but actually stabs herself/the white swan... im gonna stop now as its 4am and I have lost many braincells by now...

[@saraabed5599]

I really enjoying watching you and listening to your theories

[@juanizmtz5630]

Love Jimin love ♡♡ ternurita!!. Exelente video.gracias por compartir.

[@Moonchild....]

"He's...the black swan?" XD, I love your reactions

[@moonhalo4710]

I think Jimin is representing all of them because as you can see at the intro at the mv you will see Jimin dancing alone then you will see All of them dancing with him after a seconds and he represents all of them being a black swan because we only saw Jimin is the only one with wings

[@jamun1072]

😍😍😍😍😍😍😍Jimin amazing 😘😘😘

[@kaiwansewaile1879]

Jungkook so sexy .so handsome.🔥💋😍

[@naimaabdi8325]

Jimin’s dance 😍🔥

[@marciarenataferreiraraymun8742]

I love your reactions💜💜💜

[@nuurai0007]

I appreciate ur reaction. I find fans only talking about how good looking than talents.

[@aleshaw4762]

First time I saw Aaron's reaction with a lot of pause and rewind😊😊.

[@Moonchild....]

Both bst and black swan have the 'your last dance' theme going on 🤔

[@GavinFox2028]

Yess thanks for checking it out Aaron

[@wanni587]

I don't get why you always stay silent for taehyung

[@tracyth2210]

I think coz he doesn’t want to be labeled as a Tae biased. 😅

[@naojocauhc1961]

Beautiful MV! Love your reaction, thanks.

[@minicutness9025]

Yay loved the reaction!!!

[@Bamgeutcutiepie]

This masterpiece of a song deserved such a beautiful mv. It was so gorgeous.

[@juliebass]

Thanks for your incredible reaction to this wonderful MV. I enjoy watching your channel every day more. They exceeded all my expectations, I loved every detail in this work of art that BTS gave us. The music, the choreography, the voices, the video ... everything is perfect. And I loved it so much!

[@jimail5966]

3:33 Namjoon also has a shadow above

[@queensaharaice7376]

7:06 WOAH! His reflections didn't turn with him👀👀

[@SUIM99]

6:26 in fake love jk and jhope

[@abbiea1237]

Thank you so much, Aaron, for noticing, and pointing it out, that JIMIN appears to be the only BTS member who doesn't have a closeup!! There have even been some reactors who didn't even know it was Jimin dancing since he's usually dancing in the shadows with not much light on him!! Or he is the actual shadow!! Haha! What a shame, that we're denied closeups of only Jimin, because Jimin has such a beautiful face, and I kept waiting to see it!!! Also, being that Jimin is known for his so expressive face & eyes during performances, his eyes & facial expression might indeed have revealed or conveyed certain feelings that would have possibly added to his dance characters role!! Similar situation in the BTS "On" MV where if you blink you might miss his closeup or even seeing him on screen!! Both this time, and for the "On" MV, Jimin's face is mainly shown, if at all in side profile!! How utterly sad & disappointing!! Most strange!!

[@Zay-cv3sg]

You are actually hilarious. Jimin is clearly the star of this mv and you are sad that he didnt get a close up? and it was just that one scene

[@JemMinie2613]

@@Zay-cv3sg one scene haha! Are you kidding me? Yeah Jimin was the one who did all the solo dancing but he's hardly recognized. His dancing as if he's a shadow. For random ppl who will see this video they can't even tell that it was Jimin dancing those solo part. Will it be ruin the MV if they showed at least Jimin's front profile even on that part when all the members has given each close up shots. Being Jimin is our bias we also love to see his beautiful visual so do not come to ppl who are complaining for not seeing his close ups on this MV. And call them hilarious!

[@Zay-cv3sg]

@@JemMinie2613 i mean isnt that part of the point? for him to represent a shadow? almost all his solo dance scenes are against a dark lighting so obviously its a deliberate choice

[@JemMinie2613]

@@Zay-cv3sg no one actually knows what exactly Jimin is representing here about the "shadow" coz in most part he was wearing white, but still the filming didn't showed his face which is such a shame as we all know Jimin has an ability to show an emotion to the role he is being portrayed. So sad that we missed that part! How we love to see his beautiful facial expression while dancing emotionally. Though as I've said it must be part of the concept. I believe the OP was particularly talking about the part when each member are being close up individually & but they only showed his side profile which you can't even recognized him as Aaron pointed out you can't clearly see his face unlike the rest of the members. Besides expressing opinions isn't bad. This is how we felt after watching the MV but that doesn't mean that we don't appreciate it and of course we'll still support it! At least so glad that all of them has a shining moment. Please let me clarify this isn't similar to those ppl who constantly complaints about the "screentime" which I find more hilarious. As a fan we just want to see our idol's beautiful visual just like the rest & I don't see anything wrong with that.

[@anaboeno6050]

I loved the mv💜

[@dioriu8504]

7:18 same Aaron same be careful of wwh 😅

[@pambarab5506]

The building is a historical theater in LA. BTS filmed Black Swan MV and ON MV (maybe both ON videos) , and practiced/performed for the Grammys in just a few really busy days.

[@MB-zy7fi]

Thanks for reaction:) Black Swan MV...it's suprise for me.. Amazing, beautiful MV Our Kings:) Jimin...He is Black Swan... Suga and RM...and JK ending...shadow company... Jin..mirrors JHope...His face...He goes into the dark...Why? Where? Black Swan MV...more theories... Artistc, perfect, professional dance... And scenography, place...beautiful It's a theatre? Amazing:)

[@luckygirl1111]

Jimin and his shadow 😍

[@chimmochi5385]

Jimin shadow dancing with suga

[@k_u8169]

It took a really long time for me to see that Jin's reflections didn't turned around when he did it.

[@guillianjoynavarro6051]

i think in the ending its Jimin's shadow

[@chojackieb3269]

I like how you reacted on this MV! You're representing ARMYs who make theories on their mind. Thank you Aaron!

[@kpoplover6540]

React to KARD "Red Moon" it's an only co-ed group in Kpop two boys and two girls. They are very talented and their songs are amazing Plzzz react to them☺️❣️

[@bella7162]

namjoon is the highlight of this mv for me he looks soooo good

[@rapperjungkook4639]

8:32 Aaron was like "and I oop😮"

[@caniesarobertson5838]

😭 Aaronnn its Jin and V, V was covering Jin's eyes.

[@chimchim359]

There is a scene in bst suga covering Jimin's eyes with a blindfold

[@caniesarobertson5838]

@@chimchim359 Yea but was it that part he was talking about? I don't think so

[@chimchim359]

@@caniesarobertson5838 I think so because background settings is similar.

[@caniesarobertson5838]

The blue room is a bit different but I think once the pillars are moved from the Jin scene it looks similar. However you could be right who knows.

[@ericaelizalde1544]

🇦🇷🇦🇷

[@danicas.garado3201]

First word that come out to his mouth: OH Wow 😯 😂 I like your reaction bro. Keep going

[@FlowerLotusThe]

''Looks like a stage''🤣 Come on Aaron!! It IS a theatre!!

[@sangboihilallensangi2214]

8:40 omg jungkook shadow fake love

[@tluangarenthlei9234]

Omg jk

[@kpoplover6540]

Please react to KARD "Dumb Litty"

[@yhettepetines5313]

I am getting triple vibes on this MV= Blood Sweat & Tears / Fake Love / Black Swan . . . goosebumps

[@이순단-v3b]

l love 💘 so much for your very kindly let you know bts

[@asiastarindonesia]

your reaction are very detailed .. which is good .. and cool

[@ros.b98]

he done ballet soo maybe this is why 😁 it looks so good on him tho

[@ainpurple719]

I really wanted to ask you this......who is your bias??😃😃

[@vivianemarques9729]

he is very handsome and talented v i love you v,v,v,v,v,v,v,v,v

[@tluangarenthlei9234]

Jungkook:talented Jimin: talented

[@renaogawa6920]

Not just you aaron..me too..this send me bst vibe a lot..i cried again..bcz i'm not recover from ON mv..and bighit decided to put salt on my wound

[@monash8069]

Maybe the shadow dancing is jimin and at the end is also jimin but jungkook doesn't care.

[@Sara-bt5hz]

Your dream came true Aaron they released an MV wearing their photoshoot customs

[@fifiicz]

I AM FIRST I AM FROM PERUU HOLAAA